Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Problem of Naxalism 4
Problem of Naxalism 4
Problem of Naxalism 4
SESSION:- 2020-21
TOPIC:- Problem of Naxalism
SUBJECT:- Political science
Submitted to :- submittedby:-
Ms.Anju Gupta Muskan
Assistant Professor Sharma
(Political science) Semester :- 2nd A
CERTIFICATE
Faculty
LAW COLLEGE
MANSAROVER,JAIPUR
(Assistant Professor)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
(Signature of Student)
Table of Contents
Introduction………………………………………………………………………… ………02
Women in Naxalism………………………………………………………………………...14
Conclusion..........................………………………………………………… ……………19
Bibliography……………………………………………………………… ……………….20
INTRODUCTION
“They are not terrorists but leaders of a political movement who want to ‘liberate
India from the clutches of feudalism and imperialism”
India is bleeding not by the thousand cuts but due to “Hinterland” explosion.
Recent Naxalite attack is a major cause of concern in India today. Instances of
Naxal violence are reported at regular intervals in India. The issue of the Naxal
movement is attributed differently by the Naxals and the state power. While the
former view it as a ‘socio-economic’ problem, the later regard it as a ‘law and
order’ problem. Whatever, may be the fact, the concern of the development of
the people has to get priority and in no way it has to be compromised. The Govt.
development scheme and effort is laudable but there is limitation of effort.
1
http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Naxal
2
http://www.mha.nic.in/uniquepage.asp?id_pk=292
3
"Cops nail China link with Naxals". The Times of India. 2011-10-08. Retrieved on 25-03-2012
History of Naxalite Movement
When India became independent from the British Empire in 1947, the Nizam of
Hyderabad, a Muslim king, wanted Hyderabad State to remain independent under
the special provisions given to princely states. The Hindus of the Hyderabad
State who accounted for 93 per cent of its population launched the `Join India'
movement with the cooperation of a few Muslims for the integration of the State
with the rest of the country. The State Congress leaders and Arya Samaj leaders
invoked themselves whole-heartedly in the movement. The peasants of the state,
influenced by the Communist, had also revolted against the Nizam, who tried to
suppress their armed struggle against landlords. Qasim Razvi led private
Razakar Muslim army fighting for continuation of the Nizam's rule, did worst
forms of atrocities on people. The Government of India liberated and assimilated
the Hyderabad State on 17 September 1948, in an operation by the Indian
Army called Operation Polo.4
4
http://www.aponline.gov.in/quick%20links/hist-cult/history_post.html- Retrieved on 25-03-2012
emergency the Naxalites formed another group under leadership of Shri
Kondapalli Sitaramaiya called C.P.I. (M.L). Peoples War Group. By this group no
work was done in Democratic way and shown no-faith in government system. The
group also took unemployment, economically backward areas as medium for their
publicity. For this work, the organization divided in the areas and according to
the area Dalam emerged. Peoples War Group chief Kodapalli Sitarmaiya has added
the slogan of independent Dandkaranya in all his slogans. The P.W.G. organization
declared to include Garhacharoli of Maharashtra, Mahabubnagar, Karimnagar,
Adilabad, Warangal of Andhra Pradesh, Koraput, Khampit & Kalahandi of Orissa,
and Balaghat & Jabalpur of Madhya Pradesh in independent Dandkaranya. The
main residents of these areas are tribals, small farmers & labourers.5
Violence in Bengal
The Naxalites gained a strong presence among the radical sections of the student
movement in Calcutta.7 Students left school to join the Naxalites. Majumdar, to
entice more students into his organization, declared that revolutionary warfare
was to take place not only in the rural areas as before, but everywhere and
spontaneously. Thus Majumdar declared an “annihilation line”, a dictum that
Naxalites should assassinate individual “class enemies” (such as landlords,
businessmen, university teachers, police officers, politicians of the right and left)
and others.8
Throughout Calcutta, schools were shut down. Naxalites took over Jadavpur
University and used the machine shop facilities to make pipe guns to attack the
police. Their headquarters became Presidency College, Kolkata.9 The Naxalites
5
http://balaghat.nic.in/History%20of%20Naxalism.pdf- Retrieved on 25-03-2012
6
Naxalite Movement, pg no.17, Uday Kumar, published by Lucky International.
7
Judith Vidal-Hall, "Naxalites", p. 73–75 in Index on Censorship, Volume 35, Number 4 (2006). p.73.
8
http://www.cscsarchive.org:8081/MediaArchive/audience.nsf/b1bc9409c64d85a06525698d0025dc3c/581314
6ae3eeee2e652572870041e297/$FILE/A0260027.pdf- Retrieved on 25-03-2012
9
http://www.vifindia.org/Tackling-%20the-Naxal-Insurgency- Retrieved on 25-03-2012
found supporters among some of the educated elite, and Delhi’s prestigious St.
Stephen’s College, alma mater of many contemporary Indian leaders and thinkers,
became a hotbed of Naxalite activities.
The chief minister, Siddhartha Shankar Ray of the Congress Party, instituted
strong counter-measures against the Naxalites. The West Bengal police fought
back to stop the Naxalites. The house of Somen Mitra, the Congress MLA of
Sealdah, was turned into a torture chamber where Naxal students from
Presidency College and CU were incarcerated illegally by police and the Congress
cadres. CPI-M cadres were also involved in the “state terror”. After suffering
losses and facing the public rejection of Majumdar’s “annihilation line”, the
Naxalites alleged human rights violations by the West Bengal police, who
responded that the state was effectively fighting a civil war and that democratic
pleasantries had no place in a war, especially when the opponent did not fight
within the norms of democracy and civility.10
1. The Naxalites wanted to surround the towns and cities by the villages, i.e., they
wanted to encircle the urban centers with organized peasant forces of the
villages. If the peasant militia could have occupied the cities, according to
Majumdar, the so-called bourgeois government would fall making the passage to
the coming of a socialist government; but the Naxalites could not and did not
come up to a stage capable of organizing the peasants and thereby encircling the
towns.
3. “Khatam” (the action of eliminating the so-called class enemies in villages) was
a wrongheaded attempt at political mobilization based on the individual murders
10
Diwanji, A. K. (2003-10-02). "Primer: Who are the Naxalites?"Rediff.com. Retrieved 25-03-2012.
11
Naxalite Movement, pg no.20-23, Uday Kumar, published by Lucky International.
of a select few people whose political class and character was never adjudged by
their socio-economic conditions or the properties they possessed but very often
only by their political affiliation or by the name and color of the party or parties
they directly or indirectly belonged to. For example,
in Jalpaiguri and Alipurduar they killed some petty jotdars who otherwise could
have been comrades in action against the capitalists or could be friends in a
revolution for radical change.
4. Recruitment in the Naxalite party took place in the absence of proper judgment
and scrutiny of the political characters and behaviors of the recruits. It was not
uncommon for recruits into the Naxalite party to vent their personal animosities
by identifying their personal enemies as class enemies, to be killed with the help
of the Naxalite organization.
5. In many cases dreaded criminals too enrolled themselves in the Naxalite party
with the objective of getting fire arms.
6. The ruling Congress party inserted spies inside the unguarded Naxalite
organization to gather information about its secret bases and arrest its
supporters. Government intelligence personnel and police disguised as Naxalite
sympathizers infiltrated the party’s inner organization and arrested many of its
leaders, including Charu Majumdar. Thus police had information about the
movements of Majumdar after he had gone underground in 1970, and he was
arrested in Calcutta in July 1972. He died in jail days after his arrest, probably
in the night of 27 or 28 July. It is not known how he died, although the government
reported that he died of a heart attack.
7. Ordinary people in villages were terrified at the brutal and gruesome ways they
killed the fellow villagers vilifying them as class enemies.
The Red Corridor is a term used to describe an impoverished region in the east
of India that experiences considerable Naxalite communist insurgency. These
are also areas that suffer from the greatest illiteracy, poverty and
overpopulation in modern India, and span parts of
Andhra, Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Orissa, Uttar
Pradesh and West states.12
The districts that comprise the Red Corridor are among the poorest in the
country. Uttar Pradesh and Orissa are among the poorest states in the country.
Other areas encompassed by the Red Corridor, such as Chhattisgarh state and
the Telangana region of Andhra Pradesh, are also either impoverished or have
significant economic inequality, or both.13
The areas encompassed by the Red Corridor tend to have stratified societies,
with caste and feudal divisions. Much of the area has high indigenous tribal
populations (or adivasis), including Santhal and Gond. Bihar and Jharkhand have
both caste and tribal divisions and violence associated with friction between
these social groups.14 Andhra Pradesh’s Telangana region similarly has deep caste
divides with a strict social hierarchical arrangement. Both Chhattisgarh and
Orissa have significant impoverished tribal populations.
12
http://www.globalpolitician.com/22790-india- Retrieved 25-03-2012.
13
Naxalite Movement, pg no.85, Uday Kumar, published by Lucky International.
14
http://www.satp.org/satporgtp/publication/faultlines/volume2/Fault2-MatthewF.htm- Retrieved 25-03-
2012.
NAXALISM AND INTERNAL SECURITY
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said Naxalism remains the biggest internal
security challenge and it is imperative to control Left-wing extremism for the
country’s growth. His government has not underestimated the problem of
Naxalism.15
Naxal Operations:
The Naxal movement is coordinated by the apex body of the CPI (M), that is, its
Central Committee, which is 32-35 member body. Out of it, a 13 member
Politbureau is formed. Of the total money collected by the State Committees and
the Special zones, 30 percent goes to the Central Committee. The rest is retained
for local expenses incurred by the State Committees. The procurement of
weapons is done at the central level and then distributed to states as per their
needs. Almost 80 percent of weapons come from looting, just as the Nepali
Maoists do.
15
The Hindu, May 24, 2010- Retrieved on 25-03-2012.
16
Naxalite Movement, pg no.59-60, Uday Kumar, published by Lucky International.
17
Ibid. at pg no.61.
NAXALISM: INDIA’s HIDDEN WAR
It seems extraordinarily outrageous and almost impossible, that a big, well known
country could hide an entire guerrilla army’s activities. “There are two India’s.
The dazzling India which we see every day on our TV channels. But there is
another India which we rarely see or write about” It is estimated that sixteen
of India’s twenty-eight states are ‘infected’ to some degree, India’s
intelligence agency has estimated that the number of Naxalites could be as
high as 70,000, though other estimates go as high as 120,000.
Of course, in the world’s largest democracy, such a huge movement can hardly
have gone unchallenged. Over the past decade individual states in Central and
Southern India have affected their own campaigns with varying degrees of
failure. Strategies have mainly included arming local resistance movements and
emptying villages where there is support for the terrorists. While groups of
Naxalites have offered ceasefires, the Indian Government says it will only
consider peace talks if a complete ceasefire is forthcoming – the fact that this
has not been offered undermines the image of cohesion and of a unified army
made up of the many Naxalite groups.
The Naxalite spokesman Ganesh Ueike claims that they are not terrorists but
leaders of a political movement who want to “liberate India from the clutches of
feudalism and imperialism”. He has condemned militants in the disputed Kashmir
region who have been blamed for attacks against civilians in Mumbai, claiming that
the Naxalites only attack government forces: ‘Those who choose soft targets or
do such things to create communal hatred have nothing to do with people. They
are mercenaries funded by national or international powers … All this should be
condemned.’ The success with which this conflict has been hidden is remarkable
and can be seen as symptomatic of the Indian Government’s attitude.
Many have tried to draw attention to this conflict though, and the implication of
its existence and the way in which it has been hidden. Booker Prize-winning author
Arundhati Roy has campaigned tirelessly to draw attention to the conflict and
even defended the Naxalites’ tactics. She has attacked the government as a
‘charade of democracy’ which has used the Naxalites as an excuse for a ‘land-
grab’ of areas high in natural resources in central and southern India. Roy was
accused of sedition by the Indian Government last year though not convicted. 18
18
http://www.defence.pk/forums/indian-defence/135691-india-s-hidden-war.html- Retrieved on 26-03-2012.
RECENT MAJOR ATTACKS BY NAXALITES
19
http://www.ndtv.com/news/india/20-security-men-killed-by-naxals-in-chhattisgarh-19293.php- Retrieved
on 26-03-2012.
20
http://liveindia.tv/india/states/5-policemen-killed-in-naxal-attacks-in-chhattisgarh/- Retrieved on 28-03-
2012
21
http://news.taaza.com/source/914184-crpf-personnel-killed-in-naxal-attack.html- Retrieved on 28-03-2012
22
http://www.thestatesman.net/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=399692&catid=35-
Retrieved on 28-03-2012
23
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-17421561- Retrieved on 28-03-2012
OPERATION GREENHUNT
Operation Green Hunt was the name used by the Indian media to describe the
Government's paramilitary offensive against the Naxalite rebels in the late
2000s. The operation began in November 2009 along five states in the "Red
Corridor."24
The term was coined by the Chhattisgarh police officials to describe one
successful drive against the Communist Party of India (Maoist) in the state. It
was erroneously used by the media to describe the wider anti-Naxalite
operations; the Government of India doesn't use the term "Operation Green
Hunt" to describe its anti-Naxalite offensive.25
In October 2009, the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) announced that it was
in the final stages of planning the offensive and had received approval from
the Union-led government. The Commando Battalion for Resolute Action (COBRA)
would take the lead in the operations against Maoist insurgents. 26 At the
beginning of November 2009, the first phase of the operation began in Gadchiroli
district. As many as 18 companies of the central paramilitary forces were moved
into the area in anticipation of the operation. 27
An operation is underway in Central India, but no one really knows what it is.
Variously described as a media myth, a comprehensive hearts and minds strategy,
and an all-out offensive by paramilitary forces and the state forces along the
borders of Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra, Ops
Green Hunt has become a shoebox of news clippings, police reports, public
demonstration and armed encounters.
There is also little clarity on the extent of troop deployment, the composition of
the forces and the chain of command between central paramilitary forces and the
state police. Privately, sources in the security apparatus admit that part of the
confusion is by design rather than by default to control the information available
to Naxal commanders.
24
http://rt.com/news/maoists-naxals-india-offensive/?fullstory- Retrieved on 28-03-2012
25
http://www.indianexpress.com/news/antinaxal-operation-satisfactory-says-chid/570551/- Retrieved on 28-
03-2012
26
http://news.outlookindia.com/items.aspx?artid=667442- Retrieved on 28-03-2012
27
http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2009-11-02/nagpur/28083958_1_gadchiroli-cpmf-operation-
green-hunt- Retrieved on 28-03-2012
DALIT AND ADIVASI IN NAXALISM
Although the terms of references did not specifically mention Naxalites, the
group’s brief was to identify causes of unrest and discontent in areas affected
by “widespread displacement, forest issues, insecure tenancies and imperfect
market conditions etc.,”. Clearly, such areas fall in above mentioned five states-
and significantly enough, the group organized field visits in these areas to observe
the situation at first hand, on the basis of which it has come out with stark
revelations that expose the culpability of the state in denying the poor their basic
rights, the treachery of a corrupt bureaucracy to implement the laws, and its
complicity with a trigger happy police to suppress popular protest.
The main support for the Naxalite Movement comes from dalits and adivasis,
termed as scheduled castes and scheduled tribes respectively in official parlance,
which comprise about one-fourth of India’s population, the majority living in rural
areas.28
Apart from high levels of poverty, the dalits suffer from various types of
disadvantages like unemployment, illiteracy, social discrimination, human rights
violation. As for the adivasis population, besides remaining backward in all aspects
of human development including education, health, nutrition, etc, they have been
steadily losing their traditional tribal rights. These groups fail to take advantage
of constitutional rights. Thus they are very much attracted towards Naxalite
movements as these movements fight for their minimal rights. So most of them
join these movements. Incidentally, every dalits and adivasis poor in India have
not joined the Naxalite movement. There are many states with pockets of high
proportion of adivasis and dalits but little Naxalite influence, as in Punjab,
Haryana, Gujarat and Rajasthan.
For such a violent upheaval to happen there is the likelihood of the spread of
awareness and consciousness. And this is where the Naxalites have played a
significant role by stepping into craters of dalits an adivasis deprivation in the
five states, and organizing the deprived for their rights.29
28
Naxalite Movement, pg no.137, Uday Kumar, published by Lucky International.
29
Ibid at pg.no.139.
WOMEN IN NAXALISM
Women do not just make up the ranks. They account for three Divisional
committee members, nine Commanders, three Area commanders and two Deputy
Commanders operating as far as Maharashtra is concerned. In fact, the statistics
show men are outnumbered by the fairer sex in commanders and deputy
commander’s cadre. Two women divisional committee members Narmada and
Tarakka alias Vimala Sidam operate in the South Gadchiroli area while Sajanakka
in the North. Fifty seven others form the support strength. The role of women
cadres in the 1st February carnage at Markegaon in Gadchiroli district, which
claimed lives of 15 policemen, is also a matter of speculation. They treat women
on par even in their military struggle. Women cadres are provided training just
like their men counterparts. There is no discrimination in their diet or exercises.
It is mandatory for all new recruits to the outfit to take a nine-point oath that
declares, inter alia, that he or she would not discriminate on the basis of religion,
caste, gender, race, or ethniethnic
The Laws Made by the Government
The main aim of this act is to minimize the displacement of people and to promote
non-displacing or least displacing alternatives. The Government issued a
rehabilitation policy on 11 0ctober 2007 for the easy displacement of people who
lose their land for industrial growth. Under this policy land in change for land will
be given, job prospective to at least one member of the family, vocational training
and housing benefits including houses to people in rural areas and urban areas will
be some of the benefits.30
These laws have in many ways caused a lot of problems to the tribals and
the scheduled castes by negating the spirit of the various safeguards available
to the scheduled tribes under the constitution and other laws in the country. The
act providing 'land for land' has become a nightmare for the government and has
become a stumbling block for ensuring industrialization. As per the Unlawful
30
http://nhpcindia.com/writereaddata/english/pdf/rnrpolicy2007.pdf- Retrieved on 28-03-2012
31
http://www.nls.ac.in/resources/ded/classnotesforyear2010ded/MBL-1_Web%20Oct%2010/EL-MBL-
FORESTRIGHTSACT2006.pdf- Retrieved on 28-03-2012
32
http://archives.newswatch.in/violation/chhattisgarhs-novel-way-to-counter-naxals-gun-for-journalists.html-
Retrieved on 28-03-2012
activities prevention act (UAPA) the government has banned all organizations that
have any connections with any Naxal movements like the MCC or the CPI-M
(Marxist-Leninist). There was no need of this bill to tackle Naxalism. This bill was
formulated, only to silence the appropriate discord and dissent brewing in the
minds of people in the areas affected by Naxalism due to persistent ignorance by
the government to their situation. This Bill has also failed to make a distinction
between the anti-social, anti-national elements from the people who are peace
loving.
Various schemes launched have been launched by the government like the Pradhan
Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana (PMGSY) which offers tremendous opportunities for
rural road connectivity. For certain districts affected by Naxalism which have a
population of 500 and above in plain areas and 250 and above in tribal areas 3
years perspective plans are being formulated to cover all habitations. The
National Rural Employment Guarantee Programme (NREGP) is being implemented
in 330 districts affected by Naxalism so as to universalize the demand-driven
programme for wage-employment. Other schemes which are in addition to the
above mentioned schemes are Bharat Nirman, National Rural Health mission
(NRHM), Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA), Integrated Child Development Services
(ICDS) and other income generating and social security schemes of the Ministry
of Rural Development, Agriculture, Panchayati Raj and Tribal affairs. The central
government will also provide 100 percent assistance in the formation of Ashram
schools and hostels for girls and boys in 46 tribal areas.
States like Jharkhand and Orissa have offered huge incentives to the Naxals who
surrender themselves. Further, the government has offered cash equivalent to
the price of the weapon surrendered. They will provide them with life insurance
cover, vocational training, agricultural land, health and 47 educational facilities
for their children.
What should be done to solve the problem of Naxalism?
The solution which will solve the problem of Naxalism is the Social Integration.
The tribals and scheduled castes that live in the Naxal affected areas have been
neglected for the past many decades and now want some attention from the
government. Providing them with incentives like giving them right over the forest
produce from the forests in which they have been living for generations, providing
them with houses etc. is the right modus of solving their basic problems. The main
reason for the spread of Naxalism is the exploitation of poor and scheduled
castes. The main thing which has to be done is to enforce land ceiling laws,
utilization of the funds provided to government to the maximum and political
expediency. Use of police forces should be to enforce the land ceiling laws, evict
landlords and ensure land to the farmers for cultivation. They should be provided
with police protection, and proper rehabilitation for the people who have been
displaced should be ensured. Security as well as development has to run hand in
hand to counter the Naxal problem.
The government has to instill faith in the people that they will be governed in a
better manner than by the Naxals. The government should include laws in the
forest act that only forest dwelling tribes and scheduled castes should be allowed
to use the produce of the forest. Proper guarding of financial institutions
sanctioning loans to these tribes should be ensured which will help these tribes
to realize that the government is with them.
The Central government should form a separate ministry which will undertake the
development of the areas affected by the Naxal activities.
Using force against the tribals to deter them from joining the Naxals has and will
backfire against the government. The government should ensure peace in these
areas so that these people don't suffer more than they already have and this can
be done only if the government takes proactive measures so as to ensure social
justice and inclusive growth for the benefit of the marginalized sections.
CONCLUSION
Only with consolidated efforts on the part of the legal and political framework
socio-economic reforms can be implemented, and the problem of Naxalism
tackled.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books
Web Sources
www.thefreedictionary.com
www.mha.nic.in
www.aponline.gov.in
balaghat.nic.in
www.cscsarchive.org
www.vifindia.org
www.globalpolitician.com
www.satp.org
www.defence.pk
www.ndtv.com
liveindia.tv
news.taaza.com
www.thestatesman.net
www.bbc.co.uk
www.rt.com
www.indianexpress.com
news.outlookindia.com
articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com
www.isrj.net
nhpcindia.com
www.nls.ac.in
archives.newswatch.in
www.thehindu.com