Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Whole Grain Properties PDF
Whole Grain Properties PDF
Whole Grain Properties PDF
Original article
Wheat preharvest herbicide application, whole-grain flour
properties, yeast activity and the degradation of glyphosate in
bread
Summary The aim of this study was to determine the effects of wheat preharvest application of a glyphosate-based
herbicide (Roundup WeatherMaxÒ with TransorbÒ 2 Technology) on whole-grain flour composition and
properties, including yeast activity. The effect of dough fermentation on the degradation of herbicide resi-
dues was also estimated. Grain samples from two hard red spring wheat varieties exceeded the maximum
residue limits (5 mg kg 1) in Canada. Glyphosate had minor effects on wheat kernels composition and
properties, including fructans content and yeast gassing power. No degradation of RoundupÒ or pure gly-
phosate was seen after dough fermentation for up to 4 h and baking. These results call for more scientific
studies on glyphosate residues in wheat.
Keywords Bread, glyphosate, herbicides, wheat, yeast.
doi:10.1111/ijfs.13741
© 2018 Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada International Journal of Food Science and Technology © 2018 Institute of Food Science and Technology
Reproduced with the permission of the Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada.
1598 linas et al.
Glyphosate in wheat and yeast fermentation P. Ge
2015; Ehrampoush et al., 2017). Inhibition of baker’s Elementar Analysensysteme GmbH, Hanau, Ger-
yeast cells growth would vary much according to the many). Falling number was determined according to
herbicide (Sharma et al., 2005; Regueiro et al., 2015). AACC Method 56-81.03 (AACC, 2009). Total dry
Compared to pure glyphosate, commercial prepara- gluten content in wholemeal was assayed with the
tions of RoundupÒ may contain as much as 20% sur- Glutomatic based on AACC Method 38-12.02 (AACC,
factants and would have higher inhibitory potential on 2009). Flour moisture was measured according to
wine yeast and dairy starters (Braconi et al., 2006; AACC Method 44-15.02 (AACC, 2009). As described
Clair et al., 2012). According to Low et al. (2005), in Gelinas et al. (2016), fructans analysis was per-
yeast would metabolise about 20% of pure glyphosate formed with the Fructan Assay Procedure (K-Fruc;
in dough fermented for only 1 h. To our knowledge, Megazyme International Ireland, Wicklow, Ireland)
no scientific evidence has been reported on the effect with pretreatment of samples with a-galactosidase to
of commercial glyphosate preparation on baker’s yeast eliminate galactosyl-sucrose oligosaccharides. Analyses
fermentative activity. Little information is also avail- were performed in duplicate, except protein and gluten
able on the impact of yeast fermentation and bread contents which were determined in triplicate.
baking on the degradation of glyphosate.
The aim of this study was to determine the effects of
Dough rheology
wheat preharvest glyphosate application on the com-
position and properties of whole-grain flour, especially Farinograms were performed in duplicate according to
the fermentative activity of baker’s yeast and the AACC Method 54-21.02 (AACC, 2009), except analy-
degradation of pure glyphosate and RoundupÒ in ses were performed at 25 °C instead of 30 °C (Gelinas
dough. Due to the current awareness for pesticides in & McKinnon, 2013).
foods, this study was designed to advance scientific
knowledge on glyphosate residues in wheat flour and
Bread making
bread.
As described in Gelinas et al. (2016), bread was pre-
pared in duplicate (two mixed doughs) according to
Materials and methods
AACC Method 10-10.03 (AACC, 2009), with a 3-h
fermentation period at 35 °C. Formulation included
Whole-grain wheat flour samples
wholemeal (100 g), water (variable), shortening (3 g),
Two hard red spring wheat varieties (Major; Walton) salt (1.5 g), dry yeast (1.2 g) and ascorbic acid
for bread making were grown in a series of 1 m2 par- (50 mg kg 1 flour). Dough water absorption (14%
cels (450 plants per m2) at different farming sites in the moisture, flour basis) was determined according to
province of Quebec, respectively, in Alma (Lac-Saint- farinogram plus 0.5%. After cooling for 1 h, bread
Jean) and Saint-Anicet (Monteregie-Ouest). Nitrogen volume was determined with a laser volumeter (Vols-
(100 kg ha 1) was applied in the field. Concentration can Profiler VSP300; Stable Micro Systems Ltd.,
(1.67 L ha 1 corresponding to 0.82 kg ha 1) and tim- Godalming, Surrey, UK) based on AACC Method 10-
ing of glyphosate-based herbicide (RoundupÒ) applica- 14.01 (AACC, 2009).
tion (hard-dough Zadock growth stage 87) were based
on recommendations of the manufacturer (Roundup
Gas production
WeatherMaxÒ with TransorbÒ 2 Technology; Mon-
santo Canada, Winnipeg, MB, Canada). For Major, In duplicate, yeast gassing power (gas pressure) was
RoundupÒ was sprayed on 11 September 2015, and determined with the Risograph (National Manufactur-
kernels were harvested on 16 September. For Walton, ing, TMCO, Inc., Lincoln, NE, USA) using RisoSmart
RoundupÒ was applied on 7 August and harvesting version 1.0.233 from 2005, the software provided with
was performed on 20 August. Wheat samples were the equipment. Dough was prepared from 100 g whole-
stored in bags at room temperature for about meal as described in bread-making assays. Immediately
4 months and, in preparation for analyses, later kept after mixing, 2 9 25-g dough portions were placed into
at 10 °C. Whole-grain flour (wholemeal) was prepared Risograph jars. Equipment was programmed to get 1
by milling 500 g of grain with a Perten disc mill (disc measure per min for 3 h at 38 °C, except for assays on
#2; Model 3301; Perten Instruments, Huddinge, Swe- glyphosate degradation which were performed for 4 h.
den) equipped with a mill feeder. Means were calculated from 4 data.
International Journal of Food Science and Technology 2018 © 2018 Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada International Journal of Food Science and Technology
© 2018 Institute of Food Science and Technology
linas et al.
Glyphosate in wheat and yeast fermentation P. Ge 1599
200 g flour was spiked with Roundup WeatherMaxÒ 92 3% and 95 11%, respectively; for AMPA,
with TransorbÒ 2 Technology (13.5 or 27 mg kg 1 recovery was 94 1% and 80 1%.
flour); wholemeal was replaced by commercial white
flour (Robin HoodÒ Best for Bread Homestyle White
Statistical analyses
flour; Smucker Foods of Canada Corp., Montreal,
QC, Canada). In the Risograph, 8 9 25-g dough por- One-way analysis of variance procedure was per-
tions were fermented at 38 °C and gas production was formed with SAS (version 9.3, TS1M2, 2012, SAS
determined after 1, 2, 3 or 4 h. Additional experiments Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA). The least significant
were performed with yeasted or nonyeasted dough difference (LSD) test was used to determine the differ-
supplemented with pure glyphosate (13.5 mg kg 1; ences between treatments (P < 0.05).
Sigma) instead of RoundupÒ. At the completion of
each fermentation period, doughs were removed from
Results
the Risograph jar, placed in a pan, baked at 204 °C
for 19 min (Fisher & Paykel Aero Tech USA, Hunt-
Effect of wheat preharvest Roundupâ application
ingdon Beach, CA, USA), cooled on a grid for 1 h,
packaged into plastic bags and frozen at 45 °C until Total glyphosate residues in wheat kernels harvested
glyphosate analysis. After thawing, bread samples were after RoundupÒ treatment were 11.1 and 6.1 mg kg 1,
comminuted by hand, left to dry for 48 h at room respectively, for Major and Walton (Table 1). What-
temperature and milled with a coffee mill (Brau Mex- ever the sample, AMPA was below the detection limit.
ico, Naucalpan de Juarez, Mexico). With Major, the wheat variety with the highest poten-
tial for pan bread, preharvest application of
RoundupÒ had little effect on the composition of the
Glyphosate analysis
kernels, including falling number as well as protein,
In duplicate, 1 g wholemeal or dehydrated bread was gluten and fructans contents (Table 1), and whole-
extracted for 2 h with 10 mL water at room tempera- grain flour water absorption, dough mixing stability
ture, with stirring at 200 rpm. After centrifugation and yeast gassing power (Table 2). Similar results were
(5750 g), 50 lL of supernatant was combined with seen with Walton, a variety with lower bread-making
1 mL of 0.2 M borate buffer (pH 9) and 200 lL of a potential, except preharvest RoundupÒ application
fresh solution of FMOC.Cl in acetone (2 mg mL 1), had a negative effect on yeast fermentative activity.
vortexed and filtered after 30 min. Adapted from a Depending on the wheat variety, bread volume varied
procedure recommended by Phenomenex Inc. (Ter- significantly, but no trend could be seen according to
rance, CA, USA), glyphosate and AMPA were deter- RoundupÒ treatment (Table 2).
mined with a Knauer Smartline HPLC system
(Berlin, Germany) using a 250 9 4.6 mm Gemini C18
Effect of yeast fermentation on glyphosate degradation
column (Phenomenex Inc.) with 20 mM ammonium
bicarbonate/acetonitrile/methanol 70/15/15 to 65/17.5/ To eliminate the possibility that whole-grain flour inhi-
17.5 for 12 min, then 10/45/45 for 10 min at bits yeast activity (Gelinas et al., 2016), additional
0.6 mL min 1. Detection was performed with a 2475 experiments on gassing power were performed with
fluorescence detector (Waters, Milford, MA, USA) commercial white flour, free of bran. The degradation
with excitation and emission at 360 and 410 nm, of glyphosate was also checked in dough spiked with
respectively. Calibration curve was prepared with gly- RoundupÒ at 13.5 or 27 mg kg 1 flour (Table 3).
phosate and AMPA standards (0.1–4 lg mL 1) and After dough fermentation for up to 4 h, yeast gassing
detection limits were 0.05 lg mL 1 and 0.1 lg mL 1, power was not inhibited by glyphosate and no degra-
respectively. As determined in triplicate, recovery of dation of the herbicide was seen. Compared to spiked
glyphosate on dry basis in wholemeal and bread was dough, about 15% less glyphosate was recovered in
Wheat variety Roundupâ application Glyphosate residues (mg kg 1) Falling number (s) Protein (%) Gluten (%) Fructans (%)
c a b a
Major No 0 404 15.8 14.0 1.08a
Yes 11.1a 402a 16.2a 13.8a 0.94a
Walton No 0c 412a 13.2d 11.3b 1.05a
Yes 6.1b 406a 13.8c 11.0b 1.15a
Glyphosate concentrations are reported on flour weight basis; no AMPA was detected. Mean data (dry basis) were obtained from two repetitions,
except protein and gluten (three repetitions). Within columns, means followed by the same letter are not significantly different at the P < 0.05 level.
© 2018 Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada International Journal of Food Science and Technology International Journal of Food Science and Technology 2018
© 2018 Institute of Food Science and Technology
1600 linas et al.
Glyphosate in wheat and yeast fermentation P. Ge
Table 2 Effect of wheat preharvest RoundupÒ application on wholemeal dough mixing properties, gas production and bread volume
Dough
â
Wheat variety Roundup application Water absorption (%) Mixing stability (min) Gas production (mL) Bread specific volume (mL g 1)
Mean data were obtained from 2 data (2 repetitions 9 1 sample), except total gas production after 3 h at 38 °C (2 repetitions 9 2 samples). Within
columns, means followed by the same letter are not significantly different at the P < 0.05 level.
Table 3 Effect of the addition of glyphosate preparation Table 4 Effect of the addition of pure glyphosate (13.5 mg kg 1
(RoundupÒ) in dough made with white commercial flour on yeast flour) in yeasted or nonyeasted dough on the degradation of glypho-
gassing power and the degradation of glyphosate after fermentation sate after fermentation and baking
and baking
Yeasted Dough fermentation Residual glyphosate
Dough Added Residual glyphosate Dough time (h) after baking (mg kg 1)
fermentation glyphosate after baking Gas
time (h) (mg kg 1) (mg kg 1) production (mL) No 0 12.9a
1 12.6a
0 0 0d 0e 2 14.2a
13.5 12.7c 0e 3 13.3a
27 23.5ab 0e 4 11.9a
1 0 0d 66.8d Yes 0 11.4a
13.5 11.5c 62.3d 1 11.8a
27 21.3bc 67.4d 2 12.0a
2 0 0d 167.4c 3 12.5a
13.5 11.9c 161.3c 4 12.2a
27 23.1ab 168.7c
3 0 0d 274.1b Glyphosate concentrations are reported on flour weight basis; no
13.5 10.2c 267.1b AMPA was detected. Doughs were prepared with commercial white
27 24.2a 275.6b flour. Mean data were obtained from 2 data (2 repetitions 9 1 sample).
4 0 0d 363.7a Within column, means followed by the same letter are not significantly
13.5 11.7c 357.3a different at the P < 0.05 level.
27 21.6ab 364.9a
International Journal of Food Science and Technology 2018 © 2018 Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada International Journal of Food Science and Technology
© 2018 Institute of Food Science and Technology
linas et al.
Glyphosate in wheat and yeast fermentation P. Ge 1601
© 2018 Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada International Journal of Food Science and Technology International Journal of Food Science and Technology 2018
© 2018 Institute of Food Science and Technology
1602 linas et al.
Glyphosate in wheat and yeast fermentation P. Ge
Ehrampoush, M.H., Sadeghi, A., Ghaneian, M.T. & Bonyadi, Z. Low, F.L., Shaw, I.C. & Gerrard, J.A. (2005). The effect of Saccha-
(2017). Optimization of diazinon biodegradation from aqueous romyces cerevisiae on the stability of the herbicide glyphosate dur-
solutions by Saccharomyces cerevisiae using response surface ing bread leavening. Letters in Applied Microbiology, 40, 133–137.
methodology. AMB Express, 7, 68. Manthey, F.A., Chakraborty, M., Peel, M.D. & Pederson, J.D.
Esteve, K., Poupot, C., Dabert, P., Mietton-Peuchot, M. & Milisic, (2004). Effect of preharvest applied herbicides on breadmaking
V. (2009). A Saccharomyces cerevisiae-based bioassay for assessing quality of hard red spring wheat. Journal of the Science of Food
pesticide toxicity. Journal of Industrial Microbiology and Biotech- and Agriculture, 84, 441–446.
nology, 36, 1529–1534. Monsanto Canada (2012). Preharvest staging guide, Roundup.
European Glyphosate Task Force (2014). Pre-harvest use of glypho- http://www.roundup.ca/en/preharvest. Accessed 12/27/2017.
sate: recent Austrian decision. http://www.glyphosate.eu/news/pre- Pollock, C.J. & Cairns, A.J. (1991). Fructan metabolism in grasses
harvest-use-glyphosate-recent-austrian-decision Accessed 12/27/ and cereals. Annual Reviews in Plant Physiology and Plant Molecu-
2017. lar Biology, 42, 77–101.
Gelinas, P. & McKinnon, C. (2013). Experiments on dough rheology Regueiro, J., L
opez-Fernandez, O., Rial-Otero, R., Cancho-Grande,
to improve screening of bread wheat cultivars. International Journal B. & Simal-Gandara, J. (2015). A review on the fermentation of
of Food Science and Technology, 48, 1956–1961. foods and the residues of pesticides – Biotransformation of pesti-
Gelinas, P., McKinnon, C. & Gagnon, F. (2016). Fructans, water- cides and effects on fermentation and food quality. Critical Reviews
soluble fibre and fermentable sugars in bread and pasta made with in Food Science and Nutrition, 55, 839–863.
ancient and modern wheat. International Journal of Food Science Rissoli, R.Z., Abdalla, F.C., Costa, M.J., Rantin, F.T., McKenzie,
and Technology, 51, 555–564. D.J. & Kalinin, A.L. (2016). Effects of glyphosate and the glypho-
Green, J.M. & Beestman, G.B. (2007). Recently patented and com- sate based herbicides Roundup OriginalÒ and Roundup TransorbÒ
mercialized formulation and adjuvant technology. Crop Protection, on respiratory morphophysiology of bullfrog tadpoles. Chemo-
26, 320–327. sphere, 156, 37–44.
Harris, C.A. & Gaston, C.P. (2004). Effects of refining predicted Sharma, J., Satya, S., Kumar, V. & Tewary, D.K. (2005). Dissipa-
chronic dietary intakes of pesticide residues: a case study using gly- tion of pesticides during bread-making. Chemical Health & Safety,
phosate. Food Additives and Contaminants, 21, 857–864. 12, 17–22.
Health Canada (2015). Maximum residues limits for pesticides. Sviridov, A.V., Shushkova, T.V., Ermakova, I.T., Ivanova, E.V. &
https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/consumer-product- Leontievsky, A.A. (2014). Glyphosate: safety risks, biodegradation,
safety/pesticides-pest-management/public/protecting-your-health- and bioremediation. In: Current Environmental Issues and Chal-
environment/pesticides-food/maximum-residue-limits-pesticides.html. lenges (edited by G. Cao & R. Orr u). Pp. 183–195. Dordrecht,
Accessed 12/27/2017. Netherlands: Springer Science+Business Media.
Health Canada (2017). Re-evaluation decision RVD2017-01, glypho- Wigfield, Y.Y., Deneault, F. & Fillion, J. (1994). Residues of glypho-
sate. Pest Management Regulatory Agency. http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/ sate and its principle metabolite in certain cereals, oilseeds, and
cps-spc/pubs/pest/_decisions/rvd2017-01/index-eng.php. Accessed pulses grown in Canada, 1990–1992. Bulletin of Environmental Con-
12/27/2017. tamination and Toxicology, 53, 543–547.
Li, H., Cai, J., Jiang, D., Liu, F., Dai, T. & Cao, W. (2013). Carbo- Williams, G.M., Kroes, R. & Munro, I.C. (2000). Safety evaluation
hydrates accumulation and remobilization in wheat plants as influ- and risk assessment of the herbicide Roundup and its active ingre-
enced by combined waterlogging and shading stress during grain dient, glyphosate, for humans. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharma-
filling. Journal of Agronomy and Crop Science, 199, 38–48. cology, 31, 117–165.
International Journal of Food Science and Technology 2018 © 2018 Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada International Journal of Food Science and Technology
© 2018 Institute of Food Science and Technology