Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Journal of Popular Culture " - Securing The Success of Transformers - Age of Extinction
The Journal of Popular Culture " - Securing The Success of Transformers - Age of Extinction
The Journal of Popular Culture " - Securing The Success of Transformers - Age of Extinction
KIMBERLY OWCZARSKI
C
HINA SUPPLANTED
gest film market in 2012. That year, box office revenues in
China reached $2.8 billion, then jumped 27% to $3.6 billion
in 2013 as the country added theater screens at a rate of ten per day
to keep up with movie-going demand (Coonan, “China 2013”;
McClintock). Indeed, analysts predict that China will surpass North
America as the world’s largest theatrical market by the end of 2017
(Brzeski).1 Eager to capture a larger part of China’s box office rev-
enues, Hollywood studios have engaged in a number of practices to
gain a foothold in this growing marketplace. These strategies typi-
cally include incorporating Chinese actors, shooting in China, and
partnering with Chinese companies. Despite the potential box office
gold available in Chinese movie theaters, Hollywood studios have
met varying levels of success with these strategies as there are a num-
ber of obstacles to overcome in courting the Chinese film market.
Chief among these challenges is China’s rigid import policy. For
years, the Chinese government allowed only twenty foreign films to
participate in revenue-sharing agreements and exhibit in the coun-
try’s movie theaters, though the number increased to thirty-four in
2012. As a result, international studios jockey for one of these pre-
cious slots, while simultaneously agreeing to receive only a small
share of the box office revenue that they earn in China. In 2012, for
instance, that share had increased to 25% after lumbering below 20%
for years (Nakashima). All films being considered for screens in China
490
A Very Significant Chinese Component 491
Despite the fact that China recently raised the importation limit to
thirty-four films, the Hollywood studios’ relationship with China’s
market has a long and complex history. American films were
494 Kimberly Owczarski
the first time in a decade (Klein 204). Because Kung Fu Hustle was an
official co-production, Sony received 30–40% of overall box office
grosses in China, as is typical for such co-produced films (Klein 202).
As Klein argues, the film demonstrates “that clear-cut distinctions
between ‘Hollywood films’ and ‘Chinese cinema’ are becoming harder
to make in terms of production, style, market performance and
national-cultural-industrial identity” (205). Indeed, Kung Fu Hustle is
an early example of the growing interconnectedness of the production
and distribution interests of Hollywood and Chinese firms.
In his book Playing to the World’s Biggest Audience: The Globalization
of Chinese Film and TV, Michael Curtin uses co-productions like Kung
Fu Hustle as a launching point to discuss Hollywood’s increasing
interest in the Chinese audience. According to Curtin, these co-
produced films serve as “marquee attractions”
grossing film in that market ever (Brzeski). This record was quickly
supplanted by the comedic The Mermaid (Stephen Chow, 2016) which
grossed over $520 million in Chinese theaters early in 2016. As Hol-
lywood studios continue to look to China for its box office potential,
it is clear that there are significant challenges ahead as revenue for
domestic films now outpaces those for Hollywood films with several
local films beating imports each year. Whereas in previous decades,
Chinese firms looked to Hollywood studios to shore up their industry
and theaters, that dependence has shifted significantly. The Holly-
wood studios’ focus has been on engineering success throughout the
development, production, and exhibition processes of their films in
order to ensure strong box office returns in China. Key to any of these
successes is securing a strong relationship with the state run agencies
that market, distribute, and co-produce films in the Chinese market-
place. Paramount’s Age of Extinction is an excellent case study of this
evolving process, with key Chinese governmental bodies significantly
helping shape the film’s production and distribution.
The first three Transformers films all performed strongly in China (see
Table 1 below for a breakdown of each film’s box office performance).
In fact, Dark of the Moon emerged as the fourth highest grossing film
of all-time at the Chinese box office, earning $165 million.
Paramount thus wanted to ensure an even larger box office haul in
China for the fourth film in the franchise. Like many contemporary
Table 1
Box office revenue for the Transformers films
franchise films, Age of Extinction was partially shot in China and had
production and financial partnerships with Chinese firms, including
the state-owned China Movie Channel and Jiaflix Enterprises, a com-
pany that provides streaming services in China. It was the first Holly-
wood film that the China Movie Channel had invested in, and this
investment was described in April 2013 by Yan Xiaoming, the
Chairman of China Movie Channel, as “[T]he beginning of a new era
of collaboration with the Hollywood studios. We are very confident
that the China Movie Channel/Jiaflix cooperation with Paramount
will result in the famous Transformers brand being an even bigger
success” (qtd. in Tartaglione). Emphasizing the Chinese aspects of the
film, Marc Ganis, President of Jiaflix Enterprises, claimed: “The film
has a great deal to do with China. Effectively, China is a character in
it.” He then added: “There is going to be a single version worldwide
with a very significant Chinese component” (qtd. in “Jiafix”). Ganis’s
comment pointed to Disney’s strategy with Iron Man 3 (Shane Black,
2013), in which the company secured a separate Chinese release of
the film with additional footage featuring Chinese actors. The China-
only release of Iron Man 3 was widely criticized by fans, filmgoers,
and the Chinese press for the poor integration of the Chinese sections
into the film’s overall narrative.
To first demonstrate the film’s “significant Chinese component,”
high-profile Chinese actors were cast. In May 2013, it was announced
that Li Bingbing would join Age of Extinction (Tsui, “China’s Li Bing-
bing”). As one of the best known, critically acclaimed actresses in
China, her casting suggested she would play an important part in the
franchise. She even received a character-based movie poster to help
promote the film to the Chinese audience. Li was featured for about
thirty minutes in the film as Su Yueming, who oversees the Chinese
facility for Kinetic Solutions Incorporated (KSI). In the film, she fier-
cely navigates the streets of Hong Kong on a motorcycle and protects
KSI chief executive officer Joshua Joyce (Stanley Tucci) as rogue CIA
operatives pursue them. In July 2013, it was announced that Han
Geng would also join the film. As a film, television, and pop music
star across Asia—he was once a member of the K-pop boy band Super
Junior—Han’s casting brought a significant wave of publicity. He
had over thirty-five million followers at the time through his social
media presence, ensuring a large level of publicity (Tsui, “Chinese
Star”). Han’s role was more in the line of a cameo—he is briefly
A Very Significant Chinese Component 501
featured with his guitar as his car is drawn up by a large magnet con-
nected to a spaceship. But despite his limited screen time, Han pro-
vided two songs for the film’s soundtrack.
Age of Extinction went a step beyond previous Hollywood studio
efforts of casting Chinese stars by setting up a reality television show
to help choose additional actors for parts in the film. Announced in
April 2013 and titled Transformers 4 Chinese Actors Talent Search Real-
ity Show, the show’s goal was to find two established and two new-
comer acting talents to cast in the film in small roles. As reality
shows are one of the most popular genres on Chinese television, the
program would serve as an outlet for promotion long before the film’s
release. Indeed, for marketing purposes, all of the applicants’ email
addresses were to be entered into a large database to be used by Para-
mount close to the July 2014 release date (Block). From April to July
2013, potential contestants submitted videos to the m1905 Web site,
the online arm of the state-owned China Movie Channel. Potential
contestants had to select one of four character areas to submit their
audition videos. In a promotional video that demonstrated what the
program was looking for, clips of Hollywood films demonstrated each
of these character types, which included a male action role (punctu-
ated with images of Bruce Willis and Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson,
among others), a sexy action female role (Angelina Jolie and Halle
Berry), a male computer geek (Aaron Taylor Johnson and Justin
Long) and a cute, young female (Emma Watson and Chloe Grace
Moretz). The submissions were narrowed down from a pool of
approximately 70,000 contestants to the twelve who appeared on the
program.
Judges for the competition included the film’s producer Lorenzo di
Bonaventura, Jiaflix’s chairman Sid Ganis, and head of Paramount’s
marketing and distribution division, Megan Colligan. Stated di Bon-
aventura about this venture into Chinese reality television: “[We] are
looking forward to becoming more and more part of the Chinese
audience’s experience by bringing the Chinese culture, Chinese tradi-
tions and Chinese talent into the movie” (qtd. in Gilman). Stressed
Ganis about the program: “It’s a good way for the government to
know the American film company is eager to participate with the
Chinese in the making of the movie” (qtd. in Block). Di Bonaventura
and Ganis’s comments suggest that the production partners were not
only looking to showcase the film’s direct ties to China, but also to
502 Kimberly Owczarski
Hong Kong and China, Age of Extinction had many attributes attrac-
tive to Chinese filmgoers. Paramount also secured favorable condi-
tions for the film’s release, in large part due to studio’s marketing
partnership with the China Movie Media Group (CMMG), which
opened its own Los Angeles-based office to help support the film’s
promotion (Cheney). CMMG is a subsidiary of the China Film
Group, which was the only organization that could import and dis-
tribute foreign films at the time. In order to promote the film in
China, CMMG used social networking sites and outdoor advertising
to build awareness about Age of Extinction weeks before its release. For
example, stars from the film recorded messages for Chinese students
about to take college entrance exams in June 2014, wishing them
luck and also asking them to see the film; the videos were then placed
online and widely shared (Coonan, “‘Transformers 4’ Stars”). Subways
cars were wrapped in Age of Extinction promotions, while massive
Transformers statues were erected in both Beijing and Hong Kong
Harbor (Sauer). CMMG also leveraged government assets to enhance
the film’s performance. In particular, the agency’s in-theater advertis-
ing channel featured promotions for the film, reaching just under
three-quarters of filmgoers in over 100 major cities. In addition, ten
of China’s largest cinema chains and an online ticketing site co-
promoted the film with CMMG (Coonan and McClintock). Age of
Extinction was the first Hollywood studio film to have its worldwide
premiere in China, an event also organized by CMMG (Coonan and
McClintock).
The film opened the same day in China as it did in the North
American market, a rarity for foreign films in the Chinese market-
place. By doing so, Paramount was able to eschew the huge drops in
potential revenue that occur when there is a delay between the North
American and Chinese release dates, a financial repercussion often
ascribed to piracy (Burkitt). Age of Extinction also had the good for-
tune to not face any new Hollywood releases its opening weekend in
China, which is also a regular occurrence for studio films in the Chi-
nese marketplace. Often, Hollywood studios do not know the exact
release dates for their films in China until a few weeks before, which
limits the extent of marketing the studios can do. Despite the poten-
tial lawsuit from the Pangu investors group, the Age of Extinction
release date was assigned well ahead of time and did not waver. The
film opened on over 60% of all Chinese screens, leading to a box
506 Kimberly Owczarski
office haul of nearly $100 million dollars in its first three days in the-
aters (“Record-Breaking Transformers Stun China”; Makinen, “‘Trans-
formers’ Breaks”). By the end of its second week, the film became the
highest grossing film ever in China with over $220 million, before
eventually earning $320 million (Frater, “Transformers 4”). This out-
paced the film’s box office revenues in North America by over $80
million, and indicated a significant shift in the importance of China
to the franchise’s fortunes.
Conclusion
Notes
The author thanks Yizhou Hu for her help accessing and translating content related to Transfor-
mers 4 Chinese Actors Talent Search Reality Show.
1. The North American market includes the US and English-speaking Canada.
2. SAPPRFT was established in 2013 after the State Administration of Radio, Film, and Tele-
vision (SARFT) merged with the General Administration of Press and Publications (GAPP).
For consistency, I will use SAPPRFT throughout this paper to refer to the state’s regulatory
board.
3. Unless otherwise noted, all domestic, global, and China box office figures were acquired from
the industry tracker Web site Box Office Mojo.
4. It is important to note that the Hong Kong and Chinese film industries developed separately
in the twentieth century, until Hong Kong returned to Chinese rule on July 1, 1997. Since
then, the Hong Kong film industry has remained autonomous but is often intertwined with
A Very Significant Chinese Component 509
the mainland Chinese film industry. Co-productions abound between Hong Kong and Chi-
nese companies, while other Hong Kong films remain independent from the mainland. The
recent Hong Kong film Ten Years (2015), for example, features five segments from different
directors that examine the role of the Chinese government in a dystopian near-future. Con-
demned by Chinese officials, Ten Years received no theatrical release in China but was a
major box office success in Hong Kong. It also won several Hong Kong Film Awards
(HKFA) in a ceremony that was not carried by Chinese television networks due to the film’s
inclusion in the nominations. Derek Yee, chairman of the HKFA, described the film’s situa-
tion as demonstrating “one country [with] two systems at work” (qtd. in Karen Chu). Yee’s
statement mimics Deng Xiaoping’s proposed “One Country, Two Systems” solution for the
different economic and political models operating in Hong Kong and China before the 1997
reunification (Yiu-Wai Chu 4).
5. In 2015, Furious 7 (James Wan, 2015) earned over $390 million to take over the record of
highest grossing film in China from Transformers: Age of Extinction. It was soon surpassed by
Mouse Hunt and The Mermaid, but it remains the highest grossing US film in Chinese
theaters.
Works Cited
www.theguardian.com/film/2013/may/30/hollywood-china-film-
industry.
Cheney, Alexandra. “China Movie Media Group Pairs with Para-
mount for ‘Transformers.’” Variety, 5 June 2014, http://www.va
riety.com/2014/biz/asia/china-movie-media-group-pairs-with-para
mount-for-transformers-1201214254/.
“China Film Industry Report 2013-2014 (Shared Version).” Entgroup
Consulting, n.d., http://english.entgroup.cn/uploads/reports/China
FilmIndustryReport2013-2014(sharedversion)490.pdf.
Chu, Karen. “Hong Kong New Wave Cinema? ‘Ten Years’ and More
Indies Challenging China.” The Hollywood Reporter, 14 May 2016,
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/hong-kong-new-wave-cin
ema-894132.
Chu, Yiu-Wai. Lost in Transition: Hong Kong Culture in the Age of
China. SUNY Press, 2013.
Cohen, David S. “‘Transformers’: A Splendidly Patriotic Film, If You
Happen to Be Chinese.” Variety, 3 July 2014, http://www.vari
ety.com/2014/film/columns/transformers-age-of-extinction-patrio
tic-for-china-1201257030/.
Coonan, Clifford. “China 2013 Box Office Surges 27 Percent to $3.6
Billion.” The Hollywood Reporter, 2 Jan. 2014, http://www.holly
woodreporter.com/news/china-2013-box-office-surges-668181.
——. “China’s Box Office Surges 36 Percent in 2014 to $4.76 Bil-
lion.” The Hollywood Reporter, 1 Jan. 2015, http://www.hollywood
reporter.com/news/chinas-box-office-surges-36-760889.
——. “Paramount Picks Four Chinese Actors for ‘Transformers 4’
Roles via Reality Show.” The Hollywood Reporter, 2 Sept. 2013,
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/chinas-box-office-surges-
36-760889.
——. “‘Transformers 4’ Stars Wish Chinese Students Luck for Col-
lege Entrance Exams.” The Hollywood Reporter, 6 June 2014,
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/video-transformer-4-stars-
wish-709821.
Coonan, Clifford, and Pamela McClintock. “‘Transformers 4’ Marks
New Era in Chinese, Hollywood Marketing Collaboration.” The
Hollywood Reporter, 2 July 2014, http://www.hollywoodreporter.
com/news/transformers-4-marks-new-era-716477.
Curtin, Michael. Playing to the World’s Biggest Audience: The Globaliza-
tion of Chinese Film and TV. U of California P, 2007.
Enav, Peter. “Hollywood Yielding to China’s Growing Film Clout.” Asso-
ciated Press, 24 Apr. 2013, http://www.apnewsarchive.com/2013/
Hollywood_yielding_to_China%27s_growing_film_clout/id-6db
b6302fba9426ebad24ed9586bb09c.
A Very Significant Chinese Component 511