Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dod Progress Report On Agsa Dashboard Report Drivers of Internal Control To Achieve Clean Administration
Dod Progress Report On Agsa Dashboard Report Drivers of Internal Control To Achieve Clean Administration
Annual SMS declaration not submitted for audit. An C HR - DCM 30 Apr 2012 Financial Disclosures and Performance
instruction will be issued to all SMS members by 31 Agreements Instructions were issued under
January each year to inform them of the due date reference CD HRM/DCM/R/101/1 dated 19
for the submission of financial disclosures. The December 2011 with target dates 31 March
SMS financial disclosures database will be updated 2012 for Financial Disclosures and 31 May
and continuously followed up to ensure submissions 2012 for Performance Agreements to be
are made by members. It is also planned to submitted. Database is 100% updated for the
introduce a SMS communication process to notify current submission cycle in terms of
SMS members of outstanding financial disclosures. Performance Agreements submitted by SMS
Target date for completion is 30 April 2012 and C members. (75% Military members and 52%
HR will monitor the accuracy and completeness of PSAP’s submitted Performance Agreements.)
data. 88% SMS members submitted Financial
Disclosures for the past financial year. A
request was submitted to register CIPRO as a
DOD Supplier in order to effect payment to
8
No. DRIVERS DOD COMMITMENTS RESPONSIBLE COMPLETION PROGRESS
CHIEF & DIR DATE
CIPRO for verifications performed against the
CIPRO database. This will pave the way for all
SMS financial disclosures (Submissions due at
31 March 2012) to be verified in future against
the CIPRO database.
Declaration of conflict of interest not always on HODSCI 31 Mar 2012 The new NT SBD 4 (Declaration of Interest)
tender files. The new revised SBD 4 (Declaration of (D Mat GRC) form has been distributed by the AO to C
Interest) form will be disseminated to all SANDF instructing that this document form part
procurement entities with an instruction that they of all standard bidding documents that suppliers
must be included in all bid, price quotation and must complete. The SBD 4 will then be filed on
supplier registration documents. In addition the the procurement file with all other procurement
Central procurement Service Centre has already documents and will thus be available on the
revised their supplier registration forms to include a “tender” file. Procurement entities are solely
specific declaration to be made by the supplier responsible for complying with this prescript and
confirming whether the supplier or any other HoDSCI can only enforce compliance by
stakeholder in the business is an employee of the executing materiel governance (evaluation of
Department. The target date for completion is 31 procurement entities).
March 2012 and the responsible official is HODSCI.
Performance Information. The Departmental Primary 31 Mar 2013 A draft integrated user requirement (UR) for the
Strategic Planning Enabler (GEJIMA) is in the DOD Integrated Strategic Management Enabler
process of being replaced by a web based custom CCS (CMPSP), (DOD SME) has been developed for submission
Performance Information Management System CDPSP(CDSM) to CCMIS and SITA for the further development
(PIMS). Services and Divisions currently report Secondary of user requirement system (URS).
quarterly and annually by populating spreadsheets
that reflect the respective Annual Performance Service and
Plans (APPs). This ensures perfect alignment Divisional
between performance information and the APPs. Chiefs
These spreadsheets will be incorporated in the new
PIMS. The performance information is monitored,
evaluated and consolidated at Level 1 to ensure
integrity and validity and are available for audit
purposes The monitoring and evaluation function
will during the strategic planning process feed into
the development of performance management
information, thus ensuring continuous improvement
of reliable performance management information.
Although being phased in, the provisional target
date for full implementation and roll out of the PIMS
is 31 March 2013.
Asset Management Interventions. A request has C Log - D AM Monthly National Treasury mater has been finalized.
been submitted to National Treasury for extension of Reconciliations on a monthly basis between
the period for disclosure of assets at R1 to 31 March systems are being carried out.
2007. The certificates from the Chiefs of the
Services/Divisions will provide an assurance that
they have satisfied themselves that the information
is available. Reconciliations between the log
9
No. DRIVERS DOD COMMITMENTS RESPONSIBLE COMPLETION PROGRESS
CHIEF & DIR DATE
systems and the data warehouse, and the FMS will
also provide a reasonable level of assurance that
the information on movement of assets can be
adequately supported with evidence, as the
Services will be signing off as well.
2.b Implement controls over Monthly reconciliation of transactions. The Log Div C Log (D AM) 31 Mar 2012 The reconciliation process has commenced
daily and monthly in cooperation with the Fin Mgmt Div is developing between the systems. Sign off has been
processing and a system integrated validation process between the obtained from the Chiefs of the Services.
reconciling of FMS and the Logistical systems in order to enable
transactions monthly reconciliation between the two
functionalities with regards to additions and
accruals. Target date for completion is 31
December 2012. As from 31 December 2012 all
accruals relating to Tangible Capital assets will be
obtainable via this interface. The reconciliation
process between the Log Systems and the
Corporate data warehouse is in process of being
mapped out. This process will focus on Specialised
Military assets (SMAs) (end items i.e. vessels,
aircraft and weapons) and Transport assets for the
financial year ending 31 March 2012. Subsequent
financial periods will focus on the remainder of the
SMAs and the other categories of assets.
Monthly creditors’ reconciliations. An enhancement CFO - DSSRP 31 Mar 2013
to the FMS has been enabled to ensure that
creditor statements can be processed via the FMS.
The result being that once the statement is
captured, the system will distinguish between paid
and unpaid invoices. Unpaid invoices will then be
followed up and paid immediately. The DOD
currently has several thousand suppliers on
different supplier databases ranging from large
corporate entities to micro enterprises. Whilst many
companies have the IT and business systems to
provide the DOD with electronic creditor statements
on a regular basis, it is estimated that there are an
equally large number of suppliers who use
rudimentary methods of doing business. Currently
only 10 of the largest suppliers have been
requested to provide statements. To ensure a full
roll-out, a phased in approach will be followed.
Management of Leases. Services and Divisions will Primary Monthly A workshop was conducted where the lease
on a monthly basis submit to C Log (Asset champions from the Services were present and
Management directorate) their lease returns which C Log (D AM)
the requirements for disclosure purposes were
they would have reviewed and signed off for Secondary made to the team. Attendance was not good
completeness and accuracy. The Chiefs of the
10
No. DRIVERS DOD COMMITMENTS RESPONSIBLE COMPLETION PROGRESS
CHIEF & DIR DATE
Services/Divisions should utilise the Service IG’s to Service and however. SAAF, SA Army, DI, MP were
conduct a high level review of the returns before Divisional present.
they sign off. C Log (Asset management Chiefs Suppliers have been consulted as well to
Directorate) reviews these returns for provide the DOD with a list of items they have
reasonableness of the figures, completeness and on lease with DOD.
accuracy of the payments and liabilities to be
raised. This process will be implemented as from 1 Leases workshops will be conducted at monthly
February 2012. intervals.
Inadequate skills transfer. The problem in the DOD CFO 31 Mar 2013
is that despite the amount of work and training that
was done by the Consortium, absence of adequate
officials to continue with the tasks at hand after
termination of the contract (e.g. lease commitments)
is a serious risk as the skills gap between the units
was very high. The DOD has realised this and in
the re-organisation proposals for Services and
Divisions financial management capacity is
proposed where suitably trained/skilled personnel
are proposed for recruitment. The CFO will oversee
this process and the completion date for the FMD
re-alignment process is 31 March 2013.
2.c Prepare regular, Preparation of Financial Statements. The CFO - DCA 31 Mar 2012 The accounting manual was issued with the
accurate and complete Accounting Policy submitted by the National Dec 2011 interim financial statements
financial and Treasury is issued as departmental policy under the instruction. Matter regarded as finalized.
performance reports signature of the Accounting Officer. The DOD has
that are supported and compiled an Accounting Manual to serve as a
evidenced by reliable departmental guide for the preparation of Financial
information Statements for the DOD. The responsibilities for the
verification and sign-off of the completeness and
accuracy of figures submitted for AFS purposes are
addressed in the annual instruction for the
compilation of financial statements. Target date for
final promulgation of the Accounting Manual is 31
March 2012.
Adequacy of IT systems. The issue of the systems CCMIS ????
in the DOD is largely an outcome of the
maintenance moratorium on development that was
imposed by National Treasury. There has been
progress with the implementation of the new IFMS
module on Procurement which is currently piloted at
various sites in the DOD. The effect of this has
been that the NT agreed that the DOD unique
elements are now allowed or systems compliant to
NATO may be developed.
11
No. DRIVERS DOD COMMITMENTS RESPONSIBLE COMPLETION PROGRESS
CHIEF & DIR DATE
Lack of monitoring controls over Performance Primary 31 Mar 2013 The Interim Department of Defence Instruction
Information. An Interim Department of Defence POL&PLAN/00001/2001 (Edition 1) has been
Instruction POL&PLAN/00001/2011 (EDITION 1) CCS (CMPSP), converted into a draft policy document which is
was compiled and approved during Sep 11 which CDPSP(CDSM) currently been distributed to key stakeholders
addresses performance information reporting Secondary for inputs and comments.
against plan. The Performance Information
Management System that is being developed has Service and
already been partially implemented to ensure Divisional
integrity and validity of performance information as Chiefs
indicated under serial 2.a.
Disclosure of Assets. The objective for disclosure Primary 31 Mar 2012 Plan is on target and exemption has been given
on assets for the financial year ending 31 March subject to specific conditions from National
2012 is on Specialised Military Assets (end items), C Log (D AM) Treasury.
Transport Assets and Immoveable Assets. The Secondary
following financial period disclosure will be on all
categories of assets, i.e Specialised military Assets, Service and
Transport Assets, Immoveable Assets, Heritage Divisional
Assets, Computer Equipment, Other Equipment and Chiefs
Furniture. The achievement of this objective is
however heavily dependent on the asset
management structures being set up at the
Services/Divisions.
2.d Review and monitor Supply Chain Intervention. A comprehensive review HODSCI 31 Mar 2012 Same response as one captured under par 1.d
compliance with of the Supply Chain Management Policy Regime is (D Mat GRC) -Processes to prevent and detect irregular
applicable laws and currently in process. The review will include the expenditure.
regulations DODI on procurement, all relevant procurement
regulations and procurement delegations. SLAs
and Contracts will be will be forwarded to the Legal
Services Division for vetting prior to them being
signed. Bidders’ details will be published on the
website for all req >R500k within 10 days after
closure of the bid. ID numbers of bidders will be
verified against the DOD’s post establishment table
by utilising the revised SBD 4 “Declaration of
Interest” document for both price quotations and
bids. A procurement road-show will be conducted to
interface with procurement officials.
Asset Management. Until recently there has been Primary 31 Mar 2012 Matter finalized. All positions have been filled.
no dedicated director /coordination capacity in the
Log Division that was financially skilled. The C Log (D AM)
appointment of the Asset Management Director and Secondary
the roll-out of the structure to support her will now
help to create and, with the support of the CFO, Service and
guide the other parties to create an understanding Divisional
of the requirement in future. Furthermore, an
12
No. DRIVERS DOD COMMITMENTS RESPONSIBLE COMPLETION PROGRESS
CHIEF & DIR DATE
instruction has also been issued to Services/| Chiefs
Divisions to create the same structures within their
areas of responsibility.
Performance contracts. The target date for the C HR (DCM) 31 May 2012 Performance Agreements Instructions were
submission of signed performance contracts by issued under reference CD HRM/DCM/R/101/1
SMS members is 31 May each year. CHR is the dated 19 December 2011 with target date 31
system owner of this process and will ensure that all May 2012 for Performance Agreements to be
performance contracts are submitted and will be submitted. Database is 100% updated for the
available for audit purposes. current submission cycle in terms of
Performance Agreements submitted by SMS
members. (75% Military members and 52%
PSAP’s submitted Performance Agreements.)
Irregular expenditure reported. The Office of the CFO (Act 31 Mar 2013 The DOD Financial Misconduct Prevention
CFO has developed a Financial Misconduct DFCS) Strategy was approved in Mar 2011 and
Strategy which was presented to the Accountability implemented during October 2011 in the DOD.
Management Committee (AMC) and approved by
the Accounting Officer (AO) in March 2011. The The implementation is in process and is
main objective of the strategy is aimed at monitored by the monthly workgroup
preventing, detecting, recording, reporting, established to ensure proper implementation at
investigating, taking appropriate action and all levels.
implementing corrective measures to discourage The first info bulletin on the topic was issued in
future reoccurrence of unauthorised, irregular and November 2011 and the next will be issued in
fruitless & wasteful expenditure. The DOD’s February 2012.
Financial Misconduct policy has been revised,
approved and implemented during the 2010/11 An article for the Soldier Magazine will be
financial year. All incidents of irregular expenditure published in the March 2012 issue.
reported to the Accounting Officer are reported to Planning for the road show is in process and the
the NT via the monthly early warning report and visits to the identified units will start in April
disclosed quarterly in the interim financial 2012.
statements.
2.e Design and implement Appropriate IT controls over IT governance. The CCMIS 30 Jun 2012
formal controls over IT Operation Clean Audit Charter 1 and 2 corrected the
systems to ensure the internal controls of the PERSOL, FMS, LOGEIS and
reliability of the systems E-procure systems. The other identified sub
and the availability, transactional systems are not yet reviewed as they
accuracy and protection were part of Charter 3 that was not approved due to
of information a lack of funds. The CMIS Division is currently
investigating the matter and intends to invite tenders
for resources that will define, review and map out all
processes for all the transactional systems.
The following IT risks were identified arising from CCMIS 1 Apr 2012
the control weaknesses identified by the AGSA:
Change Management for the Financial
13
No. DRIVERS DOD COMMITMENTS RESPONSIBLE COMPLETION PROGRESS
CHIEF & DIR DATE
Management System (FMS), PERSOL, Logistics
Information Management System (LIMS),
Operational Support System (OSIS) and
Computer Aided Logistics Management
Information System (CALMIS) applications;
Security settings for Mainframe, Sun Solaris and
Oracle;
Service Level Agreement (SLA) Management;
Backup and disaster recovery for mainframe and
distributed environment;
Computer Operations for the distributed
environment;
Physical security for the Blenny Data Centre:
In response to the above risks, the CMIS Division
has developed detailed policies, processes and
procedures of which some have already been
implemented whilst others will be completed and
implemented by 1 April 2012.
GOVERNANCE
3.a Implement appropriate On 27 June 2011 the DOD received an AGSA audit CDPSP (DRM) 31 Jul 2011 The risk relating to performance information has
risk management finding indicating a possible risk related to poor been identified in the DPSP strategic risk
activities to ensure that record keeping. The DOD acknowledged that the register. Although the top ten risks for the
regular risk finding of AGSA was correct and indicated in its Defence Secretariat have not yet been
assessments, including response to AGSA dated 29 June 2011 that the risk approved, this risk has been identified as one of
consideration of IT risks and mitigating actions would be included in the the Defence Secretariat’s top ten risks. This
and fraud prevention, DOD’s risk register. matter is regarded as finalized.
are conducted and that
a risk strategy to The 2011/12 DOD Fraud Prevention plan was IGDOD 31 Jul 2012
address the risks is approved by the CSANDF and the SecDef and (DACAF)
developed and submitted to the AGSA. The annual revision of the
monitored 2012/13 plan will be finalized by 15 December 2011
and submitted for approval by 31 January 2012.
The target for the completion of the roll out after
approval of the plan is 31 July 2012. DACAF is also
in the process of finalizing a DODI on the
implementation of the Corruption and Fraud
Prevention Plan with a target date of 31 March
2012. The current responsibility is IGDOD but it is
foreseen that this responsibility will migrate to the
Internal Audit Executive once appointed.
3.b Ensure that there is an Appointment of the Internal Audit Executive. The C HR (DCM) 31 Mar 2012 After approval by the MOD a higher salary offer
adequately resourced CabMemo on the appointment of the Internal Audit was made to the member. The member
and functioning internal Executive was approved at the Cabinet meeting of however declined the offer on 16 Jan 12 after
audit unit that identifies 24 October 2011 and the DOD has since made an the member’s current employer made her a
14
No. DRIVERS DOD COMMITMENTS RESPONSIBLE COMPLETION PROGRESS
CHIEF & DIR DATE
internal control offer to the successful candidate. The official has higher salary offer on 1 Dec 11. CHR prepared
deficiencies and rejected the offer and the DOD is currently a submission to advise that the DOD must not
recommends corrective negotiating with DPSA regarding a new offer. The make a second counter offer, but rather to re-
action effectively internal audit structure will be substantially start a second head-hunting process for the
capacitated within six months of the appointment of post of Head Chief Internal Audit.
the Internal Audit Executive.
Asset management approach. Until such time that C Log (D AM) 31 Mar 2012 National treasury and Logistics Division
the Internal Audit structure is operational, the Log Inspectors have been used to review
Division will work closely with National Treasury who compliance with policy.
is willing to provide the necessary assistance for
quality control and independent reviews of the work
carried out.
3.c Ensure that the audit The IGDOD is overseeing the internal audit function IGDOD 31 Mar 2012
committee promotes of the DOD until the Internal Audit Executive has
accountability and been appointed. All action plans pertaining to the
service delivery through AGSA audit findings will be monitored by the DOD
evaluating and Audit Committee.
monitoring responses to
risks and providing
oversight over the
effectiveness of the
internal control
environment including
financial and
performance reporting
and compliance with
laws and regulations