Group B (Akasha Noor,

Shafay Ahad) Product

Comparision Sheet
ABB Models Emerson Models Honeywell Models Galvanic Models
Sr.No. Features
8206 with H2S 8209 8207 770XA 570XA Encal 3000 H2S Encal 3000 Accu Chrome C7+ Sulf Chrome GC
C6+ & H2S Not Applicable with
1 Technology Comply Does not comply only HC upto C7+ Comply Only C6+ analysis Comply Comply Only H2S analysis
H2S

2 C9+ Analysis Does not comply Comply Does not comply Comply Does not comply Comply Comply Does not comply Does not comply

Analysis time C6+ HC 6mins , H2S 13 4mins & Not 3mins for HC and 3 min HC & not 5 mins HC, 7 mins
3 &H2S Not Applicable 6mins 5mins 7mins for H2S
mins applicable for H2S 3mins for H2S applicable for H2S H2S

4 Analysis Time C9+ Not Applicable 6 mins Not Applicable 4 mins Not applicable 5mins 5mins Not applicable Not applicable

from 0.02% and

5 Low ppm H2S (0-4) 4ppm Does not comply ±3 ppm Not applicable 1ppm does not comply Does not specify 5ppb
higher
Micro Packed
6 Colum Technology Packed Columns Packed Columns Packed Columns Capillary Column Capillary Column Capillary Column Capillary Column Capillary Column
Column
Number of Detectors
7 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 NA 1

TCDs , FID (on

8 Type of Detectors TCDs TCD TCD TCD & FPD TCD TCD TCD FPD
request)
±.5 BTU / 1000
Repeatibility on BTU ± 0.125 Btu @ 1,000
BTUs ±0.25 BTU/1000 for ±0.25 Btu/scf per ± 2% F.S in case of
9 C6+ ±0.125Btu/1000Btu Does not comply Btu (±0.0125%) BTU < 0.005 % BTU < 0.005 %
±.25 BTU / 1000 ambient temp. 1,000 Btu H2S
ambient
± 0.125 Btu @ 1,000 BTU
10 Repeatibility on BTU Not Applicable Btu (±0.0125%) Not Applicable Not Applicable Not applicable Same as above Same as above Does not comply Does not comply
C9+ ambient
No. of streams 3sample streams ,1 3sample stream, 1 3 sample streams, 1 Up to 7 including 12 streams including 4 sample streams . 1 5 streams including
11 allowed NA 8 including cal gas
cal gas stream cal gas stream cal gas stream cal gas cal gas cal gas cal gas

12 Data Storage 35 days 35 days 35 days Over 34 days 35 days 35 days 35 days 35 days NA

Field Maintainable
13 Module Does not Comply Does not comply Does not comply Comply Comply Does not comply Does not comply comply Does not comply

14 GPA 2172 Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Does not comply

15 GPA 2145 Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Does not comply Comply Does not comply

16 ISO 6979 Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Does not comply

17 AGA 8 Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Comply Does not comply Comply Does not comply

18 HCDP & AGA 10 Comply Comply Comply NA Only HCDP Only HCDP Only HCPD NA Does not comply

19 Software PCCU 32 PCCU 32 PCCU 32 MON2000 MON2000 RGC 3000 RGC 3000 GUI GUI

Power (Startup in
20 Watts) 45 watts 90 Watts 45 watts 350 Watts 350 Watts 50 Watts 50 Watts 100 Watts 600 Watt

21 Power (Nominal in 7 watts 14 watts 7 watts 100Watts 100 Watts 18 watts 18 Watts 50 watts 420 Watts
Watts)

22 MEMS Components NA NA NA NA NA Comply Comply NA NA

2 serial, 2USB&1 2 serial, 2USB&1 2 serial, 2USB&1 2 serial, 2USB&1 3 serial ports, 1 2 serial, 2USB&1 2 serial, 2USB&1
23 Communication Ports 2 Serial, 2USB 2 Serial, 2USB
Ethernet Ethernet Ethernet Ethernet Ethernet port Ethernet Ethernet

24 Display Built in Built in Built in Built in Built in Separate Unit Separate Unit Built in Built in
*NA= Not Available