5/8/2018 High-efficiency milling speed changes rules - Canadian Metalworking

(/)
Home (/) / Article (/?filter=article) / Cutting Tools (/?filter=article&category=cuttingtools)
/ High-efficiency milling speed changes rules

 (https://www.sharethis.com/share?url=https://www.canadianmetalworking.com/article/cuttingtools/high-efficiency-milling-speed-
Upcoming Industry Events
changes-rules&title=High-
efficiency+milling+speed+changes+rules&summary=Lower+radial+chip+thinning+and+constant+tool+engagement+involved+in+high- "Get the Lissmac Edge" Seminar (/event/-get-
the-lissmac-edge-seminar)
efficiency+milling+processes+can+increase+cycle+time%2C+extend+tool+life%2C+and+reduce+stress+on+machines.)  MAY 9, 2018 MN
MMTS 2018 (/event/mmts-2018)
 (https://www.printfriendly.com) MAY 14-16, 2018 | MONTREAL, QC
Metalworking Manufacturing & Production
High-efficiency milling speed changes rules Expo - Moncton (/event/metalworking-
manufacturing-production-expo-moncton)
MAY 29, 2018 | MONCTON, NB
Tooling, software, and equipment combine capabilities to make the FABTECH Canada (/event/fabtech-canada)
process work JUNE 12-14, 2018 | TORONTO, ON

CANADIAN METALWORKING JANUARY 2018 (/PUBLICATION/CM/CM-JANUARY-2018) See All Industry Events » (/?filter=event)
JANUARY 10, 2018
BY: SUE ROBERTS (/AUTHOR/SUE-ROBERTS)

Lower radial chip thinning and constant tool engagement involved in high-
efficiency milling processes can increase cycle time, extend tool life, and
reduce stress on machines.

Most Popular Content This Week

Stelco donates $182,000 to the CWB
Foundation in support of welding education
(/news/welding/stelco-donates-182-000-to-
the-cwb-foundation-in-support-of-welding-
education)
Farr Gold Series dust collectors from Camfil
designed to maximize floor space
(/product/fabricating/farr-gold-series-dust-
collectors-from-camfil-designed-to-maximize-
floor-space)
DiPaolo Machine Tools’ GROB G550T 5-axis
machine handles 5-sided machining
(/product/metalworking/dipaolo-machine-
tools-grob-g550t-5-axis-machine-handles-5-
sided-machining)
Nikola Labs’ PfM predictive maintenance
sensors capture vibration and temperature
wirelessly
(/product/automationsoftware/nikola-labs-
pfm-predictive-maintenance-sensors-capture-
vibration-and-temperature-wirelessly)
Wilson Tool International’s QuickTap tapping
tool available in D station size
(/product/fabricating/wilson-tool-international-
s-quicktap-tapping-tool-available-in-d-station-
size)
(https://static.canadianmetalworking.com/a/high-efficiency-milling-speed-changes-rules- ESAB GTAW/SMAW inverter receives Red
1515082257.jpg?size=1000x1000) Dot Award for product design
By taking light radial depths of cut, it is possible to use long axial engagement of the cutting edge to maximize (/news/welding/esab-gtaw-smaw-inverter-
tool efficiency. Photo courtesy of Walter USA LLC. receives-red-dot-award-for-product-design)
Stepping from the world of standard milling to high-efficiency milling (HEM) can change just about HR0530 hardness tester from Mitutoyo
everything. HEM’s lower radial depth of cut (RDOC) and a higher axial depth of cut (ADOC) create Canada has electronic control
(/product/measurement/hr0530-hardness-
consistent wear across the end mill cutting edge, generate less heat, and lessen the chance of tool tester-from-mitutoyo-canada-has-electronic-
failure. Machines can sustain less stress and tooling can last much longer. control)

Two basic concepts differentiate HEM from standard milling. One is radial chip thinning and the Michigan Manufacturing Technology Center
to host strategic planning workshops
other is a constant tool engagement angle. Machine, software, and tooling must combine forces to (/news/management/michigan-
make the process possible. The process is known by different names, frequently assigned by manufacturing-technology-center-to-host-
software companies as they design programs for the high-speed process, including dynamic strategic-planning-workshops)
milling, advanced roughing, and high-efficiency machining. The principles behind the various Creaform’s MetraSCAN 3D-R measurement
names, however, are basically the same. device designed for shop floor measuring
(/product/measurement/creaform-s-
metrascan-3d-r-measurement-device-
Thinner Chips designed-for-shop-floor-measuring)
Luke Pollock, product manager at Walter USA (http://www.walter-tools.com), described the AIRFRAME from Levitate Technologies offers
process. “Machining with a light RDOC creates a chip that is thinner than the advance per tooth. upper body support to workers
This means that to get the correct chip thickness, the feed rate needs to be higher. We can (/product/fabricating/airframe-from-levitate-
technologies-offers-upper-body-support-to-
increase the feed rate, sometimes by as much as three times the normal calculated rate. When workers)
machining into a corner, however, the tool engagement increases and the feed rates must be
decreased to avoid chatter or tool breakage.

“To combat this, the tooling software develops a toolpath that maintains a constant tool
engagement angle (TEA). By maintaining a constant TEA, the tool never gets over-engaged in the
material and the machining condition stays constant. Combine this with elevated feed rates from
radial chip thinning because of light RDOC and you have the concept of dynamic milling.”

Dan Doiron, milling products manager for Emuge Corp. (http://www.emuge.com), referred to the
process as advanced roughing. “Advanced roughing can be described as more of a transition into
aggressive milling. It’s no longer the boxy, zig-zag, small-depth cuts. Today’s technology enables
lead-in, lead-out, helical entry, ramping, trochoidal or circular style patterns, and in some cases, use
of the full length of an end mill’s cutting flutes. It used to be roughing from the top down, but now it
has turned into roughing from the bottom up.”

Variable Trajectories and Feed Rates

Software and tooling have necessarily advanced along with the milling processes.Alan Levine,
managing director of Open Mind Technologies USA Inc. (http://www.openmind-tech.com) , said that
advanced roughing techniques have been incorporated into most CAM software over the last five to
10 years. Rather than being considered advanced programs, these complex programs are now
becoming the new norm.

“Traditional roughing toolpaths would be derived by taking a series of offsets from the internal or
external boundaries of the desired region. This was fairly straightforward from a mathematical point
of view, but was not necessarily ideal for metal removal.

“In a simple example of a rectangular pocket, the cutter would take a prescribed cut along the
rectangle sides. Then in the corners the cutter would have increased material engagement as well
as a change of direction. A shrieking sound would indicate poor cutting conditions, and a common
solution would be to reduce feed rate. In some cases, that reduction would last for the rest of the
program,” Levine said.

https://www.canadianmetalworking.com/article/cuttingtools/high-efficiency-milling-speed-changes-rules 1/5
5/8/2018 High-efficiency milling speed changes rules - Canadian Metalworking
“Advanced roughing technique software sees these challenging areas and changes the toolpath
trajectory to nibble into the corners and change feed rates to unify material removal and cutter
performance. Then feed rates can be increased. With lower stress on the cutter, the deeper cuts
are possible.”

Levine compared the new tooling paths with a circular, trochoidal-style motion to a spirograph. “The
cutter motion includes nibbles and return moves to align for the next cut. Without incorporating
additional software technology in the toolpath, the resulting cut time can actually increase due to
the longer toolpath motion. Tool paths should be smooth so the machine tool servos do not detect
acceleration spikes and force a feed rate reduction. The return moves between trochoidal passes
should have increased feed rate and a small lift to avoid rubbing and recutting previously cut
regions.”

(https://static.canadianmetalworking.com/a/high-efficiency-milling-speed-changes-rules-
1515082250.jpg?size=1000x1000)
The path of a new 3-D roughing strategy is shown in yellow in a cavity. Illustration courtesy of Open Mind
Technologies.

For the corners, Levine said, advanced roughing should combine a variable engagement with
changes to feed rate and spindle speed to ensure a constant cutting load. A properly implemented
advanced roughing technique will reduce cutting time by 50 to 70 per cent compared to traditional
techniques, and it can increase cutter life by approximately a factor of three.

Multi-purpose Tools
HEM can be a more economical way to machine when the right variables—machine, software, and
tooling—are present. One tool can be used to produce various groove widths and corner radii.

“Due to the small RDOC producing smaller side loads on the tool, it is possible to take a deep
ADOC with the tools, using the entire flute length. Using the full cutting edge of the tool is more
economical than using only the tip of the tool,” said Pollock.

“A large- diameter tool is not needed to create deep pockets. A small-diameter tool using a dynamic
milling strategy can remove the same amount of material as a large tool using a traditional slotting
strategy. The same work can be done with a less expensive tool,” said Pollock. “Producing less
side load allows using a smaller tool at deeper depths of cut, but it also means that less machine
and workpiece setup rigidity are required. In theory, the same parts could be produced on a smaller
spindle with less machine horsepower.”

End Mill Characteristics

Tools specifically designed for HEM have some special characteristics that help them produce for
up to two or three times longer than standard tooling used in a standard milling process. Their
longevity is largely accredited to the fact that less heat is generated because the flute is engaged
with the material a shorter amount of time. The heat that is produced is directed to the chip rather
than the tool. As a rule of thumb, many flutes and chip cutters are good tooling characteristics for
HEM.

Pollock said, “The tools normally contain a high number of teeth or cutting edges. Since deep
depths of cut are achieved by this strategy, long lengths of cut are also incorporated into the cutting
tools.

“The light RDOC produces a very short chip in the radial direction due to the chip thinning, but
since we are taking advantage of deep depths of cut, the chip in the axial direction can be very long
and tend to cling, making chip evacuation more difficult. Chip splitters or chipbreakers along the
cutting edge can solve the problem.”

Doiron said, “Many of today’s end mills are specifically designed to handle such machining—for
example, our trochoidal end mill line. These tools use the full range of the flute length, cutting in
circular patterns, peeling material in a climb cut direction, and pushing chips away from the tool.
Tools that are 4XD in length can have problems evacuating long chips that can get entangled and
packed into the tool, causing tool failure. To avert this problem, our trochoidal tools feature a
chipbreaker designed in a staggered pattern that enables the tool to break the chips in shorter
segments. This makes it easier to flush out the chips and still provide an excellent finish.

“Feed rates can be faster because the tool, being fully engaged in a side milling position, is stable.
Cutting forces are consistent throughout the flute length, and the tool is designed with a variable
helix along with irregular flute spacing, which reduces vibration.”

Typically Advantageous
Alternative toolpaths can be applied to most milling processes as long as the equipment can
accommodate the faster speeds and read the process program quickly, but for some types of jobs,
the advantages and savings may not be as dramatic as for others.

https://www.canadianmetalworking.com/article/cuttingtools/high-efficiency-milling-speed-changes-rules 2/5
5/8/2018 High-efficiency milling speed changes rules - Canadian Metalworking

(https://static.canadianmetalworking.com/a/high-efficiency-milling-speed-changes-rules-
1515082273.jpg?size=1000x1000)
Trochoidal end mills can be fully engaged in a side milling position, adding to the stability of the process.
Photo courtesy of Emuge Corp.

“There are no hard and fast rules for using advanced roughing,” said Doiron. “It is up to the user,
the equipment, and the application. One needs to evaluate the specific needs--perhaps conduct a
time study on a conventional CAM system using a traditional pocket mill and compare it to an
advanced milling scenario. The results of the time calculated by the CAM systems can provide an
accurate time difference between the two.”

Pollock said that shallow pockets or depths of cut bring the production closer to standard slotting
since the full-length-of-cut machining cannot be used and some materials, such as aluminum, are
already machined at such high surface footage that the productivity is already close to that of
dynamic milling.

“One of the most important reasons to use dynamic milling,” Pollock said, “is process reliability or
security. Because of only using light radial engagement of the tool, and a program maintaining a
constant TEA, the tool is never in a situation where there is a chance of becoming over-engaged or
at risk of packing chips. The machining condition stays consistent, which provides for consistent
tool life and very little risk of having a crash or tool breakage situation.”

Associate Editor Sue Roberts can be reached at sroberts@canadianmetalworking.com

(sroberts@canadianmetalworking.com).

Emuge Corp., www.emuge.com (http://www.emuge.com)

Open Mind Technologies, www.openmind-tech.com (http://www.openmind-tech.com)

Walter USA LLC, www.walter-tools.com (http://www.walter-tools.com)

(https://static.canadianmetalworking.com/a/high-efficiency-milling-speed-changes-rules-
1515082282.jpg?size=1000x1000)
Trochoidal tool paths eliminate unproductive tool motions. Illustration courtesy of Emuge Corp.

You May Also Like

(/product/metalworking/machining-
(/article/cuttingtools/tooling-
(/product/metalworking/machine-
(/news/metalworking/cmts-
centres-evaluating- tips-for-high-speed- tools-products) show-guide-product-
machine-tools) machining) preview)
Machine Tools
Machining centres: Tooling Tips for Products CMTS Show Guide
evaluating machine High-speed Product Preview
(/product/metalworking/machine-
tools Machining
tools-products) (/news/metalworking/cmts-
show-guide-product-

https://www.canadianmetalworking.com/article/cuttingtools/high-efficiency-milling-speed-changes-rules 3/5
5/8/2018 High-efficiency milling speed changes rules - Canadian Metalworking
(/product/metalworking/machining-
(/article/cuttingtools/tooling- preview)
centres-evaluating- tips-for-high-speed-
machine-tools) machining)
Sue Roberts
http://www.canadianmetalworking.com
2135 Point Blvd (http://www.canadianmetalworking.com)
Elgin, IL 60123 Contact via email
Phone: 815-227-8241 (mailto:sroberts@canadianmetalworking.com)


(https://plus.google.com/111447805139888054104?
rel=author)

More Content by Sue Roberts

(/author/sue-roberts)

Sue Roberts, associate editor, contributes to both Canadian Metalworking and Canadian Fabricating
& Welding. A metalworking industry veteran, she has contributed to marketing communications efforts
and written B2B articles for the metal forming and fabricating, agriculture, food, financial, and regional
tourism industries.

Roberts is a Northern Illinois University journalism graduate.

Published In...

Canadian Metalworking
Founded in 1905, Canadian Metalworking is a
monthly trade publication that covers all aspects of
metalworking technology in Canada.

Each issue features new product information,

technology advice, business instruction, and stories
from innovative shops. During the year readers can
(https://www.twitter.com/CdnMetalworking)
expect in-depth coverage of milling, turning, grinding, 
EDM equipment, quality and measurement devices,
and additive manufacturing technology, as well as software and IT designed for the manufacturer.

Canadian Metalworking has the largest audited circulation of any metalworking magazine in Canada
with over 30,000 readers.

Preview the Digital Edition (http://www.canadianmetalworking-

digital.com/canadianmetalworking/current)

Subscribe to Canadian Metalworking (//www.thefabricator.com/subscription/pub/cim)

Read more from this issue (/publication/cm/cm-january-2018)

0 Comments Canadian Metalworking 

1 Login

Sort by Best
 Recommend ⤤ Share

Start the discussion…

LOG IN WITH
OR SIGN UP WITH DISQUS ?

Name

Be the first to comment.

ALSO ON CANADIAN METALWORKING

Report explores future of global welding Testing & inspection/hardness testing

equipment market 1 comment • a year ago
1 comment • a year ago justinburger — yes, i also agree that
siva — Thanks for sharing this informative hardness tester is a good thing.I want to
post. This is very useful. introduce one kind of our company product

Samco Machinery brings on new project Arrow hits the mark with laser cutting
manager system
1 comment • a year ago 1 comment • a year ago
INBON MACHINERY — Congratulations SirI siva — Great information!!
think this person very nice for it positions.
http://www.inbonrollforming...

✉ Subscribe d Add Disqus to your siteAdd DisqusAdd 🔒 Privacy

Visit our Affiliated Websites Follow Us: 

(https://www.facebook.com/CanadianMetalworking/) 

(https://twitter.com/CdnMetalworking) 

(https://www.linkedin.com/showcase/10774211/) 

(https://plus.google.com/+Canadianmetalworking) 

(https://www.youtube.com/FMAnetorg) 
(/metal_fabricating_news.rss)

https://www.canadianmetalworking.com/article/cuttingtools/high-efficiency-milling-speed-changes-rules 4/5
5/8/2018 High-efficiency milling speed changes rules - Canadian Metalworking

(https://www.thefabricator.com) (https://www.fmanet.org) (https://www.fabtechexpo.com) (https://www.nutsandboltsfoundation.org)

Articles Membership Attend Scholarships
(https://www.thefabricator.com/? (https://www.fmanet.org/membership) (https://www.fabtechexpo.com/attend) (https://www.nutsandboltsfoundation.org/scholarships)
filter=article) Training Exhibit Manufacturing Camps
Blogs (https://www.fmanet.org/training) (https://www.fabtechexpo.com/exhibit) (https://www.nutsandboltsfoundation.org/camps)
(https://www.thefabricator.com/? News Education Program News
filter=blog) (https://www.fmanet.org/blog) (https://www.fabtechexpo.com/education)
(https://www.nutsandboltsfoundation.org/news)
News Events FABTECH Canada Donate
(https://www.thefabricator.com/? (https://www.fmanet.org/events) (http://fabtechcanada.com/) (https://www.nutsandboltsfoundation.org/donate)
filter=news)
New Products
(https://www.thefabricator.com/?
filter=product)

Subscriptions Industry Tradeshows (/?filter=event) Canadian Metalworking provides metal fabrication

(https://www.thefabricator.com/subscription)
Advertise with Us (/mediakit)
Contact Us (/contact-us)
FMA Store (https://www.fmanet.org/store)
Job Board (https://jobs.fmanet.org)
professionals with market news, the industry's best
articles, product news, and conference information
from the Fabricators & Manufacturers Association,
Intl. (https://www.fmanet.org)
© 2018 FMA Communications Canada, Inc. All

(/publication/cm) (/publication/cfw)

1154 Warden Avenue Suite #416, Toronto, Ontario M1R 0A1

888-394-4362 | info@canadianmetalworking.com
(mailto:info@canadianmetalworking.com)

Terms of Use (https://www.fmanet.org/terms-of-use) | Privacy

Policy (https://www.fmanet.org/privacy-policy)

https://www.canadianmetalworking.com/article/cuttingtools/high-efficiency-milling-speed-changes-rules 5/5