Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Khabar: Eeing The Igger Icture
Khabar: Eeing The Igger Icture
KHABAR
FALL 2018
I
works closely with the Department of
n retrospect, it seems inevitable that
History of Art and the Department of Art
THE SOUTH ASIA ART
the Institute for South Asia Studies
would launch a South Asia Art Ini- Practice. Both departments offer excel- INITIATIVE AT UC
tiative (SAAI). It is worth recollecting lent undergraduate and graduate training BERKELEY
that, among all the universities in the in the history and practice of the visual With the support of the University
United States, it is UC Berkeley that arts. The SAAI also works closely with and the Indo-American community, the
drew Rabindranath Tagore’s attention. museums such as the Berkeley Art Mu- goal of the Institute in the coming years
Embarking on a world tour to gather sup- seum and Pacific Film Archive and re- is to create a research center dedicated
port for Visva Bharati, his experimental search centers such as the Arts Research
to the study of art and visual culture of
educational center for the arts, Tagore Center. Community partners include the
South Asia. Fundraising plans for this
arrived in Berkeley in 1929. Several Asian Art Museum of San Francisco, the
initiative include:
decades later, in 1962, when the Indian Society for Art and Cultural Heritage of
India, the Montalvo Arts Center, The • Endowed annual lecture series
modernist artist Syed Haider Raza was on the arts of South Asia and its
San Jose Museum of Art, and Stanford
University among others to build close diasporas
collaborations across the Bay Area. • Endowed Artist and Scholar
UC Berkeley has a long history of Residency Program
teaching the arts of South Asia and its • Endowed fellowships for graduate
diasporas. Starting in 1967, Professor and undergraduate students
Emeritus Joanna Williams was the De- • Collaborations with museums and
partment of History of Art’s preeminent universities in South Asia
professor of South and Southeast Asian • Endowed biennial international
art for over four decades. Williams super-
conference at Berkeley
vised and trained a generation of scholars
whose work has focused on topics rang- • Curating exhibitions with Bay Area
ing from stone portrait sculptures of the partners
Tagore with Indian students at UC Berkeley in 1929. Pallavas and the Cholas and modernism
Picture from "South Asians in North America" Collection,
Support us by giving to
in Indian art to Buddhist palm leaf manu-
South/Southeast Asia Library, UC Berkeley
scripts from South and Southeast Asia. southasia.berkeley.edu/
invited to teach in Berkeley as a visit- More recently, the university has GIVE-BIG-SOUTH-ASIA
ing faculty for a semester, the experience hired four faculty specializing in the arts
proved to be transformative. Introduced of South Asia and its diasporas. Sugata among the Cold War, the Non-Aligned
to the work of American Abstract Ex- Ray who joined the Department of His- Movement, and art after 1945; new me-
pressionists by the Bay Area artist Sam tory of Art in 2012, teaches courses on dia and experimental cinema; and the
Francis, Raza was not only drawn to Mark early modern and colonial South and question of the global more broadly.
Rothko’s work but was deeply influenced Southeast Asian art and architecture. In the Department of Art Practice,
by it. Seeking to transcend the realism Trained in both history and art history, Allan deSouza works across different
of the Parisian School, Raza found a kin- Ray’s research and teaching focuses on disciplines, including photography, text,
dred spirit in Rothko and an artistic path early modern and
to a very different kind of interiority. colonial artistic
This happened. Here. In Berkeley. cultures, transter-
This is our history; this is our genealogy. ritorial ecologies,
Over the past several years, the In- and the natural
stitute for South Asia Studies has built environment.
a comprehensive art program and pro- Atreyee Gupta,
moted conversation around the visual who joined the
cultures of South Asia through talks, Department of
Asma Kazmi Dr. Sugata Ray Allan deSouza Dr. Atreyee Gupta
conferences, and exhibitions. With the History of Art
inauguration of the South Asia Art Ini- in 2017, focuses on modern and con- performance
tiative in April 2018, the SAAI moves temporary art and its diasporas. Her and pedagogy. His photography, installa-
onto the next level with local, national, research and teaching clusters around tion, text and performance works restage
and international collaborations that visual and intellectual histories of historical evidence through counter-strat-
twentieth-century art; the intersections egies of fiction, erasure, (cont'd on page 3)
2
Ne
Former Program Assistants—WHAT ARE THEY DOING NOW
E ven though most of my experience has been in computer The Desais have also national media, business, and government
science and research, my most breathtaking experience donated a large set of books officials; and outreach to K-14 schools
at Berkeley took place during my second semester when I from their personal collection The NRC program has been impor-
took a Sanskrit class. Before we got to the literature, we to the Art History/Classics tant to ensuring the global diversity of
had to learn the basics…eventually, I was able to read Library. The collection contains United States-paced university research,
authentic texts from thousands of years ago. Being able rare exhibition catalogs and teaching, and community outreach. Many
to read an ancient language – after only two semesters of bookson South Asian art and strong South Asia programs around the
studying – was a breathtaking moment for me. architecture, as well as other country compete to be National Resource
—Sam Kumar BS ’17, UCB University Medal Runner Up prized items such as a signed, Centers. Berkeley's selection is testimony
three-volume set on the Plan of to the great strength of its faculty and
established, "Samskrtaparmpara: The St. Gall by Walter Horn, the founder students, its deep community support,
Berkeley Sanskrit Studies Fund" with a of the Department of Art History. and the continuing commitment of ad-
generous gift of $100,000, in order to Helen Crane Desai is an alumni of ministrators across campus to sustaining
provide for the growth and continuance the Department (BA 1952, MA 1954)
of teaching and research in and on the an over one hundred year engagement
and her husband, Raj Desai, did his
Sanskrit language and literature for the with South Asia Studies. ISAS is grate-
MS in the Civil and Environmental
benefit of future generations of students. Engineering Department. v ful to both the Department of Education
and Congress for sustaining the NRC
program.
(cont'd from page 1) and (mis)translation. Stephanie Schrader, Curator, Depart- The FLAS enables students—both
Also in Art Practice, Asma Kazmi’s ment of Drawings, J. Paul Getty Museum, graduate students and exceptional under-
work deeply engages critical and perfor- Los Angeles on her recent exhibition, graduates, in both primary research and
mance theories, especially as they pertain Rembrandt and the Inspiration of India. professional fields—to study language
to Islam and South Asia and she creates Immediately after its launch, the intensively and to link language study to
transdisciplinary, performative, relational SAAI hosted a number of events. These focused regional study relevant to that
works where people, media, and objects included talks by the artist Shuddhabrata language. It is a critical support to train-
come together. Berkeley is the only in- Sengupta and the art historian Tapati
stitution in North America with faculty ing students rigorously and to supporting
Guha-Thakurta. With the aim of creating them with scholarships. FLAS, along with
expertise that spans from the premodern a network of specialists in the Bay Area,
to the modern and the contemporary. the dedicated support of the Bay Area
the SAAI also organized a conference
community, has enabled this campus to be
With the four faculty at the helm, titled Bay Area Conversations: The Arts of
the SAAI has already begun to act as an a national center for many South Asian
South Asia and its Diasporas with artists,
incubator for art related collaborations. languages, including Bangla, Hindi, Pun-
curators, and art historians from a number
Under the aegis of the Art Initiative, a jabi, Sanskrit, Tamil, Telugu, and Urdu.
of Bay Area institutions such as the Cali-
number of events have been organized The importance of these grants cannot
fornia College of Arts, University of Cal-
in the last one year, after the SAAI was ifornia-Davis, Stanford University, Uni- be underestimated. At Berkeley, it has en-
formally launched on April 27, 2018. versity of California-Merced, Asian Art abled the Institute to focus attention on
The multi-day inaugural events of the Museum, Mills College, University of San both research and teaching in emerging
SAAI included talks by Nadia and Francisco, and the California Institute areas of scholarship across the sciences
Rajeeb Samdani, the founders of the of Integral Studies. Co-sponsored events and engineering, the social sciences, and
Dhaka-based Samdani Art Foundation included the screening of Matti Braun’s the humanities. It has enabled ISAS to
and the initiators of the Dhaka Art Sum- film on Vikram Sarabhai and a talk by build links to community colleges and pri-
mit. The Samdanis discussed their vision Los Angeles-based artist Sandow Birk. mary and secondary schools. It has helped
for the Dhaka Art Summit with Chitra Over the next years, the SAAI aims support the ISAS staff whose knowledge
Ganesh, a visual artist based in New to strengthen and generate new col- and abilities have connected faculty and
York. This was followed by a talk by Dr. laborations with partners on campus, in students with communities across the Bay
the Bay Area, Area and beyond. Finally, these grants
Ne
Former Program Assistants contd. in the United
States, and in
have allowed ISAS to continue its cutting
edge work and programs on South Asia.
Manali Sheth Sridevi Prasad South Asia by
(2013-2015) (2015-2017) bringing inter- beyond – this is the SAAI’s aspirational
national cultures horizon. Looking towards the future, the
Manali left to do Devi is work-
into even closer SAAI seeks to inspire and facilitate in-
an MA in Urban ing towards an
MPH, concen- dialogue. By way novative artistic, scholarly, and curatorial
Design & Plan-
trating in mon- of investing in practices through initiating annual resi-
ning at the Uni-
versity of Washington where, itoring and evaluation and future scholars dencies for artists, scholars, and curators;
affiliated with the Urban Freight epidemiology/biostatistics, at and curators, instituting conferences and symposia on
Lab, she specialized in freight Boston University's School of the SAAI hopes campus and in South Asia in collabora-
transportation planning. She is Public Health. Recently, she to synergize the tion with our partners in the region; and
currently working for Arup and conducted a water quality next genera- generate support for students invested in
is involved in optimizing the study in Ghana, Kenya, and tion of scholars, the art of South Asia and its diasporas.
movement of goods and people Mali and is currently work- artists, and en- More about the initiative at southasia.
through innovative delivery ser- ing on studying hypertension gaged citizens berkeley.edu/visual-culture-south-asia v
vicing strategies and logistics. and obesity in South Africa. on campus and
4
UC Berkeley 'Tell Her Story' designed to showcase remarkable women About the Contest
contest honors South
in and from South Asia who fight against
social injustice. TELL HER STORY
Asian women Deepa Pawar grew up in a tribal com- Memorable Stories about Remarkable
munity in Maharashtra and became the Women in South Asia
The 2017 Indo-American Community wide and include citizenship, war and We are happy to
Lecture in India Studies counterinsurgency in South Asia, indig- announce that in
NANDINI SUNDAR enous identity and politics in South Asia,
the sociology of law and inequality. She Spring 2019, renowned
—HOSTAGES TO DEMOCRACY: was awarded the Infosys Prize for Social historian of South Asia
INDIA AT 70 Sciences - Social Anthropology (2010), TANIKA SARKAR
and the Ester Boserup Prize for Develop-
D r. Nandini Sundar, noted social ment Research (2016).
will be in residence at
anthropologist and advocate for the Institute as the next
the rights of the Adivasis, was in resi- Videorecording of lecture at southasia.
berkeley.edu/nandini-sundar v Indo-American Community
dence at the Institute in November 2017 Lecturer in India Studies
as our Indo-American Community Lec-
turer in India
Studies. Dr. The 2017 Sarah Kailath Memorial Lecture SAVE THE DATE:
Sundar's lec- on "Women & Leadership" the sarah kailath
ture, "Hostages MALLIKA SARABHAI memorial lecture by
to Democracy:
—DANCE TO CHANGE THE author & new york
India at 70,"
times journalist
explored the WORLD
aporias of de- SOMINI SENGUPTA
O
mocracy, or at n September 15, 2017, the Insti-
(From left) Drs. Nandini Sundar, Raka least certain The 7th Sarah Kailath
Ray & Lawrence Cohen constructions
tute welcomed Dr. Mallika Sarab- Memorial lecture will be
hai, one of India’s leading choreographers given by George Polk Award-
of “need,” to show how both procedural and dancers credited with transforming
and substantive democracy operate to winning journalist and The New York
contemporary Indian dance and theater,
render the lives of sections of the citi- as the 6th Sarah Kailath Memorial Lec- Times's International Climate Change
zenry precarious. Focusing on the ongoing turer to campus. Correspondent, Somini Sengupta on
civil war in central India between Maoist In her lecture titled, Dance to Change January 31, 2019
guerillas and the Indian state, she argued the World, Dr. Sarabhai spoke at length
how Indian democracy as practiced today about her career, her own upbringing,
served as an active tool of counterinsur- her dance school, Darpana, her famous the medium of dance and theater.
gency and a means of evading account- productions such as ‘Sakthi’ and ‘Sita’s Dr. Sarabhai was in the Bay Area,
ability. Daughters’ and also about how the arts along with her dance ensemble, in con-
Dr. Sundar is Professor of Sociology may be the nection with a
at the Delhi School of Economics, Delhi most pow- performance of
University. Her research interests are erful tool her new produc-
for raising tion, “Finding My
the Indo-American Community awareness, Voice,” in which
highlight- she and her team
Lectureship in India Studies ing crucial use the idiom of
was endowed in 1990-91 with the support issues, and the Bharatanatyam
of the then CG of India in San Francisco, advocating dance form to high-
the Hon. Satinder K. Lambah and hundreds for social light issues such
change. An as intolerance and
of members of the Indo-American commu-
artiste with (From left) Drs. Munis D. Faruqui, Anu Luther, Raka Ray, global warming.
nity. This lectureship enables the Institute
social com- Mallika Sarabhai, & Tom Kailath. Photo credit: Drew Detsch The lecture ended
to bring prominent individuals from India mitment, with a short but en-
to Berkeley to deliver a lecture and interact all her productions have been vehement thralling performance that gave the audi-
with campus and community members reactions to the wide spectrum of evils re- ence a preview of this new production.
over a two-week stay. The recent most lated to religion, gender, and the environ- Videorecordings of this and past lectures
invitees have been Dr. Pratap Bhanu Mehta ment and she has sought to effect politi- may be viewed at southasia.berkeley.edu/
(2016) and Dr. Nivedita Menon (2015). cal, social and personal change through sarah-kailath-chair-memorial-lecture v
5
Retrospective by 2018 Tata Social Intern breaks and “antakshari” games made
BERKELEY IN SOUTH ASIA me feel like family. “Satya, tere nautanki
—the social impact of UCB scholarship
DOSTI (Friendship) yaad dilata hai ke thodi masti ke bina life
ka maaza kuch nahi hai.” Dikshita, Yash
Innovating for Social Change By Prachi Patel, Class of 2021 and Samir for showing me the ropes and
UC BERKELEY STUDENT
ANJALI BANERJEE AND
T he first thing that people told me
when I decided to take this internship
in Mumbai was that people in India
tolerating whatever terrible sounds and
noises coming out of my mouth that
I claimed was Hindi. “Aur haan mujhe
are not to be trusted. That I had to be pata hai ke mera accent kafi cute hai.”
FRIENDS TURN GRIEF careful because almost everyone would Debason, Nikita, Rishi, Sandeep, Viraj
INTO TECH STARTUP be out to scam, cheat or steal from me. and Vishal for taking this “videsi intern”
Although I was born in India and have under your wings and for finally feeding
AFTER FRANCE ATTACK been here before, this was my first time her that “gola.” “Tumare jaise dost ke
—Anjali Banerjee, an Indian undergradu- here alone. And even though I look saath, dushman ki kya zaroorat hai?” To
ate at UC Berkeley, and her fellow class- Indian, people can tell from my garbled all the village women who welcomed this
mates started Archer after surviving the Hindi and constantly confused face strange girl into their homes and showed
2016 Nice terror attack in France. Banerjee that I am not from around here almost her what real strength and empowerment
and her classmates want Archer to offer instantly. Everything from scared aunties look like. Thank you for teaching me that
digital tools to help journalists, investiga- to travel guides money is of
tors and human rights workers tackle ter- painted Mumbai little importance
rorism, sanctions evasion, corruption and in a wicked and “siraf dil bada
other global violence greedy light hona chaiyye.”
and I came into PS: Mom and
U C Berkeley Indian college student
Anjali Banerjee was watching
fireworks during a July 2016 celebration
this experience
fully prepared
Dad if you are
reading this,
with a hard this does not
on a seafront promenade in the French shell over my mean that
city of Nice when a man plowed a truck easily trusting your naive and
through the crowd, killing 86 people and personality. But innocent little
wounding 200. The Islamic State group my experience girl is letting her
claimed responsibility for the attack. here has taught The 2017 Tata Interns from UC Berkeley. From L: Ariel guard down. You
The UC incoming senior ran through me exactly the Gans, Lorraine Pereira, Sabrina Lu, Dharna Dhamija raised her with
mobs of people to escape the chaos and opposite, so (General manager, Communications & Business a smart head on
later joined this is a tribute Development, Tata Sons-North America) Prachi Patel, her shoulders
classmates Sailakshmi Senthil, Caroline Brown. and this 9-week
to all the friends
to search who have experience has
hospitals convinced me otherwise. Karan, you made her even wiser. More than just
and plaster made a 10 hour flight “fly by” and gave personally, this internship has given me
the city this newcomer the Mumbai 101 course the professional opportunity to delve into
with flyers straight from a local. To the nice family the CSR field where I am able to apply
of fellow outside the airport who waited until analytical thinking and problem solving
students the driver came because they noticed skills everyday. I have learned that not
reported how close I was to tipping over from everything can be a clean Microsoft Word
miss- my luggage that weighed more than me. written report and that sometimes you
From left, Alice Ma,Tyler Heintz & Anjali ing. She For all the coworkers who with their have to get your hands dirty and dig and
Banerjee.(AP Photo/Marcio Jose Sanchez) later that light hearted humor, Cadbury chocolate search to find the real solutions.
learned
three students were injured, and UC
Berkeley junior Nicolas Leslie, 20, was cess. Amnesty International is using one those looking into war crimes, sanction
among the dead. of its tools, Archer Meta, to verify photo- violations or environmental crimes,” said
Banerjee and several classmates have graphs of the crackdown by security forc- Alice Ma, a former U.C. Berkeley student
since turned their grief into a startup es against minority Rohingya Muslims in who founded the startup with Banerjee
called Archer that builds digital tools to Myanmar’s Rakhine state. and classmate Tyler Heintz.
help journalists, investigators and human The tool identifies when and where Heintz was also in Nice at the time of
rights workers tackle terrorism, sanction the photographs were taken and can the attack. They have since been joined
evasion, corruption and other global vio- process 50 at once, unlike other readily by nearly two dozen other students,
lence. available internet tools that upload one including several others who were with
“In that moment, it was hard finding photo at a time and can pose a security them in France, as part of a month-long
the correct information. It was hard even risk, said Sam Dubberley, a researcher class and competition hosted by the
going to different police stations. It was with Amnesty International. European Innovation Academy, which
chaos,” Banerjee, Archer’s chief market- “We get photographs in bulk from ac- focuses on tech entrepreneurship educa-
ing officer and chief operating officer, tivists’ groups in Myanmar, and we have tion.
who is from London, said. to verify they are true. But uploading one Banerjee, a history major, had consid-
The lack of official information follow- at a time can be mind-numbing, tedious ered a career in foreign affairs but after
ing the terrorist attack led the students work,” he said. what happened in France, she wanted
to self-organize and rely on locals to Archer Meta also offers an added to take immediate action. Weeks before
navigate the city as they looked for their layer of security by al- the attack, her friend Ta-
missing friends. lowing users to analyze a rishi Jain, a U.C. Berkeley
Collaborating with each other and photo’s metadata with- sophomore, was among
with the people of Nice made the stu- out relying on an internet 20 hostages killed at a
dents realize they could create a space connection, Dubberley restaurant by militants in
in the digital world to help others do the said. Dhaka, Bangladesh.
same in the fight against terrorism, Ba- “These tools are need- “A lot of people all
nerjee said. ed in human rights work, over the world exist in
The students built a free online plat- but they are prohibitively this kind of situation, and
form that makes big data analysis and vi- expensive to develop, and we thought it was time
sualization easy to access and that helps there is no money in it for somebody suggested an-
track people and companies that have tech companies to build In Nice, just before the attack, Anjali other way we could com-
been sanctioned by the United States for them,” he said. learned that her UC Berkeley friend bat it,” Banerjee said.
crimes that include money laundering, The group’s data anal- Tarishi Jain, had died in a terrorist
ysis tool helps those in- attack in Bangladesh. AP. "UC Berkeley
corruption and terrorism.
They’re still working to turn their data vestigating terrorist financing cases, “but Indian Student Anjali Ba-
analysis tool into a for-profit company, there is a broader community of people nerjee..." India West, Aug 16, 2018. www.
but the startup has achieved some suc- who can rely on our tools, including indiawest.com v
6
Faculty Opinion the Congress deserved credit for both
the nationalisation of banks in 1969
AT BERKELEY, RAHUL and the liberalisation of the economy in
GANDHI DID NOT TAKE 1991. I can only liken this to demanding
gratitude for both the virtuous suffering
THE ONLY QUESTION of demonetisation and the kindly gift of
WORTH ASKING: ‘WHEN remonetisation – a pitch of shamelessness
not yet achieved even by the spin doc-
WILL YOU STEP DOWN?’ tors of the current Bharatiya Janata Party
—A cavalier disregard for his subjects’ regime.
faculty of thought marked the tenor of the BUNDLE OF CONTRADICTIONS
Congress vice-president’s speech.
Although Gandhi laudably empha-
By Dr. Abhishek Kaicker sised the necessity of job-creation, he
G iven the discus- offered no clue as to how his party might Rahul Gandhi
sion occasioned achieve it. In one breath we were told
by Rahul Gandhi’s speech about the importance of small and me- September 11, 2017
dium enterprises, which in his vision
at the University of
California, Berkeley on would be seamlessly linked to the global INDIA AT 70:
Tuesday, September 11, economy, and in the next we were in- REFLECTIONS ON THE
2017 – a rare instance of formed that India would “be the best” at
a member of the Gandhi doing heart surgeries because of patient PATH FORWARD
family deigning to address volumes. More ominously, Gandhi told us Videorecording of lecture at
their subjects directly that an even more important asset than southasia.berkeley.edu/rahul-gandhi
Dr. Abhishek Kaicker such skills in the global marketplace of
– it may be apposite to
offer an account of the proceedings as healthcare would be India’s genetic diver- ing with just the speed and efficiency for
witnessed by a bystander. The people sity. Unless he envisages the government which the party has come to be recog-
in attendance were given a chance to claiming copyright on the DNA of every nised – even as he declared his readiness
ask questions via comment cards. Since citizen – or perhaps we are to each peddle for the top job. Such glibness would be
mine, for understandable reasons, was not our DNA in online marketplaces – it is less infuriating if the country were not
selected, I am grateful for this opportunity difficult to imagine how our genes would on fire. It is troubling that, even as he
to ask it again. lift us out of poverty. Having mocked earnestly advocated decentralisation of
Gandhi began by declaring his affili- the “western academics” who warned of power in governance, he brazenly joked
ation, and of his party, with the idea of India’s failure in the years after indepen- that dynasty was a way of life in India. No
ahimsa, or non-violence, as explicated dence, Gandhi then made precisely the amount of comfort with contradiction,
by Mohandas Gandhi. Somewhat mys- same threat of the country’s collapse, if sadly characteristic of the Congress, can
tifyingly, he described as the “basis” of his party were not restored to its rightful resolve the brutal opposition between
non-violence the Indian principle of place at India’s helm. the practice of democracy and the rule
“ideas having people” rather than the So much for what was said. Now re- of one family. “We want no Caesars,”
reverse, which he finds prevalent in the flect on what Gandhi
West. Thus, we were told, the only means could not bring himself
to overcome a person “infected” with a to say. Missing from his
bad idea was love and compassion, not discourse was the ques-
violence. Only a little later, however, we tion of India’s rapidly-
learned that the supposed success of his degrading environment,
party’s efforts in Kashmir – in which he which is making life
was secretly involved for nine years – was increasingly unliveable
based on “denying space” to anti-India for all but the elites.
ideas. Should the philosophy of ahimsa How will the compet-
be judged by euphemisms of love and ing claims for economic
compassion given what the Congress has growth and environ-
done to people who have questioned, mental protection and
during its rule, the party’s idea of India? restoration be adjudi-
The claim to ahimsa was just one in- cated in the context of a
stance of Gandhi’s frighteningly cynical warming planet? On the
disdain for the truths of which most Indi- alienation of Kashmiris
ans are aware. In a similar vein, we heard and other peoples from
the Partition impersonally described as the Indian republic – a Rahul Gandhi in conversation with Dr. Pradeep Chhibber
“the bloodiest migration in human his- failure of the idea of
tory” rather than a catastrophe in which India for which the Congress must bear Nehru wrote, anonymously, against him-
the Congress leadership was deeply impli- the blame – Gandhi sanguinely reduced self in 1937. How shall we communicate
cated, against the wishes of the Mahatma. political grievances to economic issues. to his descendants how much less India
For his party and his ancestors, Gandhi Reminded of his party’s shameful re- needs Caligulas or Neros? That no one
claimed the successes of increasing food cord of protecting the perpetrators of the should be indispensable at a moment of
production, literacy and education, and 1984 ant-Sikh riots, Gandhi assured us national crisis is a fundamental truth that
computerisation. He did not, however, that no one loves the Sikh community the Congress, in its current state, is no
acknowledge the failures of the poli- more than him. But the small crowd longer capable of grasping. But, as the
cies his party imposed on the country, of of elderly Sikh men tearfully shouting common lament that nightly floats to the
which Indians are, again, all too aware. themselves hoarse in the drizzle outside country’s skies has it, surely in this land
The blame for the distortion in agricul- the auditorium where Gandhi was speak- of 1.3 billion souls, there are thousands
tural production, manifest in the suicide ing, each of whom must bear the scars of thoughtful and wise persons waiting to
by hundreds of thousands of farmers, and of the day a big tree fell, surely did not revitalise the party of Mahatma Gandhi
the continuing failure of educational and want his love. For them, perhaps, and for and Nehru.
healthcare systems cannot be laid entirely people in Kashmir and the North East For all that, then, only one question
at the Congress’s door. But no acknowl- on whom the Congress regime inflicted remains worth asking of Gandhi, a ques-
edgement was made of any mistakes or the violence Gandhi smugly decried, a tion from which he should no longer be
errors other than a sense of “arrogance” start might be made with an institutional shielded: when, for the love of country
that had crept into the party before the admission of guilt, a public act of soul- and party, will you step down? v
last election in 2014. searching, and the identification of per-
petrators.
Dr. Abhishek Kaicker teaches Indian
Indeed, a cavalier disregard for his history UC Berkeley. This article was
subjects’ faculty of thought marked the Gandhi alluded in passing to the
process of institutional reform in the originally printed in Scroll.in. Reprinted
tenor of Gandhi’s discourse. Thus, we
Congress – which appears to be proceed- here with permission from the author.
were astonished to learn from him that
7
Select ISAS Events Harjant S. Gill, Assistant Professor of
Anthropology, Towson University
Apr 12, 2018
Documenting the
Jul 19, 2018
Rohingya
2017 - 2018 Nov 16, 2017
Undocumented:
Bengali Muslim
Exodus:
Khoon Diy Baarav (Blood Leaves its Trail) Migrants In and Beyond the
Iffat Fatima, Documentary Filmmaker Beyond 20th Century Man-made
U.S. Archives Human
Feb 1, 2018 Vivek Bald, Tragedy
India's Changing Nationalism: Does It Matter? Associate Professor
Maya Tudor, Associate Professor of of Writing and Dipu Moni, Ban-
Government and Public Policy, Oxford Digital Media, MIT gladeshi politician
University and former Foreign
Apr 17, 2018 Minister of Bangla-
Feb 5, 2018 When Crime Pays: desh.
No One Gives Feb 2, 2018 Money and Muscle
like the Guru On Turning in Indian Politics Video: chowdhury-
John E. Cort, Mythologi- Milan Vaishnav,
Professor of
center.berkeley.edu/
cal Tales into Senior Fellow,
Omar Abdullah (on left) with Aakash Bhalo- Asian and South Asia
rohingya-exodus
Bestselling
thia, Cal senior majoring in Economics. Comparative Program, Carnegie
Religions. Works of
Apr 19, 2017 Endowment for
Denison Fiction
International Peace
The Path Forward in Kashmir University
Amish Tripathi,
Apr 19, 2018
Indian politician and Former Chief Minis- Feb 12, 2018 author of the
Mad Man of Bombay: A Tale of Magic Found
ter of Jammu & Kashmir, Omar Abdullah Satisfied spellbinding and Lost
talked about possible solutions for the Callers: Police Shiva Trilogy, and William Mazzarella, Professor of
crisis in the region, which has historically and Corporate Prof. Harsha Ram Anthropology, University of Chicago
been the site of contention and violence Customer discuss making
among Indian and Pakistani leaders. Service in India Indian mythology Apr 24, 2018
Matthew Hull, cool among the From Malthusia to the Aid Lab: A short history
Video: southasia.berkeley.edu/ Associate youth again. of Bangladesh’s surprising success
omar-abdullah Professor of Naomi Hossain, Research Fellow, Institute of
Anthropology, Video: southasia. Development Studies, University of Sussex
University of
berkeley.edu/amish-
Michigan Apr 25, 2018
Sept 18, 2017 tripathi Volga to Ganga, Buddha to Marx: The Many
The Creative Arts in Bangladesh Mar 1, 2018 Voyages of Mahapandit Rahul Sankrityayan
Anisul Hoque, Writer, poet, playwright, and Political Parties Maya Joshi, Associate Professor of English,
columnist in Sri Lanka: University of Delhi
Change and Continuity
Sept 21, 2017 Amita Shastri, Professor of Political Science, Apr 30, 2018
When God is a Traveller: Poetry Reading and San Francisco State University Rembrandt and the Mughals
Discussion Stephanie Schrader, Curator, J. Paul Getty
Arundhathi Mar 8, 2018 Museum
Subramaniam, Poet The “Protestant” Impulse in Modern Islamic
Oct 2, 2017 Thought May 3, 2018
Sept 28, 2017 Teena Purohit, Associate Professor of Rama and Sita in a Saiva Literary Key?:
The Colonel Aurangzeb: A
Who Would Religion at Boston University Rethinking the Literary and Religious
Gujarati Badshah? Orientation of Kampan’s Iramavataram
Not Repent: Samira Sheikh, Mar 16, 2018 Anne E. Monius, Professor of South Asian
The Bangla- Associate Waste of a Nation: Garbage and Growth in Religions, Harvard Divinity School
desh War and Professor of India
its Unquiet History, Vanderbilt Assa Doron, Associate Professor of
Legacy University Anthropology & South Asia, ANU College of
Asia and the Pacific
Salil Tripathi, Oct 11, 2017
Writer & Journal- Who is Your March 20, 2018
ist, paints a sear- Neighbor? Caste, Restructuring Life: Agencies and Infrastructures
ing, kaleidoscopic Dignity, and in Nepal’s Post-
portrait of Ban- Dalit Lives in Conflict, Post-
Central Kerala Feb 8, 2018 Disaster State of
gladesh from the Sharika Film & Transformation
1947 Partition to Thiranagama, Sara Shneiderman,
the present Assistant
Theatre,
Associate
Professor of National &
Professor of
Video: chowdhury- Anthropology, International: Anthropology,
center.berkeley.edu/ Stanford An Actor's University of
bangladesh-war University Perspective British Columbia
Oct 17, 2017 Acclaimed Indian Mar 22, 2018 Dr. Bob Thurman (on left) with Swami Prasan-
Welfare Needs Aadhaar Like a Fish Needs actress & theatre Travels through natmananda, Director of Vedanta Society
a Bicycle? personality Lillette Four Languages: Berkeley, and Dr. Jacob Dalton, Professor of
Reetika Khera, Associate Professor of Dubey discusses Shibli's Great Tibetan Studies at UC Berkeley.
Economics, IIT, Delhi. her work and craft Journey
Oct 18, 2017
with Prof. Harsha Gregory Maxwell
Oct 24, 2017 Bruce, Lecturer in Why does the Dalai Lama say he is
Why Marry?: Comparative Perspectives on
Ram "Son of Nalanda"?
Urdu, UC Berkeley
Kinship, the House, and Marriage in the Video: southasia.
Eastern Himalayas Apr 2, 2018 Famed Tibetologist, Dr. Robert Thurman
Stephane Gros, Researcher, Centre for berkeley.edu/ delivers the inaugural UC Berkeley-Ve-
Are Lingayats
Himalayan Studies, Centre National de la lillette-dubey Hindus? danta Society Lecture on Religion in the
Recherche Scientifique Prithvi Datta Modern World
Chandra Shobhi,
Nov 7, 2017 Professor of History, Karnataka State Open Video: southasia.berkeley.edu/
Life is Queerer Than a Chessboard: On Cows, University robert-thurman
Violence, and Love in Contemporary India
Naisargi N. Dave, Associate Professor of Apr 5, 2018 ISAS-VSB LECTURES ON RELIGION
Anthropology at the University of Toronto Testing the Limits of Comparatism: The Quarrel IN THE MODERN WORLD, INVITES
of the Ancients and Moderns in Persian and DISTINGUISHED SCHOLARS OF WORLD
Nov 9, 2017 Urdu Literary Culture RELIGIONS TO CAMPUS WITH THE AIM
On North Indian/Punjabi Masculinities: A Arthur Dudney, Leverhulme Early Career OF IMPROVING AND DIVERSIFYING
Screening followed by Discussion with the Fellow, Cambridge University CONVERSATIONS ABOUT THE ROLE OF
Filmmaker RELIGION IN MODERN SOCIETIES
8
P A K I S T A N @ ber k e l e y THE SYED SHARIFUDDIN PIRZADA
DISSERTATION PRIZE ON PAKISTAN
—Pakistan@Berkeley is the only area studies initiative or program, at a major
T
university in the US, that is focused entirely on Pakistan related research, teaching and he Pirzada Dissertation Prize
programming. The goal for this initiative is to broaden and deepen understanding Committee congratulates Dr.
of Pakistan through on-campus talks and conferences, promote scholarly exchanges William E. B. Sherman (Asst. Prof Re-
between UC Berkeley and educational institutions in Pakistan, raise funds for graduate ligion, UNC-Charlotte) on receiving
fellowships and to train the next generation of scholars of Pakistan, and provide funding
the S.S. Pirzada Dissertation Prize in
for Pakistan-specific courses at UC Berkeley. The three main highlights of Pakistan@
Pakistan Studies for 2017. Dr. Sherman’s
Berkeley in 2017-18 were the Mahomedali Habib Distinguished Lecture on Pakistan,
the Urdu language programs for Pakistani instructors and American students, and dissertation—Mountains and Messiahs:
the Social Entrepreneurship and Re-entry Seminar for Pakistani Fulbright Fellows. The Roshaniyya, Revelation, and Afghan
Becoming—was completed at Stanford
The 2017 Mahomedali Habib Lecture on on October 19th and welcomed the famed University under the supervision of Dr.
Pakistan historian of South Asia, David Gilmartin, Shahzad Bashir. The award ceremony
Professor of History at North Carolina was held on April 26, 2018, at UC-
CONTESTED GRAND Berkeley.
State University. His research interests
NARRATIVES OF HISTORY focus on the intersections between the
history of British imperialism in South
By Habib University's Office of Global En-
Asia and the development of modern
gagement politics and forms of rule. His most recent
T he Chowdhury Center in partner- week at the Center, where they take part completed its third anniversary. To mark
ship with the American Institute in workshops on research methodologies, the occasion, the Center published a
for Bangladesh Studies, the Council of writing, and the publishing process led by report detailing the achievements of the
UC Berkeley faculty. The workshop cul- past three years. Read an e-version at:
minates in a symposium where the faculty
present their papers in progress. CHOWDHURYCENTER.BERKELEY.
The Center has previously held two EDU/ANNUAL-REPORT
such workshops: the first in 2016 invited
six scholars and the second in April 2018
invited nine scholars. Reflecting back on ANNOUNCING A NEW
their experience, individual participants WORKING GROUP ON
noted: “It really motivated me to write and
publish. So glad for this introduction”; “ THE ROHINGYA CRISIS
the sessions are informative and very help- The Chowdhury Center has launched the
Dr. Isha Ray (6th from left) with the 2018 cohort ful for young researchers. The symposium Rohingya Crisis Working Group, a group
American Overseas Research Centers, and on the last day was excellent”; and, “I am in which researchers and practitioners will
the US Embassy in Dhaka, runs a program glad to highly recommend this workshop work to develop ideas and collaborations
focused on academic writing and publish- to my colleagues. I think this is a very use- related to the amelioration of one of the
ing for faculty members from top universi- ful workshop for academics”. worst humanitarian crises of our time.
ties in Bangladesh. Titled, the "Faculty More at chowdhurycenter.berkeley.edu/
More at chowdhurycenter.berkeley.edu/rohingya
collaborations
Student Funding Opportunities New Academic Collaboration Panelists discussed the rights of minori-
FLAS E
More information at
BHATTACHARYA
the
ach year the
Institute southasia . berkeley . edu /
GRADUATE fellowship fellowships U.S. Dept.
provides FLAS-FELLOWSHIPS
Deadline: J anuary 30, 2019
E stablished by Kimi and Shankar
Bhattacharya, the fellowship awards
competitive grants of up to $1000 for
—funding for of Education
funded Foreign The 2018 Award Recipients
research travel to India and up to $500 South Asian Language & ACADEMIC YEAR AWARD
for domestic conference travel on top-
ics related to contemporary India.
languages Area Studies
(FLAS) awards BANGLA: Devin Choudhury (UC
to support students studying Bengali, Berkeley), Patrick DeSutter (UC Berkeley)
The 2018 Award Recipients:
Hindi, Punjabi, Sanskrit, Tamil, Telugu, HINDI: Julia Nee (UC Berkeley)
CONFERENCE TRAVEL and Urdu. FLAS fellowships cover SANSKRIT: Maxwell Brandstadt (UC
Anirvan Chowdhury (Political Sci- tuition and a stipend and are awarded Berkeley), Gideon Enz (UC Berkeley),
ence): The General Equilibrium either for the academic year or for a Petra Lamberson (UC Berkeley)
Effects of Political Campaigns summer language study program. TAMIL: Rabindra Willford (UC Berkeley)
Tanu Kumar (Political Sci-
ence): Impact of homeownership SUMMER AWARD
on political and economic behav- measures of empowerment among ado- BANGLA: Devin Choudhury (UC Berkeley)
ior of low-income households. lescent girls in Uttar Pradesh, India
HINDI: Lauren Nippoldt (UC San Diego),
Meghna Mukherjee (Sociol-
RESEARCH TRAVEL Nicole Price (University of Kansas)
ogy): The Dual Role of the Physician-
Drew Cameron (Health Policy): A clus- Salesman in Idealizing Egg Donors MALAYALAM: Lisa Brooks (UC Berkeley)
ter randomized controlled trial to promote SANSKRIT: Gideon Enz (UC Berkeley)
the uptake and continued use of potable For details please visit
water delivery in rural Bihar, India southasia . berkeley . edu / TAMIL: Keith Cantu (UC Santa Barbara)
Gauthami Penakalapati (Energy & MAHARAJ-KAUL-GRANTS
Resources Group): Social networks and Deadline: A pril 15, 2019 BERREMAN-
the
YAMANAKA GRANT
Berkeley-AIPS Urdu Language Program in for HIMALAYAN STUDIES
Pakistan
A Pakistan-based program that provides
intensive Urdu language training
Dallon Asnes: B.A. Physics, Pomona E stablished in memory of famed
UC Berkeley Anthropologist,
Dr. Gerald Berreman, by his wife,
Maryam Ahmed: B.A. Political Science,
to students for fifteen-weeks. This University of Michigan Dr. Keiko Yamanaka, and family,
program is based at Lahore University this endowment provides an annual
of Management Sciences (LUMS) in Enas Jahangir: B.A. Religion, Smith award of up to $1500 to UC Berkeley
Pakistan. The program covers all costs College graduate students for research on topics
for US citizens and permanent residents. Jackson Walker: B.A. Political Science, related to Himalayan Studies across
These include: airfare, visa, LUMS Asian Languages and Cultures, Bhutan, India, Nepal and Pakistan.
admission, tuition, and hostel fees, as Northwestern University The 2018 Award Recipients:
well as all excursions and activities that
Shabnam Ahmed: B.S. Global Public RESEARCH TRAVEL
fall within the program. In addition,
Health and Development, University of Michael Coleman (Ph.D Student,
the program also provides a monthly
Maryland Medical Anthropology): For research
maintenance allowance.
Zainab Syeda: B.A. International in tantric Buddhist / Tibetan medi-
The 2018 BULPIP Cohort cal traditions focusing on tukdam.
Studies, Cal State University, Long Beach
Julia Chatterjee: M.A. Candidate Caylee Hong (Ph.D Student, An-
in Asian Languages and Literature, Kevin Shi: B.S. Political Science and
thropology): Infrastructures of Be-
University of Washington Public Policy, University of Chicago
longing: Gilgit-Baltistan and the
More information at southasia . berkeley . edu /BULPIP China-Pakistan Economic Corridor.
Application Deadline: M arch 1, 2019 For details please visit
southasia . berkeley . edu /
HIMALAYAN_STUDIES_UCB
the TATA summer The 2018 Tata Interns
Deadline: A pril 15, 2019
internship program in india Caroline Brown: Showcasing and market-
ing heritage crafts of India, Titan, Benga-
A
women in India and n empirically rich study of one of processes of making Hindi modern at
the most extensive electoral quota a formative moment in India's history,
elsewhere. The Nils
Dr. Francesca R. Jensenius systems in the world: the reserved seats when British imperialism was at its peak,
Klim Prize, worth and anti-colonial sentiments were on the
NOK 500,000 (appr. USD 63,000), for the Scheduled Castes (SCs, the for-
mer "untouchables") in India's legislative rise. It centers the figure of Mahavir Prasad
is awarded annually to a Nordic Dwivedi (1864-1938), an enterprising and
assemblies. Combining evidence from
researcher under the age of 35, for contentious Hindi litterateur, and his proj-
quantitative datasets from the period
outstanding contributions within the 1969-2012, archival work, and in-depth ect of construct-
arts and humanities, social sciences, interviews with politicians, civil servants, ing Hindi as a
law or theology, either within one of and voters across India, this book ex- national language
the relevant fields alone or through plores the long-term effects of electoral with a modern
work of an interdisciplinary nature quotas for the political elite and the literature in the
general population. It shows that the early twentieth
Innovating for Social Change quota system has played an important century. Dwivedi's
role in reducing caste-based discrimina- unprecedented
CAL UNDERGRADS DO tion, particularly multi-media lit-
WHAT TWITTER WON'T — at the elite level. erary campaign
Interestingly, this as long-time
LAUNCH A TOOL TO SPOT editor of the
is because it has
TWITTER BOTS made possible Hindi journal
Sarasvati paved
U C Berkeley undergraduate com-
puter science students Ash Bhat
and Rohan Phadte are doing
the creation and
empowerment of a
new SC elite who
the way for
Hindi's progress into the modern era.
what they say Twitter won’t: have gradually This study casts new light on Dwivedi as
sorting out and tagging the an- become integrated an innovative and dynamic arbiter of lit-
gry propaganda bots designed into mainstream erary modernity. He advanced his agenda
to undermine, destabilize and by exploring the collaborative potential
politics. This is a
inflame American political of art and literature, a critical element
discourse. In Oct 2017, they study of India, but
the findings and in national language and literary reform
Ash Bhat launched a Google Chrome
discussions have that has received little attention in other
browser extension that puts
broader implica- studies. This book also considers tensions
a button onto every Twitter profile and
tweet. With a click on the Botcheck. tions. Policies such as quotas are usually between the editor and others in his realm
me button, users can see if supported with arguments about various of influence. His project sparked contest
the account is run by a person assumed positive long-term consequenc- amongst a range of authorities who partici-
or automated program, based es. The nuanced discussions in this book pated alongside Dwivedi in constructing
on the pair’s own machine- shed light on how electoral quotas for Hindi modernity. Despite a common en-
learning model. Bhat told a SCs have shaped the incentives for politi- thusiasm for Hindi, they challenged some
reporter for Wired magazine, aspects of his agenda, based on their differ-
cians, parties, and voters, and indicate
which profiled the pair, that ing agendas and perspectives.
Rohan Phadte “by making data available for the trade-offs inherent in how such poli-
other fellow Americans” their cies of group inclusion are designed.. About the Author:
project is “pushing back” against Rus-
About the Author: Sujata S. Mody (Ph.D. South & Southeast
sian interference in the election.
Francesca R. Jensenius (Ph.D. Political Sci- Asian Studies, 2008) is Associate Professor
Read the complete story on Wired's of Hindi-Urdu Language and Literature at
website at www.wired.com/story/the- ence, 2013) is Associate Professor of Politi-
cal Science at the University of Oslo. North Carolina State University.
college-kids-doing-what-twitter-wont/
17
new publications contd.
Ideology & Identity: The rights from
majori-
Changing Party Systems of ties. Using
and learning. DeSouza's work will be in- India survey
valuable to the casual gallery visitor and data from
the arts professional alike, to all those Pradeep K. Chhibber & Rahul Verma the Indian
(Authors) National
who regularly look at, think about, and
Election
make art—especially art students and
faculty, artists, art critics, and curators. I ndian party politics, commonly viewed
as chaotic, clientelistic, and corrupt, is
nevertheless a model for deepening de-
Studies
and evi-
dence from
About the Author: mocracy and accommodating diversity. the Con-
Allan deSouza is Associate Professor and Historically, though, observers have argued stituent
Chair of Art Practice at UC Berkeley. His that Indian politics is non-ideological in Assembly
work has been nature. In contrast, Pradeep Chhibber and debates,
Rahul Verma contend that the Western they show
read a south asia shown nationally
European paradigm of "ideology" is not how edu-
research note on and internation- applicable to many contemporary multi- cation, the
allan desouza's ally, including ethnic countries. In these more diverse media, and religious practice transmit the
new book at at the Phillips states, the most important ideological competing ideas that lie at the heart of
southasia.berkeley.edu/ Collection, the debates center on statism-the extent to ideological debates in India
south-asia-research-notes Whitney Mu- which the state should dominate and regu-
seum, the Centre late society-and recognition-whether and About the Authors:
Pompidou, the National Museum of African how the state should accommodate various
Art, & the Yerba Buena Center for the Arts. marginalized groups and protect minority Pradeep K. Chhibber is Professor of Politi-
cal Science and Indo-American Community
Chair for India Studies at UC Berkeley. He
Afghanistan Rising: Islamic Dispossession Without has published widely on the party politics of
India, party systems, and religion and politics.
Law and Statecraft between Development: Land Grabs
the Ottoman and British in Neoliberal India Rahul Verma is a PhD candidate in Political
Science at UC Berkeley. His PhD dissertation
Empires Michael Levien (Author) focuses on the historical roots of elite persis-
tence in contemporary Indian politics.
Faiz Ahmed (Author)
S ince the mid-2000s, India has been
D
beset by widespread farmer protests
ebunking conventional narratives of
against land dispossession. Dispossession The Routledge Companion to
Afghanistan as a perennial war zone
and the rule of law as a secular-liberal mo- Without Development demonstrates that Planning in the Global South
nopoly, Faiz Ahmed presents a vibrant ac- beneath these conflicts lay a profound
shift in regimes of dispossession. While Gautam Bhan, Smita Srinivas, & Vanessa
count of the first Watson (Eds.)
Muslim-majority the postcolonial Indian state dispos-
sessed land mostly for public-sector
country to gain
independence,
codify its own
industry and infrastructure, since the
1990s state governments have become
T his book offers an edited collection on
planning in parts of the world which, more
often than not, are unrecognised or unmarked
laws, and ratify a land brokers for private real estate capi-
in mainstream planning texts. In doing
constitution after tal. Using the
so, its intention is to re-theorise planning
the fall of the case of a village
from a deep understanding of ‘place’ as well
Ottoman Em- in Rajasthan
as a commitment to recognise the diverse
pire. Afghanistan that was dis-
modes of practice that come within it. The
Rising illustrates possessed for a
chapters thus take the form not of gener-
how turn-of-the- private Special
alised, ‘universal’ analyses and prescrip-
twentieth-century Economic
tions, but instead are critical and located
Kabul—far from Zone, the book
reflections in thinking about how to plan,
being a land- ethnographi-
act and intervene
locked wilderness or remote frontier—be- cally illustrates
in highly complex
came a magnet for itinerant scholars and the exclusion-
city, regional and
statesmen shuttling between Ottoman ary trajectory of
national contexts.
and British imperial domains. From Turk- capitalism driv-
Chapter authors
ish lawyers and Arab officers to Pashtun ing dispossession
are not all plan-
clerics and Indian bureaucrats, this rich in contemporary
ners, or are plan-
narrative focuses on encounters between India. Taking us into the lives of diverse
ners of very different
divergent streams of modern Muslim villagers in "Rajpura," the book meticu-
kinds, and this di-
thought and politics, beginning with lously documents the destruction of agri-
versity ensures a rich
the Sublime Porte’s first mission to Af- cultural livelihoods, the marginalization
variety of insights,
ghanistan in 1877 and concluding with of rural labor, the spatial uneveness of
primarily based on
the collapse of Ottoman rule after World infrastructure provision, and the dramatic
cases, to emphasise
War I. Based on archival research in six consequences of real estate speculation
the complexity of
countries and as many languages, Afghani- for social inequality and village politics.
the world in which
stan Rising rediscovers a time when Kabul Illuminating the structural underpin-
planning is expected
stood proudly as a center of constitutional nings of land struggles in contemporary
to happen.
politics, Muslim cosmopolitanism, and India, this book will resonate in any place
contested visions of reform in the greater where "land grabs" have fueled conflict in About the Editors:
Islamicate world. recent years.
Gautam Bhan (Ph.D. City & Regional Plan-
About the Author: ning, 2012), Lead - Academics & Research,
About the Author: Indian Institute for Human Settlements, Ban-
Faiz Ahmed (Ph.D. History, 2013) is Asso- Michael Levien (Ph.D. Sociology, 2013) galore.
ciate Professor of History at Brown Univer- is Assistant Professor of Sociology at Johns
Smita Srinivas is Assistant Professor of Urban
sity. He specializes in legal and constitutional Hopkins University. He has been researching
Planning, Columbia University.
history in the late Ottoman Empire, modern and writing about rural land dispossession in
India for the past fifteen years. Vanessa Watson is Professor of City Planning,
Middle East, and Islamicate South Asia.
University of Cape Town.
18
In Memoriam
SABA MAHMOOD
(1962-2018)
Saba Mahmood challenged
progressive, secular and
political certainties about
religion and righteous politics.
A professor of anthropology
at the University of California
at Berkeley, she passed away
on March 10, 2018 at the age
of 56 from pancreatic cancer.
She specialised in sociocultural
anthropology and was a
scholar of modern Egypt. The
following is a tribute to her life
and work from her close friend
and colleague, Raka Ray
book. Politics of Piety: The Islamic who debated the Quran, saw veiling
I
first encountered Saba Revival and the Feminist Subject (2005) as an aspiration, and sought to find
Mahmood in the late 1990s challenged forever my progressive the discipline to pray five times a day?
when she was a post- doctoral secular political certainties, and Challenging ‘Autonomy’
scholar and I was an assistant made increasing sense of the world
professor. I attended a talk she gave we were inhabiting. It soon became In the first instance, she reminded
at a time when, as a progressive a staple in my graduate classroom, us that because of feminism’s
Indian feminist, my understanding and for the past decade, my students politically prescriptive project the
about religion was driven by the have considered themselves concept of agency was conflated
events that had unfolded around more challenged and changed by with resistance. In other words, an
the destruction of Babri Masjid, and this book than by all others. act of reinscribing norms through
the rise of Bharatiya Janata Party I know others have written, and embodied practices (such as veiling)
and its attendant organisations. At will write, about Saba’s entire oeuvre, could never be seen as agency, but
that moment, religiosity had become but let me dwell here on the work I an act of resistance, however small,
equated in my mind with Hindu know best, the watershed Politics of would. In the second instance, she
fundamentalism, and I had begun Piety. The book is an ethnographic challenged the belief that there is, in
to doubt the Indian government’s study of groups of women in Cairo all human beings, an innate desire for
claim to be secular. I had also learnt who pursue an understanding of Islam freedom; at least for a form of freedom
enough about Hindutvavadi women not as a form of worship relegated understood as personal autonomy.
to be particularly suspicious of to specific times of the day or week, She wrote a book that asked us to
discussions about religious women. but as a practice that permeates take the time to reflect on that which
And here was Saba Mahmood, every aspect of their lives. Thus, occurred in lifeworlds that were not
talking about pious Muslim women they attend prayer and discussion our own, without feeling compelled to
with understanding, challenging most meetings led by women, they strive rush to the rescue. Even more than a
of the audience’s notions about the in their comportment, their practices, challenge to contemporary feminism,
pious versus the secular, and about their daily lives, and their clothing, Politics of Piety is an anti-imperialist
agentic women versus oppressed to live a life in accordance with book, which challenges core
women. With an acute sense of Islamic precepts in a secular world. Western certainties about religion,
discomfort I listened to her speak But, their actions are not, Saba secularism and righteous politics.
that day, and I was not the only one. warns, to be understood as tradition This stance, however, meant
A murmur of dissatisfaction spread reasserting itself over their agency. neither that she was apolitical nor
through the room, and even as I was This movement could not have that she was completely at home
part of that murmur, my eyes were come about, after all, without with all religious assertions (as her
riveted by that taut figure at the fundamental transformations enabled detractors have often suggested).
podium, at the very beginning of her by modernity; for example, the Rather, living in the United States
career, who, despite what must have understanding that religious practice (US), she felt that her task was to
been a considerable level of anxiety, is not just a duty of rulers, but of speak to audiences in the West and to
held her ground against senior ordinary Muslims. This could have its dominant liberal political projects
feminists of every stripe with courage. also not come about without higher that exerted such material and
She never knew that she had set an literacy and social mobility of women discursive power over the world, in
example that day as a Muslim woman, who came to lead the movement. the creation of which her audiences
an intellectual at the beginning of Through Saba’s work we came to were often wittingly or unwittingly
her career, hiding her fears behind see that these pious women could not complicit. Through her writing and
her convictions as she attacked what be thought of as dupes of patriarchal her public engagements, she sought
were then feminist shibboleths. culture but, rather, that they were to dispel dominant myths about
This was before Saba arrived actively engaged in what she called the religious and the secular, and
at Berkeley as a faculty member a project of self-making that could to draw attention to the sometimes
(from University of Chicago) really be grasped only within the fatal consequences of those myths.
in 2004, and before our hours of cultural and ethical parameters of For example, she argued that
conversation, debate, and laughter Islam. The challenge Saba posed, those who read the oppositional
turned us into fast friends. I read that had us muttering disapprovingly response to the attacks on the image
her book on which the talk was when we first heard it, was to the core of Mohammed (for example in the
based as soon as it was published; feminist understandings of agency, Danish cartoons in 2006 or in the
for me, as for almost everyone else which assumed the universal meaning Charlie Hebdo magazine in 2015) as
who has encountered it, there was of both agency and freedom. How, an overreaction to something merely
no going back once I had read the after all, were we to think of women “offensive,” misunderstood both the
19
nature of the Islamic relationship to she studied Egypt and not Pakistan, THE INSTITUTE MOURNS
the divine and the roots of secularism. Saba’s answer was that she was not THE PASSING OF PROF.
Indeed, she argued that the prevalent ready to do so. Pakistan was too close. SABA MAHMOOD
conception of secularism as involving In the last few years at Berkeley, (ANTHROPOLOGY). PROF.
a distinction between public and however, she came to work with the MAHMOOD PASSED AWAY
private life actually draws from Institute for South Asian Studies and, ON MARCH 10, 2018 AFTER
a specifically modern Christian together with Munis Faruqui, was A PROLONGED BATTLE
emphasis on private worship and instrumental in creating the Berkeley
WITH CANCER. A HIGHLY
belief. She spoke out about these Pakistan Studies and Urdu Initiatives
issues at highly contentious public to encourage and deepen the study INFLUENTIAL SCHOLAR OF
events, as she did also about of Urdu and of Pakistan. These THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN
Palestine, and about the various US initiatives were the first of their kind RELIGIOUS AND SECULAR
interventions in West Asia. At all in the US. Once Religious Difference POLITICS IN POSTCOLONIAL
these events, she knew full well that in a Secular Age was written, she SOCIETIES, SOVEREIGNTY,
when she took the stage she was began thinking that she was ready SUBJECT FORMATION, LAW,
going to voice an unpopular opinion. to work, at last, on Pakistan. She AND GENDER/SEXUALITY,
There, she often stood at the podium, took her first exploratory research PROF. MAHMOOD WAS A
serious, determined, and willing trip in 2016, shortly before she POWERFUL PRESENCE IN
to bear the inevitable attacks from received her terminal diagnosis of THE LIFE OF THE INSTITUTE
people who refused to reflect on their pancreatic cancer. It is a great loss FOR SOUTH ASIA STUDIES.
own assumptions and certainties. to the intellectual world of South
HER VISION, ENERGY, FIERCE
In short, through her single- Asia that she was not able to see
authored, co-authored, and co-edited that project through to completion. INTELLECT, AND GOOD
books—Religious Difference in a Saba Mahmood was one of the CHEER PLAYED A KEY ROLE
Secular Age: A Minority Report (2015), deepest intellectuals I knew, yet one IN THE CREATION OF TWO
Is Critique Secular?, Politics of Religious whose intellect was matched by her DYNAMIC INSTITUTE-
Freedom—and her many articles, Saba ringing peals of laughter, her delight CENTERED INITIATIVES:
Mahmood challenged how issues in the perfect summer fruit or the THE PAKISTAN STUDIES
at the core of the enlightenment turtles in Tilden Park, her insistence INITIATIVE AND URDU@
project, such as agency, subject on feeding her family and friends BERKELEY. WE WILL ALL
formation, freedom and politics, were delicious meals (even though she MISS HER PROFOUNDLY. OUR
taken for granted. We should not did insist certain dubious foods were HEARTFELT CONDOLENCES
underestimate the anger and hostility delicious because they were good GO OUT TO HER HUSBAND,
with which Saba’s insistence—that for you). She loved spending time
SON, FAMILY AND TO SABA'S
we should understand secularism’s with friends, discussing with equal
inextricable dependence on religious intensity their work or hers, their WIDE CIRCLE OF FRIENDS.
formations, that capacities defining everyday lives, politics in West Asia
personhood were not universal or in the university, music or poetry,
but occurred within particular or where the best Japanese food was
epistemological frame-works, and to be found. Saba loved to watch
her refusal to judge what were films at home with her beloved
appropriate feminist projects versus husband Charles and son Nameer,
anti-feminist ones—was met. As I voraciously devoured world news,
often said to her when she showed derived utmost pleasure from being
me yet another angry review: “Did in nature, and frequently challenged
you think it would be easy to be a herself with extremes of exercise
revolutionary?” For that was what she (which meant that she was able to
was, though I do not think this was walk for longer distances even with
something she ever fully understood. her cancer than many of us who had Saba with (clockwise from bottom right) Raka
Saba worked on Egypt but she was no such excuse). She embraced life Ray, Salima Hashmi, Behnaz Raufi, Munis Faruqui,
born in Quetta, Pakistan in 1962, with her spirit, her intellect and her Sanchita Saxena, and Adnan Malik.
coming to the US originally not to heart, and she died with the fierceness
study religion or anthropology, but and grace that marked her life. She
architecture and urban planning remained at the end the figure I
at University of Washington in first saw, holding herself up, braced
Seattle. She received her PhD against the knowledge that her life
in anthropology from Stanford was to be cut short, hiding her terror
University in 1998. When asked why with courage, not knowing that she
was setting
an example
for us all.
Originally
printed in Saba with Anjum Altaf & Munis D. Faruqui.
Economic
& Political
Weekly, March
31, 2018. vol
53, no 13.
Reprinted here
with permission
from the
author. v
Special
Section
N
ovember 19 is World chanical equipment and without pro- THIS
tective clothing, scooping out faeces
Toilet Day. Enormous
progress has been made from ‘dry’ latrines and overflowing
PHOTOESSAY,
in the global effort to provide safe pits, it is called “manual scavenging”. CREATED BY
It’s an ancient profession and In-
and affordable toilets for the world’s
poorest citizens since World Toi- dia, which made the practice illegal CS SHARADA
let Day was first declared in 2001. in 1993, still has over one million PRASAD AND
such cleaners (the exact number is
Significant strides have been made
in “reinventing” toilet designs for unknown, and declining). They ser- ISHA RAY FOR
low-income, water-short, unsew- vice low-income urban households WORLD TOILET
ered urban zones; celebrities such and railway tracks and army barracks;
as Bill Gates and Matt Damon have they come from the lowest strata of DAY, WAS
brought this once-taboo topic into the Hindu caste system, and about
90 percent of them are women.
SELECTED BY
the open; and the Prime Minister of
India--the country with the high- Despite valiant civil society (and INDIA WATER
est number of people still practising several governments) efforts to train
them for other professions, breaking
PORTAL, THE
open defecation--has publicly de-
clared that his country needs toilets out of this denigrated caste-based LARGEST WATER
over temples. profession remains very difficult.
Many mehters live in the shadows of
& SANITATION
Well over two billion people
today lack access to basic sanita- society, invisible yet reviled, taunted PORTAL
yet essential, trapped in an uncon-
tion facilities, according to the
World Health Organization; about stitutional practice without viable
IN INDIA,
760 million of them live in India. alternatives. OPERATING
In a real sense, 70 years after
The goal of this Day is to make the
global community aware of their Indian independence, this is a com- OUT OF ROHINI
right to safe and dignified sanita- munity still waiting for its freedom. NILKEKANI'S
In this photo-essay, we explore the
tion and to support public action
and public policy to bring this right daily lives of the toilet-cleaners: their ARGHYAM
closer to those who do not enjoy it homes, their hopes, their work, and FOUNDATION,
today. On this World Toilet Day, we their determination to get their chil-
focus on the back-end of the sani- dren out of it. If World Toilet Day is AS ONE OF THEIR
tation chain, on those who clean about expanding access to clean toi-
lets, it must also be about those who
SEVEN "BEST OF
out latrines where there is no flush
or sewer to carry away the waste. have to clean the toilets. 2017" FEATURES
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Isha Ray is an development; and technology and sor at the Azim
Associate Pro- society. Her research projects focus Premji University,
fessor at the on access to safe and affordable Bangalore, India.
Energy & Re- water and sanitation for the rural He is also a re-
sources Group and urban poor, and on the role of searcher, sanita-
and Co-Director technology in advancing sustain- tion specialist,
of the Berkeley able development and social equity. and WASH con-
Water Center at CS Sharada Prasad, the photographer, sultant. His re-
Dr. Isha Ray Dr. C.S. Sharada
UC Berkeley. Dr. earned his PhD from Energy & Re- search is focused
Ray’s research interests are water sources Group, UC Berkeley in 2018. on sanitation access and work in low
and development; sanitation and He is currently an Assistant Profes- and middle income countries. v
21
— RAJAN —
It's December and we're in Lucknow.
Old Lucknow is a city of medieval architecture and narrow
alleys. The alleys are crowded, with gutters on either side that
drain away anything that flows--rainwater, bath water, kitchen
waste, human excreta. The streets have no sidewalks. On this
cold winter morning, most people are indoors, but those who
pass Rajan either don’t see him or they say nothing.
With young children to look after, Rajan’s wife works as a part-time domestic
help. She goes into her immaculately-maintained kitchen and starts making tea
for her guests. As she pours the milky tea into three tiny steel glasses, Rajan
looks at the number of glasses and says he doesn’t want any. Rajan doesn’t
want his boys to inherit the family job. Except for
the little one, they all go to school. The second one
is especially bright and plans to be a bike mechanic,
he says.
22
— KISHEN &
MEENA —
This is a community that will do just about anything
to make sure their children get educated. Kishen and
Meena, like Rajan, have pinned all their hopes on
education for their children. They both clean toilets.
Their house is just a room, 15 feet by 10 feet. At one
corner, there’s a small kitchen-like setup. The house
is lit by a single light bulb, but the toilet is a porcelain
pour-flush one, clean and dry.
Their problem is TV, they say; no one touches his homework
when the Hindi soap operas come on. No one even moves. “These
children think that education is free. Education is free only in
government schools. But our children: I save up every month to
send both my children to private schools.” Meena is proud and
worried all at once.
Meena moves
closer to the fire
and suggests some
chai; she hasn’t had
any all day. It’s not
that there’s no time:
But “we don’t eat
or drink until we’ve
washed ourselves.
Cleaning the shit of
these people is bad
enough. I don’t want
to put that in my
mouth.”
23
— VASUMATI —
The next morning, just after 7am, we go out with Vasumati.
Her husband doesn’t want her to do this work. “But we have
two children and we need money for their school, for their
shoes,” he says. “We could start a business with the money
the government will lend us. But we don’t really know how to
manage a business." He's afraid the business will fail and the
family will lose their home. How about a small business that
does not need a big investment? A corner shop or a tea stall? “
"A tea stall is a great idea. People drink a lot of tea in Lucknow.
But if they get to know our caste, we'll run into problems.”
There’s no easy escape out of this job, they all know that.
She has to get going. She has 32 more toilets to clean today.
24
KHABAR
NON-P ROF IT ORGANIZATION
U.S. P OSTAGE
PA ID
U N IVE RSITY OF C AL IF ORNIA, BE RKE L E Y
What’s Inside
Faculty Opinion: On Rahul
Gandhi's Cal Speech
v
Photo Essay: Where there are
no sewers: The toilet cleaners of
Lucknow
v
In Memoriam
Saba Mahmood
Bangladesh@Berkeley
Editor: Puneeta Kala
Upcoming Events in
SPRING 2019