Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2020-36 Defense Delivery of Evidence
2020-36 Defense Delivery of Evidence
ONEMINUTE
JACKIE LACEY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY
BRIEF
COPYRIGHT © 2020 LOS ANGELES COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY’S OFFICE. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. MAY BE REPRODUCED FOR
NON-COMMERCIAL PROSECUTORIAL, LAW ENFORCEMENT AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. 1MB@da.lacounty.gov
NUMBER: 2020-36 DATE: 10-22-20 BY: Devallis Rutledge TOPIC: Defense Delivery of Evidence
ISSUE: What if the defense attorney comes into possession of the fruits, instrumentalities or
evidence of a crime?
Occasionally, a criminal defendant or a third party turns over weapons, stolen property, video,
writings or other incriminating evidence of a crime to the defense attorney. Should the attorney conceal
the evidence, to avoid helping the prosecution? (No.) Or must the defense attorney deliver the evidence
to the prosecutor, or to the court to be disclosed to the prosecution? (Yes.)
“A person who, knowing that any matter or thing is about to be produced in evidence upon a trial
or investigation authorized by law, willfully destroys, erases or conceals the same, with the intent to
prevent it from being produced, is guilty of a misdemeanor.” PC § 135 (condensed).
PC § 32 provides that an accessory to another’s felony is him/herself guilty of felony, and
“Concealment of a weapon used by the principal in the commission of a felony may constitute
the actus reus of the offense.” People v. Wilson (1993) 17 Cal.App.4th 271, 275.
In some circumstances, withholding evidence of a crime is a felony-wobbler. PC § 153.
“It has been held an abuse of a lawyer’s professional responsibility knowingly to take
possession of and secrete the instrumentalities of a crime. A defendant in a criminal case
may not permanently sequester physical evidence such as a weapon or other article used
in the perpetration of a crime by delivering it to his attorney.” People v. Lee (1970) 3
Cal.App.3d 514, 526 (citing PC § 135).
● The prosecutor need not (but may and sometimes should) make a formal request for
disclosure of all physical evidence in the possession of defense counsel or his/her agents. The
defense has an absolute, affirmative duty to take steps to deliver the evidence:
LADA ONE-MINUTE BRIEF NO. 2020-36 PAGE 2
BOTTOM LINE: Physical evidence of a crime that is removed, altered or held by defense
counsel must be delivered to the prosecution, or to the court for timely disclosure.
(Emphases added and citations omitted from quoted material.)
This information was current as of publication date. It is not intended as legal advice. It is
recommended that readers check for subsequent developments, and consult legal advisors to ensure
currency after publication. Local policies and procedures regarding application should be observed.