Wind Shear, An Invisible Enemy To Pilots

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 13

OPERATIONS

Wind shear

Wind shear:
an invisible enemy
to pilots?
Weather plays a significant role in aviation safety and is
regularly cited as a contributing factor in accidents or major
incidents. Wind shear in the form of microbursts particularly,
can be a severe hazard to aircraft during take-off, approach
and landing.

JEAN DANEY XAVIER LESCEU


Director Flight Safety – Experimental Test Pilot
Accident Investigator

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 1/13


As commercial aviation began to develop in the middle of
the last century, we knew very little about wind shear. The
detection and reporting of wind shear related events was
actually really poor. Yet, in its many forms, although actual
encounters with severe wind shear are fairly remote in a pilot’s
career, this phenomenon can change a routine approach into
an emergency recovery in a matter of seconds.
As research and technology progressed, we have learned to
identify, prevent and if necessary, handle such events.
We will look at the effects of wind shear on an aircraft and at
piloting techniques for coping with a shear situation, focusing
more particularly on microbursts.

UNDERSTANDING WIND SHEAR

Definitions
>> Wind shear

Wind shear can be defined as a sud- decreasing headwind or increasing


den change in wind velocity and/or tailwind, or a shift from a headwind The change in
direction over a short distance. It can to a tailwind – of up to 100 knots
occur in all directions, but for conven- per nautical mile. (Fig.1) shows
velocity or direction
ience, it is considered along vertical how a penetration would appear as can drastically
and horizontal axis, thus introducing an aircraft crosses a cold front. alter the aircraft
the concepts of vertical and horizon-
tal wind shear: This weather phenomenon can occur lift, indicated
• Vertical wind shear consists of wind at many different levels of the atmos- airspeed, and thrust
variations along the vertical axis of phere; however it is most dangerous
typically 20 to 30 knots per 1000 ft. at the lower levels, as a sudden loss
requirements when
The change in velocity or direction of airspeed and altitude can occur. climbing
can drastically alter the aircraft
lift, indicated airspeed, and thrust It is usually associated with the follow-
or descending
requirements when climbing or ing weather conditions: jet streams, through the wind
descending through the wind shear mountain waves or temperature shear layer.
layers. inversion layers, frontal surfaces,
• Horizontal wind shear consists of thunderstorms and convective clouds
variations in the wind component or microbursts, occurring close to the
along the horizontal axis – e.g. ground.

>> What is a microburst?


COLD C
A microburst clearly creates the most Microbursts are either dry (i.e. little or
B
dangerous forms of wind shear. It con- no rain reaches the ground) or wet
sists of a small column of exceptionally (usually within a downpour). They typ- A
intense and localized sinking air, which ically form under or close to thunder-
descends to the ground (called “the storms and cumulonimbus clouds in Wind-Shift Line
downdraft”) and upon contact with the particular (fig.2).
earth’s surface, diverges outwards in The radial pattern means winds of var-
WARM
all directions, thus forming a ring vor- ious directions within a small area, and
tex. It is capable of producing powerful hence considerable wind shear near
(fig.1)
winds near ground level. the ground, for up to several minutes. Horizontal wind shear

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 2/13


OPERATIONS
Wind shear

(fig.2)
Microburst caused by a cumulonimbus

Typical characteristics of microbursts


Size Covers an area less than 2.5 nautical miles in diameter.

Downdrafts are 40 knots (4000 ft/minute), horizontal winds


Intensity
between 45 and 100 knots.

Duration Approximately 15 minutes.


Visual signs Often associated with heavy thunderstorms, embedded in heavy rain.

Microbursts: a threat to aviation safety


From a safety perspective, microbursts bring a threat to aircraft due to the
scale and suddenness of this phenomenon. To put it briefly, microbursts com-
bine two distinct threats to aviation safety (fig.3):

• The downburst part, resulting in • The outburst part, resulting in large


strong downdrafts that rapidly push horizontal wind shear and wind
the aircraft downward. The power of component shift from headwind to
the downburst can actually exceed tailwind. This sudden change from
aircraft climb capabilities. headwind to tailwind reduces the lift
of the aircraft, which may force the
aircraft down, typically during take-
off or landing.

An aircraft actually encountering a microburst in the vicinity of an airfield while


it is about to land or take-off, may be flying through 3 different and difficult
phases of wind conditions at a critical phase of flight, at low altitude. For exam-
ple, an aircraft flying through a microburst at landing should expect to encoun-
ter the following phases:

>> Phase 1: Headwind

•W
 hen first entering a microburst, •T
o descend the aircraft back on
the pilot notices a performance its descent path and decrease
enhancing headwind gust, which speed, the pilot will naturally retard
instantaneously increases the air- the engines and push the side
craft airspeed, thus causing lift and stick, thereby forcing the aircraft to
the aircraft to rise above its intended descend.
path and/or accelerate (see (fig.3),
items 1 and 2).

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 3/13


>> Phase 2: Downdraft
A microburst
•A
 s the aircraft continues into the •T
 he pilot, now traveling at a lower
microburst, it meets a sudden speed and pushed downwards, will
is a serious threat
surge of downdraft affecting both attempt to regain the original trajec- to flight because
the aircraft flight path and then the tory by initiating a climb. of its direct and
Angle-Of-Attack (AOA): the aircraft
will sink and the AOA will increase aggressive impact
(see (fig.3), item 3). on the aircraft
>> Phase 3: Tailwind
airspeed, altitude,
Angle-Of-Attack,
•A
 s the pilot attempts to climb to
recover his/her altitude, the aircraft
•T
he tailwind gust instantaneously
decreases the aircraft lift and air-
and thus, lift
now experiences a change in wind speed and thus, it tends to make capability.
direction and encounters a tailwind. the aircraft fly below its intended
path and/or decelerate(see (fig.3),
item 4).

A microburst is a serious threat to flight because of its direct and aggres-


sive impact on the aircraft airspeed, altitude, Angle-Of-Attack, and thus,
lift capability.

(fig.3)
Effects of a microburst on aircraft
performance

Downburst

1
2 Gust front

3
Headwind Tailwind

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 4/13


OPERATIONS
Wind shear

PREVENTION: HOW TO DETECT


AND AVOID WIND SHEAR

Wind shear has a negative effect on aircraft


performance and is therefore a real threat
to the safe conduct of flight. The best line of
defence against such hazards is: detection and
avoidance.
Since the discovery of the effects of priate actions. In practice, flight crew
wind shear on aircraft performance in awareness and alertness are key fac-
the early 1980’s, different tools have tors in the successful application of
been developed to help pilots recog- wind shear avoidance techniques.
nize these events, and take appro-

Wind shear awareness and detection means


The best ways a pilot can prevent an encounter with wind shear is to know
wind shear is there and to avoid it where possible. However, should an encoun-
ter be unavoidable, it is important to know the likely magnitude of the change,
and be prepared to react immediately. Although there is no absolutely reliable
way to predict the occurrence, different tools and information can be used to
detect areas of potential or observed wind shear, and thus be able to develop
efficient avoidance strategies.

A good >> Weather reports and forecast


communication Many airports – particularly those These devices are able to detect
between flight that are prone to microburst and microbursts and warn aircraft of their
crews and ATC wind shear – are now equipped occurrences by sending an alert to
with a Low Level Wind shear Alert- ATC. In this respect, a good com-
is essential. ing System (LLWAS) and/or a Termi- munication between flight crews and
nal Doppler Weather Radar (TDWR). ATC is essential.

INFORMATION
The LLWAS is comprised of a central anemometer (sensing wind velocity and
direction) and peripheral anemometers located approximately two nautical
miles from the center. Central wind sensor data are averaged over a rolling
two-minute period and compared every 10 seconds with the data from the
peripheral wind sensors.

There are two LLWAS alerting modes: wind shear alert and microburst alert. A
wind shear alert is generated whenever the wind speed loses 15 to 29 knots,
or gains more than 15 knots. Microburst alert condition is when the wind speed
loses more than 30 knots. LLWAS may not detect downbursts with a diameter
of 2 nm or less. This system enables Air Traffic Controllers to warn pilots of
existing or impending wind shear conditions.

The TDWR enables to detect approaching wind shear areas and thus, to pro-
vide pilots with more advance warning of wind shear hazard.

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 5/13


Safety First #19 | January 2015 43

>> Crew observations

Blowing dust, rings of dust, dust dev- of potential or existing downburst. A


ils (i.e. whirlwinds containing dust and large difference between actual wind
sand), intense rainfall or any other evi- (on ND) and wind reported by tower
dence of strong local air outflow near can also be a good indication. There-
the surface often are good indications fore it is better to avoid these areas.

>> Pilots’ reports (PIREPS)

PIREPS of wind shear in excess of bursts intensify for several minutes


20 knots or downdraft / updraft of after they first impact the ground, the
500 ft per minute below 1000 ft above severity may be higher than that ini-
ground level are all good indications tially reported. Conversely, the micro- Remember that
of severe conditions and should be burst reported may well have dissi-
avoided at any time. pated by the time the aircraft plans to
the aircraft ahead
Considering that these conditions cross the incriminated area. may experience
develop, change or dissipate rap-
idly, those reports should however
Therefore it is very important to
remember that the aircraft ahead may
vastly different
be interpreted with great care and experience vastly different conditions conditions than
judgement. A pilot must consider the than the following one will encounter the following one
amount of time since the report was in the same airspace.
made. Indeed, knowing that micro- will encounter in the
same airspace.
>> On-board weather radar

Generally microbursts are accom- on-board weather radar. Those areas


panied by heavy rainfalls, which can should be avoided.
be detected and identified using the

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 6/13


OPERATIONS
Wind shear

>> On-board predictive wind shear system

Today, most aircraft models have pre- The PWS provides typically a one-min-
dictive wind shear equipment to warn ute advance warning by showing first
pilots of possible threats via aural and an amber “W/S AHEAD” message on
visual means. the PFD (fig.4).

To provide an early warning of poten- If conditions worsen and the wind


tial wind shear activity, some on-board shear location gets closer to the air-
weather radars feature the capability to craft, the “W/S AHEAD” amber cau-
detect wind shear areas ahead of the tion turns into a red warning and is
aircraft, based on a measure of wind associated with an aural synthetic
velocities ahead of the aircraft both ver- voice “WIND SHEAR AHEAD, WIND
(fig.4) tically and horizontally. SHEAR AHEAD” during take-off,
“W/S AHEAD” predictive caution
display on PFD
or “GO AROUND, WIND SHEAR
This equipment is referred to as a Pre- AHEAD” at landing. This is a pos-
dictive Wind shear System (PWS). This sible indication that the aircraft is
system is active and provides reliable indi- approaching a microburst.
cations between 50 and approximately
1000 feet above the ground surface.

>> Summary

Flight crew should consider all availa- •W eather radar implemented at


ble wind shear awareness means and airports. These systems serve to
assess the conditions for a safe take- detect microbursts in close proxim-
off or safe descent, approach and ity to the airport and send out alerts
landing based on: to both pilots and ATC alike.
• Most recent weather reports and • On-board weather radar to ensure
forecast. Pay a careful attention to that the flight path is clear of hazard
ATC indications in particular. areas.
• Visual observations. • On-board Predictive Wind shear
• Crew experience with the airport System (PWS).
environment and the prevailing
weather conditions.

Operational best practices: how to avoid wind


shear and get prepared altogether

The wealth of tools and indications listed previously should allow crews to
gather sufficient knowledge about the weather conditions ahead, and thus
plan accordingly. But how can these pieces of information be best used to be
prepared to react and effectively avoid an actual encounter with wind shear?
Here are a few tips.

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 7/13


>> Take-off

•C
 onsider delaying the take-off until •U  se the weather radar (and the
conditions improve. Remember predictive wind shear system, as
a downburst is not a long-lasting available) before commencing the
phenomenon and can clear within
minutes.
take-off roll to ensure that the flight
path is clear of hazard areas.
BEST
•
Select the most favourable • Select the maximum take-off PRACTICE
runway and initial climb out path, thrust.
considering the location of the • Closely monitor the airspeed and If wind shear is suspected, or is de-
likely wind shear / downburst. This speed trend during the take-off tected by the Predictive Wind shear
may involve asking ATC for “an roll to detect any evidence of wind System (PWS), delay the take-off.
immediate left or right turn after shear.
take-off to avoid”.

>> Descent and approach

•W hen downburst / wind shear •C losely monitor the airspeed,


conditions are anticipated based speed trend and ground speed
on pilots’ reports from preceding during the approach to detect
aircraft, or based on an alert issued any evidence of imminent wind
by the airport LLWAS, the approach shear. If the presence of wind
and landing should be delayed until shear is confirmed, be prepared
conditions improve, or the aircraft for a possible missed approach
should divert to a more suitable and escape maneuver. A
airport. minimum ground speed should be
• Select the most favourable holding maintained to ensure a minimum
point, approach path and runway, level of energy to the aircraft, and to
considering the location of the likely ensure proper thrust management
wind shear / downburst condition, during the approach in case of
and the available runway approach sudden headwind to tailwind
aids. change. This is automatically
• Select less than full flaps for performed on Airbus fly-by-wire
landing (to maximize the climb aircraft by the Ground Speed mini
gradient capability) and adjust the function, when the speed target is
final approach speed (i.e. VAPP)
accordingly.
managed.
• In anticipation of a possible wind
BEST
• If an ILS is available, engage the shear event, be alert to respond PRACTICE
autopilot for a more accurate immediately to any predictive
approach tracking. wind shear advisory, “W/S If wind shear is suspected, or is de-
• If a gusty wind is expected, consider AHEAD” caution or warning. tected by the Predictive Wind shear
an increase in VAPP displayed on the And be prepared to perform a System (PWS), delay the approach
FMS CDU (a maximum of minimum missed approach or go-around if until conditions improve, or divert to
approach speed (i.e. VLS) + 15 knots necessary. a more suitable airport.
is allowed).

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 8/13


OPERATIONS
Wind shear

RECOVERY: HOW TO
RECOGNIZE AND HANDLE
ACTUAL WIND SHEAR
CONDITIONS
Despite the available prevention means, an
actual encounter with wind shear can happen.
A timely recognition of this weather phenomenon
is crucial to allow enough time for the crew to
decide on the next course of action.
As far as wind shear is concerned, the encounter, piloting techniques exist for
best course of action is almost always coping with a shear situation.
avoidance. But in case of an actual

Recognition
As rare as an actual encounter with severe wind shear may be, timely recog-
nition of this condition is key for the successful implementation of wind shear
recovery / escape procedures.

>> How to strengthen the wind shear situational awareness

The following deviations should be •V  ertical speed excursions of 500 ft/


considered as indications of a possi- minute
ble wind shear condition: • Pitch attitude excursions of 5
• Indicated airspeed variations in degrees
excess of 15 knots • Glide slope deviation of 1 dot
• Ground speed variations • Heading variations of 10 degrees
• Analog wind indication variations: • Unusual autothrust or auto throttle
direction and velocity activity.

>> On-board reactive wind shear system

A reactive wind shear warning system The wind shear warning system asso-
is available on most aircraft models. ciated to the Speed reference System
(SRS) mode of the flight guidance con-
This system is capable to detect a wind stitute the Reactive Wind shear Sys-
shear encounter based on a measure tem (RWS), since both components
of wind velocities, both vertically and react instantaneously to the current
(fig.5) horizontally. When it activates, the variations of aircraft parameters.
“WINDSHEAR” reactive warning audio “WIND SHEAR” is repeated 3
display on PFD times, and a red “WINDSHEAR” warn-
ing appears on the PFD (fig.5).

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 9/13


Recovery technique for wind shear encounter

The aircraft can only survive severe floor protection, even if TOGA was
wind shear encounters if it has already selected (do not forget to
enough energy to carry it through the disconnect the Autothrust in this
loss-of-performance period. It can case, when out of alpha floor).
sustain this energy level in the follow- • If possible, trade height energy for
ing three ways: speed. Any aircraft can do this.
• Carry extra speed. The aircraft does
this automatically when in approach Proper pilot technique helps in this
in managed speed (Ground speed process, providing the following few
mini). recommendations are duly followed,
• Add maximum thrust. The aircraft in a timely manner.
does this automatically with alpha

>> During take-off

If a wind shear is detected by the exceeding the target V1) and the
RWS or by pilot observation during pilot assesses there is sufficient run-
the take-off roll, V1 may be reached way remaining to stop the aircraft.
later (or sooner) than expected. In
this case, the pilot may have to rely • After V1:
on his/her own judgement to assess if - Maintain or set the thrust levers
there is sufficient runway remaining to to the maximum take-off thrust
stop the aircraft, if necessary. (TOGA);
- Rotate normally at VR;
In any case, the following recovery - Follow the Flight Director (FD) pitch
techniques must be applied without orders if the FD provides wind
delay: shear recovery guidance, or set
• Before V1: the required pitch attitude as rec-
Reject the take-off if unaccept- ommended in the FCOM.
able airspeed variations occur (not

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 10/13


OPERATIONS
Wind shear

>> During initial climb, approach and landing

If a wind shear is detected by the pilot, •A  pplying full back stick on Airbus
or by the RWS, during initial climb or fly-by-wire aircraft, or flying close
approach and landing, the following to the stick shaker / stall warning
recovery technique must be applied Angle-Of-Attack (AOA) on aircraft
without delay: models that do not have full flight
envelope protection, may be nec-
•S
 et the thrust levers to the maxi- essary to prevent the aircraft from
mum take-off thrust (TOGA); sinking down;
•
If the Auto Pilot (AP) is engaged • Do not change the flaps and land-
and provides wind shear recovery ing gear configuration until out of
BEST guidance, keep the AP engaged;
or, if the AP is not engaged, do
the wind shear condition;
• Closely monitor airspeed, airspeed
PRACTICE not engage it. Follow the FD pitch trend and flight path angle (if flight
command if the FD provides wind path vector is available and dis-
If wind shear is detected by the Reac- shear recovery guidance, or set the played to the PM);
tive Wind shear System during take- required pitch attitude, as recom- • When out of the wind shear, let the
off or approach, recover with max- mended in the FCOM; aircraft accelerate in climb, resume
imum thrust and follow the Speed •
Level the wings to maximize the normal climb and clean aircraft con-
Reference System (SRS) guidance. climb gradient, unless a turn is figuration.
required for obstacle clearance;

NOTE
To recover from an actual wind shear encounter, recovery measures are indi-
cated in the FCOM ABNORMAL AND EMERGENCY PROCEDURES. Refer
to PRO-ABN-80, or FCOM Inclement Weather Operations on A300/A310/
A300-600.

RWS and PWS compared characteristics

RWS PWS

- Detect in the wind shear - Detect ahead of the aircraft


PURPOSE - Guidance to escape - Guidance to avoid the event

- Aural - Aural
WARNING - Visual - Visual

- Comparison between inertial - Doppler weather radar


PRINCIPLE and aerodynamic data

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 11/13


SUMMARY: OPERATING IN
WIND SHEAR CONDITIONS
Considering the threat that a severe The following key points and recom-
wind shear represents to safety, mendations on avoidance, recogni-
the best option is always to avoid it tion and recovery can be considered
whenever possible. Nevertheless, in for the development of company
the case of an actual encounter with strategies and initiatives aiming to
wind shear, it is essential to recognize enhance wind shear awareness.
it and then, recover from it.

Avoidance
•A  ssess the conditions for a safe more suitable airport.
take-off or approach-and-landing •B
 e “go-around minded” when flying
based on all the available meteor- an approach under reported wind
ological data, visual observations shear conditions.
and on-board equipment. •
Be prepared and committed to
• As far as possible, delay the take- respond immediately to a predictive
off or the approach, or divert to a wind shear caution or warning.

Recognition
•B
 e alert to recognize a potential and on the monitoring of the aircraft
or existing wind shear condition flight parameters and flight path.
based on all available weather data, • 
Scan instruments for evidence
on-board equipment indications of impending wind shear. NOTE
To safely operate an aircraft in wind
Recovery shear or downburst conditions, best
recommendations are indicated in
• If a wind shear warning occurs, • Make
 maximum use of aircraft the FCOM SUPPLEMENTARY PRO-
apply the recommended FCOM equipment, such as the flight-path CEDURES.
recovery / escape procedure i.e. vector (as available).
set maximum thrust and follow the
FD wind shear recovery / escape
pitch guidance.

Wind shear can be a serious threat to aviation safety. Thanks to


extensive research into the understanding of the phenomenon,
efficient equipment is now available to assist pilots in identifying,
avoiding and if necessary, handling wind shear conditions. With the
technology, flight crew awareness and alertness are key factors in
the successful application of avoidance techniques and recovery
/ escape procedures.
But above all, remember that avoidance is undoubtedly the best
defence against the hazards of wind shear.

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 12/13


002 Safety First #19 | January 2015

Safety first, #19 January, 2015. Safety first


Safety first
The Airbus magazine contributing to the enhancement
is published by Airbus S.A.S. - 1, rond point
Maurice Bellonte - 31707 Blagnac Cedex/France. of the safety of aircraft operations by increasing knowledge
Publisher: Yannick Malinge, Chief Product Safety and communication on safety related topics.
Officer, Editor: Corinne Bieder, Director Product
Safety Strategy & Communication.
Concept Design by Airbus Multi Media Support
20142795. Reference: GS 420.0045 Issue 19.
Photos by Airbus, DGA/V. Ricco, H. Goussé, Safety first is published by the Product Safety depart-
Lindner Fotografie, A. Doumenjou, B. Lange,
P. Pigeyre.
ment. It is a source of specialist safety information for the
Computer rendering by Fixion. restricted use of flight and ground crew members who fly
Printed in France by Art & Caractère. and maintain Airbus aircraft. It is also distributed to other
This brochure is printed on Triple Star Satin. selected organisations.
This paper is produced in factories that are
accredited EMAS and certified ISO 9001-14001,
PEFC and FSC CoC. It is produced using pulp Material for publication is obtained from multiple sources
that has been whitened without either chlorine and includes selected information from the Airbus Flight
or acid. The paper is entirely recyclable and is
produced from trees grown in sustainable forest Safety Confidential Reporting System, incident and acci-
resources. dent investigation reports, system tests and flight tests.
The printing inks use organic pigments or
minerals. There is no use of basic dyes or Material is also obtained from sources within the airline
dangerous metals from the cadmium, lead, industry, studies and reports from government agencies
mercury or hexavalent chromium group.
and other aviation sources.
The printer, Art & Caractère (France 81500), is
engaged in a waste management and recycling
programme for all resulting by-products. All articles in Safety first are presented for i­nformation only
and are not intended to replace ICAO guidelines, stand-
ards or recommended practices, operator-mandated
requirements or technical orders. The contents do not
supersede any requirements m ­ and­­ated by the State of
Registry of the Operator’s aircraft or supersede or amend
any Airbus type-specific AFM, AMM, FCOM, MMEL docu-
© Airbus S.A.S. 2015 – All rights reserved.
Proprietary documents.
mentation or any other approved documentation.
By taking delivery of this Brochure
(hereafter “Brochure”), you accept on behalf Articles may be reprinted without permission, except
of your ­company to comply with the following where copyright source is indicated, but with acknowl-
guidelines:
edgement to Airbus. Where Airbus is not the author, the
No other intellectual property rights are granted
by the delivery of this Brochure than the right to contents of the article do not necessarily reflect the views
read it, for the sole purpose of information. of Airbus, neither do they indicate Company policy.
This Brochure and its content shall
not be modified and its illustrations Contributions, comment and feedback are welcome. For
and photos shall not be reproduced without
prior written consent of Airbus. technical reasons the editors may be required to make
This Brochure and the materials it contains editorial changes to manuscripts, however every effort will
shall not, in whole or in part, be sold, rented, or be made to preserve the intended meaning of the original.
licensed to any third party subject to payment.
Enquiries related to this publication should be addressed to:
This Brochure contains sensitive information
that is correct at the time of going to press.
This information involves a number of factors that
could change over time, effecting the true public
representation. Airbus assumes no obligation
to update any information ­contained in this
document or with respect to the information Airbus
described herein.
Product Safety department (GS)
Airbus S.A.S. shall assume no liability for any
damage in connection with the use of this 1, rond point Maurice Bellonte
Brochure and of the materials it contains, even if 31707 Blagnac Cedex - France
Airbus S.A.S. has been advised of the ­likelihood
of such damages. safetycommunication@airbus.com
Fax: +33(0)5 61 93 44 29

Safety first #19 January 2015 - 13/13

You might also like