Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lubricating Oil Basestocks: Product Dossier No. 97/108
Lubricating Oil Basestocks: Product Dossier No. 97/108
97/108
lubricating oil
basestocks
Prepared by CONCAWE’s Petroleum Products and Health Management Groups
CONCAWE
Brussels
June 1997
I
product dossier no. 97/108
ABSTRACT
This dossier summarizes the health, safety and environment data currently available
on lubricating oil basestocks derived from the refining of petroleum.
KEYWORDS
NOTE
Considerable efforts have been made to assure the accuracy and reliability of the
information contained in this publication. However, neither CONCAWE nor any
company participating in CONCAWE can accept liability for any loss, damage or
injury whatsoever resulting from the use of this information.
This report does not necessarily represent the views of any company participating in
CONCAWE.
II
product dossier no. 97/108
CONTENTS
PREFACE V
1. INTRODUCTION 1
2. PRODUCT DESCRIPTION 2
3. TYPICAL PROPERTIES 4
4. TOXICITY 5
5. HEALTH ASPECTS 12
6. EXPOSURE LIMITS 15
7. HANDLING ADVICE 16
III
product dossier no. 97/108
8. EMERGENCY TREATMENT 17
8.1. INHALATION 17
8.2. INGESTION 17
8.3. ASPIRATION 17
8.4. SKIN CONTACT 17
8.5. EYE CONTACT 17
8.6. INJECTION 17
9. DISPOSAL 18
12. REFERENCES 27
APPENDICES
IV
product dossier no. 97/108
PREFACE
− Gasolines
− Kerosines/jet fuels
− Aromatic extracts
− Petroleum coke
− Crude oil
These product dossiers are being prepared by CONCAWE to provide, for each
major product group, comprehensive information covering :
V
product dossier no. 97/108
1. INTRODUCTION
Lubricating oil basestocks are the primary components for various types of marketed
lubricants including engine oils, automotive transmission fluids, hydraulic fluids, gear
oils, metalworking oils, medicinal white oils and greases.
The general term lubricating oil basestocks covers a number of different types of
material including vegetable oils, synthetic oils, mineral oils and re-refined oils. This
dossier only covers mineral oils which are produced from the distillation of crude oil.
In this process, the residue from atmospheric distillation of crude oil is further
distilled under vacuum conditions to produce a range of vacuum distillates. Solvent
extraction and/or hydrofining are then used to increase the viscosity index, enhance
the colour and convert undesirable chemical structures such as unsaturated
hydrocarbons and aromatics to less chemically reactive species. Finally, solvent
dewaxing is used to reduce the wax content of the base oils so as to prevent wax
crystals forming within the normal working temperature range of the lubricant.
Historically, the refining process has included treatment with sulphuric acid and
special earths, but this process has been largely superseded.
The purpose of this dossier is to collate the available health, safety and
environmental data on the range of lubricating oil basestocks produced from crude
oils.
1
product dossier no. 97/108
2. PRODUCT DESCRIPTION
Lubricant basestocks are defined as either light or heavy according to their kinematic
2
viscosities at 40°C. Those having viscosities above 19 mm /s at 40°C are described
as heavy and those below as light.
All crude oils contain polycyclic aromatic compounds (PACs). Some of these,
particularly the 4-6 condensed ring compounds, are known to be carcinogenic. The
content of PACs in base oils is determined mainly by the severity of the refining
process which they have undergone. Mild processing such as acid/earth treatment
reduces the total aromatic content slightly but does not significantly reduce the PAC
content. Mild hydrotreatment, used to enhance oil colour, may, in some instances,
reduce PAC content but has little effect on total aromatics. Severe solvent extraction
or hydrotreatment reduces both PAC and total aromatic content substantially.
Sufficiently severe treatment with oleum or hydrogen can remove aromatic
components, including PACs, almost entirely to produce white oils of medicinal
quality.
2
product dossier no. 97/108
The definitions for the lubricating oil basestocks included in EINECS are given in
Appendices 1-3. The oils included in the appendices have been grouped as follows:
The grouping of these oils was developed in the context of their carcinogenicity
hazard classification. The first group comprises oils which, due to their mild refining
production processes are all considered to be carcinogenic, whilst those in the
second group are so highly refined that they are not carcinogenic. The
carcinogenicity of the oils in the third group depends on the severity of the refining
processes used in their production (see section 4.3.2).
3
product dossier no. 97/108
3. TYPICAL PROPERTIES
The properties of some lubricating oil base stocks are summarised in Table 1.
Distillate oils
Residual oils
White Oils
White mineral oil 27.3 5.0 217 -15 0.86 400
(8042-47-5)
* Kinematic viscosity is often expressed in Centistokes (cSt). It should be noted that throughout this
2 2
dossier the units for kinematic are mm /second (1 mm /s = 1 cSt).
4
product dossier no. 97/108
4. TOXICITY
The references cited identify the original data. It should be noted that summaries of
some of these data have also been published elsewhere and the overall conclusions
have been the same as those given in this review (Beck et al, 1984; Kane et al,
1984).
Table 2: Summary of data on acute systemic toxicity, skin and eye irritation and skin
sensitisation for lubricating oil basestocks
Naphthenic distillates
Solvents refined, light
API 78-5 >5 >5 Slight Non Non API, 1982g
Solvent refined, heavy
API 79-1 >5 >5 Slight Non Non API, 1982a
Hydrotreated light
API 83-12 >5 >2 Irritant Slight Non 33-30592 (API, 1986)
API 83-12 2.18 34-32775 (API, 1987)
Hydrotreated, heavy
API 83-15 >5 >2 Slight Slight Non 33-32639 (API, 1986)
Other mineral oils
White mineral oil
Tufflo 6056 >5 API, 1992
White mineral oil Slight Hoekstra & Phillips, 1963
Paraffin oil Non Carpenter & Smyth, 1946
A space in the table indicates that the data have not been determined
1. Skin and eye irritation described as either slight, moderate or non irritating
2. Skin sensitisation indicated as non-sensitising
5
product dossier no. 97/108
Irrespective of the crude source or refining history, the oral and dermal LD50 values
for the lubricating oil basestocks were greater than the highest doses that had been
administered. The inhalation studies were conducted using aerosols of the test
materials and with the exception of a low viscosity naphthenic oil with an inhalation
LC50 of 2.18 mg/l, the other oils (3 samples) tested had LC50 values in excess of
4 mg/l.
Except for an unrefined oil and a hydrotreated light naphthenic distillate, none of the
other oils tested were more than slightly irritating to the skin in a 24 hour closed
patch test. The unrefined oil was moderately irritating and the low viscosity
hydrotreated light naphthenic oil was irritant in a 24 hour closed patch test. In
another study (Trimmer et al, 1989), six highly refined paraffinic base oils were found
to range from minimal to slightly irritating. In a further study six naphthenic
basestocks were also found to range from non to slightly irritating in a 4 hour
occluded patch test in rabbits (Jones, 1984).
Selected mineral oils, mineral oil fractions and individual hydrocarbons were applied
to shaved guinea pigs on days 1, 3, 5 & 7. The volume applied varied somewhat, but
usually was 0.6 ml/application. The area of the skin exposed to the test material was
not measured, or controlled. The skin was evaluated for erythema, thickening,
hyperkeratinisation, desquamation and fissure formation every other day. Mineral
oils, mineral oil fractions and individual hydrocarbons with boiling points above
350°C caused only minor irritation (Trimmer at al, 1989).
Apart from two oils which caused slight eye irritation, no other tests resulted in
irritation of the eyes following instillation of lubricating oil basestocks (Table 2).
None of the oils tested has been shown to be a skin sensitiser in guinea pigs using a
Beuhler test.
4.2.1. Oral
Studies have only been carried out on food and medicinal grade mineral oils (white
oils). Findings from these studies have been reviewed by Smith et al (1995). In
summary, Beagle dogs and Long Evans rats were fed four highly refined mineral oils
at concentrations of 300 and 1500 ppm (w/w) for 90 days. No toxicological effects
were noted.
mm2/s at 40°C) produced the greatest effects with lesser effects noted with the
intermediate viscosity oils (~70 mm2/s at 40°C) and no effect noted in high viscosity
oils (~100 mm2/s at 40°C). The biological effects seemed to be related to the
molecular size of the hydrocarbon rather than petroleum crude type or method of
refining (CONCAWE, 1993). Studies are ongoing to elucidate the mechanism for the
strain differences to determine the relevance of these findings.
4.2.2. Skin
The data from subacute dermal studies reported for lubricating oil basestocks are
summarised in Table 3. The studies have been carried out in New Zealand white
rabbits for up to 28 days. In most cases dosing was for 3 days per week and dose
levels ranged from 200 mg/kg up to 5 g/kg.
The only consistent finding has been slight skin irritation for many of the oils tested.
Systemic effects have rarely been observed. The only oil which caused systemic
effects was a hydrotreated, heavy naphthenic distillate (API 83-15) which caused
increases in the activities of certain liver enzymes (SGOT and SGPT) in the rabbits
treated at dose levels of 1000 and 2000 mg/kg. Additionally, body weights were
decreased in the 2000 mg/kg animals and this was also associated with a subacute
hepatitis. In the females at this dose level there was also an increase in relative liver
weight (API, 1987a).
Several solvent-refined lubricant base oils were applied to the shaved skin of rats 5
days/week for 13 weeks at dose levels up to 2000 mg/kg. No significant irritation of
skin or effects on body weight gain, haematology, serum chemistry, organ weights,
or histology were seen (Cox and Cruzan, 1986).
4.2.3. Inhalation
7
product dossier no. 97/108
8
product dossier no. 97/108
Carcinogenicity
4.2.4. Oral
No data have been published on the carcinogenicity of lubricating oil base stocks by
the oral route. However limited data are available from an oral carcinogenicity study
with a sample of liquid paraffin. The 70 mm2/s (at 40°C) viscosity liquid paraffin
sample was not carcinogenic in either male or female F 344 rats when administered
in the diet for two years at concentrations of 2.5 and 5%wt (Takahashi, 1996).
4.2.5. Skin
Numerous lifetime skin painting studies have been carried out in mice, and many of
them have been summarised and reviewed elsewhere (IARC, 1984; Bingham et al,
1980; Kane et al, 1984). In addition, hitherto unpublished data have been collected
from individual companies and summarised (CONCAWE, 1994). For details of the
studies which have been carried out and the results obtained, reference should be
made to the papers cited above.
An extremely large database now exists and the following general conclusions can
be drawn.
Many authors have described the oils that they have tested as having undergone
"poor", "mild" or "severe" refining but it has proven difficult to define precisely the
meaning of these terms. For this reason, there has been considerable effort to
develop analytical or other techniques (other than long-term skin painting studies)
which could be used to distinguish between oils which may be carcinogenic from
those which are non-carcinogenic. There are considerable data relating
carcinogenicity to measurements by the DMSO extraction technique using method
IP 346 (CONCAWE, 1994; IP, 1993). This measurement has been adopted by the
EU as a criterion for the classification of base oils for carcinogenicity (EU, 1994;
CONCAWE, 1995).
4.2.6. Inhalation
In their 1986 review of the health aspects of worker exposure to oil mists,
CONCAWE noted that the limited range of materials investigated showed low
chronic toxicity. In addition, no carcinogenic effects had been reported in any of the
animal species studied. Accumulation of oil in the lungs with lipoid granuloma
formation resulted from repeated and prolonged exposure to relatively high levels of
3
oil mist, ie., approximately 100 mg/m (CONCAWE, 1986).
9
product dossier no. 97/108
Compared with other species, primates may accumulate greater quantities of oil in
the lungs, and repeated and prolonged exposure to high levels of oil mist may
enhance an existing tendency to develop infective pneumonia. However, long term
exposures at lower oil mist concentrations more similar to actual workplace levels
have, in general, not caused adverse effects (CONCAWE, 1986).
4.2.7. Other
It was also noted that the intraperitoneal administration of liquid paraffin was
associated with the occurrence of plasma cell tumours, probably arising from the
mesenteric oil granulomas that had formed. Such findings are not considered
relevant to hazard evaluation.
4.3. GENOTOXICITY
Although some early studies of the mutagenicity of mineral base oils found some
relatively potent dermal carcinogens to be inactive, unrefined oils were subsequently
found to be mutagenic using a modified Ames assay (Blackburn et al, 1984). Highly
refined oils have not been found to be mutagenic (McKee & Przygoda, 1987;
Blackburn et al, 1984). The level of mutagenic activity has been shown to be a
reflection of PAC content (Roy et al, 1988).
A range of solvent extracted paraffinic and naphthenic base oils was tested in
mouse lymphoma and bone marrow cytogenetics assays (Conaway et al, 1984). All
seven samples were inactive in the mouse lymphoma and all but one were inactive
in the cytogenetics tests. The clastogenic result with a 72 mm2/s viscosity oil (at
40°C) was inexplicable as similar oils of lower and higher viscosities were inactive.
In another study, solvent extracted paraffinic oils were inactive in mouse lymphoma,
in vitro transformation (McKee & Przygodas, 1987) and micronucleus assays
(McKee et al, 1990).
In their 1987 re-evaluation of mineral oils, IARC reported that "two insulation oils
from highly refined mineral base oils induced morphological transformation in Syrian
hamster embryo cells and showed promoting activity in the C3H 1OT1/2 mouse
embryo fibroblast test" (IARC, 1987). However, examination of the original reference
(Aarsaether et al, 1987) indicates that the oils had been misclassified; they had only
been mildly hydrotreated and not highly refined.
In summary, the preponderance of data indicate that highly refined mineral oils are
not mutagenic either in vitro or in vivo; whilst less well refined base oils show
mutagenic activity in some test systems.
10
product dossier no. 97/108
11
product dossier no. 97/108
5. HEALTH ASPECTS
Very few human data are available on the effect of lubricating oil basestocks. There
is, however a large amount of information on the effects of formulated lubricants in
man. Information given in this section on health effects relates largely to information
from exposure to formulated products.
Provided that excessive skin contact and exposure to high concentrations of oil mist
are avoided, lubricating oils do not present any significant health risks. Activities in
which appreciable exposure is possible, particularly if suitable precautions are
neglected, include metalworking, the maintenance and repair of engines and other
equipment, and the handling of used oils. Manufacture of mineral base oils and
formulated products is usually carried out in closed systems and significant
exposures do not normally occur under these circumstances.
Skin cancer, particularly of the scrotum, has been associated with excessive
exposure to poorly- or unrefined mineral oils together with poor personal hygiene
practices. In their reviews of epidemiological literature, (IARC, 1973; IARC, 1984) the
International Agency of Research on Cancer (IARC) noted:
− Between 1950 and 1967, 187 cases of scrotal cancer occurred in the
Birmingham region of England. At least two-thirds of these cases could be
attributed to exposure to cutting oils.
− Between 1955 and 1970, there were at least 60 cases of scrotal cancer and
many cases of skin cancer in the Savoy Alps in France among bar automatic
machine workers who were in contact with undiluted cutting oil.
− A 1985 report showed that among 682 metal turners exposed to mineral oils for
more than 5 years, five cases of squamous cell carcinoma (four of the scrotum)
occurred although the expected occurrence was virtually zero.
− Exposure to mineral oils was likely to have occurred in 62% of 344 cases of
scrotal cancer occurring between 1936 and 1976.
Other studies have confirmed an association between skin cancer and exposure to
unrefined or mildly treated mineral base oil products. However, as noted by IPCS in
12
product dossier no. 97/108
their criteria document, evaluators of such studies must keep in mind that because
of the long latency period of carcinogenic effects, reported findings may reflect
exposure and hygiene conditions of 20 to 30 years ago. Any increased risks
observed in these studies may not be relevant to evaluating health risks associated
with most recent exposures because: (1) industrial hygiene practices of today are
more stringent than in earlier time periods, and (2) oils used in the workplace today
are mostly highly refined oils, thereby reducing the level of PACs present in the oils.
(IARC, 1984) In fact, in many of these studies, human exposure was to oil derived
from shale and coal and not to mineral oils. These studies are of limited relevance in
assessing the hazards of mineral oils.
In a review of the health aspects of worker exposure to oil mists (CONCAWE, 1986),
it was concluded that available studies have identified adverse health effects only
3
where exposures greatly exceed atmospheric concentrations of 5 mg/m .
Respiratory problems such as chemical pneumonitis and pulmonary fibrosis have
not been reasonably substantiated except where exposure to oil mist has been
massive. There was no evidence of respiratory tract irritation at exposures with
satisfactory workplace hygiene conditions. IPCS also concluded that when oils with
3
low content of PACs are used and the TLV (5 mg/m ) is not exceeded, pulmonary
disease is unlikely to arise.
5.2. INHALATION
Most lubricating oils are insufficiently volatile to present a vapour inhalation hazard
under normal operating conditions. For example, the saturated vapour concentration
for a typical lubricating oil basestock has been calculated to be about 0.015 ppm at
20°C (Sanderson and Eyres, 1980). Even the saturated vapour concentration of 1.4
ppm (calculated to occur at 100°C) is unlikely to give rise to adverse health effects.
However, decomposition of lubricants at high temperatures may result in fumes
which could cause irritation of the respiratory tract.
5.3. INGESTION
Ingestion is an unlikely event with lubricant basestocks except in the case of the
highly refined medicinal white oils.
Ingestion of low viscosity formulated lubricant products can produce irritation of the
mouth, throat and gastrointestinal tract; vomiting, with its consequent risk of
aspiration, commonly occurs. Although oral toxicity of formulated lubricants is
generally low, there is a potential danger with children when, for example, low
viscosity oils are incorrectly stored in the home in containers such as soft drink
bottles.
13
product dossier no. 97/108
5.4. ASPIRATION
There is little risk of aspiration of liquid into lungs with most lubricating oils,
particularly those with viscosities greater than about 15 mm2/s at 40°C. However, oils
with a low viscosity (below about 7 mm2/s at 40°C) do present a significant hazard.
Aspiration of these oils, either directly or as a result of vomiting following ingestion,
could give rise to rapidly developing and potentially fatal chemical pneumonitis.
Short-term occasional skin contact with lubricating oil basestocks is unlikely to cause
any problems. With excessive, repeated, or prolonged exposure, particularly under
conditions of poor personal hygiene, effects such as dry skin, erythema, dermatitis,
oil acne and folliculitis may result. Such contact with products containing mineral
base oils which have not been severely refined may also lead to the development of
warty growths which may ultimately become skin cancers.
Most lubricating base oils cause no more than transient slight irritation to the eyes.
5.7. INJECTION
A potentially serious hazard when formulated lubricating oils are used in high
pressure systems is the possibility, for example as a result of pin hole leaks on
pipework etc., for injection of oil through the skin. This may cause considerable
damage to the underlying tissues which can occur regardless of the formulation
ingredients (See Section 8.6).
14
product dossier no. 97/108
6. EXPOSURE LIMITS
Lubricating oil basestocks are of low volatility, and as a result, exposure to significant
concentrations of vapour is unlikely. No vapour exposure limits have been
established.
The ACGIH documentation (ACGIH, 1991) indicates that these limits apply to oil
mist, but do not apply to vapour. Furthermore, they only apply when there has been
no substantial altering of the composition by heat and/or oxidation. They have been
set mainly on the basis of preventing subjective complaints of discomfort and they
do not apply to lubricants containing significant levels of more hazardous
components or additives. However, the ACGIH TLVs for oil mist are currently under
review (1997).
In a review of the health aspects of worker exposure to oil mists (CONCAWE, 1986)
it was concluded that:
−
3
The ACGIH TLV of 5 mg/m provides an adequate margin of safety for a broad
range of oils recognized as non-carcinogenic and containing additives which, by
virtue of their nature or limited concentrations, are of no significant toxicological
concern;
−
3
The ACGIH TLV of 5 mg/m may not be applicable to products containing
lighter oils, oils containing additives or oils used as emulsions;
15
product dossier no. 97/108
7. HANDLING ADVICE
− management and supervision of the control measures to ensure that they are
used;
16
product dossier no. 97/108
8. EMERGENCY TREATMENT
The first aid emergency treatment for a casualty who has been over-exposed to
lubricating oil has been summarised elsewhere (CONCAWE, 1997). It is as given
below.
8.1. INHALATION
In case of exposure remove the casualty to fresh air and if recovery is not
immediate, obtain medical advice.
8.2. INGESTION
In the case of ingestion do not induce vomiting but obtain medical attention
immediately.
8.3. ASPIRATION
If there is any suspicion of aspiration into the lungs either directly or as a result of
vomiting, obtain medical advice.
Some industrial oils may be used at very high temperatures and severe burns can
result in the event of an accident.
If the eyes are affected, irrigate them immediately with copious amounts of water. If
irritation occurs and persists, obtain medical advice.
8.6. INJECTION
When using high pressure equipment, injection under the skin can occur. If this has
happened the casualty should be sent immediately to a hospital. Even when there
are few or no symptoms, do not hesitate to refer to a hospital.
17
product dossier no. 97/108
9. DISPOSAL
Formulated lubricants and used oils are outside the scope of this report. However,
for information on this issue, the subject of collection, regeneration and disposal of
waste oils has been recently reviewed (CONCAWE, 1996a).
18
product dossier no. 97/108
The majority of lubricating oil basestocks have high flash points and are of low
volatility; therefore, fire and explosion hazards are minimal. This may not be the case
when lower boiling components in formulated lubricants may be included, for
example two stroke engine oils diluted with kerosine.
19
product dossier no. 97/108
• Ready tests are more stringent (ie they give the lowest % biodegradation)
• Of the ready tests, the highest numbers are obtained with the modified
Sturm test
• Across all the test methods, the ranking order for biodegradability of
different lubricating oil basestocks is similar
It is apparent that the extent of biodegradation recorded for a particular lubricating oil
basestock is dependent on the test procedure used. It has been shown that the
presentation of the sample in a biodegradation test is important and the use of
solvents, surfactants or inert carriers (e.g. glass fibre filter papers) can significantly
affect the results obtained. The incorporation of carbon from base oils in the creation
of new biomass cells has been studied (CONCAWE, 1996b) and it was concluded
that this was not a significant loss process in biodegradation studies.
20
product dossier no. 97/108
21
product dossier no. 97/108
Whatever the method of presentation, lubricant base oils are not readily
biodegradable in standard 28-day tests, but since they consist primarily of
hydrocarbons which are ultimately assimilated by micro-organisms, they are
considered to be inherently biodegradable. A test procedure involving an adaptive
phase and based on an ISO headspace method (ISO, 1996) is being developed by
the oil industry (CONCAWE, 1996c) with the objective of enabling the demonstration
of the inherent biodegradability of oil products.
11.2. BIOACCUMULATION
22
product dossier no. 97/108
The constituent hydrocarbons of lubricating oil basestocks typically have very low
water solubility, high molecular weight and are believed not to be significantly
accumulated. There are no data to indicate that lubricating oil basestocks are
significantly bioaccumulated by aquatic organisms.
11.3. ECOTOXICITY
Both acute and chronic ecotoxicity studies have been carried out on base oils using
either the lethal loading/water accommodated fraction (WAF) approach
(CONCAWE, 1992) or oil in water dispersions.
Acute toxicity
The available acute toxicity data for fish, invertebrates and algae are summarised in
Table 5. The loading rate results indicate that the acute aquatic toxicities to fish,
Daphnia, Ceriodaphnia and algal species are above 1000 mg/l using either water
accommodated fractions or oil in water dispersions. These results are predictable
from the known compositions of the base oils studied and the reported acute
toxicities of homologous series of hydrocarbons (Adema, 1986 and 1991).
23
product dossier no. 97/108
Hydrotreated, light 64742-55-8 Fish (O. mykiss) OWD LL50, 96h >5,000 Barbieri et al,
paraffinic distillate 1993
Solvent-dewaxed, 64742-65-0 Fish (O. mykiss) OWD LL50, 96h >5,000 Barbieri et al,
heavy paraffinic 1993
distillate
Hydrotreated, heavy 64742-54-7 Fish (O. mykiss) OWD LL50, 96h >5,000 Barbieri et al,
paraffinic distillate 1993
Solvent-refined, heavy 64741-96-4 Fish (O. mykiss) OWD LL50, 96h >5,000 Barbieri et al,
naphthenic distillate 1993
Solvent-dewaxed 64742-62-7 Fish (O. mykiss) OWD LL50, 96h >5,000 Barbieri et al,
residual oil 1993
Solvent-refined, light 64741-89-5 Fish (O. mykiss) OWD LL50, 96h >1,000 BP, 1990-91
paraffinic distillate
Hydrocracked, solvent- 9748873-8 Fish (O. mykiss) OWD LL50, 96h >1,000 BP, 1990-91
refined light distillate
Solvent-refined, heavy 64741-88-4 Fish (O. mykiss) OWD LL50, 96h >1,000 BP, 1990-91
paraffinic distillate
Solvent-refined, 64742-01-4 Fish (O. mykiss) OWD LL50, 96h >1,000 BP, 1990-91
residual oil
Solvent-deasphalted, 64741-95-3 Fish (O. mykiss) OWD LL50, 96h >1,000 BP, 1990-91
residual oil
White mineral oil 8042-47-5 Fish (Lepomis OWD LL50, 96h >10,000 Mobil,
macrochirus) 1984-91
Solvent-refined, light 64741-89-5 Alga (Scenedesmus WAF IrL50, 96 h >1,000 BP, 1991a
paraffinic distillate subspicatus) IbL50, 96 h >1,000
Solvent-refined, heavy 64741-88-4 Alga (Scenedesmus WAF IrL50, 96 h >1,000 BP, 1991b
paraffinic distillate subspicatus) IbL50, 96 h >1,000
Solvent-refined, heavy 64741-88-4 Alga (Scenedesmus WAF IrL50, 96 h >1,000 BP, 1991c
paraffinic distillate subspicatus) IbL50, 96 h >1,000
Similarly for alkylbenzenes (Adema, 1991), those materials having carbon numbers
of C15 and above were too water insoluble to cause acute toxicity. Since lubricant
base oils mainly contain hydrocarbons having carbon numbers in the range C15 to
C50, it is predictable from the work of Adema that acute toxicity would not be
observed with these substances.
The available data from algal studies (BP, 1996a) indicate that lubricant base oils
are not acutely toxic, an observation that aligns with the data for hydrocarbons
derived from quantitative structure activity relationships (QSARs) (European
Commission, 1996), and results of studies with other aquatic species.
Chronic toxicity
The available chronic toxicity data for both fish and invertebrates are summarised in
Table 6. The results show that the no observed effect level (NOEL) usually exceeds
1000 mg/l for lubricant base oils. For one study (Shell Research, 1994) carried out
with a hydrotreated light naphthenic distillate (CAS No. 64742-53-6), tests were run
at two loading rates viz 1000 and 1 mg/l and toxicity was observed at the upper but
not the lower level. However, this is an exception and the weight of experimental
evidence leads to the conclusion that lubricant base oils do not cause chronic toxicity
to fish and invertebrates.
It is to be noted that the spillage of large volumes of lubricant base oils into water will
result in films of undissolved oil on the surface and this will cause direct physical
fouling of organisms and may interfere with surface air exchange resulting in lower
levels of dissolved oxygen. Petroleum products have also been associated with
causing taint in fish even when the latter are caught in lightly contaminated
environments.
Few published data are available in the open literature on the effects of lubricating oil
basestocks on terrestrial organisms. However, much of the data from studies of the
human health effects of base oils are relevant to the assessment of hazards to
environmental species.
Direct fouling of aquatic mammals and sea birds may result from exposure to
floating base oil following a spill into water. Highly refined base oils sprayed onto the
surface of eggs, either early or late during incubation, has been proposed as a
method for controlling goose numbers; fully coated eggs fail to hatch (Christens et
al, 1995).
Toxicity to plants
Lubricating oil basestocks are used both alone and as components of many crop
protection products, where according to application, they contribute to the control of
both weeds and pests in economic crops. Extensive experience from laboratory and
field trials in a wide range of crops has confirmed that either aerosol exposure or
direct application of oil emulsion to the leaves of crop plants produces little or no
damage (Beattie et al 1995).
Studies of the effects of base oils incorporated into soil on seed generation and plant
development have demonstrated evidence of little or no adverse effect at
contamination rates up to 4% (Ahlf and Gunkel, 1992).
25
product dossier no. 97/108
Solvent-dewaxed, heavy 64742-65-0 OECD 202, D. magna Reproduction/ >1,000 Shell Research, 1994
paraffinic distillate Part II, WAF survival
Solvent-dewaxed, heavy 64742-65-0 EPA 1002.0 C. dubia Reproduction/ >5,000 Barbieri et al, 1993
paraffinic distillate WAF survival
Solvent-dewaxed, heavy 64742-65-0 EPA 1000.0 Fish Reproduction/ >5,000 Barbieri et al, 1993
paraffinic distillate OWD (P. promelas) survival
Hydrotreated, light 64742-55-8 OECD 202, D. magna Reproduction/ >1,000 Shell Research, 1994
paraffinic distillate Part II, WAF survival Barbieri et al, 1993
Hydrotreated, light 64742-55-8 EPA 1002.0 C. dubia Reproduction/ 550 Barbieri et al, 1993
paraffinic distillate WAF survival
Hydrotreated, light 64742-55-8 EPA 1000.0 Fish Reproduction/ >5,000 Barbieri et al, 1993
paraffinic distillate OWD (P. promelas) survival
Solvent-refined, heavy 64741-88-4 OECD 202, D. magna Reproduction/ >1,000 Shell Research, 1994
paraffinic distillate Part II, WAF survival BP, 1995a
BP, 1995b
BP, 1995c
Hydrotreated, light 64742-53-6 OECD 202, D. magna Reproduction/ >1 Shell Research, 1994
naphthenic distillate Part II, WAF survival
Hydrotreated, heavy 64742-54-7 EPA 1002.0 C. dubia Reproduction/ >5,000 Barbieri et al, 1993
paraffinic distillate WAF survival
Hydrotreated, heavy 64742-54-7 EPA 1000.0 Fish Reproduction/ >1,000 Barbieri et al, 1993
paraffinic distillate OWD (P. promelas) survival
Solvent-refined, heavy 64741-96-4 EPA 1002.0 C. dubia Reproduction/ >5,000 Shell Research, 1994
naphthenic distillate WAF survival
Solvent-dewaxed 64742-62-7 EPA 1002.0 C. dubia Reproduction/ >5,000 Shell Research, 1994
residual oil WAF survival
Solvent-refined, light 64741-89-5 OECD 202, D. magna Reproduction/ >1,000 BP, 1995d
paraffinic distillate Part II, WAF survival BP, 1995e
26
product dossier no. 97/108
12. REFERENCES
ACGIH (1991) Documentation of the threshold limit values and biological exposure
indicies - 6th edition. Cincinnati OH: American Conference of Governmental
Industrial Hygienists
ACGIH (1996) Threshold limit values (TLVs) for chemical substances and physical
agents and biological exposure indicies (BEIs). Cincinnati OH: American Conference
of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
Adema, D.M.M. (1991) The acute aquatic toxicity of alkylbenzenes. Progress report
no. 1 for 1990 and 1991 from TNO to the Dutch Ministry of Housing, Physical
Planning and Environment. Report no. 91/198. Delft: TNO
Adema, D.M.M. and van den Bos Bakker, G.H. (1986) Aquatic toxicity of compounds
that may be carried by ships (Marpol 1973, Annex II) - a progress report for 1986
from TNO to the Dutch Ministry of Housing, Physical Planning and Environment.
Report no. 86/326a. Delft: TNO
API (1982a) Acute toxicity tests of API sample 79-1 naphthenic oil (90 SUS/210°F).
Study conducted by Elars Bioresearch Laboratories Inc. API Med. Res. Publ. 29-
33065. Washington DC: American Petroleum Institute
API (1982b) Acute toxicity tests of API sample 79-4 paraffinic oil (550 SUS/100°F).
Study conducted by Elars Bioresearch Laboratories Inc. API Med. Res. Publ. 29-
33066. Washington DC: American Petroleum Institute
API (1982c) Acute toxicity tests of API sample 79-3 paraffinic oil (350 SUS/100°F).
Study conducted by Elars Bioresearch Laboratories Inc. API Med. Res. Publ. 29-
33067. Washington DC: American Petroleum Institute
API (1982d) Acute toxicity tests of API sample 79-5 paraffinic oil (800 SUS/100°F).
Study conducted by Elars Bioresearch Laboratories Inc. API Med. Res. Publ. 29-
33068. Washington DC: American Petroleum Institute
API (1982e) Acute toxicity tests of API sample 78-9 paraffinic oil (70 SUS/100°F).
Study conducted by Elars Bioresearch Laboratories Inc. API Med. Res. Publ. 29-
33104. Washington DC: American Petroleum Institute
API (1982f) Acute toxicity tests of API sample 78-10 paraffinic oil (150 SUS/100°F).
Study conducted by Elars Bioresearch Laboratories Inc. API Med. Res. Publ. 29-
33105. Washington DC: American Petroleum Institute
27
product dossier no. 97/108
API (1982g) Acute toxicity tests of API sample 78-5 naphthenic oil (150 SUS/100°F).
Study conducted by Elars Bioresearch Laboratories Inc. API Med. Res. Publ. 29-
33106. Washington DC: American Petroleum Institute
API (1986a) 28-Day dermal toxicity study in the rabbit. API sample 83-12
hydrotreated light naphthenic distillate (CAS 64742-53-6). Study conducted by
Tegeris Laboratories Inc. API Health Environ. Sci. Dep. Rep. 33-30499. Washington
DC: American Petroleum Institute
API (1986b) Acute oral toxicity study in rats. Acute dermal toxicity study in rabbits.
Primary dermal irritation study in rabbits. Primary eye irritation study in rabbits.
Dermal sensitization study in guinea pigs. API sample 83-12 hydrotreated light
naphthenic distillate (CAS 64742-53-6). Study conducted by Hazleton Laboratories
America Inc. API Health Environ. Sci. Dep. Rep. 33-30592. Washington DC:
American Petroleum Institute
API (1986c) Acute oral toxicity study in rats. Acute dermal toxicity study in rabbits.
Primary dermal irritation study in rabbits. Primary eye irritation study in rabbits.
Dermal sensitization study in guinea pigs. API sample 84-01 light paraffinic distillate
(CAS 64741-50-0). Study conducted by Hazleton Laboratories America Inc. API
Health Environ. Sci. Dep. Rep. 33-30595. Washington DC: American Petroleum
Institute
API (1986d) 28-Day dermal toxicity study in the rabbit. API sample 84-01 light
paraffinic distillate (CAS 64741-50-0). Study conducted by Tegeris Laboratories Inc.
API Health Environ. Sci. Dep. Rep. 33-31642. Washington DC: American Petroleum
Institute
API (1986e) Acute oral toxicity study in rats. Acute dermal toxicity study in rabbits.
Primary dermal irritation study in rabbits. Primary eye irritation study in rabbits.
Dermal sensitization study in guinea pigs. API sample 83-15 hydrotreated heavy
naphthenic distillate (CAS 64742-52-5). Study conducted by Hazleton Laboratories
America Inc. API Health Environ. Sci. Dep. Rep. 33-32639. Washington DC:
American Petroleum Institute
API (1987a) 28-Day dermal toxicity study in the rabbit. API sample 83-15
hydrotreated heavy naphthenic distillate (CAS 64742-52-5). API Health Environ. Sci.
Dep. Rep. 35-32430. Washington DC: American Petroleum Institute
API (1992) Mineral oil review. API Health Environ. Sci. Dep. Rep. 39-31651.
Washington DC: American Petroleum Institute
28
product dossier no. 97/108
Baldwin, M.K. et al (1992) Feeding studies in rats with mineral hydrocarbon food
grade white oils. Toxicol Pathol 20, 3 (part 1), 426-435
Barbieri, J.F. et al (1993) Acute and chronic toxicity of petroleum base stocks to
aquatic organisms. Paper presented at the 14th annual meeting of the Society of
Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, November 14-18, 1993, Houston TX
Beck, L.S. et al (1984) The acute toxicology of selected petroleum hydrocarbons. In:
MacFarland, H.N. et al (Eds). Advances in modern environmental toxicology.
Volume VI: Applied toxicology of hydrocarbons, p. 1-16. Princeton NJ: Princeton
Scientific Publishers
29
product dossier no. 97/108
BP (1996a) BP Oil algal toxicity data for base oils. Summary of results for studies
conducted by Safepharm Laboratories Ltd. Sunbury: BP Oil Technology Centre
BP (1996b) BP Oil aquatic toxicity data for base oils. Summary of results for studies
conducted by Safepharm Laboratories Ltd. Sunbury: BP Oil Technology Centre
Bridie, A.L. and Bos, J. (1971) Biological degradation of mineral oil in sea water. J
Inst Petrol 57, 557, 270-277
Carpenter, Ch.P. and Smyth, H.F. (1946) Chemical burns of the rabbit cornea. Am J
Ophthal 29, 1363-1372
CONCAWE (1986) Health aspects of worker exposure to oil mists. Report No.
86/69. Brussels: CONCAWE
30
product dossier no. 97/108
CONCAWE (1993) White oil and waxes - summary of 90-day studies. Report No.
93/56. Brussels: CONCAWE
CONCAWE (1994) The use of the dimethyl sulphoxide (DMSO) extract by the IP
346 method as an indicator of the carcinogenicity of lubricant base oils and distillate
aromatic extracts. Report No. 94/51. Brussels: CONCAWE
CONCAWE (1996a) Collection and disposal of used lubricating oil. Report No. 5/96.
Brussels: CONCAWE
CONCAWE (1997) Petroleum products - first aid emergency and medical advice.
Report No.1/97. Brussels: CONCAWE
Cox, G.E. and Cruzan, G. (1986) Thirteen-week toxicity study by dermal application
of petroleum stocks to rats. Toxicologist 6, 1, 240
31
product dossier no. 97/108
Hoekstra, W.G. and Phillips, P.H. (1963) Effects of topically applied mineral oil
fractions on the skin of guinea-pigs. J Invest Dermatology 40, 2, 79-88
ISO (1996) Water quality - Evaluation in an aqueous medium of the ultimate aerobic
biodegradability of organic compounds - method by analysis of released inorganic
carbon in sealed vessels. Geneva: International Organisation for Standardisation,
ISO / CD 14593
Jones, J.R. (1984) 17 base oils coded A to Q: primary skin irritation and corrosivity
studies in the rabbit. Report No. 3878-540/4-20. North Yorkshire, UK: Hazleton
Laboratories Europe Ltd.
32
product dossier no. 97/108
McKee, R.H. and Przygoda, R.T. (1987) The genotoxic and carcinogenic potential of
engine oils and highly refined lubricating oils. Environ Mutag 9, Suppl. 7, 72
McKee, R.H. et al (1987b) Developmental toxicity of EDS recycle solvent and fuel oil.
Toxicol 46, 205-215
Mobil (1984-1991) In-house company data. Princeton NJ: Mobil Oil Corporation
MRC (1968) The carcinogenic action of mineral oils: a chemical and biological study.
London: HMSO
Sanderson, J.T. and Eyres, A.R. (1980) Health hazards from mineral oil. In: Harvey,
B. et al (Eds). Handbook of occupational hygiene. Kingston-upon-Thames, UK:
Croner Publications Ltd.
33
product dossier no. 97/108
Smith, J.H. et al (1995) Subchronic feeding study of four white mineral oils in dogs
and rats. Drug Chem Toxicol 18, 1, 83-103
Smith, J.H. et al (1996) Ninety-day feeding study in Fisher-344 rats of highly refined
petroleum-derived food-grade white oils and waxes. Toxicol Pathol 24, 2, 214-230
Trimmer, G.W. et al (1989) Evaluation of the dermal toxicity of paraffinic lube oils.
Toxicologist 9, 162
Werner, A.F. and Kimerle, R.A. (1982) Uptake and distribution of C12 alkylbenzene
in bluegill (Lepomis macrochirus). Environ Toxicol and Chem 1, 143-146
Whitman, F.T. et al (1989) Evaluation of the acute and subacute inhalation toxicity of
lubricating oil mists. The Toxicologist 9, 1, 143
34
product dossier no. 97/108
APPENDIX 1
265-051-5 64741-50-0
265-052-0 64741-51-1
265-053-6 64741-52-2
265-054-1 64741-53-3
35
product dossier no. 97/108
265-117-3 64742-18-3
265-118-9 64742-19-4
265-119-4 64742-20-7
265-121-5 64742-21-8
265-127-8 64742-27-4
265-128-3 64742-28-5
36
product dossier no. 97/108
265-135-1 64742-34-3
265-136-7 64742-35-4
37
product dossier no. 97/108
APPENDIX 2
232-455-8 8042-47-5
276-735-8 72623-83-7
295-425-3 92045-44-8
295-426-9 92045-45-9
295-550-3 92062-35-6
38
product dossier no. 97/108
APPENDIX 3
265-077-7 64741-76-0
265-090-8 64741-88-4
265-091-3 64741-89-5
265-096-0 64741-95-3
265-097-6 64741-96-4
39
product dossier no. 97/108
265-098-1 64741-97-5
265-101-6 64742-01-4
265-137-2 64742-36-5
265-138-8 64742-37-6
265-143-5 64742-41-2
40
product dossier no. 97/108
265-146-1 64742-44-5
265-147-7 64742-45-6
265-155-0 64742-52-5
265-156-6 64742-53-6
265-157-1 64742-54-7
41
product dossier no. 97/108
265-158-7 64742-55-8
265-159-2 64742-56-9
265-160-8 64742-57-0
265-166-0 64742-62-7
265-167-6 64742-63-8
42
product dossier no. 97/108
265-168-1 64742-64-9
265-169-7 64742-65-0
265-172-3 64742-68-3
265-173-9 64742-69-4
265-174-4 64742-70-7
43
product dossier no. 97/108
265-176-5 64742-71-8
265-179-1 64742-75-2
265-180-7 64742-76-3
276-736-3 72623-85-9
276-737-9 72623-86-0
44
product dossier no. 97/108
276-738-4 72623-87-1
278-012-2 74869-22-0
Lubricating oils
292-613-7 90640-91-8
292-614-2 90640-92-9
292-616-3 90640-94-1
45
product dossier no. 97/108
292-617-9 90640-95-2
292-618-4 90640-96-3
292-620-5 90640-97-4
292-656-1 90669-74-2
294-843-3 91770-57-9
295-300-3 91995-39-0
295-301-9 91995-40-3
46
product dossier no. 97/108
295-306-6 91995-45-8
295-316-0 91995-54-9
295-423-2 92045-42-6
295-424-8 92045-43-7
295-499-7 92061-86-4
295-810-6 92129-09-4
297-474-6 93572-43-1
297-857-8 93763-38-3
47
product dossier no. 97/108
300-257-1 93924-61-9
305-588-5 94733-08-1
305-589-0 94733-09-2
305-594-8 94733-15-0
305-595-3 94733-16-1
305-971-7 95371-04-3
305-972-2 95371-05-4
305-974-3 95371-07-6
305-975-9 95371-08-7
48
product dossier no. 97/108
307-010-7 97488-73-8
307-011-2 97488-74-9
307-034-8 97488-95-4
307-661-7 97675-87-1
307-755-8 97722-06-0
307-758-4 97722-09-3
49
product dossier no. 97/108
307-760-5 97722-10-6
308-131-8 97862-81-2
308-132-3 97862-82-3
308-133-9 97862-83-4
308-287-7 97926-68-6
308-289-8 97926-70-0
308-290-3 97926-71-1
309-710-8 100684-37-5
309-711-3 100684-38-6
50
product dossier no. 97/108
309-874-0 101316-69-2
309-875-6 101316-70-5
309-876-1 101316-71-6
309-877-7 101316-72-7
51