Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Spirituality of Staff Nurses: Application of Modeling and Role Modeling Theory
Spirituality of Staff Nurses: Application of Modeling and Role Modeling Theory
This qualitative study examines the spiritual needs of staff nurses. Focus group participants discussed “care of the
patient” and “care of self.” We use theory to argue that self-care is essential for the care of both nurses and
patients, and spirituality is the foundation of nurses’ work. KEY WORDS: meaning and purpose, model and role
modeling theory, nurse, self-care, spirituality Holist Nurs Pract 2013;27(1):37–44
Nurse’s work is spiritual in nature.1 Nurses touch requirements. Yet, the spiritual needs of the practicing
patient’s lives during many significant moments: the nurse are not typically evaluated or addressed. And all
birth of a child, the experience of acute and chronic attempts at surveying nurses’ spiritual needs alert us
pain, and the loss of life; yet, little is known about the of the research gap in this area.6
spirituality of staff nurses. The purpose of this article
is to explore the meaning and purpose of spirituality in
the work environment of staff nurses.
Defining spirituality is no easy task. There are a LITERATURE REVIEW
plethora of definitions of spirituality in the nursing
literature.1,2 For purposes of this study, we describe Literature reveals survey methods have been used to
spirituality as the pursuit of meaning and purpose in examine spiritual practices of nurses. The results of a
life and the shared interconnections with the world, survey by McSherry and Jamieson9 found that nurses
with a Higher Power, and with other persons who desired more spiritual support of their work. The
share this world. It can also, but not always, be survey of practicing nurses by Grant et al10 found
transcendence to another level of being.3 many instances of spirituality in nurse’s work; yet,
The nursing literature is steeped in methods nurses there is little opportunity for nurses to discuss and
can use to provide spiritual care for their patients.4,5 expound on their own spirituality. In this survey, one
However, there is a lack of information regarding nurse described a patient situation in which the patient
ways nurses might nourish and enhance their own discussed his thoughts and feelings as he approached
spirituality.6 Jackson7 and McEwan8 state that if death. The nurse described this emotional experience
nurses are not aware of their own spiritual needs, they as spiritual, yet there was little opportunity for the
will not be able to provide for the spiritual desires of nurse to process or share these experiences with
their patients. If we accept the fact that nursing is others. During the hectic pace of the staff nurse, there
spiritual in nature, we need also accept that nurses is rarely time to share meaningful moments and
have a need for continued sustenance of their spiritual process what implications such moments might have
in the nurse’s work life.
Yang and Mao6 believe nurses must first have an
Author Affiliations: Northern Illinois University School of Nursing and
Health Studies, DeKalb, Illinois. awareness of their own spirituality before they can
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
deliver spiritual care to their patients. Exploring
spirituality is a journey that takes time and effort and
The author thanks Judith Hertz, an expert consultant, and Ellen Schultz for
reviewing the article for accuracy of MRMT content. nurses need to take time to cultivate their own
Correspondence: Mary Elaine Koren, PhD, RN, Northern Illinois Univer-
spirituality for this journey and care for themselves.
sity School of Nursing and Health Studies, 1240, Normal Rd, DeKalb, IL What we have learned from this review of the nursing
60115 (mkoren@niu.edu). literature is there is an abundance of information
DOI: 10.1097/HNP.0b013e318276fc38 regarding how nurses assess and implement nursing
37
Copyright © 2013 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
38 HOLISTIC NURSING PRACTICE • JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2013
Copyright © 2013 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Spirituality of Staff Nurses 39
nursing care will assist in the development of support hospital. Nurses who were interested in participating
systems that directly nurture nurses’ needs. The in the study were asked to contact the primary
specific objectives of this study, therefore, were to investigator. Once a group of 4 to 6 nurses indicated a
(a) identify the spiritual needs of nurses, (b) desire to participate in the study, a mutually agreeable
understand how nurses experience and use spirituality time was established where we met with the
in their daily work practice, and (c) identify participants in a private room. At that time, the nurses
facilitators and barriers to supporting the spirituality were asked to sign a consent form and invited to join
of the practicing nurse. the focus group discussion. All discussions were
audio-recorded. One investigator facilitated the focus
group discussion while the other helped with the
METHODS logistics of the meeting and noted all nonverbal
behaviors. We asked each focus group broad
Design questions related to spirituality (see the
Appendix).
We used a descriptive qualitative research design14 to
study staff nurses in an acute inpatient setting. Data
were collected via focus groups of staff nurses. Focus
groups allowed us to collect in-depth information
about participants’ spiritual needs as well as DATA ANALYSIS
facilitators and barriers of spirituality in the Data were professionally transcribed into Word
workplace. The merit of this method centers on the documents verbatim from the audio-recorded sessions.
interactions among focus group participants as they We coded separately and then exchanged and
share their experiences and discuss their practices with discussed themes and categories. We performed a
other focus group participants.15 content analysis of the data to analyzed themes that
emerged from the focus groups transcripts. We used a
Setting and sample constant comparative methodology to develop and
Data were collected from a 400-bed suburban refine categories, common themes, critical exceptions,
community hospital located outside a large and relationships across categories and themes.16,17
metropolitan area. Eleven nurses, 5 in one focus group Once we had preliminary themes and categories, we
and 6 in the second focus group participated in the solicited the advice of an expert consultant to help
study. All the nurses were female and all but 2 were finalize the themes. The expert consultant has written
married. The majority (n = 7) of participants ranged and lectured extensively on the theory of MRMT.
in the age from 36 to 55 years and reported either a After this consultation, we continued with the
bachelor’s degree (n = 8) or associate’s degree in constant comparative method by reviewing the
nursing (n = 2). One nurse reported no religious data anew and reflecting on possible new
preference; the others reported various Christian themes.
denominations (5 Catholics, 5 Protestants). Although We kept an audit trail of discussions, resolutions of
every attempt was made to recruit from various disagreements, and suggestions. An audit trail is an
clinical units, 8 of the nurses worked on an orthopedic organized collection of materials that attests to
and neurology unit, 1 nurse worked in labor and the generation of findings because it maintains
delivery, 3 worked on an oncology unit, and 1 worked records of procedures followed during the
in women’s health. analysis.
Last, we shared preliminary themes and categories
Procedures with a group of graduate nursing students (n = 16) in
the context of a research methodology class to solicit
Institutional review board approval was obtained from feedback and member checking. This process of
both the academic institution and the participating validation, discussion, and possible disagreement is
hospital. Recruitment and focus group facilitation took important in qualitative analyses for the accurate
place as follows. Flyers with a description of the description of complex phenomena such as
research and the name and contact number were understanding the experience of spirituality of staff
posted on all hospital units of the participating nurses.
Copyright © 2013 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
40 HOLISTIC NURSING PRACTICE • JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2013
Copyright © 2013 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Spirituality of Staff Nurses 41
An example of an external resource would be mobile “And I think we all want to emotionally and
phones provided to nurses during working hours. The spiritually [be there] for our patients but sometimes
nurses discussed the external resources in the hospital we really need someone to give to us.”
work environment that enhanced quality patient care. “I need 5 minutes of somebody.”
The nurses described “hot topics.” These are
discussion points relevant to nursing care, provided to “I think it would be great if we were vulnerable with
one another and say, you know what, I’m really not
employees during the lunch hour. handling this well.”
“[We had] a hot topic and it was yoga. And it was an
instructor from [place] came over and do their hot “It was very important that staff nurses felt like there
topic lunch and they do a yoga session.” was support from both their peers and management. It
was important that someone was consistently
Yet, another nurse described a ceremony in which available to back them up.”
her hands were blessed.
The nurses said chaplains did provide needed
“I think one of the things that really touched my heart support for patients and families; however, the staff
this year . . . We had the chaplain bless the hand of the nurses felt the chaplains could also offer support to
nurse.”
them.
Nurses week, a week devoted to the recognition of
“I think that I would like more connections with the
staff nurses, was another positive aspect in the work Chaplain staff. Just to come by and say ‘How is
life of these nurses. everybody doing? Is there anything that we can do for
“The nurse’s week is really wonderful, a reflected you?’ Give me an extra boost to get through a difficult
kind of the work we do . . . different events like taking night or difficult situation or a difficult patient. I wish
time to take care of yourselves . . . massages . . . there was more.”
Avon.”
One nurse commented on how helpful the memorial
service was. DISCUSSION
“I know also they have the memorial service for the The nurses in this study described how they
patients that have passed. They’re very supportive on
experienced spirituality or found meaning and purpose
that.”
through the work they performed as a nurse, such as
Several of the nurses were involved in debriefings through their nurse-patient relationships and the
and perceived those as helpful. caring moments during patient care. These findings
“I like those debriefings. I have been to them in the are congruent with other recent studies such as
past. They have spiritual guidance.” Vouzavali et al18 hermeneutic exploration of the
relationship between 12 intensive care nurses and their
External resources (Barriers) patients. The subjects in this study described how
The nurses suggested persons and things, external those relationships provided profound meaning and
resources, they felt could improve the work purpose in their work. The surgical nurses in the
environment and provide avenues of self-care. phenomenological study of Jangland et al19 described
“I think something I would love to see is more how nurses empower and encourage patients to
organizational presence somehow support of us.” participate in their own care, by establishing a
meaningful relationship with patients. Finally,
One of the nurses noted it would be helpful if there
Miner-William’s20 findings tell us that through the
was some type of social network that was available
nurse-patient relationship nurses demonstrate caring
online to staff nurses only.
for the patient and meaning and purpose in their
“ . . . trying to see if we can put up like a social practice.
network you can only access it only from with[in] The nurses’ description of caring for the patient
these walls, pretty much.”
closely reflects Watson’s Theory of Caring. Watson
Many of the nurses talked about the need to discuss states as follows:
daily issues with other staff nurses.
It is when we include caring and love in our science,
“You need to distress. You just need to dump it once a we discover our caring-healing professions and
week.” disciplines are much more than a detached scientific
Copyright © 2013 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
42 HOLISTIC NURSING PRACTICE • JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2013
Copyright © 2013 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Spirituality of Staff Nurses 43
Copyright © 2013 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
44 HOLISTIC NURSING PRACTICE • JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2013
Copyright © 2013 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.