Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sentence THE: Time Perspective
Sentence THE: Time Perspective
Sentence THE: Time Perspective
DIAGNOSIS OF PERSONALITY
MORRIS I. STEIN
C h u a l Psychologist, Mental Hygiene S e m b of the Ray Clinic, N e w York
Rrgioml Ofice, Veterans Administration
The Sentence Completion Test de- level was affected by stress and frustra-
scribed in this paper was developed in tion. (h) Time Perspective: a candi-
the Office of Strategic Services Assess- date’s attitude toward the past, present,
ment Program under the direction of and future. ( i ) Reactions to Others:
Murray and MacKinnon(1). There it a candidate’s attitudes towards his in-
proved so valuable that it is being feriors, his equals, and his superiors.
adopted for extensive use in the Veter- ( j ) Reactions of Others to the Cundi-
ans Administration. The purpose of date: a candidate’s impression of how
this projective test as used in 0. S. S. others felt towards him.
was to provide interviewers with a body From an earlier version of the test
of data which when analyzed would many of the items were derived that are
yield brief descriptions of the personafi- included in the version presented in this
ties of the candidates. paper. Of this earlier form, 25 records
were studied, and the words or phrases
DESCRIPTION
OF THE TEST used to complete each of the 100 incom-
The Sentence Completion Test con- plete sentences were tabulated. If the
sists of two parts each of 50 incomplete range of answers to any one of the sen-
sentences. The incomplete sentences tences was small (i.e., 50% to 75% of
were selected to contribute relevant in- the answers being the same), then that
formation to one of the ten areas that item was said to have a high index of
were considered important for personal- stereotypy. On the other hand if the
ity evaluation. The ten areas included : range was large, few answers being
(a) Family : the candidate’s attitude alike, then that item was said to have a
toward the family unit and toward each high index of individuality. In con-
parent. ( b ) Past: the candidate’s atti- structing the present form of the test,
tude toward the past, his reactions to items which had a high index of stereo-
previous frustrations and failures and typy were eliminated and only those
the effect of past experience on his pres- which had a high index of individuality
ent behavior. (c) Drives: the primary and which could still be expected to
motivating factors in a candidate’s per- yield material for any one of the ten
sonality. (d) Inner States: the feelings categories indicated above were in-
which a candidate experienced most fre- cluded. Additional items were con-
quently and the nature of the situations structed for those areas which had been
that aroused such feelings. (e) Goals: incompletely covered. Analysis of 40
the ends toward which a candidate was complete records of the present form of
striving. ( f ) Cathezes: objects, activi- the test indicates that the index of in-
ties or ideas which a candidate desired dividuality for each of the items is still
and for which he was willing to make high.
sacrifices. (g) Energy: the energy The incomplete sentences may be
level of a candidate and how this energy divided into two types. Type A refer
48 MORRIS I. STEIN
etc., of third parties. In these sentences which I should like you to complete as rapidly
as possible with the first thing that comes to
use is made of a person’s proper name your mind. Sometimes you will find that a
or the personal pronoun “he,” and the single word will ‘complete the sentence and
subject is called upon to indicate what sometimes you will find that a brief phrase
another’s reactions or behavior would will do. I should prefer a brief phrase, but
be in a variety of situations. These if a word is all you can think of, then that
sentences are referred to as the projec- will be sufficient. You have only ten minutes
within which to complete the test so you have
tive sentences. Type B are incomplete to work as rapidly as possible.
sentences in which the personal pro-
noun “I,” is used and in which no at- The test can be administered either in
tempt is made to hide the purposes of a group or individually. The lists of
the examiner. These sentences are re- incomplete sentences appear below, fol-
ferred to as the personal sentences. lowed by a tabulation of the answers
In this test the value of the projec- commonly given by forty male sub-
tive items has been reinforced by re- jects.* The examples listed below are
quiring the subject to “complete each not intended to serve as norms against
item as rapidly as possible with the first which examiners may check their re-
thing that comes to your mind.” It is sponses, but rather to indicate the usual
obvious that this emphasis upon speed range of individual responses that can
is also an important factor in “per- be obtained to the various items. In
sonal” sentences, since most subjects selecting the illustrative responses, bi-
are slow to censor responses that reveal zarre or uncommon answers were
significant data. Since in several in- avoided.
stances personal and projective items
cover the same area, future research SENTENCE TESTWITH
COMPLETION
will be oriented toward evaluating these USUALRESPONSES
items to indicate which type of sentence Part I
yields more accurate information when
checked against life history data and
1. Charlie was happiest when . . ..
he was young, at play, alone, eating,
clinical notes made by independent ob- working.
servers. 2. H e liked nothing better tkau to .. ..
read, sleep, be drunk, play ball, keep
OF THE TEST
ADMINISTRATION busy.
3. When caught behind the enemy’s lines,
The test is administered in two parts, Ted+ . .. .
first to avoid a negative mental set that cried, surrendered, hid, remained
would develop if one were faced with calm, made a miraculous escape.
the imposing task of completing 100 4. Nothing annoyed Bob more than . .. .
mosquitoes, profanity, noise, teasing,
items; second, to minimize fatigue fac-
terrible dreams.
tors; and third, to enable those subjects . .
5. Mike’s fondest ambition . .
who approach the test with misgivings was to be rich, was to become a law-
to rid themselves of their feelings dur- * The writer is indebted to Mrs. A. Quann and
ing the first part of the test and hence Mr. J. D. Robinson for their assistance in tabu-
lating the responses.
to cooperate better on the second half. t!n the form used in the Veterans Adminis-
The instructions for the test are as tration, this item was omitted since it referred
specifically to the war. A new item, “John’s
follows : wife . . . .” was substituted for it.
USE OF SENTENCE COMPLETION TEST 49
succeed, please her, gain favors for 46. H e is often at a loss when ..
..
himself, make his wife happy, avoid he talks to his boss, suddenly called
work. upon to speak, he is misunderstood,
34. Joe feels that he suffers most f r o m . . . . there are two choices, things happen
lack of education, lack of companion- quickly.
ship, intimidation, inferiority com- 47. H e often thinks of himself as . , . .
plex, being ordered around. a poet, philosopher, brilliant, man-
35. T h e men under me . . . . about-town, being restless.
like me, respect me, are satisfied, 48. W h e n they said that it was dangerous,
are difficult to lead, hate me. Bert . . . .
36. Bud would rather do m'thout . . . . thought a minute, cringed, volun-
food in order to get a room, than teered, rolled up his sleeves and dug
work for a living, than ask for help, in, laughed.
than see others suffering, a thing 49. From past experience BiU learned that
than get it unfairly. .
he . .-
37. After Bob left the interview, he was slow, must be careful, was ahead
thoi4ght . . .. of the game, did not know as much
that he had failed, that he was as he thought he did, had better think
through, of other things to say, that twice.
he had left a favorable impression, .
50. Z take pains . . .
that he could do it. to please her, to be accurate, to get
38. His father . . . . along .with others, to have time to
was dead, reproached him, was very enjoy myself, to be neat.
pleased with him, was a good man,
was an understanding individual. Part 11
39. George was sorry after he . . .. 51. John prefers the company of . . ..
swore, said it, left home, argued with men, women, happy people, fellow
his wife, turned down the offer. workers, a crowd.
40. W h a t they liked about him most 52. H e didn't like Bill because he was . . ..
was.. .. too slow, concerned with himself,
his manner, his frankness, his cour- fussy, proud, aggressiyl
tesy and consideration, his ability to 53. Dave felt that the men over him
cope with any situation, his person- were . . . .
ality. inconsiderate, o v e r b e a r i n g, too
41. Whenever there was overtime work to severe, capable, fair.
be done, Bob felt ... . 54. The thing which got him into troubk
sick, imposed upon, he should do it, was . . . .
someone else should do it, that it was his temper, dishonesty, women, lack
worthwhile. of self-confidence, lack of inhibitions.
42. People think of me as . . .. 55. Zt was irritating to be .. ..
a fool, being snobbish, being a bore, left alone on a job, treated so, a
a nice fellow, a straightforward per- coward, without her, cheated.
son. 56. Bill is afraid of ... .
43. They made fun of his accent SO horses and dogs, falling, the news
Tom . + . . from home, taking a chance, himself.
kept quiet, blushed, cried, sought to 57. His younger days ....
correct it, hired an English tutor. were vigorous, are over, were wasted,
44. Bud could work best at . . . . were spent alone, were spent under
home, night, anything to do with ideal conditions.
mathematics, strenuous tasks, some- 58. Roger would have done anything to
thing he likes. forget the time he . . ..
45. Z always wanted to be . . . . lost his head, was kicked out of
an engineer, a sailor, the boss, happy, school, stole, lost his buddy, missed
independent. an opportunity.
USE OF SENTENCE COMPLETION TEST 51
59. Others think my standards are . . .. his worries, his in-laws, his inhibi-
low, very lax, average, high, hard to tions, his health, insomnia.
meet. 75. H e made a point of . . . .
What bothered Jack w their. . . .
60.
5
quarrels, insincerity, anners, lack of
sympathy, sending him on personal
being on time, being friendly, doing
things in a systematized manner, get-
ting ahead, selling himself.
errands. 76. If Fred could only . . . .
61. Jack really became angry w h e n . . . . see her now, snap out of this mel-
he was fired, she left without him, he ancholia, forget himself, find some-
was disobeyed, they hinted distrust in thing to do, control his temper.
him, patronized. 77. M y philosophy of life i s . . . .
62. Charlie felt his acquaintances . . . . the Golden Rule, vague, still grow-
failed him, had influence, did not ing, do it easily, happy living.
back him up, were not the best, were 78. The people who worked B Jewy’s de-
partment . . . .
4
fine and good.
43. M y family. . . . liked him, were cheerful and coopera-
capes from the best stock, is highly tive, were his friends, were very in-
sentimental, is very fond of my sister, dustrious, were friendly.
cares for me, is proud. 79. Most of the time . . . .
64. When Dick failed the course he . . .. he was out of work, he boasted, he
felt like giving up, cried, resigned, spent reading, is spent werthlessly,
took it over again, was told to repeat. he works hard.
65. M y greatest worry is . . . . 80. H e was dominuted b y . , . .
my family, her health, financial, fail- his wife and mother-in-law, false
ure, unfounded. ideas, his ambition, his mother, his
66. .
When luck turned against him, Joe . . . vanity.
drank, gave up, became sour toward 81. M y worst fault . . . .
everyone, decided to try a new field, is my temper, is lack of preparedness,
buckled down. is egotism, is day dreaming, is a
67. . .
If I would only . . tendency to criticise.
remember, do what I decide, find a 82. When I have something to say and oth-
perfect job, try harder I might suc- ers are wound . .. .
ceed, grow up. I say it, I am careful, I say it quietly,
68. He went mad when . . . . I am struck dumb, I am at my best.
his wife was killed, told the news, ..
M. I e n j o y . .
affronted, he lost his family, ques- eating good food, listening to myself
tioned. as well as to the next man, music, a
69. I often . . . . job well done, getting out in the
dream about the war, repeat myself, open.
pray, sit and think, day dream. 84. When they turned him domn for the
70. He is apt to complain about . . . . .
job, B i l l . . .
himself, his wife, his health, hard gave up, couldn’t figure out why,
work, little things. scowled, sought another one, never
71. I dream a great deal about . .. . stopped trying.
the future, her, war, security in life, 85. Most people do not know that I . ...
a business of my own. am scared, have a hard time making
72. His mother . . . . ends meet, am a n idealist, am a fairly
was dead, is a wonderful woman, is good egg, love life.
getting old, was a great help, loaded U.I t is embarrwsing . ...
him with selfish affection. to lose, to be found wrong, to be
73. Discouragement made him . . . . called down, to be so short, to be
take to drink, give up early, sad, ill- called lazy.
tempered, try harder. 87. When they toM him that the job may
74. .
Joe is most troubled by . . . be too much for him, D o d . . . .
52 MORRIS I. STEIN
begged for a chance, got furious, said attainable, are set high, are to be
they were wrong, was ashamed, went happy and content.
ahead anyway.
88. The main thing in my life . . . . INTERPRETATION
OF THE RESULTS
is to get ahead, is to be independent,
is work, is learning, is my family and The validity of the personality de-
their security. scription written by the psychologist on
89. H e thinks of himself as . . . . the basis of the responses to the incom-
a no-good, just another guy, a good plete sentences is highly correlated with
follower, a great man, too good for his experience, insight, and knowledge
them. of the dynamics of behavior. In
90. When they laughed at Fred, h e . . . . analyzing his material, the clinician ac-
cried, paid no attention, got angry,
tried to improve, only worked harder. cepts the following theoretical assump
91. When they decided to put him under tions : ( 1) when an individual is put un-
presszwe, Frank . . . . der pressure to respond with the first
fainted, gave in, reacted violently, idea that occurs to him, he usually offers
was at his best, decided to really go significant material which he does not
to work. censor; (2) when faced with the prob-
92. I would rather. . . .
eat than sleep, be good, be alone, die lem of completing or structuring an un-
than surrender, be dead than a slave. structured situation, an individual’s re-
93. When the other men avoided him, sponses will be indicative of the true
Bob.. .. nature of his own reactions and senti-
was hurt, was worried, was indiffer- ments; ( 3 ) in talking about others, an
ent, made it his business to know individual is apt to reveal himself.
why, kept quiet until they changed.
However, the clinician must beware of
94. M y greatest ambition is . . . .
to be useful, to be a physicist (or any the fact that many of his subjects have
other profession), to get ahead, to sufficient social awareness and are in-
have a happy home, to attain secur- telligent enough to differentiate be-
ity. tween “desirableJJand “undesirable,’ re-
95. I suffer most from . . . . sponses. In order to gain psychologi-
lack of sleep, nervousness, introspec- cally relevant data in such cases, the
tion, procrastination, loneliness.
96. .
I often think about how I . . . clinician must utilize his clinical experi-
outsmarted my friend, failed, could ence to the utmost and the beginner may
improve the situation, used to enjoy find some aid in the suggestions that
life. follow below.
97. The worst thing was . . . . The technique of analysis is to read
to be defeated, shame, when my faith the responses and to underline those
died, not being at ease, lack of sleep. answers that appear to be significant.
98. I was happiest w h e n . . . .
single, with my wife, I was young, I The significance of a response is usually
was trying, I was alone. determined by :
99. When he thought that the odds were a. The clinician’s knowledge of the dy-
agairtst him, B i l l . . . . namics of behavior and personality,
gave in, did not dare advance, was which is utilized to infer the crucial
cautious, was not afraid, really factors in the personality structure of
started to fight. the subject under observation. For
100. M y goals . . .. example, in the case of the individual
are not good, are in a state of flux who completes item No. 99, “When he
depending on conditions, are few but thought that the odds were against
USE OF SENTENCE COMPLETION TEST 53
him, Bill . . . .,” with “fought harder,” terial and at times it may show that
this completion suggests that we are the subject wanted to correct an error
dealing with an individual who has a in spelling or did not understand a
high energy level, a strong need for word in one of the sentences.
achievement and who does not yield The intensity of the language used in
easily in the face of obstacles. the response. Strong and colorful
b. The frequency with which a response words are frequently employed by in-
has been made by other individuals. dividuals who are very definite about
The rare responses are more critical certain reaction patterns or who at-
than the usual ones. Since formal tempt to bend over backwards to fool
norms have not yet been established, the examiner.
the clinician should develop his own
on the basis of experience. These are only a few of the cues
C. A subject’s reaction time to the indi- which a clinician utilizes in determining
vidual sentences and to the test as a critical responses. Indeed, most clini-
whole. Most subjects complete each cians will develop their own techniques.
part in approximately ten minutes.
The records of those who take less Some have used the handwriting sam-
time are usually sterile insofar as a ples in the test for purposes of diag-
complete analysis is concerned, as they nosis.
respond with only single words. When the critical items have been
d. The length of the completions. noted, the problem is then one of order-
Lengthy responses are frequently ing them into groups or clusters so that
found in records of individuals who
wish to mask their true feelings or who each group refers to a single area of be-
have a strong desire to indicate to the havior or personality. As an aid to be-
examiner the precise nature of their ginners who have just begun to learn
reactions. the test, a form was developed in which
e. Behavioral manifestations during the all ten of the categories listed on page
course of the test. The tensions and 47 appeared. I n the space provided
anxieties of some subjects increase
during the course of the test. It is as for each of these categories, there is a
if they were aware of the fact that list of the sentences that might con-
they were revealing themselves, but tribute data to that category. This is
lacked sufficient psychological insight only a suggested list, since on one oc-
to realize that their emotions were be- casion an item may yield information
ing stimulated by the test items or for one category and on another occa-
their answers to these items. It is
valuable to observe which items stimu- sion it may apply to a different category.
late a subject’s anxieties and his tech- With increasing familiarity in the use
niques of reacting to tension, i.e., tics, of the test, most clinicians will use
increased restlessness, refusal to con- scratch pads instead of a form on which
tinue with the test, etc. to assemble their groups, and many will
f. Erasures and omissions. Erasures and
omissions frequently appear where in- develop new categories on the basis of
dividuals feel that their responses have their own theoretical views. On the
been too revealing or when an item has basis of the data in each of the groups,
touched upon a critical area. When the clinician is prepared to write his
erasures and omissions are present it personality description.
is valuable to question the subject,
after he has turned in his paper, as to THECASESOF J. Q. AND R. V.
what it was that he erased or the rea-
son for the omission. At times such Two cases that were seen at the Men-
questioning may reveal significant ma- tal Hygiene Clinic are presented below.
54 MORRIS I. STEIN
Notice to Contributors
Beginning with the April 1947 issue, it is planned to include a new section en-
titled Clinical Notes which will be devoted to the brief presentation of new clinical
methods, modifications of older methods, unusual clinical cases, and other new develop-
ments which might prove to be of general interest to the profession. These brief
reports will be limited to material which is relatively new and has not been published
in this Journal previously. We are particularly interested in the ways in which clinical
psychologists have solved minor problems of technique.