Professional Documents
Culture Documents
When To Choose Intel® Itanium® Architecture For The Enterprise Microsoft® Windows® Server Environment
When To Choose Intel® Itanium® Architecture For The Enterprise Microsoft® Windows® Server Environment
When to choose Intel® Itanium® architecture for the enterprise Microsoft® Windows®
server environment
Executive summary............................................................................................................................... 2
Introduction......................................................................................................................................... 2
Windows operating systems for IA-32 and the Intel Itanium architecture ..................................................... 4
Floating-point performance................................................................................................................ 8
Conclusions ...................................................................................................................................... 10
Whether choosing IA-32 or Intel Itanium architecture, demand more from HP ........................................... 11
Appendix ......................................................................................................................................... 12
Executive summary
HP, Microsoft, and Intel® have joined forces to demonstrate superior performance and scalability
for the Windows enterprise data center. New options are available that bring greater scalability
and performance to applications through the introduction of the 64-bit Intel Itanium® architecture
for industry-standard platforms; Windows Server 2003, which supports up to 64 Intel Itanium
processors; and HP Integrity Superdome servers, which are scalable to 64 Intel Itanium processors.
As with any newly evolving technology, it is important for customers to understand how to select
the best solution for their business needs. To help customers make that decision, this paper
examines some of the differences between IA-32 and the new Intel Itanium architecture. The
paper focuses on the key factors for successful Itanium-based solution deployment, including
operating system and application availability and performance advantages.
As the needs of Windows customers grow beyond the capabilities of IA-32, customers increasingly
have the opportunity to incorporate additional Windows performance and scalability into their
data center by adding Itanium 2-based servers running Windows Server 2003 and 64-bit
applications. HP has had a 10-year partnership with Intel to develop the Intel Itanium architecture,
and a 20-year partnership with Microsoft to optimize Windows for IA-32 and now Itanium 2-
based servers. These partnerships have effectively positioned HP as the vendor of choice for
enterprise Windows solutions—whether they are based on IA-32 or Intel Itanium architecture.
Introduction
Companies that base their information technology strategy on Microsoft Windows and Intel
industry standards are certain to be impacted sooner or later by the confluence of several
significant events:
1. The introduction of the next processor in the 64-bit Intel Itanium Processor Family, the Itanium 2
processor code named Madison
2. The release of Windows Server 2003, which has 64-bit versions for servers with up to 64 Intel
Itanium processors
3. The availability of server platforms, such as the HP Integrity Superdome server, that can scale
up to 64 Intel Itanium 2 processors with Windows Server 2003
4. The release of major 64-bit enterprise applications and leading 64-bit relational databases for
Itanium 2-based servers, and their associated performance and price/performance benchmarks
These events are the critical elements that establish the Intel Itanium architecture as the next-
generation industry-standard platform that will complement and coexist with the IA-32 architecture
in the Windows enterprise data center.
This paper focuses on the Intel Itanium architecture as an industry-standard server choice for
Windows customers and provides information on how to determine the best fit for this compelling
new architecture within the Windows data center.
room to grow. Current roadmaps indicate growth in the IA-32 server space for several more
generations of processors.
In addition to providing substantial computational speeds for most customers, 32-bit systems
benefit from highly tuned operating environments and applications. Microsoft continues to improve
their operating systems with new versions of Windows Server 2003 that are optimized for IA-32
server platforms. Many applications will continue to be fine-tuned for the 32-bit environment even
as their database requirements grow beyond the 4 GB memory addressability limits of IA-32.
Going beyond the 4 GB memory limitation can be accomplished with an IA-32 platform,
although doing so requires the application to enable special memory paging application
programming interfaces (APIs), which adds an additional level of address translation that will
reduce performance. Most application vendors prefer not to enable these APIs, relying instead
on the operating system to manage memory for their applications.
Scaling out by clustering a number of servers is a technique often used to increase the database
performance of an IA-32 application. However, databases that do not easily partition into member
tables along a partition column—and those that allow direct client access to data—do not benefit
from a scale-out architecture. Frequent user-defined, large-scope queries and query flexibility
detract from the scale-out architecture performance by prolonging server response times. Thus,
a scale-up approach is appropriate for these environments.
However, when scaling up to more than 8 processors with an IA-32 system, the 4 GB memory
limitation—coupled with other processor architecture limitations—contributes to a reduction in
the percentage of performance increase. Symmetric multiprocessor systems typically decline
in scalability at the high end simply because contention for shared resources decreases any
performance gains achieved by adding new processors.
Itanium 2-based systems have demonstrated very strong performance in multiple operating
environments for applications such as transactional databases and those requiring complex
computations of large data volumes. The greatly expanded memory addressability of Itanium 2-
based systems allows very large databases to be held in main memory. The processor’s higher
floating-point capabilities also enable faster SSL transactions that are essential for the security
of sensitive data.
Table 1. Microsoft Windows Server 2003 system specifications (versions supported by Intel Itanium processors in italics)
Recommended CPU 550 MHz 550 MHz 733 MHz 733+ MHz
speed
In addition, those same servers will be upgradeable to the mx2 dual-processor module technology,
which will be available in 2004. The HP mx2 dual-processor module is a daughter card that puts
two Madison processors and an L4 cache into the same socket that a single Madison processor
uses. The HP mx2 not only has the same footprint as a regular Madison processor, but also fits
into the same volumetric space and power envelope. The end result is a processor module that
can increase the performance of a server by over 50% for the target workloads: databases,
transaction processing, and business intelligence. This will effectively double the number of Intel
Itanium 2 processors that can be installed in the same chassis, which will result in outstanding
performance increases at a fraction of the cost of purchasing a new unit. HP will be the only
vendor to offer dual-module technology for Itanium 2-based systems as early as 2004.
Since HP Integrity servers will support 64-bit Windows Server 2003, HP-UX 11i, and 64-bit Linux
(plus OpenVMS in 2004), customers will be able to eliminate the costs of multiple hardware
support groups needed for multiple architectures. As computing requirements change, these
valuable resources can then be re-deployed in revenue-producing activities. In addition, when
it comes time to upgrade to newer platforms, these same systems can be re-deployed with other
supported operating systems for different workloads.
Customers who are already using 64-bit operating systems and applications (HP-UX, Tru64 and
OpenVMS, Solaris, and AIX) will be able to migrate to HP Integrity servers either immediately or
over time, as their plans require. HP has established comprehensive migration programs to help
customers ease this transition:
• Planning
• Porting and migration
• Financing and leasing
• Hardware and OS services
• Education and training
• Implementation and startup services
• Online transaction processing (OLTP) applications and online analytical processing (OLAP)
applications that benefit from quick access to large volumes of data residing in processor cache
and main memory
• High-performance technical computing requiring complex analytical computations
• Applications structured for multiple work threads that benefit from the parallelism capabilities
of the processor
• Data mining of complex data sets
• Faster encryption and decryption, resulting in a greater number of SSL transactions
For these types of workloads, users will see substantial benefits by deploying Itanium 2-based
systems rather than IA-32-based systems.
The fourth critical element needed to create the new 64-bit industry standard is a set of robust
applications and databases tuned to this environment. In addition to running the 64-bit Windows
Server 2003, the use of optimized applications is recommended. Although customers can run
32-bit applications on 64-bit Windows Server 2003 operating systems, the applications will run
in 32-bit emulation mode, potentially restricting performance.
Concurrent with the availability of Windows Server 2003, major ISVs have launched production
versions of applications compiled and optimized for the Intel Itanium architecture. Optimized
64-bit Windows-based applications include database, enterprise resource planning (ERP),
supply chain management (SCM), and business intelligence (BI) applications.
Major commercial products that will be available in 2003 include the following:
• Databases
– Microsoft SQL Server 2000, 64-bit Enterprise Edition
– Oracle® 9.2
– IBM DB2 UDB v8.1
• Enterprise resource planning
– SAP R/3 Enterprise v4.6
• Supply chain management
– mySAP Supply Chain Management live Cache
• Business intelligence
– SAS v9
– SAP BW 3.0B/3.1
Helping to round out the 64-bit Windows solutions ecosystem in 2003, major vendors such
as BEA, BMC, Computer Associates, VERITAS, Legato, and Symantec have committed to
producing infrastructure applications in areas such as manageability, disaster recovery,
and security.
Floating-point performance
An additional benefit of the Intel Itanium architecture is greater floating-point capability. As
more and more e-commerce is transacted over the Internet, real-time online marketing will
require rapid customer profiling. Applications such as SAS Data Mining running on the Intel
Itanium 2 microarchitecture are providing the additional power needed to accomplish this. The
computationally intense SAS Data Mining application is seeing a four to five times performance
increase over 32-bit systems. Given this impressive performance advantage, customers will
quickly recoup their investment in the new Itanium-based hardware.
“Cataloging a portion of the observable universe requires vast amounts of memory and
exceptional processing power. The Johns Hopkins SDSS project is handling over 70 million
galaxies in the database, stored in Microsoft SQL Server 2000. With each successive generation
of HP Itanium-based servers running Microsoft SQL Server 2000, we have reduced the time it
takes to analyze the distribution of galaxies and other objects by—in some cases—months. For
example, when we start working with about 32 million objects, a server with 1 GB will take half
a year to complete the calculations, while an Itanium-based platform with 28 GB of memory will
do the job in 10 days. The database performance has been nothing short of spectacular. We
ran queries at speeds of 700 megabytes/second. We have also used the Itanium 2-based
machines for cosmological computations, measuring the curvature of the universe. We expect
another quantum leap in performance with the newest generation of HP servers, based on Intel
Itanium 2 ‘Madison’ processors and running the 64-bit version of Microsoft SQL Server 2000.
HP Itanium 2-based servers running Microsoft SQL Server 2000 are a superb platform for our
mega calculations.”
Conclusions
A culmination of years of effort, the critical Intel Itanium architecture ecosystem elements from
hardware and software vendors have converged to create a new industry standard for Windows
customers. The Intel Itanium architecture will not displace the huge IA-32 infrastructure already in
place or significantly impede its growth. Instead, the Intel Itanium architecture complements the
pervasive IA-32 infrastructure by adding new capabilities, especially when compared to what
has traditionally been the “high-end”—greater than 8-way IA-32—server space. Complex
applications and applications that require greater memory addressability, higher application-
level performance and scalability, or massive floating-point performance are ideal for the Intel
Itanium architecture. In general, for scalability beyond 8 processors and 16 GB of memory, the
Intel Itanium architecture should be considered against both IA-32 and proprietary architectures
for better absolute performance, price/performance, and continued improvements in both over
the coming years. In the near term, the Intel Itanium architecture is ideal for Windows database
scalability and database consolidation as well as for the highest performance for complex, line-of-
business enterprise applications.
As application support for Itanium-based systems increases, Windows customers will need to
weigh the benefits of the two industry-standard architectures. Because applications that are
optimized for the Intel Itanium architecture will provide the biggest performance gains, availability
of these applications will be a determining factor in when customers adopt the architecture.
10
11
The achievements HP has made in hardware and software innovation and design are world
renowned, as evidenced by its strong patent record: 17,000 patents worldwide, including 2,000
in 2002. Moreover, no other manufacturer enjoys long-term and mutually beneficial relationships
with Microsoft and Intel, as well as with major independent software vendors, including SAP,
Oracle, SAS, and others. For customers who want to streamline their infrastructure costs and
simplify their operating environments, industry-standard solutions from HP will provide them
with the greatest selection of solutions and resources to meet their business requirements.
HP’s strong services capabilities extend to all of its products, maintaining services leadership in
key areas:
• HP is #1 in mission-critical services
• HP is #1 in services across open IT environments
• HP is #1 in enterprise Microsoft services
In addition, HP customers benefit from the largest, best-trained service force in the industry, with:
Appendix
Reference:
Platforms for a New Millennium, HP’s Transition to Servers Based on Itanium Processors,
an IDC white paper sponsored by Hewlett-Packard Company. Analysts: Jean S. Bozman
and Christopher G. Willard
http://esp.mayfield.hp.com:2000/nav24/srs/salescom/nafocus/SellingTools/090017ad812de3db/
12
5981-7397EN, 06/2003