Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Culture of Sharing
A Culture of Sharing
• The
high
school
is
a
three-‐time
Reward
School,
with
its
junior
class
earning
above
a
21
composite
average
on
the
ACT.
• Bridge
Magazine
has
twice
recognized
Kingsley
with
Academic
All-‐State
honors.
As
they
proceeded
to
drive
full-‐scale
implementation,
focusing
on
the
elements
with
the
highest
effect
size,
it
all
became
clearer.
“Like
a
sledgehammer
hitting
me
in
the
chest,
I
actually
heard
what
was
being
said.
The
Common
Core
assessments,
when
implemented,
are
going
to
call
for
different
sets
of
skills—nothing
shocking
there.
When
the
incremental
approach
to
showing
how
these
problem-‐solving,
higher-‐order
questions
were
going
to
be
phased
in,
it
hit
home.
We
have
got
to
start
doing
this.”
A
Common
Language
One
key
area
of
focus
has
been
the
establishment
of
a
common
language
of
instruction.
“I
guarantee
that
every
classroom,
every
hour,
has
a
learning
goal
and
scale
that
the
kids
understand,”
says
Smith,
and
the
common
language
often
reaches
beyond
the
classroom.
He
shares
a
story
about
an
elementary
school
teacher
who
was
helping
to
organize
a
holiday
play
outside
of
school:
She
asked
the
kids
to
show
her
on
their
hands
where
they
were.
All
the
kids
put
up
between
one
and
four
fingers.
While
the
adults
had
no
clue
what
she
was
talking
about,
the
children,
regardless
of
grade
level,
have
been
using
a
universal
scale
for
quick
checks
for
understanding.
The
idea
of
evaluating
teachers
on
60
different
elements
and
scales
was
a
bit
daunting
at
first.
“In
the
beginning,
it
took
a
bit
to
agree
on
what
the
dominant
elements
even
were,
but
as
our
skills
have
developed
in
this
area,
so
has
our
confidence.
It’s
not
nearly
as
scary
as
we
had
made
it
out
to
be.”
After
the
first
round
of
observations,
Smith
and
his
team
realized
that
they
had
been
tougher
on
their
strongest
teachers,
who
welcomed
constructive
criticism,
than
they
had
been
on
developing
teachers,
who
were
not
quite
as
receptive
to
it.
Smith
discussed
the
matter
with
administrators,
pulled
the
information
together
in
iObservation,
and
made
quick
adjustments
in
training
and
practice
to
correct
the
inconsistency.
In
addition,
Smith
was
concerned
that
teachers
could
artificially
inflate
their
scores
by
pandering
to
the
rubric
while
observers
were
in
the
room,
something
that
had
occurred
with
a
prior
evaluation
model.
However,
he
eventually
decided
that
it
wouldn’t
be
entirely
bad
if
that
happened.
“We
concluded
that
if
gaming
the
system
means
implementing
the
elements
frequently
enough
in
your
classroom
that
kids
can
seamlessly
do
it
when
you’re
being
evaluated,
then
game
away.”
Smith’s
teachers
are
inspired,
and
the
district
is
thriving.
“While
demonstrated
student
achievement
is
the
measure,
come
look
at
our
classrooms.
What
is
going
on
is
not
window
dressing
or
gamesmanship;
it
is
just
a
focus
on
excellent
teaching.”
A
Culture
of
Sharing
Smith
attributes
much
of
Kingsley
Area
Elementary
School’s
success
to
the
leadership
of
its
principal,
Karl
A.
Hartman,
who
has
been
there
for
29
years.
Hartman,
in
turn,
credits
his
school’s
commitment
to
collaboration
and
collegiality.
The
school’s
leadership
team
provides
support
to
colleagues
in
using
the
model,
whereas
its
district
team
addresses
training,
teacher
rounds,
and
inter-‐rater
reliability.
Through
online
forums
and
local
networks,
teachers
work
together
to
develop
lesson
plans,
and
as
an
added
support,
Hartman
and
his
staff
created
observation
“norms”
that
outline
how
to
collaborate
areas
of
strength
and
weakness
in
a
positive
way.
Hartman
shared
an
example
of
the
collegiality
that
has
solidified
within
his
staff:
Last
year,
I
completed
an
observation
with
one
our
very
best
teachers,
identifying
areas
that
needed
growth
(developing)
and
areas
that
were
strong
(applying).
When
I
left
the
classroom,
the
teacher,
who
is
respected
and
identified
as
highly
effective,
immediately
reviewed
her
observation,
printed
it,
and
met
with
her
team
to
help
them
with
the
feedback
and
suggestions
that
I
provided
in
her
observation.
Her
colleagues
were
able
to
quickly
implement
the
suggestions
in
their
subsequent
observation
and
received
higher
ratings
as
a
result
of
her
amazing
collegiality.
We
have
created
a
culture
of
collaboration
to
be
rivaled
by
few.
Learning
Targets
Educators
at
Kingsley
Elementary
have
always
been
focused
on
telling
students
what
they’re
going
to
teach
them.
They
post
learning
targets
and
refer
to
them
frequently.
They
provide
scales
with
increasing
complexity
to
help
them
examine
student
growth.
“We’ve
always
attempted
to
keep
track
of
students,”
says
Hartman,
“but
tracking
student
progress
in
real
time,
with
students
responsible
for
recording
their
progress,
has
been
a
remarkable
advance.”
The
Marzano
growth
model
has
been
the
best
tool
that
I
have
used
in
my
administrative
career;
it’s
the
best
thing
that
has
ever
happened
for
me.
—Karl
A.
Hartman,
Principal
Starting
as
early
as
preschool,
students
know
the
lingo:
learning
targets,
learning
scales,
tracking
progress,
celebrating
success,
critical
information,
review,
reflecting
on
learning,
digestible
bites,
guided
practice
…
Kingsley
students
all
know
that
they
will
have
a
learning
target,
critical
information,
a
review,
and
a
lesson
agenda,
regardless
of
the
classroom
they’re
in.
“Lessons
have
become
predictable,
and
students
know
what
to
expect
from
every
teacher,”
he
adds.
“Students
know
that
they
will
keep
track
of
their
growth,
whether
it
is
on
a
chart,
a
graph,
a
class
graph,
a
progress
folder,
a
passport,
or
countless
other
practices.”
Refining
the
Use
of
Strategies
Jennifer
Hoffman
has
been
teaching
first
grade
at
Kingsley
Elementary
School
for
12
years,
and
she
finds
the
Marzano
model
helpful
for
tweaking
and
improving
upon
things
that
teachers
are
already
doing.
She
uses
the
example
of
Element
9
from
Design
Question
2
(chunking
content
into
“digestible
bites”).
“Naturally,
I
was
internally
doing
this
in
my
mind
with
each
lesson
I
taught,
but
to
refine
it
and
make
it
more
consistent,
I
named
each
lesson
part—or
‘bite’—and
listed
[the
parts]
on
the
board
for
the
students
to
see.”
With
the
lesson
parts
permanently
displayed,
she
uses
a
pointer
to
move
through
them.
“This
has
kept
my
teaching
organized
and
the
students
involved
with
the
parts
of
my
lessons,”
she
says.
She
likes
the
flexibility
that
the
model
encourages.
“Our
principal
allows
us
the
creative
license
to
take
the
information
provided
in
the
Marzano
model
and
make
it
our
own;
to
fit
each
unique
grade
level
and
teaching
personality.”
Hoffman
also
offers
some
advice
to
teachers
who
are
new
to
the
model.
“The
Marzano
model
does
not
have
to
mean
reinventing
the
wheel.
It’s
an
opportunity
to
spice
up
what
you’re
already
doing
…
to
put
life
back
into
your
teaching.
Embrace
this,
own
it,
and
make
it
your
own.
Don’t
change
the
great
things
you’re
already
doing
to
fit
the
model.
Be
creative—it
doesn’t
have
to
be
rigid
or
black
and
white.
Make
it
what
you
need
it
to
be
for
your
grade
level
and
teaching
style.”
“They
Truly
Strive
to
Do
Their
Best.”
“I’ve
always
had
a
learning
target
for
the
day,
but
[the
targets]
were
always
tucked
away
in
my
lesson
plans,”
says
Jenifer
Wolf,
who
has
been
teaching
first
grade
at
Kingsley
Elementary
School
for
6
years.
“Now
that
I’ve
had
the
Marzano
training,
I
realize
that
learning
targets
shouldn’t
be
a
mystery
for
students.
Posting
the
learning
targets
for
the
students
to
see
each
day
gives
them
a
clear
idea
of
what
they
are
going
to
learn,
and
it
keeps
me
focused
during
my
lessons.”
Wolf
says
that
she
thought
she
was
tracking
student
progress
sufficiently,
but
something
had
been
missing.
“Students
should
not
only
be
a
part
of
their
tracking,”
she
says—they
should
be
responsible
for
it.
“Now
that
each
student
is
accountable
for
tracking
his
or
her
goals
and
progress,
I
can
see
how
motivating
it
is
for
[all
of]
them.
They
truly
strive
to
do
their
best.”
This
is
just
a
way
to
organize
your
teaching
in
a
very
positive
way
that
will
impact
your
students
for
a
lifetime.
—Jenifer
Wolf,
Teacher
Once
the
teachers
at
Kingsley
Elementary
started
learning
about
the
Marzano
elements,
they
began
to
notice
the
things
they
could
do
to
help
students
even
further,
says
Jessica
Dear,
who
has
been
teaching
there
for
13
years.
“It’s
not
like
we’ve
stopped
doing
what
has
always
worked—we’re
just
making
it
better!”
“We
take
and
share
pictures
of
ideas
we
are
using
so
that
others
can
take
them
and
make
them
their
own,”
she
explains,
adding
that
Hartman’s
support
has
played
an
important
role
in
their
collaboration.
“If
we
have
questions
about
elements
or
are
looking
for
new
ideas,
he
encourages
us
to
visit
other
classrooms.
We
can
observe
some
of
the
creative
ways
teachers
are
implementing
the
elements
into
their
lessons.”
Kate
Leonard,
a
first
grade
Title
I
reading
specialist
at
Kingsley
Elementary,
has
also
experienced
“aha
moments”
throughout
the
Marzano
training.
“Many
of
the
strategies
or
elements
are
so
simple
and
have
enriched
my
teaching,”
she
says.
Leonard
always
knew
to
tell
students
what
they’re
going
to
learn,
but
learning
targets
have
made
that
easier,
whereas
scales
provide
feedback
that
helps
her
determine
who
needs
more
instruction
and
who’s
ready
to
work
independently.
Willing
to
Share
and
Change
After
11
years
with
the
district,
Kristin
Goethals,
a
kindergarten
teacher
at
Kingsley
Elementary,
feels
that
Marzano
training
has
made
her
teaching
more
deliberate,
and
she
wanted
her
colleagues
to
collaborate
and
share
in
that
growth.
“I
felt
very
strongly,
after
going
to
trainings
and
seminars,
that
there
is
too
much
information
for
teachers
to
absorb
all
at
once—and
one
of
the
best
ways
to
implement
something
is
to
be
constantly
talking
about
it.”
Every
Thursday
morning
during
her
prep
time,
she
facilitates
an
open
dialogue,
focused
on
one
element,
so
that
teachers
can
seek
help
and
share
ideas
and
materials.
After
each
meeting,
she
sends
the
ideas
to
all
staff
members.
“A
really
important
part
of
this
meeting
is
opening
myself
up
to
ideas
and
input
for
others,
modeling
how
to
share
ideas,”
she
adds.
The
norms
for
this
meeting
include:
Be
positive.
Be
open-‐minded.
Share
ideas.
Be
willing
to
share
and
change.
—Kristin
Goethals,
Teacher
Goethals
has
a
monkey
theme
in
her
classroom,
and
she
has
added
a
great
sound
piece
to
help
students
focus
on
identifying
critical
content.
She
says
that
they’ve
become
so
adept
at
doing
it
that
it
creates
awkward
situations
on
occasion,
relating
a
time
when
a
parent
was
in
her
classroom.
“I
said
the
word
‘important,’
and
all
of
my
students
made
monkey
sounds
and
gave
me
their
full
attention.
The
parent
seemed
surprised,
and
I
wrapped
up
our
discussion
with
‘Maybe
we
should
schedule
a
different
time
to
talk.’”
“Being
an
early
childhood
teacher,
movement
is
a
big
part
of
our
day,”
says
Amy
Alger,
who
has
been
a
first
grade
teacher
at
Kingsley
Elementary
School
for
18
years.
“However,
now
including
movement
is
more
deliberate
and
scheduled
within
my
daily
agenda.”
Alger
also
has
found
that
the
Marzano
model
makes
it
easier
to
scaffold
instruction—and
with
a
deeper
knowledge
of
her
students’
confidence
and
levels
of
understanding,
she’s
better
able
to
adapt
her
teaching
to
meet
students’
needs.
Alger
believes
that
Hartman’s
support
has
been
outstanding.
“Our
principal
provides
time
before,
during,
and
after
school
to
study
the
model,
and
even
provides
snacks!
He
also
allows
us
to
observe
other
teachers
by
doing
walk-‐throughs
at
any
time.
He’s
always
ready
to
talk
about
elements,
strategies,
learning
targets,
and
scales.
He
provides
clear
and
direct
feedback
during
his
observations.
For
students,
he
celebrates
their
success
and
holds
them
accountable
for
their
learning.
He
asks
them
their
status
in
subjects
and
what
their
goals
are
for
the
marking
period.”
The
Marzano
model
prepares
students
for
college
and
the
workplace
by
“giving
them
tools
and
the
power
to
construct
their
own
learning,”
says
Alger.
As
a
result,
they
ask
better
questions
to
clarify
the
content
of
the
lessons,
she
adds.
“The
Marzano
model
helps
students
discover
their
strengths
and
weaknesses.
This
should
aid
them
in
choosing
a
career
in
which
they
will
be
successful.”
The
common
language
supports
professional
sharing;
professional
sharing
promotes
professional
growth.
—Vaughn
White,
Middle
School
Principal
Kingsley
Middle
School
teacher
Andrew
Sias
agrees
that
a
common
language
of
instruction
is
crucial.
“We
all
use
the
Marzano
lingo
and
know
that
teachers
and
students
alike
understand
exactly
what
we
are
talking
about.
For
the
most
part,
teachers
and
students
know
the
difference
between
a
scale
and
a
rubric.
We
are
all
working
within
the
same
conceptual
framework,
so
it
facilitates
dialogue
among
staff
and
students.”
In
particular,
Sias
points
out
the
importance
of
Design
Questions
2
and
3.
“We
have
no
way
to
predict
what
the
future
will
be
like,”
he
says.
“We
need
to
help
students
develop
the
abilities
to
examine
similarities
and
differences,
examine
errors
in
reasoning,
develop
and
use
strategies
and
processes,
revise
their
knowledge,
engage
in
cognitively
complex
tasks,
and
generate
and
test
hypotheses.
These
are
skills
students
will
need,
whether
they
work
in
the
corporate
world,
run
their
own
businesses,
or
opt
out
of
the
rat
race
and
start
their
own
permaculture
homesteads.”
Vaughn
White,
principal
of
Kingsley
Middle
School,
says
that
the
Marzano
model
supports
the
transition
from
teaching
to
learning.
“It
begins
to
address
the
need
to
develop
grit
in
students,”
he
says,
adding,
“Students
have
increased
motivation
and
determination
when
they
track
their
own
learning.”
One
of
White’s
teachers,
Justine
Rinehart,
likes
that
the
Marzano
model
pushes
students
toward
the
rigorous
instruction
that
will
prepare
them
for
the
future
and
encourages
cooperative
work
among
students
who
didn’t
necessarily
choose
to
work
together.
“This
skill
will
most
definitely
serve
our
students
when
they
enter
the
global
workplace,”
she
explains.
Self-‐evaluation
turned
out
to
be
quite
popular
with
Rinehart’s
students.
“One
of
the
biggest
surprises
I’ve
had,”
she
says,
“was
when
I
handed
out
a
copy
of
my
first
unit
learning
scale
and
saw
most
students
trying
to
evaluate
where
they
were
on
the
scale
before
we
even
discussed
it.
They
were
much
more
interested
in
self-‐evaluation
than
I
could
have
imagined,
and
I
was
very
pleasantly
surprised.”
Mike
Moran,
principal
of
Kingsley
High
School,
taught
for
a
decade
before
becoming
the
school
leader.
He
feels
that
academic
rigor
is
essential
to
success
on
assessments
and
overall
college
readiness,
and
he
sees
great
value
in
having
a
common
language
of
instruction
in
place.
“This
comfort,
with
the
elements
and
the
model
itself,
has
allowed
staff
members
to
effectively
communicate
and
build
skills
in
one
another,”
says
Moran.
As
the
conversation
and
use
of
the
language
becomes
more
common,
the
frequency
of
teachers
realizing
the
positive
impact
that
the
model
has
on
instruction
also
increases.
—Mike
Moran,
Kingsley
High
School
Principal
Moran’s
teachers
express
similar
thoughts.
Georgean
(Gigi)
M.
Krygier,
who
has
been
teaching
at
Kingsley
High
since
2001,
is
enthusiastic
about
the
direction
the
school
is
taking.
“While
we
are
in
the
beginning
stages
of
implementing
the
Marzano
model,
we
take
pride
in
being
‘ahead
of
the
curve’
here
in
northern
Michigan,”
she
says.
“It
is
with
great
satisfaction
that
we
hear
our
students
exchanging
ideas
in
class
about
what
they
comprehend
and
how
they
can
best
master
new
ideas
and
concepts.”
“I
feel
that
I
have
always
been
a
good
teacher,
but
by
conscientiously
working
through
the
elements,
I
feel
that
I
have
become
a
better
teacher,”
says
Sue
Graham,
who
has
been
teaching
art
at
Kingsley
High
School
for
9
years.
As
an
art
teacher,
she
sees
growth
every
day,
but
it
hasn’t
always
been
easy
to
produce
evidence
of
that
growth.
Graham
has
developed
a
habit
of
writing
out
the
specific
strategies
that
she
will
use,
as
well
as
the
learning
goals
that
her
students
need
to
meet.
“Following
the
Marzano
model
can
help
a
teacher
focus
on
a
variety
of
elements
that
can
improve
teaching,”
she
says.
“If
we
focus
on
some
of
the
elements
for
every
lesson,
our
students
will
most
likely
get
a
better
education,
because
they
will
have
a
better
teacher.”
Upon
receiving
her
first
evaluation,
Kristen
Bauer,
now
a
Kingsley
High
School
teacher
for
10
years,
wasn’t
ecstatic;
Moran
noted
her
accomplishments
but
put
her
in
the
developing
category
and
asked
her
how
she
might
improve.
“I
pouted,
quickly
went
through
the
five
stages
of
grief
for
my
own
perceived
excellence,
and
came
to
the
conclusion
that
he
was
right,”
says
Bauer.
“While
having
initiated
the
focus,
I
had
not
yet
given
students
the
opportunity
to
make
meaning
from
targets,
by
recording,
self-‐
evaluation,
and
questioning—which
is,
of
course,
how
students
create
an
accurate
road
map
of
their
own
learning.
My
students
and
I
are
in
the
process
of
creating
and
trying
new
ways
to
better
accomplish
this.
We
are
going
toward
a
mutual
finish
line
together
more
so
than
we
ever
have
before.”
It’s
All
About
the
Why.
Bauer
credits
the
Marzano
model
for
fostering
a
shift
away
from
a
pedagogy
where
teachers
provide
an
uphill
push
and
then
micromanage
student
learning.
“The
old
system
of
teaching
seemed
task-‐oriented,
without
the
understanding
that
tasks
overlap
and
learning
isn’t
just
about
one
part
or
piece,”
she
explains.
This
model
instills
in
them
the
habit
of
starting
with
a
need
to
understand
why
they’re
doing
what
they’re
doing—and
knowing
that
little
tasks
and
pieces
interlock
and
form
pictures,
revealing
a
greater
understanding.
—Kristen
Bauer,
Kingsley
High
School
Teacher
Bauer
likens
it
to
giving
students
academic
“cleats”
that
remind
them
to
employ
deeper-‐level,
higher-‐order
thinking
skills
as
they
navigate
their
own
learning
process.
As
a
result,
she
says,
students
gain
a
deeper
knowledge
that
serves
them
well
as
they
work
in
groups
and
take
on
a
variety
of
leadership
roles—things
they
will
eventually
need
to
do
as
adults.
We
are
honored
to
be
working
with
the
wonderful
leaders
and
educators
at
Kingsley
Area
Schools.
If
you’d
like
to
help
your
teachers
make
the
critical
instructional
shifts
they
need
to
make
to
move
students
toward
increased
cognitive
complexity,
connect
with
us!
We
provide
Michigan
districts
with:
• A
clear,
well-‐articulated
model
of
instruction,
Essentials
for
Achieving
Rigor,
to
move
students
toward
mastery
of
the
cognitive
complex
tasks
in
a
standards-‐driven
classroom.
• A
hierarchical
evaluation
model
that
helps
everyone—district
leaders,
school
leaders,
teachers,
and
non-‐classroom
instructional
support
staff—focus
on
increasing
student
achievement.
• Student
Surveys,
powerful
professional
development
tools
that
help
districts
use
data
from
teacher
feedback
to
identify
strengths
and
areas
for
growth.
• Practical
formative
assessment
strategies
developed
by
Dr.
Dylan
Wiliam
to
significantly
accelerate
student
learning
and
improve
Teacher
Learning
Communities.
• Targeted
school
leadership
coaching
and
support
models
to
increase
student
achievement
and
take
schools
from
good
to
great.
• Books,
specialized
software,
and
digital
professional
development
packs
created
by
leading
education
authors,
including
our
award-‐winning
Essentials
series.
• iObservation—an
online
tool
for
collaboration,
planning,
skill
development,
data
analysis,
and
performance
monitoring—in
one
easy-‐to-‐use
resource.