Concrete Construction Article PDF - Metrification For Ready Mix Producers

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3

Metrication for

ready mix producers


etrication is a pain. If it were at a faster pace. This is the new reality.

M painless, all of the United States


would have converted in the
1960s when metrication first re-
ceived congressional approval. Unfortunately,
procrastination resulted and little happened.
The tide of progress is ruthless. Twenty
years ago, the hand-held electronic calcula-
tor replaced the slide rule. Today, the met-
ric system is doing to the English system
what the calculator did to the slide rule.
Make the
transition
to metric
easier by
Now, however, the choice is clear.
The Federal Highway Administration has Where we stand now learning it
mandated that after October 1, 1996, all Right now, there is a waiting game going
projects receiving federal funds must be in on. The first vendors and suppliers to con- in bite-size
metric units. Not surprisingly, the results of
a recent survey (summarized in Table 1)
vert could be losers. For example, if a
batch computer vendor creates a system for
pieces
show that all state departments of trans- batching loads in either metric or English
By Teck L.
portation plan to be converted by then. In units, would the vendor realize a return on
the Washington, D.C., metropolitan area, the investment, or would the vendor have Chua
the General Services Administration and the to carry the inventory for several years until
Corps of Engineers are already awarding demand picks up?
contracts in metric. In this matter, the government may have
Although ready mixed concrete is not a failed to provide leadership where it is need-
product that lends itself to export, most of ed most. Perhaps, it should have fixed a
the suppliers to the ready mix industry do deadline for the demise of English units. Af-
compete in the global market. As a result, it ter the deadline, everything would be in
becomes increasingly difficult for them to metric. That way, everybody would be
use dual units in their production lines. As working together toward a common, fore-
the demand for goods in English units de- seeable goal. At present, however, the indus-
creases, selection goes down and price try is forced to install short-term measures to
goes up. Now that free trade is becoming a accommodate both systems. Providing life
global reality, metric conversion will occur support for the dying English units is not a

Table 1. Summary of survey of state DOTs

Number of states responding: 48


Number of states Concrete Mix design
switching to metric in: specifications submittals
1993 1994 1995 1996 Metric Both Metric Both
1 2 4 38 40 8 40 8
Note: At the time of the survey, three states were undecided as to the date they would
switch to the metric system.
Source: Master Builders Inc.
sound investment.
Table 2. Bite-size
Bite-size metrics
The metric system covers the metric conversion factors
measurement of the entire known
1 MPa = 145 psi (145.0 psi)
universe. Only a small portion of it,
1 m3 = 1.3 cy (1.308 cy)
however, applies to ready mixed
1 lb/cy = 0.6 kg/m3 (0.5935 kg/m3)
concrete.
1 L/m3 = 0.2 gallons/cy (0.2022 gallons/cy )
To do their individual jobs,
1 fl.oz/cwt = 0.65 mL/kg (0.6519 mL/kg)
equipment mechanics and concrete
technicians do not need to know 1 kg = 2.2 lb (2.205 lb)
the same conversion factors. As 1 metric ton (1000 kg) = 1.1 ton (1.103 ton) = (2205 lbs)
people become proficient with the 1 ft = 0.3 m (0.3048 m)
conversion factors that impact their 1 in = 25 mm (25.4 mm) = 2.5 cm (2.54 cm)
daily job functions, they can learn 1 gallon = 3.8 L (3.785 L) = 1000 mL
additional conversion factors. 1 fl.oz = 30 mL (29.57 mL)
A sales representative and a
Temperature conversion: (100° C 1.8) + 32 = 212° F
technician could probably limit
(212° F - 32) 1.8 = 100° C
their initial knowledge to what is
listed in Table 2. These conversion Unit weight of water = 62.4 lb/ft3 = 1000 kg/m3 = 1 kg/L
factors are intended for easy mem-
orization. For example, 1 MPa =
145 psi is easier to memorize than will batch one load in English units standard. For dial scales, the scale
1 psi = 0.007 MPa. Similar bite-size and the next one in metric units, company will be able to laminate a
pieces of information can be pack- depending on the customer. This metric scale onto the scale head.
aged for other support groups was possible only after a program- All of my clients have multiple
within a company. ming upgrade. Unfortunately, the plants, all of which have operated
An inexpensive calculator simpli- batch plant operator is not able to on a centralized dispatch system for
fies the conversion tasks. Because it change units on the scales through years. This is how it works: All or-
can carry many decimal places, the the computer. However, there is a ders are taken at central dispatch
results are more accurate. manual switch that can change and stored in a mainframe comput-
Try to reduce the number of con- units from load to load. er. Each batching plant computer is
versions whenever possible. For Moreover, the scales cannot be linked to the mainframe computer
example, a slab that measures 100 calibrated in dual units. So far, the by a telephone line. When a truck
feet x 200 feet x 6 inches has a vol- state DOTs in the Washington, is available, the dispatcher sends
ume of 370.37 cubic yards. Apply- D.C., area have not fixed a date for the order information to the plant.
ing the cubic meters/cubic yards switching over to metric calibration. This information includes mix de-
conversion factor, the slab equals Therefore, practical considerations sign weights and delivery informa-
283.2 cubic meters (370.37 1.308). dictate that we stay with one unit tion for that truckload of concrete.
This is easier than converting the system throughout the day. In this fashion, the batch plant
individual dimensions to meters Our plan is to convert to metric computer functions as a “dumb”
first and then figuring the volume in two phases. Right now, most of terminal. But, it also has stand-
in cubic meters. our production volume remains in alone capabilities, should the tele-
English units. Therefore, we will phone linkage go down.
Batching and dispatching use English units as the plant stan- Before sending a metric order to
At this writing, one of my clients dard. When shipping metric jobs, the plant computer, the mainframe
is gearing up to supply a metric the batch plant computer will con- computer converts the mix design
project. All the mix designs have vert scale weights and admixture weights from English units to met-
been submitted and approved. In volumes into metric units. Howev- ric units. From the standpoint of
converting all of the test data and er, material usage and inventory data storage, this is a good arrange-
mix designs from English units to will cumulate in English units. To ment because it eliminates the need
metric units, the pain of metrication do all of this without computers for the computer to use additional
really hits home. The metric con- would be nearly impossible. This is memory to store duplicate mix de-
version plans described here, while phase one. signs. At the same time the plant
fairly firm, will likely be revised be- Phase two kicks in when the de- computer receives the metric mix
fore the first cubic meter of con- mand for metric units exceeds the design weights, it is instructed to
crete is delivered. demand for English units. Then, turn on its own metric conversion
The plant’s batching computers metric units will become the plant program. This ensures that a metric
customer receives 7 cubic meters wanted 3000 psi concrete, but had gineering Reference Manual,
(9.2 cubic yards), not 7 cubic yards failed to distinguish the difference fourth edition, Professional Publi-
of concrete. Even worse would be between pound-force and pound- cations Inc., Calif.
if the customer were to be billed mass. The unit psi means pound- 2. Terence C. Holland and Charles
for 7 cubic meters, but receive only force per square inch. One kilo- Nmai, “Metrics Are Coming,” Con-
7 cubic yards of concrete. gram equals 2.2 pound-mass, not crete Construction, N o v e m b e r
The accounting and billing system 2.2 pound-force. Therefore, to con- 1994, p. 878.
is expected to be fairly straightfor- vert from psi to MPa, it is necessary 3. Conversion to the Metric Sys-
ward, once the batching and the to figure in the gravitational accel- tem (System International—SI),
dispatching systems are correctly eration, which is 32.17 ft/s2. But, first edition, Publication 181, Na-
established. why bother? Just divide 3000 psi by tional Ready Mixed Concrete Asso-
145 and the answer is 20.7 MPa. ciation, Silver Spring, Md.
Early confusion The moral of the story is: Memorize
Be prepared. As metrication mate- the conversion factors in Table 2. ✥
rializes, there will be some mistakes
in conversion. A specification I re- Teck L. Chua is president of Concrete
cently reviewed called for a con- Engineering Inc., a Springfield, Va.,
crete compressive strength of 210 consulting firm providing quality con-
kg/cm2. As hard as I tried, I could trol and quality assurance services to
the ready mixed concrete industry. PUBLICATION #J950231
not convert this specification into
mega pascals (MPa). Finally, it References Copyright © 1995, The Aberdeen Group
dawned on me that the specifier 1. Michael R. Lindeburg, Civil En- All rights reserved

Table 3. Metric mixture proportioning example

Proportioning concrete using metric


Proportioning concrete using metric units is actually simpler than using inch-pound units since the unit weight
of water is 1kg/L, which simplifies the mass-to-volume conversions. An example of concrete proportioned using
metric units is shown below.
Develop metric mixture proportions for Ingredient Specific Volume Mass
concrete with the following characteristics: gravity m3 kg
Cement: 350 kg/m3 Cement 3.15 0.111 350
Silica fume: 35 kg/m3 Silica fume 2.22 0.016 35
Water 1.00 0.154 154
Water-cementitious Air – 0.060 –
materials ratio: 0.40 Fine aggregate 2.63 0.297 781
Fine aggregate Course aggregate 2.67 0.362 967
specific gravity: 2.63 1.000 2,287
Coarse aggregate
specific gravity: 2.67
Air entrainer: 175 mL
Fine aggregate to be 45% of total aggregate High-range water reducer: 3,500 mL
volume Bulk density: 2,287 kg/m3
Entrained air: 6%

Air entrainer 50 mL/100kg Cement: 350 kg 3.15 = 0.111 m3


High-range water reducer 1000 mL/100kg Paste volume: = 0.341 m3
Total aggregate
Remember:
volume: 1.000 m3 – 0.341 m3 = 0.659 m3
1000 L = 1m3 1 L of water has FA = 45% = 0.297 m3
a mass of 1 kg 297 2.63 = 781 kg

Source: Reference 2.

You might also like