Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Berg Metaphor and Comparison in The Dialogues of Plato 00berg
Berg Metaphor and Comparison in The Dialogues of Plato 00berg
^ft^W
-.-^.^V
/.
m«|^
- A^^^'
\^^'^f\\
.^^i^::
^«^«A/^
'^»ti» f
- - , ^A /
^A'^, ^;lNlf^
V^^a'^A,^^
i^#i /» O^-^r.A^/
•rr VV^.'
'^TT-
:J.tT
f^^^^^v^s^^ ArN:^^>'
.%^.,..^^-^^::^^^«^^;^
K;^A^^,
^.^^A^i^O^Oo^^^S^^'?^;^'^^rv^0^c:)..^r^-'^ '^M^***^'
r^/^^,^^;Qn'^:C i^;sA''^'^.C'''A'''f>''
sA r\r\riy^'
'f,r^r^r^-/^r
"'Sr^Sfy/yfy,,
ai^'^
^'^.^mmtf^^ime''
.^iyr^^f^^'^''^'^r<^'
'^-^:^^^;^'}^^: A^^fc^p-^;^:
'V^^^/^^
??i**-*'*5t2iifs*^::':
,,^/^^AAA' M- . '
.^ r'^O'^-
f7^-^
^^^iTA^^^^:??^^'^^^
•/^-•.fsi-xr'ii^
^A^^
^^a;--^
/^r^'>^^'^^
il^ft^y^;
y-^;;^^.^^' •""
^r^.t^rlr.^-^'-:''
.
a; a --p ^/^r^"^a'^^a-
^ '^^ ^.'^^ -^ A^ri mT. Aa^^^^'
^^':'W!M^^^'
f-^'^:/^';
^^'^^^.^'^^^-^
^"^^
/r'^^
MM^' w^'^'
^^r
>^/^/^
^.^^^^.^rfff\f^
A'^^n
..O/f^^^^
^^SAaSj
..».CAA^^"^^'"^>^^V'-"..iA4iwvv,A;-"-^C)5J^-2*;;Ai
,
' . c .^. h J.
— -^^^^^Jjy'^AXk
1/ -is>c'_e^
u-
o
M^ <^'^ '^>hJ(/<--<lC<yu/Ut-<UlyU^ (Ui-C/uyiJLCKj % ^ "ULc- jt^t^Ct
i^'
iuJ
-^
o f
''
li.' /, 7^ - ^
• , ^ /
/
H
6
^V.
"...
3. ^/
;7r
'Xu.^.^y<xA- A/^5uvt4/t^ 'yyjCLk/if '''Cu!"t~^ -i^.JyUi^ ^xJLt.cry-''^^yyvtiyux'
CO
{ u' J - J
J •
a
%' n
7Yt >v'»'tu<' C't-^^cX^'^^-^^i^ /4v6-M^ VpL.ixA- u>1>uJlo 'i'-o-r'^L.^
<vvfl 'y^-yjyi^
'^i,^.,<iA//lld> OAX'
t
^
r
!i
: U If 1 J ^ ,
b
,
d
V 1 ft > I '^
V /^ '^ /
(jyUjiA/^^
ly^
r.ir^.yc;^:
r 'C^'t-C'Tut-M^
o ^ JO A
I
^
C^-/yvUjL' ^U-id^-ov, "Ot-*^ ^X^ T/uc^ TTo^ ^ «r /iU? '>7 u>'fUM^
A^
/^
7
($^^MaJa^ -m^ "^i^M^
U _
'
^
,6-
O'
hi .
• . • ^ ^ .
'I
^ •
'
•
'^^
O Ii
n
J
^ ^ ^ V.
/ r y I,
, \\
[ \
u
^?
)^y
'J ' ^ J .
I
^
i/
A
'7"
't'M^'
J O ^ 1/
.HlO
U I J
1^
^n r
^0
:t <^'^<~' yyuMiyp i-i^hy •^jyt-n^j) aMX'Ooi TaZiU
i. Jl^0^y\^
HD .X7S
SCS
HD
7. .171
16 .UL.
II. .315.
II (2^t^jJU^
:ii^.
.Ill
li. ili
/7 . J-^.-, .loH i.m
;o
5-6
<^ 7^u6- 'taJyU^ .i^'A-^f-ti^t'^, 'n.^rr il^-t^ TKju^ 4^-iy^ cry MroA-
r ^
- n .
T-1
^y
vLyyn^M.ir^ V -c^
,
-LI ^ B- c ^
>-7i B^ D ,Xl7^ ^ll^B,
'1/
^ j^Mti^^c^i-^i^^ ^. (^. ^. :2 2^
'^ ^. -Ld/
f,
3D
^-^
b
J \
^V ^ •
DP f
"
V
V
I
A^iyiJj i^-^i^^u-t-T^ -tf^K^'A'Mi-'^Lc' Irurr-^i^ \ ^/ ^-^-^ -^"'y'uy cL' rwz-^.-^
t
-J <J u
lil
^- MJ. .
?-UUn^ JW^v<kt^i3^ur>u 1^-^^ji-
31-
<^
u
yy^y^^vL- i^i-'rfu^ io-uv^uj^ A^^-<Jco 2'-j ^ K- X J"^ ^ CU
j
7^^<t^Vt<t'<y'vtK? <ViO '^f-C^U'^-t-t^ ^^u^"T?1''tc7 --^-^•^*^^K^ '^-tJ Pw^^x/-
/
'1
\ u
3^
''
j jtj
^
(?.,/
/ 0' ^
II
"VUyLy cLa,^JC^'<j,^'UJL. ^
^ t^
_
^We/f, i^A^. 2Z^/^
_
/^n el;^^^
,
^ v^.^^ww..^ />
'Jkuvu-
. c
11
^U «- .q^fxiMA^ ^f'B <^ /X^J
"
«372 ^f( 1^63 Jij. UC/\, ^073^ ^itj)
'^
/ n - i
^
^ J
<^i9-c<^ .-i^ t^u^ "^-i^^ V-/ ^ ^--^z -llc^ e^ltl^^TyuL^ ^^^^'
r %ij
7-
/^X><u\QyOtX^
^ '
[I
I
^
\ U J
' " r C
CK^
I'
^
i ^ J
7jJ
-'U^t-n.^:^^
H^
so
,,-Wl,
<r/
.'•'1
,^ »t«^ C , BH di t^ B ^-0 olLl^ .-^m. t$u^ cA>-^ili -^fe^^-^'-^c^TL-
^c^ C-tS'-j'T^ -
J2-
-— ^.^^.^ 1
'
'J I
^
J
7 /
^j
/^
n/
J
(^ A<?rc5 TtAtvT'i^'n ^*<- p-^ dt/Kojv-tey'cx ciit^rD
T uj vorfiovji Pii
ifcp A oy
Aoytcy aKo-n^. t-^^^vv^^ <C'xZc4 i-'o-
u
V
-
S'i
I
^"TUIjAa' X7C V'tcMt&iJ( UMttu^'t^J- ^Z^t/uvtcfu^-t^ -K) WnCUA.^ ~U)
n
''j
'P-PC x«-+-C.~
i
*''
J
tD
^ -
J
t \
^ J L< i/ g p (M t^t^ / To rifkh/J*^^' &(M^ ''^v' T'y] Y'*^ y^cKTd^i^i^-
*
C
6i
^
, ^ , ^/ r-P
-r; ,.
zJC —-^ ~ 'tvf-vw ^U/yi.x^^tiyi^ o.^<Zj(^ a^t^ t^tA^ TH/iX' -<.^<^ o^ T^^^a-tt*' -
-
(-3
t
.
^
ll
i
^
(.^
rio^
^t-t-o A.,'
s ^ . "i -v . i|
^ly r^^/ri-U^^^^ ^-ayvi- (yi /lu^ iK^^l "Lm^. H^33 ey[ H'^Hd
L I I ;|
l/
I
rt-rx y ^\!iKO^
-
t6
Vet;
J
/i^j <siAf f4x<uJy^. rL^'nd]^- Z'^S'4 Tfc^r-r^c vcxxu^yxjo^
11
7.
'
= / \
J
J. •
-^T-jtV^t
(VJ.
n
I ^ ^ L y r^ \ "}/ ^ ^l
iu:l^.-
i' f
I
i-j Id 7^
^ ] \
-rf'^'^'ni r<aiKLaiS '^POiP'cZ H U\X^ IZi/h.'CL^^ • \\
'^O^XX/C
• '
II
a '' ^ 1
^,y\^
I
'^
A / .•I
^
I) ^ y n "o^ °^ \ -^ " ^ ^ c
OfuXo^odfOv Ctvocu cv^TToP Toy Utp l toC b-itlol d(j<3-~
^ //^fs/ cl/ e/ ,
/
. 2^/^ #^6 //' '?7 1/ Ta P ~
r
-yT-T.^Z.'-yl,^ "'^T'iH^^-'yi..^^ !
9\
j^iii^UUVv
I
y - — jM>Uxt^xi^t-<;vL<.-^^->i^ .<d/^T.'eMM-y\^ ^pj-t^-^v^ fi-^^-Ot-^tZ ^t^^t-t-i-^^? ^ i
t
\
i/uuO-n^ t^f^ HH '^ t^j^ix^iA^ -£^^t>w 'liAM.-u^ if-t<yt<^ ^ /ve/3/t^-
ii
^ a^
'^->^ —
1/
tZ-^t^t^yS^o-^^Cc^-^^.-e^ to ^Mli^t^L.ix^tZ^ live 'r^'^-<:V'-yurU/i^ -^^^ u>A^.J;i^
M>-pu;
I'
Y^
C-ff-yy^-^
'^ wv^^^U^ "t^t-^-ipf 7^ 'P'^ydJi £^0.ycA^ cCUu^L^ fi-^ir^u^ t^ JU^>x.z^
(TCf oLLpT^l.
r
-1'
tC<A)-
U-^y\^t^<nc<:
f3
i
f ;
I—
VrJyiJL ''>'VT^^<^ ^r^<^A}^ XU-Ua^ .e^Vt^^7*-t^ ^t-w "tn,^ C-jJ^-vus.^ '^c-<^v^
\J
Mil ^ K-\\ y^D voY Uxn. t/oo^jcii i^ripcp Tru T^t /W?i-
%
"/'^^^^
^1
/uMa. -
(P4- <u/kjla.mX ti^^^^nyii Yv\^y(\^ LOV yi^ Ai^iJLA -v^^iH^^
^ -^ ''
'?•
' ^ ^(L.
1 ? •
1^
"u-^ <^L<^MVU^' •
(> Lvi^n^; uu-Ku^ t*-;^ ~Vh.^ syi^ijy^ "/L^sx^l^ CjAAZ-t^o
^ / /
V ^'
3^ / V /O / { C ^ \
TT/^i^V 2\' JiJMTJi TL^ T0\/ IoloV d i-^ ^ ^ ^ M-^'
^^
TE- A 6
1
U/d^i- -KinLL^ .u^^vm-tX-Vi; z^>-nx«? •r^y^yyu <'*-^'^lU. ^irr^"*-^^ "^xju ^i^U:^AX ~
VC'A-^t''*^ '1HVVi1<HX>-T'1'^
C-f^^vi^ tiA^C^-tm i.t-'^^v^.oA 'f-o-^M^'-w^ 'yy^vi/ x-i^:^ 'U-^ cc^'i^^yytc^ nA^LC '
\
ITl
I f.ot
O I' ^ v'
^
'
li
^^f-^ \
10'
^
I 1/
J
,
iZcd O'l^ 7>t<Lt-U?i<u<^d<; 'y^^-ti^ -VUiyi^ xf^O"^ ^-y-ru.^n^
lOb
» ^ 1 . ft
"
L-t-t-
1/
'"^y^jCOx^A^-.^'^-'if^ "^^"U^ C<rvn/i7,<^Ax-<^<?^>^c7 yt-rf-y'j/L^ Vviu^
u
\
I
^ ^ J t ^
IlL
ii
•'
I,
-<**/'
-
5 'thjL.
^ . I
/ V () i/ (/ (/ i;'
'^
cl
//^
T^ At'At< 0(VT-nS i^Sc T'n5 ii /Celt ^^^ i; t^ri t)J tcoj^i^io j^tV^'j
'
'''
l'
"
• • • />
;
;< M lO V <5'u7 T'n o ^ oc /
V r\ •v c
t '^ '/
U /) //
c / r f
//^
i^Hy-i'^ZJl ^(^ (X\i' ojs cku oc\ j^ ^tl- Koi^u dl^ nyi^'S rr^i--
<M K ^ S ; Sir- ^$ Tto^ CTi /^' e rc« l ', (^ly^^ BCj I^ T^^u^
J^ ^ 3 .
'
i.
/xo
Lvav-
3 -^;i,''t-c-«-<'-»t-
•IJI,^ Or-A.-^ -^^ /if it<^ 4.-*-v CiyyjCOi^L^d^^'^'^ U>t7A- t^H-t- A^'l'^^yU^
Ill
\ -^
(J
TT.
I i^yt:'i<lLA^^yiy^yf yn^j- ; u: -^
i
t-IO
CL^
I
1^1
Lr U "
J
:.1^ (,
--^J-i-l-- , *2 "2/,
I
C/ & -^
ptvj^K
^ -^ J) / J
^'oir^p cxu^i^ dlryoK^vTU) j^'^vov ^ (jfp-
I
J
.'"
t*Jti^
I
/U/l'' Hh''^ D "l^Hc ^n^M^ m-ct-vv- tWU-i^u -^^ ~Ph^x^
jl
Tap T^^tui^-a)l/ 7rc>Ai^tM
i3v
£A\
r^ji
<^ dM^ j-^Mx. I'j^ B "TOY D(yprhv Kov'y]yvr^^ u,tTciv^y
I
/?i
^
^
/ f II
-y] p Ui e'e^s
i\C 13 cv^rriiv -Kp^t^ ly^-ti kol-t^ r« kJk tx u.p^M.f.^ffc:j\\ 4
'
^yU/J'X'^ ^.H^ -ii^ <</V-Uyk .-t^V^ TtUjU/U- "^^^V-tf^-^^ 'f-TT^Ti^ '/-L^-^^l/A-
';
TO -n^v ^oyiTh^roclvir^, d S /\.^ •^^^j J^f^K. l^HD Ti-KnuL-,
il
^^ -
) , 2" -^
« w c/ . /
1 ri
-) .--»
1^0
^
I
" ^ J h
.
'''^ "n^ AA/vUU. 9'. iJJLt' cM^Xtc. (^rt^ t^^^^vw^y <^ '''"^ "^^
.
I
IHI
\
^ '
''
^ ( / ^ e I
'
C - / ;
-
/
-r-t-
Hi^
p^
ii J
,
(EJ _
I 3 '^ "^ f'fuy CyC<AJc4> A^ry^ o^^ <h^i-^ .i^W- z^.-mt^ Oxx^h^-
'^
\
1 \ \
It/ f ^ ^
f
U , .J J
/
^
o ^
H'^6'^ TOJ \cy^ ^crrep l^TPU) TT^Co t-'y^Lw ocTT^KPi-
VOL) \
JX. 'V^^ i3 LW^^ irs.p ^ myy Sl icu^s'rmi/ lo^jt^o
J
H't[
[-
lo'O
J/ .-//,/ /- 3 (
"^-^ -^
r * 'I J' / *
,
TT&p 6 e^ \ bV rt- 5
J
l2AAXLt4^M .
If B o \o;r^ ^ '^rt^ u^X ^^'
,
-— - — ^-^.-^.-^ K
I-
I
.
^-VU^ '.vui^^
'T-^T, ^ ^ A^. i^J /^ ,
T-^vl^ y~j£ T-r^v ;<^ri
/.
•-V If
i a;'
3 i"
W ^ -^
T^^t ^-^ i'C/l/l^V 7^ 7?T>v
^^T^K-Co. . l'-tMu^<XjL^
J
^-c ^^bAi^^c^^ % T'K^ /(yia-^^ Til^ £ylCl-Ay<^
C^^-vt-^t^iC;
\
O o
KuY Aoi^wCi/' A c\ t? <? / TiN - - - ^ '^ 7TK/ rtH; ^<n/)U- 6^i31/ ive'TTTl'
f
I
^ \ c *• \ ^ 1 J
t' tf^v pc^rov
^VTOCS \Jlr^ ^'^Po}L<> t"/ -Vyvs V0\/ \o.fOL5 . tyi p(HAyf-%7^^
'S'
I fluhXcUii/ ,,
^f^'i^ylx^e^U CUcJi ^,^ujju/^ plMtl^ui
/ ^ /
-
"^r uj>
^fV 's
die. I //V/i ^^^^Pl^^ S^S-c^^ Toct 6'oC<, TT/oc?-
^ c/ ?^ c ^ . V 5 / /
\ / c/ c / / c/ -v
CL ^
1^/
'
'J ' v^
flyv^t^'v^ '•
: T'^^<Mjy. ^fA d^Vio-S Too T^'i -^ ^^ i/'-^f
^
.J' •
^ ^ ^ 91 --^z _ y
/U
I vJ w
Ij
^ - /
rr
^
/ ^ (I
I
] ^ ^
(\ J
kh
J/
J
C^.AAyi^i.^t^
clue
_ c/ < c
l^.
L
, c5
*)( 11 "?- /-C^rcM, c--^ 1/ -tVc^ -t-t^ <^ C-O-n^t-i^ .1ZAA..^L.<^t \^/l. J 7 ^^
'i
I(>1
^'O^/Oy^yy^
CJCii^
.
^ /I ,
^-
c
" / •
I'
'
1 J J
175
U^. ^fO /) ^
p^ldd- r7A ^ su^^-n fob ^ S'^ ^y
1/
^
v'
II
^
\
- ^ I V I
^
J
Are
/
US'
C/ ^
'C'U^
r
^ -U^ ii'C^^ 'jj-Lc ^Y^'ito^'^'^ju) to -^ ^ .
'^^^ ~^^vt4^ j-^ry-
f-
/ / -»
/ I
V -'Z V
dxLLccyp^ v'&u^'SU^tO^ t^^ iOvri^'^ ^/-<^^^ 7"a ^jh^'^'t; Toe
^
" ^
i
1
.' .
•
.
.^ ^ ^' ^/^ ..
'
(Jo r/ ^/
n
^ )
'
ti^
'
i^ O5 ^^ t-TJ-C-t-t'ti^ '^--c^^
/H
'U^ C'^>-y^^ -
isl
L 6
,, uu j '
/
' ^ I
c/ £ .'^
I :? ~ (' / ^ *
,_,
r\ .^ c / -^ ^ 'N / /
^
rr / ^ ^ .
'^"
^
IL
\£^iryvv4>
Jr. '\J
^
'•J
-hf J ' J J "^ "^
' ^
^ — '"
:> /
~J ~ r J J U ,
nf
[ ! J I
/
CO-
/^
:ij^5
1 J
^
I
'^
^ > ^ ^ 2 ^ \ ^
*^ <^vv^^'^ 'jyJCiyi,
no
J I
'
I
2^1/u iM:^/U/i^ 4^ 'Kt^ 4A<^aA^; o6 ~p <? Tro K erg.
'^'^i'Uy'^^yy'^ ^t'VU.—
u ^A^rrioL y-^J
?2
'i/L^ "
/
e.^ ^t^wa. i^^z-i i<i(o B. 2^10 :b
•J V
'I
I' y
3 \
, (^ ^ (^ /I C5^C' ?-; TT^u c e 77X TT^t/
T
^-t-ir
d-tK/Xt^^:5 ^ cvv
t^:
arrv
u
^ojiyy yi<x\toV e^iCe^p b^<^ivou [^ a<hji^li^ <^Tro<:f\i^i4^yi/u-onl
^ I -> ^ / -5
<^ '
r C ^ \
'
J
-"
J
'VV\
L
(^ -^(j^-CCl^'M^ /*U/tM/t-i^w VKuo--^^^ "yhJL. -^^^^yi^ % .<^
-V /' c /
2>. '^CUaJ^ tt^ix^ ijX-'i^
'
I;
. 'J
U
XL '" ^^Tf^f pt^i-i^] {^j^iuy^ }^H B olo/ t}^!-^^ p^H^
J) ^ '^
L
<- / .>
/
^ '
^ :!
T
i
'kbi
^lU^z^t^
J
"J •/
^
^PM**.... ', ->^s»TWM^v..,< ;;.:^^^
'"v« « '
" A-^.A'
'
\^.. . A r^/^occ"^'^'-- ' .
,'.^,/^^^Apx•^"^'^^••^''^. ./'^'.«^'^'^'-?o^.
^^^ai5«c' ^^^^^Ar,OA''^;'^r^'^^,^??.''
^^wa 'CC^'^.'>
::--..'~^.,.>sK«»*'"'^^ ''^s;j««}A«fl^
v» ^ />, •^ r^
'^V-''-''^/^'^'- '-^^5?^=p?«»;^
-^r^oPo^O^^^
>Ar^.Or
^^^««A.'
•;vr--'^'^ f^.^. ^
,/^/^0'1/
^:"^a^^^/^^^?^'?5??5:^^!^^^a;
A':< ->/
^^^^^^r'y'^r'>n^Q'^
"^'^/^'. ...'
.
*^rni^ >^^/^,A
^^.ft<^?^'^*^-i5^AA-J il'^l^^^sS
«?"
>^MV»^M^;.eVS^^^:
'f^^f^l'f^^
ife^^^s.^