Professional Documents
Culture Documents
International Journal of Infectious Diseases: Kevin B. Laupland, Lisa Steele, Kelsey Pasquill, Elizabeth C. Par Fitt
International Journal of Infectious Diseases: Kevin B. Laupland, Lisa Steele, Kelsey Pasquill, Elizabeth C. Par Fitt
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijid.2020.12.064
1201-9712/© 2020 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd on behalf of International Society for Infectious Diseases. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND
license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
K.B. Laupland, L. Steele, K. Pasquill et al. International Journal of Infectious Diseases 104 (2021) 45–49
of S. aureus BSI in our region and examine secular changes using histograms to assess their underlying distribution. Medians
associated with the implementation of a novel clinical infectious with interquartile ranges (IQR) were used to describe skewed
diseases service. variables and groups were compared using the k-medians
(Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney) test. Categorical variables were com-
Methods pared using Fisher’s exact test.
Incidence data were expressed as annual rates per 100,000
Surveillance population population using regional population data. Direct age- and sex-
standardized of incidence rates against the 2019 western interior
Population-based surveillance for all S. aureus BSI occurring population was performed using 5-year age strata through to age
among individuals residing in the western interior of British 89 years and then 90 years and older. This was calculated for the
Columbia, Canada was conducted between April 1, 2010 and March Kamloops area specifically whereas the data for the other local
31, 2020 (Laupland et al., 2019a). The western interior region (total health areas were pooled.
population in 2019 191,000) encompasses the city of Kamloops A logistic regression model was developed to investigate factors
(population in 2019 123,000) and a large and geographically associated with 30-day all-cause case-fatality. We a priori selected
diverse area inclusive of 6 local health areas (Cariboo–Chilcotin, variables of infectious diseases consultation: age, gender, Charlson
100 Mile House, Lillooet, South Cariboo, Merritt, and North comorbidity index, infection onset category, diagnostic group,
Thompson) within the southern interior of the province of British residency in Kamloops versus other area, MSSA vs MRSA,
Columbia. Within this region, tertiary care is provided at the Royal admission to tertiary care, and echocardiography in the initial
Inland Hospital in Kamloops with care also provided in 5 smaller model. Stepwise variable elimination and grouping of categorical
hospitals in the region. The Interior Health Research Ethics Board variables was then performed to develop the most parsimonious
granted a waiver of individual informed consent (201314052-I). model. After the putative model was developed we re-inserted
eliminated variables one-by-one to test for effect in the final
Study protocol model. The final model discrimination and calibration were
assessed using the area under the receiver operator characteristic
S. aureus BSI cases were initially identified by the regional and Hosmer-Lemeshow test, respectively. In all statistical testing
laboratory based in Kamloops. Once positive blood cultures were we deemed a P-value of <0.05 to represent significance.
identified, a case-by-case review of the electronic medical charts
was conducted by one investigator (a senior infectious diseases Results
consultant) to further classify cases as incident episodes, apply
definitions, and obtain clinical details. Population incidence
Residency status was established based on town/postal code of
primary residence and non-residents of the surveillance area were During the decade of surveillance, 581 incident S. aureus BSI
excluded. For the purposes of this study methicillin-sensitive were identified among 540 individuals for an overall crude annual
(MSSA) and methicillin-resistant (MRSA) strains were deemed to incidence of 31.9 per 100,000. Of these, 460 (79.2%) and 121 (20.8%)
be separate. The first isolate of S. aureus per episode of disease was were MSSA and MRSA, respectively. While both MSSA and MRSA
deemed to be the incident isolate and all positive cultures within BSI were most commonly healthcare-associated (227; 49.4% and
the following 30-days were considered as part of that episode even 66; 54.6%. respectively), MSSA were more likely to be community-
if there was a period of culture negativity within that time frame. associated (161; 35% vs 22; 18.2%; P < 0.001) and less likely to be of
The total number of isolations, as well as the time (in days) from hospital-onset (72; 15.7% vs. 33; 27.3%; P = 0.005) as compared to
index positive culture draw to last positive isolate from that MRSA BSI.
episode, were recorded. Two-thirds of S. aureus BSI episodes were in males (363/581;
A most likely diagnosis/source of infection related to the S. 62.5%) and the median age was 64.7 (IQR, 53.3–76.6). The overall
aureus BSI was assigned based on an overall assessment of all age- and gender-adjusted annual incidence rate was 32.9 per
available microbiology, clinical, laboratory, and diagnostic imaging 100,000 population and was 34.0 and 30.9 per 100,000 among
information. Comorbidities were recorded as per Charlson et al residents of Kamloops and the other areas, respectively. There was
(Charlson et al., 1987), and episodes were classified as community- an annual increase in the incidence of S. aureus BSI during the study
associated, healthcare-associated, and hospital-onset as per Fried-
man et al (Friedman et al., 2002). Death at 30-days post index
infection was determined using provincial vital statistics informa-
tion (Laupland et al., 2019b). Echocardiography was recorded as
not done, transthoracic only, or transesophageal transthoracic
related to the BSI episode. An infectious diseases consult was
evidenced by a full consultation note although in some cases this
was deemed to be present where clear written evidence of an
assessment and recommended plan as established with a specific
named infectious diseases consultant was included in the
electronic chart. Management at the tertiary centre was docu-
mented by some or all of the admission to hospital at the Royal
Inland Hospital in Kamloops. Length of stay in hospital was
calculated as an inclusive sum of all hospital admissions (including
interhospital transfer) associated with the BSI episode.
Analysis
Figure 1. Blood culture sampling rate and incidence of Staphylococcus aureus
bloodstream infection during a decade of surveillance in the western interior of
All data were analysed using Stata 16.0 (StataCorp, College British Columbia, Canada (culture rate refers to all blood cultures performed in the
Station, USA). Prior to analysis, all continuous data were examined study region).
46
K.B. Laupland, L. Steele, K. Pasquill et al. International Journal of Infectious Diseases 104 (2021) 45–49
that was associated with an increased population culturing rate as 24.6% vs. 31/215; 14.4; P = 0.004) and to have an infectious diseases
shown in Figure 1. consultation (211/366; 57.7% vs. 91/215; 42.3%; P < 0.001).
However, no difference was observed for age, gender, Charlson
Clinical determinants and secular changes comorbidity index, onset of infection, diagnosis, or case-fatality
among Kamloops and other area residents.
Demographic and clinical determinants across the 3 eras of
infectious diseases program pre-implementation (2010–2012), Infectious diseases consultation
development (2013–2016), and full service (2017–2019) are
displayed in Table 1. Age, sex, hospital admission details, and Overall 302/581 (52.0%) of episodes had a documented
the proportion of MRSA versus MSSA infections did not vary among infectious diseases consultation. Patients who received infectious
the 3 eras (Table 1). Ninety-five per cent of patients (554/581) were diseases consultation were twice as likely to have an echocardio-
admitted for management and this did not vary among the 3 eras gram (281/302; 93.0% vs. 133/279; 47.7%; P < 0.0001), and 3 times
(P = 0.6). However, later eras were associated with increased more likely (69/302; 22.8% vs. 20/279; 7.2%; P < 0.0001) a
echocardiography performance, demonstration of persistent transesophageal echocardiogram, than patients who did not have
positive blood cultures, and diagnosis of fewer non-focal infections an infectious diseases consultation. Those managed with infec-
(Table 1). tious diseases consultation were more than twice as likely (128/
The overall median follow-up time was 429 (IQR 43–1141) days. 302; 42.4% vs 48/279; 17.2%; P < 0.0001) to have >2 positive blood
Thirty-eight (6.5%) patients had a second episode, 2 a third (<1%), cultures.
and 1 patient a fourth episode of S. aureus BSI. The median time The overall 30-day case-fatality per episode was significantly
between subsequent episodes was 132 (IQR, 50.8–393.8) days. lower in association with infectious diseases consultation (43/302;
Recurrence within 1 year was less likely in the later eras as shown 14.2% vs. 85/279; 30.4%; P < 0.0001). A logistic regression model
in Table 1. limited to the 540 first episodes of S. aureus BSI had good
As compared to other areas of the western interior, residents of discrimination (area under receiver operator characteristic =
the Kamloops area were more likely to have an MRSA BSI (90/366; 0.8180) and calibration (goodness of fit P = 0.9) and found
Table 1
Characteristics among during pre-, development and full service implementation of a clinical infectious diseases service.
47
K.B. Laupland, L. Steele, K. Pasquill et al. International Journal of Infectious Diseases 104 (2021) 45–49
Table 2
Logistic regression of factors associated with 30-day all-cause case fatality among 540 first episodes of Staphylococcus aureus bloodstream infection.
infectious diseases consultation associated with reduced risk for et al., 2020). Importantly, residents external to Kamloops were not
death as shown in Table 2. at increased risk for adverse outcome in our study (excluded from
the model; Table 2), as other studies have suggested that telephone
Discussion support alone may be inadequate (Forsblom et al., 2013). Although
we do not have the empiric data to demonstrate this, our
This study demonstrates the major burden of illness associated contention is that the improvements in management that have
S. aureus BSI and the benefit of the implementation of a novel occurred following infectious diseases service implementation
clinical infectious diseases service in mixed rural to small city have been the result of direct consultation and the indirect effects
regional population. Our observation of an annual incidence rate of of increased awareness of the importance of S. aureus BSI.
33 per 100,000 is comparable to that observed in other studies While this study benefits from population-based design and
conducted in Australia, New Zealand, Europe, and North America ability to stepwise measure the effect of the implementation of a
(El Atrouni et al., 2009; Huggan et al., 2010; Lam et al., 2019; novel infectious diseases clinical service, some limitations merit
Laupland et al., 2013; Laupland et al., 2008; Opintan and Newman, discussion. First, this is an observational study and unmeasured
2017). It is noteworthy that we observed a similar rate of 30.9 per variables could be confounding our assessment of the benefit of
100,000 in the areas of the western interior other than Kamloops. infectious diseases consultation. The quality and availability of
This area is vast (91,000 km2), geographically diverse, and has a electronic records have improved during the past decade and
very low population density (<1 resident/ km2) with the next changes over time in some variables (i.e., Charlson comorbidities)
largest centre represented by the city of Williams Lake (city and may be influenced in part by the inclusion of more detailed data in
surrounding population 18,000 residents). Much of the previous later years. Second, improvements in care may be at least
population-based study on S. aureus BSI has been reported from attributable to general improvements in service provision during
academic centres primarily based in urban centres. It is an the past decade. Major recruitment and programmatic develop-
important finding that we observed similar epidemiology of ment have occurred with an approximate doubling of medical
S. aureus BSI in our mixed rural to small city population. speciality services. Third, we did not record therapy details such as
Several studies have investigated the role of infectious diseases the type, route, and duration of antimicrobial therapy nor
consultation on the outcome associated with S. aureus BSI interventions for source control. While we suspect that these
(Kawasuji et al., 2020; Sherbuk et al., 2019; Suzuki et al., 2020; changed with the implementation of the infectious diseases
Vogel et al., 2016). Vogel et al conducted a systematic review of the service we do not have the actual evidence to support this claim.
literature on this topic and included 18 reports inclusive of more Fourth, we did not record the date and time of consultation such
than 5,000 patients (Vogel et al., 2016). Infectious diseases that timeliness could not be evaluated as an outcome determinant.
consultation was found to be associated with improved antimi- However, it is our standard practice to receive all consults by
crobial therapy, increased use of echocardiography and repeat physician-to-physician telephone request with initial immediate
cultures, and a 30-day case fatality reduction (relative risk 0.53; discussion of management. Provision of comprehensive bedside
95% CI 0.43–0.65) (Vogel et al., 2016). We considered increased use clinical consultation is performed same-day during weekdays and
of repeat blood cultures (or documentation of persistent bacter- next-day during the after-hours. Fifth, it is possible that early
emia), fewer cases without an identified focus of infection, and use deaths occurring prior to the opportunity to have infectious
of echocardiography to be measures of improved care associated diseases consultation could have influenced results. However, a
with S. aureus BSI. While we do not have evidence of changes in post hoc analysis of our logistic regression model limited to
anti-microbial therapy, our study findings provide further evi- survivors to at least 2 days showed no significant changes in the
dence in support of the value of infectious diseases consultation in parameters. Finally, data collection was retrospective and, as a
non-academic centres. result, we were limited to an assessment of information that was
We observed several changes associated with the development available in the chart. While variability was minimized by
and implementation of the infectious diseases service in our assessment by a single expert reviewer, the possibility of
region, including increased blood culture sampling rates, docu- incomplete data remains.
mentation of persistent bacteremia, and use of both transthoracic In summary, this study reports results of a decade of
and transesophageal echocardiography (Laupland et al., 2018). surveillance for S. aureus BSI in a mixed rural to small city
Before 2013, only telephone advice or transfer to a hospital population and provides evidence to support the value of the
external to the region were available for infectious diseases implementation of clinical infectious diseases programs in non-
consultation (Parfitt et al., 2020). Starting in 2013, direct academic centres.
consultation access increased and by 2017 full service was
available. However, it is important to note that infectious diseases Funding
consultants were based only in Kamloops such that patients in
other areas of the western interior were required to either be This research did not receive any specific grant from funding
transferred to Kamloops or managed by telephone support (Parfitt agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
48
K.B. Laupland, L. Steele, K. Pasquill et al. International Journal of Infectious Diseases 104 (2021) 45–49
49