Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2012 Arrivillaga Et Al HIV AIDS Treatment Adherence in Economically Better Off Women in Colombia
2012 Arrivillaga Et Al HIV AIDS Treatment Adherence in Economically Better Off Women in Colombia
2012 Arrivillaga Et Al HIV AIDS Treatment Adherence in Economically Better Off Women in Colombia
AIDS Care
Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/caic20
To cite this article: Marcela Arrivillaga, Andrew E. Springer, Monica Lopera, Diego Correa, Bernardo Useche &
Michael W. Ross (2012): HIV/AIDS treatment adherence in economically better off women in Colombia, AIDS Care,
DOI:10.1080/09540121.2011.647678
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to
anyone is expressly forbidden.
The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents
will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae, and drug doses should
be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims,
proceedings, demand, or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in
connection with or arising out of the use of this material.
AIDS Care
2012, 17, iFirst
Studies on HIV/AIDS treatment adherence have been carried out in a limited number of geographic settings, but
few studies have explored it in people of higher socioeconomic status in Latin America. This qualitative study
explored and compared determinants of adherence behaviors among 52 HIV-positive Colombian women in
Downloaded by [Marcela Arrivillaga] at 08:55 24 January 2012
medium and high socioeconomic positions (SPs). Findings indicated that the two SP groups reported high
adherence behaviors related to taking medication, following a diet, and executing lifestyle changes in line with
healthcare providers’ recommendations. Nevertheless, differences were observed between the two groups. While
women with a medium SP disclosed their diagnosis, were empowered, and had acceptable access to economic
resources that resulted in favorable adherence, their better off counterparts tended to hide their status and made a
conscious effort to keep their adherence behaviors in secret due to HIV-related stigma. More studies on
adherence of people living with HIV/AIDS from high SPs should be conducted to better understand how
psychosocial support can be provided and to advance the knowledge of how and why adherence practices in these
groups are undertaken.
Keywords: adherence; socioeconomic position; gender; stigma
HIV-positive women were identified through health view. (4) Conclusions of the FGD. Data were
care center registers with the following inclusion collected to complete the criteria of theme saturation.
criteria: receiving antiretroviral therapy (ART),
age]18, not pregnant, and a classification of med-
ium or high socioeconomic position (SP) according to Data analysis
the country’s official socioeconomic classification. Data obtained in the FGDs were digitally recorded
Out of a total of 185 women registered in four for later transcription and analysis. Content analysis
healthcare centers, 68 (36%) were eligible. Of these (Deslauriers, 1991) consisted of two phases: (1) Data
68, 52 agreed to participate in the FGDs. To control deconstruction and (2) Data reconstruction and
selection bias, women were recruited from compre- synthesis. In the first phase, after a systematic reading
hensive HIV care programs in places directed toward of the transcriptions, we transformed data into codes.
women of all socioeconomic status levels. To begin Atlas Ti v5.2 software was used, resulting in the
the recruitment process, women were invited with an identification of 67 quotation groupings based on
initial phone call made directly by personnel from 35 codes. Afterward, we proceeded to analyze the
the respective health care center. Finally, all of the initial data codification obtained from the text; for
women were formally recruited by a second phone this analysis, we considered the frequency of the
call following strict protocols for ensuring their codes. In the second phase, we organized codes in
confidentiality. specific categories, identifying recurrent patterns to
Women in the medium SP were considered social obtain emergent categories that were described and
level 3 or 4 by the official system of the Colombian interpreted. In this process, we maximized differences
Government. They had a technical or undergraduate dividing data into groups and later synthesized codes
educational level and were affiliated with a basic into dominant themes. To ensure the validity and
health care plan. Their job/occupational profiles reliability of data, we carried out the following steps:
included: housewives, small business owners, self- (1) Discussion sessions between researchers to com-
employed with a steady income, employees at private pare original transcripts and the analysis about
or public entities, or self-employed professionals. emergent categories; (2) Reading and validation of
They earned roughly US$800 monthly, had access the content analysis with 10% of the participant
to credit and owned property. Women with a high SP women; and (3) Comparison of researcher field notes
were characterized by the Colombian Government as with those of the participant observer.
social level of 5 or 6. They had a postgraduate
education, were affiliated with a basic health care
Results
plan complemented by additional expanded private
health insurance. Their job/occupational profiles Sociodemographic characteristics
included: housewives, business owners or employees Out of a total 52 women, 32 (61%) were classified as
in private, or public entities with directive functions. belonging to a medium SP and 20 (39%) as belonging
They earned roughly US$3000 monthly, had access to to a high SP. The mean age of the study participants
credit, and owned more than one property. was 34 years; other sociodemographic characteristics
AIDS Care 3
families. On receiving the HIV diagnosis, women occupational Self-employed with a steady 17
reported that the initial impact could be disconcert- profile income
ing, resulting in anger, and sadness. Soon, they coped Employees at private or public 18
entities
with the treatment, conscious of the benefits of
Self-employed professionals 4
staying healthy with favorable adherence. These
Business owners 12
women had socioeconomic advantages, but they Employees in private or public 19
also had pressures to meet economic and social entities with directive functions
obligations and could not afford the time to delay HIV-positive Yes 17
or refuse treatment. children
Women with full or partial economic indepen-
dence and who communicated their diagnosis to their
families kept active roles as homemakers. They rejection. Disclosing their condition more readily
expressed feeling empowered, able to cope with their than less advantaged women, they did not shy away
diagnosis and to developing self-care behaviors. from seeking help from non-government organiza-
Economic power let working women with their own tions (NGOs). Fear of rejection and discrimination
income exercise autonomy and self-efficacy as women from the healthcare providers did not interrupt their
capable of facing their HIV-positive status. treatment, and their HIV-positive diagnosis was
The SP of this group of women permitted them accepted by them as would be their acceptance of
access to formal education and the development of any other chronic disease. Defending and advocating
skills to understand the complexity of the ART in for their healthcare rights was also tied to their
addition to the importance of properly managing the knowledge of the health system, along with commu-
disease. Their educational background facilitated this nity support networks. They learned about legal
knowledge and promoted practices to seek out issues, how to navigate the governmental bureaucracy
detailed information about HIV/AIDS once they and administrative paperwork, and how to take legal
were diagnosed. They developed information-seeking actions when the treatment is interrupted. These
skills that allowed them to select trustworthy infor- skills allowed them to succeed in getting medical
mation on HIV, attend workshops and conferences, attention and timely and continuous access to ART.
and surf the Internet. The benefits of their educa-
tional background derived from their SP facilitate
them to take up adherence behaviors. Also, this ‘‘ADHERENCE IN HIDING’’ among women of
group expressed a high level of self-efficacy to high SP
negotiate their treatment with the doctors, under- Women classified as having a high SP enjoyed greater
stand their medication, correct doses, side effects, access to economic and other resources that generally
viral loads, and CD4 count. led to a greater tendency for strong adherence
Another characteristic of the empowerment of practices. However, adherence was not confronted
this group was the habit of defending their rights to without barriers. Higher-income women coped with
access to treatment. They demanded a response from HIV and with an expected social role that may have
the health system even when they might have faced created more difficulties in accepting their diagnosis
4 M. Arrivillaga et al.
as compared to women with a medium SP. Confront- overwhelming and eventually lead to the deteriora-
ing these unique sources of stress could eventually tion of their mental and physical health.
lead to threats to their health.
Trying to avoid HIV-related stigma, higher in-
come women attempted to bypass the healthcare Discussion
system. First of all, these women preferred to pay
In this study, findings showed that women in medium
directly for HIV treatment. In this way, they avoided
and high SPs engaged in adherence behaviors for the
having their diagnosis registered with the national
management of HIV. However, distinct differences
healthcare system. As they could afford private
were observed between the groups.
appointments, frequently they also looked for specia-
In women from a medium SP, acceptable access to
lists in Colombian cities other than their cities of
economic resources empowered them and resulted in
residence; this strategy minimized threats to the
favorable adherence. Economic empowerment has
confidentiality of their diagnosis. For this group,
been found to be one of the six areas of empowerment
the economic cost of healthcare was less important
for HIV-positive women, along with socio-cultural,
than keeping the secret of their diagnosis.
familiar/interpersonal, legal, political, and psycholo-
In contrast to women from a medium SP, higher
gical (Malhotra, Schuler, & Boender, 2002). Empow-
income women tended to think of HIV/AIDS more as
Downloaded by [Marcela Arrivillaga] at 08:55 24 January 2012
behaviors to defend their treatment, their better off Also, the authors recognized that because the women
counterparts hid their status and kept their treatment are economically capable of making use of social and
a secret. Paradoxically, secretive adherence practices health services some of them could underestimate the
had the goal of conserving not only their health but problems of adherence. And third, from those we
also their physical image, appearance, and personal invited to participate there were 14% who did not
aesthetics. For them, the diagnosis was a pivotal join the study; so it is possible that differences in
point and implied a redefinition of their identity adherence existed among this social group. Because
(Carr & Gramling, 2004; Pecheny, Manzelly, & Jones, of these limitations and the exploratory nature of the
2007). These women reflected every prejudice and study, further insights on adherence issues among
rejection learned from society on themselves, which better off women are needed.
gave way to irrational fears while silence took control Finally, based on these results as well as the
of their lives (Arregui, 2007). As shown by other findings from previous studies on adherence among
authors, not sharing the diagnosis was to avoid Colombian women (Arrivillaga, 2010; Arrivillaga,
embarrassment and shame, keeping their daily rou- Ross, Useche, Alzate, & Correa, 2009; Arrivillaga,
tine, avoiding, fear of rejection, and being an object Ross, Useche, Springer, & Correa, 2011), policy-
of ridicule or spiteful commentaries in their social makers and health care providers should: (1) design
circles (Pecheny et al., 2007). appropriate protocols for providing comprehensive
Downloaded by [Marcela Arrivillaga] at 08:55 24 January 2012
The overwhelming emotional burden for them care; (2) guarantee access to medications and health
represented potential risks to their health and posed a care services; (3) reduce HIV stigma from health care
latent threat to adherence. Some authors demon- providers; (4) uphold existent norms related to
strated that secretiveness leads to isolation, family mandatory confidentiality regarding HIV diagnosis;
problems, stress, anxiety, depression, and guilt (Ruiz- and (5) provide technical and financial support to
Torres, Cintrón-Bou, & Varas-Diaz, 2007; Thi et al., NGOs. We recommend conducting further research
2008), and that along with the appearance of side on adherence of people with the virus from higher SPs
effects can have a negative influence on adherence to better understand how psychosocial support can be
(Rao, Pryor, Gaddist, & Mayer, 2008; Rintamaki, provided and to advance the knowledge of how and
Davis, Skripkauskas, Bennett, & Wolf, 2006). Others
why adherence practices in these groups are under-
have suggested that revealing their true status elim-
taken.
inates rituals of adherence (Serovich, McDowell, &
Grafsky, 2008) and is associated with better quality of
life and the use of social networks (Emlet, 2006; Li, Acknowledgements
Lin, Ji, Sun, & Rotheram-Borus, 2009). Regardless,
This study was conducted with funding from the Pontificia
some data indicate the opposite and are not always
Universidad Javeriana Cali, Colombia. The authors also
associated with obtaining social support (Smith, acknowledge the support of Paula Andrea Hoyos, Re-
Rossetto, & Peterson, 2008); in the case of people searcher of the Health and Quality of Life Research Group
with HIV/AIDS with a high SP, the evidence about of the same university (COLCIENCIAS, Colombia, Cate-
the benefits of disclosure is limited. gory A), who participated in the data collection.
Health services should provide a network of these
women to create mechanisms for emotional, instru-
mental, and informational support. We also recom- References
mend further analysis of the effects of stigma and Arregui, M. (2007). Living with HIV in the Dominican
cultural beliefs associated with social status on Republic. Interamerican Journal of Psychology, 41(1),
adherence in the HIV/AIDS population with high 3140.
SP. It is also advisable to study the effects of Arrivillaga, M. (2010). Análisis de las barreras para la
disclosure in obtaining social support for adherence. adherencia terapéutica en mujeres colombianas con
The differences in the experience of stigma for people VIH/SIDA: Cuestión de derechos de salud. Salud
from diverse cultural backgrounds should be consid- Pública de Me´xico, 52, 350356.
ered (Rao et al., 2008). Arrivillaga, M., Ross, M., Useche, B., Alzate, M.L., &
Correa, D. (2009). Social position, gender role, and
Several limitations of the study merit mention.
treatment adherence among Colombian women living
First, we could not analyze the associations between
with HIV/AIDS: Social determinants of health ap-
immunological variables and adherence due to ethical proach. Pan American Journal of Public Health, 26(6),
and recruitment limitations that did not allow us 502510.
access to their medical records. Second, information Arrivillaga, M., Ross, M., Useche, B., Springer, A., &
about adherence based on self-reporting could be Correa, D. (2011). Applying an expanded social
biased by answer desirability and memory issues. determinant approach to the concept of adherence to
6 M. Arrivillaga et al.
treatment: The case of Colombian women living with Kim, J.C., Watts, C., Hargreaves, J.R., Ndhlovu, L.X.,
HIV/AIDS. Women’s Health Issues, 21(2), 177183. Phetla, G., Morison, L.A., et al. (2007). Understanding
Ashburn, K., Kerrigan, D., & Sweat, M. (2008). Micro- the impact of a microfinance-based intervention on
credit, women’s groups, control of own money: women?s empowerment and the reduction of intimate
HIV-related negotiation among partnered Dominican partner violence in South Africa. American Journal of
women. AIDS and Behavior, 12, 396403. Public Health, 97(10), 17941802.
Behforouz, H.L., Farmer, P.E., & Mukherjee, J.S. (2004). Kleeberger, C.A., Buechner, J., Palella, F., Detels, R.,
From directly observed therapy to accompagnateurs: Riddler, S., Godfrey, R., & Jacobso, L.P. (2004).
Enhancing AIDS treatment outcomes in Haiti and in Changes in adherence to highly active antiretroviral
Boston. Clinical Infectious Diseases, 38(5), S429S436. therapy medications in the Multicenter AIDS Cohort
Carballo, E., Cadarso-Suárez, C., Carrera, I., Fraga, J., de Study. AIDS, 18(4), 683688.
la Fuente, J., Ocampo, A., . . . Prieto, A. (2004). Koenig, S.P., Leandre, F., & Farmer, P.E. (2004). Scaling-
Assessing relationships between health-related quality up HIV treatment programs in resource-limited set-
of life and adherence to antiretroviral therapy. Quality tings: The rural Haiti experience. AIDS, 18(3),
of Life Research, 13, 587599. S21S25.
Carr, R., & Gramling, L. (2004). A health barrier for Li, L., Lin, Ch., Ji, G., Sun, S., & Rotheram-Borus, M.J.
women with HIV/AIDS. Journal of the Association of (2009) Parents living with HIV in China: Family
Nurses in AIDS Care, 15(5), 3039. functioning and quality of life. Journal of Child and
Downloaded by [Marcela Arrivillaga] at 08:55 24 January 2012
Decock, R.C., Depoorter, A.M., De Graeve, D., & Family Studies,, 18(1), 93102.
Colenbunders, R. (2001). Direct costs of health care Malhotra, A., Schuler, R.S., & Boender, C. (2002).
for HIV/AIDS patients in Belgium. AIDS Care, 13(6), Measuring women’s empowerment as a variable in
721731. international development. Washington, DC: World
Deslauriers, J.P. (1991). Recherche qualitative: Guide pra- Bank.
tique [Qualitative Research: Practical Guide]. Mon- Ministry of Social Protection. (2009). Resumen de situación
tréal: McGraw Hill. de la epidemia por VIH/SIDA en Colombia. 1983 a
Dworkin, S., Kambou, S., Sutherland, C., Moalla, K., & 2008. Bogotá, Colombia: Oficina Asesora de Comuni-
Kapoor, A. (2009). Gendered empowerment and HIV caciones.
prevention: Policy and programmatic pathways to Mohindra, K.S., Haddad, S., & Narayana, D. (2008). Can
success in the MENA Region. Journal of Acquired microcredit help improve the health of poor women?
Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 3(51), S111. Some findings from a cross-sectional study in Kerala,
Ehrhardt, A., Sawire, S., McGovern, T., Peacock, D., & India. International Journal for Equity Health, 7(2), 2.
Weston, M. (2009). Gender, empowerment, and Park-Wyllie, L.Y., Strike, C.S., Antoniou, T., & Bayoumi,
health: What is it? How does it work? Journal of A.M. (2007). Adverse quality of life consequences of
Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 3(51), S96. antiretroviral medications. AIDS Care, 19(2), 252257.
Emlet, C.A. (2006). An examination of the social networks Pecheny, M., Manzelly, H.M., & Jones, D.E. (2007). The
and social isolation in older and younger adults living experience of stigma: People living with HIV/AIDS
with HIV/AIDS. Health Social Work, 31, 299308. and Hepatitis C in Argentina. Interamerican Journal of
Gupta, G. (2000). Approaches for empowering women in the Psychology, 41(1), 1730.
HIV/AIDS pandemic: A gender perspective. In Expert Rao, D., Pryor, J., Gaddist, B., & Mayer, R. (2008).
groups meeting on ‘‘The HIV/AIDS Pandemic and its Stigma, secrecy, and discrimination: Ethnic/racial
Gender Implications’’. Retrieved from http://www.un. differences in the concerns of people living with HIV/
org/womenwatch/daw/csw/hivaids/Gupta.html AIDS. AIDS and Behavior, 12(2), 265271.
Hardon, A.P., Akurut, D., Comoro, C., Ekezie, C., Irunde, Righi, E., Beltrame, A., Bassetti, M., Lindstrom, B.,
H.F., Gerrits, T., . . . Laing, R. (2007). Hunger, waiting Mazzarello, G., Dentone, C., . . . Viscoli, C. (2008).
time and transport costs: Time to confront challenges Therapeutical aspects and outcome of HIV/HCV
to ART adherence in Africa. AIDS Care, 19(5), 658 coinfected patients treated with pegylated interferon
665. plus ribavirin in an Italian cohort. Infection, 36(4),
Hofman, P., & Nelson, A.M. (2006). The pathology 358361.
induced by highly active antiretroviral therapy against Rintamaki, L.S., Davis, T.C., Skripkauskas, S., Bennett,
human immunodeficiency virus: An update. Current C.L., & Wolf, M.S. (2006). Social stigma concerns and
Medicinal Chemistry, 13(26), 31213132. HIV medication adherence. AIDS Patient Care &
Johnson, M.O., & Neilands, T.B. (2007). Coping with HIV STDs, 20, 359368.
treatment side effects: Conceptualization, measure- Ruiz-Torres, Y., Cintrón-Bou, F., & Varas-Diaz, N. (2007).
ment, and linkages. AIDS and Behavior, 11(4), AIDS-related stigma and health professionals in Puer-
575585. to Rico. Interamerican Journal of Psychology, 41(1),
Kim, J., Pronyk, P., Barnett, T., & Watts, C. (2008). 4956.
Exploring the role of economic empowerment in HIV Serovich, J.M., McDowell, T.L., & Grafsky, E.L. (2008).
prevention. AIDS, 22(4), S57S71. Women’s report of regret of HIV disclosure to family,
AIDS Care 7
friends and sex partners. AIDS and Behavior, 12, UNAIDS. (2010). Report on the global AIDS epidemic.
227231. Geneva: Author.
Smith, R., Rossetto, K., & Peterson, B.A. (2008). Meta- WHO. (2003). Adherence to long-term therapies. Evidence
analysis of disclosure of one’s HIV-positive status, for action. Geneva: Author.
stigma and social support. AIDS Care, 20(10), 1266. WHO & UNAIDS. (2008). Epidemiological fact sheet on
Thi, M., Brickley, D., Vinh, D., Colby, D., Sohn, A., HIV and AIDS. Core data on epidemiology and
Trung, N., . . . Mandel, J. (2008). A qualitative study of response. Colombia 2008 Update. Geneva: UNAIDS/
stigma and discrimination against people living with WHO Working Group on Global HIV/AIDS and STI
HIV in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. AIDS and Surveillance.
Behavior, 12, 6370. Wyss, K., Hutton, G., & N’Diekhor, Y. (2004). Costs
UNAIDS. (2008). Report on the global AIDS epidemic. attributable to AIDS at household level in Chad. AIDS
Geneva: Author. Care, 16(7), 808816.
Downloaded by [Marcela Arrivillaga] at 08:55 24 January 2012