Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Integral Accessibility To Airports in The Colombian Coffee Region. Case Study: Coffee Airport, Colombia
Integral Accessibility To Airports in The Colombian Coffee Region. Case Study: Coffee Airport, Colombia
net/publication/327072047
CITATION READS
1 87
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Santiago Cardona on 22 May 2019.
Abstract
Objectives: The investigation seeks to calculate the benefits generated in terms of travel time on the road network until
the place where the International Coffee Airport, in the municipality of Palestina, in the department of Caldas, Colombia,
will be built. Methods/Statistical Analysis: Calculating the integral accessibility to airports in current situation
without the construction of Coffee Airport and future situation with the start-up of the Coffee Airport we can calculate
the savings in travel time generated by the new facility in the Cofee Region. Besides, for the geo statistical model Kriging
Ordinary model is used. Findings: The obtained results probe that the new airport benefits 528381 people in terms of
travel time and accessibility and improved the Coffee Cultural Landscape and its importance in the Coffee Region Tourism.
Application/Improvement: The integral accessibility as a planning tool to determine the advantages of the construction of new
facilities like airports in terms of travel time on a specific road network. By calculating the integral accessibility to
airports in current and future situations, with the start-up of the Coffee Airport, calculating the savings generated through the
savings gradient is possible, finding which are the municipalities and percentage of population in the area of influence that
will benefit the most in terms of time.
Keywords: Airports, Coffee Airport, Colombian Coffee Region, Integral Accessibility, Saving Gradient
Currently, the region has 4 airports in operation that Colombia (AEROCIVIL, acronym in spanish)13. In 2005,
connect it with the rest of the country and the world: two the construction of the project began, which is far from
international ones, the Matecana in Pereira, which has 3 finished, due to various problems in the design, financing,
international destinations, and 6 national ones of a com- administration and political areas, among others14. In 2018,
mercial nature7, and the Eden in Quindio, which has 2 the Colombian congressmen reaffirmed the will to complete
international and 2 national destinations of commer- it thanks to the economic and social viability of the project15.
cial nature8. The Santa Ana national airport in the city of In this research, an analysis of integral accessibility
Cartago, located in the north of Cauca Valley, will have a at the territorial level was made to the airports that are
regular operation by 2018, due to the arrival of airlines that currently operating in the region of the coffee region and
will make flights to the capital of the country9. Finally, La were compared with the future situation, where the Coffee
Nubia is located in Manizales, which is a national airport, Airport comes into operation by means of the gradient of
and makes daily flights to Bogota, but which is constantly savings in travel times, finding the real benefits generated
closing operations, cancelling and postponing flights due by the implementation of this important airport.
to its geographical location and the adverse climatic condi- Accessibility is a concept that appears in research
tions of Manizales10,11. On some occasions, passengers are articles thanks to Hansen (1959) where he defines it as “...
directed to the Matecana airport, located an hour and a half the potential of opportunities for interaction ...”16 but that,
by land causing discomfort to different users12. according to Batty (2009), has been applied in the United
For this reason, the construction of the airport project States of America since the 1920s as an instrument for
called the International Coffee Airport (Aeropuerto transport planning and land use17. Later, Ingram (1979) is
Internacional del Cafe or AeroCafe for its name in spanish) responsible for defining different types of measures such as
was proposed, which will help to revitalize the coffee region, relative accessibility, which is calculated between two spe-
opening international markets to trade and tourism, and cifics nodes and integral accessibility18, which calculates the
because it may have a track long enough to admit transoceanic accessibility of a city, region or number of people with dif-
capacity airplanes in its second stage5. The International ferent nodes of health activity19, education20, commerce21
Coffee Airport will be located in the municipality of Palestina or airports22, as it is in this research article. This measure is
(Department of Caldas), at a distance of 24 kilometers of made in distance or travel time, including speed in the road
Manizales, the capital of Caldas department and 27 kilometers network. Likewise, it can include qualitative variables of the
of Pereira, the capital of Risaralda department. On the other measured activity nodes, generating accessibility models
hand, it is located at 1500 m.a.s.l. and a favorable climatic that include impedance and friction variables such as sever-
conditions during a great part of the year and without ity models16,23 or models based in profit24-26, widely studied
topographic barriers, which generates an airstrip that can over the last decades. In addition to the measures proposed
work on both sides. Its beginnings go back to the year 1977, by Ingram (1971), global accessibility emerged, which mea-
when the idea arose from a study of roads for the trunk sures the relationship between set of nodes that exist in the
Felisa-Chinchina in Caldas. Then, in 1985 the municipality road network27,28. This measure has been used in Colombia
of Palestina and the Chamber of Commerce of Manizales for various studies such as obtaining benefits in new road
(Camara de Comercio de Manizales in Spanish) created the infrastructure works and the evaluation of connection alter-
Palestina Airport corporation, to which the governorship of natives27. For this study, territorial integral accessibility will
Caldas in 1986 and the municipality of Manizales in 1989 be used, which has been used in various investigations29-33.
adhered, allocating resources from the airport tax levied at After the introduction, the research methodology
La Nubia Airport. In 2002, the financing and promotion used, the main results obtained and the conclusions are
institutes of the department of Caldas (INFICALDAS) and presented.
the municipality of Manizales (INFIMANIZALES) together
with the United Nations Development Program (UNDP)
began pre-feasibility studies of the project from where the
2. Methodology
environmental licenses were obtained before the Regional The research methodology (Figure 2) addressed consists
Autonomous Corporation of Caldas and the Special of four main stages and a preliminary stage of input data,
Administrative Unit of the Civil Aeronautics of Republic of which are described which are described below.
2 Vol 11 (26) | July 2018 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Diego A. Escobar, Santiago Cardona and Carlos A. Moncada
Vol 11 (26) | July 2018 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 3
Integral Accessibility to Airports in the Colombian Coffee Region. Case Study: Coffee Airport, Colombia
tant because the spatial structure of the study situation is 6.11% of the study area (203 611 Ha), which corresponds
characterized, which in this case is the vector of travel to 29.28% of the population (1 241 308 people). On the
times41,42. Where N ( h ) is the number of pairs Z xi + h ( ) other hand, 20.64% of the population (874 584 people)
( )
and Z xi separated by a distance h = h , so the smaller
must invest between 30 and 60 minutes of travel time to
reach one of the airports, corresponding to 14.39% of the
distance between the data, the better the estimate study area (429 906 Ha). This indicates the clear proxim-
times41,42. ity of urban centers to airports due to the fact that a large
n percentage of the population (50%) is covered in a much
Z 0* = ∑λ Z (x )
i =1
i i (1) smaller area percentage (21%).
N (h )
∑ ( ) ( )
1 2
γ ( h ) = Z x + h − Z x (2)
2N ( h )
i i
i =1
4 Vol 11 (26) | July 2018 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Diego A. Escobar, Santiago Cardona and Carlos A. Moncada
3.2 Integral Accessibility, Future Situation in the areas near the Coffee Airport. Also, there is up to
12% of the population (528381 inhabitants) who get up to
Figure 6 shows the isochronous curves for the future situ-
5% savings in travel times. For savings of up to 10%, the
ation where the Coffee Airport is included, which
percentage of the covered population reaches 10%
continues in its construction phase. In this case, it can be
(425964 inhabitants), a population higher than that regis-
seen how the area covered by the isochrone up to 30 min
tered by Manizales (414000 inhabitants), capital of the
grew 20 897 Ha (0.7%) in area and 68 405 people (1.614%)
department of Caldas and one of the main nodes of eco-
in population, which indicates a greater coverage gener-
nomic activity in the studied region.
ated by the new activity node in the airport. Likewise, it is
clearly observed in the map how the isochronous curve of
30 min grows with respect to Figure 4, corresponding to
the current situation.
Figure 6. Integral accessibility to airports, future situation. Figure 9 shows the graph that relates the percentage
savings with the percentage of area and population cover-
age. Again, the percentage of population covered is greater,
Figure 7 shows the population and area coverage
due to the large number of inhabitants who live near the
warnings with respect to the isochronous accessibility
studied airports. On the other hand, it is interesting to
curves where growth is observed in the coverage for the
note that savings up to 20% is covered by up to 6% of the
isochronous curve less than 2 hours, reaching 70% cover-
population, demonstrating the great benefit in terms of
age for 2 950 382 people.
travel time savings generated by the Coffee Airport.
Vol 11 (26) | July 2018 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 5
Integral Accessibility to Airports in the Colombian Coffee Region. Case Study: Coffee Airport, Colombia
stands out (400 136 people), in which 35% of the popula- coming from Manizales and its metropolitan area would
tion reaches up to 5% of savings, reaching a saving of 65% not have to travel to the Matecana Airport to access their
for 1% of the population. On the other hand, municipali- flights.
ties near the Coffee Airport obtain savings of up to 5% Finally, for future research, an accessibility calculation
(Riosucio -63 719 hab., Pacora -11 124 hab.- and Quinchia based on profits could be made to find the benefit gener-
-33 941 hab.-), 10% (Chinchina -50 880 hab.-), 15% (La ated in the study area, in economic terms, by the Coffee
Merced -5 172 hab., Marmato -9 266 hab. -and Supia-27 Airport, using attractor variables that would include a
239 hab.-) and 30% (Palestine -17 639 hab.-) for the total greater offer of international and national destinations
of its population. Likewise, the municipalities of and a track of greater length that would allow, given its
Chinchina and Palestina obtain a greater benefit due to climatic and geographical conditions, to operate commer-
their proximity to the Coffee Airport, reaching savings of cial flights at a lower cost than the Jose Maria Cordoba
some percentage for 100% of their population. airports of Medellin and El Dorado in Bogota.
5. Aknowledgments
The authors are grateful for the participation of the stu-
dents and professionals involved in the research center
for sustainable mobility of the Universidad Nacional de
Colombia - Sede Manizales, Departamento de Ingenieria
Civil, Facultad de Ingenieria y Arquitectura.
6. References
Figure 10. Saving gradient percentage vs. covered
1. Division politica administrativa eje cafetero en 2010.
population, municipalities.
Available from: http://www.carder.gov.co/app/webroot/
index.php/index.php/web/es/datos-abiertos#datos_abier-
4. Conclusions tos. Date accessed: 15/05/2018.
2. Arango O. Ciudad region eje cafetero: hacia un desarrollo
The comparison of travel times generated by activity urbano sostenible. Desafios. 2005; 2(12):191-4.
nodes such as airports through integral accessibility and 3. DANE - Departamento Administrativo Nacional de
the savings gradient, serve to determine the travel time Estadistica. Proyecciones de poblacion total por sexo y gru-
savings generated by a new activity node such as the pos de edad de 0 hasta 80 y mas a-os (2005–2020). Available
Coffee Airport and its effect on the population, which from: http://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/estadisticas-por-
reaches a direct impact of 530 thousand people in the tema/demografia-y-poblacion/proyecciones-de-poblacion.
Date accessed: 20/05/2018.
coffee region and will boost commercial air transport,
4. UNESCO. Cofee Cultural Landscape: An exception fusion
allowing faster and more efficient access to different des-
of nature, collective human effort and culture. Available
tinations in the country and the world. Also, the different
from: https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1121/documents/.
people who visit the coffee region for tourism will benefit Date accessed: 2011.
in the same way by having a new arrival offer, enhancing 5. Ensayos sobre economia regional: Turismo en el eje cafetero.
the Coffee Cultural Landscape, registered as a world heri- Available from: http://www.banrep.gov.co/documentos/
tage by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and publicaciones/regional/ESER/manizales/2004_junio.pdf.
Cultural Organization and Culture-UNESCO-. Date accessed: 06/2004.
On the other hand, the Coffee Airport would func- 6. Valencia F, Cortazar D, Lopez A. Composicion de la econo-
tion as an important development attractor for the mia de la region eje cafetero de Colombia. Ensayos Sobre
municipality on which it is being built, Palestina. Also, Economia Regional. 2013; 54:2-55.
it would work as an alternative to the La Nubia air- 7. Aeropuerto Internacional Mateca-a, AEROMATE.
port, which has numerous problems of infrastructure Organizacion. Available from: http://aeromate.gov.co/.
Date accessed: 21/05/2018.
and unfavorable weather, so that travelers entering and
6 Vol 11 (26) | July 2018 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Diego A. Escobar, Santiago Cardona and Carlos A. Moncada
8. Aeropuerto El Eden. Informacion general. Available from: 20. Walsh S, Cullinan J, Flannery D. The Impact of Proposed
http://aeropuertoeleden.com/aeropuerto-el-eden. Date Higher Education Reforms on Geographic Accessibility to
accessed: 21/05/2018. Universities in Ireland. Applied Spatial Analysis and Policy.
9. En octubre Viva Colombia iniciara operacion en el 2017; 10(4):515-36. Crossref.
Aeropuerto Santa Ana de Cartago. Available from: 21. Montoya JA, Escobar DA. Propuesta de ubicacion de nuevos
https://www.elespectador.com/noticias/nacional/valle/ centros comerciales, aplicacion de un analisis de accesibili-
en-octubre-vivacolombia-iniciara-operacion-en-el- dad territorial urbana. Revista Espacios. 2017; 38(51):1-4.
aeropuerto-santa-ana-de-cartago-articulo-752658. Date 22. Koster P, Kroes E, Verhoef E. Travel time variabil-
accessed: 27/04/2018. ity and airport accessibility. Transportation Research
10. Vientos y altas temperaturas afectaron vuelos a Bogota. Part B: Methodological. 2011; 45(10):1545-59.
Available from: http://www.lapatria.com/caldas/vientos- Crossref.
y-altas-temperaturas-afectaron-vuelos-en-bogota-347879. 23. Xu W, Ding Y, Zhou J, Li Y. Transit accessibility measures
Date accessed: 09/02/2017. incorporating the temporal dimension. Cities. 2015; 46:55-66.
11. Baja visibilidad cierra operaciones en el aeropuerto La Crossref.
Nubia. Available from: http://www.lapatria.com/manizales/ 24. Geurs K, Van Wee B. Accessibility evaluation of land-use
baja-visibilidad-cierra-operaciones-en-el-aeropuerto-la- and transport strategies: Review and research directions.
nubia-360737. Date accessed: 19/04/2017. Journal of Transport Geography. 2004; 12(2):127-40.
12. Vuelo Bogota - Manizales aterrizo en Pereira por supuesta Crossref.
falta de combustible en La Nubia. Available from: http:// 25. Gulhan G, Ceylan H, Ozuysal M, Ceylan H.
www.lapatria.com/economia/vuelo-bogota-manizales- Impact of utility-based accessibility measures
aterrizo-en-pereira-por-supuesta-falta-de-combustible-en- on urban public transportation planning: A case
la-nubia. Date accessed: 07/07/2018. study of Denizli, Turkey, Cities. 2013; 32:102-12.
13. Rese-ahistorica. Available from: http://www.aeropuertodel- Crossref.
cafe.com.co/index.php/layout/about-page-style-3. Date 26. Nassir N, Hickman M, Malekzadeh A, Irannezhad E.
accessed: 26/06/2018. A utility-based travel impedance measure for pub-
14. Sigue siendo incierto el futuro del Aeropuerto del Cafe lic transit network accessibility. Transportation
en Caldas. Available from: https://www.elespectador. Research Part A: Policy and Practice. 2016; 88:26-39.
com/noticias/nacional/sigue-siendo-incierto-el-futuro- Crossref.
del-aeropuerto-del-cafe-articulo-600391. Date accessed: 27. Moncada C, Cardona S, Escobar D. Saving Travel Time as
20/11/2015. an Urban Planning Instrument. Case Study: Manizales,
15. Aerocafe, con viabilidad economica y social. Available Colombia. Modern Applied Science. 2018; 12(6):44-57.
from: http://www.lapatria.com/economia/aerocafe-con- Crossref.
viabilidad-economica-y-social-415581. Date accessed: 28. Barco A, Escobar D, Moncada C. Road Redirection Analysis.
07/07/2018. Case Study: Araucarias Avenue, Manizales, Colombia.
16. Hansen WG. How Accessibility Shapes Land Use. Journal Contemporary Engineering Sciences. 2018; 11(32):1559-69.
of the American Institute of Planners. 1959; 25(2):73-6. Crossref.
Crossref. 29. Escobar D, Garcia F, Tolosa R. Analisis de accesibilidad ter-
17. Batty M. Accessibility: In search of a unified theory. ritorial a nivel regional. Universidad Nacional de Colombia.
Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design. 2009; Facultad de Ingenieria Y Arquitectura. 2013; p. 1-182.
36(2):191-4. Crossref 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. 30. Loaiza C, Holguin J, Escobar D. Analisis compara-
18. Ingram D. The Concept of Accessibility: A search for an tivo de alternativas viales entre Manizales y Mariquita
operational form. Regional Studies. 1971; 5(2):101-7. (Colombia) a traves de un estudio de accesibilidad ter-
Crossref. ritorial. Informacion Tecnologica. 2016; 27(5):231-42.
19. Escobar D, Holguin J, Zuluaga J. Accesibilidad de los cen- Crossref.
tros de ambulancias y hospitales prestadores del servicio 31. Mu-oz A. Analisis de accesibilidad territorial a nivel regional
de urgencias y su relacion con la inequidad espacial. Caso y el impacto de las concesiones 4G Proyecto Autopistas
de estudio Manizales - Colombia. Revista Espacios. 2016; para la Prosperidad Pacifico 1, 2 y 3. Universidad Nacional
37(20):1-20. de Colombia. 2016; p. 1-90.
Vol 11 (26) | July 2018 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 7
Integral Accessibility to Airports in the Colombian Coffee Region. Case Study: Coffee Airport, Colombia
32. Ordosgoitia I, Mu-oz J, Angel C. Analisis de la Accesibilidad 38. Zuluaga J, Escobar D. Geomarketing Analysis for Shopping
Vial en la Region del Occidente Colombiano. In IV Malls in Manizales (Colombia). Accessibility approach
Congreso de Ingenieria del Transporte. 2000; p. 1-12. methodology. Revista Espacios. 2017; 38(21):1-20.
33. Zuluaga J, Escobar D. Analisis de accesibilidad territorial 39. Lindner A, Pitombo C, Rocha S, Quintanilha J. Estimation
de la region noroccidente de Colombia. Revista Espacios. of transit trip production using Factorial Kriging
2017; 38(6):30-45. with External Drift: an aggregated data case study.
34. Bunge W. Theoretical Geography. Lund Studies in Geo-Spatial Information Science. 2016; 19(4):245-54.
Geography, Series C. 1962; 1:1-16. Crossref.
35. Cardozo O, Gomez L, Parras M. Teoria de grafos y sistemas 40. Simpson T, Mauery T, Korte J, Mistree F. Kriging models for
de informacion geografica aplicados al transporte publico global approximation in simulation-based multidisciplinary
de pasajeros en Resistencia (Argentina). Revista Transporte design optimization. AIAA Journal. 2001; 39(12):2233-41.
Y Territorio. 2009; (1):89-111. Crossref 1, 2.
36. Dijkstra E. A note on two problems in conexion with graphs. 41. Diaz, M. Geoestadistica Aplicada. Universidad Nacional
Numerical Mathematics. 1959; 1(1):269-71. Crossref. Autonoma de Mexico. 2002.
37. Wu Q, Qin G, Li H. An Improved Dijkstra’s algorithm appli- 42. Giraldo R. Introduccion a la geoestadistica. Teoria y aplica-
cation to multi-core processors. Metallurgical & Mining cion. Universidad Nacional de Colombia Sede Bogota. 2002.
Industry. 2015; (9):76-81. PMCid: PMC140387
8 Vol 11 (26) | July 2018 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology