Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fast During: Variation in The Diatom Ice Syowa Station, Antarctica, 1997/98
Fast During: Variation in The Diatom Ice Syowa Station, Antarctica, 1997/98
from the iceto the water column. Aceumulation of small diatomsin a sediment trap
fo11owed a decrease of their abundance in the w'ater column. These results indicate
that most of the icealgae detached from the ice sank direetly to the bottomduringthe
latterhalf of the austral summer.
key words: chlorophylL a, diatom comrnunity. water column, sinking, Syowa Station
Introduction
that the icealgae released from the ice seed the bloom in the water column, especially in
ice edge zones (Garrison and Buck, 1985; Smith and Nelson, 1985; Garrison et al.,
1987). However, Riebesellet al, (1991)contend that grazingand sinking are the main
fates of sea icebiota.
Studies on ice algae near Syowa Stationhave been undertaken since the late1950s
(Hoshiai and Watanabe, 1996). Near Syowa the icea]gal biornass reaches a maximum
in spring/early summer (Hoshiai, 1981a,b; Watanabe and Satoh, 1987) and the abun-
dance of phytoplankton inthe water column usually reaches itsmaximum at the efld of
January and in early February (e.g., Satoh et aL, 1986). The primary productiQn of
the phytoplanktonin the water column islower than that of the ice algae in the spring
but higherin the summer (Satoh and Watanabe, 1988; Satoh et aL, 1991).
'
E-mail: ishikawa@bio.mie-u.ac.jp
10
Materialsand methods
44,
59i
's
69'oo'
S
Ol,
02i
for positiveidentification of species, cells were cieaned with concentrated HCI and
KMn04 mixture (Simonsen, 1974), driedin air, placedon aluminum stubs, coated with
gold, and examined with a scanning electron microscope (JEOL, JSM-T-200), The
species was identified by referring to Medlin and Priddle (1990)and Hasle and
Syvertsen(1997). Among the diatom population,the two dominant species were
selected to determinespecies succession. In this analysis, the two dominant species
almost always occupied more than 80% of the total diatom population.
Sinkingdiatoms were collected with a sediment trap moored 20m below the ice.
The sediment trap was 70.6 cm inheight;upper 40.6 cm cylinder, with a baMe at the top,
and lower 30cm funnelwith 500ml bottleat the bottom. The diameterwas 15.4cm,
making a collecting area of 186cm2. The collection was made duringthe periodfrorn
2 January to 2 February 1998. The traps were fi11ed with artificial sea water with
trap was replaced at approximately weekly intervals. For species identification and
magnification. Counts were carried out in triplicatefor each sample and the daily ee]1
flux (cells m'2 day'i) was calculated. Although the cell fluxis illustrated oniy for
dominant diatoms in this study, these species occupied most (83・-98%) of the total
diatorn cells.
Results
January and deepened to the end of January (Fig. 2A). Warm water exceeding OOC
seemed to be located from shallow to deeper layersas the thermocline deepened.
Maximum temperature was recorded (O.250C) at 1 m below the iceon 17 January.
The vertical salinity gradient was very small in the water column from the end of
December to the beginning of January (Fig.2B). Thereafter,the gradientgradually
appeared at depthsshallower than 15m and developedthroughout the water column by
the end of January, Minimum salinity was recorded (31.4PSU) at 1 m below the iceon
The water densitywas almost homogeneous in the water column deeper than 1 m
below the iceuntil the beginningofJanuary (Fig. 2C). A density gradientwas formed
in the surface layershal]ower than around 10m on 7 January and developedthrough the
water column by the end of January. No apparent pycnocline was observed.
Date
1997Dec.27 1998
Jan. Feb.3013
301 5 10 15 2025
159131721252933
・ N,
ki,,
(A)
AEv=-Qma
159131721252933 ,
Chlorophylla
Throughout the study, two periodsof high Chl a concentration were observed in
layersshallower than 20m: the first
from lateDecember to early Januaryand the second
from mid- to late January (Fig. 3A). Total Chla showed a trend of decreasing
graduallywith depth, Detailed changes in tota]Chl a 1 m below the ice are shown in
Fig.4A. Concentration of totalChl a increasedfrom the beginning of the study to 30
December (7.9xtgl' i),
decreasing to 1.3psgl ion 10 January. Total Chla increased
again from 14 January,reaching tltehighestvalue of 9.9ygl'' on 22 January. The
high abundance lasted for about 7 days,then decreased until the end of the study,
The fraction>20ptm accounted forrnore than 90% of the totalChl a through the
water column at the end of December but decreasedto < 10% at the end of January
(Fig, 3B), Detailed changes inrelative abundance of the fractions to the total Chl a at
1m beiow the iceare also shown in Fig. 4B. The fraction >20"m comprised 50-90%,
from the end of December to the beginning of January,decreasing laterin the season
(Fig. 4B). The 10-20"m fractionincreased, supplanting the >20pam fraction,from
the beginningof January,and became the major component of the total Chla by the
middle of January. Thereafter, this fraction comprised almost 60-90% of the total
Chl a. Throughout the study period, the fractionef > 10pam (sumof >20 and 10--20
ptm) accounted for62-99% of the total Chl a, except in a f'ew samples (30December,
Date
1997Dec. 1998
Jan. Feb.
1
5
10
15
20
25
30AE
3sZ'a-'
gy
iii
1,S)i],il
1oas
o'
eo}liiiil,ii>ll)ii
,1
10
7e 6e
90
15
20
25
30
35 (B)
Fig.3, Temporal variations of (A) total chlorophyll a concentration (sigii),
and (B) relative
10
tt3u=)-`a99=-o-"
8
2
oF
o1OOAS
n <lo "m
6osoca
40otz・-asca
20cr
o
27 1 10 20 30 3
Dec. Jan, Feb.
1997 1998
Fig. 4. Daily changes in (A)total chlorophylla concentration and (B)relative abundance of itssize
fractions at 1 m below the ice in the water column at St. A. Unfi11ed partsdenote no data.
and 21 and 24 January). No obvious trend in the change of relative abundance of the
fractionsmaller than 10"m was observed.
dinoflagellates(Fig. 5B) was always much lower,at a densityfrom O-103 cells l i, than
that of diatoms, Almost 100% of the species observed in the dinoflagellate population
were Protqperidinium spp,, which are heterotrophic. Centric diatoms were observed at
the relative abundance of 9-10% of the total diatom popuaation from 27 December to
3 January. The relative abundance decreased thereafter to <1% by 12 January.
Instead,pennate diatoms occupied nearly or totally the diatom populationsafter 7
January. In this study, 11 species of 8 genera of centric diatems were observed (Table
1), Among them, the large species, forosira pseudodenticulata (53.9ptm in average
69-100% of the centric diatom population beforethe middle of January (Fig. 6A).
lo7
io6
---.r9oe.-ts285o
leS
lo4lo4
lo3
lo2
o
27 1 10 20 30 3
Dec. Jan. Feb,
1997 1998
Fig. S. Daily changes in celi densitiesof (A) diatoms and (B)dinoflagellates
at 1 m belowthe ice in
the water column at St. A.
The pennate diatom population,in which 8 species and 3 unidentified groupsof 7 genera
were observed (Tablel), was characterized by the ]arge species, iFlseudo-nitzschia
turgiduloides (94.9
and 2.6ptm in average for the apical and transapicalaxes, respective-
ly;n 103),and the small
=
species, Ragilariopsis
curta andE cylindrus (23.5 and 2.5pm
in average for the apical and transapicalaxes, respectively; n=106) (Fig.
6B). The
]F)'agilariqpsis species were counted as a single taxon (D'agiiariopsisspp.) becausethe two
species were not distinguishable
by lightmicroseopy. ]Rgeudo-nitzschia turgiduloides
was the dominant species, at a relative abundance of 47-99%, from 27 December to 8
January and iF)ragilariopsis spp., at a relative abundance of 50-100%, duringthe rest of
the study period, except on 13 January. In this study, R turgiduloides often formed
long chains, whereas most cells of F},agilariqpsis
spp, were solitary or in short chains of
2-3 cells. Aggregates were often observed in the water samples.
As a result of analysis in relationships
between the cell densitiesof the dominant
diatoms and concentration of the >20 and 10-20um chlorophyll a fractions at 1 rn
below the ice, P. pseudodenticulata and PL turgiduloides showed significant positive
relationships with the >20ptm fraction; the correlation coeMcients (r2) were O.78 (p<
O.OOI) and O.57 (p<(O.OOI), respectively (Table 2). On the other hand, a highiy
significant positive relationship (r2=O,80,p<O.OOI) was found between rvagitariqpsis
spp. and the 10-20ym fraction.
DiatomsCentrales
(Castracttne)
Mangin
pseudodenticulata(Hustedt)
PorosiraRhizosolenia Jouse
sp.mierotrias
Pennales
F7agiiariopsis curta (VanHeurck) Hustedt
(Grunow)Krieger
ENaviculaIV.N.NitzschiaN.Pinnularia
cvlindrus
directa(W.Smith) Ralfs
gtacieiVan Heurck
spp.stetlata
Manguin
spp.quadratarea
var, constricta (Ostrup)
Heiden
Pleurosigma directunlGrunow
turgidutoides <Hasle)
ltsceudo-nitzschia Hasle
Stauroneis spp,
Sinking diatoms
Of the dominant diatoms, the two large species, P. pseudodenticulata and R
turgiduloides, and the smatl species ofjF}'agilariopsis showed an opposite trend in cell flux
at 20m below the ice (Fig.7). The cell fluxes ofthe two large species were high during
the first halfof January,with maximajust beforethe middle of January of 5,1 × i06cells
?day'
m for P. pseudodenticulata(Fig.7A) and 1,5× 10S cells m 2dayi for R
turgiduloides (Fig. 7B). Thereafter, their cell fluxes decreaseddrastically to lessthan
2.5× 10Sand 2.8× 107cells m' ?day ], respectively, at the end ofJanuary. Although the
2day'i
cell fluxof the small species was relatively modest at < 1.8× 10' cells m in the first
halfof January,itincreased laterand reached the maximum flux of 1.2× 109 cells m 2
day'i from the end of January to the beginningof February (Fig. 7C). The cells
deposited in the trap were well aggregated.
1OO
tw-pazChaetoceros sp.1
Porosira
80 pseuciodenticulata
thalassiosira
aushalis
Others
60
40
.AL8voo=cuvc=Dcuo>'.-"-.Jas-ocr
20
o1OO
-hegilariopsis spp.
Pseucto-nitzschia
80 tuigiduioides
Others
60
40
20
o
27 1 10 20 30 3
Dec. Jan. Feb.
1997 t998
Fig. 6. Daily ehanges in relative abundance of the two dominant species umong (A)contric and (B)
pennate diatom populationsat 1m below the ice in the water column at St.A. ND and NC
denote no data Hnd no cells. respectively.
respectively,
Fraction of chlerophyll a
Diatom species
',,
le-20gm 20um
6(A)
ATvnyEseMo 5
3
ooor
2
xv
1
o
18
16Ar {B)
× 14vc>J
==ooen=y'.!co
12E9
tOgsr".
6V,v
2o14
(c)
12ATv
10cy
E8seig
6co04r5
2o
2 10Jan.20 30 2
Feb.
1998
Fig. 7.Temporal changes in sinking cell fiuxesof dominant diatoms, (A)Ilorosira pseudodenticulata,
(B) Ilseudo-nitzschia
turgiduloides and (C)Fhagilariopsis
spp,, rnonitored by sediment trap 20
rn below the bottorn of the fast ice at St. A from 2 January to 2 February 1998. Bars
Discussion
In thisstudy, the concentration of >20pam chlorophyll afractionat 1 m below the
icewas related to the cell abundances of two largespecies, R pseudodenticulata and R
turgiduloides 2). A higher
(Table significant positiverelationship was found for the
former species although itscell abundance was much lower than that of the latterone.
This isprobably due to the largercell volume of the former species, which contains more
1989; Garrison,1991) and they have also been found in the sea ice around Syowa
Station(Watanabe, 1982, 1988;Watanabe et aL, 1990). Apart from the ice,limited
information(Watanabe,
pers. commun.) about the species composition in the water
as dominant species among the diatom populationfrom spring to early summer at the
chlorophyll a fraction at 1 m below the ice was found (Table 2), indicating that the
main component in the phytoplankton population duringthe other periodof high total
Chl a, i.e., from the middle to the end of January,was the small nano-sized pennate
diatom. Those species were also observed to be dominating in the water column under
the icearound Syowa Stationin January 1984 (Watanabe, pers. commun.).
Iwanami et al. (1986) observed a development of chlorophyll a concentration at a
pycnocline fbrmed at shallower depth (ca. 1.3m below the ice) near Syowa Station,
from the middle to the end of January 1984,and suggested that the developmentwas due
to growth of phytoplanktonat the shallower pycnoclinewhich kept them from sinking
te poorly lighted deeper layers for a longer time. In this study, instead of no
appearance of an obvious pycnocline, a densitygradient developedthrough the water
column by the end of January (Fig.2C).Furthermore, the apparent growth rate
calculated frornthe change in diatom cell density(Fig. 5A), from 2.6× 10`cells l i to
4.7× 106 cells l i
(themaximum value during the study) on 10 and 22 January,
i)
respectively, was much higher (O.43d than the growth rate of the phytoplankton
community January (O.18d i; Ishikawa, unpubiished
on 16 data), as estimated in situ
(incubated at ca. O,5m below the ice) by the dilution method (Landry and Hassett
1982). This indicates that the developmentof the population at 1 m below the iceafter
10 Januarycannot be explained only by the growth of the cells. jF}ragilariopsis curta and
]Fl
cylindrus are common and often dominate in the ice algal assemblage around Syowa
Station (Watanabe,
1988; Watanabe et al., 1990) and in other Antarctic regions (e.g.,
Burkholderand Mandelli,1965;Richardsonand Whitaker,1979;Garrisonet aL, 1986;
Garrisonand Buck, 1989;Garrison,1991). Ithas been reported that the abundance of
chlorophyll in the bottom ice decreases markedly
a in January with ice melt (Sasaki and
Hoshiai, 1986; Watanabe et aL, 1990 ). Judgingfrom the fact that the ice also melted
in January, 1998, it can be strongly a$sumed that a largenumber of the cells of
iF},agilariopsis spp. were released into the water column from the bottom ice,where those
species dominateover other populations ofice algal species. This isa major reason why
the 10-20pam fractionof chlorophylla in terms of F>'agilariopsis spp. populations
developedinthe water column from the middle to the end of January. In other words,
itislikelythat most of the phytoplanktoncells in the water column were derived from
the ice,while they could stM grow. Sasakiand Hoshiai (1986) reported that the ice
algae detachingfrom the ice increased in lateDecember, also indicating the possibility
that the phytoplankton increasewe observed at the end of December was a result of the
increaseddetachment of icealgae from the ice.
Ithas been reported that the icealgae released from the iceare a seed for the bloom
in the water column at the iceedge zone (Garrison and Buck, l985;Smith and Nelson,
1985;Garrisonet al., 1987). On the other hand, ithas also been suggested that the
aggregated ice algae sink rapidly to the bottom and do not act as a seed for the bloom
(Riebesell et aL,1991). In this study, relatiyely higherconcentration of total Chla
extended from the surface to the subsurface (Fig. 3A) and the sinking cell fluxof the
dominant species (Fig. 7) increased with decreasingchlorophyll a concentration (Figs.
3A and 4A), indicating that our results would be comparable with the latter scheme.
According to Marchantet aL (1996), the organic materials (marine snow) collected by
divers below the surface in the water column around Syowa Stationinmid-January 1994
were dominated by diatoms and muci]age which derivedfrom the ice community.
Sasaki and Hoshiai (1986) also reported that the icealgae detachedfrom the icearound
the station sink directly to the bottom duringsummer and are net grazedduring sinking.
Thus, the algae reaching the bottom become a major fbod source for the benthic
animals.
As a whole, abundance and community structure of diatoms varied drastically
within the short summer of 1997/98.
The variation was due predominantlyto abiotic
events, such as ice rather than bioticevents,
melting, such as growth of the
Acknowledgments
We are gratefulto Profs, K. Moriwaki and K. Shibuya, the leaders of the 39th
We a}sQ express our thanks to the members of the 39th and 38th parties, especially Mr.
A. Masuyama and Dr. K, Seto, respectively, for their cooperation in the field work.
of this manuscript.
References
Burkholder, P.R. and MandeHi, E,F, (1965): Productivityof rnicrealgae in Antarctic sea ice. Science, 149,
872 874.
Fukuchi, M,, Tanirnura, A. and Ohtsuka, H. (1984):Seasonal change of chlorophylla under fast ice in
Ltitzow-Holm Bay, Antarctica. Mem. Natl Inst.Polar Res., Spec. Issue,32, 51-S9.
Fukuchi, M.. Tanimura, A. and Ohtsuka, H. (198S): Marine biological and oceanographical investigations in
Ltitzew-Hotm Bay, Antarctica,AntarcticNutrient Cycles and Food Webs. ed. by W.R. Siegfriedet
aL Berlin,Springer,52-59.
Heshiai,T. (198la): Proliferation of ice algae in the Syowa Stationarea, Antarctica.Mem, Natl Inst.Polar
Biol.,67, 283-288.
Marchant, H.J., Watanabe, K. and Kawachi, M. (1996); Marine snow in Antarctic coastal waters. Proc.
NIPR Symp, PolarBiol.,9, 75-83.
Med]in, L.K. and Priddle,J. (1990):Polar Marine Diatoms. Cambridge, BritishAntarctic Survey, 214p,
Parsons,T.R., Maita, Y. and Lalli,C,M, (1984): A Manual of Chemicaland BiologicalMethods for Seawater
Analysis.Oxford,Pergamon Press,173 p.
Riehardson, M.G. and Whitaker, T.M. (1979): An Antarctic fast-icefood ehain: observations on the
interactionof the amphipod Pbntogeneia antarctiea Cheyrellx with ice-associated micro-algae. Br.
AntarcLSurv.Bull.,47, 107-11S.
Riebesell,U,, Schloss,I. and Smetacek, V. (1991):Aggregation of algae released from melting sea ice:
implicationsfor seeding and sedimentation, Polar Biol.,11, 239-24S,
Sasaki, H. and Hoshiai, T. <1986): Sedimentation oi' microa]gae under the Antarctic fbst ice in summer.
Mem. Natl Inst.Polar Res., Spec. Issue,40, 45-55.
Satoh,H, and Watanabe, K. (1988): Primary productivityinthe fasticearea near Syowa Station,Antaretica,
during spring and summer 1983184. J,Oceangr.Soc. Jpn.,44, 287 292.
Satoh, H,, Watanabe, K., Kanda, H, and Takahashi, E. (1986): Seasonal changes of chlorophylla standlng
stocks and oceanographic conditions under fast ice near Syowa Station,Antarctica, in 1983184.
Nankyoku Shiry6 (Antarct. Rec.),30,19-32,
Satoh, H., Watanabe, K. and Hoshiai, T. (1991): Estimates of primary preduction by ice algae and
phytoplankton in the coastal ice-covered area near Syowa Station,Antarctica. Nankyeku Shiry6
(Antarct. Rec,), 35, 30-38.
Sirnonsen,R, (1974): The diatom plankton of the Indian Ocean Exped{tion of R,V. "Meteor"
1964-65,
Meteor Forschungsergeb. (D,Biol.),19, 1-66.
Smith, W,O. and Nelson. D.M. (1985):Phytoplankton bloom produced by a Teceding iceedge in the Ross Sea:
spatial coherence with the densityfield. Science,227, 163-166.
Suzuki, R. and Ishimaru, T. (1990):An improved method for the determinationof phytoplankton chlorophyl]
using N, N-dimethylformamide. J. Oceangr. Soc. Jpn., 46, 190-194.
Wakatsuchi, M. (1982): Seasonal variations in water structure under fasticettear Syowa Station,Antarctica,
in 1976. Nankyoku Shiry6 (Antarct, Rec.), 74,85-108.
Watanabe,K. (1982):Centrlc diatom communities found in the Antarctic sea ice, Nankyoku Shiry6
(Antarct. Rec.),74, 119-126.
Watanabe, K. (1988): Sub-ice microalgal strands in the Antarctic ceasta] fastice area near Syowa Station.
Jpn. J. Phycol.,36, 221--229.
Watanabe, K, and Satoh, H. (1987): Seasonal variations of ice algal standing crop near Syowa Station, east
Antarctica,in 1983184, Bull,Plankton Soc. Jpn.,34, 143 164,
Watanabe, K,, Satoh,H. and Hoshiai, T. (1990); Seasonalvariation inice algal assemblages inthe fasticenear
Syowa Stationin 1983/84, AntarcticEcosystems, Ecologica]Change nnd Conservation, ed. by K.R.
Kerry and G. Hempe1, Heidelberg,Springer,136-142.
rReceived
October 13, l999; Revised manuscript accepted FlebruatyZ 2000)