Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Solis Indie
Solis Indie
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to look at the histories of community-based art and social justice art
and the influence both movements have to art education in schools. It chronicles the impact these
movements have on young people and specifies some key learnings and contributions.
Highlighted in this paper are significant people and organizations that are part of the community-
based social justice art movement. This paper concludes with an outline of ways to begin
multicultural perspectives and social justice work into our art programs.
Keywords: community-based art education, social justice art, culturally relevant teaching,
multiculturalism
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 3
Introduction
Art has been an integral part of society going back as far as we can trace through
storytelling and legacies left behind. When we look at community-based art programs we see
different tendrils spanning out in multiple directions. There is so much potential when we come
together as a community to brainstorm, create, and provide a mutual exchange of ideas, services,
and art. I will connect the history of community-based art programs to social justice art and delve
into the reasons it’s so important for art educators to bring these principles into the education
system. “Art education practice provides a significant opportunity for students to engage in a
research about movements and people with ties to community and social justice art, I found
myself being pulled in many directions. Ultimately, there are numerous paths into this work and
it’s vital that we connect young people to issues they value and to their communities.
I focused on movements and work specifically from the United States, starting in the
early 1900s, to showcase a range of folks doing this work. I started with John Dewey, an art
educator who was prominent in the Progressive Education movement, and ended with a youth-
based, advocacy theater company called Rising Youth Theatre. People use art to make their
voices heard and you’ll see that these movements have had a lasting impact decades later.
Finally, I’ll examine the Culturally Responsive Teaching (CRT) curriculum to show that the
foundations have been laid in our education system for this work to continue. “Students learn to
think of diversity as a strength, and that no one way of being is the norm,” (Garber, 2004, p.9).
By offering students opportunities to explore their ideas and positions on race and other social
justice issues through historical, cultural, and social practices in art, they will begin to recognize
community art programs that improve art skills, promotion of contextual learning about local art
and culture, and outreach programs to empower different groups of people. “This work often
shares a commitment to create art that draws attention to, mobilizes action towards, or attempts
programs, with a focus on education, first emerged in the United States at the beginning of the
twentieth century to assist new immigrants in building marketable skills (Davis, 2010). Skill-
based arts learning continued in art centers and was actually seen in local Massachusetts public
schools as early as the 1860s (Stankiewicz, 2001). Davis (2010) states that, “From theater
programs designed to expand the horizons of young people who have been incarcerated to
intercultural mural making aimed at social reconciliation, these centers identify and serve
changing community needs,” (p.85). The progressive movement at the turn of the twentieth
century had a major impact on art education because school systems were being criticized for
their rigidity, rules, and routines. Art educators, inspired by this movement, adapted their
curriculums to be less rigid. There were varying paths in this movement with some educators
wanting to give total freedom to their students, others wanting more community focused
curriculums, and some wanting a more child-centered approach (Stankiewicz, 2001). “John
Dewey argued that schools should be social centers where groups of children explored subject
matter selected with their interests and local community needs in mind,” (Stankiewicz, 2001,
p.33). During the 1960s, cutbacks in arts education in schools led to artists creating centers to
Community-based art programs serve the needs of multiple populations and foster
cognitive goals, like increasing skills in making and appreciating arts, enhancing creative
thinking, focus, and self-discipline. They foster personal and interpersonal goals that help create
self-awareness, self-expression, respect for others, and the ability to communicate and work
together. “Researchers studying these sites have found that they offer younger children and teens
authentic entrepreneurial encounters, opportunities for work that they see having a positive
impact on their communities, and the chance to meet high expectations and experience deep
engagement,” (Davis, 2010, p.85). They provide knowledge of one’s heritage and highlight the
the intersection of arts-learning and community engagement by interacting with and performing
for the public. Davis (2010) highlighted that young people can grow a strong sense of personal
These community-based art programs and artists are concerned with the ways art can
function and be accessible in different avenues like community development, education, the
environment, healthcare, politics, and disability, to name a few. There is an openness to work
with all media, disciplines, and locations from prisons, outdoors, juvenile halls and public
schools (deNobriga and Schwarzman, 1999). Art teachers who integrate understanding of their
local communities into the curriculum give motivation to work towards community-based
program goals. Students are more invested in the learning process and in projects that investigate
and tackle issues that concern them and their communities. “Through collective identification of
generative themes, teachers can draw all students into personal engagement with the curriculum
content because learning new skills becomes an important skill for exploring significant life
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 6
issues,” (Gude, 2007, p.8). By studying local cultures, young people develop a basis for
Arts-Based Service-Learning
The progressive education movement produced a service-learning effort that gained
widespread interest, in the 1990s, as a way to engage and inform citizens through direct
acts as a tool to bring people together, to support collective action and change the physical
landscape of a community in a mutually empowering way. “Given the power of art to transform
and the power of service learning to engage, art educators in the academy have a moral
community crisis in civic engagement,” (Krensky and Steffen, 2008, p.18). By exploring social
issues and meeting a community-identified need, we can create a community-based art education
of visual and performing art that aims to raise critical consciousness, builds community, and
motivates people to promote social change. Naidus (2005) writes, “In my mind, it begins in the
fifteenth century with the invention of the printing press,” (p.169). During this time, illustrated
newspapers were created and circulated to speak about the injustices experienced by poor people
at the hands of the mediaeval lords and Church establishment (Naidus, 2005). There are
examples of socially engaged art in many forms over the centuries that can be seen in songs,
satirical theater pieces, and visual art. To trace social justice and community-based art through
the public and educational spheres we need to look at critical theory and its influence in the
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 7
United States, starting in the 1960s. European neo-Marxist theory and Brazilian educator Paulo
Freiere’s theory were vehicles for responding to political and economic oppression (Freedman,
response to the desire for extreme individualism. “By the 1970s, the U.S. version of neo-Marxist
theory and Freire's "pedagogy of the oppressed" became entangled in education with feminist
and cultural theory related to civil rights,” (Freedman, 2000, p.320). By the 1980s, critical
theory, no matter which line you went down, referred to critical reflection at a social level and
became part of the discourse of art education which perpetuated the growth of social viewpoints
in the field. Art educators, who had grown up in the 1950s and 1960s and been a part of the civil
rights marches and protests again the Vietnam War, were the ones pushing these social
viewpoints. Freedman (2000) writes, “Their convictions about the relationship between aesthetic
meaning, civil rights, and social justice were long held and strongly felt,” (p.321). Profound
changes have happened in the visual art world and art educators are responsible for representing
issues such as race and violence. As Dewhurst (2010) writes, “as long as the process of making
arts offers participants a way to construct knowledge, critically analyze an idea, and take action
in the world, then they are engaged in a practice of social justice artmaking,” (p.8). Socially
engaged art provokes thought, creates dialogue between groups in conflict, empowers, heals,
educates, enlightens, transforms, and makes invisible groups more visible. Naidus (2005) gives
examples of activist art over the last several decades including protest art during the Vietnam
War era, pre-McCarthy era socially engaged art, art about the AIDS crisis, early feminist art, and
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 8
contemporary work that embraces women’s issues (p.179). It has also been argued that art is a
public good, a human right, cultural history, and a means to heightened experiences. “Many
theorists and practitioners have called for an arts education that clearly links the arts to social
change," (Quinn, 2010, p. 227), drawing from social reconstructionist, multicultural, and critical
was to provide students an equal opportunity to learn about experiences, histories, cultures, and
perspectives of people of color (Acuff and Kraehe, 2013). It’s about providing young people
with an authentic truth about the many contributions and stories that have been left out of history
books, but make up America. It’s also a way to show how we interrelate and how our paths are
intimately tied together (Delacruz, 1995). In order to gain a more realistic perspective on how
our country was developed everyone needs to hear these reconstructed histories (Delacruz,
1995). Accuff and Kraehe (2013) write that, “critical multiculturalism provides the best means
by which to integrate and advance various theoretical threads that address power relations and
are potentially transformative even outside of the traditional classroom,” (p.300). These
curriculums help us see the world through the eyes of other people by looking at the complex
aesthetic, social, and historical contexts of the artwork from which they emerge in terms of
shared and unique meanings and purposes. Gude (2007) writes that it’s better to introduce
students to fewer artworks and cultures in depth than to present many pieces with little to no
context. “Multicultural art education teaches students and teachers that art is purposeful,
reconceptualize who we are, what kind of people we want to be, and what we want to teach our
young people. Delacruz (1995) sums it up by saying, “Our views of our art, our culture, and our
children, along with our notions of what knowledge is and how it is influenced by educational
John Dewey was a major player in the advancement of the progressive education
movement. At the end of the nineteenth century we saw growth of a new middle-class
professionalism in America following the Gilded Age, which allowed for mass urbanization
(Hopkins, 2017). Hopkins (2017) writes about the desire to move away from traditional,
literature-based education into a curriculum that could meet the public needs, function in the
modern and daily life, and was reflective of the current political and industrial life. Dewey
wanted course instruction to revolve around projects, field work, and questioning instead of
recitation. “Dewey saw the university function as a way to improve the democratic community
by effectively using academic freedom against the power of convention,” (Hopkins, 2017, p.62).
United States civil rights organization formed in 1909 as an interracial endeavor to advance
justice for African Americans by a group. Some prominent members of this group included
W.E.B. Du Bois, Mary White Ovington, Moorfield Storey, and Ida B. Wells (Tuttle, 1999).
Between 1920 and 1938, the N.A.A.C.P. marked lynchings by flying a black and white flag from
the window of its New York headquarters on Fifth Avenue. The banner read, “A Man Was
Lynched Yesterday”, confronting residents with the horrifying regularity of these murders. The
N.A.A.C.P. stopped flying the flag when their landlord threatened to evict them if it was not
removed. In 2015, artist Dread Scott was compelled to recreate this flag after witnessing the
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 10
video of Walter Scott who was stalked and murdered by Michael Slager, a North Charleston
police officer, as he fled for his life (Scott, 2020). He updated the text to read “A Man Was
Lynched by Police Yesterday” and the flag was displayed on the façade of the Jack Shainman
Gallery in New York during a 2016 exhibition organized by the artist-run political action group,
For Freedoms. Scott (2020) talks about his work, “My art often looks at how the past sets the
stage for the present but also exists in the present in new form. This artwork is an unfortunately
necessary update to address a horror from the past that is haunting us in the present.” The gallery
removed the flag to a display indoors following pressure from their building owner.
AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power (Act Up) was officially formed in 1987 after six men
in New York City – Avram Finkelstein, Brian Howard, Oliver Johnston, Charles Kreloff, Chris
Lione, and Jorge Socarrás – began meeting to share their experiences of AIDS related loss. The
government and mainstream media had ignored the AIDS epidemic in the early years and it
wasn’t until 1985 that President Reagan finally uttered the word “AIDS”, after 12,000
Americans had already died (Bennington-Castro, 2020). Before Act Up became official, their
conversations turned political and inspired by posters from the Art Workers Coalition and the
Guerrilla Girls they took six months to settle on the Silence=Death design (Finkelstein, 2013).
The poster shows a hot pink triangle, an inverted version of the symbol Nazis used to label gay
men, on a black background above the words “Silence=Death”. In February of 1987, they began
wheat pasting the poster all over the city (Finkelstein, 2013). “We hoped the poster might
stimulate some kind of collective action. But we were unprepared for what was actually
coming,” (Finkelstein, 2013). This poster became the most enduring icon of H.I.V./AIDS related
activism and was the catalyst for the formation of Act Up. Later that year, April 15, 1987, Act
Up stormed the city’s General Post Office carrying copies of the poster to an audience of people
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 11
filing last minute tax returns. This act gave them media coverage since television media routinely
did stories about last minute tax return filers (Crimp, 1990).
Project Row Houses is a community platform that enriches lives through art with an
emphasis on cultural identity and its impact on the urban landscape. They work in a collective
creative action with neighbors, artists, and enterprises to help create sustainable opportunities in
marginalized communities (Project Row Houses, 2020). In 1992, Rick Lowe had been living in
Houston for seven years when a few high school students visited him at his studio while he was
making large-scale paintings and sculptures inspired by the poverty and inequality he saw around
him in the city’s Third Ward. He was inspired to create Project Row Houses when one of the
kids asked him, “If you’re an artist, why don’t you come up with a creative solution to the
problem?” Lowe and a group of collaborators raised money to buy 22 shotgun houses, and
renovated them for artists’ residencies and community use. On the Project Row House website
they state, “The organization brought together groups and pooled resources to materialize
sustainable opportunities for artists, young mothers, small businesses, and Third Ward
Residents”. This project began to shift the understanding of art from a traditional studio practice
to a more conceptual base that transformed the social environment. They have helped cultivate
independent change by supporting people and their ideas and providing them with the tools and
Groundswell is an organization that engages youth in the creative process at the intersection of
arts education, youth development, and social justice to inspire community engagement and social
change. The organization was founded in 1996 by a group of New York City artists, educators, and
activists who believed that collaborative art-making combines personal expression with the
(Groundswell, 2020). Since their foundation, Groundswell has completed over 500 murals while
working with youth and teaching artists in collaboration with hundreds of community-based
organizations, neighborhood groups, and government agencies throughout New York City.
These murals are the end product of a comprehensive youth, community, and artistic
collaboration. They strive to infuse this collaboration process with elements of social justice and
activism to amplify and lift up the people they interact with daily. The collaborative process
behind these compelling artworks demonstrate our enduring belief that art creates community
Rising Youth Theatre was founded in 2011, in Phoenix, Arizona, and their mission is to
imagine and build the world we want to live in through youth-driven, multigenerational
collaboration, and a justice-centered artistic process and performance that generates reflection,
connection, and action (Rising Youth Theatre, 2020). The company works with young people
and professional adult artists to create socially relevant, original plays that have a positive impact
on their community. Young people work alongside adults in creating original plays, develop
social emotional skills through arts education in their schools, and grow into community leaders
through strong relationships and arts learning. Young people work in leadership spaces across all
levels of the organization, including the staff, board, and creative spaces using the arts as
powerful tools with which they can stand up and advocate for themselves and their peers.
people learn in school and their cultures, languages, values, and experiences. In the early 1990s, Dr.
Gloria Ladson-Billings made “culturally relevant pedagogy”, which has evolved into CRT, popular and
provided clarification between critical and culturally relevant pedagogy (Gay, 2010). She said the
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 13
difference being that culturally relevant pedagogy urges collective action grounded in cultural
understanding, experiences, and ways of knowing the world (Ladson-Billings, 1992). “This model
acknowledges that culture is fundamental to learning and in order for learning to be meaningful,
the central facets of culture should be embraced, not just as a passing fad but with deeper
meaning that gets to the core of who students are and encompasses from where they came,”
(Hunter-Doniger, Howard, Harris, Hall, 2018, p.47). Students are better able and more willing to
invest in the learning process if they have a personal investment in what is being taught. When
teachers acknowledge and value the different lived experiences of their students they are able to
get young people to actively participate in lessons and become part of the process (Hunter-
Doniger, 2018).
preparation reinforce the need for teachers to have a culturally sensitive educational ideology,
ethnic and cultural literacy, and skills in culturally centered pedagogy,” (Gay, 1997, p.163). Gay
(1997) writes that teachers cannot implement multicultural education effectively if they have
received minimal exposure to cultural diversity in professional and personal development. She
also highlights that infrequent, scattered, and surface level exposure to cultural diversity does not
constitute sufficient preparation (Gay, 1997). “Most proponents of multicultural education agree
that preparing teachers to work effectively with ethnically and culturally diverse populations and
content is a multidimensional process,” (Gay, 1997, p.161). This work is ongoing and will not
happen overnight but it’s crucial to use the art educator platform to center a culturally responsive
teaching standpoint.
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 14
Student Driven Projects allow young people to select their own topics for exploration
and respond with activities and lessons that move them into a deeper analysis. By allowing them
to maintain control over the direction of their projects, with guidance and prompts as necessary,
they are encouraged to articulate their intentions for their artwork and share with others. “In
social justice education, students' interests, voices, and lives are now understood as part of
curriculum,” (Garber, 2004, p.6). This process empowers young people by reclaiming their
voices and learning to resist oppressive power that exploits themselves and others (Garber,
2004). It’s important for students to see teachers as intellectuals “rather than as technicians
implementing prepackaged content and instructional procedures,” (Garber, 2004, p.8). When
teachers are empowered as leaders who are capable of promoting and implementing social
change and social justice this will provide the foundation for students to believe that social
justice is possible.
Relevant Reflection should be encouraged so learners can reflect on their own identities,
experiences, and interests to help them identify project topics that are meaningful and rooted in
their own lives (Dewhurst, 2010). An anti-racist education offers students opportunities to
explore their positions on race and other types of discrimination, with time to reflect, talk
through their discoveries, and begin to ask critical questions. This web of connections will help
educators implement, “questioning as a tool to prompt learners to delve into a study of their
A Tactical Balance should be “encouraged to balance both their activist intentions and
their aesthetic aims – sacrificing neither one for the other,” (Dewhurst, 2010, p.12). As students
narrow in on the specific strategies they want to use to create their art, they begin the process of
translating their ideas into objects or actions that will affect injustice. “Art that is created to
challenge or change injustices must be allowed to leave the confines of the room in which it was
made in order to reach the intended impacts of the artist,” (Dewhurst, 2010, p.12). Students work
should be brought to a public audience. Although there are risks to opening up art to the public,
by locking it up there is no way for the work to influence inequality and change and has no
Conclusion
With the advancement of technology, young people have access to more information than
ever before. In my work with young people I have been surprised by how much they know and
recognize about what’s going on in the world around them. It’s important to engage them on
topics and issues that they personally feel connected to, which means we as educators need to
keep up on the trends. It’s also important to have conversations and be open to communication
about our students’ individual needs and desires. There has always been community art and there
have always been social justice movements but now these movements and conversations are
Social media has only enhanced the circulation of information including social justice art.
“It is up to us teachers to promote social justice while creating an artistic environment in the
classroom when faced with narrow perspectives created by limited art education and by
museums, galleries, and books dominated by the artwork of White men,” (Hunter-Doniger, 2018,
p.17). We should embrace pop culture and be the leaders young people need us to be. The
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 16
foundations and momentum are already present in our education system. As artists and art
educators we already have the perfect platform to provide students with a safe space to create,
explore, and engage with peers and the community about issues that our world is facing. It’s a
long and arduous process to change, especially going up against a white supremacist system with
ties in every facet of this country, but it is imperative that we try. Every step, no matter how
small, matters.
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 17
References
reagan
Beyerbach, B. (2011). Chapter One: Social Justice Education Through the Arts. Counterpoints,
http://www.jstor.org.lp.hscl.ufl.edu/stable/42981592
Clark, G., & Zimmerman, E. (2000). Greater Understanding of the Local Community: A
Community-Based Art Education Program for Rural Schools. Art Education, 53(2), 33-
39. doi:10.2307/3193848
Art Centers Teach Us about Arts Education. The Journal of Aesthetic Education, 44(3),
82–95. https://doi.org/10.1353/jae.2010.0001
deNobriga, K., & Schwarzman, M. (1999). Archival Revival | Community-based Art for Social
art-for-social-change/
COMMUNITY-BASED ART EDUCATION’S ARC INTO SOCIAL JUSTICE ART 18
Social Justice Art Education.” Art Education, vol. 63, no. 5, 2010, pp. 6–13. JSTOR,
Finkelstein, Avram (2013, November 22). The Silence=Death Poster [Blog post]. Retrieved from
https://www.nypl.org/blog/2013/11/22/silence-equals-death-poster
Force, T., Lescaze, Z., Hass, N., & Miller, M. H. (2020, October 28). The 25 Most Influential
Works of American Protest Art Since World War II. The New York Times.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/15/t-magazine/most-influential-protest-art.html
Freedman, K. (2000). Social Perspectives on Art Education in the U. S.: Teaching Visual Culture
Garber, E. (2004). Social Justice and Art Education. Visual Arts Research, 30(2), 4-22. Retrieved
Peabody Journal of Education, 72(1), 150-177. Retrieved February 21, 2021, from
http://www.jstor.org.lp.hscl.ufl.edu/stable/1493265
Gay, Geneva (2010). Culturally responsive teaching: Theory, Research, and Practice (2nd ed.).
Giroux, H. A. (1991). Border Pedagogy and the Politics of Postmodernism. Social Text, 28, 51.
https://doi.org/10.2307/466376
Gude, O. (2007). Principles of Possibility: Considerations for a 21st-Century Art & Culture
https://doi.org/10.1080/00043125.2007.11651621
Hopkins, E. (2017). John Dewey and Progressive Education. The Journal of Educational
Hunter-Doniger, T. (2017). “But He Looks Like Me. I Never Saw an Artist Look Like That”:
Making Connections to Social Justice Through Art. Art Education, 71(1), 17–19.
https://doi.org/10.1080/00043125.2018.1389587
Hunter-Doniger, T., Howard, C., Harris, R., & Hall, C. (2017). STEAM Through Culturally
https://doi.org/10.1080/00043125.2018.1389593
Kraehe, A. M., & Acuff, J. B. (2013). Theoretical Considerations for Art Education Research
with and about “Underserved Populations.” Studies in Art Education, 54(4), 294–309.
https://doi.org/10.1080/00393541.2013.11518904
Krensky, B., & Steffen, S. L. (2008). Arts-Based Service-Learning: A State of the Field. Art
Ladson‐Billings, Gloria (1992). "Reading between the lines and beyond the pages: A culturally
doi:10.1080/00405849209543558
and-core-values
(Eds.), The arts, education, and social change: Little signs of hope. New York: Peter
Lang
Scott, D. (2020, November 20). A Man Was Lynched by Police Yesterday. Dread Scott.
https://www.dreadscott.net/portfolio_page/a-man-was-lynched-by-police-yesterday/
Tuttle, Kate (1999). National Association for the Advancement of Colored People. In Appiah,
K.A. & Gates Jr., H.L. (Eds.), Africana: The encyclopedia of the African and African
https://doi.org/10.1080/00393541.2011.11518840