Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ashley Vargas Thesis Final
Ashley Vargas Thesis Final
How has queer representation in 21st century children’s cartoons impacted youth
audiences’ understanding of sexual identity?
Ashley Vargas
Fashion Institute of Technology
SS 444
Professor Celik Levine
December 1, 2020
2
Abstract
This research paper aims to understand how queer representation in children’s cartoons
can result in LGBTQ youth gaining a better understanding of their sexuality. This was done
through analyzing two studies from Communique and the International Journal of
Communication that quantify how media impacts the minds of LGBTQ individuals. Also, it will
examine queer characters in cartoons throughout history and how they have developed into
genuine and positive influences on their audiences. Once these factors were connected, it was
determined that cartoons can be a positive social support for LGBTQ youth. They can result in
queer children feeling more confident in their identity or questioning their identity from a young
age.
3
Introduction
With each new generation, the starting age of internet usage becomes younger and
younger. However, a lack of curation and age-restrictions on social media platforms like
YouTube, Tumblr, and Twitter, young minds are often exposed to harmful content1. These
platforms cannot fully control the content they recommend to child users. Unfortunately, for the
LGBTQ preteen audience, these social media platforms were the first and frequently only places
to find content that represents who they are and be a part of safe communities composed of other
queer youth who feel the same2. Often, G-rated media targeted towards children avoids LGBTQ
themes due to queer topics being taboo or deemed too sexual for young audiences. Therefore,
queer children must look to social media platforms for representation. However, this results in
Until the last decade, larger youth media channels like Disney, Cartoon Network, and
DreamWorks, did not create shows that had characters of diverse LGBTQ identities. This was
until a new wave of cartoons were greenlit and the writers behind them pushed behind the scenes
for queer representation. Though these cartoons were not made without imperfections, they were
made with children in mind. Shows like Adventure Time, Steven Universe, and She-Ra and the
Princesses of Power explicitly display same sex love and different types of gender representation
within G ratings. This representation not only positively impacts LGBTQ children, but how
those in their family and social circles accept and see them. Through the study of the reception of
these western cartoons, we can gain insight of how queer representation in 21st century children’s
1
Martin, F., Wang, C., Petty, T., Wang, W., & Wilkins, P. (2018). Middle School Students’ Social Media
Use. Journal of Educational Technology & Society, 21(1), 213-224.
2
Ridder, S., & Dhaenens, F. (2019). Coming Out as Popular Media Practice: The Politics of Queer Youth Coming
Out on YouTube. DiGeSt. Journal of Diversity and Gender Studies, 6(2), 43-60.
4
animated shows impacted youth audiences’ understanding of their own sexual identities. This
research will also serve to help the creation of a pitch deck of a LGBTQ inclusive cartoon,
Methodology
researched the impact that diversity in media has on young audiences and the benefits of them
joining show communities, or fandoms, they find online. I will also analyze audience’s positive
and negative reactions to cartoons known for their queer representation. The definition of queer
in the context of this paper is “an adjective used by some people, particularly younger people,
whose sexual orientation is not exclusively heterosexual”3. First, I researched the origins of
queer characters in animated western media. Then, I will examine Steven Universe and
Adventure Time on Cartoon Network, which have been recognized for paving the way for
LGBTQ+ representation in children’s shows. Then I will discuss She-Ra and the Princesses of
romantic relationship. All these shows had queer artists working on their staff, which will assist
to examine the importance of representation behind the scenes as well. Lastly, I reached out to
online forums and spoke with young fans about how these shows influenced how they viewed
themselves. When creating my pitch deck, my design and story choices were made with these
findings in mind.
3
Defining LGBTQ. (n.d.). The Center, https://gaycenter.org/about/lgbtq/
5
In a research study done by Communique, a psychology journal that aims to support and
enhance the mental health of children and youth, they define the minority stress theory. This
theory proposes that sexual minorities, or those whose sexual preference and practices differ
significantly from the mainstream4, go through distinct and chronic stress that results in
disproportionately adverse behavioral and mental health outcomes. These stressors include
victimization, discrimination, and family rejection which lead to queer individuals turning to
harmful coping strategies such as self-harm and drug usage. To counteract these stressors, the
study asserts that one of the main protective factors for these adolescents is social support. This
social support states that those who see or have relationships with other LGBTQ people are
reported to have lower rates of depression and feel more affirmed with their identity5.
A study done by the International Journal of Communication further explores this idea of
social support by analyzing the effects of gay adolescent portrayals in media on young viewers.
The researchers monitored the reaction of four hundred and sixty-nine participants ages thirteen
to twenty-one to a story line of two romantically involved thirteen-year-old boys. The results
found that LGBTQ youth that watched the narrative felt an emotional response of hope and
positive emotions. The study further explains that lack of LGBTQ representation may lead to
4
Sexual Minorities. (2010). In R. L. Jackson (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Identity (Vol. 2, pp. 723-729). SAGE
Reference. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/CX1700600247/GVRL?u=fitsuny&sid=GVRL&xid=dd6163e2
5
Taylor, J. (2019, November). Mental Health in LGBTQ Youth: Review of Research and
Outcomes. Communique, 48(3),
4+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A610762162/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=0806d882
6
youth, queer or not, believing that LGBTQ individuals are not an important or normal part of
broadcasting, much of the forming of public opinions occurs though what they see in media.
specifically in their search for role models they can relate and look up to. Finding queer “media-
models” were reported to have positively impacted lesbian, gay, and bisexual youth when
dealing with self-realization, coming out, and defining their identity6. A modern example of
these media models can be found on YouTube. Queer creators on YouTube facilitate their own
identity development and create communities through establishing more visibility and promoting
acculturation. This acculturation provides queer youth with information about shared experiences
and connects them with one another to help them interact with other LGBTQ individuals and
survive heteronormative culture7. This is another example of social support that can be provided
to LGBTQ individuals who might not have access to an immediate queer community. This social
support can be provided to a younger and wider audience when as we see the development of
6
Gillig, T. K., & Murphy, S. T. (2016). Fostering support for LGBTQ Youth? The effects of a gay adolescent media
portrayal on young viewers. International journal of communication [Online],
3828+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A491909946/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=602d7b4a
7
Wuest, B. (2014). Stories like Mine: Coming Out Videos and Queer Identities on YouTube. Queer Youth and
Media Cultures, 19–33. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137383556_2
7
The first appearances of gay characters in animated shows happened at the end of the
twentieth century. Many adult-oriented cartoons began using queer characters as a punchline.
Though it may have seemed progressive for shows like Family Guy, South Park, and The
Simpsons to have reoccurring LGBTQ characters in the nineties, the way that they are portrayed
often perpetuate negative stereotypes8. For example, in an episode of South Park which
premiered in nineteen-ninety-seven, Mr. Garrison, a closeted gay teacher, explains what “gay” is
Well, Stan, gay people are evil, evil right down to their cold black hearts which pump not
blood like yours and mine but rather a thick vomitous oil that oozes through their rotten
veins and clots in their pea-size brains, which becomes the cause of their Nazist patterns
of violent behavior. . . . Now you go outside and practice football like a good little
heterosexual9.
Though South Park is known for its edgy satire, this dialogue furthers the normalization of the
homophobic rhetoric to its audience. This is especially detrimental as this episode was one of the
first times a gay character was seen on mainstream animation. Another issue facing writing of
queer characters is making them recognizably queer while also not making their sexuality or
gender a character’s central trait10. For example, Smithers from The Simpsons, is a recurring gay
8
The Changing Representation of LGBTQ Cartoon Characters. (2018, November 12). UWIRE Text,
1. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A618737008/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=be08b758
9
Janssen, D. (2003). "Time to Lose Faith in Humanity": "The Simpsons, South Park", and the Satiric
Tradition. Studies in Popular Culture, 26(1), 27-36.
10
Green, M. (2013). Screenwriting Representation: Teaching Approaches to Writing Queer Characters. Journal of
Film and Video, 65(1-2), 30-42. doi:10.5406/jfilmvideo.65.1-2.0030
8
character, but does not have any other notable storylines besides his unrequited love for Mr.
Burns. Moreover, he did not officially come out as gay until twenty-sixteen, almost three
G-rated cartoons targeting children did not include recurring representation of queer
characters until twenty-ten. As a newer and more open-minded generation of showrunners were
hired, there was a notable uptick of queer representation in animated shows. The employment of
LGBTQ showrunners, writers, and animators at that time led to more positive and genuine
depictions of queer characters12. At first the appearances of these queer characters were cameos
of same-sex parents13; however, the following shows helped to bring queer romance to the
forefront.
Rebecca Sugar first gained notoriety for becoming the first female showrunner in Cartoon
Network’s history. She has since come out publicly as non-binary and bisexual14 and has used
this perspective to create one of the most historical representations of queer love in children’s
media. Steven Universe is an animated series on Cartoon Network placed in a fictional coastal
town in the United States. The main character Steven is a half-human and half-gem hybrid who
is being raised by three gem-based aliens named the Crystal Gems. Though the show is primarily
focused on Steven, a cisgender boy, the relationships that surround him often represent queer
11
D'Addario, D. (2016, April 04). The Simpsons: Waylon Smithers Coming Out as Gay Falls Flat.
https://time.com/4280546/the-simpsons-smithers-comes-out-episode-review/
12
The Changing Representation of LGBTQ Cartoon Characters. (2018, November 12). UWIRE Text,
1. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A618737008/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=be08b758
13
Roshanian, A. (2016, July 19). Nickelodeon's 'Loud House' to Feature Married Gay Couple.
https://variety.com/2016/tv/news/loud-house-gay-couple-nickelodeon-1201816592/
14
Rude, M. (2018, August 10). How This Nonbinary Woman Created the Queerest Cartoon on Television.
https://www.them.us/story/rebecca-sugar-steven-universe-interview
9
intimacy and Steven himself does not shy away from displaying more feminine traits15. The
show’s most notable feat was displaying the first ever same-sex wedding within a children’s
cartoon in the episode titled “Reunited”16. However, Sugar has been transparent about her
They brought me in for a meeting, and they essentially said, ‘We know that you’re doing
this, and we know that if we were to tell you to stop, that would be based in bigotry.
Ultimately they told me in this meeting that it would be my decision if I were going to
tell the truth about what I was doing, which in hindsight was a really bold move for
Cartoon Network to make, to actually give the decision to speak about this to the queer
Though Cartoon Network knew the possible repercussions of airing this episode, they decided to
take a progressive step forward and deal with the show being censored in multiple territories17. In
another interview she stated that the planning of this same-sex relationship began before gay
marriage was even legal, further exemplifying how Steven Universe is a historical step forward
Steven Universe’s most notable feat was its ability to intertwine this queer representation
seamlessly into its storyline. The characters did not need to be queer to tell a compelling
15
Ravela, C. (2017). STEVEN UNIVERSE. Queer Studies in Media & Pop Culture, 2(3),
389+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A511005192/PPDS?u=fitsuny&sid=PPDS&xid=c8ce40c4
16
Alptraum, L. (2018, July 09). Steven Universe's message of love is emphatically queer.
https://www.polygon.com/tv/2018/7/9/17549458/steven-universe-wedding-queer-love-ruby-sapphire
17
Holloway, D. (2020, April 07). 'Steven Universe' Creator Looks Back on Her Groundbreaking Series as It Comes
to a Close. https://variety.com/2020/tv/features/rebecca-sugar-cartoon-network-steven-universe-
1203537231/
18
Nick Romano August 13, & Romano, N. (2018, August 13). 'Steven Universe' creator is doing more for LGBTQ
visibility than you might know. https://ew.com/tv/2018/08/13/steven-universe-rebecca-sugar-lgbtq-
cartoons/
10
narrative; however, it is organic, and it is told from a protagonist who genuinely believes that
everyone deserves love. A major example of how LGBTQ themes are intertwined with the
storyline is the exploration of ‘fusion’ between the gems. Fusion is the ability for gems to
combine with one another to become a more powerful being. This fusion can only happen when
the gems are in sync and preform a choreographed dance that merges different dance styles.
These dances between two female presenting aliens imply romance and sometimes end in the
gems kissing. Besides the explicit physical representation these fusion dances give to their queer
audience, it also represents a stronger bond of trust and intimacy between two gems19. Garnet,
one of the main Crystal Gems, is revealed to have been a fusion of a Ruby and a Sapphire at the
end of the shows first season. The relationship between the two also gains more depth as the
audience learns that Ruby and Sapphire were not allowed to fuse in the eyes of their planet’s
leaders, and had to run away from their home to be together20. This reflects the homophobia
many queer couples face in the real world; however, it displayed in a way that younger children
Though Cartoon Network has received notable praise for airing queer relationships, it did
not come without criticism from the LGBTQ community. Sugar also worked on another Cartoon
Network original, Adventure Time. The show was created by Pendleton Ward, and its story is
centered on the adventures of Jake the dog and Finn the human in the land of Ooo21. Two
recurring love interests for the main hero Finn, Princess Bubblegum and Marceline the Vampire
Queen, were implied throughout the show to have had been in a lesbian relationship. However, it
was not until the shows finale that the two share a kiss and confirm their past romantic
19
Ravela, C. (2017). STEVEN UNIVERSE. Queer Studies in Media & Pop Culture
20
Pladek, Brittany. "Steven Universe." Science Fiction Film and Television
21
Leslie, C. (2015). Adventure Time and gender stereotypes. Screen Education, (78),
44+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A440821085/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=a24410e4
11
relationship. Many fans felt as if this was queerbaiting or an afterthought to the storyline22.
Queerbaiting is an unofficial media term referring to when show creators make characters seem
like they might be gay but have no intention of making it happen. This allows the show to appear
more progressive and gain a dedicated queer audience, while also not facing the consequences of
DreamWorks animation also has received criticism for queerbaiting. Voltron Legendary
Defender is a follows a group of five pilot students and their journeys in space. It received heavy
criticism for feeding into its fanbase’s push to romantically pair two of the main male characters
to grow the show’s audience. To appease fans to appear progressive, the show reveals one of the
older main characters had a previous gay relationship. However, the episode after this romance is
introduced, the main character’s past lover dies in a battle. Many within the queer community
refer to this as an example of the “bury your gays” trope, which refers to killing a LGBTQ
character or causing them suffering without progressing the plot24. The executive producer of the
show, Joaquim Dos Santos responded to the disappointed fans by explaining that, “…the staff
created this Voltron series with the intent of being as inclusive as possible.” However, he also
stated, “Are there still boundaries? Well, for this type of action adventure/product
driven/traditionally boys toys” show the answer is unfortunately yes.”25 The case of Voltron
Legendary Defender demonstrates the extra barrier more “masculine” shows face when trying to
22
The Changing Representation of LGBTQ Cartoon Characters. (2018, November 12). UWIRE Text
23
LGeekBT: The Damage of "Queerbaiting." (2016, March 30). UWIRE Text,
1. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A447839338/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=25df613f
24
The Changing Representation of LGBTQ Cartoon Characters. (2018, November 12). UWIRE Text, 8
25
Haasch, P. (2018, August 16). Voltron creator addresses fans over season 7's queerbaiting controversy.
https://www.polygon.com/tv/2018/8/16/17698024/voltron-adam-controversy-netflix-queerbaiting-dos-
santos-letter
12
appeal to a male audience at the expense of queer representation. In the research study done by
the International Journal of Communication, heterosexual boys had the highest rates of
experiencing disgust when viewing a show featuring a gay relationship26. This further explains
DreamWorks apprehension for including gay characters within a space action adventure targeted
She-Ra and the Princesses of Power. The show’s creator, Noelle Stevenson, is a lesbian comic
artist who is known for her feminist narratives27. The show centers around Adora, who can
transform into the powerful warrior She-ra, and her adventures with other magical princesses in
the enchanted land of Etheria28. The show is aimed at an adolescent girl audience with its pink
and sparkly art style; however, it quickly broke out of stereotypical expectations. Adora’s same-
sex romantic relationship is not only a side story within the series, but rather a pivotal piece
within its storyline. Catra, Adora’s half-cat humanoid childhood friend, is often on the side of
evil throughout the seasons; however, the love that the two have for one another climax within
the series finale. Throughout the show, their relationship goes through heartbreak, loss, and
growth. Their romance was undeniably planned since the first episode, which is why their
relationship provides such strong queer representation. Stevenson took a risk with She-ra and the
26
Gillig, T. K., & Murphy, S. T. (2016). Fostering support for LGBTQ Youth? The effects of a gay adolescent
media portrayal on young viewers. International journal of communication [Online],
3828+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A491909946/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=602d7b4a
27
Stevenson, N. (2020, October 11). Noelle Stevenson Shares Her Coming Out Story in an Original Comic.
https://www.oprahmag.com/life/relationships-love/a34100347/noelle-stevenson-coming-out-story/
28
'SHE-RA' CREATOR NOELLE STEVENSON TALKS TO GLAAD ABOUT THE FINAL SEASON, QUEER
REPRESENTATION IN ANIMATION, AND WATCHING 'KILLING EVE'. (2020, May 18). States
News Service,
NA. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A626548115/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=eaea8aae
13
Princesses of Power by placing this lesbian romance in the center of the show’s narrative.
I had been working closely with a few members of the crew specifically on the Catra and
Adora story, the writers were in on it. Some of the board artists were in on it. It was a
secret that was kept close to the heart of the crew. Then once we started the writing for
that final season, I was like, this is time. It is time now. There was a day where I just
entered the writer's room, like [I] was a cartoon character, I kicked the door open, I was
like, "I'm going to further the gay agenda. All right everybody, here's the plan, here's
Like Sugar, Stevenson also had intentions of including LGBTQ themes within her show since its
conception and received high praise from queer fans. Beyond the show’s romantic
representation, fans also identified with the diverse character designs of the princesses. In a
response to a Reddit post I made in the She-ra community asking “Did She-Ra help you feel
more comfortable about your sexual identity growing up? If so how?”, anonymous fans shared:
I mean I'm pretty short but I do have big """manly""" shoulders and honestly she ra really
Oh my god yes, it has. I'm a trans woman (17) but only some of my closest friends and
family members know. I'm really glad that I started watching this show when I did,
29
'SHE-RA' CREATOR NOELLE STEVENSON TALKS TO GLAAD ABOUT THE FINAL SEASON, QUEER
REPRESENTATION IN ANIMATION, AND WATCHING 'KILLING EVE'.
14
because Perfuma's character gives me hope. It's really great seeing someone like myself
in a normally cisgender space like cartoons. It helps me understand that I'm not alone.
These comments specifically refer to the characters of Scorpia and Perfuma, who both appear to
have flat chests and more masculine body types. However, the show uses these designs to further
Conclusion
When looking at the main commonalities of the shows examined it is apparent that there
is a stronger ease in displaying LGBTQ representation in children’s shows with a more feminine
audience. Nolle Stevenson and Rebecca Sugar were able to succeed in their portrayals of queer
storylines not only because of their own genuine experiences, but the shows that they produced
had a more accepting audience that would support them. Also, there are still barriers because
most queer characters are often non-human, and their stories can only take place in alternative
universes to our own. These shows can provide social support to a wider audience of young
people and are created with them in mind. When coming up with my own show idea, I designed
a more masculine main character within a setting close to the world we live in. Though cartoons
are often used for escapism, its important for queer youth to see characters like them in a world
References
Alptraum, L. (2018, July 09). Steven Universe's message of love is emphatically queer.
Retrieved November 20, 2020, from
https://www.polygon.com/tv/2018/7/9/17549458/steven-universe-wedding-queer-love-
ruby-sapphire
D'Addario, D. (2016, April 04). The Simpsons: Waylon Smithers Coming Out as Gay Falls Flat.
Retrieved November 23, 2020, from https://time.com/4280546/the-simpsons-smithers-
comes-out-episode-review/
Fan, Y., Shepherd, L. J., Slavich, E., Waters, D., Stone, M., Abel, R., & Johnston, E. L. (2019).
Gender and cultural bias in student evaluations: Why representation matters. PLoS
ONE, 14(2),
e0209749. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A573981588/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&x
id=483f1a59
Gillig, T. K., & Murphy, S. T. (2016). Fostering support for LGBTQ Youth? The effects of a gay
adolescent media portrayal on young viewers. International journal of
communication [Online],
3828+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A491909946/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=
602d7b4a
Haasch, P. (2018, August 16). Voltron creator addresses fans over season 7's queerbaiting
controversy. Retrieved November 26, 2020, from
https://www.polygon.com/tv/2018/8/16/17698024/voltron-adam-controversy-netflix-
queerbaiting-dos-santos-letter
Holloway, D. (2020, April 07). 'Steven Universe' Creator Looks Back on Her Groundbreaking
Series as It Comes to a Close. Retrieved November 30, 2020, from
16
https://variety.com/2020/tv/features/rebecca-sugar-cartoon-network-steven-universe-
1203537231/
Karmo, L. (2020, September 30). All ages cartoons bring new perspective to LGBTQIA+
representation. UWIRE Text,
1. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A636978550/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=3e2f
5568
Knowles, Samantha. "'We're alive and we're breathing': How queerbaiting harms the LGBTQ
community." UWIRE Text, 19 June 2020, p. 1. Gale Academic
OneFile, https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A627336883/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xi
d=749be90c. Accessed 19 Nov. 2020.
Leslie, C. (2015). Adventure Time and gender stereotypes. Screen Education, (78),
44+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A440821085/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=a2
4410e4
Nick Romano August 13, & Romano, N. (2018, August 13). 'Steven Universe' creator is doing
more for LGBTQ visibility than you might know. Retrieved November 24, 2020, from
https://ew.com/tv/2018/08/13/steven-universe-rebecca-sugar-lgbtq-cartoons/
Pladek, B. (2016). Steven Universe. Science Fiction Film and Television, 9(3),
501+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A474661215/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=4
63f89b8
Ridder, S., & Dhaenens, F. (2019). Coming Out as Popular Media Practice: The Politics of
Queer Youth Coming Out on YouTube. DiGeSt. Journal of Diversity and Gender
Studies, 6(2), 43-60. Retrieved December 1, 2020, from
https://libproxy.fitsuny.edu:2598/stable/10.11116/digest.6.2.3
17
Roshanian, A. (2016, July 19). Nickelodeon's 'Loud House' to Feature Married Gay Couple.
Retrieved November 13, 2020, from https://variety.com/2016/tv/news/loud-house-gay-
couple-nickelodeon-1201816592/
Rude, M. (2018, August 10). How This Nonbinary Woman Created the Queerest Cartoon on
Television. Retrieved November 23, 2020, from https://www.them.us/story/rebecca-
sugar-steven-universe-interview
Sexual Minorities. (2010). In R. L. Jackson (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Identity (Vol. 2, pp. 723-729).
SAGE
Reference. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/CX1700600247/GVRL?u=fitsuny&sid=GVRL
&xid=dd6163e2
Stevenson, N. (2020, October 11). Noelle Stevenson Shares Her Coming Out Story in an
Original Comic. Retrieved November 23, 2020, from
https://www.oprahmag.com/life/relationships-love/a34100347/noelle-stevenson-coming-
out-story/
Taylor, J. (2019, November). Mental Health in LGBTQ Youth: Review of Research and
Outcomes. Communique, 48(3),
4+. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A610762162/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=080
6d882
The Changing Representation of LGBTQ Cartoon Characters. (2018, November 12). UWIRE
Text,
1. https://link.gale.com/apps/doc/A618737008/AONE?u=fitsuny&sid=AONE&xid=be08
b758