Professional Documents
Culture Documents
سلوكيات القيادة التحويلية واثرها على الابداع التنظيمي
سلوكيات القيادة التحويلية واثرها على الابداع التنظيمي
د
א א
د
א
وووو
<<<<<<<<
د א
א
ود א
د א
א
ود א
א عא א א عא א
א عא א א عא א
א
د
א א
د
א
אد אد
د א
א
ود א
د א
א
ود א
אد אد
"\*! א !*\"א+
"\*! א !*\"+א+
+
* ) ( '& $ %س * ) ( '&% $س
د
< < < < < < < < < << <
,
, א א
B א א , Eא قAو C א B? 3 B א א , Eא قAو C א B? 3
ل אA
א Aאد\"ل,
"\אد,
,א א B Eא قAو C א B? 3 B א א , Eא قAو C א B? 3
ل אA
א\" Aאد,
"\אد,
ل
1
; :ً 4 8 $א1 2 &3 4 ل 67א א ,3د ل 67א ; :ً 4 8 $א א <= >? @4 3& 2 1א ,3د א @ ?> =<
; :ً 4 8 $א1 2 &3 4 ل 67א א ,3د ل 67א ; :ً 4 8 $א א <= >? @ 4 3& 2א ,3د @ ?> =< א
-. ( / $0 -. ( / $0
! !
! !
2010
/
@&F&@F
@&F&@ F
ل אA
א Aאد\"ل,
"\אد,
א Aل
א Aאد\" ل,
"\אد,
مممم
! B א ! א, C! وA א قE א B? 3 ضN
س $ %&' ( ) *
\"
س $ %&' ( ) *
F :אF :א
K
Z$ [ B ,א א אو
F :א: א
X !!YA !!
B4 א صP!!*A!! א وQ R !!& א وS4 !! א وB? T!! א$ ; U !! , %!!? V&!!K !! وW
FWWWW
VWWWW
V , ,א א
V , אV , א
مممم
1
LWWWW
L@ @א א
L@ אL@ א
/
2010
/
E@ 4 T , @ E@ 4 T , @
א א א א
E@ 4 T , @E@ 4 T , @
א א א א
$8J א,د
$8J د,א
و א عא א א
د
א و א عא א א
د
א
و א عא א א
د
א و א عא א א
د
א
W W W W
V, W 3^ وV , W 3^ و
E@ 4 אT _ ` E@ 4 אT _ `
/
V, W 3^ و, W 3^ و
1
2010
مممم
/
V
Kد,A אKد,Aא
Kد,A אKد,Aא
L@ L@
א א
L@ @א א
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
f$ &; א g
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
KKKKKKK
ً`א
cدא
? eK
, א
ً 3, h ً` א
KKKKKKK
, אذ Aא
ً N E? & ً وa,
ً`א
cوאWB אFd
KKKKKKK
KKKKKKKKKKK
-. ( / $0
KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
KKKKKKK
, א
, א
ج
א د
א
! ، ل و א، א
\"
א
! !
!J !;* ! !
و
!J !;*
و
! !
!J !;*! !
و
!J !;*
و
2 +CBא
جאA7
و9
…
89 ل :و
;
1 م0 אو = * ،אو
.>?@
2 ABא
34
\" N OP
7
+% 67
2/8
א
S=
0 VوW
א@ אو X*Eאو
KL9
،
HI
אً، Gאذ ? -E
8
ل אB
$א ذ @M 81
אUد ?2
אً
+
Rل
،
S
و Q، ً /ن א
$
9$
$ن
a P
E אل א
O
;
2/8
אوBא ذ 81
،
א _ 1א2
c1وB! א א ق
&% S
+\> א. > E + !h& و 1 43א &!. E% ل/O[9 + \ = ./b!& א. E
e f2 =0 א دg7
? Iو\[
&E,
و> $
K
$و
א ق !Bوc1 א
&%
א _ 1א2
& אO ` & א
S & bא
bא
2/ P E א
O
&^
2/8
]א ذ 81
م
و[\$
!I 9
و
K
& 1 א
@ $
مو% mI و
/م
9
ً %/
אوi
אBوg
،
و/A$א\
و g7א
\/A7
/ אو
אBلو
وI?$
%$
!I 9
م
و[\$
א Bل
א
I?$
K
ز f %نود
אد=27
زא(8
&& I 9 1 ن l$ 9א 4 3ز
[\ وI?
> Ek81
8A$و
\ \ 1B
0. S
،
ً /E %1 4 % % ً د$و
K
א
و
% @ I?$
S& _א
א0% % 3
9$ b e27@ دfאو
و$81 ذA$ I?$
KK
ً אA: e ًא، وKA
K
$و
I! &، %# (@ א 1 67 م4 3 א
K
(( א
אو
س * ) ( '&$ %
د
_
_ א א_א א
_ א אא א
.........
?k 8_א B` אو אو l7 א%? m ?k 8_א B` אو אو l7 א%? m
?k 8 _ אB ` אو אوl7 א%? m ?k 8 _ אB ` אو אوl7 א%? m
\" \" \" \"
? ? ? ?
fK 3 q &N f ; و B אو (, r אf(, fK 3 q &N f ; و B אو (, r אf(,
KKKK KKKK
JhJh
J hJ h
p אوp אو
p אو אو
fK 3 q &N f ; و B אو (, r אf(, fK 3 q &N f ; و B אو (, r אf(,
K 7אK 7א
K 7 אK 7א
KKKK KKKK
K %? v K %? v
f$u6 א אو @אK B? f$u6 א אو @אK B?
j\" j\" j\" j\"
K %? v K %? v
tאtא
t אtא
k
ل،'& م،א7&%،3 دא، ، ?،, k
ل،'& م،א7&%،3 א، ، ?،,
د
س $ %&' ( ) *
FR FR
BwBw
Bw Bw
c Z3
x c c Z3
xc
c Z3
x c Z3
xc
...
c
ع א o 4אo 4
@ aאu
!
א_ א
د
*; وJ
@ א T ,אE@ 4
n
H IJ
ج
و
1
B א { א|P 4
ل
م
א Tلوא @a
6
)
1
ـ
ـ
1
(
W
?
א4
)
س
)
5
9
א, א
א, א +א
W
(
ـ
(
א, ' א دو
W
ـ
10
6
)
1
)
Z Q و א, א ?;E
א, א oN
7
2
(
(
1
W
4
)
ـ
1
ـ
3
W
3
W
(
)
9
ـ
1
12
(
)
1
ـ
7
(
W
א, gא אد
10
)
1
ـ
8
א, } א جذ
(
W
12
W
و
I6 א I6 א
I6 אI6 א
u a@
א u a@
א
u a@
א u a@
א
)
א
د
א
16
1
15
ـ
ع א o 4אعo 4
ع
)
[, א[,א
& א א, cאو א
& א א, cאو א
~K~ K
(
?
א4
W
אאאא
[, א [ ,א
& א א, cאو א
& ,א א אوc א
v6I אv6I א
W W W W
17
K~ K~
2
W
ـ
v6I אv6I א
(
i ~ אi ~ א
56
i W W W W
$ 3A אوB א
& א א, א
6
W
(
Wא ?
ـ
54
W
2
)
2
ـ
5
)
(
א_א 3אو
8 א א_א 3אو
8 א
32
41
א عא א
د
א @k
)
W
א عא א
2
(
ـ
)
2
3
W
ـ
4
2
2
(
W
(
3
)
57
א_א 3אو
8 אא_א 3אو
8 א
?
א4
3
ـ
3
58
4
)
ـ
v אو אB4
و'
(
3
)
W
ـ
2
)
3
58
(
1
W
ـ
א, א ? ?Z
57
(
ـ
vא 'a 6 K $ א ? ??_k? %
,א $h
67
3
)
8
(
W
65
(
3
)
ـ
9
W
א
(
5
)
3
ـ
6
(
W
)
' a 6א? P &4 א אT B4
3
7
W
(
ـ
64
ز
u a@
א u a@
א
u a@
א u a@
א
(
0 ? אوa א E@ ? 0 ? אوa א E@ ?
71
)
1
2
W
e
e? ?אe? ?א
e? ?א? ?א
,א אQ % ,א 3 א c,; א אL ز א
W W W W
0 ? אوa א E@ ? 0 ? אوa א E@ ?
4
ـ
א
(
3
4
W
v6I אv6I א
4
)
ـ
,א אoN,$h
v6I אv6I א
84
(
ـ
I6 א I6 א
W
)
v6I 6אI א
ع o 4 אعo 4א
v
v6I אv6I א
ع o 4 אo 4א
ع
Lא אLא א
o I א, $ h\" وv ? אa K o I א, $ h\" وv ? אa K
69
105
ـ
ـ
)
)
B אL3א4 א
111
ً :و
W
106
W
0 א
(
5
(
W
?
4א
3
W
$ 3A אL3א4 א
ً K
116
2
ـ
W
5
(
1
106
?a א
5
108
)
L3א4 אa @3א4 אa @
110
L
L3א4 אa @L3א4 אa @
a@ a@
a@ a@
?'k4'אk4א
?'k4'?אk4א
?
121
L L L L
v
& $'( ! *) א
! א
! دو
\"#$ א %د א د
@a@ a
لوא T Tאلوא א
@a@ a
v6I F@,v6Iא F@,א
4
67
א ! א א8 42$5
4
ـ
3
66
3
1
ـ
3
9 8א! א ق$ 7 ;אد
א7 * *= <
59
دא 1 1א !23א א42$5א /6و א!א
3
60
-ن
!* .
א
0 / ود א
1
ـ
3
29
ـ
2
+
1
ـ
2
4
75
ـ
4
ـ
א
4
E D#$ א
3
77
ـ
א
2
א% B$ 7
א
(D א
83
4
ـ
7
4
5
!א אJ
ـ
;@א1 א ?7אو
א
4
ـ
א F(-$
A\" ; 1\"$ א \"*;$و
;@א5 א 1א ?7אو
79
85
א
د א
ود א
8
א! א
6
!عא H I $ א \"*;$و
;@א5 א 1א ?7אو
"\א1
و*;\"$
;@א5 א 1א ?7אو
81
8- N $ !א عא
אJ
א!?7א = Kد! 5$א LM $א$9
.
4
ـ
ط
I
)
oع א o 4א4
ع
@a@ a
@a@ a
ود א
.
4
(D א
89
88
א
د א
(
86
א
د א
ـ
9
4
4
!א 1אJ "\א א ! א
!؛عא IאJ
د א
)
13
ـ
4
ـ
15
95
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
א
د א
ود א
אRS$97 $9 LMא $
.
4
93
א
د א
ود א
.
1א! Jא "\א א ! א
(
14
ـ
- א
- *א 42$ ;Q
\"#$ א
P
oع א o 4אع4
א o 4א o 4ع
F@,א Tلو F@,א Tلو
v
F@,א Tو F@,א Tلو
v6I F@,v6Iא F@,א
v6I F@,6Iא F@,א
ل
@a@ a
@a@ a
ل
L L L L
א I6א I6
ع
I6 א I6 א
4
ـ
16
LM $א$9
א% د ; "\
;@א5 א 1א ?7אو
;Q
א$
P
97
4
\"#
ـ
17
RS$9
.
; "\ د א%
א
د א
ود א
98
4
99
RS$9
\"#$ א
19
ـ
א
ود א
ـ
101
4
20
P
\"#$ א د% א
@א
Q;
RS$9
100
.
7א
@ אD U\" א. *!V א%!*
RS$9
\"#$ א
$9 אLM $
4
103
22
4
ـ
ـ
ود א
*! %א. *!V
21
א% د ; "\
;@א5 א 1א ?7אو
\"#$ א
Q;
P
42$*
%!* RS$9
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
א
د א
ود א
4
)
(
!א 1אJ "\א א ! א
א! Jو ؛عא
I
-
ع
I6 I6א א
*F ج\"5 $
\
ـ
I6 אI6 א
عo 4 אعo 4א
? 4א4 ? א
?
? 4א4 א
v
v6I אF@,6I אF@,
v6I אF@,v6I אF@,
ـ
L L L L
F@,F@,
a@ a@
ل;*A ;*A א א
a@a@
?'k4 ?'k4 אو אو
\"Y
א ! א جذ
ل
1
1
ـ
123
א ! א %אد
2
122
2
1
[ +C -Mא F-(Z0
ل
*) *"\DU
وووو
א عא א א عא א
א
د
א א
د
א
א عא א א عא א
א
د
א א
د
א
E$א,AدK LאAא ود 6J * E$א,AدK LאAא ود 6J *
א א
د ,د,د ,د,
E$א,AدK LאAא ود 6J * E$א,AدK LאAא ود 6J *
$8J
$8J
$8J
$8J
א א
$س * ) ( '&% $س * ) ( '&%
س
$س * ) ( '&%&' ( ) * $ %
د
-. ( / $0 -. ( / $0
.
!]
1\ א ! א
\" `
. RS$`9
_^
7א
`b אcd `M 9
RS$9 `
`
\"#$ א %د ` א `; "\
` א
د א
ود א
_^
() 6 א
`*` .F א
)
(
55
.
`` אو`` $9
א `` ``n ``o kو=`` K ذ0
د p1
م
` א!א
100
)
)`*
SPSS
.
` -
J אQ א )* !
! !b$
א مא א
M g
#$
وq
ن _ !א )* د LM $
]d-
^
d
وm 1
"\ \ /א ! א
א!א
= #$ א
^
א!א ]!אR
:
i
`oא0
و `!
2
د א
א
ود א
ً
*.F א )
! א!5
\"#$ \" 1 "\
א %د א
*;\"$ ن
.
`
ود א
.
3
د א
א
ود א
ً D
ن*
.
. א"\א א ! א 1א! J
*;\"$ ن
4
و\"o
د
.
1
ً D
ن*
.
د א
א
.
)
א 8- N $
v
wא42$
` א!` Jعא
! *; \"$د7
א
د א
ود א
`
* "\
ذt
^M g
אد
`
; "\ א %د ` א \"#$
ذ tد 7
4<C
د!و م\"o
0.05
אRS$9
`
אد `
`
د א `
ود א `
`*` .F א ` "\
.
(.
`
د 7א
ود א
. D U\" א T
)
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
א
M `g^
7"\ د$;* !
א
0.05
)
6
.
0.05
אRS$9
ذ t
(.
و\"o
د
ن
Transformational leadership behaviours and Its
Effect on Oganizational Innovation
ABSTRACT
Shareef Ahmad Hasan Abbas
Companies
An Applied Study on Jordanian Human Pharmaceutical Industrial
Supervised by:
Prepared by:
Shabah Hameed Aga
Dr.
(
paragraphs to gather the primary information from
study sample. The statistical package for social sciences (
55
100
SPSS
) program was used to
) individuals from
the mid level Employess in Jordanian Human Pharmaceutical Industrial Companies.
س
hypotheses; the sudy concluded that:
The study used many statistical methods. After executing the analysis to study
3.
2.
Companies at level (
5.
behaviours due to (Age; educational level; experience in the current job and
0.05
).
level (
6.
ع
?ë?a@?—???Uaë?a@?—???Ua
@
?@@@@@@@
?ë?a@?—???Ua?ë?a@?—???Ua
??aŠ‡UU@âbEUa@Šb?⁄a?aŠ‡UU@âbEUa@Šb?⁄a
??aŠ‡UU@âbEUa@Šb?⁄a??aŠ‡UU@âbEUa@Šb?⁄a
?@@@@@@@
@
1
,א א oN ,א א oN
,א א oN ,א א oN
)
ـ
1
5
+א+ א
W WW W
ـ
+א+ א
)
W WW W
(
4
ـ
(
3
1
)
,א ,א א א
,א ,א א א
W WW W
ـ
2
1
ـ
?!!!!!!!!
?!!!!!!!!א4
א4
(
)
Z Q و א, א ;E?Z Q و א, א ?;E
1
)
?!!!!!!!!
?!!!!!!!! א4
א4
W WW W
(
(
א, א א, א
א, א א, א
W WW W
א, א جذ } א, א جذ }
7
W WW W
ـ
(
)
1
א, א אد g א, א אد g
א, gא אد א, gא אد
1
)
א I B אא I B א
ـ
9
(
I Bאא I B
א א
W WW W
1
!!!!!!!!?
?!!!!!!!!א4
א4
(
?!!!!!!!!
?!!!!!!!! א4
4א
W WW W
1
1
% \"<و
*\" 5א
)
d$ \"*
א
\" אو
.
وT
6 ($ א
*d
*)
د ^|
א-N 5
=o
ض1
!
! א vo"\א
!#$ א
-N 5א
z]
א
gS$5א
B
!g
^!
א
ـ
א@ 8
x$
xD
א7
Tق
א 42$אو
א;$5
א \
*)
7
אو7
.
.
א. 5
y
!d
א
!
! א
*;\"$
אد=9
א-N 5
i9
=- א ?
?دt
Marloes,
.
א% د
אد=9
^_ ن
J
א אد
^7
!
א !
*)
ن
] A
*F א
!
א
و
*)
}c א
] A
"\ =M א
4
.
ن
%4B
"\א*=
א5
; !
($ א
* !F
bص
"\41
و
ل و\" g
.
قT
!%
!o
)
^| د
i
T
4}
א! $
א! Jعא
8- א
?Y
ز ]1
\
م! $א
v /C
و
א-N 5
*)
% B$ א
א-MS5
*ً -d
א? ود
?()
א
)
א \
!#$ א do*"\א
.
א
v
![
-N 5א
%[ د
?E 3
*
tz א
c]
)*
.
I$א
\"#$ א %د א
د א
(
و*)
et..al,
א
2008: 231
!
!lא
،d
FDU\"5אد9= א
F* א
.
*(א
4xD
لu
=- א
c?
?- א
kذ
tد א
_^
g
^و
/D א
-N
)
f
!#$ אو
f# א
א tz
w
א-$;5
=- א
B
!@א
cd x
و
cd (? k z و
-N 5א
א
ج$K
)*
ود
א "\
vo
"\ אو
אא! J
א
cd
![ -א
و
*"\אdo
א= 5
א
א-N 5
"\
.
*)
4<C$ א
S9ل
cd
* -N
وw
.
ن
.
א 42$אو
iD$
2
Q אو
،Rא!] א
=M \" א
و
،d K
f g )*
א5 دא
fg
R!d
$5א
i K
.
)*
8d1
?
א?-$
* א
و
א-N 5
? ]E
*)
}]4
)
א-d5
א!] אوR
"\
*)
"\א? 0
א\"lد%
;-
#/ *!9 c
!
ود א
1
אو($ 7
د% -
?
ل ?א
و?$1
א
א]?5
[`` ً *``) ذ `` ،kא ` א ! א \ ` !` ``1 * _^ `` @1
``4<C
.
د א\"5א
ل S2$ א );g
=- אو
Q
\ א
?6 $
א!x$;5א
אوT b5
y
، !%
!o
.
،
d
! $ א
!
ن
d*
N א
.
1?א
0\"m
!^
א
.
k
،?-
I
و
Q
_^ 1 mJ
.
$5א
dMאد
)
د א
א
ود א
عא ! J אI
.
8- N $ א عא! Jא
؛
Idealized Influence
`
(D א
؛و
% B$` 7א
Intellectual Stimulation
)
Individualized Consideration
)
ـ
2
!Z Q ,و !! א א ! ;E? !Z Q ,و !! א א ! ;E?
W WW W
Motivation
א1 א ! א \"
؛و
F(-$``` א
!אJא
E``` D#$ א
؛و
```
א$ 7
```
د D א
و
Adoption of Innovation
Empowerment
Innovation Abilities
(
؛و
(
d*!`
` 5"\א
-$;5א
42
7 ?א
.
; א
אو $
x$
\
.
% دJ
N א
`d
x$ * وd
*!`9 c
!`
dU
d
-d*
RS$9א
`
*
vo"\א
-N 5 1
! o @א
`-N 5א
1
` א
`
א7 $-` د )`*
Ld `5א
4(D$` א
=` $ א
.
% ` وm
א
d* xgو
d "\א
و
!
! א
*F אو
d
א
وo g
]zא
Q
*)
د [
.
=g
t! $ א
cM א
و Zא
S( 5א
tz` א
1"\א
` gS$5
`*
Q`
عא ! Jא
?
& وx$
ً S*
%]U
/C$*
א2$` 4א א
v*
%!دx$*
8 !אJא
(
.
Garc?a-Morales, et..al,
6 U\"
א z]
نC א
)
2008: 230
ً
!
f gو
و ?و
^ ن
Ld 5א
n
og
#*
og
-N 5א
ن
vx
د `7[$א
42$א
א `
dm D
אو` -$o7
אد ^
م\" א
&$
!1
.
و? =
عא !H
אJאد %
نو
אو!5
.
ز `D
?`
و? `/
=`- א
?`Y
د ` אt
)
?- א
2000
(
31
kz و
ن?`1
א ً "\
א `tz
א6`U\"5
*)
و? 5א F
ن(`"\
א!` J
عא
`x $
)`*
ً[`! א
k` 3
`d
א
אدD*و
?M V
=`-
? א
T
אو%!` 5
` א
`d
א-N 5
א% / 5
(.
:
)
%
א `NوR
א42$`5
^_
1 `mJ
.
Bو `]4}1 אو
א?`-$
אو ;
د ` א%
8
\"#$ א
?$1
"\41
א! Jو 8א
? א
،
א 42$א
7\"`#$ אو
א\"5
\
د |^و
6 U\"
و
Ld 5א
S( 5א
1?ن
yو
do5"\א
o
@א
k7
v x$
.
;$5א
v1
!#$ א *"\אdo
` ?- א
لS9
א \
tz א
א
* `!*d$
عאאو! J
*)
אt د`
و.
ل `?א
B
א@!
و?$`1
!
!x$ אو
א [ "\
c;$
%!
($ S
[`! א
)`*
*
c
!$
.
א!` ^و
F` א5 ?و
!
cMS5א
?$`D ;`
!א
gص
fg א
?Y
ن
ق ?1א
k ذ
8
\"`#$ א
`tz א
ض א
?d
و
א% د`
אو? 5
אV
0\"m
و
!#$ א
א 42$אو
2003: 527
)
`1 `-N -
.
ن
"\אddo
%B و
^_
^7
.
ذ `k
א@ `o
?
\
Jung, et..al,
(
Q`
t ` وm
א
v$ - $
`
א
د א
ود א
Sز* א
\%
א5
d
*-d
.
(`"\
ن
`?
4
.
ل -אو
cd
אT 5
cd
"\אo
ل u
م א
& ?: א & ?: א
WWWW
& ?: & ?: א א
)
؛
و ؛8 <C$א B54 א
! د ?!%
~! k!h %!? _k!3ل "\ ! ,
! د ?! ;E!? , Z?\" %; %א א, 6! ! ,
~! k!h %!? _k!3ل "\ ! ,
; ;E!? , Z?\" %א א, 6! ! ,
! د ?!%
~! k!h %!? _k!3ل "\ ! ,
; ;E!? , Z?\" %א א, 6! ! , ! د ?!%
~! k!h %!? _k!3ل "\ ! ,
; ;E!? , Z?\" %א א, 6! ! ,
د D א
؟
א
د א
7? ;$ א
Dא
(
)
$ א
:
(
F(-$ אو
ً: WWWW
iB
و
2
و
E D#$
؛ א
*!
و وً :
א عא א א عא א
א א א ! א 1א! J
*
*)
א ]z
ود א
*.F א )
א!5
ل? ; $א
و "\
א عא א א عא א
2 ?J2 ?J
؛
2 ?J ?J
عא Iא! J
و
א
د
& א א
د
א &
א
د
& א א
د
א &
v v v v
؛
(D א
א$ 7
!
1 1 1 1
و ً :وً :
א \"#$
د א%
"\
"\א1
؛
(D א
<C$א B54
و ؛8 א
א% B$ 7
א E D#$؛
د D א
\"#$ א %د א
؛و
)
ً WWWW
ً K K
8- N $ א عא ! J"\ א$;*
ً WWWW
*
\" ;
A ]
=]
4<C
; "\
RS$9
)
א ! א 1א "\
(
א
ود א
א
د
ً Bא,ً Bא,
؟ .
ً Bא,Bא,
\"
. RS$9 אA ] =]
.
F(-$ אو
.F* א
ً WWWW
5
` א!א (* .دوא
:
vو*% ;D
N א وg
(
3
ـ
1
)
8
*א א\"Y 42$א \" #א و ،جذ? ; "\
) א 7? ;$ m 1 iא و ? )* א ! אoJ
!! א, א !!o N א, א oN
3
! ;I؛ א
oI א
&a א
א, ~ ! :
HO
1
:
عא Iא! J
2-1
! *; \"$د7
א
د א
ود א
HO
א!
)
.
(
1-1
(
HO
عא ! J אI
:
0.05
!o\"
4<C
Jא א ! א
4<C
(
7
א א
,א !!!
א
?$!!!Jعא !!! א
)
K
(
S ^M g
0.05
"\!o
)
د وذ7
؛
! *; \"$د7
! *; \"$د7
)
א
د א
ود א
(
(
"\!o
4<C
د وذ7
:
و
E D#$ ^M g
؛
F(-$ ^M g
7
8- N $ ! Jא
א عא
7د وذ
5-1
HO
0.05
)
:
HO
4<C
4-1
א
د א
ود א
(
:
HO
)
عא Iא! J
؛
S ^M g
د D א
$
و
"\!o
د وذ7
7
4<C
)
א
د א
ود א
.
אא! J
(
K
(
! *; \"$د7
0.05
! *; \"$د7
א
د א
ود א
؛
(
0.05
)
K
عא Iא! J
)
8- N $ א! J
א عא
.
א! א
(
א א! J
6
I? 6 אوPE אFZ6a 6h
HO
K~ א &a א
؟
+k h
א
oI א
\" ;
א
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
א. RS$9
!! د
א &!!
E!!$ !! אKد,Aא !! ودA אL 6!!J !!*
2
, 6!!J 1
1-2
+k !!h3!! א :
7
1 ? ? !!B א
د א
!o\"
HO
:
8- $ א5;$"\ א
)
7"\ د$;* !
RS$9
\"#$ א%
- א
)
0.05
(
K
0.05
K
(
7"\ د$;* !
RS$9
א \"#$ א %د
; "\
א
د א
ود א
.F* א \"
. RS$9א
!o\"
:
!o\"
HO
7
\" ;
א
د א
ود א
3-2
; "\
א
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
א. RS$9
7
!o\"
7"\ د$;* !
0.05
)
(
K
@א
د א
א
ود א
*! %א. *!V
5-2
:
HO
*; \"$د7
"\!o
7
(
0.05
K
\" ;
א
د א
ود א
.F* א \"
. RS$9א
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א
)
)
! *; \"$د7
RS$9
\"#$ د א% א
(
K
7
!! א, !! א, א א
)
4
ـ
(
!! א, !! א, א א
!
W WW W
1
)
و7
(
אA
1
]
d
* -N
א $-אو
א?-$
\
!م
א
א
لא E
\ Ng
אF-$d5
fg
*)
م]-$
?
= [
ن
ل ?א
א zd
NK
א\"m\"5
א-d5
!g
א% د
tz א
$وv
]-
ع א\"m\"5
]-
??z
*)
א!א
]- א
- א
;!-$
B א
:
:
F
o
] א!א ;?z] !-$
*)
d$ -
אد א
!-$
?M
7
و*
d K
(=
d
و
א[!
אد א
*)
k
-d5א
tد א
f
א@!
א ?-
אJאد t
א ! אو
ط
א
(D א
]zא
*)
*F
d
א [!
]-
]?z
א!א
\"$א1
.
و]"\
?41\"$
אcMS5
7
א
8 א
!
E
-N 5א
yو
1
? d$
.
? 5א
v
)*
f# א
tz א
?
/ ?و
^ !א
?Y
8
\"#$ א
z9C
!M א
א
א\"*و]Q
($
ود א
.
ع
.
א!א
*"\\"m
ع
א
א% د
\ و
אو=M
8- N $ א
\"#$ א
d$[S و
عא !J
)*
cM [
]\
tz א
fg
ن
،
kذ
8- N $ ! Jא
א عא
!
!
![
و^*(
]c
א!א
*)
.
ن
-
]?z
א^!
?
*
!م
2
*)
)
(
B
ن ("\
\א
*"\
א
א 7\"#$
אFDU\"5
و
^!
א
8?$
א ($
אو! Jعא
T
*)
[! א
?-
!
!x$ אو
F x *) و
د *
-
א($ 7
*)
=o
[ د%
^_
}]4
ود
א
ج$K
fg
א $-אو
ن
م
.
(=
د אt
:
אد0
?4<C
و
]
dM
و! א
א!א
א-N 5
א g
]-
- א
و*!
*)
*)
]-
אA
א B
T
d
^ אد
;E $م
.
א
.
(%0 D
א
א;$5
d$m 1
و\"oאد [ د
\"K
]!אd1
و1
א@
ق وT
*d
i K
<c
و*)
א ?
.
א 42$אو
!#$ א
م ;x
אو7
i #$
א\" $אi1
T
%
*
8
!! א, א +א !! א, א +א
1
5
)
W WW W
8- N $ א عא א! J
(
א?!R
ن ^
`4<C
??z
.
=B-$
س א
א!א
`Sb$א א ` ?5א ز ` ص ! %!` D5א `
א
و `
.
1
(D א `d
?\"$
א! -8א א TJ0 ]א!] ;4 .אو @ ،א
^_
R`$ אو ` א ! % 5א
.
ل`S`9 )`* k ،ذو
`
د א
` א
ود א
.
4
4<C
3
ن
(
عא Iא!` J
؟
` `"\א א `! א 1א! J
א
`
א
د א
ود א
؛
8`- N $ א عא*; \"$א! J
א !` א 1א `"\
^_
"\D U אو b א cd M 9
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
5
.
RS$9
`
`*.F א
(
؟
א
د א
ود א
.
א! Jא
*! א7
؟
` "\
. RS$9
` א `
د א `
ود א `
^_
R $ א
9
U وdg\"m !و مE -$
d
f# אو
N
.
:
ـ
6
!g k z و-
دو
fg
،
!gدو *(
N
و 0 -א\" א د (=
و
!gز دو*
و
8
\ א \" #א?
!! א, א دو ' !! א, א دو '
!! א, א دو '!! א, ' א دو
(
1
W WW W
)
.
دو 7אدو 7א
WWWW
دو 7א دو 7א
.
E$ א دو 7א E$ א دو 7א
د
א1א
WWWW
*) א\"$;5
א
د 7א
ود א
ن\" * א
.
-$ د
q ! 1א7
)
(
1991
(
)
(
א! Jא عא 8- N $
42$w i $
- 1و
Avolio, et..al,
/
2010
/
12
8؛ B54 <אC$ א
)
2 و
.
B א دو 7א B א دو 7א
\"#$ א42$ \" א %د א * fg א !-$
10
א
WWWW
Rafferty & Griffin,
2004
ـ
(
(
"\א1
7
!! א, א אد !! g א, א אد g
F(-$ אو ؛
د D א
؛
(D א
א$ 7
و
Iא! J
؛عא
و
א% B$ 7
= م *) [
)
و
2000
.
i`- $ א _^ ج ? ` `$K "\
א $ *= * *`42$م
*! v ً ،ل @א 1( 6 ?
4<C$ אv د
<C$
vא
אg %4;* 0 < [\" 5 אو \" ! *)
! א vo"\א
v
g . ;ن
^א نJ
.
f` g
`tz א8אo `V
?# 1و * \; و א =(
<C`$א `* ? `Z4 א لد ` $
?b ` אن f` g ،v
10
i`
-$o7אو
;
א ! אJ ً א ?
^
ل\" `@א ن `k ذو \" ` א ¢ d F-M א א ، m 5אوو\do א د\" *! \
o
و]`z
א
\" `/ و ل\" @א ن`[\" * t `do א\"* نود `
= 08 (*J ? v
.
^،
ذ
א*\" 5
` א א ` א ! אو ?\"`# `! *`)
! א A`] ن
1
\[\" אf g )*
א u .ل n \" / fg א אوvo
]`?z م!` ` £א د `5א )` Q $ אو א ! א!dl אو \[\" א _^ ج ¤$ ??z
!g [
[\
2
fg א c
.
.
8- N $ א عא אو! J
\"#$ \" \ و א %د א
:
8
w [\" 5א "\ אو ¢ Eo\"
fg א ن? 1
א!א ??z ; *
.
א!א
y א!א ، ?
.
.
.
7 fg א 1د
[ א*\" 5
دوא
א د$ 7 $
*F !
א & ¢و ? م
.
3
11
2{ 4א
v
א&4
א2{ 4
L א
ـ
)
8
1
(
W WW W
א عא א
א, ~ :
א, ~ :
;Iא ;I א
א א א ,
א JאN ,
א א א
א JאN
,
א א א
א JאN ,
א א א
א N אJ
WI אW I א
WI אI א
د
א
א
:א, $ : א $,
ع
1
א, א جذ }
(=
1
)
א
د
א א
د
א
W WW W
א
د
א א
د
א
Transformational Leadership
)* ?- א k ذ
%د א
tz א
E
א, 864א, א 864 א
)
1
ـ
9
I Bא 3אa א I Bא 3אa א
(
א, 864א, א 864 א
W W W W
2002
]?z
? א
cMS$
א
، t*
-M א
d
!
و
.
x
و
-N
א
FDU\"5א
zD
7
42
EDgو
#mאو
?
א "\[\
אو =-
v;D
!%
א!5
.
? א
)
א
د א
ود א
12
א ! C$
o^ R ¥אً M
و
:
0
א!] אR
(
א. / V
א !M
!%
*
وi 9
א-MS5
? א
x
و
-
אو =-
! Hعא
\
* ?و v
*F א
0
J
.
!
א! J
א
]
\
א! א
et..al,
.
1991: 15
;I א ;I א
ـ
= 5 ً و B cd l F * א % <^
1
)
د א5$ B )
و0א،
م ¦9
^ * dUא7
א
g
א, ~ :
א, ~ :
(
7
.
? *) אل S9 )* v [ c$
R\" و
W WW W
)
d$ و -N 5 אR]!א
i K !M א% ![ ?(
w
-N 5א . B אو
$ 7 א.
Idealized Influence
Intellectual stimulation
)
9?6 * אT $ S9 )* k ذc$
אل
\"D
و $"\[ ،א ق
tz ! אlאد א0 אi K ض
א
Avolio,
0\" א% ? אو6 . אدQ
\"o 1 * وB
א 1 ^_ 0 א mJ /\" V c;$
אv * F * א
W WW W
70 אS
? !M אم [
ـ
14
.
Individualized consideration
o P م-$]
, $ :א: $ , א
دI א دI א
c] * وcd; g
Avolio, et..al,
. cd$ * وcd
g * وc] (1
(
1991: 13-
)* ? אل S9 )* v [ qو
אو7 $- ع
)
8
$ 7 א.
15
(
)
.
WI אI א
WI אW I א
Avolio, et..al,
)
F* א
23
(
)
(
!
و F [\" $א و? - ??
^ لS9 )* ،vo= و-
16
v;D
ـ
.
، -N 5 א2$ 4 . א- |J אQ
? ? א\"l
א
? !M אم [
$ 7 א.
W
W WW W
)* ?
.
1991: 13
Motivation
S9 )* v [ qو
אل
29
24
2006: 6
.
.
ـ
$ 7א
Purvanova, et..al,
E D#$ R א!] אi #$ =B-$5 אt!
#$ אE אوi
D א ?و % B$ "\
م
و ]!אR
(
E$
مא
F و? 5א
)
)
7
א 0אد .و* d5
وS9 )* v [ qא ل ? *)
.
(
13
d
א d5
א -N
F;K و%!
!o *!9
\
א(
و* cd#א@
* ? א * ig Fא R $א א ذ £אو
* d
و
א
،
§ / وtE א
5 c]!
E
و
و gS א cd
\"£ i
T ) -N 5אد9= א
)
!Z א \[\" א. \"
د
cd
?
?; ;א א
W WW W
Empowering
?; ;?א א
:
2008
16
)* ? S9 )* v [ qو
אل
.
(
39
)
ـ
30
א عא א א عא א
(
$ 7 א.
.
א عא א א عא א
W WW W
Jones,
.
1998: 515
%! ً M אo^ R ¥¥
و
)
0S- א o @ =?1 x$ א
F* א
א1 دא
i #$
c;$
.
B
!
(D$א @4 א
א ! אو
Q
א/ V
(
]z אو
א
א
د א
ود א
Organizational Innovation
\" c$
א -א
i K
$
dא
-א ل-N 5
\*!b$ א
ون
?
i ;
ون
אD 5
!%
!o
د |^و ( $אو
א
د א
ود א
و Q
Tق
o\" \" ($אو J8אد t א d
o
. @ אd
-وd
*!9 S
!
ل 9د^ و
d
(
$ 7 א.
ـ
.
Adoption of Innovation
16
-d*
:
2002
0 אد%!
!o و -
)
، ( ;8 א
عא א א?$J عא ?$J
.
W WW W
ع
J
א אد
.
\"$;5 א.
cd و
F* א
)
17
ـ
)* ? S9 )* v [ qو
אل
(
Innovation Abilities
40
48
ـ
55
* d* )* v "\نD (
* ? زJ %!
!o Q ($
-N 5
47
7
% ![
א א א,
,א א א א
א
.
17
.
(
W WW W
)
(
)
، 8; ( א
2002
:
14
?Oib?Ua@pb?aŠ‡Uaë@?‹??Ua@Šb?⁄aOib?
Ua@pb?aŠ‡Uaë@?‹??Ua@Šb?⁄a
?@@@@@@@
@
?Oib?Ua@pb?aŠ‡Uaë@?‹??Ua@Šb?⁄a?Oib?
Ua@pb?aŠ‡Uaë@?‹??Ua@Šb?⁄a
ï?brUaï?brUa
@?—???Ua@?—???Ua
@
@?—???Ua?—???Ua
@
ï@@@@@@@
ï?brUa?brUa
2
)
1
(
W WW W
ـ
!!!!!!!!?
?!!!!!!!!א4
א4
?!!!!!!!!
?!!!!!!!! א4
4א
)
2
ـ
(
2
W WW W
א
د
א א
د
א
)
2
א
د
א א
د
א
א عא א א عא א
א عא א א عא א
W WW W
ـ
2
3
(
& א א, א% 7א א, א ? W
& א א, א% 7א א, א ? W
(
2
ـ
6
)
& א א, א% 7א א, א ? W
& א א, א% 7א א, א ? W
W WW W
)
א عא א
د
א @k א عא א
د
א @k
ـ
)
2
Bאو$ 3A א
& א א, BאوA
א3$ א
& א א, א
5
א عא א
د
א @k א عא א
د
א @k
4
(
ـ
W WW W
$ 3A אوB א
& א א, BאوA
א 3$ א
& ,א א א
W WW W
(
15
)
1
2
`9 ?אو. `dU f` g t אدJ( אD א. B
א =!@9
א!5א *)
\"#$ ! *!
א %د א =9
ـ
(
?!!!!!!!!
?!!!!!!!!א4
א4
?!!!!!!!!
?!!!!!!!! א4
4א
W W W W
` v` 1 !` tz א
fg !א
8m 5א אن )*
Leadership
v $ .
Burns
\"
\"
`
! ` [ _^ %د($ ^ %
. =`B-$א@@ `oא ` !
א א 5 # .א 5א@@` 8 } א !g ن
; א
:
(.
،
ً S
\"T -$;
7ً }و
.
Inspirational
8 B54 <אC$ ]و8 א،
\"#$ א %د / ?<S< )-
א tz
`` ً א
``
\"(*
Bass
)
R ``m !``[و
(
1990
F*` א
8* ``?Jא
.
,
Bass
v`` i`` T
(D א
% B$ 7א
Individualized Consideration
؛
و؛
Intellectual Stimulation
م `-$]
Idealized Influence
R`
; "\ Aد א tو]`"\ *` א =*א\" س ?
*و
7אو
1 دא `
Motivation
16
"\41
2
)
2
א
د
א א
د
א
2
(
W W W W
ـ
2
ـ
)
א
د
א א
د
א
1
(
ـ
<`0
`N
? ` $ v ` * ?وE` DK
z` D
$
` -(* -N 5 אR]!א
cddo`"\א
` א
c]!`M مא g7 & אوx
א5 ?ن\"` و `
،و
ل `-
،
אو "\07אوJ
א
S `- א! אو
B
אو ? ? א \"* א-d5
`|^ \"`? c`]4(Dد
`4B
` cو א
!%
!o l *
אE`D? \"
1 نو
"\
ن
` ? ` د%
و
` cd
7
\"#$ א ?د 1
`
}
د $א4
E D#$
د א%
\"#$ א %د א
N
،
`
א ?و ` א `\" 51
م"\
cd
،
.
= [ )* fא . F 5א-N 5
!g! و
!o \"] * =( 8 -l"\א ل א
?!אg^
0אE`o
` 1 ?SB` `
\"#$ א %د `
308
:
ـ
1
"\ !
.
?
*!x$د%
?
(
2
.
"\!gא א-N 5 אو
.
א وJ
\";$ $א 5א و אو א*E $;5
.
`! `/ ` k
!`gא م\"` $2` 4 . -א ?א\"` `-N 5
ذ ن ` 0א
`"\& J
3
אد
.
17
4
א %د ` א \"#$
א lאو ذ Dא bא אذ [S א !M
א;
[ ً *) א (1
אو
- אو 8
} i #$ضא ^
)
Tichy & Devanna
,
1990: 187
(
ن
%"\د א مdD*
، א2-"\ ض¢ vD $(
لאز 7
א \"#$
و ?0
! *\"dDم
gא ! א \ ¢و !K
،v
( = א-N 5
( = د ^و %
و
"\ * =Mא 2 א *
[S9
dא\"* ! %א0
C
مA "\
א د^
]zد א ? -א אt ن
א %د א \"#$
.
^ذ ^
"\[ ،و*) <c
^_ ?* و ل o $g
(
"\ = ]z
אא
\"K و،cd
o $g
8
7
.
و
- אcd
g . אz אi K وA ?א دi $
- 1 cd
og عJ 1 א! אcd
! ! \"$
)
_^ ;
8
!Mא \"#$ א ن? 1 i
و? * 8و %د v
ز
F * ( אو - ?و %]N א o @"\] אo
.
42 * "\د
i K R!d F א5 ?و [T
[ -B$
אوo @ אk
ع אو-= ^
2000:233
Trofino,
-N 5 אو-lא
\
)
* א 5 #א ^_ b א § 5א زو ?و
_^ \"$;50 א
אz א
\
אو7
0
א _^ J8
\"#$ ! אM 8א !*
I
\"#$ د א ن% א
Kark,et..al
,
و¤"\ א ل1 دא
N
do وQ;g
247
(
\"#$ א %د א I
و
.
2003:
(
مא !b$ א
)
Fد?5א _^ tא E D#$ 1 و
F = Dאو %د א ? 5
d
C
\"#$ א %د א
و] )* A
d
.
`
"\ אو א-5
? Qא = (D59 3نو ^
o )*و
_
!`
Rafferty & Griffin,
8 א5;$"\ א
.
2004: 330
0 אد א )* طY cN אو
tذ
J אi` #$ F * ` 1` *`) *`;$"\ א
א
د א
`;. 4B$
و ` \"?-א`-N 5 אو
"\
ز ?`
` vא?c`-
א
kא tz ذ \"]و
،
42$א? `/ 5
א א ` א `5 **v
،
8
\"#$ ! אM א v iT
و v
אz t אدJ! אM א
\
و
ن ^_
אدvM
18
cא\"@א = * E1אد א0
!
،
1999
=
א! ^و\"K ً و ً
?و (1 F
xא5
و
\
)
.
147
t א\"?א
:
(
(
)
x$
زو
א א %د k
d
\"#$ د% א
cd;`D
C cd$` < ?` د
ز ` v` 1 =`-
`tz א \`[\" א . ;M א 5א
? "\ 8 אو
N
،ًو49א
א
Conger
2002: 47
,
، d
*و$ !א d$1 <
. 2 4א
?!Kو
ً- [
،
] ]\"o .
-N -
%!دx$* d 1 F *
و*y %42$
v x$ 7א D
; !$و\"oאد [ د ?k $
א * Fאو$5 } o #1و
?
! cو
א %د א ن \"#$
^
9א! א אo V42$ אو
.
-N - ًא0 א )* ً \"($ن Eo
א
cdא zא
]* -$
א
-Nא% / 5
*(
د
;1
9 * وR وU . -N 5א5 "\* د [و% א cN
$אو د א \"- = D
و א6 U\"$
,
("\
f
ً
zo 6 $£ א! * $و [ -و ?M 9
,
1992: 22
E -$ $
אو 2 4
؛
א
xאو#m
!-$א א
و (7 $אو
5و #$
א -N 58 ]א D א -N 5 1
ً |
. E -$
Bass & Avolio
:
8
(.
)
1998: 173
(
Aminuddin
,
* =-
\"#$ א %د א
?א
\"#$ א %د א ن
^ًT
?!
و
ن
א!א * cN * \D f g F "\8D U א m אو
אد א 0
1
* Fאو * F * $5א-N 5 א }و
.
2
.
א
\"$;* 1
א 0אد8-N 5
.
.
g.
אl $אو @ /א א-N 542$ א =. * ? - D א אx$ 7
o
19
E$مא cdא7
=- א cd x
و
)
.
:
,
1992: 17-21
Leihwood
=-
\"#$ א ?د א
(
ن
cd \"D
. f
و
.
3
، 0 -$
א\"5א Tאو7
و^
] cو?
0
אد א ،
س
.
،
! cא א 42$א 1 B
و = *) cd$ Eאd5
و
،
% -$;* % \" cd
و d* F;Kא
،
*F א
\
م (g
-N - $;5א
? אو
3
.
א
^. ; א
!/
; !]c
و
.
א א
א!]وd1
א!] אR
.وm
i #$ 1 m
! %و zא ل\"dlא دJ
!o T
F* א
-N 5א
A
2
.
.
א7? طא c]EDKو
، - N $ א
S( - !א
د-$
4(D$ א
^
ً7\" g !*"\ن
א *F
? = *)
د $-א و
]!אR
و?
،
*! $د?J %
אز
\" g cل
!$
!א 8
אJ
/ . cd
و
-N 5 *F א
E -$ א
n
4
5
عא אو! J
.
ً * 9
ً
و
ً B
?
و
gS و?;5א אو c $
،
!g= אو- i
1
)* =(
cd* *
-N 5 א. F * א
(y 7ً אو *?
©
و
.
i #$ א
S9 )* d K
ل ن\" -
#m אوn
?
ن\"( 3$ F \"#$ א %د א
^ ن
.
4 2$ א א ?$-א Zאد -M8
; J %!] o
و
אوF * $5
.
cd
א ![و
-
אא א
N$ א
?;#$
og
א *F
.
@o ;D Q x$
و
،
d
.
6
20
\" ? cd
\"-dن
و
* א § 5א
א
d
جذ -ن\"1 $
z$¤
،
،
و
F* א * cd /"\א
.
אE* )* cd (3
وא و אא cd
و
8
!Mא \"#$
א *F
،
ED¤
?ز
? )^ א אوT b5
"\D U א
א-d5
، 1
و?;5א
ن \" -#$
א ق5
ز ?J
-d5א
cd@ * 1"\ق
، b א
عא!H
ً!אM [ vD/\" R $
و gS "\
א عز
8
\"#$ א
!M א
,
Jung, et..al
;
c} $* =- i
ن
ًא !] o
D
(
!?
zd
د! א א و
2003: 526
)
א
د
ود א B א
د
ود א B
[\"$
2
ـ
2
ـ
.
אق \"D
אد0
*;\"$
2
א
د
ود א B א
د
ود א B
i #$
W W W W
(
)
MLQ
`
Qو "\
و
1
; ?W , א
س-N 5 א א;gJ
و
.
،
! א\" אo
!Kو
-d5א
:
Charisma
8 $ א#"\ א k ذو \" z5א ن د א\" א% . א7 $
\"#$ א
،
*F אس \"D
.0
א (?
א د% د !
و!K )(3
،
د $א %د א س )
! و
\"#$ د د% א <S<
1985
Bass
(
,
^
ذ
،
`
v m وtz א
2س
-] B א
!M "\א م
?
8*E
( ! אM 1
K
F*
ً #mאو
! א
ً
א
،
ً4א <C
?!K \" * d*
5- ^אد cd*!אb$ א f g )* %א د
)
Kent, et..al,
A
و
2001: 221-230
(.
،
)* c]4} ) c]E ? )(3
% ! * k $3 v
-
ن
א (1وً ? ?
א7
cdDא * 5;$-א =/א\" $אو * F אل
\" *E
א %د ( 1
*) S9
،
א5
و
= א-N 5 ) *;$
،
אE25
21
-
& ? 9 ? و אR $ א c]E DK وd
y )* cd (?و
א% <
, $ :א
b$ אو
.
cd
دD א قوD א *و% א cd
אd*
Individualized Consideration
2
K
gS א ¢
\"D$ k ذو
،
دI א
F $
،
Intellectual Stimulation
3
K
\
،
, ~ :א
;I א
y
S( 5= אg
،
. %!
!o ق
مא ![J= א8 [
t
(.
R
)
^I
و
و
= ! א! א א ?5א "\
*) S9ل د א ]?z
\
1988: 695-702
Hater &
Bass,
،
)
? c-
=-
8
\"#$ ! אM 1
1 m^ q -
،
.
d ^ אد ¨ !
!o 9? !
=- אS( * = K E
و
.
(
)* 1 א =-
v
]!دg
د א א ! )* \"-u tא ?M Vאوd5
)
(
Avolio, et..al,
1991: 9-16
8] ، ?M 9
:
1
K
, $ :א
دI א
kz 8
\"#$ ! אM אو d$ و -N 5 אR]!אC ;g B cd l cd وو F*
אo g
)
א
ً * -$]
= Q;#
1 cd \" 4 2
R!d )
نو?9 א ?<
B
אً4
*) د א7 %
1998: 21-27
¢ لو و[! g
.
? א אود א ز=?1 =( cd T 5
ن
(
R!d cdدJ cd 1
& ?!د! %
،
"\. % אو ? 6א Q
Bو* \"o 1
א 8 א0
\"#$ ! אM א
.
Krishnan,
0אد
و
E
\[\" ? אD
.و
F* א
%!g ;\ אوcd
o #1
،
8
\"#$ א !M א
،
"\ 8
fg
/\" V c;$
אv * F * א oP
Individualized Consideration
22
F * 0 אm ^[ אو ع.
? ! ودوM 0 * ! % א
\"
W WW W
;I א
!-$
א
! אo\"
- ،
? ? אوC
وcd$
, ~ :א
6 ¬$ א
!M !א مb$;
![ -
0אد
.
و B cd l F * א% <
D U\" אc] אودc]? ز
.
^v !
و
^ -]C )
[J 4(D$א ع?9 א
א !b$و = א مא
א [\"$
\"Dق
tz א
Q| 8
\"#$ ! אM 1
=-
ن
I
א z]و
)
-N 5 אS( 5 א!^
(.
،
0אد
אi K ض
אS( 5
ن
Krishnan,
1998: 21-27
-
("\ن d 1
א @ 7א .
-
* )* FאF- $5 א }Q
ً
و m!
v
א ن E D#$א t (D
^.
! g\"$א -8א bאو 8-N 58
vدو!? ( 5א )%
\ א !M 9?%و* "\*
אذ
،
א )* ع "\
"\\"/ل ^_ * Fو[ cא-N 5 א
ً
و m!
و^ / 9
\" # - א! א د א]F א ? אو c
!
و א\"@א
ل
c[F نزא\" $א c
8
\"#$ ! אM 1
!אJא
.
m c]
cd
g
¬ z9
* وcdMא
15 אو5; ]- אو
23
cd
-N * d * 8
א
،
v$א 5; ]-א [ .د א lو % .دm و}
אد !5א م
و
[S * [^ v ? $
v
،
z S*E
0א ? א0 אو )* x $ אو c! N¤ v
v v- ن
#m אوv* d* ن
cd *
t!#$ ? "\א )* ع
و
- ن
،
و
"\م v
=- א ]-
،
،
و
9אد* o 9 و
،
و
v
! *
LM $
-
C 6U\"5 א- v
g _^
J
א א ! אو ?\" #אد א
cdM7وو
1991: 9-16
-N -
Avolio, et..al,
(.
cd*אE$ אi-
8 وD U\" א
)
!$
NK v
"\אدdu
لS9
)*
، -N 5 =- مאE$
و
ً S9 دv 1\"
-N 5א
،
، 0 ? א )* Rאو7 א
ً
Eu
ون
7 v ;g^
، د $* < [S
8[S9 و دאز7?? א-
ون
K
(.
Motivation
3
WI א
،
)
1997
:
43
; א c . 5אو
، א$ ، ط\"; אو
-N$ א
k;
*! ?!¤
E D#$ 1 ،
אE -$5
א7 אو 5;$-אR
א و Jد %
CאدcdM
cd xאو (7 $א! Jعא
cdو
* Fم 7]$-אو } c $אو0 2/J و k ذ $אو
\
v
C
א =/א\" $אو ل
-א7
E D#$ א
)
Woods,
"\
5א! 6T א\" אو ^< %
(
אو 4 $
g . ?* ;$א = D 7 אو 5;$-
2003
،
=-אو@ *F א
د אو%
R ¥
،
v
!Mو^3 א !%و و אوg
\"
א * ?Jאو ?
=-
و
\" .
E D#$ א
Q א
-d
و
F*
ً[ T 8
\"#$ ! אM א
אEDK
-N 5 * § אi K . } אو
t?د
[\"
} /
d -K * -N 5א
\
i Kא!] א Rא ? אو\"m\"5
،
_^
"\א -5 541
אو
، t!#$ אو
!l 6 $
א
d
)-?
* \"]و
.
، = $;- M D$5 אوg D א% N
"\ !
و
5د% = [ א-
(.
)
Avolio,
)
EDZא
!?
و
?8
k z ]4 2א ? ?7א ن ; !M
c$א d ;$وא
7 א "\
]\"5א )* ع
8] *E
( א
(
نو% د N
FBg ن¢א
1991: 12
Avolio, et..al,
1994: 1564
ن
،
$
%
F $ אس\"D
. J c[i-
3א ن
=-
و
E D#$ א
، 5 אR]!א F* א !
ً?
ً ;g^
8
\"#$ 5 /א א %د א
!1
$
E D#$ א -
F $א
$;* .
N
א )* cd 5و`do
אJא %אد
\"
cd
אd*
E D#$ *) א * o دcd
("\ن !
!![ % א אد [ ن
?1
، -N - א א %אدJ
\"$;*
. M و U\"# * E D#$ א v 1 ("\ن
tz 8 א \[\" אD1
E D#$ / אذ S( *
،
)*
=-
\
א0א ،و] ?zאoJ
)
د9? F-d * %
? -אود א
! אود ] cو
،و!K
.
א = -א[\"$5
א\"!K do5
?2 א
و "\ v
cאو ن\" אc? %! ;5
!
،
~4א
K
א Q 2$ א
C cd ;g^ وcd;D
C cd$ < c !
و
نو
F* א =| v
\"
ً MEo \" !? وK k ذi K
دא 1א
*) S9א م 7]$-א لE5جود ! $
? א م * Fو^*(
! א !M ! %א* ?J
! cא5
A\" ; א אz]و
،c]E DKو
،cd$-
^
Idealized Influence
4
،
=
- ^[ * א و
لS9 )* 8 B54 <אC$ א dN
-
-N 5א
.
d
7 و
\"
R ]!אi K
R ¥
(
Avolio, et..al,
1991: 10
v
C
^
ذ
א-N 5 . B א
،
!M א
ن\" * א ?;#$
*! k ذو،
v
!*v*
v
-w < نوC$
*F א )* = | ن
8
\"#$ א
و د 5$א B א 0و
،
25
?( x$ S cd
و?
ن
. 4<C$ *) אv (
F * א אd* \
< x$
\"] 8 B54 <אC$
1 ،cd;D
[ د%
)
د [ cd
א
\"#$ د א% ? אM 9 n
.
C cd [^ و،
Qo\"w
،
8-N 5
[ *"\א. F * א *
c$
7 b א cd1 ]!אi K
ن
)
cd i K R!d ،=-
א$ نو א
8- ! אg\"$ "\א )* ع
د |^ I
א bאو 8
אz] و، -N 5 אR ]!אi K
) لE w
0אد
\"$;* i #$
Bass & Avolio,
(.
-N 5א
אz] و،F * א
)
(
;gJ4% אو
س
8 B54 <אC$ ^
אن
1992: 23
)
z א %د א ! U\"# * / 9
و
א ن\"( 3$
^و ع o gא * F
- Nא !] F Q 58א Rא-N 5
א$
2001
)
،
8
"\
א
^!g
نزא\" $א ?א
= *) [
!$
\"doאدً
g7אو مא Bאو ) \"N¤
ن
،אو z
א )* ع\" א * F א = | %د
^1 m
!*"\ن
v
\" 2
tz אQ 5א و
^ذ
لB* cd
c
?;!
ن
א F$
!Mوv$ y א "\A ن
!نو *
و،
?1 k ذQ
®
¨S9אو ق c
א & x Jאو g7אو مא d] ? B
c .
(
)
و! ز\"* و ط R $د אYC %
*! ?!¤ 8 B54 <אC$ ^
אن
.
[\"$ \"D
אق
Woods,
? ن\" * א N
2003
4
و
.
v*F* א
^ v o\"
$א
E
tz د% אt! $ 8 ) א-"\א جذ b$ אQ
_
cd
o $gאو
cd
S( *و
??$
و
،
0S- א
**א
R\"D א. FDU\"- d?
\"D
c$
نא
c$
8(
ً4<אC
B v ? ،* ص @א א5 § א
.
Empowerment
?; א
،
5
!g
\" ; א
ضא
)(-$ א
\"#$ א %د
א]\"l
אو 17
،
ض *) D5
א
א א ذ £א
نא F(-$ א 1( % .?M א
26
( Fא
*!دא
z9Cאو
)(3
? ?k $
א א אد
*!دא]c
و?( cd
?!
^
ذ
ن
[
8
\"K A\" ;
"\ن$-$
)
אن z א %د
^ !% א cd
!
d N1 Z אوg _
cd
! ;5 )
9
? אF(? =-
8
\"#$ א
!M אن
،
^ cd$
? =
\"K
?
^.
5 و $אو ?*)
[ د%
א¬1 (5 אو & "\&
،
1
= !ً7 $;-
-$د
^ i
T ) R $ א )*
7*) א
E
ز
tz 8 ? *א
J אA\" ; אi 9 d
! E -$
\"#$ 1 א %د
.
،
אد א E -$
و
* \"/\" Fא _א ل?!R
א Dא zא
? FDU\"5א
Bass & Avolio,
)
FDU\"-
אz אD אE
E
d
! g\"-T"\[ و
d
! א
0 c]E DKو
®و
*!دא
^
5 * ? אi £
¯d
و
Q
.
ن
א\"DU\"5
ن
Nو Rא-$ %! ;5 א
(
1993: 49-52
i Kא ? =-
א א א א ذ 7£
)
k ذو 8،
\"#$ ! אM ?M 9 \
Hetland & Sandal,
1992: 147-170
(
8 $ א#"\ א
:
و¤!د
1
.
R!? אi #$
د D א%د 5א
.
? Wאو< $ K: א
,
$א ? WאوK: א
,
א
? Wאو< $ K: א
,
<א ? Wאو$ K: א
,
א
v \"
5? $
vא/Jאو 72 0
! 8
!Mא \"#$ א
::::
$-$
_א
^ 1 mJ نو ?9א
<
^
! %א =* $ א _ ذ k $3 \"d1 k
? =-
\"d1 ،
1 m^
d ? $ אQ
kא
و ?* 2א [6א\"5א *
.
!
!K لS9 )* ddo"\א
א [6א\"5א *"\ א. -d5
لو א
אو!g
]!א،v1
E
ز\"* ز?
אد 4 2$ א ?b z] =B3 4 2$
אא א א
4 (א א
) -]Cא?
9?
v
} ? m\"
و
، ]\" $
)
9
و u .ل
= oא? =-
v
^ = Q;#1 אz] ?
J [
،
אع
،
،
v z9
d "\م
א
"\ وא
27
\" و$g @ אvo"\א
2
.
cMS5א
،
v
T b5 אv o
W W W W
[ P4 אv ?
[ P4 אv ?
-
،
% T b5= א-K وx 8
\"#$ א !M א c;$
אً! v نو 9
)
iBא?
و )
97 iB
v
C 8
\"#
ًS
v;D
? _^ ;
و7
!אو d +
? \" و$g )
9S @6 ( א
و
،
،
\ *?5
4} cM א m\" ¢1 א
و %א\";Z
¤ -א لو D$ 7د$;* d * %
v - v ; אن = D
.
*) א = D
)* =-#$
*"\[אو ?m6
("\ن ?b
نא I
] x 1
)]z د $
![ - 0 2 אو
،
% h? אوh?אو
% h?אو% h?אو
%WWWW
eI
~ אeI
~ א
)*
\"-u v;D 8 @ א2$ 4 ! אM [ و
8
!Mא \"#$ א ?
* و}
.
"\
!$ אو ? ; $א
.
אא א /
;v
7 d )*?
=( $
dM\"m . א
!
*! !M א vo $¤ * \"]
،و
)
9
"\07אو? א!
g7אو مא ! $
"\ ! א Bאو
.
م ;x
אن
*
ل 1א
لא\"[ א
!A
v
-
.
Cא ن = D
?*) אدً -M
و
ل\" א ? *)
.
v
1
["\א vو "\ vو
-u
4
8
!Mא \"#$ א =-¤
א= א مא?'א= '?א مא
WWWW
א
א= א مא?' א= '?א مא
;. d !
5א א °د
א\"@אو E1אو "\
iא
T ) 8DT א Q
*= * אl
.
אאאא
،
=* $ א
،אو=B5
. S9א ق
v -
$
و
،
=^
.
ل
و ل^
! %א7 $-$
v
?1 k z ^_ و [אوv
"\ א
n
=-
و
42
5
!M ! Qو? 5א < م F ; ?
*) \"doא د 4 2$
א
،*"\
.
אJ:ل 6
,
אJ:א 6
,
א
.
v D
ن
.
!
א\" א5 #m
?
א .ذ k
אً
אJ:ل 6
,
אJ:אل 6
,
א
لW WWW
- \"
م
ن
\"#$ א !M א $-$
¦ א5
) *;! $
9
v ("\
ن
ن
82
5 \" $ 8 !% א
28
? س &' א س &' א
? س &' א? س &' א
6
،
م ;x
7*) א o دد |
^
.
?
% h h
% h% h
= o _^ 8
!Mא \"#$ א ;
%WWWW
k )ذ
c? -
ًS?1
.
dM ?
.
=-
v
?1
F
1و\" 5 א ?و א -l
وא
א & ($א c` F b$5א `-N 5אو `; "\A
)* \"-? fg و*) S9א * ل oא
? א0
cdو . cd$ 1אد0
0 D \"$;w 0
- [ Bو* *)
& א
; lJ א
1
2
B$ א
1
(
)
2
` ،אو!`l
لو
\"#$ א %د `
)
"\ ?mذ k
ـ
.
ـ
א?
(
!o
لو
א% B$ 7
Bass
Avolio, et..al
% B$ 7א
& $'( ! *) א
! א
! دو
\"#$ א %د א د
% B$ 7א
؛E D#$ א ؛
دD א
1999
א% B$ 7
(D א
% B$ 7א
(D א
؛8 B54 א
א$ 7
E؛ D#$ א؛
دD א
<C$ א
8 ؛B54 <אC$ א
2001
Kent, et..al
MacKenzie, et..al
(D א
2000
F(-$ א؛
א (D
א% B$ 7
1999
2001
א$ 7
Avolio, et..al
1
` !`gد] אد` א ` !-$
א!אن ?א ![ @א
2003
؛E D#$ א؛
א Dد
א$ 7
א% B$ 7
(D א
2004
Judge & Piccolo
؛E D#$ א؛
א Dد
א$ 7
؛8 א <C$א B54
$ 7א
% B$ 7א
2006
29
.
\"#$ א %د א . FBg א }
$
ن Q| אz
د !g
)
، t א\"?א
1999
:
71
(
d*
-
\"#$ א %د א
8
?
:
1
.
{ א 7 3א ?א,د{ jא א 7 3א ?א,د jא
W W W W
)
2
2
(
3
ـ
א
د
א و? )a א
د
א و? )a
א
د
א و? )a א
د
א و? )a
_ א 4 2$
،
) @^ o
9
?^[ א ع v
![ )* k ذ
dN
و
Q
¤ 7 \";Z אT b- Q?و
،
،
-$o7[ אS9
،
0\"m R $
v
)* c $
* ! vM
c $ ^_ אN
و
אو c א
،
42
8
\"#$ ! אM 1
-
8d$
7v
\
?د tא_
א א 7 $א 7 tz
א (4 2$ 1
\"Dא ق
o$
אi K _^ v
C 8 "\/"\ل
!Mא \"#$ א
\"Dق *
]!א Rو
ل\" [ $ 8و
،
cd
אo $g
\
!x$ F * א ل\" % B$ אو
]!
،
-N 5 א )*وcd * [\"$* \"]
!
;
و
d- دو
)
9
.
א ?0
א =-
"\و * }1
א \" א
? א و?=B
Qد א? %
.
(=
و
،
WWWW
ذ ^
אو ? א 0 - אو ? א 0 -
،
د אو%
v
א-N 5
"\م
tz
אو ? א 0 - אو ? א 0 -
.
2
א? .
tz "\? א
i1 א
^ -N 5 אوF * S-
0 אو 8
1992
؛
)
Kotter,
5 1 دא
C c¤8
ن
\"#$
o @? אS9 )* i #$
א
אج $¤ f g
d א## .א
(.
Kotter & Heskett,
1996
?g
-x i #
،
v
tz "\? א
! א
،
4 2$ א
I
&
-$Zא ? <?و
D 1
30
א?& ,و fJ{ 2 Aא جذ } א?& ,و , hJ{ 2 Aא جذ } , h
אאאא
א אوV
"\ و
3
א !#$د *) S9و لm
א5
-
f W W W W
א ;5א ن
-N
vא5
א - 8א tz
.
א?& ,و fJ{ 2 Aא جذ } א?& ,و , hfJ{ 2 Aא جذ } , h
kא (17א
=B-$א جذ\" -א Q 5א . -N 52$ 4 .
.
[ א\" אوR وN -MS* ("\ن
אو
،
(y 1 אi ¤ وc N $ ²! א مtz (= א
d * R وU \K d$ 1 \$ < وd$ ? \
،
] -א ?
_^ 4
،و
5 א 8- N $ א 2$ 4
? ?7א E DKא و $2 4 "\?m
?!
و
ذ 7£دא 1
ن
دא 17א¢ ?
; Qא
![
? א
1996
-
وא
v
\"/ . 4 2$ \"m . $g
א نא 0
،
; - א $ 1א
(
)
Kotter,
.
WWWW
4
? J0א T א? :א - ? J0א T א? :א -
א!
!d$ א ن ;@א . z9C
%!
!o
x
א אm_ و
^ ج$¤ v
?1
،
g $5 א صD אو
א@ o
ول ?
א -l [\"$5א * F
!b$ 7א = مא "\ =MאJ (-5
،
%!
xא!l
אو א7 אو
? א. B-$51( ? א
v*F* א
%!
!o x
و א א
?
^ 7
? ?-#$ אو (1
8
C
) z]و
א
אz] ?
א k
I $ cd
i ²س @-א !
..
?1
ن
،
אد[ن("\
ن
8
\"#$ ! אM ن א
^و
v Y
L
و
.
?1 אz(]و
WWWW
* ? D $? ? /
)(3 7
. c$
ن
،
\*
; -d* %!M א -N$ א 1 B אو 0אد
،
"\m אن
=Uא
Nא4
لkh %? مאW 4 אN
khل ?% Wمא
x
אو א7 אو
? א i #$
:
4 אN
لkh %? مאW 4 אN
لkh %? مאW
^
? /
،
و
*אE
Q
31
4 2$ L*
I
$ o @ و% ? א
4 2$ ? אx 1
لS9 )* 1%
،
!*
d
F* !
א )* א
%!
!o 1 < !M א !oو
*E و
.
אد
،
[و مאJ E$
א %د א א
،
א-N 5
אذ ^
?
א
*)
و^
? א "\? m
F;K =o
א א
W W W W
.
عא אعא א
عא א عא א
א א
ـ
)
2
`-d5`"\ אm\"5*) א
`
OI
`dl
א د אو
"\אو عא!5
אو \"m\"54 *) א$ "\ ع. אB( |و- א (M אو
Organizational Innovation
.
`d *و
! Jאو
عא
،
t z`l8 ( אو MEl= אB*
8 אو عא !J ?K \" $ ! *) א
"\א !? عאE5
א! /و
.
אو د א\"5א(*J
ج\"5 $א عא! ^و א و ? * 8אو. mJ
`"\א1
"\א( `* v`o
@א ` c(#$אو!` Jאو عא `-N 5א ` %42 א \" /و
%و*) <0? c
و} ` &
א5
`-d
\$
"\א( * vo
-N 5 1א ( %4
"\ א@ ( cxא אو cx@4א 42
،
`Dא \" *`;$و د`-N 5 א ` *`;\"$
،
- אو
? `!
d$m 1א "\5 א [
א ن#$ 7
.
!`gCא` V
ن )`( ` 3א א א ` ]-دאدز!` J
عא
א א دא! $אو F ;1 5א`-N 5
و*
و ^4
*?1
9 #
و6 ($ d ^ Cx
2$ ]z
אא
א $-عא !
`u . `]E ? .ل ` #
،و^
אJ %د א k
א =? 1ن8] -N 5
`"\م `` v
و]`zא *`
.
? `! א ن . \` B
"\א ن@ ` %
[ ن
; $ 1א * i #$א%E 5
א!5;$א
(Bא ! א )`* _^ ` ` 4 אن
א *
5
\
=` D( !` Jא ن
א عא$5"\א/`= ]`"\ א
(.
א =( ] )-m
)
) S?1
6 b$* v ?
،
Wheelen & Hunger,
2008
HP
و
!1
)
Lawrence & Lorschs,
( ؛
،
($
א D ( "\א لg 4 ( א7]$- א م
! J אdא
x$ * -N 5 אd 1
(.
;$ א
א! _אو
1961
-B א
א ! !d و
)
1967
ل B* )* =Mאو א
Burns & Stalker,
)
v`
`!و عאJ אc !`
i`
` א - N $ אد א [ ;א
Drazin & Schoonhoven
و
_^ `"\د
`!عאJ` א
( 1א ن _ N وא
(
1996: 1066
دאو ` א ` `;d א
)
،و` ?
و
,
و
`
`( $א%! $;`5 א6
F;`#$א-$;`5 `$אو ج!` J
אو عא
J` א
F;`K وo $
אJ
و^
،
)
-$;`5 אF;`#$ \"`l` א
د% אو E
1999: 647
Currie
,
_
(
* \"l אد% ^_ ^א
د% א
Just in Time
و ^
0 אد אF;`K ` E` א
` !` ` א
،و^
אE` dx$ _ א
` א
8`
?
Activity Based Costing
ل -
א
א
Business Process Re-Engineering
` - ` ! ] %_ ^ ` د
7
^ن
Mcabe
Knights &
8- N $ א عא ! Jא ن
(
ل ` -א ` ` -
[! m ن
v
1998: 169
,
- א
،
.
,
!` ^ c`<
عא
!] لو אMא
)
Davenport
`1 58 و/ א ع- N $ אc $ א - * =gא5 ? אz] \ * (
c< - א
1997
Process Innovation
(
F;`K^ `!و عא E א
E א
7ن ^
.
;$ א.
33
`! %وو
"\ ! !o `(1
-
! %و
ن _^ D* 4
^א ن do\"$א * .א (DאJאد t
(
1
`)
`v
`! و ` 0
ًSg
S?1
אو ً
¯ عא \"dD* ? ¤א م! J
،
ض\" 2-א *)
3
א عא א א عא א
א عא א א عא א
)
ـ
ـ
W W W W
2
` vא ` Vאو \" ` $אو ل`1 5
אودو
(
،
:
"\ `!
אً
`v
\" 4 `2
=` 1
1999
א ن` J
א! ع
39
<\"* <S
8`] ،
(
` _^ 4
عא ? א!` J
1
)
:
;
.
و
،
.א-N 5
)
ً $א دא 1א ج1 * F \" $5
)
د D S9
אل
و?!g
د
א
`[S `/ 9 `D Uو
Entrepreeneurship
(
1998: 149
,
Drucker
! Jא
عא
v`
.
א@ } iMو 5א * iM g )* 14א 1 .و =/
و*) * \"Nد [$א! t
`!)`* %
א א د `!l 5אو @א ل -א*!V אو ?d L
א
? `;$
א!` Jא عא `($
(
)
`0 نود 8
C
א! Jو عאو = -عא !doو?د& 7
.
"\א d
C
(
)
v` 1
3
.
2
אذ %!
!o ج$
^ \"*
دא
Entrepreneur
tد
א d ($
= אM \" ]و8 א
،
( .
א i` K
, !;N ?$!J و ! J, !;N ?$!J و ! J
)
x$`
, !;N ?$!J و ! J , !;N ?$!J و ! J
`d * $* `o @ =?`1
!o *!9
\
!Z
$8Jو
! 3 !Z
$8Jو
! 3
،
!Z
$8Jو
! 3!Z
$8Jو
! 3
1998:515
Jones,
)-?`$5אو
B א B א
- א ! \"$
.
E
E
^*( א د א\"5א@
?3
[-
و
\"dD-و ،م]8 \"- א "\ %א
:
``T' ;`³ )`* i
B א B א
، ،، ،
;=- $
d
`
אل S9
،
18
( .
);g
)
אS( 5
:
، ، ، ،
4א4 ?א?
4א4 ?א?
8` - א
George & Jones,
( .
,א א NAא א،@ ,دא NAدא، @
)
,א א NAא א، @ ,دא NAدא، @
2008:26
34
،
2000
331
א!o =9!* _^ -N 5
`; ! ]`zא =5`!9א א5
و
`
`* )`(
א
. %!`
`; [ ً \"`dU `* ،א =9א!`5א!l
:
! cNא v$ א =9
182
مא `!b$
א
(
*!
و bאودوv 1 א v
;-
(.
س ¥د
1996:1093
،
،و^
)* S9!56 א C$
Nא م! Jא عא? 5
ن
Kotler & Armstrong
v` o\"wو
\" $* =9 *) *!אd ;
)
,
` B-$5` אo b5 `!אو عאJ`= אg אw ` B-$5?` אو- ` א א `<
،
` !1
` %א`5
،
"\%
.
Team-based Product Development Approach
=9
* }i
D אو
،
!א D
E
و \[\" א $"\41א \
، 0S`- אو
و
א!`5
`k *)
ذو لو א =5!9א
)* vא)(-5
7^ ?
E* c}
א
،
8
B א
Daft
,
2001: 351
א5 $"\ج
\
(
< _^
tz א
^
v`
!-$
`
!$
$אو א אو! )* D ?5א )* /42دx$ 5
א;
3M
=*!9و*L א
.
ً g ?iK d
Traditional
t!`` $ א
\"`
،
g x$ *
ً `` % אدJ`` אd [א
\"Bg
ن אو
Development
אو-ل
!* =-
v o\"wو
%!`
!o x$ * ($ 7
"\
F;`K و
א5
%!
*!!o x$ * 1 9 وא אm
.
و ``F
א \"-
! Hعא
)
;D*
Drazin & Schoonhoven
tz` 8 `אD ($ א \"`N 5` א $
]
v`o\"
1996: 1066
,
]\"o . و، x $ א i K D
"\لg
D$א 54 א
_ ^
^_
2002
^ א5
و\"`oد
(
،
)
1970
`. v
`;8 ( א
(
`
N
:
)
4
و
96
א
,
Hage & Aiken
7
,
1998: 9
^ 7 g =( ? $"\[ \ و א$ )(3
(
v
א f g )*
d ^ N
!عאJא
N
ن
)
Coombs,et..al
!` J`"\א ` א د لg cd$D;` 1 . אوE`
عא !
د!`? א%، و
.
ج`@א `d-xg 1`"\ق `-N 5 אc`xg ?` - v &\"} *
و، ! Jא
عא
عא !` H t! \"$ د% א5 !א ل
\" و ،عא 5-אو = ?א ¢ . dא! J
ز
[\ 0D
;M < ?Sא1 אm
ن
:
d$ * 4} =-
? `!
و
d
*! F$
=` - א
? ! א D;` D
و،א -$ * [\"D$* x$وd ;K عא ^!
~!K א
,
(
)
1999: 37
Berthon,et..al
d.
E 1
،
"\`do
`
` ^ ` ،k zو[ 1 %א\"$5א م
אد ` - %
א ص ! J1
د א\"5אو ،عא
:
8] -d* /
א! Jو ،عא\"gא E1א
! Jعא
.
و
] A
ن
אA
وj
^
_
36
א عא א عא K و ,د ?6 א عא א عא?و ,د K 6
- N $و ` ! cd } )( 8א! א د `5א` 9 "\א د * ع! J
א عא
ج א )* و`V
)
ن \"Bg א4
א عא א عא K ?6 د, و א عא א عא K ?
6 د, و
W W W W
_^
Ivancevich,et..al
,
=98 *) א! א
C
ن
2
)
ـ
א ن!` J
عא
2
.
(
4(D$ אو = א ود
3
و
אوo V
ـ
`
f` g
)(3
ن
_
,
`
.و
^
1998: 78
(
1997: 548
(
Amabile
)
!`
عא א!` J
،ض $אو
و!``@א? }``4
Unexpected
א``[\"$5
:
א `=9אد ``-N 5و ` א و]``8
`ً `D 8א ص!` Jو ،عא!`gد f#א m 2
א\"` אو 8 א )
]`` ?zא ``Dא ص\"``o\"5د%
*`)
42$אو .
،א `
ق، `(D$א S`V4 אو א ، ` Dאو`d5 אو `
(D א א5 1 אو?Vא
L$
d } و،t ]) אz א.
8] / <S< = D
)
*^ ، o Vאو! אو1 א! א9 אو
:
(
!`[\"$ *`) אC `
!אJא
ن
!?1
Drucker
)
1998: 150
,
Process Needs
Birkinshaw &
، Q$(5 ط
7^
.
Industry & Market Changes
ن
%!``
!lאو5 1` א، S ?``D$ ! א3"\} א1 ` ، אو42$
` א. אو قאوذ א
J! אM אRא ? و
)
Incongruities
Occurrences
`א ق\";` אو =( ]
Hood
)
2001: 131
,
v` ^ ` `* אz] و،)
! l א صb
`(1 א x`
و &z`oو
א )* F
א F* א )* dN
عא א! J
א %! lאو
س `@-א ` i` 9 . א B
2001
ً `?
،
אو tא cd 5אوB5 אد
E
`"\
cא \"m\"* -N 5א! Jא!`* )* عא=9 ; "\ Aא - N $
و8 אل \"Bgن u . א لو
!
%
`B$
\
א
182
*? `!
אً
(
("\
ن
א ن-N 5
ن
،و א-N 5
\"$;* = )* iB
א
B
`$*
:
^
`(1 א
ً א !
!אJא
،8``- N $ !``
א عא
`?b
_
^
cd
` אد 7 د [ ![و u
،
d
\"$;* = . 8 !אJ4 (אD$ א
D $?
N
و
.
37
``
؛
,
`!
!o v`o\"
(
(
Damanpour
1991: 555
8| !`
و
)
E` * 6 $ z] )-mو
אא
8M `d
c-
.
_ t zo FD /
`I
}`و 4
^
)
א t z`l6אوR ?`5
؛
`$ א א ! $-א א
(
؛
? ; 42
! א )*و
،
אد
א
I
و
)
*8g
6
1990
.
)
(
Henderson & Clark
,
(
؛
:
1997
341
7^
Architectural Innovation
عא ! J א- !
?(
.
א !` א ?z`] ` ! אFBg ` B`( אc$]
4 *`) א
א 1 ! !א مJ ! א א ! א/
*
ن
4ً אB` v `$
`
\"(5א ن
9א$5! אD אd
[S
f` g
`!عאJ אو،L$` -
א عא5 !!ل
t `- 5א
Traill & Gruenrt
,
J אF
Modular Innovation
(
%\"
)
42$ = אB3 tz א
א `* ً B
!`g -- `5` א
` ¢א\"(5
i
1997: 5
`; אل `(
?;"\
Q`¤א،% T `b5
و
?Dو ` ?
? א ?א،0
)،
9
و
، t! D$ 4א } vD/\" !ع א5 ?b א cd? ذو
` ` `<
،و
، S(
و
v` (? `[S9 %4 ` وذ
\" `/
tذ
F \"`
!? %
=gא S( 5א5 !% א
، )
9
א?
`(D$א J4 אو ; ;= و ( 1אd` K
.
`!א 8
8 #$ א4 (D$ (D$
א 4 ]- א
-$د
1999
و
303
183
`` `` * =``Bא ` Bא
א (D$א نود = 5;$א @א 74
*)
،?D
و
)
:
:
،
1989
8
`"\
א
182
د [و ? א * =* $א ;\"d
)
9
F !` -
?M ``V א¢`
(
ـ
د!`gو
t
، ز\"` א
c ;$;
7
"\ !א! $* =Mد`* =* $ %
*)
)
(.
א`5
و
!g ! 1د]
:
و ، QאوZ
x$ א. } א
?t
د ،
)
* .
([\"$51 א }4
و
20
ـ
17
(
אو ل\" @א ) f# א )-?$
tz א
1999
و
و?;`5א ، `! =`-K ` % א
، `!%
; א?Vא א!l אو
و
، QPز ?א1
38
`! =`g ` % א
:
دو وy
!عא
ً
ن ±gS
)
` ` ?Dאو?`9 א `B (D$
אو 4 ! %אو و?;5א א א S( 5و Qgא % T b5و=-K
)
2
ـ
3
ـ
3
W W W W
جذ } جذ }
(
א عא א א عא א
"\אد,
"\אد,
"\אد,
"\אد,
د%
^و! Jא .عא5 ،א < 1
!
4} E1"\אg cN
0 و cN$א
،8 `!אJ4 (אD$` ? א$ -N
!
!K
:
` - א c -و`ozY
وE`o
. و
` -א! Jא `
،
،42$ אود1
א
و w Tא`D $? =g
)-?$
(
!
!K
و
Davenport
,
1993: 24
)
\"`]
] `!دf` g )`* 8`- N $ א
`!عאJא
_ ن
-
- =g* א
\" و
)
z אن \"Bg א$9 6 א
א
![
عא !` Jא
^
(
1994: 582
,
Scott & Bruce
)
.
و
(
1996: 661
، ` [\"$5`! אM"\אD אو D(
,
8M `d א i
و
Schermerhorn
`
!
!K
، iא % (Dא-$Z
א*0S5
وً 1
و
و [-
و `8
א! Jعא
\א ]`،8
` <J
אو t\"D ) S9 )* % (1א ل! J
א عא
("\
ن
א `Q
x$ א
^
و.
!%
א!l
و?m
، tو* `lא`*\" 5
و
)
39
J
!`
iא ج\"5 $א!l
;"\
$وج
ـ
لو !o
)
2
(= א
، _א ` -
-
(.
1
"\א .
`! ^
!o =9!`* z` D
و
ـ
2
)
(
1
F* 5 $"\ج
\
8
`-B !`
!lא
عא !` J"\א א
(
ج \"`$ -
4th ed., New York, John Wiley & Sons, Inc: 661
و
Source:
”,
Management and Organizational Behavior
و
% ``(D `` א ض
،
،% ``(D و7د% א
:
8``] `"\א
(
_
^
ن
` -
?z`] نf` g
)
` و
.
.
i
א \";`$
* ` zא %د7و % `(D * א =gא!` J
عא
( \` j `d
\";`$ א
ق\";` א ` $9א
و
و ،
، אL$` 5
\"
`ً
% (D 8
\";$ אQ
، t x$ א-= = אK
`DV
x
א ` א
\"`
،``"\مdD5א
\"`
FBg ` א
و
1999: 275
)
، א$;"\ق
=`n
,
Kotler & Armstrong
و
و
و
א \
Kuratko & Welsch
l אd Q}
,
2001: 153 - 156
40
Jא
عא !
`D9
. ` * c `א
و
:
8`] وd$ -;`
. `"\אD $9
א
?`@א5 "\*` ، - ` ` אn وi` #$ `) אco ` א \"`] ?o ` ! Jא
א عא
!و
وא
% `(D א ` ? ، `d 8 \"` \"g 4(D$
` א ل א5 "\* א$5"\א1 % ) * ( * [
= دא
1
א
Incubation
Process
ًא !o
o @= אgא
.
zD$ d( $3 א א d5! א
( 1א!K א و !
א!K )* )(-$5
` \"`] ?o א ع!` ("\
5א ن
و
Evaluation and Implementation
5א
)* !
אو
z` D $ אو
c` $א
tz` א =`@אو% `(D 6א `(
د
، `B B אو `
B אF$ g `5א9= `!א
` ` نBg א `! אz ،%Cx1 v
D !א ن\" אo %4B5= אgא
5א
The Idea Exprienece
)* !
אو
^ ;
2
ـ
א عא א
د
א @k א عא א
د
א @k
W WW W
)
4
א
t אدJ( אD א. %!
; [ ً \"dU * ،א =9א!5א!l
א عא א
د
א @k א عא א
د
א @k
(
?\
ن^و אو 8-N$ אو
א [!
ن
v
] A
א! Jعא
لu
FBg א
אوb$5
F
ن
cd x
|!
ل،
ل S9
ع ^n
א! Jא
F
ن
א ]z
?-
و? 5א F
.
א?
<C$
א! 5א
א% د
.
א ! אو
; !M א
אא! J
.
)(3
%1 د
د
?#D$5
،ع
.
*)
(.
Glynn,
1996:1093
و t (D א ل 5א س Eא-N 5
د%
ز . % ] U d?S* ^ d
7ن
N
(=-$
אא! J
1
)
عא Eא! J
E
. t א ود א ?!
^א 5 1א %אد
و? cd 5
; ]\"-א
א! א
-
م ]-$
אJ
א [=
4(D$ א
و
دא!x$5
*)
א[\"$5
[!و%
.
*F
? 0 אو
ن
ن ("\
138
ن (w
אذ ^
א?د *!x$
.
]- א
א% د
1994
(D
،
cd; M
ن
4?א (D
)*و
8
ز
? 1
ن
(D
v .
ن\" و? 5א
א5
^ !א ?
א [=
d1
\" x
א
)(3
.
א! א1
-
د%
ن
cN
لS9
"\ cd
א tz
*)
א! Jعא
* ?و cd
ض و
א
?\" g
אو t! $
"\m
(=
?
"\*"\א
= 5א
=g
(
R]!א
? ;1^
و
)
:
ل ?א
)*و
cd* *
لS9
cd
**
8
?\"$D*
41
F א5 ?و
$g
=/\"$
F
v
ن
=
)
9?א
cd 1!
x
?1 $ א
4(D$ א
cd$ [ *و
، d1
غ S ^و
c
!
*
،d
v;D
]"\
v
?1
،
*)
د *!x$
(1 א
אد
א
?
ن ("\
!M א
8D(
7v
ل\" א )(3 v
=
.
?o א
ن
.
!
!o \"] 5 ً * -$]
8א
و7
!
ن C
%!
!o
)*
v * ?و
)*
لS9
%!
!o
(1
% (D
8
C
)*
cMS5א
41\"
! ;
د *
tz א
ن\" א
، ]z D $
)*
^*(
אJאد %
א
א! Jعא
،
א ?z
א%! l
* -N
v
;E $
م
( 6
و
م "\
)*
i
?z]
، (1 א
، d
_\"$
و
_^
"\א0
ن
אJ
א !
2000: 1122
fg
!و ]
,
Batkin
. و
(
- א
(*Jא
!$ א
n
א%! D5
& #/
0
(1 א
)
،
و* "\
"\ =M א
g
و^
^_
"\41
)
zא
"\ن
1
-d5
F
J
א אد
א% د
س א
0
אEl
k
S
=B3
א! Jא 8
^_
;
א
!
א-l
د אD
#o א
1\"$
م
لS9
و\"oد
*)
ن
)(3
א% د
^7
*;\"$
7
ذk
t
.
??
"\41
k ذ
ذو k
"\A
ن
ن
عא، !H
אcMS5
א? 5
א =-
،8 g
_^
و
و
د אD
א-l
-N 5א
=
\"K
א(*J
،
؛
t א
،
8
א@
،
؛
"\&
؛
8
E א
،
)* !
! א
v
1999
325
.
ً \" و ً אو ،عא! ^
)
؛
= ،Fو* cd و? 5א ($
א ود ]-
* !
و]zא
א B5א 7ل@
:
א!א
د |^و
8- N $ א
א? 5
אcMS5
א tz
א! Jعא
^_
"\
د
و
x
ن، ]x
-M א
אא א
אא! J
،
- א
S( -
(
)
ل\" @אو
2001
1 B א ]- و D; 1 =U .א -N 5א q ! 1 - $5א ! C$
ودو ]
א 2$ 4א 0א ^o ?*) x $א .دא 1א-N 5
و*D ($
\"[ 1 < "\دo و% وm
! C$ אq f g
(.
2000
1997
1994
1992
42
,
Daft
)
- $5 א-N 5א
&\" =U . 1 B z]و
א ود \"] א
(.
g . $gو
א
^ 1 mJ
1 ?א ن
%!
gא ( 1א مא!l
Bאو$ 3A א
& א א, BאوA
א3$ א
& א א, א
ـ
5
)
2
2006
(
W WW W
ض ?م Bא א %?Aא ???B א ط `$ א א,دK א ?
W
B א
،
*א א ( 5- د\" ; א %Edo
2008
א .
\"#$ א %د א i
(
?
; 4
אA
אWZ3A
א
"\
1
-
،
)
ل Sd א
()
د
א
א א
,
א א
? ? $8J $ 8
"\.
א & Bد
^_
^_
R $ א
Bنא
א,د
]!\1
א!]7אو אوR
? א i #$ !g א\" אi
= -אو D א ?و ! d- E$
مא
אو7
243
.
؛
\
%"\دl א ن-m -]C
\"#$
א אد א * Fא د^و ؛A
= -אو\" 5 א ?و א 1
< א 1
"\\ /
و
*) א
!* .
]ز
،LM $ א )* !
! א _^ א ! א
\"#$ א %د א i
(
.
*) א!א \
("\
$#אو ![8 !b$א مא Ld 5א "\D/
و 8،
.
م א
א وq
I
)
:
2006
،
(
"\
F
د\" ; א * F
} جذ
אA
אWZ3A
? א & Bد
W
د
א
]!\1
?/
?
"\.
א
^_
R $ א
1
نא B
א,د
،אو=]?5
אو ،ع
ً
א ! א دא ، 1
!7 א אذ قو D א
אF M g7
^ o
^_
8
\"#$ ! אM א ?M 9
د\" ; א
^_
.
R $ אאz
و
אد א *! א*AS$
* א
43
F Dא !7א אذ قوM gJ א
^o
א ! א دא 1
א ?z] i #$ و 8
\"#$ א !Mא *I * ?
^_
ذ\" ج
R $ אو
\"#$ א %د א A\" ; i $
- 1 8- א
fg [ א مR]!א
Y c
!
و 8
\"#$ א
!M ? אM ? i $
- 1 ،8- ،א =]?5אو
אو ،ع
"\
ن
ً
א*
א و ،م! *وS9 )* ،!Mل
\" -ن .
)
z א،
0
?M V אوA\" ; ) א
( Sא\"Z
*
.
8- ،א =]?5אو
אو ،ع
ً M gو1
د אذ ق^ 7
7v
و1 !o
"\
389
،
(
F
-
)
?zא א\"Z م א ? \"$5א ? fg ،
و
)
(
cd
د[ن
ن\" 3 cd
د [ نא نو
א ! א دא 1
?zא א\"Z م א ? \"$5א ? fg ،
ضg
! ?zא א 2
"\ \ /ن _^ א ! א
f
399
א$
^ E !1 א!א ?z] .
א
] cא /\"$
!אو
k zא D$ 7د% و *
و א ^6
* א* o و، و!d1 k 5 ،א
د\" ; א
*) א?Vא א "\ Tא. $b5
!d 5 i#א א ! 8א
א %د א א א و! אو. $b5
*
* E
[*
א אد א
Q
!$
uא % .د א ل* l
o Qوو )*7א لm
* א -م 7]$-אو !$
* @?"\
א אد gא/D
א?Vو! א א *) S9ل ^
?
- א
! *) א7
*E
D$ S
א אد א $9א -م ]-$
د)* %
1 mJ ،
9א! א %אزو نא א ( 5- "\
د\" ; א
! F
* Fא!5 א 1א! J
א ! عא
"\
و
8
!Mא \"#$ א + F [S א
^_
אR $
אh א
? ? Bא ? K 4אزو نא, א
א,د ?&
^_
]!\1
"\.
*
.
-
א,د
)
א*8 ز
W
אد א عאc, Z @k و א
د
א
2006
نא B
(
،
"\
44
و\"oد S
( #1
*) א!א \
\"(
(
300
)
:
F
9א! א %אزو نא!5 "\
א )*
8دDU\"* )*
] ز نLM $ ! *) א
"\ _^ \ /א !
و[!
!w
.
ض
א
א! א9
*AS$
Fא
.
"\אزو نא %
!
א!5 א אد !
+و \"#$ א %د א "\א?M 9 1
*!
אR $
^_
א! ^ א ![و א d5 d
و?;5א "\א مdl
C fgن א /و
Aאد א
.
و[!
J
א אد א אد
= Dא
و %د
ز v
(= * *) C
אو 8
; -و ?M 9א !Mא \"#$
*S$
*? * AS$و
ن א "\T
،
)
"\1
* F
א %د א !
\"#$ א %د א
+
نא B
2005
(
دc
א? & א
א,د
-
"\
.
\"#$ א %د א 9א! א %אزو نא?M 9 "\
و ;-
!
א!5
^_
R $ א
"\.
]!\1
*!
אh א
אز, אد?A א
pא
W
ض א
N ;4 ? Bא, P4א ? 8 א
א ? א,د Kאد א,
א
5
ض
א
* א %אد
.
* . FאJ א אد)* M א\" D
"\ \ /א !
و
* و[! qא$9
!
،و
א ً1 "\
[= +א %د א \"#$
.
،Bو
! א %د א * F
א \"#$
"\د א %1
!5 cd$
? ? -و F b א =*א\" א < א د kz ]?
و %د א 07
و
"\ز ( א %د א *1 +
א =]?5א Fא\"? ? ?7 و -8 "\F [S !o
7v
+א م 7]$-א Dد- ،t
"\א x $ 1 +
D5אد \"gل
א دא 1א
Fو -8א =]?5א ? F *"\o ط
] [S Aא
א! Jو 8א
א!א
"\\ /
نא
_^
*) ]d- ن LM $
%! _
B ن
x $ א+ k ذ. ]S
*E
(8+ * ] F
א %د א א %د א .
א ^
אً 4
א ًא 1
"\
;- א
:
< + cא %د א * ?Jو9
א! 7א 8
+ 1\"$
? א \"? F<\"# 5 אF RS$9! אo\"
v
،و
-
Fא *"\o ط
[Sא
Fو\"oد
-
.
?*
+ Fא %د א \"#$ و
Dد tא %د א +وאJ
+א م 7]$-א
45
-
F 1S$9 אA ] )(
? Fg . ،
;( א
א Eא _א. RS$97
א \"#$ א %د
א =-
Eא_
\"#$ \"$
א %د א 1 +
? א\"? F<\"# 5
א
א [S אد T
^_
(
א,د
2003
)
.
،
t- א
نא B
د
| אa 6h ? @kB א
?Eא
دTא
\"
v$
n م [ tz א
Bass & Avolio
|^ [S ?
.
،
t א\"?א
n^
ً7 `
1\"
!*و
\"#$ א %د א ?M 9 F
(
)
^^ 1 m
]!\1
_ * س
1999
\ /א א ! א_
"\
و[!
v;D ] \"T
$ א
א n . fg ^א %אد\"l
א ! $-א ![و * א %د
"\.
د° *
[ ^
7
א!א![ * א
) .א; ?5
!- 8
\"#$ אt د אA\" ; ;* ن$"\ א
`
d * LM $
%!
?M 9 Fא %د א \"#$ ،
_ *; \"$א\"*C5ل
א& S4
?B א
"\
د
א
1
نא B
א,د
.
cd
א? 9و -א cd
*?]S و
א
א "\D U
_ א ? ن0
"\م =( * א %د- ،
א ^ LM $
cd
(= c] - C t ]\"oא * و <C$
?8
"\א A\" ; 1 /د א tא \"#$
א\"? 6U\"5
د אذ^ * M g^ 7א %אدl
["\
"\.
]!\1
אد א
א?I? 4
א,د k8 א
R $
א
?,א_
^_
)
(
-
،
W
*t א
2002
! ? f gد]c م
/
م
א8 * l
2001
2000
k ،ذو
د\" ; א
א* l
-$u
א!א
ن("\
و
\"#$ א
.
\" z א
=D א
S9ل
?
!$ א
8
אB
א!א 8
]?
?0
.
n
*)
\
א
و*
א% د
א3 د
/
!M א
8
\"#$ א
)
Tichy & Devanna
, 1986
(
אذ ^
A ]
אذ
]!دg
?M 9و
$?
.
אد א
$?
D U\" אو
،? b$ אو
?M ?
?z]
!*
M g^
1 قو
42$5א
lא
E
7د
، *
!M א
?M 9و
46
$ א
2912
fg א
/
س
و-l
?"\אً،
\"T
א!א
M g^
-
.
.
A\"
7د
، \"$;5א
\"#$ א
و!o
قو 1
אذ
א% د
د\" ; א
א* l
/
.
א3 د
!M א
אد
^? M g
قو 1
"\!o
E
و7
E
t42$5
8
א \"#$
،D
42$5
א "\U
אد א !
א% د
\"#$ א
א!א
LM $
/ و
?M 9
ن
dUو
،8
\"#$ א
قو 1
د7
אذ
، ? b$ אو
-
א* l
dU
?
א !M
^M g
? ?M
i $
-1
-
? ?M
א3 د
.
?$
א
אد
^M g
د7
E
אذ قو 1
dN
و\"o
د
LM $ א
د و\"o
אو ? b$
،
א !M
t42$5
نא B
"\
-
א,د
،
2002
ض] دא 1د! ?
א
* !w *? ;
600
*"\6U
،
(
*t א
א ? ;7א & Bد
א WZ3A1 ? א [א 4א
.
"\
^_
]!\1
)
א\" א*=
<
!
!K
و د cא
א? & א
א* l
)(3
8
\"#$ א
E
ن
.
42$5
]?z
א-5
b א
א\"- 5
א42$5א
¢
-
،
א \"#$
=j
]zא
א *
س 5א
8- א =]?5אو
، אو%?V
א b
،
وT
-
"\D U א
و!o
\"#$ א
tא; ?5
*!
א!א ،
א-5
-
"\\ /
و
^_
!
8
!
.
א!א
FDU\"5א
(
Hellriegal, et..al
,1992
)
$9
אq ![و
\" س
tz א
%א د
.
א5 س fg א
v--/
!مb$ אو
15
8-N 5א
4 2$
%א د
iK
%א د
،
\"#$ א
[S9 ^ن
?M V
FDU\"5א
?
oא]
)
אد
م ]$-א
\
(
,2001
\"#$ א
?=
? و %و]-
א 4 2$
وT
אو%?V
א!א
م !
א 8-
n
*-d
-א=]?5 אو
* "\7
و\"oد
t
4<C
LM $
!
-
\#mو
=-
א z]
fg
]\
!م
_^
U\" א
-]
8[S9 א
! א
\ 9
-N 5א
D א
47
256
*
c]EDK
، ل-
!*
א!א
!1
\j
، dM و
د \"dlא
، d
\" z
א
ز*
?
(1
!م
و
[ د%
\K
45
אً
*!
23
نא *!
ً ،و
^
אد
J
!?אdo "\אz cd
ن\" 5א ! و
?
< א0
،ً M 9
א[\"$5
و -mن
*)
א-N 5
\]
? cא¬1 (5
]-
אو Eא]
\"o
* d9
m
*)
!م
n
!]"\
.
ع و
א-N 5
8[S9 א
ع وm
Q
אl
! א
!1
א !M
אو* $5
i K
*
* א
[\ و 0אد א
م!
4N
(
2001
"\
،
-
א?8 S
א
)
Bنא
א,د
\]
א-N 5
F;#$
!1
.
*? د%
אJאد %
\
0 B$ 7
¢م ;[ א ? 0و 0א! -א .
د%
אو ) mא
"\
אB? T
א 3אو HB 1 aא ; א
د
Uא K Pمא
"\ Y ? mد א ط! %
]!\1
^_
.
% 1د % د א
زو ! *) א!dl
z .ل *E } cd
"\^ ? mא د
¢א ( א * lو
.
"\ن f gد ن oא? \"$5
\"K cd
س cd;D
Nא نو_
0 א ن-! אd-] L
M$
^ א!א "\\ /
%אد Cو ،א !
W
fgא$ 7 א ! $-אو
א,دK א ?
_ !%
cd
א
M אoJ ; "\ אcd*!אb$ *) אB
\"K \" \"*!b$;
ن
=/\"
ﻭ
-
t א
א,د
אد ? - tو Fאو R $
^_
! J !Mא عאJ ; "\ Aد אt א
،
"\
?و ? c,
W
א عא
دc
א א
אد
א א? & @k
نא B
)
ض ? 7; ? 1א א
אWZ3A
]!\1
א42
? ?I k8 א א,د
^_
"\
$* ¢
.
R $ א
48
D
* \ א ! אK
F *\"(@ אFDU\"-
J !א عאJא
t אد
א!א
%Edo DU\"* )*
8א
\ /\"
![و
.
ض
א
א @("\* .א!5
א bאو "\D U
¢א42$5א [S
^_
%Edoאو *\"(@א R $ א . F
אد7א
و[! q
)
i
א$ 7
א n . Bg אو$-! א
313
d * LM $
_ !%
? -و ! ^ \"$;w Fא cdאJאد t
.
^
.
(
*;\"$ ن
א!א
אذ
7د אذ F M gد o א
אد t
א! Jא عאJ
*;\"$
|
^
א! Jא عאJ
אد t
و
? -و F
d# 3א !M א
@א
[S "\دo وF
و،cd
!
t אد
א! א \"$;* . M g
د7
^
א! Jא عאJ
\"$;* F و
? و\"oقو 1د
^
،
-
ن
א dU
و? F 5 !Mאc$d5 א A\" F M g
אد t
א! Jא عאJ
| د אذ7
"\א 1אً
] [S A
^
! و? 5א F
[= /
tאو = $#א ? Fنא
-
?M 9 Fא !Mא bو F
?ً
?
א - ،FDU\"-
אAא $ 3A3 $
(
نא B
\"
Employee positive moods as a mediator linking
transformational leadership and employee work outcomes
\"
.
? \" א و! א $
!]
_^ \1
F * אLM $
و
א \"#$ א %د *F F E-א جא8 |J
^9
א!א \
o
(
.
)
282
49
.
c? 8 |Jא جאE5א لS9 )* F * א LM $
\"#$ א %د }
*4
<4
אً
F [S א $9
\"
transformational leadership and organizational culture
^
[S A ] نא F
"\& א = $#א? ( 8
^_
$د
]!_^ \1
א!א \
o
.
אو! Jאو عא Bא - N $ 1
? -א - N $א F [S 8
د א%
א ودً
A
א ? 5אو! Jنو 8،א ]
\"#$ א %د א F
)
א% د
.
\"#$ א
(
1158
Building a climate for innovation through
-N * )*
د,א
,2008
(
\"
ًא
*!
نא B
Sarros, et..al
)
-
.
א! Jא عא 8- N $
و/
א ع Vא7 א ص 8
אو! Jو ،عא
\"#$ א
.
7 و
,2008
Erkutlu
_^ \1!]
)
-
א [S A ]
قدD א.
Multifactor Leadership
662
70
نو
.
א R ]!אi #$
Questionnaire
א !
.
(
,2008
Marloes
-
.
د,א
\"#$ א %د א ) "\ *) * o ض !*c
x$ א
? ]z
*)
*;x$
ً
*) א!א \
("\
.
335
א "\ ? 42$5א )* =( ? lא!5
) אو * F
\"
Transformational Leadership and Innovative Work
Behaviour: Exploring the Relevance of Gender Differences
.
\"
_^ \1!]
<א
F [S א $9
نא B
$9א
א7 אD $;5 א8 . !אJ א-= אA\" و
א %د א \"#$
_^ 1 mJ
.
א
50
א7 א * . FאD $;5 א
]\"l
א )* א ! א * . F \
\"(
و v
.
%א د F = D$ < !o\"
7
_ א42$- ? l
"\ Aא = -א! Jאو 8،א$- ? lو ? 42 ،و
א \"#$
.
mJא 1 "\ Aא = -א! Jא ،8 و
! *)
א!א ! א _^ "\\ /
و[!
.
:
)
!5) א
* F* א F ?
[ אS
4<C
v ?و ن
A ]ن
(
-
)
د,א
2007
Chen, et..al,
\"
)
.
E D#$א אو ع! 5א 4 (D$ א ن _^ א ! א
(
نو
.
\
.
E D#$אt ]\"l אو ع! 5א 4 (D$ * S9 )* F
אل ^!
א عא
\"#$ < د א% א $9
_^
.
\"
Exploring the Mediating Effects of Creative Thinking and Intrinsic Motivation
א
and
\1!]
?Db *
ً
4<C
ن
ًא
)
نאB نאB
نאB אB
Transformational Leadership, Organizational
\"
Jaskyte,
ن
(
.
د,א
ٍ4 ل <C
v ! ع4 א5 (D$ א
عא ! Jא
2004
-
N$ 1 א B אو
\"#$ א %د א F ط
א[S
"\/
و[!
.
(
*
א %!#$
א5
.א "\7
א
*) א!א
"\
.
? א} -N 5د ?א 14 - N $אو! J
א. א 1 B ،אو
\"#$ א %د א
.
\
("\
51
د,א
\1!]
-
\"
R $
enhancing organizational innovation: Hypotheses and some preliminary findings
א
.
The role of transformational leadership in
)
,2003
(
Jung, et..al
\"
نא B
:
] ز،LM $ א )* !
! א
א عא! ?-N 5 * }4و (= * ?<
J
א א %אد
"\ \ /א ! א ^
و[!
.
_
t
*!
^_
?Y ن D
.
32
- N $א )* = . =B-$58א F(-$אو! J
عא א ? 5א !c ? |^ [S
\"#$ א %د א ن
"\
א
*) א!א \
\"(
)*
\"#$ د א% א ??F* [א\"* ن6 א
(
-
د,א
,2003
Kark, et..al
نא B
\"
The Two Faces of Transformational Leadership:
Empowerment and Dependency
_^ \1!]
)
.
\"
)
_^ 1 mJ
א
[S A ] ن
=و
\"#$ د% א
[S A ] ن
ً
ً
cd$
وF * א F(? )* = و
\"#$ א %د א F ^|
א F [S 1 ^_ א ن mJ
(
* א #$5!%א
.א "\7
.
$ אو f gא F(-$
1
76
.
"\ Aא x$ \" -
א.ن
.
(
)
א,د
)
Politis,
א tzوv m
א\" א د! % *$د א ن*= $א FBg !b$
א مא אو 5 1א & ;$
"\א*=
د $א %د א د و
E D#$א t (D g
אو ،دא 1א مא
)
(
אو
א %C1 (5א ، -$ZאوJאد J %
(
0 B$
א
MLQ
(
א. B-$5
\"#$ א %د א د ! [S
!K
نא B
\"
Transformational and Transactional Leadership
2002
.
!
، *E
( א
-
_^ \1!]
)
for Performance
\"
! 1 \"$;5א
!مb$;
א ^ / -N w %? د אM 9 س
Bass
52
%? د אY [S !
!K \ وg
& ;$א5
5;$א אو =
، [ אو -=،א 5א ، b ?M 9و =/א\" $א א*42$وS( * cd1 س و א*42$
(
8 D א 8 5א א-N 5 س א*42$ z] =-$
א 0אد א س א -
.
Mykytyn,et..al,1994
אو ،c N $אو D5وm
& ;$א f g ، 1 5א z] =-$א
)
س*= א\"
א
) و?9
(
*
)
وو!o
F א ! א\"oد [S و) LM $
\D - ، b א ?M V אوc N
$ א5 1 אو
א
א
د,א
نא B
\"
Leadership, Culture and Performance:
\"
[S !
!
. %א د [S9C 6
$ א
The Case of the New Zealand Public Sector
.
K"\[ و$* \"] - cd
[S9 -$;5 אوigS א
\
_^ \1!]
Multifactor Leadership
% \" $5[ אS9
،
)* \ א ! א
\"(
Craig & Gustafson, 1998
= [ )* "\عm\"5א
)
Bass, 1985
Questionnaire
(
.
)
1345
ن \" -
(
א ً *)
] \"$;* A ن א!א LM $
dUو
!
"\
ز
-N * .
.
ًא
*!
.
[S9א% \" $5
9 /و <C$א B54אو 8 א!
א \"#$ א %د F
^|
T
] ^A نو
ً
ً
53
א?9
F
(
. دא 1א ;d*!b$
א x
א7 א !
!K
1998
د,א
.
Strategies used by Followers
\"
Krishnan,
)
نא B
J
א אد
\"$;5*) א
Influencing the Transformational Leadership:
\"
)* א!א \
\"(
)
א!5
.
(
* א #$5!%א
7\" -N 5א
_^ \1!]
א
ط
.
96
LM $ن ] [S A א\ و
א\" א د! % *$د א*=
وq
א
مא !b$
; ن
א
7\" %E -$* * o
oא$;o 5ل -א %אد^ . 4 . د א@ F /
א
!
א
.
(
س *
F 5א د! ? و
.
Multifactor
ً *
.
)
2
6
ـ
(
)
8
? ،v b
)(3 ; א א!א ) @ א א ! אE 3 * c] ن
^
.
& א א, א% 7א א, א ? W
& א א, א% 7א א, א ? W
\"#$ א א %د אو
& א א, א% 7א א, א ? W
& א א, א% 7א א, א ? W
W WW W
.
س [ \ ]!1אو ; ،א א ! B# א ?]
FBg א= א% *) [!Zد
\"#$ א %د א د 4 <C
*) f g
2
]!R
א!א
"\ \ א7
:
.
وא * א %د \"l 9 *
א42$
:
א!א ? *) f g
و و אو (
* א א ! א-N 5 ;א א \
o
j ?א
د א ( 5-א
J
.
.
א _^ -N 51 א¢ m
1
54
א! J
عא
\" \"#$ 4 א %د א <
_^ R $ @א א ! א א _^ \ Fg .
.
!%
.
-ن
א\" א[ !* .
א
د
א
8. / -N
ود א
$ א
.
א א!אن
د !-$
*1 d o אو
.
%د!? 94 א! א ?د\}
8- N $ א \ و! J
א عא
_^ 1 mJ
!א א ;
א !
א 0א "\
و
א א نو } Q
د ; \ ³و \"#$ א %د
א א ! א ن@
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
55
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
@?—???Ua?—???Ua
@?—???Ua@?—???Ua
@
sUbrUaUbrUa
sUbrUasUbrUa
@
p@@@@@@@
pa?a‹u⁄aë@?O?‹ĐUapa?a‹u⁄aë@?O?‹ĐUa
pa?a‹u⁄aë@?O?‹ĐUaa?a‹u⁄aë@?O?‹ĐUa
s
W WW W
?
? א4
א4
3
(
1
(
ـ
3
)
ـ
W WW W
(
4
ـ
3
?
? א4
א4
v אو אB4
vو' אو אB4
و'
א, א ? ?Z א, א ? ?Z
)
v
? ?Z
א, א א, א ? ?Z
W WW W
3
8
W WW W
3
(
א, א
אد ق 0א, א
אد ق 0
)
ـ
9
W WW W
אאאא
א, دא א א {NA N א א4 {2א א, دא א א {NA N א א4 {2א
א, دא NAא א {N א א4 {2א א, دא NAא א {N א א4 {2א
)
3
ـ
6
(
W WW W
א? B4, ل 67א ,د ?6و א א אود ل 67א ,د ?6و א? B4, א א אود
א? B4, ل 67א ,د ?6و א ل 67א ,د ?6و א ? B4,א אود א א אود
3
3
)
ـ
(
א T B4א ' a 6א? P &4א T B4א ' a 6א? P &4
W WW W
W WW W
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
56
* c `א
)`* i #$* \"] * F ? אg ، xd 5 ! א¥
)
3
W W W W
1
(
ـ
!!!!!!!!?
?!!!!!!!!א4
א4
?!!!!!!!!
?!!!!!!!! א4
א4
)* i #$ אR!d ، * -N 5א
.
ًS $;
F` `
8، و
`
? )-`m `-N 5 אT `
ول !b$א*`- . d
)* ; $ذ kא א ،c
* ، xd 5*; א א
tz א
*(
.
^
، gو*;$
א
.
;M ط
?³ =D א \
Z ZZ Z
(
W W W W
3
)
א
ً D %!دZ * غ/! "\א א ! א.
א -$
(
2
7 אi K
` o Vא! א9 ` אوd
T
F 4<C$ م =( 6 [\"$
אو ? א א
א-N 5
ن ?` ?
? ?Z ? ?Z
)
`*.F א
? ?Z ? ?Z
א
؛ ``
(D א
)
و
א% B$`` 7
<C``$א ``B54و ؛8 א
``
<`` `` "\ א %د ` א \"#$
`!b$مא ذو `k
א f`gאLd `5
א "\8D`/
אو ،8` #$
و v
م
א `!b$
d
"\א א ! א 1א! Jא
؛و
F(-$ אو
``
دאD
E D#$؛ א
و
؛
(
و]?D ` 8
א! Jא عא 8- N $
)
عא Iא! J
57
8DU\"`* )`*
5 א$# = אو%!g \ وB?
DU\"* )*
d Kو
א
، 8
. cd;
o$$
א *א، d M 9 ?m\"
%و א] N 6
8D ( 4 א 1 $
?`m\"
ً و ` -[ ً D`/8
` !-$א د `
tz א
mDא
،ً ` - ً وD 4ً א
$9אو
R!d
`] دF` `[S א
*\" 5 אn
! 6
7 Ld 5א אz] نא-
9 "\א ]אN * אdT
d ?
ً و ً [د D/ وdD/\" c$d
"\. !o
و [ ،א\" א
א و [א\" א - % ] N
.
א o ،دو % ] Nو d-xg *!
א א
?
\
.
;D
א _^ ل\" "\/אو ]4
=
=` K _^ !`-א % ] `Nو ` 6
`Y
^ و% ] N 6 א/\"
o )* D $b5א
` ن- `
!* .
` א `
د א `
ود א `
*`) `
` א!א
v` - C
7
)
` א!א -$
\"($ن
-$u
א!א
אو .
\ -$
د! ?] אو
(
u
(
ـ
3
(
)
1
)
% אزو
א!`l
لو
. و
ن ` `-
!*
.
` א `
`/ .
ود א אb$5 א א
0+F
)
(
ـ
4
3
و'
و'
W W W W
و'
و'
א B4אB4
א B4אB4
א ! א אد *D د! ? ![و ،ند א .
א
ود
א
`/ `
v
v אو v אو
80
א
(
(
58
Q`$(* ،% `x$א `;=x ` א %אزو אو
`-ن `
!*
.
א
ود א /. אb$5
)
(
لو !o
د د
)
3
1
ـ
د دد د
د د
.
א
0 / ود א +
ن -
*!
(
د د
ز 4א ز 4א
د د
د د
د د
16
אE 5
אو7
-B$
6
13
א@ %
אو ! א M
14
<<
א@(-
ود
2
2
5
17
و! א
8 א
13
ود א
א
5
17
ز 4א ز 4א
1
אB3?&4אB3?&4
ز 4א ز 4א
א B3?&4אB3?&4
א K $ :אK $ :
א K $ :א K $ :
ز 4א ز 4א
-$ אد0 אو! א
אאאא
א B3?&4אB3?&4
אB3?&4אB3?&4
8
4
8
9
6
6
!
;"\ א
د א
6
אو ! א M
7
3
אو ! א M
5
)
ـ
3
א, دא א א {NA N א א4 {2א א, دא א א {NA N א א4 {2א
(
W W W W
NAא دא א, א {N א א4 {2א א, دא א א {NA N א א4 {2א
50
ع ?א
ع ?א
30
39
21
א د K $ :אB3?&4
60
א لو!l
3
ـ
2
؛و
؛
=- א T
؛و
א\"$;5
1א !23א א42$5א دא 1 א!א "\?m
א\" د !
و
א. *!V
א 8- $
(
.
و
(
- א
؛
د א
א
ود א
)
59
ـ
لو !o
3
2
(
:
)
دא 1 1א !23א א42$5א /6و א!א
@%? v
?%
30
ـ
18
50
40
10
16.7
א ;, א
Q4&$ א א
30
QI א
א2{ 4
א @F
ـ
?%
%
B Bא א
)
(
B א B א
11.7
~ ?N
41.7
25
41
30
51
7
1
B pא Bא&4 pא א&4
41.7
23.3
ل م د
? 2 &3
14
25
-
د< א,
-
2
23.3
14
6
10
1.7
%? v@
87
13
v
%?
53.33
8
?N
5
52
1 ? ?א
? 1 ? ?א
?
5
1 ? ?א
?1 ? ?א
?
32
16
א
vB א B $[ B א B $[
vB א B $[v B א B $[
c,"\אد
L 6J *L 6J *
23.3
!
10
%? v@
23.3
5
15
10
ـ
14
א
11
א
?%
14
5
?%
18.3
א
15
7
א? ? 1
א? ? ? 1
?
@%? v
א7 7א
?Iא ?I א
4
11.67
?I Iא ? א
10
ـ
א
5
א7 7א
@%? v
ـ
26.67
10
?%
~ ?N
א
15
א? ? 1
א? ? ?1
?
8.33
21
~ ?N
3
)
50
*)
(
وאc] - \g
ـ
30
.
2
א,Aد Kא,AدK
ـ
א,Aد Kא,AدK
15
35
??$
fg
= [ )*
)*
18 D/\"
-42$! א א23 א א$# = א LM $
F x$;-
א لو!l
دא 1 א!א
.
^_
4
ود א /
60
71.7
F<\"# א5
ن
!
א م! אو !l8 א א E ل !
א
و]"\ *
%
*)
"
و س 5א ??g
"\و א^_
א? j
د 7א ( 5-א .
א
ود א/
i $
42$w
و- 1
F<\"# א5
ن ??1 $
}
א \"8- $ -;$ ; و
F<\"# -
.
א? j
د 7א ( 5-א .
א
ن F
!1،
ً *) א %?Vאو7
*;\"$
91.67
F *) אx$;5
.א
*! %א . *!Vא "\ D Uא@
%
א? j
د 7א ( 5-א .
א
ود א /
א%?V
.
و
א $
(?
ً ?
\"]
d
?9 !
E
א ?D \
(1
.
15
)* =[ )* cd$*!9 %!* ?وא
)
z *) אc]
5
\2 ; و،
B C1
. *!V א%!*
42$w i $
و*
! Hعא "\א %?V1א ( 1
w א א!א .
15
35
%
ـ
3
א
אود א د `-$
)
6
א? B4, ل 67א ,د ?6و א אود א א? B4, ل 67א ,د ?6و א א אود
W WW W
(
`q ، א!א !`/ * z` D $ "\*`
.
א@ א
! دא 5? 1 1א א
` אو5
א ` ل\" @א ض 2
א? B4, ل 67א ,د ?6و א אود א א? B4, ل 67א ,د ?6و א א אود
.
.
.
א!אع \"m\"w אb$5
2
אو אo7 א -
(Q$ ،אو =Mא* l אو 5 7 ،אو ،א ! א )* t N א Q
l *\" 5א$5 א
א?
1
:
א!] م! £אR
%!g وو، d;
وو ، dg\"mو?
א
، ، dدو[d$
?! ، d1و*("\
d- -
-$د .
،س [ %אد ]8و
א$ 7
^א د qא7
א )* \"-u 0א (& $
?
אو u . FBgل
א Sز* 7
\"
B אو و א
ل \" #
א
ل -($
=o d188 وو ،א!
*"\\"mא ! א ع
אQ x$;5
אو ً
61
)
)
(
وً :
(
لو א ;c א
ً K
)
(
*2$
:
?)-
5
)
(
*2و[! و oJ$9 א %د!? ? و %د! *$א
א
?? \ -
אذ
و m 1و ،א ! א
.
א 1
5
،
:
]8
<Eo <Sא0
$ 7א
وd
\ -?
;M
F
.
)
!
و `d
)
.
(
)
א ً ? 7
16
)
(
39
ً ~!
;` M
)
?
د `
`
\"#$ א %د ` א ; "\
(
`?
i $
*א42$
?)-
?)-
:
2
אf B
א ;c
س` א `\ ` "\&
א8 -V
(
א
א@
א ! א ن?، 1س א Q \" $
ع
و- 1
dא$;5
?]
.
.
א ً ? 7
(
)
``* i` #$ v !$;`¥
ل
س\"[ * -אو _^ 5 .א، c ;!b$
א א = م
? אد%
! א5
)
! 5;$א س *
?` $ *;g \"$
אو א42$5א
; D$د * 6 . d
و،ً D
ً و
#/א \"Yאو جذ <^ m D
א!`` Jא عא ``- N $אو )-?``$58،
و]``"\
א !` א 1א ``"\
و
(
.
عא `` Iא!`` J
F(-$ א
و،
E D#$
و א،
`
(D א
،
،
)``* =``
د D א
و،
א% B$ 7
א$ 7
و
،L !! א 4!! {2א
)-?$
:
<C$א 8 B54 א
אو)-?$5
،v
&4א4 {2 א
.
0אEo <S<
1
"\ א %د א \"#$
. ]4;D
$و א ! א א6 *42$
$ 7\ א
)
Likert,1961
8]و
(
.
)
א ! Jא
2
.
62
،
3
א {N |aא א?6
.
(
8`- $ א \"5`;$א
.
)
،
)* \"-uو ،א42$5א]8
و،
א `-
אو-?$5
`
`
ود א `
!? ً و
\"2 c (#$ א ?ز $o
א !* ?وא7
% 1
)* x$
*) ("\
س 5א ن
و
.
1
2
3
4
5
55
)
ً، m^ ،vو 1z`g1
א 1 =.
!
5א oא0 א! س t א$
!1 ذ 5 x$
و
)
(
א
س 5א ن و
(
:
:אوE ?N
אو?N
−
1
:אو?N
g
5
אوE ?N
42$
8
6
10
8
א 1
א 1
א 1
א 1
א 1
7
א
I
אد
وcm
$ א
:
`
\"#$ א %د א "\
?
א5
א, $ :
א` = $;5
א, ~ :
א
د
א
?2 א
א~4
Iد א
;? א
א5
WI א
;I א
?
א5
:
?$Jعא א
א
عא א
א$
`!1
cm
* א42$5
א` $
,א א א
א JאN
א
I אد
א 1
8
8
א 1
63
i #$
$ = אd; d$ !وo و، d
"\
،و
#1? א q
!1 d
m 1 א ! א، وR ]!אc !
،%!-$ * و2 \" א/"\א ?* _^ ل
]!
و، d - و، ?\"j f g )* ،8M gJ א$# = אQ 6$
q و،
\" -( א
% $
א
.
dM אo^ )* R!?א
RS$9
? P &4 אa 6': אT B4 ?אP &4 אa 6': אT B4א
(
? P &4 אa 6': אT B4 ? אP &4 אa 6': אT B4א
7
)
ـ
W W W W
:
b5א
.
D$
=* *
!مb$;5א5 אس < o ! *) دC$
? $7 א
دא 1 1א\"* !* 5 1 א!א
א
א$ 7
= #$
، d
\"Yو א ! א جذm 1 א ض $92
אl * و، M gJא
-$o7"\א م M gJא مE@ אL*
!b$ אq f g
مא
(
)
SPSS
Q
\"l א. F b$*
א
$ 7? א -l o ? ل\" @אو
Cronbach Alpha
-
א
(
)
Kolmogorov Smirnov
$9
8
.
ANOVA
:
8 $ א
?
س- ً T
!
!K q
1 *א ! א و ? ) oJ= אo )*
א5
;@א1 א ?7אو
א$9
F
)
!oلو = Kא $ !b$
مא
!د *
אو ? ;$5 א
= Kא!?7א
א<،א
א 1\"$
*;\"$
و
.
tz
; א ]-א
.
[= *)
–
2.33
64
1
א %אد و < )* i #$
? m\"$
B C1
)* D
! oא5 אو
.
3.67
3.66
–
2.33
*)
و אZJ $ , א
א
W W W W
` + cdא . ` 5 `;
cdא. ` 5
E`9 )`* %1` دJ` ! א
`[` دB א5 ` س =` o `y ،
cd
/ `$9
א
، 0 gJאو
%?V *و# א
(
(
c
c אق6 א c אق6 א
ـ
3
)
8
س א . و*"\\"m
.
? \"?P
$ 70 *=אEx ¥
ن
)
א ;
\2 ،و
(
Qא *`
Nאi# 5
2
،
(
&&&&
.
)
(
א א,
אد $א, א
אد $
[! \"o*) !و م
א\"[ د
65
B 1 א دאo د
=* * 1? نk z 1 m^ ،1 א א5 س F k -$ אو ط
74 ^_ ["\% א
\"]9 ، ^_ و
.
c} א و
Cronbach Alpha
7 אd D;
3() ن
)* )(
.
;
אو %אدJ J
א م\" א ?\"$5# א
Nא!lلو
א
.
(
3
(
Alpha ≥ 0.60
. 7\" *
)
!
Alpha
א لو!l
3
cא5 ? "\
א ص
ـ
)
ـ
3
9 8א! א ق$ 7 אد ;
א7 * *= <
? D
و
)
(
3
86.6
(α
I
)
@
B$ א
א
Iد א
@F א
א, $ :
4
3
א عא א
,א א א
א JאN
89.9
WI א
88.5
7
5
א ~4? 2 א
2
89.1
;I א
1
א, ~ :
د
א
82.8
85.9
;? א
אv; K $ :
78.2
?$Jعא א
6
i $
-1
א د$ 7 ن < =* *
و` ً 1
2003
3
)* ??$א!`l
لو
fg
)
(
K
ــ
)
`
(
% !`[
82.6
3
א ! א ضא }i K % אد א
ٍل ` ` < =`* w * % \" % אد א$? ?z] B א S* *
Sekaran,
ل !
و
?` ` < =`* * ` ن
(
)
1`"\א$
` B אS* ` * F `$1
` אLM `$ א <
(*^ _^ 4
و]"\ *
.
8`- N $ !J
א عא
(
`v
!
.
! א א! J
א
دو
א
I $א! J
عא
] ?
)
i` $
`* `*
89.9
`
א \"#$ א %د ` ; "\
]`"\
)
89.1
!
4<C$ א
(
)
! % *v
،
E D#$ א
8 B5א
-
(
88.5
v` g
` B `- [
`
±`g
دن
א% B$ 7
! ن
i $
-1
S
`- 1
(
)
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
.
82.8
(D א
`-
d
.
78.2
66
??$ن [
fg
$
\
א42$5א Fنn $
ز
"\
ط ]zא א$97
و ،א!א m1 LM $א$9
q ! 1א oא 0א$9 א!א LM $
\"m\"* )* i #$ א ضא }
9
(
(
ـ
)
Kolmogorov -
W WW W
)
لو !o
3
.
ـ
(
ط
! Dא7
8 $
*F 6
و $ ،אو 5;$א א ! א א42$
E* ط
אC
k ذ ?( و
8 42$5א ! א א
دI א
B $8 אL ز אL$
2
2.933
0.116
3
0.092
, $ :א
2.987
;I א
,~
:א
0.087
G
? א
Kolmogorov – Smirnov
F@ א
Sig.
2{ 4א
0.092
3.295
0.086
2.718
7
?$Jعא א
א
1.253
5
B $8 ز Lא L$א
;? א
4
WI א
وאF \g
8 א!אد
(
3.295
.
)
)
א
א 5 $-! .א \"5;$א \"]و l 5א ?z? M gJא !
Sekaran, 2003
0.05
)
(
? *) א =( oJ8
(
,א א
א N אJ
0.058
B $8 אL ز אL$
ز\" $א ;Q
\
fg
.
<
8
G
.163
K
0
1.119
0.05
6
א
67
)
?£ d n \
א!Zد%
א د$ 7 n نو
.
אو tz
5;$א ، $ אو
א ! א א42$א ط* F ! l
ل7 !
א
אو]z
68
pbîš‹?Ua@Šbjn‚aë@?îUznUa@w?bn?pbîš‹?
Ua@Šbjn‚aë@?îUznUa@w?bn?
@
pbîš‹?Ua@Šbjn‚aë@?îUznUa@w?bn?bîš‹?
Ua@Šbjn‚aë@?îUznUa@w?bn?
@?—???Ua@?—???Ua
@?—???Ua?—???Ua
@
@
E@@@@@@@
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
Eia‹Uaia‹Ua
p@@@@@@@
Eia‹UaEia‹Ua
ـ
W WW W
)
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
(
א o N , $ h אo N , $ h
א oN,$h oN,$h
1
(
?
? א4
א4
)
2
?
? א4
א4
4
ـ
4
א, א Q % א, 3 א א ;c, א L א א ,ز א Q % א, 3 א א ;c, א L ز א
ـ
א, א Q % א, 3 א א ;c, א L א א ,ز א Q % א, 3 א א ;c, א L ز א
)
3
4
(
א, א ,
א
W WW W
W WW W
,א א,
אאאא
69
ـ
.
4
` א D`/\" א M `g
J אQ `
1
(
!!!!!!!!?
?!!!!!!!!א4
4א
)
W WW W
!!!!!!!!?
?!!!!!!!! א4
4א
D z] R!d
אא
`
` "\ א %د ` א \"#$
\"`gل
א `¢مא LM $א `!b$
ض = ^_
א ! א دא ` 1
*) S9ل ? = Kא0 ،
$ 7 אd
1ز
;M
`
א5
א ?7א`1
F
.
? LM $ אض و[! q
)
?"\
،و
א\"$;`5
!` $ א ط و@;
*و ،א ! א אً 142$
אو
; Qא\"?5 אو t א
!`o
لوא ` ،و qא `!b$
مא
د א
` א
ود א
:
ن
($ א
ز\" $א
Q % א, 3 א Lא א ;c, ز אQ % א, 3 א Lא א ;c, ز א
Q % א, 3 א Lא א ;c, ز Q %א א, 3 א Lא א ;c, ز א
70
fg א
ـ
)
(
2
4
W WW W
א, א Q % 3א, א א ;c, אL א א ,ز א Q % 3א, א Lא א ;c, ز א
א, א Q % 3א, א א ;c, Lא א א ,ز א Q % 3א, א Lא א ;c, ز א
I &Sא لא א I &Sא لא א
L 6J *1??B pא 4 %א L 6J *1??B pא 4 %א
؟؟؟؟
W
L 6J *1??B pא 4 %א L 6J *1??B pא 4 %א
W W W W
? ? ? J pא J p ? ? ? NאN
א Aא Aא Aא A
لو لو لو لو
!Q
?!%
?& p
)
A\" ; 1\"$א <C$א 8 B54 א
1
4
(
N א
و*;\"$
א5
@F א
א ?:א+
א&7
lJJ
ـ
4
1
( :
لو !l ?m\"* \"] - ،
ـ
.
א ?7א1
א\" $א1
;@א و
א
א5
)
% Dو*;\"$ ،א ]-و
א ?7א1
;@א و
لא?; א א ) ]z o
ن $א
!o
لو
H
2
1
0.62
k - א5 . *( نc א
)* \"-u 0
لو?;5א kو "\
א!5
4.37
א $אR لو?;5א % ! k
!5 אE -$
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
LIJ ?LIJ ?
k - *( ن
L
. =א $;* ? ? k א5;?لو
D$א ل!50
4
4.32
2
LIJ ?LIJ ?
0.73
LIJ ?IJ ?
k - *( ن. F * א
L
0.61
4.36
4.40
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
4.19
1
5
v
\ [ دK cd - ?
7
F* א
ً9 * k لو?;5א
"\א !51
L
LIJ LIJ
LIJ IJ
????
0.67
3
k - = 5( ن א5;$
^[ ع %! k א5;?لو
$-$א!5
4
? LIJ ?IJ
3.83
0.45
6
0.75
م
4.18
7
(*^ = D
لو?;5א k
=-א!5
k - *( ن. F * א
3.75
1.03
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
6
0.71
. E -$ אi K F * א5;?א لو
!5 אx
7
0 אد א
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
71
fg א
*
5 ،
4.40
(
3.75
? F א@;
?
oא % D 0א
`
"\
و_ 8 ;g ? \"$w
)
)
"\ Aא <C$א 8 B54 1\"$
? א
)
4.18
.
م א @; 8א ? \"$5א
(
"\
^
ذ
ود א
!l
א 4لو
د א
א
? cd
!
.F* א )
א!5
.
ود א
.
4.40
א
א5
F $ن *;\"$
م (=
.
ً D
ن*
د א
א
ود א
= D
!oאً ? ?
\"g\"-Tن
א *F
(*^
cd1 8 $ 0% و1 و D(
و
.
t 5א
وم א
א ?7אR
د א
א
ن\" א
ود א
.F و?;5א
*F א
(*^
J
)
א!5
* א ? \"$5א@; 8
5
؛م א
א ~ Kא ~ K
א ~ Kא ~ K
W W W W
.
% Dو*;\"$ ،א ]-و
א5
)
4
(
2
ـ
;@א و
א ?7א1
لא?; א א ) ]z oS
א\" $א1
ن $א
? ? J pא J p ? ? NאN
L 6J *1??B pא 4 %א L 6J *1??B pא 4 %א
א, ~ :
א, ~ :
? ?? ?
;Iא ;I א
? ? J pא J p ? ? NאN
&Sא لא I Iא &Sא لא א
؟؟؟؟
E$אAא ود,Aد Kא E$ א אAא ود,AدK
72
لو?;5א
Eא دو!5
fg،
ـ
4
p &?
+א:? א
lJJ
)
C 4א
لو !o
( :
א
A\" ; 1\"$ א
% B$ 7א
2
\"$;*و
א5
;@א و
א ?7א1
I א
&7א
c, B4א
(D א
;I א ;I א
N א
;I א ;I א
L
* R $א $-و لو?;5א k
"\א م!5
, ~ :א
, ~ :א
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
, ~ :א: ~ ,א
? ?
? ?
F@ א
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
3.79
k* F* אk א5;?لو
!5 אx
0.78
11
L
12
1
LIJ ?LIJ ?
0.52
F * א5;?א = ® لو
"\א م!5
= [ )* d$ [ * c$
א ( 1א ?
!א نو . 4(D$
0.88
=- א لu . %! 5 אS( 5 *= * א$
L
4.00
3.75
LIJ ?IJ ?
10
LIJ ?LIJ ?
0.88
- אcd
g.v K
2
LIJ ?IJ ?
6
9
ن\" * א
"\د
3.89
8
3
14
. א5 لو?;5א kא * F
!5 אx
ً7\" g ج$K S( * dD/\" M
%! 5 אS( - "\א! ^ لg R $ א
L
LIJ ?IJ ?
LIJ ?LIJ ?
3.73
0.84
0.87
אRא0 ]!< א
%!
!lא
L
LIJ ?IJ ?
?
15
k א5;?لو
"\א م!5
5
? ?
1.03
3.15
? ?
13
אא א /
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
7
3.68
CCCC
LIJ ?IJ ?
LIJ ?LIJ ?
?
א% D 0 אo
? א
.
!1
F ? ;@א
د א
א
)
3.15
4.00
*
5 ،
م א @; 8א ? \"$5א
(
`
"\A 1\"$
ود א
.
(D א
A\" 1\"
% B$ 7א
% B$ 7א
)
א (D
_ *;\"$
(
و
3.71
(
^
4
2
!l
א 4لو
ـ
+
א ?:א+א ?:א+
0.52
)
א ?אوR
3.71
* ? t
و7א_ 8 ;g ? \"$w
א5
)
.
"\
"\
= [ )* d$ [ * c$
? (D$
א ( 1א 4 . !
א نو
*F א = ® لو?;5א
!5
[ م
4.00
(
א
* א? \"$5
5
(
73
fg
ض D5*) א c] N
*; \"$و )*و 5אdo
!א %د ^ نو (D$א 4 . ?
8 ;g ? \"$w %4
ً -Mאد
\"
ود א
.
אو 9
ل -אز ^? ?د? F;K _^ t
ن
א5
*B א
وg
د א
א
*) א)(-5 אو
.
و?;5א F
م [
)
x $א ن!5 א
"\
]?z
;D
و
.
א ?7אو م א @; 8אR
tم א א5
لو?;5א
א!5
% 1\ g -1
و?;5א . F
)
א!5
א ?7אR
1.03
)
(
x$
و م א @; 8א ? \"$5א *
5
^7
)
אא א /.
ن
א5
! א
J
א אد
* . Fא\"$;5 *ن \" x
א
و
5א ./ אא א *F א
z
نو ¤
م א،
] A
אt 5
(
3.15
* ? t
Iذ kن
و
א ?אوR
d
* ^ Fא د1 * A )(3 7 אא א *) \"-u
د א
א
ود א
. Qذ k ; אو
ن
.
ً D
ن*
د א
א
ود א
! c(P א !5א
9 g
*) א א م! وdo\"$ 1 5
א אدJ cd /
و
.
م (=
*
א (D
א% B$ 7
و
F $ن *;\"$
.
"\A "\1
*; وdM
? ?
i ~ iא ~ א
*1??B pא 4 %א *1??B pא 4 %א
א : $ ,א, $ :
? ?
&Sא لא I א I &Sא لא א
Iد א Iא د
? ? ? J pא J p ? ? ? NאN
)
3
(
.
ـ
؟؟؟؟
א\" $א1
?;5א
א!5
لو !o
lJJ
)
ـ
4
( :
א
3
;@א و
א ?7א1
و*;\"$
א5
A\" ; 1\"$ א
א$ 7
3.93
0.77
N א
I א
אc, B4
&7א
3
C 4א
+א:? א
? ?
, $ :א: $, א
? ?
F@ א
L
p &?
LIJ ?IJ ?
16
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
LIJ ?LIJ ?
0.58
1
4.25
C ?C ?
k - א5;? = * لو1 د. *( ن
=* $א!5
LIJ ?IJ ?
21
LIJ ?LIJ ?
L
7
0.80
3.70
F*
20
8
F* * אv*
. 1D א5;?لو
E$א م!5
? ? C
א ع@ oא b ? لو?;5א
!5 אc$d
3.63
0.79
19
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
5
0.68
R ? ]!אm\"
א5;? و لو$- א
!5 א ص¤
F* =- א
3.89
LIJ ?LIJ ?
18
0.72
3.87
17
6
LIJ ?IJ ?
-l * אv *
. %א5; ! אو w مE$
و
v *
L
L
مB אc, B4 א مB אc, B4א
0.46
م
א ?:א+א ?:א+
א ?:אא ?:א+
+
Cو &7א &7א4 Cא א4
? LIJ ?IJ
0.65
2
!5 אt!
L
23
LIJ ?LIJ ?
0.82
F * *و ? א g א5;?لو
!5 אcdD$
k*F* ً b ً * -$]א5;?א لو
22
LIJ ?LIJ ?
4
3.92
LIJ ?IJ ?
)
א لو!l
4
?m\"
ـ
(
و7א_ 8 ;g ? \"$w
א5
)
v *
4.25
.
\"
=*
\"
ود א
*
5 ،
F ? ;@א
د D א
4.25
.
א$ 7
(
*;\"$
"\A\" 1
`
)
3.63
? א
(
!1
א$ 7
3
د D א
م א @; 8א ? \"$5א
"\A 1\"$
ن\" א
و
د
א
א
א ?א R
و?;5א F
ود א
.
)
א ن!5
.
)
م אאt 5
و]?z
א x$
א ?7אR
F
0.58
? t *
(
و م א @; 8א ? \"$5א *
5
75
! tz אو =* $א
T
א]"\ * و *.F א =( $ -אو 1 B א
\"$;5א
v
% 1\ g -1
א!א o^ v
.
\"
fg א
*v*
. 1D א5;?لو
!5א
مאE$
א
)* vMS*E
* =* =(
ود א
د D א
אد0
(%0 D
* ،Fو]"\ *) א)(-5 א
ن
* =* $ א
א *F
"\A "\1
.
و (= *? \"$
.
*= א x$
("\
ن
د א
א
1D F*E$ *
.
ود א
.
א$ 7
F و?;5א
3.63
)
א!5
Iذ kن
و
م א، t א5
א ?7אR
)
? t *
א ?א
R
و
(
8 ;g ? \"$w %49 אو
)
*B א
א5
"\
(
*F א
و م א @; 8א ? \"$5א *
5
0.79
\"$;* نF $
م =(
و
.
(
؟؟؟؟
E$א,Aد Kא E$ א א,AدK
W
א,Aد Kא E$א,Aد Kא E$
ن $א
لא?; א א ) ]z o
H
I &Sא لא א I &Sא لא א
אL אא א
א ?7א1
76
+א:? א
WI ?א WI ?א
W
c, B4א
&7א
אدJא
p &?
C 4א
3.85
-d5
lJJ
24
و*;\"$
5א
4
א
;@א و
( :
1א7? א
F@ א
WI ?א I ?א
)
لو !o
4
LIJ ?LIJ ?
L
LIJ ?IJ ?
N א
I א
y ? x ; ! אx$ k א5;?لو
"\א م!5
1!
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
2
J! *) א
E* i #$ F * א
?ز
4.11
27
0.85
4.12
LIJ ?IJ ?
LIJ ?LIJ ?
0.87
L
1
0.65
4.43
26
=-
0.81
28
LIJ ?IJ ?
L
LIJ ?IJ ?
LIJ ?LIJ ?
L
0.91
x$ kא *k* F لو?;5א
"\א م!5
25
لو?;5א ! k
א * Fس @-א ?و
!54 אB
3.85
مB אc, B4 אB אc, B4א
k* F* אx$ k א5;?لو
"\א م!5
א ?:א+א ?:א+
0.99
LIJ ?IJ ?
5
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
3.80
F ? ;@א
!54 אB
א
ود א
د א
)
ـ
4
4
وא\g
fg،
و
"\A "\1
Cو &7א &7א4 Cא א4
&7א &7א C 4و א C 4אو
)
(
.
E D#$ א
*;\"$
א!lلو
dN
! k لو?;5א
4.43
`
م א @; 8א
(
* א? \"$5
5 ،
3.80
A\" 1\"$
? א
א E D#$
)
4.03
(
و
"\
א ?א R
?
% Dא א 0 o
!1
.
4.43
* ?J Fز D( c? -و 10% س @-א ?و
Bنو4
د א
א
"\?m
"\
.
ن \" [\"$
"\
א
y B i #$ F * א x$ k א5;?لو
א!5
[ م
א!א o^ v ! tz אو
ود א
.
% 1\ g -1
(
و7א_ 8 ;g ? \"$w
א5
.
)
=- س @-א ?و *F א
"\
و]?z
x$ א
(
.
)
א ن!5
tم א א5
א ?7אR
و?;5א F
0.65
و م א @; 8א ? \"$5א *
5
)
? t *
77
א;* V
v K
fg א
א5
8 ;g ? \"$w %49 אو
)
(
"\
(
و
? t *
)
0.99
و م א @; 8א ? \"$5א *
5
א ?א R
?! א x$
و] ?zא x $
tم א، א5
و?;5א . F
א ?7אR
.
د א
א
ود א
)
!5א
ً D
*ن
A\" 1\"
= [ )*
3.80
E D#$ א
.
\"$;* نF $
م (=
د א
א
ل -אز ^? x$ אو س @-א ?و %
ود א
e
? ? J pא J p ? ? NאN
W W W W
(
.
لو !l ?m\"* \"] - ،
?
;@א و
؟؟؟؟
א ?7א1
78
ـ
( :
I א
5
)
4
א
;@א و
N א
אc, B4
א&7
A\" ; 1\"$א F(-$ א
و*;\"$
א5
m لو?;5א k
¤א ص!5
F@ א
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
C 4א
?; ;? ? א ?א
?
!o
لو
?7א
p &?
1א
+א:? א
lJJ
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
7
0.92
3.90
4
ن (* .لو?;5א * m\" k -
"\א م!5
8
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
3
0.65
34
0.75
3.81
gS א¢
\"D
لو?;5א - k
!53 א س
3.84
0.67
?z D $ "\*"\א F* ? * ?א¹ ً א
33
35
LIJ ?IJ ?
LIJ ?LIJ ?
9
2
LIJ ?LIJ ?
=- =* \"
c
لو?;5א ! $ k
"\א م!5
0.51
v*F* ?? א
v
gS/ ¢ k - א5;? لو. *( ن
\"Dא ض!5
4.10
v \"b5 אv
gS
32
4.12
LIJ ?IJ ?
0.61
31
v
gS/ ¢ v
א5;?א لو
[א !5¹
LIJ ?IJ ?
4.04
LIJ ?IJ ?
L
L
10
0.68
3.80
i #$ ? אو زS [F*
37
0.81
3.98
?
\"D
! א5;?* و
LIJ ?IJ ?
D U\" אc] אودc]? ز
v
5
LIJ ?LIJ ?
4.03
LIJ ?IJ ?
LIJ ?LIJ ?
) k - *( ن. F *
LIJ ?LIJ ?
0.77
LIJ ?LIJ ?
36
4
^
iD$5 א د-= אF * k א5;?لو
!5? אm\"
مB אc, B4 אB אc, B4א
39
א
ود א
م
"\ Aא . F(-$ "\1
)
(
*;\"$
5
4
dN
!l
א لو
ـ
F* אn
LIJ ?LIJ ?
0.72
0.43
3.96
d
\" z
א ) N ¢2א\"dlא د
L
Cو &7א &7א4 Cאوא4
&7א C 4و &7א א C 4א
? LIJ ?IJ
6
א ?:אא ?:א+
و
+
38
3.96
4.12
v vא\"b5
= د gS 1 y لو?;5א
א!5
"\
"\
"\ Aא F(-$ 1\"$
)
F ? א@;
3.80
`
4.12
(
م א @; 8א
* א? \"$5
5 ،
(
.
3.96
c!
?
% Dא א
^ذ
\ g
!1
? א
)
79
0.61
وم
م א t א5
)
א @; 8א ? \"$5א *
5
v$;( tz אو
Rא7? א
(
א
.
.
*F א دא 5- "\? ¨1א F(-$ א \"4 ^_ *;$
ود א
x$ א
د א
و]?z
א ?א R
? t *
و
fg א
*F א لو?;5א
[א !5¹
אو 8 ;g ? \"$w %49
ز ?א] cאود ] cא "\D U
"\
א5
% א
% 1\ g -1
0.68
^? ز c? -وd[ T * ? . F(? F א
.
و م א @; 8א ? \"$5א *
5
א ?7אR
?w ; א x$ א v ! א *
c$
و
ً ?
א \"]7 . ^ c? -
و د ز ?^ ق *T) F א * [
7v
م א، אt 5
?!
و] ?zא x $
(
"\
א!א ^o
? t *
(
)
.
)
3.80
א ?א R
و
ً D
ن*
.
د א
א
ود א
.
"\A "\1
م(=
א F(-$
F $ن *;\"$
؟ ؟؟ ؟
א ?7א1
אA
&Sא م @ لא =א א
L 6JאAא ود,Aد Kא E$ *1 L 6JאAא ود,Aد Kא E$ *1
3k
%
?& p &? p
? ? ? ?
L 6JאAא ود,Aد Kא E$ *1 E$ א L 6JאAא ود,AدK *1
?$Jعא א ?$Jعא א
W WW W
א Aא Aא Aא A
لو لو لو لو
)
4
;@א و
% Dو*;\"$ ،א ]-و
א5
6
ـ
(
.
لو ? !l
80
lJJ
I $ א
ـ
\"$;*و
א5
אc, B4
عא !H
א ?7א1
;@א و
6
)
( :
א
4
!o
لو
א ?:א+
C
?$ א
I א
? C ?C
ع
?$Jא א ?$Jعא א
?& p
?$Jعא א ?$Jعא א
@F א
אC 4
א&7
C ? ?
Q $
D/"\אw x$ * ? d$ [ *\ א
1.24
C ? ?
C ?C ?
C
8- N $ אd ( ] . * 2 4א
אo
C
C ?C ?
C ? ?
o$
אJ
8
3.42
1.01
3.15
4
¢دא\"5א
S
!
אo
C ?C ?
1.05
C
C
7
ج$
!א J9= . -
א وא
? ? C
? C ?C
3
? ? C
0.91
1
2
و o gא ?F * $51
2
6
3.25
3.24
3.66
1.07
. א5
(
! . %אJאد %
!o
)
£אو א א א ذ E *S
8
א
.א 0אد -
zo 2 4א
אo
6
طY ! א-$
3.32
1.24
א
C ? ?
C ?C ?
و א א א ¢ D£אE 5
א *.F *.
א ¢ א5 و
3.51
1.33
C
7
3
C ? ?
C ?C ?
C
\" @ אduא S
!
א \ 9د
+
א ?:א+א ?:א+
&7א C 4و &7א Cא א4
و
Cو &7א &7א4 Cאو א4
0.77
3.40
Bم c,א BאB4 c,א אB4
م
Bم c,א א c, B4א Bא مB4
א ?:אא ?:א+
3.69
? LIJ ?IJ
1.23
L
Nא مd 1 *\" 5
و
LIJ ?LIJ ?
)
א$5"\ ? ;@א8 و م א *
5
א ?7אR
و
و_ 8 ;g ? \"$w
"\
3.69
א
א5
)
(
d1 Nא م*\" 5
\" @א و duא
S
!
א \ 9د
\ g
tم א א5
.
?
% Dא א
)
א و]z
א ?א R
(
? t *
!1
4
)
،
א@
? F ;
د א
א
ود א
ذ ^
3.15
`
ـ
6
(
.
? א
3.69
(
)
*;\"$
3.40
"\ Aא F(-$ 1\"$
"\
(
. عא Iא! J
dN
!l
א لو
م א @; 8א ? \"$5א *
5 ،
אن
F x$;5 אN
doو )*و
7^ d 1 *\" 5 א-N
و "\
א duא@ !\
1.23
= د ن
د א
א
ود א
= ? \"$;5
!$ א \" *;$ن
81
o$
-א 0אدJ א .
zo 2 4א
א o
\"
\"
o א ن ?(
و]"\ *
¢
8 ;g ? \"$w %49 אو
א5
*B א
)
3.15
(
و
1\ g -1
%
.
"\&
fg א
د א
א
ود א
F $ن *;\"$
م =(
\"$;w )(
?
N
do و )*وS
] ?zא ! $ ن
"\?
ً
.
و
ن
.
א!א
)
א ?א R
م א، t
א 5
و م א @; 8א ? \"$5א
;@א و
א ?7א1
,א א א
א JאN ,א א א
N אJ א
p &? p &?
* 1 1 * 1 1
p &?p &?
W W W W
K~ אK ~א
I א لאS& א I א لאS& א
E$ אE$ א
E$ אE$ א
* *
א א א,
א JאN ,א א א
א JאN
؟؟؟؟
? ? ? ?
א ~ Kא ~ K
L 6JאAא ود,AدK ود,AدK אAא L 6J
7
ـ
4
لو !l ?m\"* \"] - ،
)
.
(
א\" $א1
% Dو*;\"$ ،א ]-و
א5
82
و*;\"$
א5
;@א و
)
א ?7א1
7
^!gو ?א
אN א
لو !o
ـ
I א
c, B4א
( :
&7א
א
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
L
? م. ? א زوd
4
,
א N אJ,
א JאN
@F א
,
א א א א א א
( =P 6
ق 1و =-
?& p
lJJ
א ?:א+
אC 4
א א א א א א
7
3.85
L
א ل5"\ دא- $
2
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
3
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
0.87
א
§ &\"
4.01
. دد
7
! *و
LIJ ?LIJ ?
13
0.74
LIJ ?IJ ?
4.07
%!
!o 0 ? אc
! $ 4 ? سB
! 1 ز ? א ?و
12
LIJ ?IJ ?
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
L
0.86
4
3.95
11
L
LIJ ?LIJ ?
LIJ ?IJ ?
5
0.76
3.90
-d5 א א א א ذ£
אوS( 5א
10
16
)
xא g 5א )* *! 5א?9
3.64
0.99
C
? C ?C
? ? C
3.94
و
م
Bم c,א
א c, B4א Bא مB4
Bم א c, B4א Bא c, B4א
א C 4אو &7א C 4و &7א
0.51
א ?:אא ?:א+
&7א C 4و &7א Cא א4
+
א ?:א+א ?:א+
א 0א < . tو אو! א 0
!] א
-$oא
א7
0.86
3.89
$א^ ! . Aو
6
? LIJ ?LIJ
? LIJ ?IJ
L
1
4.22
0.71
8
15
14
? א
ـ
4
)
3.94
א لو!l
dN
)
. "\א א ! א 1א! J
א
7
(
א
ود א
د א
،
*;\"$
3.64
F ? א@;
^ذ
`
4.22
@א א! 5אو دא\"5א ل\"o\"5
א % .د א -$
* א? \"$5
5 ،
و_ 8 ;g ? \"$w
א ن ?* \"]و * F
"\
)
(
د א
א
.
(
? t *
tم א
.
א5
م א @; 8א ? \"$5א *
5
א5
א
!4b;$ %
|Jد Tא!o iM
b;$א א! 5אو دא\"5א @4 ل -
)
א
אز !?J %
T ($ق !o (= *;! J -$
אو عא ; "\
ون
4.22
; א
(
"\
(
?
% Dא א
\ g
^ذ
.
1\"$
"\ Aא F(-$
م א @; 8א
ود א
و
א ?7אR
0.71
)
و
א ?א R
83
8 ;g ? \"$w %49 אو
*Bא
)
!* *) א?9
F $ن *;\"$
م (=
"\א1
א5
)
3.64
(
و
)
"\
א ?א R
* ? t
א5
א نJאد 4} %
א]z
tم א، א5
א ?7אR
"\
xאg 5
% 1\ g -1
.
"\א א ! א 1א! Jא
א\"o\"5و א .د]"\ *?
0.99
و
و م א @; 8א ? \"$5א *
5
F* =א [ )* א ![ k ] نC ً - !J
عא *?*
(
.
,א א oN,$h ,א א oN,$h
(
f
,א א oN,$h ,א א oN,$h
g Dא
،
א!אm 1 $9 אQ
lא אz] . fg א =-
و
)
;M א
ًD
*
د א
א
ود א
ن
אאאא
אא א ! א! J
.
W WW W
.
א !b$
مא
F$ $;* F$
*) S9ل
8
א!א
m 1 ¢1 *! [ "\
ول ?z] -d* Eא 9 % Dא$
ـ
4
3
$9
د אوtg א
د! 5$אو
:
و= K
)
$ א
T
;? א א!?7א $9א
ذو
"\'a 6 د:
& aאAوj א
:
oI א
؟
L 6!J !* 1
אAא ود,Aد Kא E$
3
א! , $ :
)
א, ~ :
و؛ ~4א ? 2 א
!؛ א ;I
و
א
د
א &
! ,א א א !
א
)
(
؛و
?$Jعא א
؛و
Iد א
א عא א
(.
8
א 4<C`$
א! Jא عא 8- N $
א=`-$Z
د!` 5$א )`* i` #$
.
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
- و
،
` א `
د א
א!`?7א = K ] ?zא q m Dא !b$
مא $97
84
)
لو !o
4
.
8
د! 5$א
)
R
א!?7א = K
(
LM $א$9
(
$ ن א
ط$J,:א
)
R
2
v? B?
א
F
&uא
F
وTא
v? B?
,א:? א
DF
3,د
7א
: א
Sig*
א
د א
ود א
?& p
א
د
א
عא א
1
2 ?J
ـ
)
8
(
ذ ^
8`- N $ ` א!` J
א عא `
א %د ` א \"#$
.
`4<C
≤α
`! *`;\"$
` "\
`
\"#$ א %د ` א ; "\
ط
א7
)
* *=
^M `g
)
ذt
?
`
R
4
(
د` 7
LM $א = $#אM gJو \"o8د
dU
4<C
!`l? אm\"
لو
*
(
58
! *;\"$ دM g^ 7
0.05
א
73.809
4.00
0.520
0.000
0.721
≤α
0.05
0.721
(
)
F
م 7]$-א
عא!` J
]zא
\" *
4<C$ א
-[
_^ t?د
د. %
ز
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
و
(
)
?!
4<C`$ א `o د 2\ [ - - ،
و]`8
` ن
و]`z
א
א %د א \"#$
א \";Zאو \`2
א 8- N $
א7
د o ! %אو. %!g
E א
م -$]
-
1!
`*
=`* *
2
β
)
v$- [ *
0.520
،
ن t
!
!#$
.
(
)
א
0.799
\"
) L
. 42$ א
)
(
8- N $ א عא א! J
0.520
^
ذ ،
)
0.799
.
! *;\"$ אد
? ! !م #`/
א و]z
mD "\
אل [
;M א
73.809
0.05
4.00
:
)
!l
א و
2 א
≤α
* [-
5
(.
(
F
د 3ود 3و
د 3و 3و
?
א
! א =א m D
و
D א mD א ¢1
v ،و
د
2
2 ?J2 ?J
ذ ذ ذ ذ وووو
2 ?J ?J
! א عא ! א ! ! א
!د
&! א א عא ! א ! ! א
!د
א &
*! *!
?! B? ! B
! א عא ! א ! ! א
!د
! & א א عא ! א ! ! א
!د
א &
1 1 1 1
85
8- N $ א! J
א عא
8
- و،%!g 1 m1= $97
:
\"#$ א %د א "\ "\)* A
4<C
)* i
;? א
=
و #$
"\!o
7
1-1
(
HO
<C$א B54 ^M g
:
4<C
د وذ7
! *; \"$د7
א! Jא عא 8- N $
Iא! Jعא
؛
)
א
د א
ود א
.
و
)
8
ـ
(
؛عא Iא! J
4
2
(
.
א
د א
ود א
)
R
)
ـ
9
4
(
K
مא ] ?zא q m Dא !b$ $97
LM $א$9
א لو!l . ?m\"* \"] - ،
4<C
(
9
א7?!א = K
)
א
v? B?
ط$J,:א
0.002
0.129
58
59
0.360
4.00
10.109
? عא א$J
0.407
وTא
β
&uא
F
F
,א:? א
DF
v? B?
p &?
(
R
ن $ א
)
: א
א7
*Sig
د3,
(.
0.05
,א
א N אJ
58
1
א א
\"$;* ! M g^ 7د
1
M g^
α αα α ≤ ≤≤ ≤
8 `B54 <אC$
4<C
(
ـ
)
ذt
د7
4
א א! J
.
و
4<C
4.00
48.701
0.000
`"\
א !` א 1א
و عא ` Iא!` J
`= *`)
0.493
"\!l ?m
א لو
0.417
("\א ن <C$ذ 4
*
0.646
0.646
α
= *)
* *`=
`ط
א7
F
א
` `"\א א `! א 1א! J
א
و عא Iא!` J
0.360
R
)
ذ ^،
`?
(
9
`F
Iא! Jعא
و
86
! *;\"$
)
(
א "\א א! א 1א! J
و8 <C$א B54
و
)
)
4<C`$
≤
?
. *
0.05
(
و
v$- [ *
!عאJ אI
و
8 B54 <אC$
1!
R
2
!
!#$
(
0.417
،
(
)
0.129
نt
* *=
"\א א! א 1א! Jא
و
א
א8 B5
`"\א1
*`)
(
Iא!` J
و عא `
*`)
)
` د%
E אن `
א و]`z
)
0.417
.
β
(
0.129
(`= *`)
) Lא . 42$
F
0.493
)
0.05
(
`2 א
(
א !` א 1א ``"\
.
4.00
و]`z
א
8 `
א\"` $א
"\א א ! א 1א! Jא `
و عא Iא! J
)
)( ،
F
` \`2 אو א\";`Z
و
?!
[ `-
.
8 א\" $א
-
)( ،
?د_^ t
! oאو. %!g
(
0.493
)
0.407
` Dو א_ א
:
`= א `m D
و
D` א
`m D ¢1 א `
v` و،
?
א
`- [ `*
5
4<C`$ א
z]
א
* "\
! *;\"$ אد ]8و
)
א!lو `
≤α
mD א ل\" ?! !
[ /#م
א! J
א
! א
وذ وذ وذ وذ
E$ א L 6JאAא ود,AدK *1 E$ א L 6JאAא ود,AدK *1
,א א א
,א א א א
א
)
(
0.05
(
E$ א L 6JאAא ود,AدK * 1 E$ א L 6JאAא ود,AدK *1
?!! B? !! B
?!! B? !! B
د !!3ود !!3و
د
4
)
"\!o
7
א א א ! א! J
K
د وذ7
Iא! Jعא
(
S
M g^
4<C
.
10
1-2
:
)
HO
و
87
)
R
ط$J,:א
$ ن א
v? B?
1
3,د
7א
)
(
2
R
β
&uא
وTא
F
v? B?
(
א
DF
,א:? א
4
$9 אLM $
א
د א
ود
א
4<C
)
(
10
لو !o
ـ
I
א (D
א% B$ 7
)
א! Jא عא 8- N $
"\א א ! א 1א! Jא
א! J؛عא
.
(
*Sig
?& p
א, ~ :
א ;I
: א
"\!l ?m
א لو
*
0.000
4.00
("\א ن <C$وذ 4
58
)
α αα α ≤ ≤≤ ≤
0.599
א,
א JאN
0.593
59
! *;\"$ دM g^ 7
א א
(.
0.05
0.352
0.000
59
58
0.509
0.369
א, ~ :
1
0.607
39.765
36.895
4.00
;I א
?$Jعא א
)
عא Iא! J
و
(D א
?
(
)
% B$ S
!
!#$
א
2
)
و
!1
! *;\"$
(
. *
R
* *=
)
0.593
` א א! J
א !` א
`"\א1
و
ط `
א7
`
(D א
عא Iא! J
و
F
א% B$` 7
(D א
(
א% B$ 7
F
"\
א ! א 1א
و عא Iא! J
= *)
^M `g
(D א
א% B$ 7
4<C
S
`% B$
=`* *
` 7د
د\"`o8 وM `gJ א$# = א
4<C`
LM $
dU f g
(
ـ
ذt
.
`?
4
^،
ذ
א! Jא
10
≤α
0.352
0.05
(
R
0.369
Iא!` J
عא
*)
β
אא! J
نt
* [ v$-
و
"\א1
و
` `"\א א `! א 1א! J
א
و عא ` Iא!` J
% B$ S
(
א! א
(D א
.
(
8 א\"` $א
)( ،
0.599
)
*
و
)( ،
` ]`z
א
\"
)
4<C$ אo د-
)`* =(
[
(
0.509
0.509
0.599
!` ?
`
(D א
\`2 `- ،
A\" `
. 42$ ) אL
)
(
א% B$` 7
)
و
0.369
0.352
)
،
-
` د)`* =` . %
ز
"\ Aא <C$א 8 B54
`
`?د_^ t
د o ! %אو. %!g
E אن
א و]z
"\א א ! א 1א! J
א
*)
א\" $א 8
.
88
36.895
(
)
F
39.765
D א
`m D `"\א ل !` !` ?
م/`# [
و]z
א
`
B א
(
(
`
(D א
≤α
"\א א ! א 1א! J
א
% B$ S
)
0.05
)
`! *`;\"$ ` אد ]8و
א!lو
` *`
5
v` و،
F
2 א
(
و عא!` J אI `
)
-[
% B$ S
א (D
\2 אو א\";Z
[-
א 4<C$
4.00
.
?B? B? B? B
د: :د
:
?
א
! א =א m D
و
D א
mD ¢1 א
د D א
$
S
M g^
7د وذ
4<C
7
)
:
1-3
"\!o
0.05
HO
I
(
L 6JאAא ود,Aد Kא E$ * 1 E$ א L 6JאAא ود,AدK *1
!Jא ?$!J N؛عא ! א !JאN ?$!J؛عא ! א
E$ א L 6JאAא ود,AدK * 1 E$ א L 6JאAא ود,AدK *1
,א א א
,א א א א
א
)
2 ?J ?J
د
א ;I
? ~, ;I א
? ~,
א ;I
? ~, ;I א
? ~,
د: :د
د 3ود 3و
د 3و 3و
2 ?J2 ?J
2 وذ وذ وذ وذ
11
א
د א
ود א
ـ
.
)
لو !o
)
4
؛عא Iא! J
(
< LM $א$9
(
و
11
! *; \"$د7
(
א
د א
ود א
א ! א! J
א א
ـ
.
؛
عא א! J
)
مא ] ?zא q m Dא !b$ $97
4
א لو!l . ?m\"* \"] - ،
K
א!?7א = K
0.05
.
)
(
(
)
R
א
2
א Tو
$J,ط
β
(
58
?v? B
0.000
4.00
0.426
32.675
0.325
0.570
*Sig
DF
א, $ :
?v? B
د3,
1
Iد א
א ?:א,
א7
?$Jعא א
?& p
(
R
: א
)
F
א:
א&u
ن $ א
F
0.687
59
0.303
0.000
29.625
4.00
א א
,א
א N אJ
دI א
0.551
, $ :א
59
1
α αα α ≤ ≤≤ ≤
0.05
89
58
\"$;* ! M g^ 7د
)
*
4 <وذC$ ("\א ن
(
ـ
11
)
"\ ?mא!`l
لو
ط `
א7
א"\א א ! א 1א! J
א! Jو عא
^ ،ذ ?
R
= *)
د D א
$
S
4
`"\א1
و عאא!` J
`
`= *`)
`
د D א
`
`
$ 7א
4<C`
و
S
א$ 7
د D א
0.570
ن t
(
)
F
(
*` [ v`$-
א! Jא `
! *;\"$
אא! J
)
≤α
(
0.05
א !` א
M
^``g
``4<C
د`` 7
= $#אM ``gJو \"``o8د
LM ``$א `
``dU
ذt
.
^ذ
`` אא א `! א! J
)
د D א
"\א1
و
د D א
$
،
A\" `
. 42$` `) אL
`
0.303
`
د D א
` `"\א א `! א 1א! J
א
*)
א\" $א 8
"\A
`
א$ 7
(`= *`)
(
`
א$ 7
)( ،
)
(
0.303
` א `"\א א `! א 1א! J
و عא !
β
א` J
`
`1
R
`?
2
!
*)
S
0.325
و عא א! J
)
`
د D א `
$
(
)
و
)
(
0.325
. *
א
!
!#$
* *=
א! Jعא
و
0.687
0.426
? `! `!
[ /`#م ل\"`
א و]`z
S
`2 א
* [-
5
א!lو `
د D א
$
S
)
و عאא! J
)
*;\"$
אد ]`8و ` `!
`"\א א `! א 1א! Jא `
(
)
F
`
د D א `
$
(
(
29.625
.
!?
)
و
0.687
(
F
`
`-
د)* = . %
ز
8 א\" $א
` "\א א `! א 1א! J
א
و عא א! J
)( ،
0.426
.
0.05
≤α
` \`2 אو
א\";`Z
]z
א
\" *
4<C$ א
_^ t?د
د o ! %אو. %!g
E אن
א و]z
.
[ `-
)
(
4.00
32.675
(
?B ?B
)
,א א א
,א א א א
א
0.05
: دp &? : دp &?
E$ אKد,Aא ودA אL 6J * 1 E$ א Kد,Aא ودA אL 6J *1
(
:د د:
k k k k
! א =א m D
و
D א
2 ?J ?J
?
א
د 3و 3و
:
وذ وذ وذ وذ
د: :د
2
د
؛و و و و
Jא J NאN
?$Jعא א ?$J؛عא א
א عא א א عא א
א عא א א عא א
Iد د Iא $, א ,$
)
א m D ¢1
،و v
Iد Iא $,د א ,$
DאB B א
אmD
Jא J NאN
?$J؛عא א ?$J؛عא א
,א א א
,א א א א
א
90
؛
:
8- N $ א! J
א عא
Iא! Jعא
א! א
^M g
1-4
E D#$
K
د وذ7
4<C
HO
(
)
)
ـ
7
!o\"
0.05
(
7"\ د$;* !
.
(
4
12
א
د א
ود א
.
א ] ?zא q m Dא !b$ $97
)
.
ـ
(
12
)
)
(
4
R
)
(
2
< LM $א$9
"\א1
Iא! J؛عא
م
= K
א!?7א
א E D#$
0.000
0.871
א
20.047
?v? B
א $J,:ط
عא א
59
4.00
0.224
58
0.507
β
F
F
?$J
א Tو
א&u
?v? B
א ?:א,
DF
)
: א
R
(
ن $ א
?& p
WI א
1
د3,
*Sig
א7
,א א א
א
N אJ
0.103
12
(
E` D#$
`
M g^
7د
\"o8 وM gJ א$# = אLM $
د
dU f g
ذt
4<C
ــ
)
`"\
א !` א 1א
و عא ` Iא!` J
`= *`)
.
א! Jא
4
`
`4<C
(.
0.386
4.00
د7
WI א
1
0.321
)
0.05
و
F
Iא! Jعא
و
* *=
)
א"\א א ! א 1א! J
و عא Iא! J
(
0.321
)
(
R
א7
ط `
`"\א1
` Iא!` Jو عא
،
β
0.224
=* *
0.05
E D#$
)
.
(
(
א
`*
α≤
2
R
1!
0.224
!
!#$
?
(
)
`"\א1
و
(
א !` א
E` D#$
Iא!` Jعא
و
و
^אذ ? ،
= *)
91
Iא! J
و عא
*)
L
`
ن t
* [ v$-
"\א א ! א 1א! Jא `
*)
0.103
)
א! J
א
(
)
)
0.386
(
``-
)
20.047
`` ``"\א א `! א 1א! J
א
وع
0.871
)( ،
)
א `` Iא!`` J
`` د)``* =`` . %
ز
``?د_^ t
( ،
?
א
.
:
! א =א m D
و
א D
א m D ¢1
،و v
)
4.00
(
E D#$
א א
4<C$ א
א ]z
* "\
?!
)
≤α
E$ LאAא ود,Aد Kא 6J * 1 E$ א L 6JאAא ود,AدK *1
א א א א
(
! א عא ! א ! ! א عא ! א !
?B ?B
W! I !I
W
د 3و 3و
د: :د
2 ?J ?J
?B ?B
W! I W! I
د
)
,א !
א !JאN ?$!J؛عא ! א ,א !
א !JאN ?$!J؛عא ! א
ذ ذ ذ ذ وووو
د: :د
2
؛
عא Iא! J
(
K
ـ
)
א لو!l . ?m\"* \"] - ،
F(-$
)
= K
א!?7א
qא !b$مא ] ?zא m D $97
(
א
د א
ود
?& pد: ?& pد:
(
7
!o\"
4<C
0.05
)
.
:
7د وذ
HO
1-5
13
92
)
8- N $ א! J
א عא
4<C
"\א1
Iא! J؛عא
4
ـ
(
13
LM $א$9
)
F(-$ א
!لوo
$ ن א
R
)
(
F
)
R
DF
?$J
2
ط$J,:א
v? B?
F
,א:? א
v? B?
(
وTא
א
&uא
β
3,د
p &?
א
د א
ود
.
א
(
;? א
*Sig
58
0.000
4.00
0.643
58
0.287
JאN
1
23.297
א7
0.535
0.05
≤ ≤≤ ≤ α αα α
,א א
א
*
0.030
4.935
0.078
0.280
1
4.00
0.250
;? א
א
59
عא א
"\!l ?m
א لو
``"\א1
E`` D#$و
`"\
א !` א 1א
و عא ` Iא!` J
`= *`)
`
`4<C
)
א "\א א ! א 1א! J
و عא Iא! J
د7
`F(-$ א
ذt
4<C
*)
^M g
0.535
`= F(-$
4
ط
א7
א א! J
)
R
* *=
13
(
.
ــ
^
ذ
،
` "\א א ! א 1א! J
א
*)
L
`
Iא! J
و عא
*)
نt
* [ v$-
` "\A
א\" $א 8
(
.
אא א ! א! J
א! Jא
)
β
(
0.287
0.287
0.078
א \";Zאو \2
``"\א א `! א 1א! Jא ``
`` Iא!`` Jو عא
`` د)``* =`` . %
ز
F(-$`
F(-$`` א
_^ t``?د
`"\א1
` Iא!` Jو عא
4<C$ א
[-
0.250
) א . 42$
)
(`= *`)
93
( ،
(
)
(
)
0.643
א ]z
* "\
F
0.643
( ،)
23.297
)
"\א א ! א 1א! J
א
4.935
≤α
)
(
0.05
`! *`;\"$ אد ]8و
(
)
.
(
4.00
* [-
5
F
F(-$
2 א
!l
א و
א א א א
(
د 3و 3و
2 ?J2 ?J
د 3ود 3و
د
2 ?J ?J
(
)
0.05
! ; ! ;?
ذ ذ ذ ذ وووو
! د !: :د
א;* V
` D א
:
! א =א m D
و
D א
,א !
א !JאN ,א ?$!J؛عא ! א !
א !JאN ?$!J؛عא ! א
! א عא ! א ! ! א عא ! א !
! ! א عא ! א ! א عא ! א !
?
! ;? ! ;?
2
! ,א
א !JאN ?$!J؛عא ! א ,א !
א N! אJ ? ؛عא ! א$!J
)
)
+k h
: دp &?
(
0.05
K
E!!$ !! Kد,Aא !! ودA אL 6!!J
א !!*
I? 6 אوPE אFZ6a 6h
1 ? ? !!B א
oI א
, 6!!J 1
א
د
א &
ذو
!! "\'!!a 6 אد
:א !!3
+k !!h
אد
"\!o
HO
، د t
$9אو
7
T
g )א
$ א
د א
ود א
.F* א \"
.
א m D ? אz] $97
)
.
(
2-1
M g^
0.05
7د
:
:
$9!א مאb$ אq1 ،و m1
RS$9^
ذو
= K
?³
_^ d- ;
q m D ? אz] $97
One Way ANOVA
!
\"oو
د
8
- و،%!g 1 m1= $97 F$ $;* F$
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
א
א -
אRS$9
*;\"$
(
.
14
ـ
)
4
א لو!l . ?m\"* \"] -
א -
.
RS$9
\"#$ א
،
א% د` `; "\
` א `
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
)`* i` #$
) א `gدt
` $ `= אK !مb$`
94
41
%? v@
B א
c,
د
א
אC 4
30
–
40
50
–
51
~ ?N
א&7
א ?:א+
אC 4
אc, B4
30
)
لو !o
4
ـ
14
(
א&7
א ?:א+
;@א و
;
אC 4
א ?:א+
0.35
3.96
3.92
אB4
אc, B4
0.41
0.35
4.00
א&7
אc, B4
א&7
0.52
א
3.89
ﺃ
F
`
\"#$ א %د ` א `; "\
t
`
- אא `?D
א@;
\ ! אx$;5
4
!l )* ??$
א لو
14
(
وذ
)
لو !o
)
4
(
15
ـ
.
–
One Way ANOVA
!
40
Q;`g RS$`97א אz`] ` 71` د
5و
א )
$ =אK $9א0 אo^ q ، - *
42$ א
t` دg
k ذF
30
ـ
4
)
لو אو!`l
ــ
.
15
(
DF
אB 4
@
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א
א7
- א
ع ? ?C
א7
?& p
د3,
@
ع ?
; "\
א
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
.
LM $א$9
RS$9
0.189
10.604
MS
SOS
59
56
11.254
ع ?א
א
F
&uא
2.76
F
: א
% $ 6 , ?א
وTא
Sig.*
0.339
3
?? א
B 4א
0.217
? אvhאد
1.144
0.650
د
א
95
≤α
(
!` 7 אد 4 }
א \"! *`;$
)
!7 א *;\"$
0.05
)
`; "\
` א `
د א `
ود א
*.F א "\
)
ـ
4
(
א\";Z
)
1.144
≤α
\[-
fg
F
F
`2
)
(
(
`m D `= א
v` و
!l
א א ` و
`- [ `* `
5
)
(
\`2 -
)
`
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
.
?& pد: ?& pد:
^M g
)
0.05
B א B א
7
HO
2-2
E!!$ !! אKد,Aא !! ودA אL 6!!J !!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 , !!אJ 1 E!!$ א !! Kد,Aא !! ودA אL 6!!J
!!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 , !!אJ 1
E!!$ !! אKد,Aא !! ودA אL 6!!J !!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 , !!אJ 1 E!!$ א !! Kد,Aא !! ودA אL 6!!J
!!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 , !!אJ 1
!! !! אد אد
a 6!!'\" a 6!!'\"
!!3 :!!3 :
!!3 : !!3 :
?
אو
(
)
a 6!!'\" a 6!!'\"
:
: دp &? : دp &?
+k !!hאk !!hא
+k h א
د
א & +k h א
د
א &
B א B א
!* א
!! אد!! אد
(
D א
+ ذذذذوووو
+k !!hא+k !!hא
` 7د
One Way ANOVA
`
\" *
8`- $ א5`;$"\ א
!`
\"$;`*
RS$9 ` `
\"#$ א %د ` א ; "\
א
א% د` `; "\
` א `
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
(
)
8- $ א \"5;$א
16
4
،
)
.
אRS$9
(
0.05
و\"o
د
)`* i` #$
) א `gدt
` $ `= אK !مb$` א m D ? אz]
$97
.
RS$9
\"#$ א
.
96
لو !o
)
16
4
א@
; و
א ?7א1
א
د
א
\"$;5א
42$* Q;
P
א5
3.90
نود N
? K
א C 4א&7
0.33
אc, B4
א ?:א+
א ?:א+
אc, B4
א ?:א+
3.93
אc, B4
0.40
א C 4א&7
א C 4א&7
4.04
א,د م د
? L م د
אc, B4
א ?:א+
0.40
א C 4א&7
3.94
0.39
א@;
!l )* ??$
א لو
0.57
`
\"#$ א %د ` א `; "\
א ,د<
אc, B4
א ?:א+
אc, B4
א C 4א&7
א ?:א+
? 2 &3
א C 4א&7
3.88
0.34
3.96
16
)
ـ
ﺃ
(
4
Fذ k
(
17
.
د `z`] ` 71א אRS$`97
ــ
`P
.
"\
س
(` "\ א *`) ? `
و5
F
\ ! אx$;5
;42$`* Q
א \"5;$א 8- $
) א gدt
$ =אK $9א0 אo^ q ،
One Way ANOVA
!`lאو
لو
4
)
97
8- $ א5;$"\ א
RS$9
\"#$ د א% א
ع ?
% $ 6 , ?א
SOS
F
ع ?C ?
B 4א
B 4א
3,د
MS
7א
DF
&uא
@
!o
لو
\" ;
א
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
4
)
ـ
17
(
RS$9
.
א7
$
$9 אLM
د
א
3
: א
?& p
2.76
0.475
א
59
11.254
ع ?א
0.920
0.883
0.177
א Tو
56
1.192
אد vhא?
10.370
*Sig.
? א?
:
?
אو
F
(
)
D א
(
)
0.920
)
)
2.76
`2 !l
א א ` و
(
`=
`v و
-[\
fg
\" ;`
` א `
د א `
ود א
.
17
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א
LM $א!l . #m\"5
א لو S9 )* F
אل $
)
ـ
4
.
`! ً ^M `g لאد !و م\"oא دRS$`9
(
!7 א *;\"$
(
0.05
(
)
F
≤α
)
8- $ א \"5;$א
!!3 :!!3 :
!!3 : !!3 :
(
)
א+k !!hא+k !!h
+k h א
د
א & +k h א
د
א &
+k h א
د
א & +k h א
د
א &
a 6!!'\" a 6!!'\"
)
(
E!!$ !! אKد,Aא !! ودA אL 6!!J !!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 , !!אJ 1 E!!$ א !! Kد,Aא !! ودA אL 6!!J
!!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 , !!אJ 1
+k !!hאk !!hא
98
M g^
RS$9
ذو
2-3
HO
אد
:
א
RS$`9
لאد
\"o *) وi #$ F$
د
$;* F$
m D ? אz] $97
$9א
!مb$ א
`
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
.
!
.
ً ^M ``g
T
*;\"$
)
א
.
د7
"\!o
7
\" *
0.05
!l . ?m\"* \"] -
א لو ،
=- א T
18
RS$9
\"#$ א
=- א T
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א
(
4
)
18
.
(
لو !o
)
4
ـ
ـ
Bد א
vB א
; "\
א
د
א
ود א
*.F א "\
LM $א$9
.
7א
RS$9
0.33
C 4א
+א:? א
B $[
א
&7א
c, B4א
T
&uא
وTא
p &?
Sig.*
: א
T
3.85
0.43
?N
8
4.09
د
א
"\אدc,
0.000
52
4.591
1.645
4
و\"`o
د
)
` ` RS$9
\"#$ א %د ` א `; "\
א
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
T
LM $א!l . #m\"5
א لو S9 )* F
אل $
18
)
α≤
0.05
-[\
fg
;"\
אZ
!7 א ! *;\"$
(
(
)
)
(
?
אو
:
! א m D =א
و
α
)
`- [ `* `
5
)
אد
! *;\"$
T
\`2 `-
)
(
(
4.591
)
(
`2 א א ` و !l
(
`§ ` k ذو
1.645
0.05
!* א mD א ¢1
D א
≤
v و
.
F
J
א אد
99
)
0.05
(
`
د א
E!!$ א !! ود,Aد!! K א E!!$ א !! ود,Aد!! K א
A
"\'!!a 6!!'\" a 6
E!!$א !! ود,Aد !! Kא E!!$ א !! ود,Aد !! Kא
"\'!!a 6!!'\" a 6
L 6!!JאA L 6!!Jא!!J 1א !!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 , !!J 1א !!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 ,
L 6!!JאA L 6!!Jא!!J 1 Aא !!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 , !!J 1א !!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 ,
د
+ ذذذذوووو
` 7د
@ אD U\" א. *!V א%!*
:
\"$;`*
0.05
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
א
)
(
.
!o\"
אد
א
RS$9
ذو
HO
2-4
7
ود א
*.F א "\
.
^M g
)
19
ـ
4
19
(
لو !o
*! %א*!V
; "\ א %د א \"#$
42$* Q;g
.
א5
א ?7א1
(
;@א و
ـ
א لو!l . ?m\"* \"] -
)
One Way ANOVA
%א `د \" ;`
RS$9
\"#$ א
` א `
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
.
و\"oد
אRS$9
?%
?%
א
ـ
10
אc, B4
א&7
אc, B4
15
א&7
אc, B4
5
א&7
א&7
15
אc, B4
א ?:א+
אC 4
א ?:א+
אC 4
א ?:א+
אC 4
א ?:א+
אC 4
~ ?N
א? ? 1
?
@%? v
5
10
?%
@v
א
?I א
א
א7
א
19
0.39
3.97
د
א
0.48
3.89
0.39
3.98
(
ـ
`
`; "\ א %د ` א \"#$
א@;
ﺃ
3.93
0.35
100
و5
אد `z`] ` 71
5
א !
.
\ ! אx$;5
?!%
)
F
4
!l )* ??$
א لو
)
K ` $9א0 ` אo^ q ،
)
` $ `= א
!لوlאو
RS$97א
`P
42$`* Q;
One Way ANOVA
.
k ذF
\" ;
א
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
א7
RS$9
LM $א$9
.
` @` אD U\" א. `*!V א%!`*
(
ـ
لو !o
20
4
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א
)
ـ
4
gدt א
20
(
0.395
ع ?
11.254
2.76
59
ع ?א
אB 4
56
0.757
א
د
א
0.233
0.197
11.020
?? א
0.078
? אvhאد
% $ 6 , ?א
&uא
7א
3,د
Sig.*
p &?
: א
DF
F
MS
وTא
B 4א
? عC
SOS
?
α≤
0.05
ـ
!l
א لو
)
@ אD U\" א. *!V א%!*
!` ً M `g^ لאدRS$`9"\א دo!و م
(
)
4
)
`2 !l
א א ` و
F
` }`
אد 4
)
א\";`Z
\[-
fg
`- [ `*
5
\" ;`
` א `
د א `
ود א
*.F א "\
\2 -
(
(
!7 א *;\"$
.
!7 א ! *;\"$
0.395
)
(
)
)
(
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א
(
)
(
0.05
? Iא7 א ? ? 1א
? ? Iא7 א ? ? 1א
?
? Iא7 א ? ? 1א
? ? Iא7 א ? ? 1א
?
!! !! אد אد
a 6!!'\" a 6!!'\"
:
(
?
אو
*! א m D =א
v و
F
)
D א
אk !!hא+k !!h
+ ذذذذوووو
0.05
≤α
א+k !!hא+k !!h
!!3 :!!3 :
אد אد!! !!
L 6!!JאAא !! ود,Aد !! Kא E!!$ !!* 1 ? ? !!B !!Jא 6 , 1 E!!$ א L 6!!JאAא !! ود,Aد!! K
!!* 1 ? ? !!B !!J 1א 6 ,
101
:
2-5
`
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
.
^M g
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
א
\" *
HO
א
אد
7
ذ و
RS$9
!o\"
א% د` `; "\
` א `
د א
ود א
.F* א \"
.
RS$9א
د \"oو
)`* i` #$
One Way ANOVA
t` دg ) א
` $ `= אK !مb$` א m D ? אz] $97
\"$;*
.
0.05
7د
)
(
RS$9
`*!V א%!*
د א
` א `
ود א `
` .
)
!o
لو
. ?`m\"* \"`] `-
`
د א
א
ود א
.
،
(
א #$
*!%
*! %א*!V
RS$9
\"
4
د א
א
ود א
א. *!V
;42$* Q
21
4
P
21
(
.
ـ
)
א لو!l
ـ
א5
א \"#$ א %د ; "\
א ?7א1
;@א و
5
ـ
5
?%
?%
א
?:א+
א E$
אAود
א,AدK
א
אC 4
א ?:א+
אC 4
א ?:א+
@v
אC 4
א ?:א+
אC 4
א
?%
10
10
א
@%? v
ـ
15
~ ?N
15
אc, B4
אc, B4
0.43
א&7
א&7
א&7
אc, B4
د
א
א
אc, B4
21
3.88
0.36
0.35
3.99
4.02
3.93
0.48
א&7
`
ود א `
` .
P
42$* Q;
RS$97א
v!@
! א
.
5و
*!V א%!*
*!V א%!*
10
F
%!?
t
א z] 71 د
x$;5\ ! א
وذ
ــ
ﺃ
ـ
(
`
\"#$ א %د ` א `; "\
א@;
5
?%
د א
א
ود א
.
)
4
!l )* ??$
א لو
102
אو!`l
لو
د א
א
22
ــ
4
Fذ k
!o
لو
د א
א
ود א
.
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א
)
*! %א*!V
; "\
א
د א
ود א
*.F א "\
22
א7
.
LM $א$9
(
.
RS$9
ـ
: א
د3,
א7
? ع
אB 4
?א % $ 6 ,
?& p
אB 4
F
ع ? ?C
F
@
MS
@
59
11.254
ع ?א
א
د
א
56
? אvhאد
0.187
10.463
0.790
Sig.*
?? א
&uא
وTא
2.76
0.249
1.410
0.263
DF
SOS
(
`- [ \`
fg
د א
א
ود א
(
)
1.410
` *` [ `-
5
)
≤α
F
\`2 `-
0.05
(
א\";Z
)
!7 אد 4 }
א \"! *;$
F
)
0.05
ـ
≤α
22
(
^!` ً M `g لאد !و م\"oא دRS$`9
*; \"$א !7
(
`; "\
` א `
د א `
ود א
*.F א "\
)
RS$9
\"#$ א %د
LM $א!l . #m\"5
א لو S9 )* F
אل $
א
4
(
)
*! %א. *!V
.
+k h א
د
א & +k h א
د
א &
0.05
(
a 6!!'\" a 6!!'\"
! Kد,A אE!$ א ودA אL 6J *1 ! K د,A אE!$ א ودA אL 6J *1
? ?א
? ? ?א
?
E!!$ !! אKد,Aא !! ودA אL 6!!J !!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 , !!אJ 1 E!!$ א !! Kد,Aא !! ودA אL 6!!J
!!* 1 ? ? !!B 6 , !!אJ 1
! !
+k h א
د
א & +k h א
د
א &
א? ?
א? ? ?
?
)
(
!* א =א m D
v و
א D
?
אو
:
2.76
E!!$ L 6!!JאAא !! ود,Aد !! Kא !!* 1 ? ? !!B !!Jא 6 , 1 E!!$ א L 6!!JאAא !! ود,Aد!! K
!!* 1 ? ? !!B !!J 1א 6 ,
103
ـ
(
4
)
)
23
)
(
\"#$ א %د א "\
4<C
!oلو
"\א א ! א 1א! Jא
א! Jو ؛عא
.
)
\"#$ א %د א "\
ـ
4<C
4
` I
!l ?b
א لو
و
(
23
א ~4? 2 א
א, ~ :
?$Jعא א
;I א
א عא א
(
א"\א א ! א 1א! J
Iא! Jو ؛عא
,א א א
א JאN
א
د
א
K
K
WI א
א, $ :
Iد א
;? א
(.
!l )* ??$
א لو
!` J4
عא `<C
א `
?
\"#$ א %د א
v
! 8- N $ א
)
\" ن1 د ?S C
104
@
÷
pbî–?nUaë@bî–?nUaë@
p
÷?b©a?b©a
÷?b©a÷?b©a
@
@?—???Ua?—???Ua
p@@@@@@@
pbubn?n?bubn?n?
@?“?b??@?“?b??
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
@ üa üa üa üa
pbî–?nUaë@pbî–?nUaë@
pbubn?n?pbubn?n?
@?“?b???“?b??
@?—???Ua@?—???Ua
W WW W
)
1
W WW W
(
(
ـ
5
!!!!!!!!?
?!!!!!!!!א4
א4
?!!!!!!!!
?!!!!!!!! א4
א4
ـ
5
)
ـ
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
W WW W
3 3
א :א :א :א:
3 3
5
3
)
(
2
105
1 ?`
< א ! א )* nو $; ?7א[!*\
]`c ضא `$
?!!!!!!!!
?!!!!!!!! א4
4א
W WW W
!!!!!!!!?
?!!!!!!!!א4
4א
`-] F
1 )* = D א אz] 6 C$ ،!/ 5? אz] 2$ 5 0
7= אo )*ً א، "\و/
א7
س '
)
5
ـ
1
(
و*`
و0\"`m .
אo $ $` 7
`/\"$ א8
`C
.
5
3 3
3 3
`F
)
/\"$ אو
W WW W
.
(
2
.
ن و
.
אo $ $ 7
:
ً D
ن*
א
ود א
1
د א
?z] ^_ ز
A\" 1
ً D
*ن
د א
א
ود א
.
`
`*.F א )
`! א!`5
د D א
א$ 7
`
ود א `
`
.
د א
א
*.F א )
! א!5
א (D
א% B$ 7
"\A 1
"\
א
"\
א
*;\"$
.
ً D
*
ن LM $ و א
3
106
ن`
*;\"$
5
. Iא!` J
عא
وU
ن LM $ א d
.
د א
.
` א `
ود א `
`
ً D
*
`
د א
` א `
ود א `
`
ً D
ن*
د א
א
ود א
)
A\" ` 1א !` E` D#$א!`5
`"\
א
.
*`;\"$
א *.F
ن8 -א =` $#אM `gJ
.
4
S9 )* F
ل
و
.
6
8
` -$uو* `Dد%
! *; \"$د` 7
א
د א
ود א
.
.
``` ```= *```) אد ```* i```D$
و\"o
د
`
\" *
` 7 دtذ
. !אJא1 "\א א ! א
\"$;* ن
`
4<C
ً
7
-1
,2003
Jung, et..al
(
( ؛
א
و
` א
` 1 ^_ ` א دmJ
.
.
9
8 !אJ א-= אA\" ] دC
\"#
א$
!و م\"oد
^M g
ذt
אRS$9
אد
`` ``?RS$9
\"#$ א %د ` א ``;-
2006
(.
0.05
.
8``- ،א =``]?5אو ``
` אو ،ع
107
وE
`
،
)
(
2003
t- א
?8
\"`#$ אt د ` אA\" ;` 1 \"
/ א
\"? 6U\"5א ? ن _א0 א
.
א
cd
cd
א- و9?א
S]?* وc] - C t ]\"o =( <C$
`D U\" א
? b$ אو
`` *`` א دi``D$
``x $ ? אz``]و
(
t * `` א
`?
?M
.
`
د 7א
ود א
. D U\" א T
)
t42$`5
E`
0.05
،
)
2002
RS$9
\"#$ א %د א ; "\
א
(.
`` א
`
د א `
ود א `
`*` .F א ` "\
.
` אد
ذt
^M `g
אRS$9
و\"o
د
.
10
``! *``; \"$د`` 7
8
\"`#$ א
i` $
و \#mو\"`oאد قو ` 1د ` `- 1
א ``
!`M א
W WW W
)
5
ـ
3
0 א 0 א
`o $ $
א7
Tא ! t Nو א `k z
qא )* d ^ =/\"$אJ א
o$$
S
ً و1
جو? א $"\/ qאV ،
:
)* dא = $#א [אو8M g7 ل\" @א q א
K
אא א */.F *و א! ^ ل\" @ ج א $K אو ! * =* $ %אS( 5
!o
ق
א
ود א /
` א `
د א `
ود א `
% ![ Eد א. %
E
` `
א ! %אو *F א א ع [^ !% i $
-1
د
א
(*J אE
E
K
א
د
108
F*` א `*
K
)` N ¢2 א F* א n * אو$ نو F* gS א ¢
\"D
م א ! C$
* n *vא *F
E$مא ! wאو ;5א. %
אو7
ط `*` F א `o g ع ` ^ )5$`?-אو `*F א *`
مא% !b$
د א &\" א
`
\"#$ א
و ? ` gC
م `-$]J1 ^_ א `mJ cd ^ \"5 אc? - ز ?^و cd1 ]!אi K
W
i' $ א
`-N 5אد0 אC`
\"#$ د% א
d$[S و
i $
-1 א !
! *) א
E5א0 אo?
K
א
د א
ود א / .
zو א\"dlא د5
`
9
.
.
א \"#$ א %د
א1 5
4<C$
i $
א0 א د o
\"
?
109
@
E@@@@@@@
Eua‹¾a@?à?b?Eua‹¾a@?à?b?
Eua‹¾a@?à?b?ua‹¾a@?à?b?
:
ً و: ً و: ًو: ً و
ً K ً K
W W W W
$ 3A3 $ אAא
$ 3A3 $ אAא
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
L3א4 אL3א4 א
ً W W W W
L3א4 אL3א4 א
110
:
و ً :و ً :و ً :و ً
2000
)
א 4א L3א Bא 4א L3א B
W W W W
א 4א L3א Bא 4א L3א B
،
"\
،
(
K
1
א
א ) אد א 5א !
א%
א !א א ود
Bאد א م B ,אد א م,
Bאد א م B ,אد א م,
.
53
ـ
،،،،
29
?ل vD 9
عא אو
K
2
"\
)
? , E ? 2- 2 &3 ,
? , E ? 2- 2 &3 ,
د !& א *! א
- א ) 678א
(
W
ض
<م * א -
א Bא ! 0
2008
K
3
، * א6 א م\"
*o ،
)
، )? א ! ) !o * Sd
،ل א
* <=
! אط
( ' א ?.
د! א
40
?B א
?? Bאد:א, א
? אد:א,
لو .
"\
א
1% א )د
25 א 4/. 3
. /%
،
)
د !& א
ع ,% א .-א
/
*0 א
( ،
،
"\
.
א ( 5-א د\" ; א
:
ض
א
"\
،
!* @א אد ،ز\" $אو
ن -
ند א
:
"\
:
( F- ( F-
)
2000
( F- ( F-
ل
א )א (
ل
א )א (
5
،
"\
(
، 8o
8[\"
دא \"o
،
K
( ،
ل W W W W
4
)
E
"\
)
،،،،
"\
"\
7
،
،
(! א !א א* l
.
، );g
وא
5
& א F- א
& א F- א
5
& אF- 5 א
& א F- א
308
.
307
5
א
–
K
.
،
،! ?) א ! 8
،8
א@
)
)
(
1997
(
.
111
1999
(
8
.
)
ل
(B5 א
F- 5
*F:
(B5 א
F- 5
*F:
_
وא ،
،
8
"\
عא *Jא ) א Bא*Jא ) אB
،
)
(
? دt
\" ،
عא *Jא ) א Bعא*Jא ) אB
ع
*-
ن -
و4
9
ند 7א
،
.
:
1992
\" ،
.
:
"\
،
ل
t!D א
ل
(B5 א
F- 5
*F:ل
(B5 א
F- 5
*F:
_
وא ،
،
ن ]! א
ن
،
م ) Eg א אد
.
،8
ز
11
5
; M
د)
2 א
\"
(
.
P!
G N% א
*+I
'(
5
F-
1994
?!-
)
א د;
،
2 ./4
('
1
ص
? א5 ; ،
b1
)
ص
אو مL
! א عא א
אو مL
! א عא א
،
1989
ص
אو مL
! א عא אص
אو مL
! א عא א
( و
،
(
،
.
"\
و ! ;( א
،
لو
א Q D4 د
(I =
!R א
،
א
ل
(Bא
\"
)
(
:
T *o
،
.
د 7א א* l
(
)
(*א (
-S )TU- א ;א د :
א i$א B
א,د ? Bد i $א א
א,د ? د
،،،،
אد א אد א )
אد א) אد א )
8
\" ،
،
،
B א א i$
א,د د i$א? B א
א,د د ?
6
=
!
"\
1999
135
ـ
،
;? א
174
.
،
:
12
א(
א د! א
"\
،
1997
.
13
א (5-א د\" ; א
.
א د;
W
;א دV א א ) אزو نא د ' ( &1
، ? * ) !? ،t א
:
ض
א א * ،א م\"
"\
.
א! ( 7
8
"\
א*) !* g E !-? ،8 ز
.
14
2006
عא
7%
%1א(R و د)
2 א
،
)
אد א
)
"\
،
$
W
(
? , E ? 2- 2 &3 ,
? , E ? 2- 2 &3 ,
6
*o ،
8- א f# د% א -
.
د
)
.
15
? 4 אB? 3 ?? 4 אB? 3 ?
دB B
112
gو א fIא ( '
19
:
&
1997
\" i Tא ض? "\
ط\"; אو ؛! ?-د، ، $
،
)
K
(
.
)
1
،
"\
- F-% א א
9
(
39
.
"\
،
،
67
17
"\
א )678 אBد !& א F-% א
$د[- %1א ;و א א
א &א 2
Bאد א م, B א ?א ,אد א م B B א ?א
، ? ?! )
K
16
، *t א
(
)
،
2002
"\
(
70
)
א
? אد א ?c,אد אc,
? 2- 2 &3 ? , 2- 2 &3 ,
،
،
:
13
,E?
,E?
, E ?, E ?
،
F-% א عא
د 7[$א
،
و %אد7א
،،،،
=
א! Zא(- 0 ;א د;_ (R/% א
"\
،
دא!2 *o
:
قא א
.
19
] c
7%
R(و
! א *U. 6 א دא א ; _N
;
،
18
K
،
Eوאt א
(
2000
"\
)
،
!-? I2א= + 8،א !
א -א
"\
د)
א2 5
M ; س
I * /4אد) 2
U א ) א cא )د
(
،
א ( 5-א د\" ; א
.
.
? , E ? 2- 2 &3 ,
? , E ? 2- 2 &3 ,
:
20
)
)
"\
K
2004
.
، /
) \"d * ،t - א
` 1%א א ) אد א
(
،
! tE
؛ א
،
)
(
2008
"\
،
) א
و!? ،§ /
؛
א5
F- سא* א .!S *U. אدא א
.
)
22
2001
(
"\
،
*Oو;=
،
W
א? !
אد אو د :@ 6א م, B א ? ,אد אو د :@ 6א م B א ?
دא!،2
،
14
"\
،،،،
د :@ 6א م, אد אو B א ? ,אد אو د :@ 6א م B א ?
22
ل
(B
50
:
21
.
52
.
–
،
د! א
א ( 5-א د\" ; א
.
? , E ? 2- 2 &3 ?, E ? 2- 2 &3
:
113
? , E ? 2- 2 &3
? , E ? 2- 2 &3
ض
א ،د א\" k 5
*o ،
(
24
21
د !
)
)
،
،
)
،
7%;
h#
، t!* 2 א
،
W
\"
5 د !& א
!
1%א )دc א
2 א
!
i
1999
iB$ א B? 3 ?B$ א B? 3 ?
iB$ א B? 3 ?iB$ א B? 3 ?
.
)
23
(
،
دא a- אو ع .אو عא א
"\ ،
א?
!
"\
،،،،
?!-
;،
.
"\
دi
א 5אدMB
.א 2
0
7Db
DV R% אو
א
م *o
1989
(
،
د\" ; א
"\
א)
!*] א
8
"\
א
)
c [ !-?
،
.
$*دN$*دN
\"
WWWW
\" ،
אد א 5
F- א (
אد א c 5 אو
F- א (
אوc
*Nد*N $د$
.
26
אد א 5
F- א (
אد א c 5 אو
F- א (
אوc
:א
;א دא &: & א :
א & ;א د &:
& א F-% א & א F-% א
(
j
.
25
jb
Y אو 5
!5 אو
*F- אb
Y אو 5
!5 אو
*F- א
)
:
،
2001
\"
،
\"
jb
Y אو 5
!5 אو
*F- אjb
Y אو 5
!5 אو
א *F-
)
د dאد א )
. אد א دd
.
c [ !-? ،8
،
\"
א
د dאد א )
). אد א دd
.
l %m א (
-D א ع
א /2 5
M*J 0 -! :
2 (R/%
،
F-% א عא א
'و< 2- [ א ,د 'و [ < -2א ,د
'و< 2- [ א ,د 'و [ < -2א ,د
،
?,E
?,E
? , E ?, E
،قא א
[ $א ،د * lא$;5
"\
.
אJאو %אدJ ،
2002
)
، )
! א ;?S/ ،8 ( א
(
.
27
_ وא ،
א0 א k
ن -
.
،
"\
B v$א
&4 ? אB אv$
&4? א
W
B אv$
&4 ? אB אv$
? א&4
.
"\
1992
،
)
117
(
(
28
.
29
.
30
د! א،
.
)
.
(
n o Qk
N5 אو
;
;I n o Q k
N5 אو
;
;I
n o Qk
N5 אو
;
;I n o Q k
N5 אو
;
;I
"\
، ?!- د\" - ،א
B א 4א ? B א 4א ?
B א 4א ?B א 4א ?
\" ،
.
=M אو אد
ن _، -و א
ند 7א
:
:
،
ز\" אt
F-% א * %/א F-% א * %/א
*"\
%/א F-% א * %/א F-% א *
א; m%مא
2
)
(
، I ، א?8 S
"\
2001
$ אد א عא א
،
"\
)
!P %1א )دb א* 8אو
2 אp *F:
\"
114
، t א\"?א
!
،
? אد א ,
? אد א ,
]x
? אد א ,
? אد א ,
،
!
?) א
ن،
"\
د)
א2
د)
2 א
د
* א &2%. 0א 2 rR
د
* א &2%. 0א 2 د) r R
א2
د
* א &2%. 0א 2 د) r R
א2
د
* א &2%. 0א 2 rR
"\
)
)
)د - Bאز ) א
$د 2 1%א א #
&א 2 א
(
1999
)
، !d1 ن، "\T א
"\
،
(
،
"\
1
.
31
.
?j F *($
)
1996
(
،
"\
1% א 1%א
:
1% 1%א א
:
]% ،א
B א
، ، ، ،
د! א
،
(
2005
.
325
.
33
א ( 5-א د\" ; א
.
:
ض
? , E ? 2- 2 &3 ,
? , E ? 2- 2 &3 ,
،
115
Harvard Business Review Harvard Business Review
$ 3A3 $ אAא
L3א4 אL3א4 א
$ 3A3 $ אAא
ً K ً K
Oct.
, Sep-
ً K K
ً W W W W
3. Avolio, B.J., Waldman, D.A., and Yammarino, F.J. (1991), “
Leading in the 1990s: The
Behaviors of Athletic Directors and Coaches Job Satisfaction: A Field Study
P
”,
PhysicalPhysical
Educatorducator
EducatorEducator
E
, Canada, 55 (4): 170-174.
Physicalhysical
16.
”,
Journal of European Industrial TrainingJournal of European Industrial Training
M
Developing Transformational Leadership: 1992 and
K
KnoKnowledge wledge
Management Reviewanagement Review
8. Bass, B. and Avolio, B., (1993), “
C
T
CritiquesCritiques
Critiquesritiques
Transformational Leadership:Transformational Leadership: A Response A Response to
9. Bass, B.M., (1985), “
L
New York:
Leadership and Performance eadership and Performance beyondbeyond Expectations
Expectations””
Leadership and Performance Leadership and Performance beyondbeyond Expectations
Expectations””
The Free Press.
”, I
,
42, No. 1.
Oriantations towards Customers and Innovation”,
C
California Manaalifornia Management Reviewgement Review
California ManaCalifornia Management Reviewgement Review
,
Vol.
116
12.Birkinshaw, Julian & Hood, Neil, (2001), “
Unleash Innovation in Foreign
Subsidiaries
P
Proceedings of theProceedings of the
Leadership and Creativity: Exploring the Mediating Effects of Creative Thinking and
th
”,
Harvard Business ReviewHarvard Business Review
Harvard Business Review Harvard Business Review
, March.
Transformational
Intrinsic Motivation”,
Proceedings of theroceedings of the 13
Melbourne, Australia: 684-694.
,
ynaynamicsmics
Organizational rganizational
, winter, Vol. 19, issue 3:47.
O
Organizational Organizational
D DD Dynaynamicsmics
”,
The New Era of Managementhe New Era of Management
17.Daft, Richard L., (2001), “
O
Organization Theory and DesignOrganization Theory and Design
Organization Theory and Designrganization Theory and Design
th
Strategic Vision or Tunnel Vision
OmegaOmega
7 ed., South-Western
”,
T
”, Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, U.S.A.
”,
Omegamega
Technological Change and echnological Change and
O
, March: 647.
Organizationrganization
O
OrganizationOrganization
Technological Change and Technological Change and
Information Ecology: Mastering the information and nformation Ecology: Mastering the
information and
I
U.S.A.
k
knowledge Envknowledge Environmentironment
”,
Oxford University Press. NY.
”,
of determinants and moderators
A
Academy of Management JournalAcademy of Management Journal
19.Damanpour, Fariborz, (1991), “
, Vol. 34, No. 3: 555
Information Ecology: Mastering the information and Information Ecology: Mastering the
information and
Academy of Management Journalcademy of Management Journal
H
Community, Population, and
JournalJournal
Journalournal
, Vol. 39, No. 5: 1066.
J
117
Understanding and Managing Understanding and Managing
A
U
AdministrationAdministration
Administrationdministration
Implementation of Large Scale Innovation Programs
Journal of EducationalJournal of Educational
J
”,
Journal of Educationalournal of Educational
25.Geijsel, F. Sleegers, P. and Berg, R., (1999), “
Organizational Intelligences to Innovation
Innovative Genius: a Framework for Relating Individual and
Organizational Behaviorrganizational Behavior
Understanding and Managing nderstanding and Managing
”,
A
Academy of Management Reviewcademy of Management Review
Academy of Management ReviewAcademy of Management Review
, Vol. 21:
Architectural Innovation: reconfiguration of
QuarterlyQuarterly
30.Hetland, H. and Sandal, G. (2003), “
Q
695-702.
J
, 73 (4):
28.Hater, J. and Bass, B. (1988), “
Superiors Evaluations and Subordinates Perceptions of
”,
Journal ofournal of Applied PsychologyApplied Psychology
M
Outcomes and Personality Correlates
31.Ivancevich, John M.; Lorenzi, Peter; Skinner, Steven J. and Crosby, Philip B., (1997),
Management Quality and Competitivenessanagement Quality and Competitiveness
nd
“
Management Quality and CompetitivenessManagement Quality and Competitiveness
”, 2 ed., McGraw-Hill Companies Inc., U.S.A.
, 12 (2):147 - 170.
Transformational Leadership, Organizational Culture, and
33.Jones, Gareth, (1998), “
32.Jaskyte, Kristina, (2004), “
“,
Journal of Applied ournal of Applied
Leadership: A Meta-analytic Test of Their Relative Validity
J
Organizational Theoryrganizational Theory
Journal of Applied Journal of Applied
O
NonpNonprofit Management & Leadershiprofit Management & Leadership
,
U.S.A.
nd
”, 2 ed., Publishing Company Inc.,
”,
Nonponprofit Management & Leadershiprofit Management & Leadership
N
Organizational TheoryOrganizational Theory
The he Leadership QuarterlyLeadership Quarterly, ,
T
Vol. 14: 525-544.
”,
findings
The The Leadership QuarterlyLeadership Quarterly, ,
, 89, 755 – 768.
PsychologyPsychology
P
34.Judge, T.A., and Piccolo, R.F. (2004), “
Transformational and Transactional
Psychologysychology
118
36.Kark, Ronit; Shamir, Boas & Chen, Gilad, (2003), “
The Two Faces of Transformational
, Vol. 88,
J
Leader and Organizational Development Journaleader and Organizational Development Journal
Behavior
”,
Leadership: Empowerment and Dependency
Journal of Applied Psychologyournal of Applied Psychology
Journal of Applied PsychologyJournal of Applied Psychology
”,
39. Kotler, Philip and Armstrong, Gary, (1999), “
8th ed.,
No.2: 246-255.
Organizational Innovations in financial services in the UK
nternational nternational ournal of ournal of
\",
I II International nternational J JJ Journal of of
ournal
T
”,
Cororporate culture andporate culture and performanceperformance
The Free
C
“,
41.Kotter, J. P. (1996), “
The new rules: How to succeed in today'she new rules: How to succeed in today's postpost--
corporate worldcorporate world
The new rules: How to succeed in today'sThe new rules: How to succeed in today's postpost--
corporate worldcorporate world
40.Kotter, J. P. and Heskett, J. L. (1992), “
Press, New York.
Prentice – Hall International, Inc., U.S.A.
Principles of Marketingrinciples of Marketing
”,
, Vol. 19,Issue.1.
P
H
Human Resource Managementuman Resource Management
Human Resource ManagementHuman Resource Management
”,
by Followers
42.Krishnan, V. (1998), “
Influencing the Transformational Leadership: Strategies used
, 58 (3): 17-21.
Education DEducation Digestigest
Transformational and
E
International Association of Management International Association of Management
S
Growthrowth
GrowthGrowth
G
”,
Inc., U.S.A.
44.Leithwood, K. (1992), “
Transformational Leadership, Where does it stand?
“,
Differences
Journal CJournal Compilationompilation
Journal Cournal Compilationompilation
J
”,
, Vol.17, No. 3: 227- 244.
Transactional Leadership and Salesperson Performance
Academy of Marketing ScienceAcademy of Marketing Science
”,
Academy of Marketing Sciencecademy of Marketing Science
29: 115–134.
,
46.Marloes, Mark Reuvers; Van Engen, Claartje; J. Vinkenburg & Elisabeth Wilson-
, 49: 327–340.
J
Journalournal
JournalJournal
Behaviors: The Mediating Role of Core Job Characteristics
48.Piccolo, R.F., and Colquitt, J.A. (2006), “
Academy of Management cademy of Management
the New Zealand Public Sector
119
”,
L
51.Rafferty, Alannah E. & Griffin, Mark A., (2004), “
52.Sarros, James C.; Cooper, Brian K.; Santora, Joseph C., (2008), “
, 47: 232-242.
1 ed, Chapman & Hall, London.
I
R
Research Methods for Businessesearch Methods for Business
John Wiley & Sons.
57.Traill, B and Grunert, K. G., (1997), “
\",
\",
”,
P
th
PolPolicyicy
120
?@@@@@@@
@
?y?¾a@?à?b?y?¾a@?à?b?
?y?¾a@?à?b??y?¾a@?à?b?
ً K K
? ;u _ אt? a @ ;u _ אt? a @
? ;u _ אt? a @? ;u _ אt? a @
K K
?
ً K ً K
ً W W W W
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
W W W W
ﺃ
:
ً و: ً و: ًو: ً و
$
,א א
,אد א א
אد
KK
$ :א: $א
$ :א: א
,א א
,אد א א
אد
(
)
121
? ?? ?
? ?? ?
)
vB ?; א ن vB ?; א ن
%
\"# $
א &%
א א
وאق
א
!
KدK
B? T אB? Tא
?
1
? ;u _ אt? a @ ;u _ אt? a @
? ;u _ אt? a @? ;u _ אt? a @
F : אوB אl
Fא lא Bאو:
א
F
F : אوB אl
א :אو B lא
א
/وא.
א 01
* +א)( '
1
א א
وאق
א
!
KدK
4
3
K د K
א א
67 د *8אو
7
'
אن
!
ل
9
د:
;
!
ل
5
א א
وאق
א
!
ل
دא\"! !# 3"\2
122
? ?? ?
? ?? ?
)
<
?<<<<<<<<
(
2
<JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
<‚éŠ?]‚éŠ?]
< <K <K <K <K <? <? <? <?
<JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ<JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
J
,א א
,אد א א
אد
,א א
,אد א א
אد
?fé<?é??fé<?é?
?fé<?é?fé<?é?
<‚éŠ?]<‚éŠ?]
.
*\" * )* k
! * =?1C Q ? نو
،
? א$ 7
.
1
82
oJא
.
د א
א
ود א
8- N $ א! J
א عא
)
\"#$ א %د א "\
"\
،
ن _^ א ! א R!d
W W W W
د ,د,د ,د,
L 6JאAא ود E$א,AدK *
$8J א Kد,A אE$ A L 6J
א א ود *
$8J א
<
א عא א א عא א
א عא א א عא א
و א
د
و א א
د
א
و א
د
و א א
د
א
"\
א! م א نא\"
fg א R!d
Kد,A אE$ א ودA אL 6J *
$8J א Kد,A אE$ A L 6J
א א ود *
$8J א
fg
c(* -$]אو
=( و
،
.
\"m\"*![ و
$ 71 א א
? ?א!א.
)
oJ
ن fg
c(
و
Jو
Jو
Jو
وJ
ز
?,? ?~K %א F;aא?,א <= ن ; و_ ? ,? ?~K %?Loא F;aא?,א <= ن ; و_ ? Lo
ل (? אو[ g
tz א
Lo ? _?א <= ن ; و, אF;aא,? ?~K %? Lo ? _?א <= ن ; و, אF;aא,? ?~K %?
!
ً -d*
د א
א
ود א
. *
א ! א א42$
زאW W
אزא א
i
i' $ '$ א א
* ) ( '&$ %
س * ) ( '&% $س
س
123
1
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
א Bא B
()
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
40
30
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
? L
م د
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
–
50
–
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
41
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
30
א {N א א { Nא?|a 6 א א?|a 6
א {N א { Nא? |a 6א א? |a 6א
()
()
نودN ? K
2
< د,א
vB א B $[v B א B $[
vB א B $[ v B אB $[
3
2 &3 ?
51
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
س, ;
ٍل م د
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
~ ?N
@ @ @ @@ @ @ @
)(
א
ـ
10
15
10
5
א
5
?%
5
@v
5
א
()
?%
@v
?%
ـ
~ ?N
15
@%? v
?%
~ ?N
?N
@
5
ـ
%? v
א? ? 1
א? ? ? 1
?
?%
א
א
10
א
?%
10
א? ? 1
א? ? ?1
?
"\אدc,
15
? Iא7 א ? ? 1א
? ? Iא7 א ? ? 1א
?
4
? Iא7 א ? ? 1א
? ? Iא7 א ? ? 1א
?
15
ـ
124
لو?;5א
Eא دو!5
va אaא
3 א3 א
v
I א
I א
va אvaא
3 א3 א
I א
I א
א ~4? 2 א ~4א ? 2 א
אو?N
אوj\" ?N
:אو?N
א
د
א א
د
א
א
د
א א
د
א
אو?N
2
1
א k- = ن (* . لو?;5א $;* ? ? k
D$א ل!50
?N אو:
? '
c *) א \"-u 0
kو "\ لو?;5א
!5א
k - א5 . *( ن
cd - ?
7 F* א
ً9 لو?;5א * k
"\א !51
v
د [ \K
5
ن (k - 5
א5
=-א!5
*( ن k -
$-$א5
3
k-
- אcd
g.v K
א ;I
;Iא, E : א
א, E :
9
"\א د * F
* Rא $-و $ لو?;5א k
"\א م!5
10
* =* $ %!
ق !o
אא א
= [ [ )* d$
11
125
د * = 1لو?;5א
=* $א!5
N لو?;5א x $א * F
"\א م!5
א
د
א א
د
א
א
د
א א
د
א
15
!%
א!l < א!] 0א Rא لو?;5א k
"\א م!5
א : $ ,א, $ :
אو?N
אو?N
E
' ?
E
אوj\" ?N
:
אو
?N
M
:אو?N
3א vaא 3 א vaא
I א
I א
3 אva א3 אvaא
I א
I א
k*F* *אv*
. 1D א5;?لو
E$א م!5
19
18
*F
17
16
; -$א!5
[ لو?;5א * k * F א
!5א م ¤
v
21
! w مE$
و *و * F א لو?;5א ? g
!5 אcdD$
cdMS*= ز "\ن [ )* ل \"N¤
*
W
23
24
WI WI
א א
7 )
*k* Fאz ً א لو?;5א]b ً * -$
!5 אt!
22
-l * אv *
. %א5; אو
WI א I א
i #$ F * 1 !א
y ? x ; ! אx$ k א5;?لو
"\א م!5
! *) ز ?7א
E*
28
א
? i #$ v * F * אE D#$ k א5;?لو
!5 אc$d
27
!gא\" א
25
i
=-א ?و D لو?;5א x $ kא * k * F
"\א م!5
=- * Fس @-א ?و t! kא لو?;5א
!54 אB
d5א مJאد لو?;5א ;g^ 41\"$ kس 8 n
!5 אc$d
26
29
v K "\[ "\ن$
"\א
5א
y B i #$ k * F * אx $ k א5;?لو
!
126
"\א م5
*( ن א لو?;5א * . F
[א !5¹
mو k لو?;5א
¤א ص!5
א
د
א א
د
א
א
د
א א
د
א
30
E
אو?N
' ?
:אو?N
E
I א
I א
אو?N
אوj\" ?N
:אو?N
I א
I א
?
3 אva א3 אvaא
7$ د gS א¢
\"D
لو?;5א - k
א س !53
ً א? *¹
*= =- "\
c
لو?;5א ! $ k
"\א م!5
?z D $ "\*"\א
33
F* ? א
32
v*F* א
?? v
gS/ ¢ k - א5;? لو. *( ن
\"Dא ض!5
v \"b5א
v
gS 1 = د y k - א5;? لو. *( ن
!5 אc !
31
35
[F* 4
ن (* .لو?;5א * m\" k -
"\א م!5
#m אو- ? _^
d
\" z
"\א دdl) א
37
36
v
gS/ ¢ v?
\"D
! و?;5א
?Sאو ز i #$
38
א عא א א عא א
א عא א א عא א
א vaא 3א vaא 3
ع
عא א א?$J عא ?$J
40
?Nאو
?N אو:
?Nאو
? '
j\" ?Nאو
I א
I א
:אو?N
46
5א א א א ذ . ^£
אو E *S
(
)
8- N $ אd ( ] . * 4א
2
אo
45
44
43
o$
-א 0אدJ .א
אzo 2 4
oא
41
42
!. =9
¢א و א دא\"5א
S
!
oא
$ج
J א-
!
!o "\ج$ * c
!
! א \ gعא9 א א0א
47
א-d5
50
א א א ,
א JאN ,
א א א
א JאN
,
א א א
א JאN ,
א א א
א JאN
49
48
?
53
אd 1 F 5
א\"o\"5א % .د
55
)
xא g 5א )* *! 5א?9
54
52
!] א
128