Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Novel Concept of Container House With Zero Energetic Consumption
A Novel Concept of Container House With Zero Energetic Consumption
Piergiorgio Scaccaglia
SP Parma di Scaccaglia Piergiorgio
Mario Guareschi
ABertozzi snc
The original concept developed for industrial building has Constructive details and container temporary housing design
been extended to mobile metallic housing systems such as the are provided.
containers transported by trucks which are used for troops
and military command during field operations. This system INTRODUCTION
do not requires any external source of energy. It requires only
the presence of a water well or drilling a hole to place inside GENERALITIES
a closed loop exchanger which is used to stabilize ZEBRA means “Zero Energy Consumption Building totally
temperature of internal water which is used as a dynamic Renewable Addicted”. It is a new concept of building with
thermal barrier which maintains in the wellness conditions null energy consumption from fossil fuels in order to
inside the mobile housing equipment. maintain the comfort conditions both during the summer and
during the winter climatic cycle. It has been developed
Energetic costs of this system are related only to the very starting from a patent by Antonio Dumas [1]. The concept
reduced energy necessary for water pumping operations. It below this patent, even if presented at the end of the 70s, has
could be easily produced, together with necessary energy for been recently updated leading to the LESP (Low Exergy
light and instrumentation by a photovoltaic ceiling. The Structured Panel) adiabatic panel concept.
absence of fenestrations will be obviated by optic fiber based
external light capturing and distributing, together with air With the revitalization of the economic and oil crisis and the
ventilation system. worsening energy problems of today studies begun in 70's
and 80's, and then abandoned in the subsequent period
This paper presents the energetic balance of this military field characterized by the illusion of energy supply at low cost,
and building concept which can be used also to reduce the have been taken in account as the basis of novel studies and
surplus of naval container in the harbours of all the occidental projects.
Gratis copy for Antonio Dumas
Copyright 2012 SAE International
E-mailing, copying and internet posting are prohibited
Downloaded Thursday, March 29, 2012 06:03:27 AM
It is well known that a good portion of the wellness high temperature energy supply and the relations between the
conditions of a building depends on the thermo-physical use of radiant heating system and human comfort conditions
envelope of the buildings and its thermal quality. It is also [2, 3, 4, 5].
known that walls can be insulated by the presence of air
cavities or acclimatized by radiant floor and wall. In In particular it is well known to adopt different systems to
particular, several techniques are known and used for increase the wellness conditions mixed together with the
increasing energetic efficiency of a building and the comfort exigency of increasing the general thermal efficiency of the
conditions for occupants: system. In particular two technologies can be cited:
• prefabricated cladding for thermal insulation; 1). Ventilated facades: they increase the climatic insulation
• ventilated facades; of walls through the use of air cavities with circulating air in
communication with interior environment or exterior (Fig. 1);
• thermally insulating materials to decrease the heat losses to
the surroundings. 2). Radiant acclimatization: in many building related
applications radiant floors and walls are used, which permits
The following applications are also of common utilization: the use of low temperature water [Fig.2] for heating purposes
1). the so-called solar plans with the ability of capturing the (33-45 °C).
solar radiation;
High energetic efficiency and passive building concepts have
2). the use of radiant “floor” or “ceiling” for internal heating been developed to meet very advanced energy performance
which operates using low temperature energetic sources (33 ÷ requirements.
45 °C).
1). demand for useful energy for heating less than 15 kWh /
It is also known that low temperature energy supply is less m2 per year;
expensive on an economic and exergetic point of view than a
Gratis copy for Antonio Dumas
Copyright 2012 SAE International
E-mailing, copying and internet posting are prohibited
Downloaded Thursday, March 29, 2012 06:03:27 AM
2). no thermal bridges; Referring to Fig. 3 it can be identified the following plant
3). total primary energy demand less than 120 kWh / m2 per components:
year;
1). building wall;
4). percentage of days with air temperature less than 25 ° C
under 10%. 2). internal coil for the dynamic insulation of the wall;
In particular the energetic evaluation has been defined by The purpose of the LESP system is to create a barrier able to
using the general framework of Italian standardization [6, 7, minimize building heat loss and ensure an increased sensation
8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16]. of comfort with the unique contribution of internal energy of
low-level or derived from renewable sources. In particular
this project aims to maintain thermo-hygrometric levels of
THE LESP WALL wellness constant within the building, regardless of external
The idea of ZEBRA wall can be considered a further weather conditions, without the need of energy supplies from
development of the above basic concepts, in order to produce fossil fuels.
a dynamic building envelope with a level of energetic
dispersion much lower than any other system known today. It The project aims to achieve objectives Zebra far more
uses a novel thermal cut by circulating water which is ambitious than those associated with the passive house
presented in detail in the following paragraph. concept:
The purpose of the LESP panel concept is to create a This solution even if has some difficulties for the use into
complete building envelope system able to minimize overall large buildings presents interesting benefits in terms of
building heat loss and ensure an enhanced comfort for energy consumption of the building itself. In many cases it
occupants. In particular the novel dynamic building concept cannot need any energetic source except the necessary
can use low level energy sources and renewable energy pumping system for the water.
sources. The main objective of this concept is to maintain the
thermo-hygrometric levels of well-being constant within the
building, regardless of external weather conditions, without
the need of energy supplied from fossil fuels.
By this study also different panel architectures seem possible is the representation of the external and internal adductive
and even in terms of design. One of these solutions is related coefficient.
to the use of a container building, which can be interesting
both in terms of performances and of building simplicity.
(2)
the waste of heat from this new configuration and
(1)
Where
•
(3)
the corresponding new amount of flow assigned outside,
is the thermal resistance of the wall;
these are obviously to be determined depending on the
• distance x from the inner wall of the plate.
where the subscript t indicated the amount of heat subtracted Problem-free dispatch has been assisted by the
to the ground. standardization of transport units, such as containers, while
the standardization of certain components and some
This concept is nearly similar to geothermal heat pumps, but dimensions permits the use of standard handling equipment
uses directly the water in the ground to improve the system. and means of transport [Fig 7].
The benefit of this solution is that the waste heat dispersed
from the walls is provided almost entirely by thermal The load-carrying element of all box containers is a steel
exchanges in the ground. framework [Fig. 7], consisting of four corner posts and two
bottom side rails, two top side rails, two bottom rails, a front
In particular, a careful design activity and a correct definition top end rail and a door header.
of water velocity depending on climatic conditions allow an
effective reduction the heat dispersions of the building. In In Fig. 8 it is possible to see the container walls:
particular, the behaviour of the system parameters can be
adjusted according to different water temperature in the a). Lateral walls;
ground after the exchange. This dynamic system provides an b). Initial and end walls;
effective insulation to reduce heat loss depending on the
position of the dynamic water insulation inside the wall. c). Ceiling and floor.
Figure 8. Container's walls: (a) Side walls; (b) End walls; (c) Roof panel and pavement
In particular the design of the walls of the system is The presented design can certainly minimize the presence of
optimized to minimize the presence of thermal bridges and thermal bridges, reducing them to the corners only,
irregular conduction zones to minimize the energetic minimizing their effect on thermal properties of the building.
dispersions.
Gratis copy for Antonio Dumas
Copyright 2012 SAE International
E-mailing, copying and internet posting are prohibited
Downloaded Thursday, March 29, 2012 06:03:27 AM
The general Container house layout is represented in Fig. 12. ENERGETIC EVALUATION
CLIMATIC DATA
An effective evaluation of the energetic performances of the
above described container house requires to define the
geographic location where the system is located. In particular,
because of nationality of the authors and the disposability of
meteorological data, about the town of Bologna. Climatic
data are reported in Table 1.
Indoor temperature 20 ° C
In particular the following geometric data (Table 4) have
been assumed:
Table 4. Geometric Data and Thermal Properties
The following average annual energetic values for 1 m2 of net It has been calculated the thermal conductivities of the
plant area (Table 7) have been obtained. external and internal wall, which can be assumed:
Table 8. Average annual energetic values for 1 m2 of net plant area with Zebra walls
Figure 14. Dispersions through internal wall in different conditions and net energy needs during Winter
Figure 15. Dispersions through internal wall in different conditions and net energy needs during Summer
Gratis copy for Antonio Dumas
Copyright 2012 SAE International
E-mailing, copying and internet posting are prohibited
Downloaded Thursday, March 29, 2012 06:03:27 AM
EXTERNAL HEAT DISPERSIONS Assuming that ground water temperature is 14° C, that the
Heat dispersions trough the exterior envelope of the maximum consented difference of temperature during winter
acclimatized walls can be calculated by a simple energetic is 1° C and the same during Summer. It is evident that for
balance. In this way it can be easily calculated the water mass average temperature between 12 and 18°C the system has no
flow (and speed in the coils) to produce the necessary thermal convenience. In particular the analysis of system convenience
barrier. can be performed on the basis of the following schema (Table
10):
It can be easily calculated and results are reported as a
function of water average temperature in Table 9, both in
winter and summer.
Table 9 can be understood by considering the sign convention Table 10. Operative Model
adopted: minus means that water must be cooled, while plus
means that it must be heated to maintain thermal equilibrium.
In particular the most interesting configuration considered is To describe the wall behaviour an equivalent thermal
the one which has an average exchange temperature of 12°C transmittance can be defined (Eqn. 5).
during winter and 18 °C during summer. In this case the
water can be operated and exchange at groundwater
temperature, by use of ground based exchangers, having a
free energy contribution such as the one schematized in Fig.
3. (5)
In these operative conditions it is evaluated as 0,342.
Gratis copy for Antonio Dumas
Copyright 2012 SAE International
E-mailing, copying and internet posting are prohibited
Downloaded Thursday, March 29, 2012 06:03:27 AM
The energetic exchanges needed for the water thermal shield In particular the following consumption data have been
can be evaluated and water mass flow velocity can be evaluated for one occupant (Table 10).
defined. By assuming an efficiency of the heat exchanger
equal to 0,5 it can be evaluated the following data (Table 12). Table 14. Appliance consumptions
Pipes are assumed to have a diameter of 1″ (24,5 mm) and
operations are assumed to be 16 hours per day.
Table 15. Photovoltaic Performance analysis helps to maintain an effective balance between the
operative temperature and the mean radiant temperature can
create a more comfortable space.
On the other side the new wall model has the advantage of By these considerations the weight of a ZEBRA based
increasing human comfort. It is well known that Macpherson container house will not affect negatively the energy
[18] identified six factors that affect thermal sensation. These consumption for road transport. In particular it could be used
factors are air temperature, humidity, air speed, mean radiant as to transport fright inside during surface transport, even if
temperature (MRT) [19], metabolic rate and clothing levels. this hypothesis will require a careful interior design. A further
hypothesis for an important improvement of transportation
It is not sufficient for heat comfort only to heat the air on could be realized by using the chassis of a foldable container
certain temperature. Feelings of heat or cold perception are in this case there is a certain lose in term of time for
more complex and are influenced by: installation but also a sure gain in terms of transportation
costs because at least 3 container houses could be moved by
• temperatures of areas limiting the heated area
one truck reducing the mobility costs.
• velocity of air in room (draught)
• person's activity and his/her clothes
CONCLUSIONS
The proposed building model permits an effective reduction
A fundamental importance is assumed by the temperatures of of thermal needs by design using the water circulation Zebra
areas limiting heated area e.g. walls, ceiling, floor, windows. wall. In particular these applications regulating the
Cool walls remove radiated heat from exposed skin and temperature of the internal walls with a negligible energy
clothes. Cold walls or to the contrary high temperature of need can increase the radiant comfort for occupants,
radiant source is perceived this way. maximizing internal wellness.
In particular the proposed building system allows realizing an It is also a low cost, and easy to move solutions for a
effective regulation of the indoor Mean Radiant Temperature comfortable life in any situation of temporary housing needs
which is usually regulated by enclosure performances. During and in the case of slow moving champs, such as military.
winter, as the quality of wall increases, the wall is also
warmer and therefore higher the mean radiant temperature. This building concept has the advantage of being more than
The ZEBRA concept, which needs a further investigation and auto sufficient energetically and of being adaptable in terms
Gratis copy for Antonio Dumas
Copyright 2012 SAE International
E-mailing, copying and internet posting are prohibited
Downloaded Thursday, March 29, 2012 06:03:27 AM
of renewable production in any climatic condition. Further 14. UNI EN ISO 15927-1, Prestazione termo igrometrica
studies are necessary to produce an effective optimization of degli edifici - Calcolo e presentazione dei dati climatici -
the container house in terms of walls composition and of Medie mensili dei singoli elementi meteorologici;
plant optimization.
15. UNI EN ISO 15927-6, Prestazione termo igrometrica
degli edifici - Calcolo e presentazione dei dati climatici -
This paper demonstrates the energetic feasibility and some
Differenze di temperatura cumulate (gradi giorno);
technical features related to this building concept. In
particular the authors aims to promote an international group 16. UNI/TS11300-1, Prestazioni energetiche degli edifici,
of study comprising research institutions and companies Parte 1: Determinazione del fabbisogno di energia termica
which could lead to the optimization of this building concept, dell'edificio per la climatizzazione estiva ed invernale;
its personalization for different operative scenarios and to its
17. Madonia, M., Dumas, A., Trancossi, M., Bonnici, M.,
industrialization.
Studio del comportamento di due pannelli a diversa tipologia
di taglio termico, 66° Congresso Nazionale ATI - Rende
REFERENCES (Cosenza), 5-9 Settembre 2011;
1. Tecnicoop Soc. Coop. a r.l. e DUMAS A., Brevetto per 18. ASHRAE, Fundamentals, American Society of Heating,
modello industriale in edilizia con funzioni di coibentazione, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, Inc. Atlanta,
IT Patent no. 4907, 1979; 2001;
2. Siegenthaler, J., Radiant I Heating & Cooling Manual 19. ASHRAE Terminology, ASHRAE Handbook CD,
2008, Radiant Panel Association, 2008; American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-
3. VV.AA., Radiant II Heating & Cooling Manual 2008, Conditioning Engineers, Inc. Atlanta, 1999-2002;
Radiant Panel Association, 2008;
4. Jones, B. W., Chapman, K. S., Simplified Method to CONTACT INFORMATION
Factor Mean Radiant Temperature (MRT) into Building and Antonio Dumas
HVAC System Design, ASHRAE. Research Project 657, The antonio.dumas@unimore.it
Building Comfort Analysis Program, Kansas State
University, 1994; Michele Trancossi
5. Kaushik, S. C., Kaul, S., Thermal comfort in buildings michele.trancossi@unimore.it
through a mixed water-mass thermal storage wall, Building
and Environment, Volume 24, Issue 3, 1989, Pages 199-207; Mauro Madonia
6. Directive 2002/91/EC of the European Parliament and of mauro.madonia@unimore.it
the Council of 16 December 2002 on the energy performance
of buildings; Maurizio Bonnici
maurizio.bonnici@unimore.it
7. EN 15603, Energy performance of buildings - Overall
energy use and definition of energy ratings; Piergiorgio Scaccaglia
8. CEN/TR 15615, Explanation of the general relationship spparma@libero.it
between various European Standards and the Energy
Performance of Buildings Directive (EPBD); Mario Guareschi
mario@abertozzi.it
9. prEN 15316-4-1, Heating systems in buildings - Method
for calculation of system energy requirements and system
efficiencies - Space heating generation systems, boilers; DEFINITIONS/ABBREVIATIONS
10. UNI EN ISO 7345, Isolamento termico - Grandezze
fisiche e definizioni; LESP
Low Exergy Structured Panel
11. UNI EN ISO 7726, Ergonomia degli ambienti termici -
Strumenti per la misurazione delle grandezze fisiche;
12. UNI EN ISO 7730, Ergonomia degli ambienti termici -
Determinazione analitica e interpretazione del benessere Thermal energy flux for unitary area [W/m2 K]
termico mediante il calcolo degli indici PMV e PPD e dei
criteri di benessere termico locale;
13. UNI EN ISO 10456, Materiali e prodotti per edilizia - Thermal energy flux for the whole building [W/m2]
Procedimenti per la determinazione dei valori termici
dichiarati e di progetto;
Gratis copy for Antonio Dumas
Copyright 2012 SAE International
E-mailing, copying and internet posting are prohibited
Downloaded Thursday, March 29, 2012 06:03:27 AM
αi
Coefficient of internal convection [W/m2K]
λ
Thermal Conductivity [W/m K]
S
Wall thickness [m]
αe
Coefficient of external convection [W/m2 K]
Ti
Indoor Temperature [°C]
Te
Outdoor Temperature [°C]
The Engineering Meetings Board has approved this paper for publication. It has Positions and opinions advanced in this paper are those of the author(s) and not
successfully completed SAE's peer review process under the supervision of the session necessarily those of SAE. The author is solely responsible for the content of the paper.
organizer. This process requires a minimum of three (3) reviews by industry experts. SAE Customer Service:
Tel: 877-606-7323 (inside USA and Canada)
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a
Tel: 724-776-4970 (outside USA)
retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, Fax: 724-776-0790
photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the prior written permission of SAE. Email: CustomerService@sae.org
ISSN 0148-7191 SAE Web Address: http://www.sae.org
Printed in USA