Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Group 16 FYP Report (Final)
Group 16 FYP Report (Final)
ASPEN HYSYS
BATCH 2017-18
i
CERTIFICATE
This is certify that the work in the project report “TO SIMULATE AND OPTIMIZE
SULFUR RECOVERY UNIT USING ASPEN HYSYS” is entirely written by the
following enlisted students under the supervision of Mrs. Tuba Siraj . This project is
submitted to the Department of Chemical Engineering, NED University of Engineering and
Technology for the fulfillment of the Bachelor’s Degree in Chemical Engineering.
Group Members:
________________ ________________
Supervisor Co Supervisor
_______________ _______________
Examiner 1 Examiner 2
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
At this very onset starting with the name of Almighty ALLAH, The most beneficial, most
merciful, Compassionate, and Gracious who allowed us to complete this project. We dedicate
our work to our beloved parents. It would have utterly impossible to initiate and complete
this project without their effortless supports, who unconditionally provided the resources of
our project. We would like to thank the NED University of Engineering and Technology,
Karachi for supporting us in the completion and compilation of our project.
Firstly, we feel honored to express our deepest thanks to Prof. Dr. Inayatullah Memon,
Chairman of the Chemical Engineering Department who allow us to do this project
We are hugely indebted to our internal project advisor Mrs. Tubs Siraj for her
enlightening suggestions and intellectual advice. His professionalism, guidance energy
thoughtfulness dedication, and inspiration and will serve us as an example in our professional
career. We would also like to thank Dr. Faizan Raza for his valuable and precious time and
guideline
iii
ABSTRACT
This project is designed to simulate and optimize the Sulfur Recovery Unit. In natural gas
refinery feedstock contain impurities such as sulfur and nitrogen. During purification the
sulfur is conveted to H2S during hydrotreating.
In this report the available processes for the recovery of elemental sulfur from H 2S are
discussed and modified clause process is chosen as the best alternative among all process due
to its high recovery.
The major focus is on modeling and simulation to get highest recovery of sulfur with low
capital and operating cost.
Despite it’s simple process, the stability of sulfur in elemental form at different
temperature range and selection of best available process according to the composition of
feedstock and highest recovery is very complicated.The most attractive aspects of this
process is techno-economical analysis.
Note: More will be added after the completion of project
iv
Title Page No.
CERTIFICATE…………………………….………………………………………………….ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT…………………………………...……………………………….iii
ABSTRACT………………………………………...………………………………………..iv
TABLE OF CONTENT……………………………………………………………………….v
LIST OF FIGURES…………………………………………………………………….…….ix
LIST OF TABLES…………………………………………………………………...………..x
NOMENCLATURE AND LIST OF SYMBOLS………………………….…………….….xii
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION …………………………………........................................1
1.1 CHEMISTRY OF ELEMENTAL SULPHUR …………………………….......................1
1.2 ROLE OF SULFUR IN GASOLINE QUALITY SPECIFICATION...……......................2
1.3 WORLDWIDE PRODUCTION OF ELEMENTAL SULFUR…………….....................5
1.4 ALLOTROPES OF SULFUR ………………. ………………………….....................….6
1.5 COMBINATION OF SULPHUR WITH OTHER PERIODIC ELEMENT ......................6
1.6 RECOVERY OF SULFUR …………………………………………......................…......6
1.7 DEVELOPMENT OF SULPHUR RING …………………………….........................…..6
1.8 ELEMENTAL SULPHUR …………………………………………….......................…..6
1.9 SOURCES OF SULPHUR …………………………………………….........................…6
1.10 ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATION AND ECO FRIENDLY ……..............................7
1.11 USES OF SULPHUR……………………………………………………........................8
1.11.1 Manufacture of rubber product gun powder and fungicide in plants ......................8
1.11.2 Utilization of sulphur in batteries ……………………….........................................8
1.12 MEASUREMENT OF SULPHUR IN REFINERY SECTOR ……….............................8
1.13 SULPHUR IN FERTILIZER INDUSTRY …………………………............................8
1.14 PROBLEM STATEMENT …………………………………………....…....................9
1.16 ACID GAS RAIN ……………………………………………………...........................9
1.17 OBJECTIVE …………………………………………………………….......................10
v
1.18 BACKGROUND OF STUDY ……………………………………………..………....10
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE SURVEY…………………………………………...............12
2.1 WORLD PETROLEUM RESERVES…………………………………………...............12
2.2 SWEET AND SOUR CRUDE OIL ………………………………………............…….12
2.2.1 Sour gas …………………………………………………………….............………12
2.2.2 Major location of sweet crude oil…………………………...............................…...12
2.3 ACID GAS …………………………………………………………............……………12
2.3.1 Source of acid gas …………………………………………………….....................12
2.3.1.1 Natural gas ……………………………………………………..........……….13
2.3.2 Necessity Of Removing Acid Gas …………………………...................................13
2.3.2.1 Environmental protection agency ………………………….............................13
2.4 HYDROGEN SULPHIDE ……………………………………………...........………….13
2.4.1 Sources of hydrogen sulphide ………………………………...................................14
2.4.1.1 From Amine Treating Unit …………………………………...............……….14
2.4.1.2 From Sour Water Stripping Unit ……………………………..................……14
2.4.2 Uses Of Hydrogen Sulfide …………………………………………........................14
2.4.2.1 Sulfuric Acid And Elemental Sulfur Production………....................................14
2.4.2.2 As A Reagent …………………………………………………........………….14
2.4.2.3 Nuclear Power Plant …………………………………………...............……..14
2.4.2.4 As A Chemical Warfare ………………………………………….............…...14
2.5 SULFUR………………………………………………………………………..........…..15
2.5.1 Elemental Sulfur As Primary Product……………………..............................…….15
2.5.1.1 In Batteries ………………………………………………........………………15
2.5.1.2 Used In Matches ………………………………………………........………...15
2.2.1.3 In Explosive ………………………………………………………….......……15
2.5.1.4 Gunpowder ……………………………………………………………......…..15
2.5.1.5 Insecticide And Fungicide ………………………………………….................15
2.5.1.6 In Production Of Sulfuric Acid By Contact Process……..............................…16
vi
2.5.1.7 Lowering The Soil pH With Sulfur ……………………..................…………..16
2.6 TAIL GAS AS BY-PRODUCT ……………………………………………….………...16
2.7 PAST, PRESENT, AND FUTURE OF RAW MATERIAL AND PRODUCT …….…..16
2.7.1 Sulfur As Primary Product ……………………...…………………….....................16
2.8 AVAILABLE PROCESSES FOR THE PRODUCTION OF SULFUR………………...17
2.8.1 Oxygen-Based Clauss Process ………………………………………….............….17
2.8.2 Clauss Oxygen- Based Process Expansion ………………..................………….....18
2.8.3 Richards Sulfur Recovery Process ………………………………..................…......19
2.8.4 Super Clauss Process ……………………………………………….........………...19
2.8.5 Modified Clauss Process ………………………………………………..........…….20
2.9 COMPARITIVE ANALYSIS AMONG DIFFERENT PROCESSES ……………….....22
CHAPTER 3: PROCESS DESCRIPTION ………………………………………………...23
3.1 PROCESS SELECTION ……………………………………………………………..…23
3.1.1 Advantages Of Modified Claus Process ……………………………...................….24
3.1.1.1 Highest Purity …………………………………………………................……24
3.1.1.2 Environmental Friendly …………………………….......……………….….....24
3.1.1.3 Low Capital Cost ………………………………………………………...……24
3.1.1.4 High Design Capacity ………………………………………………….……24.
3.1.1.5 Low Operating Cost ………………………………………………………......24
3.2 EQUIPMENTS ………………………………………………………………...….……24.
3.2.1 Thermal Reactor ……………………………………………………………........…24
3.2.2 Acid Gas Burner …………………………………………………………….....….25.
3.2.3 Combustion Air Blower ……………………………………………………............26
3.2.4 Waste Heat Boiler ………………………………………………………….......…..26
3.2.5 Sulphur Condenser………………………………………………………........…….27
3.2.5.1 Filters …………………………………………………………………….………27
3.2.6 Reheaters ……………………………………………………………………....…...28
3.3 PROCESS DESCRIPTION ……………………………………………………….…….29
vii
3.3.1 Hydrodesulfrization Process ………………………………………….................…29
3.3.2 Sulfur Recovery Unit ………………………………………………................……29
3.3.2.1 Claus Section …………………………………………………….....………...30
3.3.2.1.1 Reaction Furnace ………………………………………………….......……30
3.3.2.1.2 Sulfur Condenser…………………………....................................................30
3.3.2.1.3 Catalytic Reactors …………………………………………………..........…30
3.4 PROCESS FLOW DIAGRAM………………………………………….....…………….31
CHAPTER 4 PROCESS MODEL ………………………………………………....………32
4.1 FUNDAMENTAL COMPONENTS SELECTION……………………………..........…32
4.2 PROPERTY PACKAGE SELECTION ………………………………………....……...33
4.3 UNIT MODEL SELECTION …………………………………………………....……...34
4.3.1 Thermal Reactor …………………………………………………………...........….34
4.3.2 Heat Exchanger ………………………………………………………….........……34
4.3.3 Seperator…………………………………………………………………......……..34
4.3.4 Catalytic Reactor…………………………………………………………................34
4.4 ASSUMPTIONS…………………………………………………………………...…….35
CHAPTER 5: MATERIAL & ENERGY BALANCES………………………………...…..36
5.1 MATERIAL BALANCE ……………………………………………………..…………36
5.1.1 Reaction Furnace ……………………………………………………........………..36
5.1.2 Ftrst Catalytic Reactor ………………………………………………...............…...39
5.2 ENERGY BALANCE …………………………………………………………………..42
5.2.1 Overall Energy Balance ……………………………………………….............…...43
5.2.2 Energy Balance On Burner …………………………………………............……...45
5.2.3 Energy Balance On Furnace …………………………………………............…….46
5.2.4 Energy Balance On Condenser-01 ……………………………………..............…..47
5.2.5 Energy Balance On Reheater-01 …………………………………..............……….49
5.2.6 Energy Balance On 1st Catalytic Reactor-01………………….................………...50
5.2.7 Energy Balance On Condenser-02 …………………………………..............……..51
viii
5.2.8 Energy Balance On Reheater 02 ……………………………………...............…....52
5.2.9 Energy Balance On Second Catalytic Reactor …………………..............................54
5.2.10 Energy Balance On Condenser-03 ……………………................………………..56
REFERENCE...........................................................................................................................58
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF TABLES
xi
NOMENCLATURE AND LIST OF SYMBOLS
xii
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
The term elemental sulfur comes from a latin word that means “to burn”. Elemental
Sulphur is a non-metallic element and belongs to the group of oxygen group [VI A]
(chalcogen) of the periodic table that occurs naturally both in the combine and free state as
the most reactive element and is found as the thirteen most abundant element in the earth
crust and its proportion in the earth crust is found to be 0.03 to 0.06 %. Whereas the deeper
layer of the earth crust contains a great amount of sulfur in pure and crystalline form. The
percentage of sulfur in seawater is found to be 0.09 % and is mostly in the form of sulfate.
Sulfur due to its reactive nature can react with all the elements except gold and platinum
and thus can be used as a good source to extract metals and their compounds. Many ways and
technologies have been used to separate Sulphur in their elemental form to make the
environment safe from toxicity. The Claus process, modified clause, super clause, and Frasch
process extracts elemental sulphur using amine and sour glasses and gives the final product
in the form of elemental sulphur. The elemental sulphur has a wide scope of the study to
regulate environmental conditions.
Organic sulfur is also found in gasoline diesel and fuel oil as acidic sulphur.
(mercaptans)and non-acidic Sulphur as (thiophenes, sulfides, and disulfides). Elemental
sulphur is mostly found in diesel in diesel.
The Donahue describes the summary of the structure of the Sulphur and its allotropes.
Schmidt reviewed the general properties of sulfur and eight new metastable allotropes.
Harris discovered the properties of malt. The main purpose of this study is to enhance or
optimize the amount of elemental sulphur. [1]
1
Figure 1.1 Structure and properties of elemental Sulphur1.2
2
Table 1.1 Expected regional gasoline sulphur content
REGION 2012 2015 2020 2025 2030
800
600
400
200
0
US AND Latin America Europe Middle Africa
CANADA
Name of regions
3
Role of gasoline quality specification - 2015
600
Name of regions
80
60
40
20
0
US AND Latin America Europe Middle Africa
CANADA
Name of regions
80
60
40
20
0
US AND Latin America Europe Middle Africa
CANADA
Name of regions
4
1.3 WORLDWIDE PRODUCTION OF ELEMENTAL SULPHUR (METRIC TONS)
Table 1.2 Worldwide production [2]
Region of world 2012 2015 2020 2025 2030
producing sulfur
US AND CANADA Column1 Column2 Column3 Column4 Column5
Latin America 30 30 10 10 10
Europe 520 255 130 45 30
Middle East 13 10 10 10 10
Africa 605 235 75 25 16
795 493 245 165 95
WORLDWIDE
PRODUCTION (METRIC TONS)
PRODUCTION DATA
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
NAMES OF COUNTRIES
Figure 1.6: World wide production data [3]
5
1.4 ALLOTROPES OF SULPHUR
1) Monoclinic (beta)
2) Rhombic(alpha)
3) Gamma
A half of capacity material of sulfur is available in the USA, Canada, Japan France,
Poland, and Mexico are the significant sulfur exporters of the world.
The form of sulfur naturally occurs in three forms that are S2, S6, and S8, as the
temperature increases the S8 rings will polymerize themselves into other forms of sulfur The
transition between different forms of sulfur occurs naturally and in different forms by
utilizing the enthalpy of reaction. With a high-temperature reaction, the S6 and S8 rings open.
From the oil and gas production, sulfur that is recovered or mined is known as brimstone
or elemental sulfur.
The major and the secondary sources of sulfur are S0₂ and H₂S. The sources of S0₂ is
industrial water and flue gases while the major source of H₂S is obtained from the sour
natural gas, petroleum refinery products and coke-oven natural gas.
6
Table 1.3: Typical properties of sulphur
Atomic number 16
Flashpoint 405 ⁰F
7
For environmental regulation control, it also regulates and the SRU unit. One of the most
demanding eco-friendly and optimized units as it optimizes the production of sulfur by using
modified claus process. [4]
9
1.16 OBJECTIVE
Our objective of this project is to optimize the production of a Sulfur recovery by varing
different temperature and pressure conditions here in which we are using two allotropes of
Sulphur that is S₂ and S₈ which are the most stable allotrope of Sulfur. For this purpose, we
are using the modified clause process among all processes as this process has the highest
efficiency and will do the case study on types of equipment of SRU for the attainment of
maximum efficiency.
Production of sour natural gas and higher sulfur content crude oil has been increasing in the world
and new technologies are emerging to recover Sulphur from H2S from these valuable products.
The natural gas deposits and crude oil deposits (rock shell) obtained from reservoirs contains
many impurities which increases the pH and make the gas toxic in order to avoid corrosion ,poisoning
and fouling and to make this gas environmental acceptable, it is sent through different operations
which contains different number of purifying stages. One of the major and economical purifying
process is SRU.
The Sulphur recovery unit is a major regulatory unit of the oil and gas sector and natural gas
consumption sector process for the production of elemental Sulfur by the reaction with H 2S and S02.
The SRU unit plays a large role in refinery processing, different methods have been employed to
recover elemental Sulfur from natural gas and diesel oil. The modified clause process has been
considered the most significant and economical method for recovering elemental Sulphur from
desulphurization (invented by an English scientist name carl fried rich clause a germen company I.G
fare industry A.G) This is the rich acid gas method where most of the H2S is converted before going
into the catalytic section are used to maximize Sulphur recover efficiency.
In our process we are using modified claus process which is one of the major process for the
conversion of H2S in elemental Sulfur .The end product will be Sulfur , water and thermal energy
The Sulphur plant producing liquid Sulphur consist of the degassing section and tail gas recovery
unit (TGTU).
10
11
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE SURVEY
12
2.3.1.1 Natural Gas
In 1875 Britain produced natural gas or methane gas from coal and used it in the gas
lamp. In modern times the first drill internationally to obtain natural gas was drilled in 1821
in Fredonia, NY. Initially, it was found below 27ft depth when drilled by William Athwart to
get the high pressure of the gas.
Raw Natural gas obtained from a well is called wet natural gas because it contains
impurities, contaminants, acid gas, water vapor, and some other undesired component. To
remove these impurities natural gas is processed through different processing units. Firstly, at
the collection point, it is sent to a separator vessel where free liquid water and Condensate of
natural gas are removed. The natural gas is then sent to an oil refinery where the first step is
the removal of acid gas. There are many processes available for acid gas removal e.g., amine
treating when the natural gas becomes purified and all the impurities removed and only
contain methane (CH₄) is called dry natural gas.
2.3.2 Necessity Of Removing Acid Gas
Acid gas can cause damage, corrosion, and rusting to the pipeline and the equipment
result in shortens the lifespan of both pipeline and equipment and can cost millions to replace
these pipelines.In addition to its corrosive nature acid gas can cause serious health
complications in humans. Due to their dangerous nature acid gas must be highly controlled.
In past, gas producers were incinerated or flare the acid gases into the atmosphere but due
to environmental concerns and due to the growing SO₂ emission of a small amount of acid
gas to the surrounding is prohibited that’s why H₂S removed in the refinery from the acid gas
removal section is recovered.
2.3.2.1 Environmental Protection Agency (EAP)
In the US the standard for SO₂ is set in 2010, the quantity of SO₂ in the air is 75 parts per
billion for 1 hour. When SO₂ is combined with H2O it forms H2SO4 which is the main
constituent of acid gas.
2.4 HYDROGEN SULPHIDE
H2S is also known as sulphurated hydrogen or stink damp. It is present in crude oil and
natural gas along with CO2 (acid gas). It cannot be discarded into the environment due to its
toxic nature. The feedstocks for the sulfur recovery unit are acid gas that is obtained from the
ATU (Amine Treating unit) and sour gas is obtained from SWSU (sour water stripping unit).
Both the gases contain a significant amount of H₂S and other acidic gases. H₂S is colorless
and very explosive with an odor like a rotten egg. Its boiling point is -60.4⁰C and the freezing
point is -85⁰C. When it is burnt in presence of oxygen, it burns blue, forming sulfur dioxide
and water. [7], [8]
13
2.4.1 Source of Hydrogen Sulfide
The feedstocks are acid and sour gas containing Hydrogen sulfide and other gases
coming from the Amine Treating Unit and Sour Water Stripping unit.
2.4.1.1 From Amine Treating Unit
An Amine Treating Unit having a packed column or tray is used for separating hydrogen
sulfide from acid gas. From the top of the tower in a packed column lean amine is circulated
by using a pump and gas is introduced from the bottom of the column. The hydrogen sulfide
gets adsorbed by lean amine and as a result, sweet gas is obtained leaving from the top and
lean amine becomes rich amine flows through the bottom by gravity. On the regeneration of
amine to remove hydrogen sulfide by heating with the help of a reboiler, hydrogen sulfide
goes to the sulfur recovery unit from the top of the column while lean amine is obtained from
the bottom.
2.4.1.2 From Sour Water Stripping unit
The sour water stripping unit consists of a tray column and reboiler. Pre-heated sour
water is introduced into the stripper, H₂S gets separated from water by heating with the help
of a reboiler. The H₂S gas leaving from the top goes to the sulfur recovery section while the
bottom product from the column that is the water goes to the stripped water storage tank to
reuse for internal circulation.
2.4.2 Uses of Hydrogen Sulfide
Hydrogen Sulfide has a reflective ratio close to air which makes it difficult to detect with the
human eye. Despite being flammable and reactive gas, there are quite a few ways in which it
can be utilized.
2.4.2.1 Sulfuric Acid and Elemental Sulfur Production
The principle use for H2S is in the creation of sulfuric acid and essential sulfur. Sulfuric
acid is used in fertilizers and making several chemicals. [9]
2.4.2.2 As a reagent
It is beneficial on the grounds for the preparation of different types of reduced sulfur
compounds. The reagent is a starting compound of a chemical reaction. [10]
2.4.2.3 Nuclear Power Plants
In nuclear power plants, H₂S is used in the production of heavy water, an option in
contrast to regular water that empowers nuclear reactors to utilize standard uranium fuel. [10]
2.4.2.4 As Chemical Warfare
H₂S is also used in chemical warfare. Modern industries, like iron smelters, food
processing plants, and landfills produce or use hydrogen sulfide. [10]
14
2.5 SULPHUR
Sulfur is a nonmetallic element of group 16 in the periodic table. Pure sulfur has the
following properties which are tasteless, odorless brittle solid that is yellow, a poor conductor
of electricity, and insoluble in water. It also forms a compound with a non-metallic element.
It reacts with all-metal except gold and platinum forming sulfide which is considered as a salt
of H₂S.
In oil and gas refineries sulfur is considered as an undesired element that is present in
crude, natural gas, and petroleum in the form of H₂S so it is recovered to elemental sulfur
using the Claus process.
2.5.1 Elemental Sulphur As Primary Product
A large amount of Elemental sulfur is produced in refineries as a side product which is
undesired for refineries. But elemental sulfur has many uses in other fields. The sulfur
obtained by crude petroleum oil and acid gas recovery is in the molten state which is then
converted to solid form (block) or pellets that can be easily transported. Its major uses are in
the manufacturing of H₂SO₄ whereas it’s also used in the fertilizer industry, in batteries, in
the lab as an analytical reagent, in detergent, in matches, in explosives, in black gun powder .
2.5.1.1 In Batteries
The Li-S battery is a type of rechargeable battery having high specific energy
18000KJ/kg these batteries were used in the longest and highest altitude unmanned solar-
powered airplane. The use of Sulphur decreases the cost of the battery.
2.5.1.2 Used In matches
Sulfur is the second essential ingredient in a match in which it acts as a fuel. The head of
safety matches is made up of an oxidizing agent such as potassium chlorate (KClO₃) mixed
with sulfur, filler, and glass powder. Sulfur has a good burning ability.
2.5.1.3 In Explosive
Sulfur is used as a plasticizer in explosives and organic explosives mixtures such as black
powder, flash powder the elemental sulfur are used as a fuel component.
2.5.1.4 Gunpowder (Black Powder)
There are three main components of gunpowder nitrate, charcoal, and sulfur. Sulfur
increases the rate of Combustion and it acts like fuel.
2.5.1.5 Insecticide and Fungicide
Sulfur kills fungi, it reacts with plants or fungi to produce a toxic agent or it may work by
entering the fungi cell and affecting cell respiration. Sulfur can kill insects if they eat sulfur
or even touch sulfur. It also affects body function by altering the ability to produce energy.
Sulfur is generally used in crops to combat fungal disease and post-harvest fungal disease.
15
That is controlled by sulfur including brown rot, scab, mildew, powdery mildew, leaf spot,
and rusts.
2.5.1.6 In the Production of Sulfuric Acid by Contact Process
Sulfur is oxidized to SO₂ by burning in presence of air. Sulfur dioxide is then converted
to SO₃. In the presence of V₂O₅ catalyst and then in the absorption tower SO₃ is absorbed into
H₂SO₄ to form oily liquid “oleum” (H₂S₂O₇). The oleum is then added to water to form
sulfuric acid.
2.5.1.7 Lowering The Soil pH With Sulfur
Some plants like blueberries grow under low pH. The addition of elemental sulfur to the
soil to decrease the pH of soil is the cheapest way. If the soil pH is greater than 5.5 then the
addition of Elemental sulfur inappropriate amounts can decrease the soil pH up to 4.5. The
bacteria present in the soil convert elemental sulfur to sulfuric acid so that the PH of the soil
decreases. But the temperature of soil should be above 55⁰F because the bacteria are not
active under low temperature so the addition of Elemental sulfur is not suitable or useful in
the winter season or the areas where the temperature is low. The soil should not be flooded
i.e: anaerobic then the sulfur converted to H₂S (rotten egg smell) by anaerobic bacteria which
damage or kill the plant roots.
FeSO₄ is also used to decrease soil pH but it’s more costly than sulfur and a greater
quantity is required than elemental sulfur. Aluminum sulfate also acidifies but it's toxic.
.2.6 TAIL GAS AS BY-PRODUCT
Tail gas is obtained as a side product of the Claus unit in the form of off-gas. It contains
SO₂, H₂S, CS₂, COS and hydrocarbons. In the tail gas section, these gases are combusted and
converted into H₂S.
16
SULFUR IMPORTS FORECAST
7.00E+07
IMPORTS QUANTITY (KG) AND VALUE (US$)
6.00E+07
5.00E+07
4.00E+07
3.00E+07
2.00E+07
1.00E+07
0.00E+00
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024
YEAR
VALUE QTY Linear (VALUE) Linear (QTY)
17
3- High-level oxygen enrichment (> than 45 vol% O₂).
Figure 2.2: Effects of O₂ concentration on % Claus plant capacity and reaction furnace
temperature [12]
18
In its first commercial application, 85% capacity can be achieved in the COPE process.
With a rich acid gas feed in a refinery Claus amine tail gas unit, the oxygen causes the low
Claus plant pressure drop but its capacity is increased on the order of 100%. For a large
capacity increase, we must replace or modify waste heat boiler and the downstream first
condenser, so its design capacity can be exceeded.
When the leaner acid gases typically occurred, then the COPE yields more capacity in
gas field application. When the H₂S in the acid gas feed more than 60% then a small fraction
of the total pressure drop can be contributed by the thermal conversion section.
Eleven COPE units were functioning in the year 1995. [12]
19
Feed gas Superclaus
Combustion st Superclaus99
And 1 reactor 99.5 incinerator
chmaber section
air section
20
Figure 2.5: The Modified Claus Process [13]
21
2.9 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS AMONG THE DIFFERENT PROCESSES
Table 3.1: Comparison between different processes
SOURCES FOR Oxygen Combustio High pressure By the use of Catalyst and use
REACTION n air with catalyst of two reactors
oxygen
22
CHAPTER 3
PROCESS DESCRIPTION
23
3.1.1 Advantages of Modified Claus Process
3.1.1.1 Highest Purity
The modified Claus process has the highest purity among other processes.
3.1.1.2 Environmental Friendly
In this process, we made the gas environmentally friendly by extracting the sulfur.
3.1.1.3 Low Capital Cost
Overall capital cost is low, as we used few reactors and small process line diameters are
used in this process.
3.1.1.4 High Design Capacity
This process has a design to handle 5457 lb/hr. of acid gas (feedstock) which produces
4780 lb/hr. liquid sulfur (product).
3.1.1.5 Low Operating Cost
As we only purifying the gas so it does not take so much energy consumption and the
catalyst is also recoverable and reusable during the process
3.2 EQUIPMENT USED IN RECOVERY OF ELEMENTAL SULPHUR BY CLAUS
PROCESS
3.2.1 Thermal Reactor or Furnace
The acid gas is first fed to the thermal reactor or furnace where it is combusted in the
presence of air. The reaction that takes place in the furnace is
H2S + 1.5 O2 → SO2 + H2O --------------------------------------------Equation 3.1
In our simulation, we use a Conversion reactor as the reaction furnace. Experimentally,
the thermal reactor consists of a horizontal carbon steel vessel, and from protection from the
high temperature, it is equipped with multiple refractory layers. In the reaction furnace, one-
third of the H2S is combusted to SO2.
24
Figure3.2: Reaction furnace
3.2.2 Acid Gas Burner
Before entering the thermal furnace, acid gas is heated in the burner named acid gas
burner to make the combustion process efficient. The turbulence is created for good mixing
of acid gas with process air using high velocities with the same flow rate design for air and
acid gas. The velocities should not be lower than the desired amount as it can cause a
decrease in turbulence which is necessary for better mixing of gas with process air so that the
combustion of acid gas will be efficient and complete.
25
3.2.3 Combustion Air Blower
The combustion air blower is present to generate air which is used as a source of oxygen
in the combustion of acid gas. Two types of the blower can be used [15]
1. Centrifugal compressor blower
2. Positive displacement blower
26
3.2.5 Sulphur Condensers
The condenser is placed after the Claus reactor to cool down the sulphur below the
Sulphur dew point to condense the elemental sulphur. Sulfur condensers are shell and tube
heat exchangers with kettle type. On the shell side, water is present which is exchanging heat
from the process gas and the water is converted to low or medium pressure steam. Tubes of
the condenser are 1-3 degrees sloped toward the outlet. The tube material is carbon steel.
The condenser shell side, inlet, and outlet are insulated by wood. The melting and
boiling point of elemental Sulphur is 119 ⁰C and 444.6 ⁰C. The ideal condenser temperature
is about 10 ⁰C above the Sulphur dew point.
To avoid cooling of liquid Sulphur, the liquid Sulphur outlet nozzles are jacketed. It also
increases the followability of liquid Sulphur. Demister or disengagement section is present at
the steam outlet nozzle to separate liquid sulphur from the process gas. [16]
3.2.5.1 Filters
To prevent dust, carry over in Sulphur run down lines steam jacketed filter is used at the
outlet of Sulphur condenser. To prevent the solidification of Sulphur the drains are kept
warm. A collection vessel is present to store liquid elemental sulfur produced. The level of
the vessel checks and maintain by the level controller. The sulfur is continuously removed
from the vessel.
27
FIG 3.5: Schematic diagram of Sulphur condenser [16]
3.2.6 Reheater
Direct fired or fuel gas re-heaters are used after condenser to heat the process gas and
increase its temperature to the clause catalytic reactor temperature so that reaction can take
place in the forward direction.
28
3.3 PROCESS DESCRIPTION
The HDS process is a typically catalytic process used for the removal of sulfur from
refined and gas products.
The process of desulphurization is the removal of sulfur from lighter refinery cuts such as
diesel naphtha and vaccum gas oil. The crude oil with higher viscosity and higher densities
contain a higher amount and more complex sulfur compounds. Since the aliphatic and
Acyclic sulfides (thioesters) and cyclic sulfides (thiolates)) are easier to remove from
hydrodesulfurization or by thermal treatment but the sulfur present in aromatics (thiophenes.
g. benzothiophene, dibenzothiophene, benzo naphtho thiophene) are more resistant to sulfur
removal by hydrodesulfurization.
In the hydrotreater, the reaction occurs on an fluidized bed reactor. The reaction occurs
on an aluminum-based catalyst and is absorbed in:
The feeds (olefins free) are pumped with the recycling of hydrogen-rich gas. Then heat
exchanger is used to heat the combined feed. Fired heater is used to heat the mixture until the
mixture feed is vaporized and achieve the operating condition of a fixed catalyst bed where
the reaction of desulfurization occurred. The product streams are cooled using a heat
exchanger and the pressure is reduced using a pressure controller to bubble out the gasses
from the separator. The gasses bubbled out from the separator are acid gasses (H2S). These
gasses then go to the amine treatment unit to remove hydrogen sulphide. The stripper sour
gas (H₂S) consists of heavier hydrocarbons and the components like methane, ethane,
propane, and butane. Then from the amine treating unit, the sour gas (hudrogen sulfide) is
sent to the gas processing plant for the removal of hydrogen sulfide. For recovering
hydrocarbons are then send to series to the series of the distillation column. In the refinery fuel
gas system, we can utilize the remaining hydrocarbons, hence now the removed H2S is
converted into elemental sulfur in sulfur recovery unit.
29
3.3.2.1 Claus Section
Claus section comprises the following units:
3.3.2.1.1 Reaction Furnace
The feed of the reaction furnace i.e: feed gas mainly consisting of components H2S, CO2,
and to a minor extent, various hydrocarbons are coming from amine-treating units and sour
water stripper. In a furnace burning of H2S takes place in the presence of air to form sulfur
dioxide and one-third of H2S is converted. The hot gas (process gas) from the combustion
chamber is quenched in the waste heat boiler before entering the sulfur condenser in order to
generate medium-pressure steam from high-pressure steam. As a result, 80 percent of the
heat released could be recovered as valuable energy.
3.3.2.1.2 Sulfur Condenser
The process gas from the waste heat boiler enters the first sulfur condenser where sulfur
is condensed, separated, and collected to the sulphur drum. Before entering the first catalytic
reactor, the process stream is pre-heated up to the optimum temperature for the catalytic
conversion in the first Claus reactor reheater.
30
3.4 PROCESS FLOW DIAGRAM
31
CHAPTER 4
PROCESS MODEL
A process is a set of actions carried out in series to achieve some results. Process
modeling makes the process representation useful and more simplified. Process modeling is a
major technique to organize things easily. The main objective of this modeling is to simulate
a major unit of the refinery sector that is the sulfur recovery unit in which a major portion of
sulphur is recovered in the form of elemental sulfur that is economically worthwhile. For the
simulation of this unit, we have used the software of Aspen hysys V10, which includes a
wide variety of property packages, mole palette, crude analysis, simulation environment.
This software is a major backbone of the polymer and refinery sector as all physical
processes can be easily simulated on this. It is used for both study state and dynamic
processes.
4.1 FUNDAMENTAL COMPONENTS SELECTION
The system components are the very first input to be fed while making a process
simulation. The system components include both conventional, non-conventional, pseudo
components, polymer components, and hypothetical liquids, etc. Aspen hysys includes a
wide variety of user-defined components that are called hypothetical components. If we are
dealing with such components that are not in the databank of aspen hysys then we have to
manually add it and specify its composition and weight etc.
The feed of the sulfur recovery unit includes a minute quantity of hydrocarbons and an
enhanced quantity of H2S and water for the reaction proceeding. The feed components are
pure and taken from the family of hydrocarbons included in component list 1.
32
Table 4.1: Component list
COMPONENTS ALIAS
HYDROGEN H₂
WATER H2O
HYDROGENSULFIDE H₂S
METHANE CH₄
ETHYLENE C₂H₄
ETHANE C₂H₆
PROPANE C₃H₈
I-BUTANE i-C₄H₁₀
N-BUTANE n-C₄H₁₀
NITROGEN N₂
OXYGEN O₂
S2_VAPOR S₂
S8_VAPOR S₈
SULFURDIOXIDE SO₂
33
4.3 UNIT MODEL SELECTION
4.3.1 Observations by Optimizing the Furnace (Thermal Reactor) Temperature
A Conversion reactor is utilized as a response heater for the fractional ignition of
hydrogen sulfide with oxygen to produces sulfur dioxide and water, the degree of the first
response is 25% in with the item as in the fume stage the subsequent response (endothermic
response) with the heat of reaction or standard enthalpy of reaction (12153.08 that happens
when a matter is changed by a given compound response
The adjustment in the arrangement of the level of S2 fumes was seen by eliminating and
burner and thus expanding the heap on heater dividers. The mix of burner and heater together
is made the thermal heater in which the burner sends the preheated combination of corrosive
gas and amine for additional ignition of response The recuperation of S2 without the burner
was found to exceptionally improved that was 92%. The heater works at high temperature
going from temperature around 1/third of the H2S is singed in the warm reactor.
Here the thermal reactor and heater are taken as single fitting stream reactor, where the
warm reactor shows an adiabatic Here the heat-exchanger is utilized as a cooling medium to
cool the outgoing sulfur fumes. Subsequent to coming out of the waste heat evaporator the
streams are cooled by means of a cooler
4.3.2 Heat Exchanger
The heat exchanger used in the sulfur recovery unit process is the time called the cooling
medium. The main purpose of using this cooling medium is to cool down the vapors of
sulphur that are coming out of the reaction furnace.
4.3.3 Separator
Another unit model that we have utilized in the sulfur recuperation unit is the separator
the fundamental reason for utilizing a separator is to separate the fluid Sulfur for a protected
stockpiling and assortment around 98 % of the fluid sulfur is gathered in the first separator
alongside some water (1.73%). Water hydrogen and hydrogen sulfide and a few hints of
methane has been gathered as fumes from the top.
4.3.4 Conversion Reactor as Catalytic Reactor:
The catalytic reactors contain expensive catalyst that improves the sulfur recuperation
proficiency with a few phase synergist units. The proficiency of the sulfur recuperation in the
adjusted provision area was 75% which was higher than 63% of the customary warm
segment. This builds the sulfur recuperation to 12% with the changed thermal segment that
happened because of the expulsion of water fumes that supported the balance-related
statement responses to happen toward sulfur creation.
34
4.4 ASSUMPTIONS
In order to simulate following assumptions are taken in the process;
1) The process is steady-state
2) We used a heat exchanger as a condenser
3) Side reaction are neglected
4) Conversion reactor is used as a catalytic reactor
5) The conversion of H₂S in the catalytic reactor is 45%.
6) The conversion reactor is CSTR
35
CHAPTER 05
MATERIAL & ENERGY BALANCES
36
Table 5.1: Molar Flowrate Calculation
Components Inlet (Kmol/h) Reaction Outlet (Kmol/h)
H₂O 19.03201635 18.856317 37.88833298
Hydrogen 0.160245235 - 0.160245235
H₂S 39.69750869 18.856317 20.84119206
Methane 0.06 - 0.06
Ethylene 0.06 - 0.06
Ethane 0.03 - 0.03
Propane 0.03 - 0.03
Nitrogen 217.1615954 - 217.1615954
Oxygen 57.56090481 14.886566 42.67433905
S2_Vapor 0 6.6989546 6.698954592
S8_Vapor 0 0 0
SO₂ 0 5.4584074 5.458407445
TOTAL 333.7855086 - 331.0563049
37
Table 5.2: Error Calculation
Components Mole Balance Simulated
Results Results
H₂O 37.88833298 37.88833298
Hydrogen 0.160245235 0.160245235
H₂S 20.84119206 20.84
Methane 0.06 0.06
Ethylene 0.06 0.06
Ethane 0.03 0.03
Propane 0.03 0.03
Nitrogen 217.1615954 217.1615954
Oxygen 42.67433905 42.67433905
S2_Vapor 6.698954592 6.70
S8_Vapor 0 0
SO₂ 5.458407445 5.458407445
TOTAL 331.0563049 331.0563049
ERROR 0%
38
5.1.2 First Catalytic Reactor
39
Table 5.3: Molar Flowrate Calculation
Components Inlet (Kmol/h) Reaction Outlet (Kmol/h)
H₂O 37.88833298 9.3785364 47.26686941
Hydrogen 0.160245235 - 0.160245235
H₂S 20.84119206 9.3785364 11.46265564
Methane 0.06 - 0.06
Ethylene 0.06 - 0.06
Ethane 0.03 - 0.03
Propane 0.03 - 0.03
Nitrogen 217.1615954 - 217.1615954
Oxygen 42.67433905 - 42.67433905
S2_Vapor 6.698954592 - 6.698954592
S8_Vapor 0 1.7584756 1.75847558
SO₂ 5.458407445 4.6892682 0.769139231
TOTAL 331.0563049 - 328.1255123
40
Table 5.4: Error Calculation
Components Mole Balance Simulated
Results Results
H₂O 47.26686941 47.26686941
Hydrogen 0.160245235 0.160245235
H₂S 11.46265564 11.46265564
Methane 0.06 0.06
Ethylene 0.06 0.06
Ethane 0.03 0.03
Propane 0.03 0.03
Nitrogen 217.1615954 217.1615954
Oxygen 42.67433905 42.67433905
S2_Vapor 6.698954592 6.698954592
S8_Vapor 1.75847558 1.75847558
SO₂ 0.769139231 0.769139231
TOTAL 328.1255123 328.1255123
ERROR 0%
41
5.2 ENERGY BALANCE
Energy balance is used to determine the amount of energy that flows into or out of the system
that must be added or removed. It helps in assessing ways of reducing energy in order to
increase the profitability of the process. The energy balance for the sulphur recovery unit is
as follows:
42
Table 5.5: Names of streams
Total 251466.4
44
TABLE 5.9:ENERGY BALANCE ON
STREAM-15
Stream-15 -10909328 KJ/h
TABLE 5.10:ENERGY
Mol Q(KJ/hr) BALANCE ON STREAM-16
H20 0.1525 -1663673 Stream-16 35362.29 KJ/hr
H2 0.0005 -5454.664 Liquid mol Q(KJ/hr)
H2S 0.0311 -339280.1 H2O 0.0577 2040.404
CH4 0.0002 -2181.866 H2S 0.0001 3.536229
C2H4 0.0002 -2181.866 S2 0.7216 25517.43
C2H6 0.0001 -1090.933 S8 0.2205 7797.384
C3H8 0.0001 -1090.933
N2 0.6813 -7432525 Total 35358.75
O2 0.1399 -1526215
S2 0.0001 -1090.933
Total -10974784
45
5.2.3 Energy Balance On Furnace
46
TABLE 5.15 ENERGY BALANCE ON STREAM-4
(THERMAL REACTOR OUTLET)
47
TABLE 5.16:ENERGY
BALANCE ON BURNER TABLE 5.17:ENERGY BALANCE ON
OUTLET (VAPOUR) CONDENSER OUTLET (LIQUID)
Stream_5 -9587830 KJ/h Stream_6 284059.3 KJ/h
Mol Q (KJ/h) mol Q (KJ/h)
H2O 0.1164 -1116023 H2O (L) 0.017 4829.008
H2 0.0005 -4793.92 H2S (L) 0.0002 56.81185
H2S 0.0642 -615539 S2(L) 0.9827 279145
CH4 0.0002 -1917.57 SO2 (L) 0.0001 28.40593
C2H4 0.0002 -1917.57 Total 284059.3
C2H6 0.0001 -958.783
C3H8 0.0001 -958.783
N2 0.6691 -6415217
O2 0.1315 -1260800 TABLE 5.18:ENERGY BALANCE ON
S2 0.0009 -8629.05 STREAM-4
SO2 0.0168 -161076 Stream_4 -2137592 KJ/h
Total -9426755 Mol Q (KJ/h)
H20 0.1144 -244541
H2 0.0005 -1068.8
H2S 0.063 -134668
CH2 0.0002 -427.518
C2H6 0.0002 -427.518
C3H8 0.0001 -213.759
N2 0.656 -1402261
O2 0.1289 -275536
S2 0.0202 -43179.4
SO2 0.0165 -35270.3
Total -2102322
48
5.2.5 Energy Balance On Reheater-01
50
5.2.7 Energy Balance On Condenser-02
Total 249598.3
52
TABLE 5.27:ENERGY BALANCE
ON STREAM-09 TABLE 5.28:ENERGY
Stream-9 -10375446 KJ/h BALANCE ON STREAM-10
mol Q(KJ/h) Stream-10 249623.3 KJ/h
H2O 0.1472 -1527266 mol Q(KJ/h)
H2 0.0005 -5187.723 H2O 0.0243 6065.846
H2S 0.0359 -372478.5 H2S 0.0001 24.96233
CH4 0.0002 -2075.089 S2 0.7727 192883.9
C2H4 0.0002 -2075.089 S8 0.2028 50623.61
C2H6 0.0001 -1037.545
C3H8 0.0001 -1037.545 Total 249598.3
N2 0.6793 -7048041
O2 0.1335 -1385122
S2 0.0005 -5187.723
S8 0.0001 -1037.545
SO2 0.0024 -24901.07
Total -10375446
54
TABLE 5.32:ENERGY
TABLE 5.35:ENERGY
BALANCE ON REACTOR 2
Vapor mol Heat flow
BALANCE ON CONDENSER-3
INLET(STREAM-12)
H2O 0.1496 -1447753
H2 0.0005 -4838.75 Stream-12 262845.7 KJ/hr
H2S 0.0357 -345486 Liquid mol Heat
flow
CH4 0.0002 -1935.5
H2O 0.008 2102.766
C2H4 0.0002 -1935.5
H2S 0.0001 26.28457
C2H6 0.0001 -967.749
S2 0.7856 206491.6
C3H8 0.0001 -967.749
S8 0.2062 54198.78
N2 0.6755 -6537145
Total 262819.4
O2 0.1327 -1284203
S2 0.00046 -4451.65
S8 0.0012 -11613
SO2 0.0024 -23226 TABLE 5.34:ENERGY
BALANCE ON STREAM-14
Total -9664524 Stream-14 251466.4 KJ/hr
Liquid mol Heat
flow
H2O 0.0073 1835.705
H2S 0.0001 25.14664
S2 0.7603 191189.9
S8 0.2323 58415.64
Total 251466.4
TABLE 5.33:ENERGY BALANCE
ON STREAM-13
Stream-13 -9666046 KJ/h
Vapour mol Heat flow
H2O 0.1518 -1467306
H2 0.0005 -4833.02
H2S 0.0309 -298681
CH4 0.0002 -1933.21
C2H4 0.0002 -1933.21
C2H6 0.0001 -966.605
C3H8 0.0001 -966.605
N2 0.676 -6534247
O2 0.1328 -1283651
S2 0.0057 -55096.5
S8 0.0017 -16432.3
Total -9666046
55
INLET (STREAM-13)
Stream-13 -9666046 KJ/h
Vapour mol Heat flow
H2O 0.1518 -1467306
H2 0.0005 -4833.02
H2S 0.0309 -298681
CH4 0.0002 -1933.21
C2H4 0.0002 -1933.21
C2H6 0.0001 -966.605
C3H8 0.0001 -966.605
N2 0.676 -6534247
O2 0.1328 -1283651
S2 0.0057 -55096.5
S8 0.0017 -16432.3
Total -9666046
56
TABLE 5.37:ENERGY BALANCE ON
CONDENSER-3 OUTLET(STREAM-15)
Stream-15 -10909328 KJ/h
mol Q(KJ/hr)
H20 0.1525 -1663673
H2 0.0005 -5454.664
H2S 0.0311 -339280.1
CH4 0.0002 -2181.866
C2H4 0.0002 -2181.866
C2H6 0.0001 -1090.933
C3H8 0.0001 -1090.933
N2 0.6813 -7432525
O2 0.1399 -1526215
S2 0.0001 -1090.933
Total -10974784
Total 35358.75
57
REFERENCES
[17] linde, "linde group sulfur recovery process," linde group , [Online]. Available:
https://www.linde-engineering.com/en/images/Sulfur%20Process%20Technology_tcm19-
111155.pdf.
58
59