Steroids and The Eye-Indications and Complications: W. J. Dinning

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

Postgradiuate Medical Journal (October 1976) 52, 634-638.

Steroids and the eye-indications and complications


W. J. DINNING
F.R.C.S., M.R.C.P., D.O.
Institute of Ophthalmology, University of London

Summary there are many situations where these ideals do not


Corticosteroid therapy is of great value in many types obtain. Those of us who see a lot of chronic inflam-
of eye disease. The indications are briefly discussed, matory eye disease are no less aware than specialists
together with the choice of agent and mode of admini- in other fields of the severe and often unacceptable
stration. The dangers of steroids are now widely side effects of these agents.
recognized, and the complications are discussed, The actions of corticosteroids on ocular tissue
particularly cataract and glaucoma. Reference is also have been widely studied. In experimental corneal
made to optic neuritis and thyroid ophthalmopathy, wounds cortisone has been shown to inhibit the for-
where the role of steroids is uncertain. mation of the fibrinous coagulum, cellular infiltra-
Particular stress is laid on the need to keep steroid tion, fibroblastic repair and endothelial regeneration
dosage as low as possible, so as to avoid systemic side (Ashton and Cook, 1951; Leopold et al., 1951).
effects. There are unfortunately many situations Ashton and Cook (1951) were able to prevent healing
where treatment of doubtful efficacy has produced completely with large enough doses. Cook and Mac-
severe side effects. Despite the overall benefit of Donald (1951) showed that cortisone, given locally
steroids in ophthalmology, there is a pressing need to or systemically, reduced the increased permeability
find alternative treatment for a variety of blinding in ocular capillaries in inflammation, and confirmed
disorders. Leopold's findings (Leopold et al., 1951) that there
was no effect on the permeability of normal vessels.
Introduction They also observed that on withdrawal of treatment
Corticosteroid therapy has been applied in ocular the permeability increased again, even when the
disease from the moment it became generally ocular condition was clinically quiescent. In practice
available. Initial enthusiasm in trying these drugs in we see many cases where signs of vessel leakage per-
almost every type of eye condition soon resulted in sist despite inactivity of the condition.
an appreciation of their major indications (Duke-
Elder, 1951), but it was a decade before the local Penetration, potency and choice of drug
ocular complications of their use were generally Penetration obviously depends on the drug and
recognized. mode of administration. For example, topical hydro-
Apart from their effect in reducing wound scarring, cortisone penetrates the cornea better than does
their major use is in the suppression of inflamma- prednisolone, but the reverse is true if the drug is
tion. It was very quickly realized that corticosteroids given systemically. The anti-inflammatory action is
had little effect on the cause of inflammatory reac- not directly associated with ease of penetration
tions, and that if they were withdrawn in the con- (Leopold, Kroman and Green, 1955).
tinuing presence of the exciting stimulus, then the Topical and subconjunctival injection produce
inflammation would again be manifest. therapeutic levels in the cornea and aqueous humour,
Although we now know that corticosteroids are but systemic administration or retrobulbar injection
immunosuppressant in higher doses we are still are necessary to obtain adequate levels in the vitreous,
largely ignorant of their mode of action in inflam- choroid and retina.
matory disease. Our knowledge of penetration is mostly gained
The complications of therapy are directly related from experiments on healthy tissues, but it must be
to the dosage and duration of treatment, and so the remembered that in disordered tissues, especially
most satisfactory results are to be expected where with breakdown of the blood-aqueous barrier, pene-
the disease is self-limiting, and where possible tration will be enhanced.
potentiating effects on the underlying cause can be Prednisolone is usually preferred to hydrocorti-
counteracted by specific therapy. In ophthalmology sone, both for local and systemic use. It has been
Address for reprints: Institute of Ophthalmology, Judd found to be effective more rapidly, and at a lower
Street, London WCIH 9QS. dose (King et al., 1955). The depot preparation of
Steroids and the eye 635

methylprednisolone is also widely used for subcon- (5) Trauma (a) after injury or surgery; (b) after
junctival, intravenous or retrobulbar injection, and physical or chemical burns.
is well tolerated. Triamcinolone is also used for A balance must be struck between reducing scar
orbital injection. By this means, high concentrations tissue and vascularization on the one hand, and
of the agent are delivered in the posterior segment impeding healing to the extent of producing un-
of the eye for at least a week after one injection stable wounds on the other.
(Hyndiuk and Reagan, 1968) and in practice it is (6) Herpes zoster ophthalmicus
rarely necessary to repeat the injection in under a The keratitis and uveitis which may occur re-
fortnight. spond well to local treatment. Scheie and McLellan
For local use, dexamethasone is more powerful (1959) reported rapid relief of pain with systemic
than prednisolone, but produces more problems therapy, although symptoms frequently recurred
with increased intraocular pressure. when treatment was reduced. The high doses of
The choice of therapy is largely determined by the steroids required are hardly applicable to many of
part of the eye the drug has to reach, although a the elderly patients in whom the condition occurs,
change from topical to depot or systemic therapy and systemic steroid therapy is not commonly
may be dictated by failure to respond to a previous
method of administration. The increasing use of employed.
orbital injections for conditions otherwise requiring Some controversial issues
systemic therapy saves many patients from the bur- (1) Optic neuritis
den of systemic side effects, because a much smaller There are many reports of small groups of patients
overall dose is used. treated with steroids for acute optic neuritis. Neu-
Corticotrophin is not widely used because of the bauer and Karges (1959) felt that the healing process
inconvenience of injections. It has the disadvantage was accelerated, but Giles and lsaacson (1961) were
of not producing such a prompt rise to high levels not convinced of the superiority of steroids over
of circulating corticosteroid as can be achieved by other forms of therapy. Conclusions in early studies
giving the adrenal hormone itself. must have been at least in some degree influenced by
Indications the fact that the tendency to spontaneous recovery
The following summary is not intended to be was not fully appreciated until the early 1960s.
exhaustive. Rawson and Liversedge (1969) concluded that cor-
ticotrophin should be given, but their results did not
(1) Allergic and hypersensitivity disease show a significant difference between treated and
Eyelids-drug and cosmetic reactions untreated groups. In a recent series reported by
Conjunctiva-vernal disease McDonald (1976) no difference between treated and
-phlyctenular disease untreated groups was seen at 6 months, although
Cornea-interstitial keratitis and other corneal treated patients were better than untreated patients
diseases where the specific antigen plays at the end of the first and second weeks. It is
a part in eliciting a reaction. Examples McDonald's view at the present time that 'in the
are the stromal keratitis of herpes sim- absence of any convincing evidence that treatment
plex and the reaction to staphylococcal alters the outcome of acute unilateral optic neuritis,
antigen which respond to local steroid the routine use of ACTH or steroids is not indicated'.
therapy, although effective specific ther-
apy must be given concurrently. (2) Thyroid ophthalmopathy
(2) Scleritis and episcleritis As early as 1951 reports of both success and
failure in reducing exophthalmos had appeared
(3) Uveal tract inflammation (Olson et al., 1951). (See also the discussion by Cole
Local therapy is usually effective for anterior on p. 299 of the Olson paper.) Doses of less than 20
uveitis, but orbital or systemic therapy is usually mg prednisolone or 100 mg hydrocortisone have
indicated for choroiditis, retinal vasculitis, or been ineffective (Medical Research Council, 1955;
vitreous body inflammation, and for the chronic Day and Carroll, 1961). Success has been reported
granulomatous forms of uveitis such as sympathetic with higher doses but recurrence on withdrawal of
ophthalmitis. therapy is frequent, and the side effects of the doses
(4) Giant-cell arteritis used are severe.
Systemic treatment in high doses is sight-saving. Werner has reported sustained improvement with
The dose is reduced gradually by titration against initial doses of 120-140 mg prednisolone daily in the
the erythrocyte sedimentation rate, but will need to emergency treatment of malignant exophthalmos
be restored to a higher level if visual symptoms (Werner, 1966) but he feels that 'neither prednisolone
return. nor immunosuppressive drugs nor both together
636 W. J. Dinning

shorten the overall course of active ocular disease' I1fowever, opacities may also be produced by the
(Werner, 1972). ocular inflammation itself, and are not uncommon
Corneal exposure or optic nerve involvement in chronic uveitis. Steroid therapy will add to this
endangers sight and demands emergency measures. tendency.
If steroids are to be used with hope of success, it The mechanism of the lens damage is not under-
would appear that initial doses of around 100 mg stood.
prednisolone daily are required, and that a response (2) Glaucoma
should be seen within a few days. If a rapid response In 1951, McLean, Gordon and Koteen reported
is not forthcoming other therapy should be insti- seven cases of anterior or generalized uveitis develop-
tuted. Transantral orbital decompression has proved ing a raised intra-ocular pressure after systemic
such a relatively straightforward and successful pro- treatment with ACTH or cortisone, and one after
cedure that some would consider it as primary treat- local therapy. Franqois (1954) reported eight cases
ment in this critical situation. of intra-ocular pressure elevation after 15 days-
Following improvement in exophthalmos with 15 months of treatment. Goldman (1962) suggested
steroids, therapy must be maintained until natural an individual predisposition to this effect, and
remission has occurred, or relapse may ensue (Ivy, Armaly has concluded that the response to steroids
1972). has a genetic foundation (Armaly, 1966). Armaly
Exophthalmos has been treated by the retrobulbar found a significant elevation of intra-ocular pressure
injection of steroid, but the results are not con- after 0-1%/ dexamethasone drops three times daily
vincing, and the wisdom of making an injection into for 4 weeks in 30-40% of eyes sampled at random
an already tense orbit is questionable. (Armaly, 1963). He suggested that the effect is due to
Complications alterations in the mucopolysaccharides in the inter-
Systemic side effects
trabecular spaces of the pore area of the trabecular
There are many ocular conditions requiring 20 mg meshwork, interfering with aqueous drainage. Becker
prednisolone or more daily for their control, and and Hahn (1964) suggested that a high pressure re-
systemic side effects are common. Ideally, systemic sponse to topical steroid is transmitted as a mono-
steroid therapy should be used only when the con- genetic dominant with a gene prevalence of 0-2 which
dition will be relatively short-lived, and then only in the homozygous state is associated with a primary
when the local therapy (e.g. by orbital steroid open angle glaucoma. The greatest elevations in
njection) has failed. When treatment is begun in intraocular pressure are seen in patients with this
childhood, the problem of growth disturbance must condition and, recently, evidence has been presented
also be faced. for generalized hypersensitivity to glucocorticoids in
these patients (Becker and Podos, 1974).
Ocular side effects Dexamethasone more commonly causes a serious
Ocular side effects are seen irrespective of whether rise than do prednisolone or hydrocortisone, and this
the steroid is being taken for systemic or ocular complication is seen much more frequently with
disease. topical than with systemic treatment. The lesson is
(1) Posterior subcapsular cataracts not to give steroids for long periods without super-
These were first reported by Black et al. (1960) in vision, especially for minor irritations where less
seventeen of forty-four patients with rheumatoid harmful preparations, or simple reassurance are more
arthritis on prolonged corticosteroid treatment. A appropriate.
further follow-up of the same patients (Oglesby et On withdrawal of the drug the intra-ocular pres-
al., 1961) revealed that no patient developed cata- sure falls to normal. Where steroids must be main-
ract in less than 1 year after beginning treatment, tained, changing to a different compound may
and it occurred in only one patient on less than 10 suffice, but treatment to control the intra-ocular
mg prednisolone daily. All twelve patients who had pressure is often necessary as well, and may prove
taken 15 mg daily for more than 1 year developed difficult to achieve.
cataract. Serious visual impairment was uncommon, (3) Enhancement of infective disease
although one patient required cataract extraction. Thygeson, Hogan and Kimura (1953) reviewed the
This experience is general. Lens opacities have results of cortisone and hydrocortisone in ocular
developed in five of eleven renal transplant patients infection, and pointed out the danger of depressing
being followed by the author, but in no case with any tissue defences and masking the progress of the
great visual effect. In this condition it is a small price infecting agent. Fungus infections are particularly
to pay for survival. liable to enhancement. Of the greatest practical
When steroids are used for ocular conditions importance is the disastrous effect of steroids on
similar opacities develop at similar dose levels. herpetic epithelial keratitis. The above authors also
Steroids and the eye 637

drew attention to this (Thygeson et al., 1960), but BLACK, R.L., OGLESBY, R.B., v. SALLMAN, L. & BUNIM, J.J.
one still sees cases of enhanced herpes simplex kera- (1960) Posterior subcapsular cataracts induced by corti-
costeroids in patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Journal of
titis produced by unsupervised use of local steroids. the American Medical Association, 174, 166.
The mixed antibiotic plus steroid preparations are COOK, C. & MACDONALD, R.K. (1951) Effect of cortisone on
the usual offenders. the permeability of the blood-aqueous barrier to fluores-
cein. British Journal of Ophthalmology, 35, 730.
Conclusion DAY, R.M. & CARROLL, F.D. (1961) Optic nerve involvement
associated with thyroid dysfunction. Transactions of the
In concluding it would be well to summarize the American Ophthalmological Society, 59, 220.
aims of therapy-to control the disorder within DINNING, W.J. & PERKINS, E.S. (1975) Immunosuppressives
acceptable limits with a dose of steroid which is in uveitis. A preliminary report of experience with chloram-
tolerable from the point of view of side effects. Once bucil. British Journal of Ophthalmology, 59, 397.
DUKE-ELDER, SIR STEWART (1951) The clinical value of cor-
control is established attempts should be made to tisone and ACTH in ocular disease. A preliminary assess-
find the lowest effective dose, but reduction should ment for the Medical Research Council. British Journal of
be gradual. Attempted reduction in patients who have Ophthalmology, 35, 637.
become used to a certain dose over many months FRANQOIS, J. (1954) Cortisone et tension oculaire. Annales
or years often produces a flare-up, even though d'Oculistique. Paris, 187, 8Q5.
GILES, C.L. & ISAACSON, J.D. (1961) The treatment of acute
the disease may have been quiescent for a long time. optic neuritis. Archives of Ophthalmology. Chicago, 66,
In most cases of anterior uveitis it is possible to 176.
achieve control with local treatment, thus avoiding GOLDMANN, H. (1962) Cortisone glaucoma. Archives of
systemic side effects. At the other end of the spec- Ophthalmology. Chicago, 68, 621.
HYNDIUK, R.A. & REAGAN, M.G. (1968) Radioactive depot
trum are conditions such as sympathetic ophthal- corticosteroid penetration into monkey ocular tissue.
mitis and Behget's disease where high-dose systemic Archives of Ophthalmology. Chicago, 80, 499.
therapy commonly produces severe side effects and Ivy, H.K. (1972) Medical approach to ophthalmopathy of
still does not control the disease. It is important in Grave's disease. Proceedings. Mayo Clinic, 47, 980.
KING, J.H., PASSMORE, J.W. SKEEMAN, R.A. & WEIMER, J.R.
these cases to realize that a perfect solution does not (1955) Prednisone and prednisolone in ophthalmology.
exist. Some patients regret that they were ever Further experimental and clinical observations. Trans-
treated with steroids when they find themselves actions of the American Academy of Ophthalmology and
incapacitated by enormous doses which have been Otolaryngology, 59, 759.
LEOPOLD, I.H., KROMAN, H.S. & GREEN, H. (1955) Intra-
continually increased in the pursuit of an evasive ocular penetration of prednisone and prednisolone. Trans-
clinical cure. This dilemma has led some workers to actions of the American Academy of Ophthalmology and
try other forms of treatment in these severe sight- Otolaryngology, 59, 771.
threatening disorders. Immunosuppressive drugs LEOPOLD, I.H., PURNELL, J.E., CANNON, E.J., STEINMETZ,
C.G. & McDONALD, P.R. (1951) Local and systemic cor-
have been used, and the author himself has experi- tisone in ocular disease. American Journal of Ophthal-
ence along these lines at the Institute of Ophthalmo- mology, 34, 361.
logy (Dinning and Perkins, 1975). McDONALD, W.I. (1976) Diagnosis and management of
Nonetheless, one must not let these gloomy con- optic neuritis. Transactions of the Ophthalmological Society
siderations cloud the fact that thousands of patients of New Zealand, 28, 11.
McLEAN, J.M., GORDON, D.M. & KOTEEN, H. (1951) Clinical
have enjoyed great relief of symptoms and preven- experiences with ACTH and cortisone in ocular diseases.
tion of long-term complications in a wide variety of Transactions of the American Academy of Ophthalmology
eye disease. The benefits of corticosteroids to oph- and Otolaryngology, 55, 565.
thalmology far outweigh their disadvantages. MEDICAL RESEARCH COUNCIL (1955) Cortisone in exophthal-
mos. Report on a therapeutic trial of cortisone and cortico-
References trophin (ACTH) in exophthalmos and exophthalmic
ARMALY, M.F. (1963) Effects of corticosteroids on intra-
ophthalmoplegia by a Panel appointed by the Medical
ocular pressure and fluid dynamics. 1. The effect of dexa-
Research Council. Lancet, i, 6.
methasone in the normal eye. Archives of Ophthalmology. NEUBAUER, H. & KARGES, E. (1959) Kortikosteroidbehand-
Chicago, 70, 482. lung bei Neuritis nervi optici. Klinische Monatsblatter fur
ARMALY, M.F. (1966) The heritable nature of dexametha- Augenheilkunde, 134, 615.
sone-induced ocular hypertension. Archives of Ophthal- OGLESBY, R.B., BLACK, R.L., v. SALLMANN, L. & BUNIM, J.J.
mology. Chicago, 75, 32. (1961) Cataracts in patients with rheumatic disease treated
ASHTON, N. & COOK, C. (1951) Effect of cortisone on healing with corticosteroids. Further observations. Archives of
of wounds. British Journal of Ophthalmology, 35, 708. Ophthalmology. Chicago, 66, 625.
BECKER, B. & HAHN, K.A. (1964) Topical corticosteroid and OLSON, J.A., STEFFENSEN, E.H., SMITH, R.W., MARGULIS,
heredity in primary open angle glaucoma. American Jour- R.R. & WHITNEY, E.L. (1951) Use of adrenocorticotrophic
nal of Ophthalmology, 57, 543. hormone and cortisone in ocular disease. Archives of
BECKER, B. & PODOS, S.M. (1974) Hypersensitivity of gluco- Ophthalmology. Chicago, 45, 299.
corticosteroids and primary open-angle glaucoma. In: RAWSON, M.U. & LIVERSEDGE, L.A. (1969) Treatment of
Transactions of the International Glaucoma Symposium, retrobulbar neuritis with corticotrophin. Lancet, ii, 227.
Albi (France) May 1974 (Ed. by R. Etienne and G. D. SCHEIE, H.G. & MCLELLAN, T.G. (1959) Treatment of
Paterson), p. 289. Diffusion Generale de Librairie, Mar- herpes zoster ophthalmicus with corticotrophin and cor-
seille. ticosteroids. Archives of Ophthalmology. Chicago, 62, 579.
638 W. J. Dinning
THYGESON, P., HOGAN, M.J. & KIMURA, S.J. (1953) Cortisone keratitis. Transactions of the Americant Ophthalmological
and hydrocortisone in ocular infections. Transactions of Society, 58, 245.
the American Academy of Ophthalmology and Otolaryn- WERNER, S.C. (1966) Prednisone in emergency treatment of
gology, 57, 64. malignant exophthalmos. Lancet, i, 1004.
THYGESON, P., HOGAN, M.J. & KIMURA, S.J. (1960) The WERNER, S.C. (1972) The eye changes of Graves' disease.
unfavorable effect of topical steroid therapy on herpetic Proceedings. Mayo Clinic, 47, 969.

You might also like