Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Recalling Stress and Trauma in The Workplace - A Qualitative Study of Pediatric Nurses
Recalling Stress and Trauma in The Workplace - A Qualitative Study of Pediatric Nurses
N
ursing can be a stressful pro-
fession; caring for children Kleis, A.E., & Kellogg, M.B. (2020). Recalling stress and trauma in the work-
can cause secondary trau- place: A qualitative study of pediatric nurses. Pediatric Nursing, 46(1), 5-10.
matic stress in the pediatric
nurse (Kellogg et al., 2018). Secondary Problem: Secondary traumatic stress has been identified as a problem in the nurs-
traumatic stress has been defined as ing workforce, leading to adverse effects on mental health and job dissatisfaction.
“intrusion, avoidance and arousal Purpose: The purpose of this study was to begin to discover more about the events
symptoms resulting from indirect and stressors pediatric nurses experience that may lead to the development of sec-
exposure to traumatic events using a ondary traumatic stress.
professional helping relationship Results: Content analysis was performed with the open-ended responses from a
with a person or persons having cross-sectional survey asking, “Is there anything else you would like to share?”
directly experienced the events” Seventy-two responses were analyzed and six prevalent themes were identified:
(Bride et al., 2004, p. 28). Several pub- pressure to perform despite emotion, feeling unsupported, inability to separate trau-
lications can be found in health care matic experiences from personal life, consumption by traumatic experiences, using
literature exploring work-related positivity to cope, and the need for further research.
stress and trauma. Terms used to
Conclusion: Pediatric nursing is stressful, yet many nurses also find it rewarding.
describe the occurrence vary and
Measures to improve the nurse’s awareness of work-related stress, including edu-
include secondary traumatic stress, cation and breaks during the workday, should be encouraged. Further research is
compassion fatigue, burnout, and needed to determine which experiences are most traumatic for pediatric nurses,
vicarious traumatization. Studies of negative effects of secondary traumatic stress for patients, and interventions that
work-related stress in nursing explore best reduce secondary traumatic stress in nursing.
many specialties, including labor and
delivery (Beck & Gable, 2012), emer- Key Words: Secondary traumatic stress, pediatrics, coping.
gency care (Dominguez-Gomez, &
Rutledge, 2009; Flarity et al., 2013;
Jeon & Ha, 2012; van der Wath et al.,
2013), oncology (Günüşen et al.,
2019), trauma and critical care noted in the prevalence of secondary may cause secondary traumatic stress
(Hinderer et al., 2014; Mason et al., traumatic stress or compassion in pediatric nurses.
2014; Sacco et al., 2015; Salimi et al., fatigue, with mean scores ranging Qualitative studies in the literature
2019; Von Rueden et al., 2010; Young from low levels in nursing coordina- related to stress in pediatric nursing
et al., 2011), hospice and palliative tion (Kim, 2013), average levels in crit- are limited. McGibbon and colleagues
care (Melvin, 2015; Sullivan et al., ical care nurses (Sacco et al., 2015), (2010) published an ethnography on
2019), and nursing coordination roles and moderate or high levels in pedi- pediatric nursing stress studying nurs-
(Kim, 2013). Significant variance is atric nurses (Kellogg et al., 2018). es working in a pediatric intensive care
These results indicate the occurrence unit of a pediatric hospital in Canada.
of work-related stress or trauma is Results focused on causes of nursing
highly variable and should be further stress and revealed six themes: 1) emo-
investigated so appropriate interven- tional distress, 2) constant presence, 3)
Instructions for CNE tions can be implemented. Currently, the burden due to responsibility, 4)
Contact Hours little is reported in the literature about hierarchical power, 5) bodily care, and
PNJ 2001 experiences in pediatric nursing that 6) being mothers, daughters, aunts,
Continuing nursing education (CNE) are most challenging emotionally and and sisters.
contact hours can be earned for
completing the learning activity
associated with this article. Instructions
are available at pediatricnursing.net Anna E. Kleis, BSN, RN, is a Graduate, the University of Massachusetts Lowell, Lowell, MA; and
Staff Nurse, Mount Auburn Hospital, Cambridge, MA.
Deadline for submission:
February 28, 2022 Marni B. Kellogg, PhD, RN, CPN, CNE, is an Assistant Professor, the University of
1.1 contact hour(s) Massachusetts Dartmouth, Dartmouth, MA.
Full Survey Results (Kellogg, et al., 2018) Individuals with Written Response
Variable M Variable M
Age (n = 333) 41.3 Age (n = 72) 45.7
Years of nursing experience 16.0 Years of nursing experience 20.0
(n = 334) (n = 72)
Years of pediatric nursing 14.4 Years of pediatric nursing 17.7
experience (n = 333) experience (n = 72)
Hours worked per week (n = 326) 38.2 Hours worked per week (n = 72) 37.4
Variable n % Variable n %
Gender (n = 334) Gender (n = 72)
Male 6 1.8 Male 3 4.2
Female 328 98.2 Female 69 95.8
Nurse Education (n = 334) Nurse Education (n = 72)
Diploma 10 3.0 Diploma 4 5.0
Associate’s 40 12.0 Associate’s 10 13.9
Bachelor’s 211 63.2 Bachelor’s 41 56.9
Master’s 61 18.3 Master’s 15 20.8
Doctorate 12 3.6 Doctorate 2 2.7
Pediatric Clinical Focus (n = 334) Pediatric Clinical Focus (n = 72)
Medical-Surgical 114 34.1 Medical-Surgical 23 31
Intensive Care 44 13.2 Intensive Care 9 12.5
Primary/Outpatient Care 41 12.3 Primary/Outpatient Care 9 12.5
Oncology 25 7.5 Oncology 5 6.9
Emergency Department 24 7.2 Emergency Department 8 11.1
Operating Room 5 1.5 Operating Room 0 0
Home Health 8 2.4 Home Health 2 2.7
Other 73 21.9 Other 16 22
Secondary Traumatic Stress Level (n = 338) Secondary Traumatic Stress Level (n = 72)
Severe 60 17.8 Severe 22 30.6
High 44 13.0 High 4 5.6
Moderate 66 19.5 Moderate 12 16.7
Mild 90 26.6 Mild 15 20.8
None 78 23.1 None 19 26.4
unable to recover from their previous happened. We are all humans; we Feeling Unsupported
patient experience. This concept is have emotions. These kids become The second theme found among
highlighted in one nurse’s response: family. We are more upset than respondents of the survey was feeling
people realize when there are bad unsupported. Responses describe
Management expects nursing/ outcomes. nurses feeling unable to continue
techs to go on with their day as if with their jobs and help children
nothing happened, as if a patient This feeling was echoed by another without more support from manage-
didn’t just pass away. It is hard to study participant: “It seems like there ment. One respondent exclaimed: “I
deal with the emotions of having a is more of a rapid-fire succession of had an incident of PTSD of a 14-year-
patient pass in a particular room difficult situations; you don’t have old hanging victim who survived
and then immediately filling it time to recover from one situation [who] I needed to obtain psychologi-
with another patient. There needs before another one arises.” cal counseling for. I have left primary
to be time to reflect on what just