Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7b IDOT Bridge Seminar Presentation
7b IDOT Bridge Seminar Presentation
7b IDOT Bridge Seminar Presentation
Construction Procedure
The temporary substructure platform geometry, jacking procedure, and slide-in procedure shall control twisting,
distortions and deflections within the tolerances specified below:
Final elevations of individual bridge bearings shall be within plus or minus 1/8 inch of plan elevations.
Additional shims or grinding of the concrete seat may be used to adjust elevations accordingly
o Matches Standard Specification requirements of Section 503.15 (c) for bearing seat
surface finish, Section 521.05 for setting bearings
o Easy to achieve when substructures are built (Contractors are accustomed to this)
o Possible to meet requirement on both substructures yet lock in relative differential
displacements between adjacent girders due to cumulative effects
1 ”
2
IDOT Special Provision Geometry Requirements
To satisfy twist distortion requirements, each corner of the bridge shall maintain a two inch
maximum differential elevation from the plane defined by the concurrent elevation of the
remaining three corners at all times
o Interpreted this to only apply to slide of superstructure
o Easy to satisfy
o Shot elevations at four corners and calculated twist when the slide was at 3’,
6’, 13.5’, 21’, and in final location. Maximum calculated twist was about 1/8”
IDOT Special Provision Geometry Requirements
Individual CL bearing locations shall be within ¼ inch of the plan bearing locations, both
longitudinally and transversely
o Easy to satisfy if guide tracks are straight and parallel
o Just about impossible to change plan shape of our bridge deck
o Superstructure can get rotated in plan view but is easily adjusted by adjusting
differential travel at either end
IDOT Special Provision Geometry Requirements
Design Requirements.
The superstructure of the proposed bridge shall be constructed on the temporary substructure platform
supported on piles adjacent to the south end of existing bridge.
The stiffness of the pile supported temporary substructure platform shall be sufficient as to limit total
deflections at any location on the support to less than 1/16 inch.
o Strict interpretation is: at no location at any point in time could the temporary
substructure displace vertically more than 1/16 inch
o Couldn’t satisfy this requirement
i. Estimated elastic shortening of our pile about 3/16 inch.
ii. Asymmetrical temp substructure cantilever deflected 3/8 inch (while deck
concrete was plastic)
o We accounted for displacements > 1/16 inch, and met final 1/8” bearing elevation
tolerance
Temporary Substructure
Temporary Substructure
Things Change
Spread footing. Not used due to fill and calculated differential settlement. Would not consider this
substructure type in the future except in rare favorable conditions (very stiff soil / rock).
Precast abutment with 4 evenly spaced pile. Not used due to powerline issue.
Asymmetric steel beam abutment on piles with precast slab topper.
o Minimized temporary substructure depth, excavation, and allowed us to accurately predict
girder deflections.
o Contractor re-usable components
Temporary Substructure
Temporary Substructure
Design Considerations
Accurate deflection calculations. Required to provide level guide track after superstructure is
poured.
o Varying guide track shim heights to account for 3/8” deflection
o Correct superstructure cross section
Moving load analysis for varying conditions during slide.
Lateral load due to lateral pull forces.
Transition between temporary substructure and permanent abutment (transfer beam).
Temporary Substructure
Constructability
Fewest piles and most efficient member
sizes and connections possible to control
cost and construction time.
Design of substructure components to
allow for unknowns, construction
tolerances and field variations.
o Temporary substructure guide track
elevations
o Adjustable field connections and
contractor verified shims
o WT connection
Temporary Substructure
Lateral Slide System
Lateral Slide System
Things Change
PTFE and stainless-steel slide shoes with guide track. Not used due to revised roller cost
from supplier.
Hilman Rollers with channel guide track. Used due to revised cost and known success rate.
Would be comfortable using either system in the future. Have used rollers and even
greased plates on past slides without issue.
Lateral Slide System
Procedure
Set single girder and brace off existing bridge
Erect 3 girder box outside of clearance zone
Pushed 3 girder box into place by 3 men on each end
Set remaining 3 girders in place
Interesting Observation
Estimated required push force at 5% static COF is approximately 1,550 lbs.
Three men probably can’t push 1,550 lbs.
Actual static COF was probably closer to 2% or 3%
Slide Day
Slide Day
Slide Duration
Must be done in 8 hours (Special Provision requirement)
Length of slide about 39’
Jack stroke about 8 ½”
Therefore, about 55 cycles to move 39’
Jacking cycle consists of: stroke jack, retract ram, re-tighten threaded rod nuts
Slide Day
Slide Duration
Start time 8:30 AM 4:30 PM latest
end time
Slide rate over first 2 hours was about 13
minutes per cycle end time at this
rate about 8 PM!
Contractor increased rate until stroking
was at system maximum by about
1:30 PM (initial rate was recommended
by system supplier)
At maximum stroke rate cycle time
dropped to about 6 minutes per cycle
Slide completed at 4 PM
Probably could have completed around
2:30 PM if maximum stoke rate was used
at start
Slide Day
Slide Uniformity
Travel at each end measured with
electronic wire device and with tape
measure
East end tended to lag behind west
end
Early on adjustments made about
every 6th stroke
Adjustments did not exceed ½”
Adjustment frequency and
magnitude both decreased as the
slide progressed
It was recognized that nut re-
tightening was different between
ends uniform nut re-tightening
later on seemed to cause reduction
in adjustment frequency and
magnitude
Slide Day
QUESTIONS?