Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wort Composition and Its Impact On The Flavour-Active Higher Alcohol and Ester Formation of Beer - A Review
Wort Composition and Its Impact On The Flavour-Active Higher Alcohol and Ester Formation of Beer - A Review
Wort Composition and Its Impact On The Flavour-Active Higher Alcohol and Ester Formation of Beer - A Review
Received: 14 April 2014 Accepted: 9 May 2014 Published online in Wiley Online Library: 10 June 2014
Keywords: brewing yeast; wort composition; flavour compounds; higher alcohols; esters; high-gravity brewing
J. Inst. Brew. 2014; 120: 157–163 Copyright © 2014 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling
Y. He et al.
Institute of Brewing & Distilling
Figure 1. A schematic overview of the main metabolic routes inside a brewing yeast cell.
permease (11). Two branched-chain amino acid aminotransfer- and fermentation medium that consists of carbohydrates (glucose,
ases, Bat1 and Bat2, mediate the transfer of amino groups from fructose, sucrose, maltose, maltotriose and nonfermentable
branched-chain amino acids to α-keto acids, which are precur- dextrins), nitrogenous materials (amino acids, peptides, ammonia,
sors for the synthesis of higher alcohols (12). Unlike higher proteins, nucleic acids), vitamins, minerals, inorganic ions, fatty
alcohols and esters, which are desirable volatile compounds acids, trace elements and other constituents too numerous to
for a pleasant and drinkable beer, vicinal diketones (VDKs) are mention (27). Brewery fermentations require a balanced supply
often considered as off-flavours for the majority of beers. of nutrients, providing sufficient levels as a growth medium to
According to Meilgaard (1), VDKs have the aroma of butterscotch, achieve adequate yeast growth, while at the same time acting as
which arises as an indirect result of yeast metabolism. a fermentation medium in the production of consistent levels of
All flavour-active components in beer must be controlled ethanol, carbon dioxide and flavour-active secondary by-products.
within specific limits. Their relative concentration can confer It is not difficult to comprehend that changes in nutrient
beneficial or undesirable flavour traits, and even an insignificant content or fermentation parameters will trigger different yeast
shift in their concentrations may result in an entirely different responses, with the responsiveness of the yeast culture to changes
flavour for the beer (13). Therefore, the main purposes of in the wort environment being critical to maintaining product
fermentation management to maintain a high quality beer are: quality and consistency. Therefore, the control of raw ingredients
(a) ensure the concentrations of negative flavour constituents and wort preparation, followed by appropriate fermentation
are less than their threshold levels; and (b) in the meantime, conditions, will ensure beer quality and a stable flavour profile.
ensure that the presence of well-adjusted amounts of higher In order to obtain more control over flavour production, inten-
alcohols and esters, and other compounds, imparts a positive sive research has been carried out to elucidate the factors
contribution to the final product (14). Otherwise, the desired influencing flavour formation. This review will limit the discus-
harmonious flavour balance resulting from various tastes and sion to the effect of wort composition on the production of
sensations in beer can be destroyed. For each beer style or higher alcohols and volatile esters during the course of fermen-
brand, customized descriptions in terms of ingredients, process tation. Different wort specific gravity, carbohydrate, nitrogen,
and the final features (especially product flavour) are specified lipid profiles, certain vitamins and inorganic ions can lead to
as a reference for the brewers. differences in the yeast’s fermentation performance, which can
The ability to control flavour production of beer during be reflected in the levels of esters and higher alcohols produced
fermentation is of paramount importance. It has been widely doc- (15,17,20,28–32). A better understanding of the impact of certain
umented that brewing yeast produces different concentrations of wort compounds on the flavour formation may lead to improved
flavour-active compounds as a function of wort composition flavour control during a brewery fermentations. The objective of
(5,15–18), fermentation conditions (5,18,19) and particularly the this review is to enhance our knowledge of the role that wort
yeast strain employed (20). Individual ester and higher alcohol composition plays in influencing yeast growth and in achieving
profiles produced in a similar medium differ dramatically from stable product profiles with respect to aroma-active compounds.
strain to strain, with ale strains generally producing more esters
and higher alcohols than lager strains (21). Fermentation process
Wort sugar profile
variables such as wort gravity, temperature, pressure, oxygen
and pitching rate are all known to influence the levels of Standard brewery wort contains approximately 90% carbohy-
flavour production (13,22–26). Wort is a complex yeast growth drate, which consists of sucrose, fructose, glucose, maltose and
158
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jib Copyright © 2014 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling J. Inst. Brew. 2014; 120: 157–163
Wort composition and impact on higher alcohol and ester formation
Institute of Brewing & Distilling
maltotriose, together with dextrin material. The wort sugar flavour components. Different flavour compounds are affected
profile depends on the raw ingredients (mainly barley malt) in diverse ways when part of the wort is replaced by a carbohy-
and wort preparation procedures, and also relies on the type drate solution, with fructose generally resulting in an increased
and the quantity of adjuncts employed. When inoculated into production of higher alcohols compared with other sugars,
brewer’s wort, yeast utilizes the principal wort sugars in a except for n-propanol (35). This implies that, when beers are
sequential order (Fig. 2). Maltose and maltotriose are the most produced with the addition of syrup, one should take the sugar
abundant sugars and will typically only be taken up after deple- constituents of the syrup into consideration in order to keep the
tion of the monosaccharides owing to the carbon catabolite final beer flavour consistent compared with standard worts.
repression of metabolic pathways involved in the uptake and Furthermore, when Younis and Stewart (20) reinforced fermenta-
utilization of alternative sugars (33). Although brewing fermenta- tions with high-maltose syrups, they found that it led to signifi-
tion is a process in which carbohydrates are utilized by yeast for cant decreases in acetate ester production, particularly with
its proliferation and maintenance, through the energy provided high-gravity worts.
from the conversion of sugars into ethanol and carbon dioxide, It is not clear why the metabolism of a medium containing
many more compounds are produced simultaneously during glucose or maltose produces different levels of volatiles. Several
this process with organoleptic properties, including esters and hypotheses have been proposed. It is possible that the fermen-
higher alcohols. tation of maltose inhibits the transport of volatiles out of the cell,
The carbohydrate composition of wort and the manner in perhaps by altering plasma membrane structure (15). However,
which it is utilized by yeast has a direct influence on fermenta- Stewart and Younis suggested that the idea of suppression of
tion efficiency and yeast metabolism, as well as the organoleptic volatiles’ transportation is unlikely in light of the increased viabil-
profile of the final product (34). Previous work has shown that ity and vitality of the maltose-grown cells (38). Another possibil-
significant differences in volatile profiles were obtained when ity is that the metabolism of maltose produces lower levels of
different carbohydrates were fermented individually (15,35). acetyl-CoA, which is the main substrate for acetate ester synthe-
Unfermentable dextrins, which cannot be metabolized by lager sis, resulting in fewer esters owing to the lack of this intermedi-
yeast and most ale yeast strains, are also wort carbohydrates ary metabolite (39). Furthermore, Verstrepen et al. (40) reported
and therefore remain in the final beer. They contribute to beer that a high glucose concentration strongly increased the
flavour by imparting body, mouthfeel, palate fullness and drink- production of aroma-active esters through activation of the
ability to the beer (36). Beyond that, certain levels of maltose, Ras/cAMP/PKA pathway, which results in a stronger expression
and especially maltotriose, are sometimes left unfermented at of the ester synthase gene ATF1. Thus ester-synthesizing activities
the end of primary fermentation. This lowers the efficiency of could be rapidly induced by the addition of glucose.
the process and potentially has an impact on beer quality by
influencing the relative production of flavour by-products.
Wort nitrogen compounds
Elevated production of higher alcohols by increasing the
levels of sucrose in the wort was reported by Jenard and The nitrogenous compounds available for consumption by yeast
Devreux (37). There were no significant differences in the levels are known as assimilable nitrogen, or free amino nitrogen (FAN),
of esters and higher alcohols produced during the fermentation which can be defined as the sum of the individual wort amino
when glucose or fructose was metabolized as the sole carbohy- acids, ammonium ions and small peptides (41). The relative
drate source, when examined using several brewing yeast amounts of the above components can vary owing to differ-
strains (ale and lager) (15). However, the metabolism of maltose ences in malting and mashing processes and/or raw materials.
results in considerably lower levels of esters and higher alcohols There are also differences between lager and ale yeast strains
compared with the easier assimilable glucose and fructose (15). with respect to wort assimilable nitrogen uptake characteristics
In addition to different carbohydrates affecting the concentra- (42). FAN, as a general measure of yeast nutrients, has been
tion of the flavour compounds, different malt–adjunct ratio regarded as an important index to predict yeast fermentation
worts also have an effect on the formation of a number of and beer quality (43,44). It is not only used as an essential yeast
nutrient for yeast growth, but also for the biosynthesis of a
number of fermentation by-products that affect the flavour
and stability of beer (45). Worts with more FAN (12.0°P with
115, 160, and 230 mg/L, respectively) showed higher production
rates and final concentrations of isoamyl acetate (44). In addi-
tion, treating wort with proteases increased the levels of FAN,
leading to elevated concentrations of higher alcohols and esters
during either high-gravity brewing or normal-gravity brewing by
lager brewing yeast strains (46). Moreover, the wort FAN content
can affect the transcription of both ATF1 and BAT1 genes, which
are reported to strongly correlate with ester and higher alcohol
synthesis, respectively (47,48). This suggests that the adjustment
of FAN is a factor that can influence beer flavour.
It is not only the absolute amount of assimilable nitrogen that
influences beer aroma, but also the type of amino acid that can
lead to different responses by the yeast – and ultimately to final
beer aromatic profiles. Wort amino acids constitute an important
Figure 2. Changes in different wort sugar compositions during generation 0 fraction of brewer’s wort and their determination is therefore of
considerable interest in experimental work and during brewing
159
J. Inst. Brew. 2014; 120: 157–163 Copyright © 2014 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jib
Y. He et al.
Institute of Brewing & Distilling
(49). As with wort sugars, the uptake of amino acids follows a by Procopio et al. (59) that, when using high proline concentra-
distinct order (50), with different amino acids being removed tions in a synthetic medium, an increased production of ethyl
at various points in the fermentation cycle (Fig. 3). The amino acetate was observed by both lager and ale brewing strains,
acid composition of wort is considered to be an important part demonstrating that proline is potentially an important
of the complex system regulating the biosynthesis of flavour- variable in influencing aroma compound profiles during beer
active compounds formed by the yeast (51). Therefore, the fermentation. Since proline cannot be converted into a
content of amino acids in the wort, and their utilization by yeast higher alcohol via the Ehrlich pathway, its significance in
during brewer’s wort fermentation influences both the fermenta- aroma formation could be explained by the synthesis of
tion performance and the flavour profile of the finished product. glutamate from proline (59).
The addition of branched-chain amino acids, such as valine, Although the quality and stability of beer is related to the
leucine and isoleucine, to the fermenting wort increases the for- levels of certain amino acids present in wort (60), deficiencies
mation of their respective higher alcohols [i.e. isobutanol, in fermentation performance may not be caused by the lack of
isoamyl alcohol and amyl alcohol (52,53)]. The constitutive ex- any particular amino acid group, but by the efficiency of nitro-
pression of the BAP2 gene, which encodes a branched-chain gen utilization (56). Differences in the amino acid assimilation
amino acid permease in brewer’s yeast, resulted in accelerated by yeast were observed during generation 0 and 1 fermenta-
assimilation rates of leucine, valine and isoleucine (54). Recently, tions (61), which could explain the common differences of the
a report has implicated histidine as a key amino acid for lager resultant beer flavour found between beer fermented with
yeast strains during brewing, with histidine supplementation propagated yeasts and repitched yeasts.
having a large impact on the flavour by increasing the formation Finally, with regards to oligopeptides in the wort, some of
of higher alcohols and esters (55). Isoamyl acetate production in these may be assimilated by the yeast, while others remain
beer can be affected by the leucine concentration in the wort. in the final beer, contributing to its flavour and stability,
Leucine addition increased the rate of production and final respectively (62).
concentration of isoamyl acetate, while higher levels of valine
delayed the uptake of leucine and lowered isoamyl acetate
production (44).
Lipids
Proline is the most abundant amino acid in wort but it is uti-
lized poorly, or not at all, during a typical brewing fermentation The lipid content of wort can affect the ester concentration in
and it is often classified as a nonpreferred amino acid (56). the final product. It has been shown that incorporation of
Proline has long been neglected with regards to its significance elevated levels of unsaturated fatty acids (UFAs) into the wort,
in fermentation, as its presence in wort is considered unimpor- namely oleic, linoleic and linolenic acids, results in a decrease
tant for yeast performance during brewing fermentations (16). in ester synthesis (29). This is due to a direct effect upon the
However, it has been shown by different working groups that synthetic enzyme, whereby the expression of ATF1 and ATF2 is
proline is taken up by yeast during the growth phase and is directly inhibited by the addition of UFAs (63). In addition to
excreted at the end of the fermentation (57,58). It was confirmed acetate esters, it has also been shown that higher levels of UFAs
160
Figure 3. Assimilation of different amino acids in wort by the industrial lager yeast strain TT-21.
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jib Copyright © 2014 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling J. Inst. Brew. 2014; 120: 157–163
Wort composition and impact on higher alcohol and ester formation
Institute of Brewing & Distilling
in the fermenting medium result in a general decrease in ethyl nitrogen (C:N) ratio. In an all-malt wort fermentation, where
ester production by yeast (18). the C:N ratio is low, nitrogenous compounds are still abundant
when yeast growth has ceased. Nitrogenous metabolites, includ-
ing acetyl-CoA, are still formed, which stimulates ester synthesis.
Vitamins and inorganic ions
The addition of sugary syrups is a common practice to increase
Brewing yeasts require vitamins and a wide range of inorganic wort specific gravity in high-gravity brewing. However as syrups
ions for efficient proliferation and fermentation performance. generally lack nitrogen, this normally reduces the total FAN
The major function of these wort components is to allow both content of the wort, thereby modifying the nutrient balance in
enzymes and coenzymes in yeast to function properly (64). A addition to diluting the nitrogen concentration. Therefore, when
lack of vitamins and inorganic ions can lead to many fermenta- adjuncts are used, the C:N ratio is higher, which in turn may lead
tion problems owing to malfunctions in yeast metabolic activi- to nitrogen being a growth-limiting factor (5,18,48,55). Hence,
ties. Changes in the levels of these compounds result in when growth ceases there is no excess of nitrogen to form
altered yeast growth profiles and metabolism (64). Thus, the acetyl-CoA, resulting in less ester synthesis (29).
content of vitamins and inorganic ions in the wort might affect As higher-gravity worts have reduced oxygen solubility
the final flavour of beer by altering their metabolic activities. compared with standard gravity worts (70), under-oxygenation
can lead to suboptimal revitalization of the yeast, growth defects
and low subsequent fermentation rates (71). Moonjai et al. (72)
High-gravity brewing as a general influence on beer flavour
demonstrated the potential of UFA lipid supplements to wort
From beer brewing practice, high-gravity brewing has been as an alternative to wort oxygenation (without losing fermenta-
adopted in many breweries worldwide. High-gravity brewing is tion potency or organoleptic quality). Therefore, UFA-treated
a process that employs worts of higher than normal sugar yeast may be particularly beneficial in high-gravity brewing.
concentrations (typically 16–18°P), which allows the brewery to
enhance its volumetric productivity and save labour and energy
costs without a large new investment. Nevertheless, increasing
the initial wort gravity can also modify the flavour and aroma
Conclusions
compound profile of the final beer, making it difficult to match Brewers have a broad range of different ways at their disposal to
to flavour of beers produced from normal-gravity worts (5,65). control flavour production during beer fermentation. To a great
The most common and particularly pronounced negative effects extent, the flavour balance of the overall metabolite concentra-
associated with high-gravity brewing are: (a) elevated levels of tion is largely a consequence of a combination of yeast strain
acetate esters concurrent with (b) a much less marked degree and wort composition. The selection of an appropriate brewers’
of higher alcohol stimulation (66–68), resulting in beers with yeast strain with individual aroma profiles is crucial to fulfil the
overly fruity and solvent-like aromas. This leads to an unbal- consumer’s demand for flavour diversity. However, for a specific
anced beer flavour caused by the disproportionate levels of beer production process with a designated yeast strain, a
volatiles produced, if no other process adjustments are made. considered adaptation of wort composition allows brewers to
Anderson and Kirsop (66) observed up to an 8-fold increase in assume command of the overall flavour character of their beers.
acetate ester production when the specific gravity of wort was It is obvious considering the variety of ingredients and processes
doubled. In our previous work, elevated concentrations of both in wort preparation that the types and levels of carbohydrates,
higher alcohols and volatile esters were found using high-gravity nitrogenous components and other trace nutrients in worts
brewing (16°P) compared with a normal-gravity fermentation can vary. Control of raw ingredients and wort preparation,
(13°P), while the increment of volatile esters (78%) was more followed by appropriate fermentation conditions, will ensure
than twice that of the higher alcohols (31%). In addition, beer quality and flavour. Presented with a constant wort compo-
transcription levels for all of the higher alcohol and volatile ester sition, a given yeast will metabolize medium nutrients in a
biosynthesis-related genes were enhanced during our high- predictable and reproducible fashion, with flavour-active higher
gravity brewing trials, with the exception of BAT2 originating from alcohol and ester formation occurring in a consistent manner.
both from Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Sc-type) and S. bayanus Knowledge regarding the roles of wort components in order
(Sb-type) genomes (data unpublished). to meet yeast requirements and flavour formation has increased
When sugar adjuncts are added, the type of sugar syrup used substantially. Additionally, while genetic and proteomic research
must be taken into consideration. Previous work using synthetic has built up further information to explain the production of
media has shown that the metabolism of maltose results in the different levels of volatiles in worts and defined media of differ-
production of lower levels of esters and higher alcohols (20). ent composition, there is still much to be discovered in this
Thus, increasing wort gravity by adding maltose syrup, as field. The optimization of wort nutritional content is a very
opposed to glucose syrup, resulted in a more balanced fermen- complicated issue owing to the many complex chemical
tation performance and a more favourable flavour profile of the constituents in the medium.
final beer (69). Fermentations using worts enriched with maltose
syrup, as opposed to glucose syrup, produced more favourable
flavour profiles, with less acetate ester formation, in very high- Acknowledgements
gravity (21°P and 24 °P) fermentation trials by Piddocke et al.
This work was supported by grants from the National Basic
(69). This facilitates the design of high-gravity worts resulting Research Program of China (973 Program, no. 2012CB723707)
in better flavour matching to beer produced from an all-malt and the National High Technology Research and Development
normal-gravity wort. Program of China (863 Program, no. 2013AA102109). Gregory
Another important factor whereby high-gravity brewing can Casey is gratefully acknowledged for reviewing the manuscript.
alter the aroma profile of beer is the carbon to assimilable Mei Li is especially thanked for her technical support.
161
J. Inst. Brew. 2014; 120: 157–163 Copyright © 2014 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jib
Y. He et al.
Institute of Brewing & Distilling
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jib Copyright © 2014 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling J. Inst. Brew. 2014; 120: 157–163
Wort composition and impact on higher alcohol and ester formation
Institute of Brewing & Distilling
48. Lei, H., Zhao, H., Yu, Z., and Zhao, M. (2012) Effects of wort gravity and contents and relationships with other analytical data, Food Chem.
nitrogen level on fermentation performance of brewer’s yeast and the 67, 71–78.
formation of flavor volatiles, Appl. Biochem. Biotechnol. 166, 1562–1574. 61. Miller, K. J., Box, W. G., Jenkins, D. M., Boulton, C. A., and Linforth, R.
49. Lie, S. (1973) The EBC-ninhydrin method for determination of free (2013) Does generation number matter? The impact of repitching on
alpha amino nitrogen, J. Inst. Brew. 79, 37–41. wort utilization, J. Am. Soc. Brew. Chem. 71, 233–241.
50. Jones, M., and Pierce, J. S. (1964) Absorption of amino acids from 62. MacWilliam, J. C., and Clapperton, J. F. (1969) Dynamic aspects of ni-
wort by yeasts, J. Inst. Brew. 70, 308–315. trogen metabolism in yeast, in Proceedings of the European Brewers
51. Sablayrolles, J. M., and Ball, C. B. (1995) Fermentation kinetics and Convention Congress, Interlaken, pp. 271–279, Elsevier, London.
the production of volatiles during alcoholic fermentation, J. Am. 63. Fujii, T., Kobayashi, O., Yoshimoto, H., Furukawa, S., and Tamai, Y.
Soc. Brew. Chem. 53, 71–78. (1997) Effect of aeration and unsaturated fatty acids on expression
52. Engan, S. (1970) Wort composition and beer flavour I: The influence of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae alcohol acetyltransferase gene, Appl.
of some amino acids on the formation of higher aliphatic alcohols Environ. Microbiol. 63, 910–915.
and esters, J. Inst. Brew. 76, 254–261. 64. Walker, G. M. (2000) Role of metal ions in brewing yeast fermenta-
53. Äyräptää, T. (1971) Biosynthetic formation of higher alcohols by tion performance, in Brewing Yeast Fermentation Performance, pp.
yeast. Dependence on the nitrogen nutrient level of the medium, 86–91, Blackwell Science, Oxford.
J. Inst. Brew. 77, 266–276. 65. McCaig, R., McKee, J., Pfisterer, E. A., Hysert, D. W., Munoz, E., and
54. Kodama, Y., Omura, F., and Miyajima, K. (2001) Control of higher al- Ingledew, M. (1992) Very high gravity brewing – laboratory and pilot
cohol production by manipulation of the BAP2 gene in brewing plant trials, J. Am. Soc. Brew. Chem. 50, 18–27.
yeast, J. Am. Soc. Brew. Chem. 59, 157–162. 66. Anderson, R. G., and Kirsop, B. H. (1974) The control of volatile ester
55. Lei, H., Li, H., Mo, F., Zheng, L., Zhao, H., and Zhao, M. (2013) Effects of synthesis during the fermentation of wort of high specific gravity,
Lys and His supplementations on the regulation of nitrogen metab- J. Inst. Brew. 80, 48–55.
olism in lager yeast, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 97, 8913–8921. 67. Palmer, A. K., and Rennie, H. (1974) Ester control in high gravity
56. Jin, H., Ferguson, K., Bond, M., Kavanagh, T., and Hawthorne, D. brewing, J. Inst. Brew. 80, 447–454.
(1996) Malt nitrogen parameters and yeast fermentation behavior, 68. Dragone, G., Mussatto, S., and Almeida, S. J. (2007) High gravity
in The Institute of Brewing, Proceedings of the 24th Convention, Asia brewing by continuous process using immobilized yeast: Effect of
Pacific Section, Singapore, pp. 44–50, IBD, London. wort original gravity on fermentation performance, J. Inst. Brew.
57. Gibson, B. R., Boulton, C. A., Box, W. G., Graham, N. S., Lawrence, S. J., 113, 391–398.
Linforth, R. S. T., and Smart, K. A. (2009) Amino acid uptake and yeast 69. Piddocke, M. A., Kreisz, S., Heldt-Hansen, H. P., Nielsen, K. F., and
gene transcription during industrial brewery fermentation, J. Am. Olsson, L. (2009) Physiological characterization of brewer’s yeast in
Soc. Brew. Chem. 67, 157–165. high-gravity beer fermentations with glucose or maltose syrups as
58. Ough, C. S., Huang, Z., and An, D. (1991) Amino acid uptake by four adjuncts, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 84, 453–464.
commercial yeast at two different temperatures of fermentation, 70. Baker, C. A., and Morton, S. (1977) Oxygen levels in air-saturated
Am. J. Enol. Viticult. 42, 26–40. worts, J. Inst. Brew. 83, 348–349.
59. Procopio, S., Krause, D., Hofmann, T., and Becker, T. (2013) Significant 71. Searle, B. A., and Kirsop, B. H. (1979) Sugar utilization by a brewing
amino acids in aroma compound profiling during yeast fermenta- yeast in relation to the growth and maintenance phases of metabo-
tion analyzed by PLS regression, LWT – Food Sci. Technol. 51, lism, J. Inst. Brew. 85, 342–345.
423–432. 72. Moonjai, N., Verstrepen, K. J., Delvaux, F. R., Derdelinckx, G., and
60. Gorinstein, S., Zemser, M., Vargas-Albores, F., Ochoa, J. L., Paredes- Verachtert, H. (2002) The effects of linoleic acid supplementation
Lopez, O., Scheler, C., Salnikow, J., Martin-Belloso, O., and of cropped yeast on its subsequent fermentation performance and
Trakhtenberg, S. (1999) Proteins and amino acids in beers, their acetate ester synthesis, J. Inst. Brew. 108, 227–235.
163
J. Inst. Brew. 2014; 120: 157–163 Copyright © 2014 The Institute of Brewing & Distilling wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/jib