Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reducing Harm Supporting Recovery 2017 2025
Reducing Harm Supporting Recovery 2017 2025
Supporting Recovery
A health-led response to drug
and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
EN
R ERY
V
D
CO
IL
CH
RE
FRIE
G
FA
ITY
LIN
ND
LY
UN
A
E
I
H
S
M
M
CO
Contents
Foreword by An Taoiseach 3
CHAPTER 1 – Introduction 7
Context 8
Vision 16
Values 16
Goals 17
CHAPTER 4 – Goal 2: Minimise the harms caused by the use and misuse
of substances and promote rehabilitation and recovery 33
Objective 2.1: To attain better health and social outcomes for people
who experience harm from substance misuse and meet their recovery
and rehabilitation needs 33
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 1
CHAPTER 6 – Goal 4: Support participation of individuals, families and communities 63
Objective 4.2: Enable participation of both users of services and their families 66
CHAPTER 9 – Conclusion 81
References 102
2 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Foreword
For the ideal of a Republic of Opportunity to be meaningful, it must apply to all.
Treating substance abuse and drug addiction as a public health issue, rather than
as a criminal justice issue, helps individuals, helps families, and helps communities.
It reduces crime because it rebuilds lives. So it helps all of us.
Ireland has a problem with substance misuse. Rates of drug use in Ireland have risen
significantly over the past decade, with the greatest increases among younger people.
Many Irish people engage in harmful drinking patterns and alcohol has become a major
drugs issue. The rise in the number of families affected by the loss of a loved one due
to drug use is a serious cause for concern. These issues highlight the need to intervene
effectively to reduce the harms associated with substance misuse, and combat the
underlying reasons for the demand for drugs.
The strategy recognises the need for a balanced approach, which involves reducing
the demand for drugs and reducing access to illegal drugs. It outlines the key law
enforcement strategies to protect the public from the harms of illegal drug markets
and the monitoring arrangements required to meet Ireland’s international obligations
at EU and UN level.
I welcome the initiative of the Minister for Health, Simon Harris TD and the Minister
of State for Health Promotion and the National Drugs Strategy, Catherine Byrne TD,
for bringing forward this strategy to respond to the problem of drug and alcohol use
in Ireland.
This government will work to build a Republic of Opportunity that means something
in people’s lives, especially those who have not had many opportunities in the past.
I hope the new strategy will make a real difference and encourage everyone to put
their own health and wellbeing first, so that we can realise the vision of this strategy
for a healthier and safer Ireland.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 3
Foreword
As Minister I firmly believe in a health-led and person-centred approach to our
drug and alcohol problem. Following my recent appointment as Minister of State
for Health Promotion and the National Drugs Strategy, my ministerial remit has
been extended to include the Healthy Ireland Framework. Alcohol and drug policy
are now core elements of my portfolio in line with the central vision of Reducing
Harm, Supporting Recovery, a health-led response to drug and alcohol use in
Ireland.
Through my involvement in the public consultation for this strategy, I heard how
drug and alcohol use affects individuals, families and communities across the
country and what key issues should be addressed in the new response. The need
for a more compassionate approach to drug use was raised repeatedly in the
course of the consultation, with many people calling for drug use to be treated as a
health issue, rather than a criminal issue. I was also struck by the fact that so many
contributors to the public consultation believed that drug and alcohol education
needs to start in primary school and continue through secondary school.
The importance of high quality drug and alcohol education is recognised in the
strategy, which recommends that substance use education should be provided
alongside wellbeing programmes, information campaigns and other preventative
measures. Together these initiatives, if effectively delivered, give young people
the tools to make informed choices about substance use and encourage them to
embrace positive lifestyle changes, which can improve their health and wellbeing.
The independent expert panel, that conducted a review of our previous drug
strategy, characterised alcohol as the elephant in the room, in considering Ireland’s
response to the drug problem. This strategy acknowledges that alcohol, while legal,
is a drug like any other and prioritises an integrated public health approach to drug
and alcohol use. I hope this approach will be strengthened in the coming years. The
strategy contains many measures which should contribute towards a reduction
in alcohol-related harm and delay early alcohol use among young people. The
Public Health (Alcohol) Bill which is currently being progressed, contains legislative
provisions to reduce alcohol consumption in Ireland, and this will also be a key step
forward.
A lot of work has been done over the past two decades to develop comprehensive
drug and alcohol services that are capable of dealing with all substances. There
is still considerable scope for improvement. That’s why this strategy contains
a series of actions which aim to reduce waiting times, provide more equity of
access to services around the country and remove potential barriers to accessing
treatment by those with complex needs. The introduction of a pilot supervised
injecting facility in Dublin’s city centre and the establishment of a working group to
examine alternative approaches to the possession of controlled drugs for personal
use, are among a number of initiatives contained within the strategy to promote a
harm reducing and rehabilitative approach to drug use.
4 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
The strategy also highlights the importance of continuing support for law
enforcement in an effort to combat organised crime groups which traffic illegal
drugs into Ireland. The importance of monitoring changing illegal drug markets,
against the background of national, EU and broader international experience and
best practice, is also emphasised in the strategy. Drug-related intimidation is a
further area of concern addressed in the strategy which I believe requires special
attention, as it presents a real threat to public safety in communities.
Finally, I would like to thank the many people who have been involved in the
development of this strategy and have been working intensively on this process
since December 2015. I would particularly like to thank John Carr, for his able
stewardship of the Steering Committee on the National Drugs Strategy. I would
like to pay a special tribute to the service users and recovery champions who
addressed the public consultation events in Dublin, Limerick, Cork, Galway,
Kilkenny and Carrick-on-Shannon. They demonstrated that with the support and
help of their families, communities and the staff of the drug and alcohol services,
people can rebuild their lives after addiction and that recovery is an attainable goal.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 5
Acknowledgements
As independent chair of the National Drugs Strategy Steering Committee, I was
keen to ensure that the Committee would provide a forum for all perspectives to
be heard so that the new strategy would benefit from the collective expertise and
experience of those around the table. To maintain the integrity and independence
of the process, I also chaired the Focus Groups that were convened to advise the
Steering Committee on actions to address gaps in the response.
I would like to thank everyone who contributed to the success of the project,
most notably;
l the members of the Steering Committee, whose dedication and
commitment, enabled us to develop the policy and related actions in
“Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery”, on the basis of consensus;
l the members of the Focus Groups on Supply Reduction, Education and
Prevention, Continuum of Care and Evidence and Best Practice for their
contribution to the Strategic Action Plan;
l Paul Griffith, Scientific Director and Nicola Singleton, Scientific Analyst at
the European Monitoring Centre on Drugs and Drug Addiction and Professor
Sir John Strang, Director, National Addictions Centre, Kings College London
who participated on the panel which carried out a Rapid Expert Review of
the current drugs strategy;
l all who participated in the public consultation and RPS Project
Communications, who compiled the report;
l The Centre for Public Health at Liverpool John Moores University for their
assistance in developing the evidence base;
l the Health Research Board, especially Brian Galvin, for his sterling support
during the drafting phase; and
l Susan Scally and her team from Drugs Policy Unit, for their professionalism,
commitment and support, in particular, Dairearca Ní Néill, Jane-Ann
O’Connell, John Kelly and Mary T Hally, secretary to the Steering Committee.
It is true to say that a significant effort has gone into the development of
“Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery”. This has involved a wide range of sectors,
stakeholders and interests working together. If we harness this energy and
revitalise the partnership approach which characterised previous drug strategies,
I have no doubt that we can deliver on the ambitious goals of this strategy and
achieve better outcomes for those whose lives have been impacted by drug and
alcohol use.
John Carr
Chair of the National Drugs Strategy Steering Committee
6 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
CHAPTER 1 – Introduction
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery sets out the Government’s strategy to address the
harm caused by substance misuse in our society up to 2025. It identifies a set of key actions
to be delivered between 2017 and 2020, and provides an opportunity for the development of
further actions from 2021 to 2025 to address needs that may emerge later on in the lifetime
of the strategy.
The strategy aims to provide an integrated public health approach to substance misuse.
Substance misuse means the harmful or hazardous use of psychoactive substances, including
alcohol, illegal drugs and the abuse of prescription medicines. The public consultation which
informed the strategy highlighted changing attitudes towards people who use drugs, with calls
for drug use to be treated first and foremost as a health issue.
Ireland’s previous national drugs strategies covered the period from 2001 to 2008 1 and 2009
to 2016 2 respectively. Both strategies aimed to reduce the harm caused by the misuse of
drugs, through a concerted focus on supply reduction, prevention, treatment, rehabilitation
and research. The new strategy will also advocate a harm reduction approach, but will place
a greater emphasis on supporting a health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland.
Partnership between the statutory, community and voluntary sectors was a major factor in the
success of previous strategies, and will continue to be the cornerstone of the new strategy. Drug
and Alcohol Task Forces (DATFs) will play a key role in coordinating interagency action at local
level and supporting evidence-based approaches to problem substance use, including alcohol
and illegal drugs. The new strategy will provide a way of measuring the collective response to
the drug problem, through a performance measurement framework.
The Healthy Ireland Framework 3 provides an over-arching context for the development of this
new strategy and its actions will contribute towards improving the health, wellbeing and safety
of the population of Ireland in the coming years. The new strategy will foster a person-centred
approach to those who develop drug or alcohol-related problems, while underlining the need
for a whole-of-Government response to the socio-economic, cultural and environmental risk
factors contributing to the causes of substance misuse.
This Chapter sets out the context for the strategy and outlines the vision for the future.
Chapter 2 describes the vision, values and goals linked to the overall strategic vision.
The five key goals set out to realise the vision are discussed in Chapters 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7. Chapter
3 outlines the work underway to promote and protect health and wellbeing related to substance
misuse, and proposes some specific actions to strengthen the response in this area. Chapter
4 describes the measures that have been undertaken to minimise the harm caused by the
use and misuse of substances and promote rehabilitation and recovery, and proposes a range
of new measures to improve health and social outcomes for people affected by substance
misuse. Chapter 5 discusses the key measures being undertaken to address the harms of drug
markets and reduce access to drugs for harmful use. Chapter 6 examines the arrangements in
place to support the participation of individuals, families and communities in the development
of solutions to respond to the drug problem and to provide safe, person-centred services.
Chapter 7 considers the evidence needed to inform the development of policy, initiatives and
interventions to address problem substance use.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 7
Vision
Our vision is for:
“A healthier and safer Ireland, where public health and safety is protected and the harms
caused to individuals, families and communities by substance misuse are reduced and
every person affected by substance use is empowered to improve their health and
wellbeing and quality of life”.
Context
Since the first drugs strategy was introduced in 2001 1, much has been done to improve access
to treatment and provide a wider range of services for those who develop health problems as
a result of the consumption of alcohol and other drugs. Methadone maintenance treatment has
become more widely available, particularly in inner city areas, and in those parts of the country
with higher rates of heroin use. Local and Regional Drug and Alcohol Task Forces (DATFs) have
supported the development and expansion of integrated and accessible community-based
services. This has resulted in greater access at local level to harm reduction initiatives, such as
methadone and needle exchange and other wrap-around services and supports, such as advice
and information, family support, childcare and complementary therapies.
In cooperation with family support networks, community and voluntary-led providers and peer
networks, the Health Service Executive (HSE) has provided training in the administration of
the opioid anti-dote naloxone to reduce the incidence of fatal overdoses among people who
inject drugs 4. Additional HSE funding has also resulted in an increased number of residential
addiction beds providing treatment, detoxification and aftercare services. However, it is
acknowledged that there is a need to provide wider geographic access to addiction services
and to continue to diversify the range of treatment options available to meet current and
emerging needs.
Significant law enforcement efforts have been invested in intercepting drugs destined for
the Irish market. International operations spearheaded by law enforcement agencies have
resulted in significant seizures and the disruption of organised crime networks involved in the
importation, distribution and sale of illegal drugs in this country. Recent years have also seen a
decisive response to the proliferation of headshops selling new psychoactive substances across
the country. Legislation preventing the sale of psychoactive substances in headshops has been
introduced and new controls have been put in place to remove these harmful substances from
our streets 5. However, drugs continue to be widely and easily accessible and the range of
methods by which drugs can be sourced has expanded significantly in recent years, in particular
through the internet. In tandem with this, escalating levels of violence related to the drugs trade
have had a serious impact in a number of communities.
8 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
While communities experiencing large-scale social and economic deprivation and
marginalisation continue to be disproportionately affected by drugs issues, the impact of the
drug problem has extended across the country into other cities, towns and rural areas over
the course of the last two decades. The nature of problem drug use has also changed; a wide
range of drugs are now being used, including legal drugs, illegal drugs and alcohol. The illicit
trade in prescribed medications, such as benzodiazepines and z-drugs, has created a serious
threat to public health, particularly among the population of people who are homeless and use
substances.
Substance misuse affects people from all walks of life, from different backgrounds and
communities. The 2014/15 drugs prevalence survey 6 found that one in four Irish adults (26.4%)
has tried an illegal drug at least once in their lifetime. Trends over the past decade point to
an increase in the rate of last year (an indicator of recent use) and last month (an indicator
of current use) drug use, with the greatest increases in drug use amongst younger people. In
common with other European countries, the use of cannabis is considerably higher than any
other form of drug, with 6.5% of adults using this drug in the last year. Younger people are
more likely to use cannabis than older adults. In relation to illegal drug use, cannabis is the
most commonly used drug among children in the 15-16 year age group.
A recent study indicates that the prevalence of problematic opiate use in Ireland has stabilised 7.
Based on 2014 figures, there are an estimated 18,988 opiate users in Ireland. While the overall
prevalence is stabilising, the spread of opiate use across the country is apparent, although
highest prevalence rates are still recorded in Dublin.
One of the most devastating consequences of problem drug use is drug-related poisonings
that lead to a loss of life. Data from the National Drug-Related Deaths Index (NDRDI), a national
surveillance database which records drug-related deaths (such as those due to accidental and
intentional overdose) and deaths among drug users (such as those due to Hepatitis C and HIV),
shows overdose deaths increased in Ireland from 301 in 2005 to 354 in 2014, representing an
increase of 17.6% 8.
New patterns of drug use and related harms have emerged over the past decade that need to
be considered in developing an effective response to the drug problem. These include high risk
behaviours associated with substance use, increased use of cannabis and ecstasy, particularly
amongst younger people, and a rise in cannabis-related problems that may be associated with
the increased use of more potent strains of domestically produced herbal cannabis.
Against this background, the Minister with responsibility for the National Drugs Strategy has
been tasked by Government to put a new strategy in place which would address current and
emerging challenges into the future.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 9
Methodology
Steering Committee
On 8 December 2015, the Minister of State with responsibility for the National Drugs Strategy
established a Steering Committee to advise on the development of a new strategy and
appointed an independent chair to guide the Committee in its work. The Terms of Reference
of the Committee were as follows:
l Provide guidance and advice to assist the Minister of State in the development of a new
National Drugs Strategy from 2017 onwards;
l Develop an integrated public health approach to substance misuse, which is defined
as the harmful or hazardous use of psychoactive substances including alcohol and illicit
drugs, incorporating the relevant recommendations of other related policies including
the National Substance Misuse Strategy 9;
l Review the report of the Expert Review Team on the National Drugs Strategy 2009-
2016 10 and the evidence briefing by the Health Research Board on the drugs situation
in Ireland 11 and international best practice in responses 12;
l Review the operational effectiveness of the structures and co-ordination mechanisms
of the National Drugs Strategy, including the Drug and Alcohol Task Forces, NACDA,
NDRIC, OFD, NCC and carry out a SWOT analysis on the partnership approach;
l Examine the relevance of the existing Strategy in tackling the current nature and extent
of problem drug use in Ireland, including emerging trends and cross-cutting issues having
regard to the available research, information and data sources. This will identify any gaps
presenting and indicate how they might be addressed;
l Examine developments in drug policies and identify international best practice in dealing
with problem drug use generally, at EU and International level;
l Conduct a consultative process and draw conclusions from same;
l In light of the foregoing, consider how a new Strategy post-2016 should address problem
drug use, including the structures through which this could be done, and incorporating
performance indicators to measure the future effectiveness of the new Strategy; and
l Present Report to the Oversight Forum on Drugs for discussion and submission to
the Minister of State, who will submit the proposals for a new Strategy to the Cabinet
Committee on Social Policy and Public Service Reform for approval.
The Committee met 19 times and its membership is set out at Appendix 1.
Focus Groups
To enable engagement with statutory, community and voluntary bodies who have a role in the
delivery of the objectives of the Strategy, the Steering Committee convened four focus groups.
Each focus group was asked to give their views on the relevance of the current strategy in
responding to problem drug use in Ireland, to identify any gaps presenting, and to indicate how
they may be addressed. To ensure the independence of the process, the Chair of the Steering
Committee also chaired the focus groups. A focus group was established to examine each of
the following areas:
l Supply reduction;
l Education and Prevention;
l Continuum of care, encompassing treatment, rehabilitation and recovery; and
l Evidence and best practice.
10 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Each focus group produced a position paper proposing measures to address gaps in the
current response to the drug problem, which were considered by the Steering Committee
and formed the basis for the strategic action plan.
Public Consultation
This strategy was informed by a public consultation which was undertaken by RPS Project
Communications, (part of the RPS group), on behalf of the Department of Health. The aim
of the public consultation was to engage with the general public, people who use services,
families, communities and organisations across society and to obtain their views on the drugs
issue in Ireland to help inform the new strategy. Specifically, the public consultation sought to
obtain views from the public on:
l the supply reduction, prevention, treatment, rehabilitation and research pillars
of the 2009-2016 National Drugs Strategy;
l the key issues that the Department of Health should consider in the development
of the new strategy;
l the roles involved in the management of the drugs issue in Ireland; and
l emerging trends about drugs misuse in Ireland.
A range of options were provided for feedback, including email, post, telephone, an online
questionnaire or through attendance at 6 regional events held in Carrick-on-Shannon, Limerick,
Cork, Dublin, Galway and Kilkenny. A separate questionnaire was developed for young people to
ensure that everyone who would be affected by the new drugs strategy had the opportunity to
inform and shape it.
Nearly 3,000 individuals and organisations from across Ireland provided feedback to the public
consultation. A breakdown by background of 2115 respondents to the on-line questionnaire
is set out in Figure 1. 835 respondents did not indicate any of the choices available and are
categorised as “unspecified”.
Individual 641
Service user 65
Professional 352
On behalf of organisation 76
Carer 29
Other 117
Unspecified 835
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 11
The following is a summary of the key issues raised repeatedly by respondents in the language
provided via the submissions and questionnaires. The full findings are detailed in the public
consultation report, which is available at: http://health.gov.ie/
Supply Reduction
l The need to change negative attitudes towards people who use drugs was a recurring
theme, with calls for drug misuse to be treated as a medical and health issue, rather than
a criminal issue.
l Drugs are not just a city or urban issue but are available throughout Ireland in small towns
and villages and rural areas. Drugs are also an issue across all social demographics.
l Reducing supply is only part of the problem – demand is what drives availability and the
reasons for demand need to be addressed.
l Many people who use drugs said they are subjected to debt intimidation and violence.
l Legal and illegal drugs should be reclassified based on their level of risk for real physical
and/or mental harm.
l There were calls for legalisation and/or decriminalisation of drug use.
l The potential medical benefits of cannabis were cited frequently in questionnaire
responses, with calls for cannabis to be legalised for medical use and available on
prescription for this purpose.
l There were also calls, on a lesser scale, for other addictions such as gambling, tobacco
and caffeine to be considered within the strategy.
Prevention
l Alcohol should be recognised as a major drugs issue in Ireland, particularly among
younger people and alcohol should be integral to the new strategy.
l Education should begin in primary school and many service users felt children aged 6-11
should be provided with factual information about the effects of drugs.
l More education and public awareness campaigns are needed and information should be
provided through schools, parents, communities, television, internet, social media and
mobile phone apps.
l There should be a focus on mental health as a means to address prevention.
l Calls for services for children to be improved, including safeguarding for young people
whose families/caregivers are affected by addiction.
12 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Treatment
l Service users want a sense of choice and to have a say in their treatment options.
l Fear of legal ramifications and stigma was suggested as a barrier to seeking treatment
for illegal drug use.
l There were views in support of and against injection centres.
l Calls for more GPs to be involved in prescribing methadone, particularly outside the
Dublin area, and in promoting and encouraging detoxification.
l There were calls for Suboxone to be provided as an alternative to Methadone and for the
wider roll-out of the opioid overdose anti-dote, Naloxone.
l A belief that there are significant blocks in the system for people who have both a mental
health and addiction issue was a recurring theme.
l A lack of transport and significant travel times for those in rural communities was cited as
a significant barrier to accessing services.
l People are coping with rural isolation through the use and misuse of legal drugs such as
alcohol and prescription drugs.
l A need was identified for designated assessment centres in the community for all drugs
and alcohol use, with care-pathways to other supportive specialist services in primary
care, community services, tertiary services and residential services.
l There are no programmes aimed at the recreational drug user who may not consider
themselves addicted to drugs.
l There was feedback that a holistic approach to treatment is needed with greater inter-
agency working, communication and co-ordination.
Rehabilitation
l People should be helped to meet their goals using a case management process, and
service users should have a distinct say in their own rehabilitation.
l Families should have a role in in treatment and rehabilitation; there is a need for services
for families; and for them to be more integral to how services are developed.
l To maintain recovery requires a range of services, including housing, family support,
education, community employment (CE) programmes, free legal aid, social welfare advice
and budgeting services and support to return to employment.
l Many called for mutual aid, support networks and continued aftercare to be made more
widely available, including mutual aid, such as AA, for younger people.
Research
l A wide range of research themes were identified, including research into:
n how addictive and damaging occasional use of different substances is;
n the extent and patterns of substance use in Ireland (including rural areas);
n what substances are most misused and underlying reasons for use;
n accurate death tolls;
n “secret” behaviours, such as drinking in middle class homes; and
n the cost effectiveness of the ‘war on drugs’.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 13
Evidence Review
The Health Research Board (HRB) commissioned the Centre for Public Health at Liverpool
John Moores University to prepare a trends analysis on the drugs situation in Ireland 11 and a
report on the most recent international evidence on responses to problem drug use 12. The
drugs situation in Ireland: an overview of trends from 2005 to 2015 11 reviews the current drug
situation in Ireland, analysing ten years of data up to the most recent data available with
respect to the five European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction (EMCDDA) key
indicators (prevalence of drug use, high risk drug use, treatment demand, drug-related deaths
and mortality and drug-related infectious diseases) as well as drug-related crime and supply. In
addition to presentation of national trends, this report includes additional evidence looking at
trends in data relating to specific sub-populations including people who inject drugs, prisoners,
homeless individuals, sex workers and the Travelling community.
The effectiveness of interventions related to the use of illicit drugs: prevention, harm reduction,
treatment and recovery. A ‘review of reviews’ 12 examines evidence on effective delivery of
interventions in the areas of prevention, harm reduction, treatment and recovery relating to illicit
drug use with the overarching aim of reducing the use of illicit drugs and related harms, and
increasing successful recovery and rehabilitation following drug misuse.
The review highlighted a number of drug prevention, harm reduction and treatment
interventions that are supported by evidence as having positive effects on drug-related
outcomes.
The expert panel considered the 2009-2016 strategy to have been ‘well-crafted and
comprehensive’ when compared to other European strategies and focused on issues that
were a priority at the time, such as heroin use, particularly in inner city areas. Several issues
have emerged since 2009, which require an up-to-date response in the opinion of the panel,
in particular, the use of cocaine, new psychoactive substances, and the emergence of a more
diverse social profile of users, including an aging population of opioid users. Their report also
noted that the drug market has become increasingly globalised and that the internet has
presented particular challenges to law enforcement.
14 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Many key stakeholders interviewed by the panel highlighted the fact that the current Drug
and Alcohol Task Force boundaries were no longer adequately reflecting the pattern of drug
problems around the country. As a result, the panel formed the view that there are gaps in
service provision and inequitable allocation of resources. They recommended a review of Task
Force boundaries in light of current needs and suggested that the results of the 2014/15 general
population survey and estimates of opiate prevalence would provide a good basis for such a
review.
The panel considered that the five pillar format of the strategy, which focused on supply
reduction, prevention, treatment, rehabilitation and research, had encouraged joined up inter-
agency working, but may have been unhelpful in facilitating cross-pillar coordination where
actions related to a number of pillars. To provide greater coherence, they recommended an
overarching long-term vision, a few key goals with specific objectives, related actions and
appropriate performance indicators. They also highlighted the importance of developing
synergies with other relevant strategies, such as the alcohol-focused National Substance Misuse
Strategy 9, mental health strategies and policy documents related to homelessness and Healthy
Ireland.
For the future, they recommended that the strategy should focus on achieving equality of
access to evidence-based services that adhere to quality standards and are responsive to
changing needs, such as new drugs, new patterns of use and new groups of users. They said
that the perspective and engagement of those affected by substance misuse should be integral
to the process of developing the new strategy.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 15
CHAPTER 2 – Vision, Values and Goals
Vision
The vision of the strategy aims to create:
“A healthier and safer Ireland, where public health and safety is protected, and the
harms caused to individuals, families and communities by substance misuse are reduced
and every person affected by substance misuse is empowered to improve their health,
wellbeing and quality of life.”
This vision recognises the importance of responding to the harms caused by substance misuse
which impacts on individuals, families, communities and wider society, and helping those who
develop drug or alcohol problems to address their personal health needs and improve their
health, wellbeing and quality of life.
Values
The new strategy is guided and underpinned by the following values:
l Compassion
A humane, compassionate approach focused on harm reduction which recognises that
substance misuse is a health care issue.
l Respect
Respect for the right of each individual to receive person-centred care based on his or
her specific needs and to be involved in the development of their care plan.
l Equity
A commitment to ensuring people have access to high quality services and support
regardless of where they live or who they are.
l Inclusion
Diversity is valued, the needs of particular groups are accommodated and wide-ranging
participation is promoted.
l Partnership
Support for maintaining a partnership approach between statutory, community and
voluntary bodies and wider society to address drug and alcohol issues.
l Evidence-informed
Support for the use of high quality evidence to inform effective policies and actions to
address drug and alcohol problems.
Taken together, these values underpin the goals, objectives and actions in this strategy and
reinforce the Government’s commitment to adopt a health-led approach to substance misuse
and to provide the supports that are necessary to help people recover their health, wellbeing
and quality of life.
16 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Goals
Goal 1
Promote and protect health and wellbeing
A healthy population is a major asset for society, and improving the health and wellbeing of
the nation is a priority for the Government and the whole of society. Healthy Ireland 3, Ireland’s
framework for improved health and wellbeing, aims to support people and communities in
making more positive changes, to address the social determinants of health and thereby reduce
health inequalities, and to influence the wider environment to enable healthier choices by
everyone. This strategy aims to protect the public from threats to health and wellbeing related
to substance misuse by preventing early use of alcohol and other drugs among young people,
influencing behaviour and challenging social norms and attitudes and providing targeted
interventions aimed at minimising harm for those who have already started to use substances.
Goal 2
Minimise the harms caused by the use and misuse of substances and promote
rehabilitation and recovery
This goal recognises the role of the individual in addressing his or her dependence on
alcohol and other drugs, and that the context within which drug dependency develops has
a fundamental impact on the type of response that is most appropriate to addressing it. It
also acknowledges that substance misuse affects not only those who have developed a drug
or alcohol problem, but also their families, the community and the wider society. Therefore,
interventions and supports are needed to target not only those who have developed a problem
due to the misuse of substances, but also those harmed by another person’s drug and alcohol
use. It is also important to provide tailored interventions to effectively address the needs of
those who face a higher risk of substance misuse because of their lifestyle or because they
belong to a specific group or community of interest.
Goal 3
Address the harms of drug markets and reduce access to drugs for harmful use
Protecting the public from dangerous or potentially dangerous substances and their harmful
effects is a core objective of Ireland’s drug control framework. Gathering information and
intelligence at national and international level is a vital part of the work involved in intercepting
drugs destined for the Irish drug market. It strengthens the response to organised and
gang-related crime, involved in the supply of drugs and related criminal activities. Effective
monitoring of the drugs situation, and the public health threats associated with the supply of
illegal substances, including new drugs, is required to address the harms of the drug market and
reduce access to drugs for harmful use. Addressing the harmful aspects of the drugs situation
in communities, such as drug-dealing and drug-related crime and intimidation, requires a
collaborative effort, across a range of agencies and sectors of society.
Goal 4
Support participation of individuals, families and communities
Building the capacity of communities to respond to the drugs situation is a key goal of
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery. Building social capital is seen as particularly important
in those communities that are most impacted by socio-economic disadvantage, marginalisation
and exclusion, as such communities may require more targeted interventions to address the
issues they face. The full involvement of all stakeholders, including people who use services and
others affected by problem substance use, in the design, implementation and review of services,
policies and strategies is also of vital importance. Throughout this strategy, the term service
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 17
user is used to include people who use healthcare services, their parents, guardians, carers and
families, organisations and communities that represent the interests of people who use health
and social care services, as well as potential users of healthcare services such as people who
currently use drugs. Family members have a particularly important role to play, as they may be
involved in supporting a loved one with a drug problem and may be service users in their own
right.
Goal 5
Develop sound and comprehensive evidence-informed policies and actions
Improving our knowledge and understanding of the drugs problem is a core objective of
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery. For this reason, a sound and comprehensive evidence-
base is needed for policies and actions. Information systems which monitor trends and patterns
in drug use and availability, evaluation of programmes and research into the causes and
consequences of substance misuse will be supported under the new strategy.
18 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
CHAPTER 3 – Goal 1: Promote and protect
health and wellbeing
Introduction
As a nation, we are seeing increasingly higher rates of substance use. One in four (26.4%) adults
has tried an illegal drug at least once in their lifetime and about 24% of the population have
used cannabis at some point in their lives. The 2014/15 All Ireland Drug Prevalence Survey 6
shows higher rates of cannabis use in the last year, (an indicator of recent use) and last month,
(an indicator of current use), than previous surveys. As illustrated in Figure 2 below, the rising
trend in last year cannabis use evident in Ireland can also be seen in other northern European
countries, while the long-term decreasing trends in Spain and the United Kingdom have
stabilised 13.
Figure 2: Last year prevalence of cannabis use among young adults (15-34):
selected trends
25.0
20.0
15.0
10.0
5.0
0.0
2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016
Ireland also has a high level of alcohol consumption and many Irish people engage in
harmful drinking patterns which have significant health, social and economic costs. Alcohol
consumption in 2014 was 20.9% higher than the target of 9.1 litres per capita per annum,
recommended in the National Substance Misuse Strategy. Survey data from the 2013 National
Alcohol Diary Survey 14 indicate that drinkers in Ireland consume alcohol in an unhealthy pattern;
l 37.3% of drinkers engaged in monthly risky single-occasion drinking (RSOD), more
commonly known as binge drinking, in the previous year;
l 54.3% of drinkers had a positive score on the AUDIT-C screening tool and would be
classified as harmful drinkers, indicating that 1.35 million harmful drinkers in Ireland;
l 6.9% scored positive for dependence, which indicates that there were somewhere
between 149,300 and 203,897 dependent drinkers in Ireland in 2013; and
l At least three-quarters of the alcohol consumed was done so as part of a risky
single-occasion or binge drinking session.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 19
Figure 3: Harmful drinking patterns among 18–75-year-old Irish drinkers
(National Alcohol Diary Survey 2013)
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Monthly RSOD Positive AUDIT-C Score Positive DSM-IV Score
The figures presented here are probably an underestimate of the extent of harmful drinking as
there is strong evidence that surveys of self-reported alcohol consumption result in estimates
of per capita consumption well below the level calculated from alcohol sales data.
People who use substances in a harmful way can be influenced by a complex set of factors,
including the publicity messages to which they are exposed, the availability of alcohol, tobacco
and illegal drugs and social, cultural and environmental norms.
This strategy adopts a population health approach to addressing the underlying reasons
for substance misuse, recognising that behaviour change is complex, challenging and takes
time. It puts the needs of people and communities at the centre of the response to substance
misuse and empowers people to take charge of their own health. It reinforces key measures
in the National Substance Misuse Strategy 9, which aim to support people and communities
in making more positive changes and to influence the wider environment so that the healthier
choice is the easier one for everyone. It complements the Public Health (Alcohol) Bill 15, which
contains the proposed legislative provisions to provide a public health response to issues
associated with alcohol consumption in Ireland.
The measures contained in the Public Health (Alcohol) Bill relate to the recommendations
contained in the Steering Group Report on a National Substance Misuse Strategy. The Public
Health (Alcohol) Bill aims to reduce alcohol consumption and to reduce the harms associated
with alcohol.
20 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Recognising that there is no single simple answer, the Public Health (Alcohol) Bill includes a
range of measures designed to collectively have a positive impact on the health and well-being
of Irish people. Those measures include introducing a minimum unit price for alcohol, health
labelling on products that contain alcohol, restrictions on the advertising and marketing of
alcohol, the separation of alcohol products in retail outlets and the regulation of sponsorship
and promotions.
Raising awareness of the risks of substance use and increasing understanding of the harmful
effects of substance misuse on the health of the user and other people in the person’s life is
an important part of the work of prevention. DATFs have made a significant contribution in
this area through organising local and regional awareness initiatives and promoting evidence-
based approaches to community action on alcohol that raise awareness of alcohol-related harm.
Support for these initiatives will continue under the new strategy.
Evidence suggests that education and awareness programmes that are delivered alongside
other measures, which build the lifeskills and confidence necessary to support positive
behaviours and choices, are more likely to be effective in encouraging protective and healthy
behaviour than stand-alone measures. On the other hand, initiatives that use scare tactics or
testimonials from ex-drug users to discourage drug use can be counterproductive and may
have little impact on changing behaviour 12.
Effective drug prevention involves integrated holistic policies and actions, which take account
of the different risk factors for substance use, such as parental substance misuse, family
circumstances, peer pressure, school or work life, lifestyle reasons and socio-economic factors.
Promoting a joined up approach between different government policies and strategies that
may have a bearing on the risk factors for substance misuse is important in this context.
Using manual-based programmes, which set out the practical aspects of the intervention and
ensuring programmes are implemented and regularly evaluated, all increase the likelihood
of success and better outcomes. A coordinated and consistent approach to prevention and
education interventions will be achieved by supporting specific capacity building initiatives
aimed at the relevant sectors and interests groups involved in drug and alcohol education.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 21
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
Preventing or delaying substance use aims to reduce the negative health and social
consequences of drug and alcohol use in society and is therefore an important element in
promoting healthier lifestyles and a healthy society generally. Using substances at a young
age increases the likelihood of developing problems with alcohol and other drugs later in life.
There are physical health risks associated with drug and alcohol use, and adolescents who
use the substances expose themselves to those risks over a longer period of time. Family
circumstances, socio-economic status and a lack of educational attainment can be underlying
reasons for early substance use, and drug use in adolescents frequently overlaps with other
mental health problems.
Surveys from the past ten years show that the greatest increases in drug use are amongst
younger people 6. Figure 4 illustrates that the proportion of young people consuming illegal
drugs in the last year has risen since 2002/03. Last year use of ecstasy among 15-34 year olds
rose sharply from 0.9% in 2010/11 to 4.4% in 2014/15.
22 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Figure 4: Last year prevalence of substance use among 15-34 year olds
18%
16%
14%
12%
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
2002/2003 2006/2007 2010/2011 2014/2015
Data Source: Prevalence of drug use and gambling in Ireland and Northern Ireland. Bulletin 1
The proportion of 15-34 year olds reporting using cannabis in the last month has almost
doubled since 2010/11 as illustrated in Figure 5.
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
2002/2003 2006/2007 2010/2011 2014/2015
Source: Prevalence of drug use and gambling in Ireland and Northern Ireland. Bulletin 1
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 23
School-based interventions
Most universal prevention programmes take place in an educational setting. In Ireland,
substance use education in primary and post primary schools has been developed through
Social, Personal and Health Education (SPHE). The 2015 Life Skills Survey (forthcoming)
indicates that more than 90% of schools provide their students with information on alcohol
and drug misuse through SPHE and other means and that 95% of post primary schools have,
or are progressing, a substance abuse policy. DATFs can play a valuable role in supplementing,
complementing and supporting a planned, comprehensive and established SPHE programme.
Building the capacity of young people to take charge of their own physical and mental health
and wellbeing is at the heart of a whole-school health promotion approach to substance misuse.
The Action Plan for Education 17 aims to ensure resilience and personal wellbeing are integral
parts of the education and training system.
Evidence suggests that comprehensive school-based programmes that combine social and
personal development and provide information about substance use are more likely to be
effective in preventing early substance use. This is the approach recommended in the Action
Plan for Education 17 and will be a key component of a new wellbeing area of learning to be
introduced at Junior Cycle level from 2017 onwards.
Schools will have flexibility in designing their Wellbeing Programme to ensure that it suits their
students and their local context. They will be encouraged to work towards a shared vision
and set of indicators which describe what is important. Activity, responsibility, connectedness,
resilience, respect and awareness are the six indicators which have been identified as central to
wellbeing.
It will also be important to ensure that SPHE teachers, guidance counsellors and Home School
Liaison co-ordinators are given the opportunity to avail of continuing professional development
to build their capacity to deliver substance use education in line with the Action Plan.
In addition, Wellbeing Guidelines that provide a clear and rational structure to support the
promotion of health and wellbeing in all schools, have been developed by the Department of
Education and Skills, the Department of Health and the Health Service Executive and the Action
Plan is committed to the roll out of a national programme to support the implementation of
these guidelines in all primary and post-primary schools.
Out-of-school interventions
Youth services
Youth services play an important role in developing the confidence, social skills, wellbeing
and resilience of young people. The Department of Children and Youth Affairs’ Value for Money
Policy Review (VFMPR) 18 in 2014 recommended changes to youth funding programmes to
ensure evidence-based, effective, value for money services that secure the best outcomes
for young people, particularly, vulnerable young people.
The VFMPR examined three targeted programmes including the Young People’s Facilities
and Services Fund (YPFSF), which was established in 1998, as part of the Government’s overall
strategy to address drug misuse, in order to assist with the development of youth facilities
(including sport and recreational facilities) in areas where a significant drug problem exists or
has the potential to develop. The review recommended amalgamation of the three programmes
into one targeted programme for youth, as there was significant cross-over in the ‘types’
of needs targeted by the programmes, in particular addressing concerns relating to drugs
misuse, crime/anti-social behaviour and educational disadvantage. This recommendation was
accepted by Government and is now Government policy. The target groups of young people
are unchanged under the new scheme.
24 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
The review recommended that service provision for young people would aim to achieve seven
key outcomes which could have a positive impact on delaying the onset of substance misuse.
These seven outcomes are:
l Communication,
l Confidence/agency,
l Planning and problem-solving,
l Relationships,
l Creativity,
l Resilience and determination, and
l Managing feelings.
In order to address the above outcomes, DATFs will be supported to develop targeted,
appropriate and effective services for young people at risk of substance misuse, focused on
social and economically disadvantaged communities.
Family-based interventions
Children living in communities with higher prevalence of problem substance use are at
increased risk of developing problems themselves. For some of these children there are early
identifiable behaviour patterns that indicate possible problems with substances later in life 12.
Personal trauma or life difficulties are associated with risk taking and resultant harm and very
particular, targeted programmes may offset these risks and reduce the possibility of future
harms. However, these risk factors are not always apparent and even those who may not be
identified as being at risk may develop substance use problems given certain conditions.
Parental involvement and concern are the most important protective factors when it comes
to consuming alcohol, cannabis and other drugs for both early-school leavers and those who
remain in school. Substance use by either parent may increase the likelihood of young people
consuming the same substance. On the other hand, a family environment in which substances
are not used on a regular basis can reduce this risk by limiting experimentation at a young age
and providing positive role models. Awareness of these risk and protective factors can provide
parents with the tools to protect their children against the risks of early substance use.
Young people living with family members who have substance use problems can be supported
through the use of programmes specifically designed for these groups and delivered in informal
settings by youth workers and other support staff. Family-based interventions may reduce
initiation and use of cannabis among adolescents and this approach may be particularly
beneficial in communities most affected by problem drug use 12.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 25
Social class and gender can influence the risk of early school leaving. Developmental issues,
emotional and behavioural disorders, mental health concerns, poor attainment and learning
disabilities are also risk factors, which can lead young people to struggle with the curriculum,
peer relationships and the school community. This can result in a gradual disengagement, early
school leaving and consequent greater risks of substance misuse.
There are a number of initiatives and programmes that aim to address the factors that influence
early school leaving and improve school retention rates. These include:
l the School Completion Programme and the Home School Community Liaison Scheme;
l the Department of Education’s Programme “Delivering Equality of Opportunity in
Schools” (DEIS), which has seen significant improvements in retention rates in DEIS
schools in recent years;
l Meitheal, the TUSLA national practice model, an interagency model of work to ensure the
effective delivery of services for “at risk” young people; and
l the Department of Housing, Planning and Local Government’s Social Inclusion and
Community Activation Programme (SICAP), which provides supports to children and
young people from target groups who are at risk of early school leaving and/or not in
employment, education or training aged between 15 and 24.
During 2017, a School Completion Strategy will be developed by the Department of Children
and Youth Affairs in collaboration with TUSLA Educational and Welfare Services and the
Department of Education and Skills and a review of senior cycle programmes and vocational
pathways will be undertaken by the Department of Education and Skills to ensure that those
who do not seem to thrive in a traditional academic setting complete their education. The
review will include all those in the 16–18 age range and cover the range of programmes and
vocational pathways currently provided in this regard – Leaving Certificate, Leaving Certificate
Applied, Leaving Certificate Vocational Programme, Transition Year, Youthreach and Community
Training Centres, Special Education, and other relevant programmes.
The State has invested a lot of resources in providing some excellent facilities for schools. The
availability of such school facilities outside the times they are required to deliver mainstream
education could facilitate many positive initiatives, particularly in disadvantaged areas, such as
sport, recreation, music and artistic activities. This would enable communities to meet the needs
of young people and the wider community much more effectively, at little extra cost to the
State.
26 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
1.2.4 Promote a health In line with the Action Plan for DES DOH/
promotion approach to Education HSE
addressing substance a) Commencing and rolling out
misuse. a national programme to
support the implementation
of the Wellbeing Guidelines to
all primary and post-primary
schools; and
b) Developing Wellbeing Guidelines
for Centres of Education and
Training.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 27
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
1.2.8 Improve services for Developing a new scheme to provide DOH DCYA,
young people at risk targeted, appropriate and effective HSE,
of substance misuse in services for young people at risk of DATF.
socially and economically substance misuse, focused on socially
disadvantaged and economically disadvantaged
communities. communities.
Not all children in homes where substances are misused experience harm as a result, but
children living with parental problem substance use are more likely to experience mental
health problems, academic under-achievement, have poor social skills and be more prone to
developing substance misuse problems themselves later in life. Genetic factors combined with
physical and emotional neglect and exposure to poor parenting can impact on a child’s social
and emotional maturation, development of social competencies and undermine reliance and
the capacity for emotional regulation, all established determinants for substance misuse in
adulthood.
Analysis of general population survey and treatment data can provide estimates of the numbers
of children of parents who misuse substances and may help in determining the scale of the
interventions needed to respond to this problem. For family-based interventions, prevention
experts recommend approaches that involve the whole family rather than those that train
parents alone.
Evidence suggest that prevention interventions targeting those at risk may be more effective
if they involve both schools and parents, are interactive and have positive goals. There is some
evidence that family interventions may be effective in delaying or reducing drug use but
there is not a great deal of research on family interventions targeted at children of drug-using
parents 23.
A coordinated response to the needs of children in families where substances are misused will
help to protect these children from harm. Addiction and other services providing support to
children can work closely together and agree protocols for exchanging information, agreeing on
referrals and for sharing other responsibilities in this sensitive area.
28 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
For young people with substance use problems, family therapies may be effective in reducing
drug use frequency and severity in comparison to other interventions among adolescents,
including cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT). For very young at-risk children, interventions
that are aimed at strengthening relationships between children and their parents and
developing parenting skills can impact on child behaviour. As with universal prevention
programmes these interventions are more likely to be successful if they are delivered by trained
professionals through frequent sessions. There is a need to ensure continued support for family
support programmes. Strengthening Families, Parenting under Pressure and the 5 step method
(Stress-Strain-Coping-Support model) are examples of programmes that have been supported
in Ireland to build the resilience of families and support them in their own right.
The “Men who have sex with men internet survey Ireland” 26 (MISI) published in 2016, reported
that 36% of respondents had used recreational drugs within the previous 12 months: the most
commonly used were cannabis (28%), MDMA (17%) and cocaine (13%). Over half (58%) of
respondents reported that they binge drank on a typical drinking occasion, and 44% binge drink
every week. Separately, a 2016 survey of men attending the Gay Men’s Health Service (GMHS)
in Baggot Street, Dublin noted that 27% of respondents reported that they had engaged in
chemsex (used drugs for or during sex) within the previous 12 months; the most commonly
used drugs were gamma-hydroxybutyric acid/gamma-butyrolactone (GBH/GBL), cocaine,
ketamine and chrystal methamphetamine.
While prevalence of new psychoactive substances (NPS) use is relatively low in the general
population, the increase in the rate of deaths involving NPS from 8 in 2012 to 28 in 2013, and
23 in 2014 is a cause for concern 8. Moreover polydrug use, including alcohol can increase the
risks associated with NPS use. This underlines the ongoing need for targeted initiatives to raise
awareness of the dangers and significant mental and physical health effects that can be caused
by NPS use.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 29
Use of image and performance enhancing drugs (IPED) can also put people at risk. Service
providers report an increase in clients of their needle exchange programmes who use IPED,
such as steroids. Existing harm reduction services are traditionally geared towards users of
psychoactive substances. Given the divergent profile and nature of substance use among
IPED users, there is a need to develop a tailored approach in response to the profile of harm
within this group. Expanding the range and nature of models of practice may serve to enhance
accessibility, engagement, and effectiveness. There may be a case for developing a specialised
IPED clinic for those currently using mainstream needle exchange services 27.
These findings point to the need for targeted harm-reduction, education and prevention
measures that are tailored towards these higher risk groups. These may include education,
information and interaction with people who use drugs in environments where drug taking can
occur (e.g. festivals, nightclubs etc.). Harm reduction initiatives and drug welfare are becoming a
mainstream part of festivals in many European countries and there have been similar initiatives
in Ireland. The development of IT/web based drug education, harm reduction and brief advice
tools targeted at 3rd level students, which have a component signposting to locally available
supports, will be a key element of the prevention strategy. The development of such initiatives
will need to be compatible with national drug prevention programmes and involve the relevant
networks, such as student and LGBTI organisations. The engagement of people who use drugs
and/or services in the development and roll-out of any awareness campaigns is particularly
important to ensure relevance and accuracy.
Examples of awareness initiatives targeting 3rd level students include the “What’s In The Pill?”
campaign, and SpunOut’s targeted online advertising. Online awareness campaigns along
the lines developed by Drugs.ie, which use advertisements on Facebook and Twitter, as well
as active engagement with online discussion sites and other online media outlets frequented
by young people, play an important role in highlighting the risks of psychoactive substances.
Similarly, targeted awareness campaigns, such as the Drugs.ie campaign on the use of GBH/
GBL, highlight particular issues among high-risk groups or about particular patterns of drugs
use.
In order to respond to emerging trends such as high risk behaviours associated with lifestyle
choices or risky patterns of substance use, a need has been identified to establish a working
group to undertake an examination of the evidence on the effectiveness of early harm reduction
responses, such as targeted information campaigns, drug-testing and amnesty bins to respond
to emerging trends. This will be pursued by the HSE in conjunction with other relevant
stakeholders.
30 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
1.3.9 Mitigate the risk and a) Developing and adopting HSE, NFSN
reduce the impact of evidence-based family and TUSLA C&V
parental substance parenting skills programmes for (Joint sectors
misuse on babies and services engaging with high risk Leads)
young children. families impacted by problematic
substance use;
b) Building awareness of the hidden
harm of parental substance
misuse with the aim of increasing
responsiveness to affected
children;
c) Developing protocols between
addiction services, maternity
services and children’s health
and social care services that will
facilitate a coordinated response
to the needs of children affected
by parental substance misuse;
and
d) Ensuring adult substance use
services identify clients who
have dependent children and
contribute actively to meeting
their needs either directly or
through referral to or liaison
with other appropriate services,
including those in the non-
statutory sector.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 31
Performance indicators related to Goal 1
l Reduction in the use of illegal drugs in the last year (Drug Prevalence Survey).
l Reduction in the alcohol consumption rate (Drug Prevalence Survey).
l Increase in knowledge with respect to the harms of alcohol, cannabis and other drugs
(Drug Prevalence Survey, other sources).
l Delaying the age of first use of illicit drugs (ESPAD survey).
l Delaying the age of first drink (Drug Prevalence Survey, ESPAD survey).
l Reduction in binge drinking among young people (ESPAD, Drugs Prevalence and HBSC
Surveys).
l Stabilisation in recent and reduction in current prevalence of illicit drugs in 15-24 year old
population (Drug Prevalence Survey).
l Stabilisation in recent and reduction in current prevalence of illicit drugs in 15-24 year old
population (Drug Prevalence Survey).
l Prevalence of children living with parental substance misuse (GUI survey (Growing up
in Ireland), NACDA research on children living with parental substance misuse).
l Identify the number of children who come to the attention of child protection services
as a result of parental substance misuse (Children in Care dataset, HSE).
32 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
CHAPTER 4 – Goal 2: Minimise the
harms caused by the use and misuse
of substances and promote rehabilitation
and recovery
Introduction
Problem substance use is a chronic, often recurring condition that can cause substantial harm
to the person concerned. As a result, recovery is often seen as a journey, and rehabilitation as
a process, that supports and encourages the individual at each stage along the pathway to
recovery. Recovery is a personal matter. A successful outcome or improvement for one person
may involve improving their quality of life and overcoming reliance on their primary drug of
dependence. For another person, the ultimate goal for their own recovery may be to become
drug free. In order to promote recovery and minimise the harms caused by substance misuse,
timely access to appropriate services relevant to the needs and circumstances of the person
concerned is of fundamental importance.
Information, advice and referral interventions are provided through Tier 1 of the model. Tier
1 interventions also include the type of social reintegration and rehabilitation support and
wraparound services that a person may need following specialist treatment provided in Tier 3 or
Tier 4 settings. These interventions are made available through an integrated system of support
that includes education and training, employment, housing, family support, general health and
other services.
Specialised and dedicated inpatient or residential units or wards provide Tier 4 interventions,
which include inpatient detoxification, sometimes linked to residential rehabilitation units, or
assisted withdrawal and stabilisation.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 33
Figure 6: The Four Tier Model of Care
TIER 1
Interventions where
main focus is not
drug treatment
Family Social
TIER 2
support care
Drug-related
interventions
TIER 3 Community
Job Pharmacies Specialist drug- based Housing
seeking related interventions
support
skills
TIER 4
Specialist
Prison dedicated Community
setting inpatient or setting
residential
units or
Employment wards Education
support services
Primary Hospital
Outreach
care setting
Specialist Criminal
Vocational addiction justice &
training services probation
services
General
healthcare
setting
Source of image: Doyle J, Ivanovic J National Drugs Rehabilitation Framework Document. National Drugs Rehabilitation
Implementation Committee. Dublin: Health Services Executive 2010.
The recognition that no one service can cater for the diverse needs of the service user is key to
improving health and social outcomes for people who experience harm as a result of substance
misuse. Case management aims to increase engagement with different services and to achieve
common goals through providing an integrated care pathway for the service user. Evidence
suggests that it is an effective approach to retaining people in treatment.
The HSE has developed a National Drugs Rehabilitation Framework 29 (NDRF) which
acknowledges that the integrated care pathway is the shared responsibility of a range
of agencies. These may include education, training and employment, health, welfare and
housing sectors, depending on the circumstances of the individual concerned. The framework
contains broad national protocols to facilitate inter-agency working, covering issues such as
confidentiality, common assessment tools, referral procedures and conflict resolution between
agencies.
As part of the NDRF, the HSE has devised a structured and evidence based model of screening
and brief intervention that is undertaken prior to the key working, care planning and case
management phases of service provision. It enables an initial assessment to be made in relation
to problem alcohol and substance use in order to intervene early with at-risk groups in a variety
of settings and refer the person on to relevant services as appropriate.
34 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
The HSE has also developed a series of training programmes on the NDRF, including an online
training package on key working and care planning, aimed at drug and alcohol services, and
homeless services involved in the rehabilitation process. The intention is to expand this training
to a range of other services and settings in order to achieve integrated case management,
seamless transition between services and optimal pathways to recovery for people who use
addiction services. This will include training on screening and brief intervention.
Drug treatment services have been expanded throughout the country over the past decade to
respond to a rising demand for drug treatment. Much of this expansion has concentrated on
improving access to opioid substitution treatment (OST) and harm reduction initiatives, such
as needle exchange programmes, outside Dublin, especially in areas of the country that have
experienced opioid problems more recently. Community-based drug projects have contributed
towards expanding the network of services by delivering an integrated holistic service on the
ground in their communities on behalf of statutory agencies.
In the past ten years, the number of residential beds has increased significantly, largely due
to the increased provision of beds in community-based residential facilities. The most recent
figures available (including private provision) estimate current provision at 787 residential beds,
comprising 23 inpatient unit detoxificiation beds, 117 community-based residential detoxification
beds, 4 adolescent residential detoxification beds, 625 residential rehabilitation beds and 18
adolescent residential beds.
The rising demand for drug treatment is evident in the treatment figures in the past decade 11.
The numbers of new treatment cases, excluding alcohol, increased from 2,278 to 3,742 between
2006 and 2015 30. The most notable changes were in the numbers of new cases treated for
problem cannabis use, which rose rapidly in the time period, and for benzodiazepines, which
rose steadily between 2008 and 2014, with a small decrease recorded in 2015.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 35
Figure 7: New treatment cases by drug type 2006-2015
4000
Number entering treatment
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0
2002/2003 2006/2007 2010/2011 2014/2015
Ireland remains a country with a relatively large opiate problem, and although the
characteristics of this group are changing, they remain a key target for drug treatment services.
Since 2009, the HSE has provided wider access to Opioid Substitution Treatment (OST) around
the country. This has been achieved through the establishment of new treatment centres, the
participation of more GPs in the prescribing of OST and the involvement of more pharmacies in
the dispensing of methadone.
Reflecting the wider availability of OST, the number of clients in receipt of OST as of 31st
December each year increased steadily from 7,260 in 2005 to 10,087 in December 2016. At the
end of December 2008, there were 5,181 patients attending clinics, with a further 452 receiving
OST in prison. At the end of December 2016, the figures were 5,438 and 465 respectively.
Within a GP setting there have been even greater increases. At the end of December 2008,
there were 3,085 patients receiving OST in GP settings, which had increased to 4,184 at the end
of December 2016 (an increase of more than 35%) 31.
36 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Figure 8: Numbers in OST treatment by provider
6000
5000
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
Clinics GPs Prison
Despite improvements in service provision, people report having to travel a significant distance
to access more specialist treatments, especially in rural areas. The time involved, the cost
of travel, the need for childcare or the absence of a support network can result in barriers
to accessing treatment for some people, even when there are financial supports available.
Difficulties in accessing OST also include a lack of local services and waiting times. A range
of options will therefore be explored to facilitate wider access to OST in the community. This
includes measures to involve more GPs in prescribing OST, an examination of the feasibility
of nurse-prescribing of OST and the provision of OST in a wider range of settings, such as
community-based initiatives or homeless services.
In conjunction with the Irish College of General Practioners, the HSE is working to increase
engagement of all GPs who are trained at Level 1 and Level 2 throughout the country. Level 1
training provides the foundation for treating stable methadone maintained patients. Having
successfully managed a number of patients for at least one year and having completed an
external clinical audit, a GP may progress to Level 2. A Level 2 GP may initiate treatment,
stabilise doses and provide ongoing maintenance treatment to a drug user in the primary care
setting. Ideally all stable methadone patients who are registered with a Level 1 GP should be
transferred to their own GP, where appropriate, provided their own GP has Level 1 training.
People who are dependent on opiates, are engaged in high risk drug use such as injecting,
or who are using multiple substances can also experience barriers to accessing treatment,
especially residential treatment 11. At the end of 2014, there were 9,764 people availing of OST.
The national prevalence estimate of opiate users in 2014 was between 18,720 and 21,454, which
would suggest that there is a considerable number of people who use opiates not currently in
treatment 7. All the participants in a 2009 Irish study on sex work 32, had a history of injecting
drug use and half reported recently injecting drugs. This highlights the need for an effective
response for those with complex interlocking needs.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 37
Some residential services do not have the appropriate level of clinical governance to respond to
those with more complex needs, and may have entry thresholds in place which exclude those
who have more unstable patterns of drug use. Standardising referral processes and lowering
the entry criteria for accessing residential treatment services, while ensuring appropriate levels
of clinical governance, would make it easier for people with more complex needs to access
treatment. The development of residential services that can cater for the needs of those who
use a variety of substances will be particularly important in this context.
It is also intended to improve treatment choices for people who are not clinically suited to
methadone treatment, but require medication-assisted therapy to address dependence on
opiates. There is a commitment in the 2017 HSE Service Plan to provide wider access to
alternative OST products containing buprenorphine or buprenorphine/naloxone.
The National Clinical Effectiveness Committee (NCEC) Standards for Clinical Practice Guidance
(2015) promote consistency of approach for the development of guidelines and guidance such
as policies and protocols. These NCEC National Clinical Guidelines and National Clinical Audit
endorsed by the Minister for Health are mandated for implementation in the Irish health system
and their implementation will be monitored through HSE Performance Assurance Reports,
compliance with the National Standards for Safer Better Healthcare and increased alignment
with the Clinical Indemnity Scheme.
The HSE has published national clinical guidelines for OST to ensure that the quality and safety
of care to the patient is maintained and improved where necessary. The HSE will implement
these guidelines until National Clinical Effectiveness Committee guidelines are in place 31.
Mapping the range of services currently available against underlying need in order to identify
gaps in provision across the country will help to ensure that there is an appropriate mix of
quality services to respond to changing trends and patterns of drug use, including the rising
demand for treatment for cannabis-related problems. It will also be important to continue
developing the capacity of services to respond to those with more complex needs, including
vulnerable groups, such as Travellers or those affected by homelessness, or those with more
high-risk behaviours or patterns of use.
38 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
2.1.13 Expand the availability a) Identifying and addressing gaps HSE C&V
and geographical spread in provision within Tier 1, 2, 3 and sectors,
of relevant quality drug 4 services; DATFs
and alcohol services and b) Increasing the number of
improve the range of treatment episodes provided
services available, based across the range of services
on identified need. available, including:
l Low Threshold;
l Stabilisation;
l Detoxification;
l Rehabilitation;
l Step-down;
l After-Care;
c) Strengthening the capacity of
services to address complex
needs.
2.1.15 Enhance the quality Implementing the HSE National HSE DOH
and safety of care in Clinical Guidelines on OST and
the delivery of Opioid reviewing in line with National Clinical
Substitution Treatment Effectiveness Committee processes.
(OST).
Helping individuals to build their recovery capital is at the heart of the continuum of care model,
which is centred on the individual and their needs at each stage in their personal recovery
pathway. A variety of elements can support or jeopardise recovery; these include social
networks, physical, human, cultural and community issues. In the circumstances, developing
social, educational and employment skills should form a key part of individual care plans.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 39
Community Drug Projects play an important role in building recovery capital by delivering an
integrated holistic service on the ground in their communities in partnership with statutory
agencies. They are well placed to adapt and respond to the changing needs of service users,
their families and the wider community. A rehabilitation project based in Dublin’s north-inner
city is a good example of a community-based interagency initiative. It provides a structured
assets-based programme of learning and development which gives educational opportunities
to people in recovery who may have left school at a young age.
The contribution that a job can make to progressing and maintaining recovery is well
established 34. The Department of Social Protection’s (DSP) Community Employment
Programme aims to support the development of personal and employment skills and act as
the labour market element in the Continuum of Care. This programme allocates 1,000 places to
people in recovery through a number of dedicated Drug Rehabilitation CE schemes. Building on
the key role of Community Employment (CE) in relation to the rehabilitation, progression and
reintegration into society of recovering drug users, the implementation of the DSP Programme
Framework for CE Drug Rehabilitation Schemes will be monitored under this strategy to
improve overall progression rates.
Often a number of issues need to be addressed before individuals can progress to activation
and job search. Therefore, undertaking wellbeing/self-esteem/confidence building work is often
a starting point for progression towards employment or further education. The Social Inclusion
and Community Activation Programme (SICAP), which is overseen and managed by Local
Community Development Committees (LCDCs) in each local authority area, supports individuals
and marginalised target groups experiencing educational disadvantage or unemployment so
they can participate fully, engage with and progress through life-long learning opportunities
through the use of community development approaches. SICAP programme implementers
engage with participants on a one-to-one basis and agree a personal action plan. SICAP
supports include educational supports, labour market training and occupational specific skills,
career advice and guidance support, employment supports and self employment supports
which assist in moving individuals closer to or into the labour market, which has a positive
effect on the individuals, their families and the wider community. During 2016, 55,890 children
received educational and/or developmental support under SICAP, of which, 782 were identified
as being at risk of early school leaving and a further 5,373 young people aged between 15 and
24 years old who were not in employment, education or training were also supported.
Poverty, deprivation and inequality contribute to the vulnerability that may lead to dependency
and harm and act as barriers to recovery and leading a fulfilling, safe and healthy life. Those
who have completed treatment programmes will continue to need access to aftercare services
and other progression options to enable them to sustain recovery. These options may include
educational support, personal development, training and employment opportunities, as well as
continued access to peer-support. In order to help such groups maintain their recovery, it will
be necessary to increase opportunities for their progression. Identifying and remedying any
barriers to accessing such supports will be important in this context.
40 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
2.1.16 Improve relapse Developing and broadening the range HSE C&V sectors,
prevention and of peer-led, mutual aid and family UISCE, NFSN
aftercare services. support programmes in accordance
with best practice.
2.1.19 Increase the range of Establishing a Working Group to: DOH HSE, DSP,
progression options a) Examine the range of IPS, Other
for recovering drug progression options for relevant
users and develop a those exiting treatment, prison, Departments
new programme of Community Employment & Agencies
supported care and schemes including key skills
employment. training and community
participation with a view to
developing a new programme of
supported care and employment;
and
b) Identify and remedy the
barriers to accessing the
range of educational, personal
development, training and
employment opportunities
and supports, including gender
specific barriers and the lack
of childcare provision, for
those in recovery.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 41
Improving access to services for women, children and young people
Women
Women can experience barriers to engaging and sustaining involvement with treatment and
rehabilitation services. Many women in addiction have experienced domestic violence (in their
family of origin and/or in intimate partner relationships) and services should be equipped to
respond appropriately to this issue. There is a need for greater awareness of the implications
of domestic violence, trauma and mental health for treatment and rehabilitation of women
with addictions.
The absence of childcare can be a barrier for women attending treatment and after-care
services. While there are good examples of wrap-around services for female drug-users in
recovery and their children, there is only one residential treatment service located in west
Dublin, where mothers can keep their babies with them during treatment. There is a need to
increase the range of wrap-around services and supports to facilitate more women with children
or who are pregnant taking up treatment.
There are currently three Drug Liaison Midwives, with each attached to one of the three Dublin
maternity hospitals (the Rotunda, the National Maternity Hospital and the Coombe Women &
Infants University Hospital). They are employed by the Addiction services and work in special
clinics in each of the hospitals. The Drug Liaison Midwives see pregnant opioid dependent
women in their clinics, support them throughout their pregnancy and for six weeks post-natal.
They can arrange for inpatient detoxification or stabilisation if necessary and have contributed
significantly to reducing stigma and harm to this vulnerable group of patients.
A study in the Coombe Women & Infants University Hospital 35 in Dublin showed that 4.6%
of women who registered for care reported using drugs during pregnancy, the vast majority
of which related to methadone. These women have complex medical and social needs and
are at an increased risk of having babies with low birth weights and other complications.
Their involvement with the maternity services provides an opportunity to reduce their drug
dependence and improve their social circumstances and wellbeing.
While recent years have seen a decrease in the number of opiate dependent women attending
these services, there are concerns about alcohol use during pregnancy. A 2017 Lancet study
36 found that, of the 50 countries for which data were available, Ireland was one of the five
A National Women & Infants Health Programme (NWIHP) has been established within the HSE
to lead the management, organisation and delivery of maternity, gynaecological and neonatal
services across primary, community and acute care. The National Maternity Strategy 37 made
the following recommendations regarding alcohol and drugs misuse:
l The NWIHP will examine the need to provide drug liaison midwives and specialist medical
social workers in all maternity networks;
l Maternity hospitals/units will strengthen their methods of detecting alcohol abuse and
supporting women to reduce their intake; and
l The NWIHP will develop a consistent approach to informing women about the risks of
alcohol consumption during pregnancy.
42 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Children and young people
The National Substance Misuse Strategy 9 highlighted the need to expand services for people
under 18 years of age who are experiencing problems as a result of using substances. Most
young people can be treated in the community, but some will need more specialised services,
including residential rehabilitation and detoxification facilities. Many young people with
substance use issues may also be experiencing mental health problems which need to be
addressed as part of their treatment. The Youth Drug and Alcohol Service (YoDA) based in west
Dublin provides assistance and treatment to those under 18 who are having problems related to
their drug or alcohol use. A 2013 study of users of the service 38 found that 48% had a lifetime
history of psychiatric disorders, with deliberate self-harm being the most common condition.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 43
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
2.1.21 Respond to the needs a) Increasing the range of wrap- HSE DOH,
of women who are around community and DATFs
using drugs and/or residential services equipped to
alcohol in a harmful meet the needs of women who
manner. are using drugs and/or alcohol in
a harmful manner, including those
with children and those who are
pregnant; and
b) Developing interventions to
address gender and cultural
specific risk factors for not taking
up treatment.
2.1.22 Expand the range, a) Identifying and addressing gaps HSE, C&V
availability and in child and adolescent service TUSLA sectors,
geographical spread provision; DATFs
of problem drug and b) Developing multi-disciplinary
alcohol services for child and adolescent teams; and
those under the age of
c) Developing better interagency
18.
cooperation between problem
substance use and child and
family services.
The HSE is currently examining the most practical, sustainable means of supporting staff
to deliver services in culturally competent ways in consultation with traveller representative
organisations. Cultural competence is defined as the ability of service providers and
organisations to effectively deliver health care services that meet the social, cultural and
linguistic needs of those who use services. Service-delivery staff should uphold fundamental
values and attitudes (such as equality, empathy and engagement) towards all service users.
44 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
People with a co-occurring mental health and substance use problem
A recurring theme in the public consultation was a concern about access to services for
people who have a co-occuring mental health and substance use problem, often called “dual
diagnosis”. Ensuring that people with a dual diagnosis receive an assessment, an onward referral
and timely access to appropriate treatment is extremely important. They may be dealing with
the impact of trauma or a psychiatric disorder as well as experiencing problems as a result of
alcohol and/or drug use. These individuals may also have physical and psychological health
problems, disabilities, or problems with housing, employment and relationships or have a
history of offending.
The HSE’s Mental Health Division is working with the Clinical Strategy and Programmes Division
to develop a new Mental Health Clinical Programme called “Dual Diagnosis: mental illness
and co-morbid substance misuse”. The aim of this Programme is to develop a standardised
evidence-based approach to the identification, assessment and treatment of co-morbid mental
illness and substance misuse. This includes increasing awareness of the frequent coexistence of
mental illness and substance misuse; ensuring there is a clear clinical pathway for management
of people with such a dual diagnosis, including when they present to Emergency Departments;
ensuring a standardised service is provided throughout the country; and ensuring adolescents
are also included within the scope of this Clinical Programme.
An integral part of the Dual Diagnosis Programme will be to devise a model of care that will
ensure that all adolescents and adults suspected of having a moderate to severe mental illness
coexisting with significant substance misuse have access to a timely mental health service
delivered on a regional basis. The service will be provided in an integrated manner across
the Primary Care Division and the Mental Health Service. There will also be close working
relationships with the relevant specialities in Acute Hospitals to deal with any medical co-
morbidities that may occur, particularly in those with alcohol misuse.
In Rebuilding Ireland: Action Plan for Housing and Homelessness 41, the Government committed
to a tripling of the target for tenancies to be provided. Housing led/housing first programmes,
which provide for accommodation with supports as required, are internationally considered as
best practice in addressing the needs of people who are long-term homeless and with complex
needs. The success of such initiatives depends not just on housing but also, crucially, on drug
and alcohol, mental health, and community integration services being available.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 45
There is a range of drug rehabilitation programmes available for prisoners that involve a
significant multidimensional input by a diverse range of general and specialist services
provided both by the Irish Prison Service (IPS) and visiting statutory and non-statutory
organisations 43. The programmes seek to reduce the demand for drugs within the prison
system through education, treatment and rehabilitation services for prisoners with addictions.
Particular initiatives include the provision of detoxification, methadone maintenance, education
programmes, addiction counselling and drug therapy programmes. The delivery of these
services is being achieved in partnership with community-based services and has brought a
significant improvement in the range, quality and availability of drug treatment services in the
prisons.
The IPS continues to work to decrease the availability and use of illicit drugs in the prison
environment. These efforts will need to take into consideration the challenges posed in
responding to the newer drugs of choice, in particular, new psychoactive substances, in
the prison environment. These newer drugs will require more contemporary and advanced
strategies to meet the physical, procedural and related security requirements.
46 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Although male Travellers entering drug treatment were less likely to have lifetime prevalence
of injecting drug use compared to the general population, female Travellers reported higher
rates of injecting; 24% compared to 16% in the general population. Travellers entering drug
treatment were more likely to report polydrug use, with cannabis the most frequently reported
second problem substance 11. Good practice guidelines, produced on behalf of this community,
provide useful and practical advice on supporting Travellers who need to use treatment
services.
2.1.23 Improve the response Examining the need for the HSE C&V
to the needs of older development of specialist services to sectors,
people with long term meet the needs of older people with DATFs
substance use issues. long term substance use issues.
2.1.24 Improve outcomes for a) Supporting the new Mental HSE DOH,
people with co-morbid Health Clinical Programme to IPS, C&V
severe mental illness address dual diagnosis; and sectors
and substance misuse b) Developing joint protocols
problems. between mental health services
and drug and alcohol services
with the objective of undertaking
an assessment with integrated
care planning in line with the
National Drug Rehabilitation
Framework.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 47
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
48 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
HPSC data show a gradual decline in new cases of HIV amongst PWID from 2005 to 2012.
The number of such cases began to rise in 2013 and continued to rise to 27 cases in 2014.
In 2015, 9% (45) of newly diagnosed HIV cases were PWID. This is the highest number of
new HIV cases among PWID recorded since 2008 45.
Ensuring access to needle exchange, harm-reduction advice promoting sexual health and
screening programmes will continue to play an important role in reducing the risk of contracting
blood-borne viruses such as HCV and HIV. Needle exchanges are provided in counties Dublin,
Kildare and Wicklow by a mix of static and outreach services. The National Pharmacy Needle
Exchange programme provides needle exchange interventions outside of these areas. At the
end of 2016, there were 109 pharmacies participating in this programme 31. An average of 1,330
individuals attended pharmacy-based needle exchanges each month in 2014.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 49
The National Drug Related Deaths Index (NDRDI) indicates that prescription drugs were
implicated in three in every four, or 259, poisoning deaths during 2014. Benzodiazepines were
the most common prescription drug group implicated and diazepam (a benzodiazepine) was
the most common single prescription drug implicated in 115 (32%) of all poisoning deaths in
that period 8.
The illegal trade in so-called z-drugs, has exacerbated the problem particularly among those
who inject drugs. The Minister for Health has amended the Misuse of Drugs Regulations to
tighten controls on benzodiazepines and z-drugs. It will be important to ensure that the health
needs of people, who can no longer gain access to these substances through the illegal drug
market are addressed when such controls are in place.
There is a recognised problem with street injecting in Ireland, particularly in Dublin City
centre. This practice poses a significant health risk for people who use drugs, and results in
discarded needles which presents a public health risk to others. Mounting public concern
and campaigning by harm reduction advocates led to a proposal for the establishment of
supervised injecting facilities (SIF) to ameliorate these problems and the Programme for
Government contains a commitment to legislate for such facilities.
On 16 May the Misuse of Drugs (Supervised Injecting Facilities) Act 2017 (No. 7 of 2017) 46 was
signed by the President having been passed by the Oireachtas on 10 May. The Act will allow for
the licensing and establishment of supervised injecting facilities by the Minister for Health. The
HSE plans to establish the first SIF on a pilot basis in order to determine its utility, safety and
cost effectiveness in an Irish context.
There is a worrying level of overdose rates in Ireland. 4,256 non-fatal overdose cases, or
poisoning by alcohol and/or other drugs, were recorded as being admitted to Irish hospitals in
2014. This reflected a marginal increase from 4,233 cases in 2013, but trends over time indicate
a decrease from 2005 when there were 5,012 cases 45.
In 2014, the EMCDDA reported the mortality rate due to overdoses (poisonings) in Europe
was estimated at 18.3 deaths per million population for people aged 15–64 47. Estimates for
overdose mortality rates in Ireland are much higher, at 71 per million, the third highest in Europe
after Estonia (113 per million) and Sweden (93 per million). However, caution is required when
interpreting overdose data across the EU for reasons which include systematic under reporting
in some countries and registration processes that result in reporting delays.
According to the latest NDRDI figures available, the total number of drug-related deaths
rose from 505 to 697 over the period 2005 to 2014 inclusive. The NDRDI reports on poisoning
deaths (also known as overdose) which are due to the toxic effect of a drug, or combination
of drugs, and on non-poisonings which are deaths among people who use drugs, as a result
of trauma or medical reasons 8.
50 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Figure 9: Drug Related Deaths in Ireland 2005–2014
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Deaths due to non-poisoning increased at a greater rate than poisoning deaths. Deaths due to
poisonings remain a higher proportion of the total: the number of poisoning deaths increasing
from 301 to 354 and non-poisonings deaths from 202 to 342, during the 10 year period. Many
of these deaths are premature; half of all deaths in 2014 involved people aged 39 years or
younger and three in four (523) involved males.
Alcohol was implicated in one in three drug-related deaths and remains the single most
common drug implicated in deaths between 2004 and 2014. 59% of deaths where alcohol
was implicated involved other drugs, mainly opiates. Three deaths per day in 2013 were alcohol
related and one in three self harm cases during 2013 were alcohol related. Alcohol alone
was responsible for 13% of all poisoning deaths.
The risk of overdose or death due to poisoning or fatalities caused by disease, infection or
other effects of drug use is higher among those who inject drugs or those engaged in polydrug
use. Opiates were the main drug implicated in deaths due to overdose. Two thirds of those who
died in 2014 had taken a mixture of drugs. Benzodiazepines were the most common drug group
involved in polydrug deaths.
This points to the need for overdose prevention strategies to reduce the incidence of both fatal
and non-fatal overdose through the provision of targeted preventative responses for cohorts of
the drug using population at higher risk of overdose. This should involve the targeting of known
risk-periods, such as release from prison and leaving drug-treatment.
The piloting of the Naloxone Programme by the HSE between 2015 and 2016 is an example of a
successful measure to reduce overdoses and drug-related deaths among those who use drugs.
The pilot project was supported by voluntary service providers, the Irish Prison Service and the
National Family Support Network. The HSE Service Plan for 2017 includes a commitment to
further expand the Naloxone Programme to other drug users and their families 48. The HSE will
continue to strengthen overdose prevention strategies in the coming years in order to maintain
the focus on reducing drug-related deaths and non-fatal overdoses.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 51
In addition, a clear ongoing association between certain types of non-poisoning deaths and
mental health issues is emerging from the data. This points to a high level of such deaths
involving persons experiencing both drug or alcohol misuse and mental health disorders
(dual diagnosis). There was a 21% increase in deaths due to hanging between 2013 and 2014
and more than two thirds (67%) of people who died as a result of hanging had a history of
mental health illness.
Ireland’s National Strategy to Reduce Suicide “Connecting for Life” sets out a vision of an
Ireland where fewer lives are lost through suicide, and where communities and individuals
are empowered to improve their mental health and well-being 49.
This Strategy is being led by the Department of Health and involves actions assigned to the
HSE, various Government departments and key statutory and non-statutory agencies in Ireland.
Responsibility for monitoring and reporting systems to support the delivery of the Strategy
has been assigned to the National Office for Suicide Prevention. The Strategy provides an
implementation and evaluation structure to achieve each of the goals it proposes, with defined
actions and a lead agency and key partners in place for each individual objective. It also has a
strong partnership dimension, and aims for the coordination and implementation of the relevant
goals and actions to generate outcomes which may not otherwise be achievable by bodies
working in isolation.
52 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 53
CHAPTER 5 – Goal 3: Address the harms
of drug markets and reduce access to
drugs for harmful use
Objective 3.1: Provide a comprehensive and responsive
misuse of drugs control framework which ensures the
proper control, management and regulation of the
supply of drugs
Protecting the public from dangerous or potentially dangerous and harmful substances,
while facilitating the safe use of certain controlled substances, which though harmful if misused,
have medical and therapeutic value, is a core objective of Ireland’s drug control framework.
In line with our obligations under the international UN conventions, Ireland adopts a balanced
approach to the drug problem, based on protecting public health, while engaging in national
and international cooperation aimed at combating transnational organised crime and drug
trafficking.
Ireland’s law enforcement agencies play a vital role in enforcing drug laws and in the national
effort to stem the flow of potentially harmful substances entering the illegal drug market.
An Garda Síochána, Revenue’s Customs Service, the Naval Service and the Health Products
Regulatory Authority work together to protect public health and safety from the harms of
the illegal drug market.
Ireland’s misuse of drugs legislation provides for different levels of control of substances based
on their health risk, potential for misuse and validity of legitimate use. Under Irish legislation,
unless expressly allowed to do so, it is illegal to possess, supply, manufacture, import or export
a controlled substance. Precursor chemicals which can be used in the illegal manufacture of
narcotic drugs and psychoactive substances are controlled through an EU legislative framework.
The Misuse of Drugs legislation provides for criminal offences and penalties for these offences,
including possession of drugs for personal use. There is a need to keep this legislation under
review to respond to the changing drugs situation.
2016 was a significant year in the evolution of global policy on the drug problem. The UN
General Assembly convened a special session on drugs in New York in April 2016 50. This
conference was an important milestone in achieving the goals set out in the 2009 Political
Declaration and Plan of Action on International Cooperation towards an integrated and
balanced strategy to counter the world drug problem.
Ireland participated at UNGASS as a member state of the EU and supported the key strategic
position of the EU on drugs policy, which welcomes a steady transition towards a more
balanced global approach that includes aspects of public health based policies, while continuing
to pursue efforts to counter transnational organised crime and drug trafficking.
54 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
In tandem with education and awareness measures, the Government initiated a multi-pronged
approach to targeting the activities of head shops and the sale of unregulated psychoactive
substances and there were related actions in the 2009-2016 strategy 2.
In May 2010, the Government made an order declaring approximately 200 psychoactive
substances to be controlled drugs for the purposes of the Misuse of Drugs Acts and the
Minister for Health introduced the necessary regulations to control these substances. These
instruments, which made the possession and supply of the substances concerned subject to
criminal sanctions under the Misuse of Drugs Acts, covered most substances then commonly
being sold in head shops. Since that time, more than 260 NPS have been controlled under
Misuse of Drugs regulation.
Experience has shown that new psychoactive substances can quickly emerge and there will
always be a time lag before such new substances can be made subject to control under the
Misuse of Drugs Acts. For that reason, the Government also decided in May 2010 to introduce
the Criminal Justice (Psychoactive Substances) Bill as a general criminal justice measure to deal
with new psychoactive substances as they emerge on the drug market. The Bill was drafted as
a matter of priority and was signed into law on 14 July 2010. The Act 5 came into operation on
23 August 2010.
The Criminal Justice (Psychoactive Substances) Act 2010 5 makes it a criminal offence to sell,
import or export, for human consumption, a psychoactive substance which is not regulated or
controlled under other legislation.
Drug Driving
Driving under the influence of drugs is a problem in Ireland, as it can impair ability to drive.
The Medical Bureau of Road Safety (MBRS) found that out of the 9,734 specimens of blood
and urine tested for the presence of a drug or drugs between the years 2009 and 2015, 6,232
or 64% tested positive 51. The Road Traffic Act 2016 64 gives An Garda Síochána new powers
to test drivers for drugs at the roadside and in Garda stations. Current provisions for Mandatory
Alcohol Testing (MAT) checkpoints will be extended to provide for Mandatory Intoxication
Testing (MIT) checkpoints testing drivers for both alcohol and drugs. The new measures
commenced on 13th April 2017. The Road Safety Authority has recently launched a campaign
to increase awareness of the new measures which will include an ad campaign, a social media
campaign and updated leaflets on drugs and driving and taking medicines while driving.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 55
Spent Convictions
The Criminal Justice (Spent Convictions and Certain Disclosures) Act 2016 65 provides for
certain convictions to become spent once 7 years has passed since the date of conviction.
The purpose of the legislation is to provide that persons who have made a mistake by
committing a minor offence in the past and paid the price, can move on with their lives after
the appropriate time and will not be held back. In accordance with the provisions of the Act
the following convictions will be spent:
l All convictions in the District Court for motoring offences which are more than 7 years
old will be spent, with the proviso that spent convictions for dangerous driving are limited
to a single conviction.
l All convictions in the District Court for minor public order offences which are more than
7 years old will be spent.
l In addition, where a person has one, and only one, conviction (other than a motoring
or public order offence) which resulted in a term of imprisonment of less than 12 months
(or a fine) that conviction will also be spent after 7 years. This provision will apply to
either a District Court or Circuit Court conviction.
It should be noted that serious offences, including most importantly criminal actions directed
against children and vulnerable persons, are not within the scope of the Act.
The Act was commenced in full on 29th April 2016. The Steering Committee is of the view that
the operation of the Act should be reviewed after a period in operation to ensure that pathways
to rehabilitation and a normal life for those who have committed offences during a period of
drug use are not unduly affected by the system of recording of convictions. It was noted by the
Steering Committee that the Act will be liable for post-enactment scrutiny at the discretion of
the Justice & Equality Committee under the new Dáil procedures.
Sanction Options
Within the Criminal Justice System there are a range of options available to the Court in
dealing with those who have committed a criminal offence. The legislature generally sets the
maximum sentence that can be imposed within the drugs legislation and it is then a matter for
the judiciary to decide what is the appropriate sentence in a particular case taking into account
all the circumstances surrounding the crime and the individual offender. The range of options
available to the Court in dealing with drug offences can include fines, custody, imposition of a
Peace Bond/Probation Order, suspended sentence etc.
The Minister for Justice and Equality is examining options as a way forward for the operation
of the Drug Treatment Court. The matter will be progressed alongside wider justice reforms
that are also under consideration, such as the proposal to establish a Community Court.
An independent review of the Drug Treatment Court could inform the Minister’s deliberations,
and the initiative should continue to be supported in the meantime.
56 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Community Justice Intervention
It should also be noted that a working group within the Justice Sector has been examining
proposals for the development of a ‘Community Justice Intervention’ initiative aimed at tackling
low level adult offenders (i.e. those committing relatively minor offences in specific offence
categories) and effectively addressing their offending behaviour. This would be a diversion
from the courts system and would have the potential to respond more effectively to one-off
and repeat, low level offending with the emphasis on speedy processing aimed at reducing the
risk of re-offending and also to provide quick referral to the necessary services for those that
need them. This work is at the very early stages and is on-going.
It is worth noting that “UNGASS 2016” encouraged the development of “alternative or additional
measures with regard to conviction or punishment in cases of an appropriate nature, in
accordance with the three international drug control conventions” 50.
In June 2015, a joint parliamentary committee on Justice, Defence and Equality visited Portugal
and discussed the approach to drug addiction adopted there since 2001. It was reported that
the approach in Portugal has had a very positive result for the communities concerned and is
therapy-based rather than punitive. Under this system, people found in possession of drugs are
brought in front of a commission made up of a social worker, a psychiatrist and a lawyer.
Following the visit and subsequent public hearings, the Committee concluded that a health-led
approach may be more effective and more appropriate for those found in possession of a small
amount of illegal drugs for personal use, rather than a criminal sanction.
The Committee’s report recommended that the possession of a small amount of illegal drugs
for personal use, could be dealt with by way of a civil or administrative response rather than via
the criminal justice route. It also highlighted the need for research to ensure that the adoption
of any alternative approach would be appropriate in the Irish context.
There is a need to explore the approaches taken in other jurisdictions to the possession of small
quantities of drugs for personal use in light of the recommendations in the report. This should
include a review of the current legislative regime in Ireland that applies to simple possession
offences and the rationale underpinning this approach.
3.1.31 Keep legislation Keep legislation under review, against DOH, AGS,
up-to-date to deal the background of national, EU and DJE Revenue’s
with emerging broader international experiences and Customs
trends in the drugs best practice, to deal with emerging Service,
situation. trends, including: HPRA
a) new synthetic substances;
b) new or changed uses of
psychoactive substances; and
c) the evolving situation with regard
to drug precursors and the surface
web and dark net drug markets.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 57
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
58 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Objective 3.2: Implement effective law enforcement
and supply reduction strategies and actions to prevent,
disrupt or otherwise reduce the availability of illicit drugs
Law enforcement is increasingly faced by a more joined up and globalised drug market.
Drug trafficking groups increasingly exploit the opportunities that this presents, which can
include the growth in container traffic and parcel delivery services. Organised crime groups
increasingly establish operational links between countries, or to operate on a transnational basis.
Demographic changes in Europe also mean that crime organisations can exploit the existence
of new migrant communities resulting in the need for law enforcement to identify and target
new organisations becoming active on their territories.
The increased prevalence of cannabis cultivation facilities has led to a shift in the market, with
domestically produced high potency herbal products becoming more available and displacing
imported resin. The growth of the cannabis market in Ireland is associated with increased levels
of criminality, including drug-related intimidation and violence.
The evolution and spread of NPS continues to be a persistent threat, with the injecting of
synthetic high potency opioids resulting in harmful consequences for vulnerable users, such
as the risk of contracting blood-borne viruses.
Significant law enforcement efforts have been invested in intercepting drugs destined for
the Irish market. International operations spearheaded by law enforcement agencies have
resulted in significant seizures and the disruption of organised crime networks involved in
the importation, distribution and sale of illegal drugs in this country.
Ireland participates in international drug fora at EU, Council of Europe and UN level, as
part of the international effort to counter the world drug problem. An Garda Síochána,
Revenue’s Customs Service and the Naval Service actively work with partners at EU and other
international levels to intercept drugs, and precursors for diversion to the manufacture of drugs,
being trafficked to Ireland. National and international cooperation between law enforcement
agencies and other bodies, including those involved in identifying and confisgating the
proceeds of crime, will continue to be strengthened through the international mechanisms
for cross border cooperation.
The expansion of online markets for drugs, mentioned above, represents a new and potentially
growing challenge, as do changes in synthetic drug and cannabis production. The internet
facilitates movement of products, money and information across global borders. Medicines
and other substances, including controlled drugs, can be sourced through the dark net and the
surface net. When a website selling psychoactive substances is taken down, it is replaced by
other websites, almost immediately. Capacity building measures will be necessary to provide
the technical support and know-how to enable law enforcement agencies to effectively monitor
online drug markets and prevent their use as a means of trafficking illegal drugs and other
substances into Ireland.
In line with the Garda Síochána Strategy Statement 2016-2018 54, and supported by the
Garda Síochána Modernisation and Renewal Programme for the period 2016-2021 55, An Garda
Síochána will continue to confront drug related crime utilising intelligence-led operations and
multi-disciplinary approaches to targeting organised crime groups and individuals involved in
crime.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 59
An Garda Síochána has recently strengthened its response to organised criminality including
drug crime through the establishment in 2016 of a consolidated Garda National Drugs and
Organised Crime Bureau (GNDOCB). The GNDOCB works closely with other specialist National
Garda Units including the newly established Special Crime Task Force and with local Garda
Divisions in targeting persons involved in drug related criminality.
Community Impact Statements (CIS) are used in the criminal justice system in the UK to
provide relevant and useful additional information about the impact crime or a particular
incident is having on a particular community. A CIS is a statement compiled with the authority
of a Police Force in active partnership with the community and other stakeholders, describing
the impact of anti-social-behaviour on a specific neighbourhood or identifiable group of people.
The intention is to enable better informed decisions that are made with the knowledge of the
local context and can be used throughout the justice system.
In order for CIS to be used in the Criminal Justice system in Ireland, legislation would be
required. The Group noted that the Garda Inspectorate Report on Crime Investigation
recommends that An Garda Síochána, in consultation with the Director of Public Prosecutions,
should consider the use of CIS in the Criminal Justice system in Ireland. In addition the Group
noted that the Garda Commissioner has set up a group to examine the recommendations of
the Garda Inspectorate Report 2014 56, which refer to the use of Community Impact Statements
in Ireland.
3.2.36 Support the role of law Investing in capacity building AGS, DOH,
enforcement authorities measures to support the role Revenue DJE,
in monitoring drug of law enforcement authorities Custom’s HPRA
markets, in particular in monitoring drug markets, in Service
new drug markets, particular new drug markets, surface
surface web and web and darknet drug markets.
darknet drug markets.
3.2.37 Consider the case for Subject to the completion of the AGS
the use of Community Garda examination of Community
Impact Statements Impact Statements, bringing
within the Criminal forward recommendations on their
Justice System in implementation.
Ireland.
60 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Objective 3.3: Develop effective monitoring and
responses to evolving trends, public health threats
and the emergence of new drug markets
Ireland’s Early Warning and Emerging Trends committee is chaired by the Department of Health.
This committee is currently the forum through which information from national and EU sources
on new psychoactive substances (NPS) of concern is received and shared, in the context of
Council Decision 2005/387/JHA on information exchange, risk assessment and control of new
psychoactive substances.
One of the major challenges facing Customs Administrations and Law Enforcement agencies
in general is the ability to rapidly and easily identify NPS when encountered. This task is made
more difficult by the wide range and complexity of products available on the market, together
with the tendency for manufacturing chemists to make frequent, and often minor, changes to
composition which takes them outside the analytical capability of available frontline technology.
A lack of international research on the composition and effects of NPS can hamper efforts to
place controls on such substances and provide expert testimony in court cases involving the
sale or supply of NPS.
Monitoring NPS presents challenges to laboratories and there is a need to develop analytical
capacity, data collection and public warning mechanisms. It is essential to avoid inaccurate
communication around high profile drug ingestions and laboratories need to develop the
analytical protocols for accurate identifications of substances and distinguish between
analogues with only tiny variations.
Government recognises the importance of developing the analytical capacity of the laboratories
involved in identifying substances, and has made a commitment to provide funding in the
capital expenditure programme for the construction of a purpose built new laboratory for
Forensic Science Ireland (FSI), with €6m prioritised to enable the commencement of building
work two years earlier than originally scheduled.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 61
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
3.3.38 Strengthen the a) Continuing to develop systems DOH HSE, HRB, FSI,
response to to monitor changing drug State Lab, MBRS
the illegal drug trends in line with the EU Early AGS
market, including Warning System;
the changing b) Completing the development HSE DOH, HSE, DJE
nature of new of the HSE public alert system
psychoactive for adverse events due to
substances. drugs and commencing
implementation;
c) Supporting government DPER,
funded laboratories, tasked DTTAS
with analysis of drugs of abuse,
to engage in novel analytical
development work, in relation
to psychoactive drugs but
especially new psychoactive
substances (licit or illicit), while
continuing to fulfil their core
functions;
d) Providing funding in the capital DJE
expenditure programme for the
construction of a purpose built
new laboratory for Forensic
Science Ireland with €6m
prioritised to commence the
project immediately; and
e) Strengthen the legal robustness
of Presumptive Drug Testing
(PDT) to contribute to the
timely prosecution of Section
(3) drug-related offences.
62 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
CHAPTER 6 – Goal 4: Support
participation of individuals, families
and communities
Objective 4.1: Strengthen the resilience of communities
and build their capacity to respond
Promoting community participation and involvement
Building the resilience of communities to respond to the drug problem is a key feature of
Ireland’s drugs policy. It recognises the importance of enabling communities to participate
in shaping the decisions that affect them, through providing opportunities for meaningful
participation and engagement in policy development and decision-making.
There are a great variety of community and voluntary organisations in Ireland whose knowledge
of local concerns and commitment to their own area helps to build a community’s capacity to
respond to these concerns with flexibility and sensitivity. Such organisations play a valuable
role in promoting positive social change, in partnership with the local communities and
communities of interest they serve.
Supporting social connectedness and involvement in community life are key to empowering
people at the individual level and building strong communities for health and wellbeing.
This approach is a core theme of the Healthy Ireland Framework, which states that building
awareness of and action on the social determinants of health will assist communities to
organise and mobilise their response to the challenges that affect health and wellbeing
within their own communities.
Community organisations working in disadvantaged areas give a voice to the most marginalised
and build the capacity of individuals, families and communities to organise and participate
in decision-making around the issues that affect them. Prevalence of poor health and social
problems is markedly higher in those communities with the greatest levels of deprivation.
These are the communities most susceptible to consequences of problem drug use.
Understanding the underlying socio-economic and cultural factors which contribute to the
drug problem has resulted in the development of an integrated whole-of-government response
based on a partnership approach between the statutory, community and voluntary sectors. As
key stakeholders in addressing the drug problem, it is crucial that communities are supported to
effectively participate in partnership structures at local, regional and national level. The need for
improved coordination in service provision and to utilise the knowledge and experience of local
communities in designing and delivering those services led to the establishment of Local Drugs
Task Forces (LDTFs) in areas with the highest prevalence of problem drug use. Regional Drugs
Task Forces (RDTFs) were later established to complement this effort in the parts of the country
not covered by the LDTFs. They have been key to the development of practical services such
as treatment and rehabilitation facilities through supporting and funding local initiatives. Task
Forces have also played a key role in harnessing the efforts of community groups, families and
local residents and have built partnerships with statutory services and local representatives.
Local Community Development Committees (LCDCs) are responsible for directing SICAP
funding to those areas that are most socially disadvantaged, in accordance with the needs
and priorities identified in the Local Economic and Community Plans and the County
Development Plans informed by the key demographics for each area. There is potential for
LCDCs to improve their links with Task Forces over time. SICAP’s vision is to improve the
life chances and opportunities of those who are marginalised in society, living in poverty
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 63
or in unemployment, through community development approaches, targeted supports and
interagency collaboration. SICAP Programme Implementers actively encourage the engagement
and participation of disadvantaged individuals and marginalised communities in local
development and supports them to enhance their participation in local, regional and national
decision-making structures.
Initially established in response to a largely heroin problem, Task Forces have had to adapt
to an evolving drug situation. During the period of the current strategy, cannabis has become
the main problem drug for young people presenting to treatment services for the first time.
Polydrug use, misuse of prescription medication and new psychoactive substances present
new challenges to the overall health and security of communities. Alcohol misuse, particularly
in combination with other forms of problem drug use, presents particular difficulties in
marginalised communities. In recognition of the scale of the difficulties associated with alcohol,
and of the potential of community mobilisation in responding to it, the task forces were
renamed Drug and Alcohol Task Forces (DATFs) in 2012.
There are a number of data sources available that can be used both to identify risk factors
in a particular area and assess the impact of efforts to strengthen protective factors. Using
information on the prevalence of opiate use and other high risk drug use we can identify the
areas most affected. Drug-related deaths information from communities most affected by the
fatal consequences of substance misuse help to establish the link between social and economic
determinants and drug-related mortality.
It can be difficult to assess the real impact of drug markets and other illegal activity on a
community, even when the consequences of these activities are very apparent to the people
living there. One approach might be to identify indicators, derived from health, law enforcement
and other monitoring systems, that can be used to measure the effects of high level problem
drug use, and the crime and antisocial behaviour associated with it, within a defined area.
Analysis using these indicators could provide valuable information to a community preparing
and evaluating a response to these problems.
Criminal activity and an active illicit drug market can create an intimidating and frightening
environment in an affected community. The concentration of illicit drug markets in particular
areas means that already marginalised communities must also deal with social and public
disorder and property crime associated with the sale and distribution of drugs. The use of
violence or the threat of violence to enforce debts further impacts on these communities by
creating an atmosphere of fear and undermining the health and wellbeing of families affected
and the wider community.
64 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
The National Drug-Related Intimidation Reporting programme, developed by the National
Family Support Network and An Garda Síochána, provides a framework to allow reporting of
an incident of intimidation to a nominated inspector. Further development of the community
approach to this problem will need to be informed by evaluations of these and other initiatives
being undertaken in a number of taskforce areas. A review by the HRB of the international
literature on gang prevention, desistence from gangs and criminal and legal interventions to
counter gang activity, will be useful in informing the development of a collaborative response
to intimidation involving law enforcement agencies, social services, schools and community
organisations 57.
The task of building safer, more resilient communities will be helped by the type of cooperation
and mutual support between An Garda Síochána and community representatives that has
been established during the period of the first two drug strategies. An Garda Síochána
representatives sit on task forces, and mechanisms such as Local Policing Fora help to build
important intra-sectoral relationships within communities.
Joint Policing Committees, facilitate the important work of consultation and cooperation
between An Garda Síochána, local authority officials and community representatives on which
effective community policing depends. In line with the Garda Síochána Strategy Statement
2016-2018 54 and the 2017 Crime Prevention and Reduction Strategy 58, and supported by the
Garda Síochána Modernisation and Renewal Programme 2016-2021 55, An Garda Síochána is
continuing to promote and embed a new community policing ethos across An Garda Síochána
to enhance trust and confidence and to ensure a visible, accessible and responsive service and
implement a suite of customised crime prevention approaches to protect communities from
crime.
Recognising the harm caused by drug-related debt intimidation, An Garda Síochána will
carry out an evaluation of the Drug-Related Intimidation Reporting Programme to strengthen
its effectiveness and to identify further opportunities to build on that work through Community
Safety Fora and the creation of linkages with community policing and the asset profiling
programme. The National Family Support Network, who have worked with An Garda Síochána
to build support for this programme, will also carry out their own evaluation from the
perspective of their network. These reviews will further inform development of the reporting
programme by An Garda Síochána and The National Family Support Network.
The depth of experience and knowledge built up by the community sector in responding
to this situation will be an immensely valuable resource to this strategy.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 65
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
The term ‘service user’ includes people who use health and social care services and their
families. It also includes people who are potential users of health services and social care
interventions, including people who use drugs, who may not yet have availed of treatment.
All HSE and HSE funded addiction services in primary care are expected to work within
the National Standards for Safer Better Health Care 59. These standards reflect many of the
elements that have been outlined within this Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery, such as
the importance of person-centred care and ensuring that service users’ needs and preferences
inform the planning, design and delivery of services.
66 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Service user involvement is about facilitating people to become meaningfully involved in
defining the issues of concern to them, in making decisions about factors that affect their lives,
in formulating policies and in planning, developing and delivering services, and in taking action
to achieve change.
Patient safety and quality is one of the four core elements of the recently adopted HSE
Accountability Framework. In addition, health professionals are guided by their codes of ethical
and professional conduct. Assurance of patient safety requires active leadership, governance
and clinical commitment to quality. Each substance misuse service should have a defined
patient safety and quality operating framework to address service user advocacy, complaints
and learning procedures, incident management and response, and substance misuse quality
elements such as standards, guidelines, audit and performance indicators in order to foster
a patient safety culture.
Peer-led services can support person-centred care, by providing social support to the individual
during and after treatment.
Support for independent representation for those who use drugs, as well as those who are
using services, is recognised good practice for enabling advocacy and improving outcomes.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 67
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
4.2.43 Build capacity within drug Requiring the delivery DOH HSE
and alcohol services to of services within a
develop a patient safety Quality Assurance
approach in line with the Framework, which will
HIQA National Standards a) standardise
for Safer Better Healthcare. services;
b) include basic
tools in relation to
safety, complaints,
competencies and
procedures around
prescribing; and
c) reflect a human
rights based and
person centred
approach.
68 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
CHAPTER 7 – Goal 5: Develop sound
and comprehensive evidence-informed
policies and actions
Objective 5.1. Support high quality monitoring, evaluation
and research to ensure evidence-informed policies and
practice
Monitoring
Ireland has good information on the substance misuse situation at a national level. Routine
monitoring provides the information on the nature, extent and consequences of substance
misuse needed to formulate evidence-informed policy, plan services and measure the
effectiveness of the responses to this problem. In fulfilment of both European and national
requirements Ireland’s monitoring system collects and analyses data on drug use in the
general and school-going population, treatment demand, high-risk drug use and on
consequences, such as infectious diseases, deaths and overdose.
It is important that monitoring systems are aware of and in a position to exploit new sources
of data. Longitudinal studies, such as TILDA – The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing or
Growing up in Ireland, present opportunities to complement information from routine
monitoring with insights into substance use behaviour of particular population cohorts. The
analysis of trends over the past 10 years carried out to inform this strategy points out that most
of the information on vulnerable groups was obtained from single studies 11. In order to observe
trends we will need to explore ways of monitoring drug use and treatment uptake among the
populations at particular risk.
Evaluation
The strategy will largely be implemented through interventions delivered by statutory,
community and voluntary services. As evidence is one of the values underpinning the strategy
it will be expected that these interventions will be based on findings from the most recent
scientific research and that their implementation will be carefully studied. The effectiveness
of interventions will be established by measuring outcomes through a system of evaluation
built into programme plans. This is particularly important when the available evidence does
not clearly point to a particular course of action and innovative approaches are being followed.
Evaluation also includes reporting on the extent to which the implementation of an intervention
adheres to protocols and guidelines associated with the intervention.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 69
Evidence-informed decision-making can be encouraged by working with services to improve
their evaluation processes and adopt an outcomes-focussed approach to implementing
interventions. DATFs, working with the HRB National Drugs Library, have identified a number of
outcomes that are relevant to the progress of service users in recovery 60. These outcomes are
organised by particular facets relevant to recovery such as personal circumstance and needs,
relationships and employment and skills. The framework also identifies validated instruments
that the taskforces can use to evaluate these outcomes. This project builds on the HRB’s
research dissemination activities that include specially commissioned reviews, a research
bulletin, an online library and web-based evidence resources.
Research
Research illuminates topics on which there is limited knowledge and tests the usefulness or
appropriateness of new approaches to delivering services and coordinating responses. This
work may involve primary research, secondary analysis of existing datasets, or synthesis
of existing research to ensure the highest quality evidence is available to practitioners and
policymakers. The HRB’s review of reviews 12 is an example of this synthesis and the strategy
will continue to build on this valuable resource. In order to derive maximum benefit careful
consideration should be given to implementing the findings of research and ensuring they
are central to the decision-making process in service delivery. All research projects, including
primary research and evidence syntheses should include a programme of dissemination and
knowledge-to-action activities that engage the stakeholders who will be implementing the
research findings.
While Ireland has good information at the national level, information on service needs and
on the implementation of interventions at the local level is less comprehensive. As the Rapid
Expert Review 10 noted, there are well managed and evaluated programmes throughout the
country. These could provide examples of good practice if there was a means of thoroughly
cataloguing them and making this knowledge available in a systematic way. This resource could
be very valuable in guiding decision-making and supporting innovative services who want to
use evidence in the selection, implementation and measurement of interventions. Findings
from individual programme evaluations can be aggregated and further analysed when there is
a shared approach to measuring interventions that have outcomes in common. In this way new
evidence can be created leading to refinement and further service improvement. So, monitoring,
evaluation, research and knowledge transfer are interdependent activities supporting good
practice, consistency and more effective services.
Adapting swiftly to rapidly changing conditions using reliable information will be an essential
attribute in the strategic response to substance misuse in the coming years. Developing this
capacity will require reliable, timely and comparable information. A robust, flexible and inclusive
system of monitoring, evaluation, knowledge transfer, and research can provide this resource.
70 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
5.1.47 Strengthen the Requiring all publicly funded drug and DOH, HSE,
National Drug alcohol services to complete the NDTRS DJE IPS, C&V
Treatment Reporting for all people who use services. sectors
System (NDTRS).
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 71
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
72 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
CHAPTER 8 – Strengthening the
performance of the strategy
Resources should be directed towards those interventions and strategies which are most likely
to lead to a reduction in problem substance use and a positive improvement in public health,
safety and wellbeing. The need for a way of measuring the overall effectiveness of the response
to the drug problem is therefore an important objective of public policy.
The level of progress achieved in delivering on the goals and related objectives and actions
of the strategy will be determined using performance indicators linked to each objective.
In addition, the key bodies responsible for delivering the strategic actions will be required
to report on progress on an annual basis to the Minister with responsibility for the National
Drugs Strategy. Monitoring of the progress in implementing the strategy will be supported
by a coordinated system of monitoring, evaluation and research as set out in in Goal 5.
The model which is at the core of the measurement framework makes predictions regarding
the level of problem drug use in a small area based on a number of social indicators describing
levels of deprivation, urbanity and social class. It then compares the predicted level of problem
substance use with the actual prevalence of problem substance use, on the basis of routine
monitoring systems, such as drug treatment data. If significant changes in problem drug or
alcohol use are found from one year to the next, or differences are observed between DATF
areas, there is an opportunity to analyse why such differences have emerged.
By identifying reasons for differences in outcomes, important and valuable information can
be obtained to support the successful implementation of the strategy. It will also facilitate
performance improvement in areas of the country where the strategy appears to be less
successful. This can also help DATFs improve their actions and interventions over time.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 73
The active participation and collective buy-in of all the key stakeholders will be extremely
important to the success of the system. Bringing forward measures to achieve positive change
and improve outcomes for individuals, families and communities affected by problem substance
use will require the commitment of all the key departments, agencies, DATFs and service
providers. It is therefore intended to develop an implementation plan to operationalise the
Performance Measurement Framework by 2020, in consultation with relevant stakeholders
and sectors. The implementation plan will aim to ensure that Task Forces have appropriate
arrangements in place for the selection and renewal of the Chair and members of the Task
Force and have proper procedures in place for addressing conflict of interest. It is envisaged
that these arrangements will be in line with the principles outlined in the Review of Drug Task
Forces (2011/12) 62.
74 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
The coordination of the implementation of the 2009-2016 National Drugs Strategy was initially
led by a Minister/Office of the Minister for Drugs at the Department of Community, Rural and
Gaeltacht Affairs. The organisational structure of the current strategy is set out in the figure
below.
Government
The main role of the Office of the Minister for Drugs was to ensure national coordination of
the Strategy, support policy development, support the work of the Task Forces, support the
National Advisory Committee on Drugs (NACD), and support the community and voluntary
sector. Following a change of Government in 2011, the national drugs strategy function
was transferred to the Department of Health and the functions of the Office of the Minister
for Drugs, including the Drugs Advisory Group, were taken over by the Drugs Policy and
Programmes Unit within that Department.
A review of Drug Task Forces was undertaken in 2011/12 to assess the impact of Drug Task
Forces in order to ensure that they would continue to remain relevant, effective and fit for
purpose. The review also led to the commissioning of research into the development of a
Performance Measurement Framework for DATFs, which has been outlined above.
The Rapid Expert Review of the Strategy 10 noted that the current structures and
communication flows have evolved over time and appear rather complex and disjointed.
Their recommendations focused on the different functions needed to support the strategy
rather than on the specific bodies that are currently, or might in the future, be tasked with
these roles, emphasising:
l Leadership to provide drive, direction/prioritisation;
l Coordination at national and local level;
l Mobilisation of resources in terms of finances and personnel, including those
for whom drugs is not the primary focus of their work;
l Quality assurance and clinical governance involving national bodies working with
local areas to identify and evaluate innovative approaches and ensure standards are
maintained;
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 75
l Monitoring and evaluation of progress including appropriate performance indicators
linked to the specific objectives of the strategy;
l A structure to ensure that research is integrated within the strategy;
l Analysis and advice drawing out the implications of research findings for policy and
practice to be fed into discussions around direction and prioritisation at national level;
and
l Needs assessment, coordination and support for local implementation and a review
of Task Force boundaries in light of current needs.
A more streamlined structure is required to deliver on the key functions identified as important
by the Rapid Expert Review 10 and to optimise participation in the strategy, in a way which
avoids duplication and overlap.
Membership
The Committee will have a cross-sector membership from the statutory, community and
voluntary sector, as well as clinical and academic expertise. Representation from the statutory
sector will be at the level of Assistant Secretary. It will be a matter for the Minister of State to
determine the final membership of the Committee, however, the suggested membership is set
out in the Table below.
Sector Body
Statutory TUSLA
76 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Sector Body
Task Force Local Drug and Alcohol Task Force Chairs Network
Task Force Local Drug and Alcohol Task Force Coordinators Network
Task Force Regional Drug and Alcohol Task Force Chairs Network
Task Force Regional Drug and Alcohol Task Force Coordinators Network
Terms of reference
The National Oversight Committee will have the following terms of reference:
(a) To give leadership, direction, prioritisation and mobilisation of resources to support
the implementation of the strategy;
(b) To measure performance in order to strengthen the delivery of drugs initiatives and
to improve the impact on the drug problem;
(c) To monitor the drugs situation and oversee the implementation of a prioritised
programme of research to address gaps in knowledge;
(d) To ensure that the lessons drawn from evidence and good practice inform the
development policy and initiatives to address the drug problem; and
(e) To convene Sub-Committees, as required, to support implementation of the strategy.
Operational Procedures
The National Oversight Committee will develop a prioritised work programme to support
the implementation of the strategy. The Committee will establish Sub-Committees, as it
sees fit, to address specific issues and to harness relevant expertise to enable it to deliver
on its key functions. Such committees will be required to report to the National Committee.
The number of Sub-Committees and their modus operandi will be a matter for the Chair
of the National Committee.
Standing Sub-Committee
A Standing Sub-Committee of the National Oversight Committee will be established to drive
the implementation of Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery and promote coordination
between national, local and regional levels. The Sub-Committee will be chaired by a Senior
Official in the Department of Health. It will play a key role in ensuring that the statutory,
community and voluntary sectors, Drug and Alcohol Task Forces and other key stakeholders
are engaged in supporting the implementation of the strategy.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 77
Membership
There will be a balance of representatives drawn from the statutory, community and voluntary
sectors. Membership will include, but not be limited to, representation from the networks of the
Chair and coordinators of the Local and Regional Drug and Alcohol Task Forces, the National
Family Support Network and UISCE. Statutory membership of the Standing Sub-Committee
will be at Principal Officer level or equivalent. Representation from the Department of Health
will include senior officials that are responsible for drug policy and alcohol policy.
Terms of Reference
The Standing Sub-Committee will have the following terms of reference:
(a) To drive implementation of Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery at national, local
and regional level;
(b) To develop, implement and monitor responses to drug-related intimidation as
a matter of priority;
(c) To support and monitor the role of Drug and Alcohol Task Forces in coordinating
local and regional implementation of the National Drugs Strategy with a view to
strengthening the Task Force interagency model;
(d) To improve performance, promote good practice and build capacity to respond
to the drug problem in line with the evidence-base;
(e) To ensure good governance and accountability by all partners involved in the delivery
of the Strategy; and
(f) To report to the National Oversight Committee on progress in the implementation
of its work programme.
Operational Procedures
The Standing Sub-Committee will meet on a monthly basis, and agree an annual programme
of work to support implementation of the strategy. Drug-related intimidation will form part
of the early work programme agreed by the Standing Sub-Committee, in view of the need to
commence work on the issue.
Members of the Standing Sub-Committee will develop a liaison relationship with Task Forces
to support multi-directional coordination and communication between delivery bodies and
stakeholders at local, regional and national levels.
The Standing Sub-Committee will provide progress reports on the delivery of its work
programme for the quarterly meetings of the National Committee.
78 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Figure 11: Structures supporting implementation of Reducing Harm,
Supporting Recovery
Minister of State for Health Promotion and the National Drugs Strategy
As stated above, the National Oversight Committee will prioritise the research to be
undertaken to address gaps in knowledge. The HRB will manage the commissioning of
the research.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 79
The Early Warning and Emerging Trends Sub-Committee plays a role in the Early Warning
System. Its original Terms of Reference were:
l To receive, share and monitor on behalf of the Department of Health, information from
National and EU sources on New Psychoactive Substances of concern in the context of
the Council Decision of 2005/387/JHA on information exchange, risk assessment and
control of new psychoactive substances;
l To receive, share and monitor on behalf of the Department of Health, information on
emerging trends and patterns in drug use particularly poly drug use and associated risks;
l To monitor the work on emerging trends being developed at EU level (EMCDDA
responsibility), to consider its implementation in Ireland;
l To monitor the reports to the Early Warning System on a quarterly basis about
emerging trends and New Psychoactive Substances, but more frequently if
circumstances warrant it;
l To examine new ways of getting sensitive information on changing patterns of drug use
and trends;
l To consider the implications of changing drug markets and distribution networks which
can impact on the popularity of certain psychoactive substances; and
l To review the risk assessment reports provided by the EMCDDA and determine their
relevance to the Irish situation and advise Government accordingly.
The role and terms of reference of the Early Warning and Emerging Trends Sub-Committee,
within the Early Warning System, will be reviewed under the strategy.
The Task Forces are the key bodies to provide needs assessment, local coordination and
implementation and the performance measurement framework will provide Task Forces with
the information required to more effectively fulfil these functions. The Minister for Health
Promotion and the National Drugs Strategy will convene meetings with the DATFs as required.
Boundary issues
Local and Regional DATFs have been effective in promoting cooperation between the statutory,
community and voluntary sectors. They have also provided a targeted response to drugs
issues as they affect people on the ground. It has been suggested, in the past, that the large
number of Local DATFs creates administrative difficulties and unnecessary complications in
the relationship with other service providers. These agencies are often required to interact
with multiple Local DATFs within a given catchment area. The RAM within the Performance
Measurement Framework provides a rational basis for addressing the boundary issues that
arose for historical reasons following the establishment of Regional DATFs, in and around the
Dublin areas.
80 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
CHAPTER 9 – Conclusion
This strategy was drawn up by a Steering Committee, established in December 2015, by the
Minister with special responsibility for the National Drugs Strategy.
The process of developing the strategy involved an intensive process of public consultation, a
rapid expert review, a review of reviews of interventions to tackle the drug problem, an analysis
of drug trends in the past decade and a series of engagements with key stakeholders to identify
gaps in the current response to the drug problem. The independence of the process was
assured by an independent chair, who guided the Steering Committee in its work.
The core objective of the new strategy is to provide an integrated public health response to
substance misuse, which recognises that substance misuse includes the harmful or hazardous
use of psychoactive substances, including illegal drugs, alcohol and prescription medicines. It
underlines the importance of a health-led person-centred approach to tackling the problem of
substance misuse. It contains a series of actions which are to be delivered over the next four
years (2017-2020). These are set out in Chapter 10 of this document. Key partners are identified
to drive implementation of the actions, while recognising there will be many actions of a cross-
sectoral nature requiring input from a range of stakeholders.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 81
CHAPTER 10 – Strategic action plan for
the period 2017-2020
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
1.1.2 Improve the delivery a) Organising a yearly national HRB HSE, DOH,
of substance use forum on evidence-based and DES, DCYA
education across all effective practice on drug and
sectors, including alcohol education; and
youth services, b) Developing a guidance
services for people document to ensure substance
using substances use education is delivered
and other relevant in accordance with quality
sectors. standards.
1.2.4 Promote a health In line with the Action Plan for DES DOH/HSE
promotion Education
approach to a) Commencing and rolling out
addressing a national programme to
substance misuse. support the implementation
of the Wellbeing Guidelines to
all primary and post-primary
schools; and
b) Developing Wellbeing
Guidelines for Centres of
Education and Training.
82 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 83
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
84 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
2.1.13 Expand the a) Identifying and addressing gaps HSE C&V sectors,
availability and in provision within Tier 1, 2, 3 DATFs
geographical and 4 services;
spread of relevant b) Increasing the number of
quality drug and treatment episodes provided
alcohol services and across the range of services
improve the range available, including:
of services available,
l Low Threshold;
based on identified
need. l Stabilisation;
l Detoxification;
l Rehabilitation;
l Step-down;
l After-Care;
c) Strengthening the capacity of
services to address complex
needs.
2.1.15 Enhance the quality Implementing the HSE National HSE DOH
and safety of care Clinical Guidelines on OST and
in the delivery of reviewing in line with National
Opioid Substitution Clinical Effectiveness Committee
Treatment (OST). processes.
2.1.16 Improve relapse Developing and broadening the HSE C&V sectors,
prevention and range of peer-led, mutual aid and UISCE, NFSN
aftercare services. family support programmes in
accordance with best practice.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 85
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
2.1.19 Increase the range Establishing a Working Group to: DOH HSE, DSP,
of progression a) Examine the range of IPS, Other
options for progression options for relevant
recovering drug those exiting treatment, prison, Departments
users and develop a Community Employment & Agencies
new programme of schemes including key skills
supported care and training and community
employment. participation with a view to
developing a new programme
of supported care and
employment; and
b) Identify and remedy the
barriers to accessing the
range of educational, personal
development, training and
employment opportunities
and supports, including gender
specific barriers and the lack
of childcare provision, for
those in recovery.
86 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
2.1.21 Respond to the a) Increasing the range of wrap- HSE DOH, DATFs
needs of women around community and
who are using drugs residential services equipped to
and/or alcohol in a meet the needs of women who
harmful manner. are using drugs and/or alcohol
in a harmful manner, including
those with children and those
who are pregnant; and
b) Developing interventions to
address gender and cultural
specific risk factors for not
taking up treatment.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 87
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
2.1.22 Expand the range, a) Identifying and addressing gaps HSE, C&V sectors,
availability and in child and adolescent service TUSLA DATFs
geographical provision;
spread of problem b) Developing multi-disciplinary
drug and alcohol child and adolescent teams; and
services for those
c) Developing better interagency
under the age of 18.
cooperation between problem
substance use and child and
family services.
2.1.23 Improve the Examining the need for the HSE C&V sectors,
response to the development of specialist services DATFs
needs of older to meet the needs of older people
people with long with long term substance use issues.
term substance use
issues.
2.1.24 Improve outcomes a) Supporting the new Mental HSE DOH, IPS,
for people with Health Clinical Programme to C&V sectors
co-morbid severe address dual diagnosis; and
mental illness and b) Developing joint protocols
substance misuse between mental health
problems. services and drug and alcohol
services with the objective of
undertaking an assessment
with integrated care planning
in line with the National Drug
Rehabilitation Framework.
88 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 89
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
90 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
3.1.31 Keep legislation up- Keep legislation under review, DOH, DJE AGS,
to-date to deal with against the background of national, Revenue’s
emerging trends in EU and broader international Customs
the drugs situation. experiences and best practice, Service,
to deal with emerging trends, HPRA
including:
a) new synthetic substances;
b) new or changed uses of
psychoactive substances; and
c) the evolving situation with
regard to drug precursors and
the surface web and dark net
drug markets.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 91
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
3.1.35 Consider the Establishing a Working Group to DOH, DJE AGS, Relevant
approaches taken in consider the approaches taken in (Joint) Departments
other jurisdictions other jurisdictions to the possession and agencies
to the possession of small quantities of drugs for
of small quantities personal use in light of the Report
of drugs for of the Joint Committee on Justice,
personal use with Defence and Equality on a Harm
a view to making Reducing and Rehabilitative
recommendations approach to possession of small
on policy options to amounts of illegal drugs to examine:
the relevant Minister a) the current legislative
within 12 months. regime that applies to simple
possession offences in this
jurisdiction and the rationale
underpinning this approach,
and any evidence of its
effectiveness;
b) the approaches and experiences
in other jurisdictions to dealing
with simple possession offences;
c) the advantages and
disadvantages, as well as the
potential impact and outcomes
of any alternative approaches
to the current system for the
individual, the family and
society, as well as for the
criminal justice system and the
health system;
d) the identification of the scope
of any legislative changes
necessary to introduce
alternative options to criminal
sanctions for those offences;
e) a cost benefit analysis of
alternative approaches to
criminal sanctions for simple
possession offences; and
f) make recommendations to the
relevant Minister within twelve
months.
3.2.36 Support the role of Investing in capacity building AGS, DOH, DJE,
law enforcement measures to support the role Revenue HPRA
authorities in of law enforcement authorities Custom’s
monitoring in monitoring drug markets, in Service
drug markets, in particular new drug markets, surface
particular new drug web and darknet drug markets.
markets, surface
web and darknet
drug markets.
92 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 93
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
94 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
5.1.46 Support evidence- a) Ensuring that public funding is DOH DES, DSP,
informed practice targeted at underlying need and DCYA, HSE,
and service supports the use of evidence- IPS, PS, HRB
provision. informed interventions and the
evaluation of pilot initiatives;
b) Designating the Health Research
Board as a central information
hub on evidence on the drugs
situation and responses to it;
c) Ensuring that mechanisms are
in place to communicate this
evidence in a timely manner
to those working in relevant
healthcare settings, including in
acute and emergency care; and
d) Developing collaborative
relationships with third level
institutions in the area of drugs
and alcohol so as to further
government funded research
priorities.
5.1.47 Strengthen Requiring all publicly funded drug DOH, DJE HSE, IPS, C&V
the National and alcohol services to complete sectors
Drug Treatment the NDTRS for all people who use
Reporting System services.
(NDTRS).
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 95
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
96 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
No. Strategic Action Delivered by: Lead Partners
Agency
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 97
APPENDIX 1 – Membership of the Steering
Committee on the National Drugs Strategy
Sector Body Number of
Representatives
Cross-sector Task Force Local Drug and Alcohol Task Force Chairs 1
network Network
Cross-sector Task Force Regional Drug and Alcohol Task Force Chairs 1
network Network
98 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
APPENDIX 2 – List of relevant inter-
connected strategies and policies
l National Substance Misuse Strategy, 2012
l “Creating a better future together”: National Maternity Strategy 2016-2026
l Healthy Ireland – a framework for improved Health and Wellbeing, 2013-2025
l Better Outcomes, Brighter Futures, 2014-2020
l Updated National Action Plan for Social Inclusion, 2015-2017
l National Sexual Health Strategy 2015-2020
l Connecting for Life: Ireland’s National Strategy to Reduce Suicide 2015-2020
l National Traveller and Roma Inclusion Strategy (2016-2020)
l National Women’s Strategy 2017-2020
l Rebuilding Ireland – action plan for housing and homelessness
l Homeless Strategy National Implementation Plan
l Mental Health Strategy A Vision for Change
l The Joint Irish Prison Service and Probation Service Strategic Plan 2015-2017
l Irish Prison Service 2011, Health Care Standards
l An Garda Síochána’s 2016 National, Regional and Divisional Policing Plans
l Garda Síochána 2017 Crime Prevention and Reduction Strategy
l Garda Síochána Strategy Statement 2016-2018
l An Garda Síochána’s Modernisation and Renewal Programme 2016-2021
l Tobacco Free Ireland, 2013 and Tobacco Free Ireland Action Plan, 2014-2025
l Irish Sports Council’s National Anti-Doping Programme
l EU Drugs Strategy and action plans, 2013-2020
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 99
Glossary of Terms
AA Alcoholics Anonymous
EU European Union
GP General Practitioner
100 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
MAT Mandatory Alcohol Testing
NCC National Coordinating Committee for Drugs and Alcohol Task Forces
UN United Nations
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 101
References
1. Department of Tourism, Sport and Recreation. Building on experience: National
Drugs Strategy 2001–2008. Dublin: Stationery Office, 2001. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/5187/
8. Health Research Board. National Drug-Related Deaths Index 2004 to 2014 data. Dublin:
Health Research Board, 2016. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/26299/
10. Griffiths P, Strang J, Singleton N. Rapid expert review of the National Drugs
Strategy 2009-2016 Dublin: Department of Health, 2016. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27289/
11. John Moores University. The drugs situation in Ireland: an overview of trends from
2005 to 2015. Liverpool: Centre for Public Health Liverpool John Moores University,
2017. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27254/
12. Bates G, Public Health Institute Liverpool John Moores University. The drugs
situation in Ireland: an overview of trends from 2005 to 2015, 2017. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27254/
13. European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction. European drug report 2017
trends and developments. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union,
2017. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27401/
14. Long J, Mongan D. Alcohol consumption in Ireland 2013: analysis of a national
alcohol diary survey. Dublin: Health Research Board, 2014. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/22138/
102 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
15. Department of Health. General Scheme of the Public Health Alcohol Bill 2015. Dublin:
Department of Health, 2015. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/23383/
16. Department of Children and Youth Affairs. Better outcomes brighter futures.
The national policy framework for children & young people 2014–2020. Dublin:
Stationery Office, 2014. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/21773/
17. Department of Education and Skills. Action plan for education
2017. Dublin: Department of Education and Skills, 2017. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27255/
18. Department of Children and Youth Affairs. Value for money and policy review of
the youth programmes that target disadvantaged young people. Dublin: Government
Publications, 2014. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/23242/
19. Tickner N. Early leavers – What next? Dublin: Department of Education, 2013.
Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/20767/
20. Haase T, Pratschke J. Risk and protection factors for substance use among
young people: a comparative study of early school leavers and school attending
students. Dublin: National Advisory Committee on Drugs, 2010. Available
at www.drugsandalcohol.ie/14100/
21. Smyth E. Educational research and policy reform: unpacking the relationship.
European Conference on Educational Research 2016, Leading education: the
distinct contributions of educational research and researchers. Dublin, 2016. Available
at http://www.eera-ecer.de/ecer-programmes/conference/21/contribution/39139/
22. Horgan J. Parental substance misuse: addressing its impact on children: a review
of the literature. Dublin: National Advisory Committee on Drugs, 2011. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/16114/
23. Horgan J. Parental substance misuse: addressing its impact on children: Key messages
and recommendations from a review of the literature. Dublin: National Advisory
Committee on Drugs, 2011. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/16115/
24. Ryan S, Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse. Report of the Commission to inquire
into child abuse (The Ryan Report). Dublin: Stationery Office, 2009. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27364/
25. Bingham T, O’Driscoll C, De Barra G. National student drug survey 2015. Dublin:
National Student Drug survey, 2015. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/24807/
26. O’Donnell Kate, Fitzgerald Margaret, Barrett Peter et al MISI 2015 – Findings from the
men who have sex with men internet survey. Dublin: Health Protection Surveillance
Centre, 2016. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/25656/
27. Jennings Ciaran J, Patten Emer, Kennedy Mark, et al. Examining the profile and
perspectives of individuals attending harm reduction services who are users of
performance and image enhancing drugs. Dublin: Merchants Quay Ireland, 2014.
Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/23024/
28. Bryant-Jefferies R. Models of care for drug service provision. Oxford: Radcliffe
Publishing Ltd 2004.
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 103
31. Health Service Executive. Health service performance report October-
December 2016. Dublin: Health Service Executive, 2017. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/26957/
32. Cox G, Whitaker T. Drug use, sex work and the risk environment in Dublin. Dublin:
National Advisory Committee on Drugs, Stationery Officer 2009. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/11907/
33. Munton T, Wedlock E, Gomersall A. The role of social and human capital in recovery
from drug and alcohol addiction. Dublin: Health Research Board, 2014. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/23078/
34. Sumnall H, Brotherhood A. Social reintegration and employment: evidence and
interventions for drug users in treatment. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the
European Union, 2012. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/18596
35. Barry S, Kearney A, Daly S, et al. The Coombe Women’s Hospital: study of alcohol,
smoking & illicit drug use 1987–2005. Dublin: Coombe Women’s Hospital, 2007.
Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/6131/
36. Popova S, Lange S, Probst C, et al. Estimation of national, regional, and global
prevalence of alcohol use during pregnancy and fetal alcohol syndrome: a systematic
review and meta-analysis. The Lancet Global Health 2017;5(3):e290-e99. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/26659/
37. Department of Health. Creating a better future together. National Maternity
Strategy 2016-2026. Dublin: Department of Health, 2016. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/25218/
38. James P, Smyth BP, Apantaku-Olajide T. Substance use and psychiatric disorders
in Irish adolescents: a cross-sectional study of patients attending substance abuse
treatment service. Mental Health and Substance Use 2013;6(2):124-32.Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/18305/
39. Health Service Executive. Clinical guidelines for opioid substitution treatment. Dublin:
Health Service Executive, 2016. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/26573/
40. O’Reilly F, Barror S, Hannigan A, et al. Homelessness: an unhealthy state.
Health status, risk behaviours and service utilisation among homeless
people in two Irish cities Dublin: The Partnership for Health Equality, 2015.
Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/24541/
41. Department of the Taoiseach. Rebuilding Ireland: action plan for housing
and homelessness. Dublin: Department of the Taoiseach, 2016. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27268/
42. Health Research Board. Irish National Focal Point to the European Monitoring Centre
for Drugs and Drug Addiction. Ireland: national report for 2016 – prison. Dublin: Health
Research Board, 2017. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/25265/
43. Clarke A, Eustace A. Review of drug and alcohol treatment services for adult offenders
in prison and in the community. Dublin: Probation Service and Irish Prison Service,
2016. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/26569/
44. Higgins A, Doyle L, Downes C, et al. The LGBTI Ireland report: national study
of the mental health and wellbeing of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender
and intersex people in Ireland Dublin: GLEN and BelongTo, 2016. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/25323/
104 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
45. Health Research Board. Irish National Focal Point to the European Monitoring
Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction. Ireland: national report for 2016 –
harms and harm reduction. Dublin: Health Research Board, 2017. Available
at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/25259/
46. Department of Health. Misuse of Drugs (Supervised Injecting Facilities) Act 2017. 2017,
Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27445/
47. European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction. European drug report
2016: trends and developments. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European
Union, 2016. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/25579/
48. Health Service Executive. National service plan 2017 Dublin: Health Service Executive,
2016. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/26523/
49. Department of Health, Health Service Executive, National Office for Suicide Prevention.
Connecting for life. Ireland’s National Strategy to reduce suicide 2015-2020 Dublin:
Department of Health, 2015. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/24167/
50. United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. Outcomes document of the 2016 United
Nations General Assembly Special Session on the World Drug Problem New York,
19-21 April 2016. Our joint commitment to effectively addressing and countering
the world drug problem. Vienna: United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, 2016.
Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27442
51. Road Safety Authority. Anti drug driving. Campaign tackles drug driving and promotes
awareness of new Preliminary Drug Testing. Available from: http://www.rsa.ie/en/RSA/
Road-Safety/Campaigns/Current-road-safety-campaigns/Anti-Drug-Driving/ accessed
June, 13 2017.
52. Strategic Review Group on Penal Policy. Strategic review of penal policy. Dublin:
Department of Justice and Equality, 2014. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.
ie/22657/
53. Department of Justice and Equality. Report of the review of the operation of the drug
treatment court. Unpublished. Dublin: Department of Justice and Equality, 2013.
54. An Garda Síochána. An Garda Síochána statement strategy July 2016-2018 Dublin:
An Garda Síochána, 2016. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27305/
57. Murphy L, Farragher L, Keane M, et al. Drug-related intimidation. The Irish situation
and international responses: an evidence review. Dublin: Health Research Board, 2017.
Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27333/
58. An Garda Síochána. Crime prevention & reduction strategy. Putting prevention first.
Dublin: An Garda Síochána, 2017. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27147/
59. Health Information and Quality Authority. National standards for safer better
healthcare. Dublin: Health Information and Quality Authority, 2012. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/24404/
Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025 105
60. Ni Ogain E, Hodgson L. Drug and alcohol recovery outcomes framework. London:
Catch Impact, 2017. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27096/
61. Haase T, Pratschke J. A performance measurement framework for drug and alcohol
task forces. Dublin: Trutz Haase – Social & Economic Consultants, 2017. Available at
www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27488
62. Department of Health. Report on the review of drugs task forces and the national
structures under which they operate. Dublin: Department of Health, 2012. Available
at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/19054/
63. RPS Group Limited. Public consultation to inform the new national drugs
strategy – public consultation report: RPS Group Limited, 2017. Available at
http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27489/
64. Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport. Road Traffic Act 2010, 2010.
Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27504/
65. Department of Justice and Equality. Criminal Justice (Spent Convictions and Certain
Disclosures) Act 2016, 2016. Available at http://www.drugsandalcohol.ie/27503/
106 Reducing Harm, Supporting Recovery A health-led response to drug and alcohol use in Ireland 2017-2025
Department of Health
T: +353 (0) 1 6354000
health.gov.ie