Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Can One Accurately Date A Bruise State of The Science
Can One Accurately Date A Bruise State of The Science
Keywords Abstract
Age of bruises; color of bruises; dating bruises;
forensic nursing; injury. Forensic nursing experts and other health professionals often testify regarding
the injuries women and men receive from violence. Bruise discoloration can
Correspondence provide an opportunity for health professionals to grossly estimate the age of
Katherine R. Nash, MSN, RN, FNE-A, SANE-A,
impact and determine if it is consistent with a given reported history. How-
D-ABMDI, 525 N. Wolfe Street, Baltimore, MD
ever, there is much confusion in the literature and clinical practice as to the
21205. Tel: 240-418-1656; E-mail:
knash3@son.jhmi.edu accuracy of dating bruises. This article will demonstrate that using the color of
the bruise as the primary criteria to determine its age is not the best practice.
Received: April 27, 2007; accepted: May 28, The limited available research and related literature on the topic are flawed
2007 and inconsistent. Finally, recommendations will be made for future research
and clinical practice.
doi: 10.1111/j.1939-3938.2009.01028.x
compassionate care of the patient and appropriate out- Factors affecting bruise appearance
comes in criminal or civil proceedings.
Numerous factors have been thought to affect bruise dis-
coloration and its change over time but few have been
actually studied. Low levels of connective tissue support
Bruise defined and high levels of vascularity and adipose tissue can con-
In general, a bruise is discoloration resulting from in- tribute to larger quantities of extravasated hemoglobin,
jury transmitted through the skin to its underlying struc- such as in the periorbital and genital regions (Johnson,
tures and occasionally to other organs, causing bleed- 1990; Langlois & Gresham, 1991; Vanezis, 2001b). In
ing from ruptured blood vessels. It is accompanied by other words, more adipose tissue (fat), as compared with
pain, swelling, and inflammation (Stedman, 2005; Venes muscle, can contribute to an increase in bleeding. Skin
& Thomas, 2001). Bruising of the dermis is often specified color can affect how bruise discoloration is perceived
as being caused by blunt and/or squeezing force trauma by the naked eye (Schwartz & Ricci, 1996; Stephenson,
(Venes & Thomas, 2001). A bruise is synonymous with 1997; Vanezis, 2001a, b).
the word contusion. However, a bruise is different from The depth of the injury can affect how soon bruise
ecchymosis, petechiae, and purpura, because these cuta- discoloration appears. Although superficial bruises may
neous hemorrhages are best categorized as rashes or leak- present immediately, deep bruises may take hours or
ages of blood under the skin not directly caused by blunt even several days to appear, if at all (Langlois & Gresham,
force trauma (Sheridan, 2003). In fact, Stedman’s Medical 1991; Randeberg et al., 2007; Schwartz & Ricci, 1996).
Dictionary (2005) actually cautions the reader to not use The characteristics of the inflicting object, including its
the term bruise to describe hemorrhagic lesions unrelated surface and force of impact against the body, can also
to blunt force injuries. Bruises to skin can vary in pain, affect a bruise’s size, shape, and pattern of appearance
tenderness, color, distinction of margins, and induration (Randeberg et al., 2007; Vanezis, 2001a). Bleeding from
(Sheridan, 2003). Color is the only constant that should some deep bruises or muscle tears can be totally or par-
be present for a dermal bruise to be externally identified tially reabsorbed by the body prior to reaching the outer
without dissection or histological analysis. layers of the skin. Therefore, it is possible that when the
bruise is first visible, it has the appearance of being older.
Age can also impact bruising due to characteristic
changes typical of different age groups. The elderly (es-
Pathophysiology of bruise discoloration pecially frail elderly) tend to bruise easily due to: (a)
The red discoloration in a bruise/contusion following thinning skin, (b) weakening of the tissue surround-
blunt or squeezing force trauma is caused by the release ing and supporting blood vessels, and (c) side effects of
of hemoglobin and/or red blood cells from damaged ves- medications (Vanezis, 2001a). Children are also more
sels into the subcutaneous tissue. The extravasation of easily bruised than adults because of their delicate skin
blood is followed by an inflammatory reaction that causes and increased adipose tissue (Langlois & Gresham, 1991;
vasodilation and attracts macrophages to the site of in- Vanezis, 2001a, b).
jury. The erythema, secondary to vasodilation and fresh Gender also affects bruising, as women tend to bruise
escape of blood, is quickly replaced by a blue or purple more easily due to increased adipose tissue distribution
appearance due to the further extravasation of deoxy- (Vanezis, 2001a). Specifically, women with red hair have
genated venous blood into the interstitial tissue. been found to report higher levels of bruising as com-
Over time, these macrophages ingest the escaped pared with women with brown or black hair; how-
erythrocytes and degrade the attached hemoglobin. ever, coagulation tests have not been found to differ
Hemoglobin is first broken down into biliverdin, which (Liem et al., 2006). Numerous diseases and medica-
accounts for the green color often seen in a healing bruise tions can affect coagulation, macrophage production, and
(Hughes et al., 2004). Biliverdin is then quickly broken hemoglobin degradation, ultimately changing the bruise
down into bilirubin, which accounts for the yellow color discoloration process (Langlois & Gresham, 1991; Valente
of a healing bruise (Vanezis, 2001b). As hemoglobin is & Abramson, 2006; Vanezis, 2001a, b). Medications af-
broken down, some of its contained iron is released and fecting bruising include prescription drugs, over-the-
it combines with ferritin. This gives rise to hemosiderin, counter drugs, and certain herbs (Valente & Abramson,
which appears brown in the tissue (Hughes et al., 2004). 2006).
This may explain why many bruises take on a yellow- In the 1950s and 1960s, several studies by researchers
brown to purely brown appearance late in the healing explored bruising of animals from inflicted trauma.
process. This research cannot be ethically replicated by current
32
K. R. Nash and D. J. Sheridan Can one accurately date a bruise
research standards in regard to the use of human sub- No subjects displayed yellow discoloration during the
jects. Hamdy et al. (1957) found that, when multiple first 18 hours. However, the absence of yellow did not
bruises were present, the bruises tended to resolve on av- necessarily mean that the bruise was less than 18 hours
erage 2 days faster. This could be an important fact to old. Some bruises never achieved a yellow discoloration.
consider when examining chronically abused victims of Red, blue, purple, and black were found to appear at any
violence. Bruising of animals was also found to be af- point of age progression. Yellow also developed signifi-
fected by environmental temperatures, in which those cantly faster in subjects less than 65 years of age (p <
animals kept in colder climates resolved their bruises 0.001). Two surprising observations made by the authors,
more slowly and overall the bruises had a more yellow but not statistically examined, are important to mention
appearance (Hamdy et al., 1961). Putting ice on a new here. First, a given color could appear, disappear, and
injury may cause a similar affect in slowing bruise resolu- then reappear at a later date. Second, two bruises on the
tion and altering bruise appearance in humans. Also, the same subject with the same location, age, and etiology
color progression of bruising was found to differ between could display different colors and color progression. De-
species (Hamdy, Deatherage, & Shinowara, 1956; Lan- spite this study’s significant limitations, the authors con-
glois & Gresham, 1991; McCausland & Dougherty, 1978). cluded that, “it would seem unlikely to be able to accu-
rately age a bruise from appearance alone” (Langlois &
Gresham, 1991, p. 236).
Research on dating bruises
A literature search was performed using two com- Stephenson and Bialas (1996)
puterized databases: CINAHL (1982–2006), consisting
Stephenson and Bialas (1996) examined 36 accidental
of nursing and allied health literature, and PubMed
bruises in 23 Caucasian children of ages 8 months to 13
(1950–2006), consisting of biomedical and life sciences
years (13 male and 10 female). Photographs were taken
literature. The search keywords included individual and
using a standardized color chart. Some bruises were fol-
combinations of the following words: bruise, bruising,
lowed up and rephotographed to examine progression.
contusion, skin, dermal, dermis, age, dating, aging, age-
Only a single observer (one of the authors) who was blind
ing, discoloration, color, colour, and change. Four stud-
to the time of injury examined the photographs, prevent-
ies exploring bruise color as assessed with the naked eye
ing assessment of interobserver reliability. The observer
and the age of injury in human subjects were included in
was asked to estimate the age of the bruise by category:
this review: Langlois and Gresham (1991), Stephenson
fresh (within 48 hours), intermediate (2–7 days), and
and Bialas (1996), Bariciak et al. (2003), and Mosqueda,
old (greater than 7 days). No statistical analysis was per-
Burnight, and Liao (2005). Animal studies were not in-
formed on the data.
cluded because of the significant difference in physiology
The authors determined that aging bruises was inaccu-
between species and humans on both a gross and a histo-
rate when examining photographs.
logical level.
Blue, gray, brown, and purple were observed anytime
within 1–14 days after impact. Red was found to occur
Langlois and Gresham (1991)
only in injuries 7 or fewer days old. Yellow occurred only
Langlois and Gresham (1991) based their study on the in bruises more than 24 hours old. The observer did not
observation of 369 photographs of bruises from 89 Cau- estimate any bruise more than 48 hours old as fresh. But
casian subjects of ages 10–100 years. The mean age of the in total, the observer was only correct in estimating the
subjects is unknown. For statistical analysis using logis- age of the bruise 50% of the time. No relationship was
tic regression, the subjects were dichotomized for an un- found by the authors between the accuracy of the esti-
specified reason into two groups: older and younger than mation and the age or location of a bruise. The authors
65 years. The gender of the subjects was not reported. conclude that, “ageing of injuries from photographs is im-
Some bruises were followed up and re-photographed to precise, even in a controlled research setting” (Stephen-
examine progression. Green, orange, and brown were not son & Bialas, 1996, p. 55).
included in the study because of the problem in differen-
tiating between these colors with combinations of others.
Bariciak et al. (2003)
Self-reported ages of these bruises ranged from 6 hours to
21 days. The procedure for examining the photographs Another study on bruising involving children was done
is unclear. The number of observers and whether they by Bariciak et al. (2003). Observers blind to the actual age
were blinded to the bruise’s history is unknown, raising of impact examined the bruises of 50 children between
concerns about intra/interobserver reliability. the ages of 1 week and 18 years (mean = 6.5 years).
33
Can one accurately date a bruise K. R. Nash and D. J. Sheridan
Bariciak et al. described the skin tone of the partici- tion. Mosqueda, Burnight, and Liao concluded that, “one
pants as 66% fair, 12% medium, and 12% unknown. cannot reliably predict the age of a bruise by its color”
For each bruise, one to three observers from a pool of (p.1339).
63 examined it and offered an age estimation. Evaluation
of the bruises was done in vivo (in person), as opposed
to via photograph, and bruise progression was not fol-
Discussion
lowed. K-statistics were performed to evaluate interob-
server reliability. Overall, the research is sparse surrounding dating bruises
Red, blue, and purple colors were significantly associ- based on color. The four studies had a few consistent find-
ated with bruises less than 48 hours old (p < 0.001), but ings worth noting. Yellow was found most often to de-
they were also observed in 30% of bruises older than velop in bruises after 24 hours. However, this color in
7 days. Yellow, brown, and green colors were signifi- not always noted in bruise progression. Bariciak et al.
cantly associated with bruises more than 7 days of age (2003) found yellow in almost a quarter of bruises less
(p < 0.001), but were also seen in 23% of bruises less than 48 hours old. Only two of the studies discussed
than 48 hours old. Poor interobserver reliability was green, which was observed in bruises more than 48 hours
noted (k = −0.03). The accuracy of individual observer’s old. No similarity in the results was noted for red, blue,
attempts at estimating a bruise’s age ranged from 0% purple, and black. The color progression of bruises was
to 100%, with only 40% of estimations correct within only consistently followed up by Mosqueda, Burnight,
24 hours of the actual age. The authors recommended and Liao (2005).
the use of “extreme caution in estimating bruise age, even There are several limitations of this research review
when such estimates are based on direct examination of and studies presented. Only English studies that involved
the injured area (Bariciak et al., 2003, p. 807). human subjects were included in this review. The four
studies only included Caucasian participants. It is diffi-
cult to compare findings from pediatric studies with those
Mosqueda, Burnight, and Liao (2005)
whose subjects are adult or elderly. As discussed earlier,
A more recent study, Mosqueda, Burnight, and Liao the age of the individual can affect the appearance of
(2005), examined bruise progression longitudinally in bruises due to physiological changes to the dermal and
101 Caucasian elderly subjects over age of 65 years (mean underlying structures.
78, 35 male and 66 female). A total of 108 bruises were When photographs are reviewed as part of a study,
followed for 6 weeks with daily head-to-toe evaluation clear steps must be taken to standardize the process and
(in vivo) by one of the two observers. According to then present these steps to the reader. Langlois and Gre-
Mosqueda, Burnight, and Liao, self-report of the bruise’s sham (1991) did not include any details surrounding
age was obtained but was not required due to daily obser- their photographic methods. Photography can create sev-
vation of the subjects. In addition to bruise descriptions, eral additional problems when examining the color of
other variables collected in the research included the type injuries. Lighting can alter color portrayal in photogra-
of residence, the ability to perform activities of daily liv- phy. Fluorescent light has been found to make bruises ap-
ing (ADLs), mobility, the number of falls, medications, pear green or yellow (Pasqualone, 2006). Having a stan-
and medical conditions. dardized color chart, as in the Stephenson and Bialas
Statistical analyses were performed, including t-tests, (1996) study, can help quality film developers correct
chi-square tests, and correlations; however, the results much of the effect of light and film speed on color
were provided to the reader using only basic descrip- (Zercie & Penders, 2006). When color charts are used,
tives (percentages) in the section “Timing and Sequence each print can be manually adjusted to match the stan-
of Color Change” (Mosqueda, Burnight, & Liao, 2005, dardized color chart as best as the developer can vi-
p. 1341). Almost 20% of the bruises were yellow within sually determine. This is true for both digital and film
the first 24 hours. Purple and red were observed at all photography.
ages of bruises. Despite daily examinations, the accu- Another problem exists with studies that involve both
racy of the ages of the bruises is questionable due to photographs and in vivo evaluation of bruises. The
the bruises’ unknown depth. As discussed earlier, deep question arises, can two people observe and describe
bruises can take hours or even days to appear at the skin the same color similarly? Is the bruise bluish-black or
surface. Medications affecting coagulation did not signif- blackish-blue? Color perception of bruises has recently
icantly correlate with the duration of bruise or discol- been shown to be a subjective process with poor inter-
oration with age. Decreased ADLs and residential setting and intraobserver reliability. Munang, Leonard, and Mok
also did not affect the number of days until bruise resolu- (2002) found that only 25% of observers of the same
34
K. R. Nash and D. J. Sheridan Can one accurately date a bruise
35
Can one accurately date a bruise K. R. Nash and D. J. Sheridan
to provide an accurate determination of the bruise’s age. trauma. Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Biology and
However, a conservative, relative estimation of a bruise’s Medicine, 95, 255–258.
age as being newer versus older could be given when Hamdy, M. K., Kunkle, L. E., Reins, M. S., & Deatherage, F. E.
combined with other clinical findings, especially in com- (1957). Bruised tissue III: Some factors affecting
parison with other existing bruises on the same patient. A experimental bruises. Journal of Animal Science, 16,
red, painful, indurated bruise with well-defined margins 496–501.
is more consistent with a patient’s given history of re- Hamdy, M. K., May, K. N., Flanagan, W. P, & Powers, J. J.
cent injury then a bruise that is yellow, nonpainful, and (1961). Determination of the age of bruises in chicken
nonindurated with blurred margins. In the absence of a broilers. Poultry Science, 40, 787–789.
Hughes, V. K., Ellis, P. S., & Langlois, N. E. I. (2004). The
reliable history, one could never provide an exact age of
perception of yellow in bruises. Journal of Clinical Forensic
the bruise within hours or even in days, except to de-
Medicine, 11, 257–259.
scribe the red bruise as being newer than the yellow one.
Hughes, V. K., Ellis, P. S., Burt, T., & Langlois, N. E. I.
Even with a reliable history, the forensic nurse could only
(2004). The practical application of reflectance
testify that the bruise’s appearance is consistent with or
spectrophotometry for the demonstration of haemoglobin
not consistent with the history of when the trauma was and its degradation in bruises. Journal of Clinical Pathology,
inflicted. 57, 355–359.
In the case example, it would be difficult, if not im- Johnson, C. F. (1990). Inflicted injury versus accidental
possible, to say with any degree of scientific or medical injury. Pediatric Clinics of North America, 37, 791–814.
certainty that the injuries to the patient’s inner thighs Kaczor, K., Pierce, M. C., Makoroff, K., & Corey, T. S. (2006).
were the direct result of the reported assault or from a Bruising and physical child abuse. Clinical Pediatric Medicine,
possible trauma from the previous consensual sexual act. 7, 153–160.
Despite the fact that the police in our earlier case example Langlois, N. E. I., & Gresham, G. A. (1991). The ageing of
may understandably want to hear that the injuries are re- bruises: A review and study of the colour changes with
lated to the recent assault, the current state of the science time. Forensic Science International, 50, 227–238.
in determining the age of bruises does not support that Liem, E. B., Hollensead, S. C., Joiner, T. V., Sessler, D. I.
conclusion. (2006). Women with red hair report a slightly increased
Forensic health professionals are frequently asked to rate of bruising but have normal coagulation tests.
examine victims of violence and comment on the time- Anesthesia and Analgesia, 102, 313–318.
line of their injuries. But when judgments are made McCausland, I. P., & Dougherty, R. (1978). Histological ageing
purely based on opinion and guesswork rather than re- of bruises in lambs and calves. Australian Veterinary Journal,
search, the results can be disastrous. Children can be in- 54(11), 525–527.
appropriately taken away from their parents, and rapists Mosqueda, L., Burnight, K., & Liao, S. (2005). The life cycle of
bruises in older adults. Journal of American Geriatric Society,
can be set free to assault again. The studies presented in
53(8), 1339–1343.
this article demonstrate the lack of consistency in findings
Muelleman, R. L., Lenaghan, P. A., & Pakieser, R. A. (1996).
between the available research on dating bruises based on
Battered women: Injury locations and types. Annals of
color. The role of the forensic health professional is to re-
Emergency Medicine, 28(5), 486–492.
main as objective as possible.
Munang, L. A., Leonard, P. A., Mok, J. Y. Q. (2002). Lack of
agreement on colour description between clinicians
examining childhood bruising. Journal of Clinical Forensic
References
Medicine, 9, 171–174.
Bariciak, E. D., Plint, A. C., Gaboury, I., & Bennett, S. (2003). Palmer, C. M., McNulty, A. M., D’Este, C., & Donovan, B.
Dating of bruises in children: An assessment of physician (2004). Genital injuries in women reporting sexual assault.
accuracy. Pediatrics, 112(4), 804–807. Sexual Health, 1, 55–59.
Besant-Matthews, P. E. (2006). Blunt and sharp injuries. In V. Pasqualone, G. A. (2006). Forensic photography. In V. A.
Lynch &J. B. Duval (Eds.). Forensic nursing (pp. 189–200). Lynch &J. B. Duval (Eds.). Forensic nursing, (pp.170–186).
St. Louis, MO: Elsevier Mosby. St. Louis, MO: Elsevier Mosby.
Dyer, C. B., Connolly, M. T., & McFeeley, P. (2003). The Randeberg, L. L., Winnem, A. M., Langlois, N. E., Larsen, E.
clinical and medical forensics of elder abuse and neglect. In L. P., Haaverstad, R., Skallerud, B., Haugen, O. A., &
R. J. Bonnie &R. B. Wallace (Eds.). Elder mistreatment: Svaasand, L. O. (2007). Skin changes following minor
Abuse, neglect and exploitation in an aging America (pp. trauma. Lasers in Surgery and Medicine, 39, 403–413.
339–381). Washington, DC: The National Academies Press. Schwartz, A. J., & Ricci, L. R. (1996). How accurately can
Hamdy, M. K., Deatherage, F. E., & Shinowara, G. Y. (1956). bruises be aged in abused children? Literature review and
Bruised tissue I: Biochemical changes resulting from blunt synthesis. Pediatrics, 97(2), 254–257.
36
K. R. Nash and D. J. Sheridan Can one accurately date a bruise
Sheridan, D. J. (2003). Forensic identification and Trujillo, O., Vanezis, P., & Cermignani, M. (1996).
documentation of patients experiencing intimate partner Photometric assessment of skin colour and lightness
violence. Clinics in Family Practice, 5(1), 113–143. using a tristimulus colorimeter: Reliability of inter
Sheridan, D. J. (2007). Treating survivors of intimate partner and intra-investigator observations in health adult
abuse: Forensic identification and documentation. In J. S. volunteers. Forensic Science International, 81,
Olshaker, M. C. Jackson, & W. S. Smock (Eds.). Forensic 1–10.
emergency medicine, 2nd ed (pp. 202–222). Philadelphia, PA: Valente, M. J., & Abramson, N. (2006). Easy bruisability.
Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins. Southern Medical Journal, 99(4), 366–370.
Sheridan, D. J., & Nash, K. R. (2007). Acute injury patterns of Vanezis, P. (2001a). Bruising: Concepts of ageing and
intimate partner violence victims. Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, interpretation. In G. N. Rutty (Ed.). Essentials of autopsy
8(3), 281–289. practice, vol. 1 (pp. 221–240). London: Springer.
Smock, W. (2001). Forensic emergency medicine. In J. Vanezis, P. (2001b). Interpreting bruises at necropsy. Journal
Olshaker, M. C. Jackson, & W. Smock (Eds.). Forensic of Clinical Pathology, 54, 348–355.
Emergency Medicine (pp. 63–83). Philadelphia, PA: Venes, D., & Thomas, C. L. (Eds.). (2001). Taber’s cyclopedic
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. medical dictionary, 19th ed. Philadelphia, PA: FA Davis
Stedman, T. L. (Ed.). (2005). Stedman’s medical dictionary, 28th Company.
ed. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Zercie, K. B., & Penders, P. (2006). Concepts of
Stephenson, T. (1997). Ageing of bruising in children. Journal photography in forensic nursing. In R. M. Hammer,B.
of the Royal Society of Medicine 90, 312–314. Moynihan, & E. M. Pagliaro (Eds.). Forensic nursing: A
Stephenson, T., & Bialas, Y. (1996). Estimation of the age of handbook for practice. Boston, MA: Jones & Bartlett
bruising. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 74, 53–55. Publishers.
37