Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

ISSN (Print) : 0974-6846

Indian Journal of Science and Technology, Vol 9(2), DOI: 10.17485/ijst/2016/v9i2/83339, January 2016 ISSN (Online) : 0974-5645

Finite Element Analysis of a Four Wheeler


Automobile Car Chassis
K. Santa Rao1, G. Musalaiah2 and K. Mohana Krishna Chowdary3
1Departmentof Mechanical Engineering, GMRIT, Rajam - 532127, Abndhra Pradesh,
India; ksantarao@gmail.com
2Department of Mechanical Engineering, AITAM, Tekkali – 532201, Andhra Pradesh,

India; musalaiah.321@gmail.com
3Department of Mechanical Engineering, RGUKT, (IIIT), Nuzvid - 521201, Andhra Pradesh,

India; mohanakrishna.k@rgukt.in

Abstract
Background/Objectives: The objective of the present work is useful for certain recommendations to modify the existing
design of four wheeler chassis in order to satisfy the need of both customer and manufacturer. Methods/Statistical
Analysis: Static and modal analysis has been carried out on a four wheeler automobile chassis applying with finite element
method using PRO-E and ANSYS softwares. Findings: The main findings identify maximum stressed regions, deflections,
reactions and natural frequencies of a four wheeler automobile chassis. Applications/Improvements: It has been
proposed that Nickel-Molybdenum (Ni-Mo steel) is suitable for the analysis in comparison with the other materials in all
criterions.

Keywords: Deflection, Four Wheeler Chassis, Natural Frequency, Static and Model Analysis

frequencies obtained lie beyond natural range so as to


1. Introduction
be compensated with increasing the stiffness of chassis.
A vehicle without body is termed as Chassis. Various Decreasing the chassis length can increase the stiffness of
components of the vehicle viz., Power supplying unit, chassis. It is also observed that resonance phenomenon
Transmission unit, Axles, Wheels and Tyres, Suspension, and unusual chassis vibration can be prevented.
Controlling units like Braking, Steering and electrical V. Veloso et al.2 reported the results of failure analysis
system parts are fitted on the Chassis frame. It is also of longitudinal stringer of vehicle. Plastic deformation
called as Carrying Unit. and cracks were observed when durability tests were
Pravin A. Renuke1 made an attempt to evaluate the performed on prototype. Stress analysis was performed
changes in chassis dynamic behavior by varying the usage using finite element analysis. Reinforced models were
offinite element method. First six frequency modes of the proposed. The selection of the best solution was based
modified chassis are less than 100 Hz and in the series of on combination of high strength and production costs.
42.423 to 79.531 Hz. Car chassis revealed global vibration The finite element analysis of several different models
for the first two modes and sixth mode. Torsion and reduces the number of physical and expensive tests to
vertical bending with 2 nodal points are parts of global be conducted. Consequently, it was not indispensable to
vibrations of the car chassis. Due to vibration, the local fabricate several prototypes. Results of compression tests
bending takes place at the top hat cross member where were compared with numerical results. Validation tests
the gearbox is mounted. As mass of chassis increases were conducted on vehicles produced with the reinforced
owing to the fitted equipment, the values of natural stringer and failures were not observed.

*Author for correspondence


Finite Element Analysis of a Four Wheeler Automobile Car Chassis

Mohd Hanif Mat et al.3 discussed the results of strength of the truck chassis structure. It was reported that an
and rigidity of the ‘Eco-Challenge’ race car’s chassis when improvement in the results of bending stiffness from 2.2
subjected to the required loads using FEA. For the design, kN/mm to 3.26 kN/mm and torsion stiffness from 3.9
a steel space frame was chosen as it is the most effective kN-m/deg to 5.9 kN-m/deg were achieved.
and cost efficient structure. It was found that that chassis Hossein Farahani et al.9 focused on comparing natural
was able to withstand the required loads with minimal frequencies along the x-axis of composite cylindrical
deflections complying with the rules and regulations. It tank. Vibration analysis is performed on composite
was also found that maximum stresses are well below the cylindrical tank using the finite element package ANSYS
yield stress in most loading conditions. by incorporating different fiber angle (–900 to 900 and 00
T. Ananda Babu et al.4 performed crash analysis of to 900) and layering in the direction of x-axis of the tank.
car chassis frame applying Finite Element Method. It The boundary conditions applied are (1) located at the
was reported that by increasing the bumper thickness extremities of tank; (2) fixed along the y and z coordinates
from 3mm to 6mm the Von-mises stress reduced from and is free in x-axis. It was reported that with increase of
531.523MPa to 127.317MPa and natural frequencies layering angles natural frequency decreases.
estimated are very low. It was also reported that the Ali Zare et al.10 used finite element method and
maximum amplitude is 0.7611mm under transient analyzed axial fan blade with dissimilar chord lengths
loading when the impact takes place on the bumper and to find factor of safety and Von Mises stresses. It was
the value is very less than 2.8mm as per the Ford Motor reported that when pressure load applied on blade’s lower
Vehicle Design Test (FMVDT). Hence the bumper design surface is varied from 100 kPa to 800 kPa, maintaining
is safe based on dynamic conditions. constant chord length and 5° of twist angle, an increase in
Sairam Kotari et al.5 discussed that existing TATRA Von Mises stress and simultaneous fall in factor of safety
chassis was analyzed by the finite element method for is observed.
Antenna and Electronic components installation and
the stress levels are found to be 737.3 N/mm2. After 2.  Static Analysis
modifications of the TATRA chassis with suitable
reinforcement, increase in thickness, addition of stiffeners, The main objective of a static analysis is to calculate
the finite element analysis was carried out and the chassis effects of steady loading conditions, such as those caused
stress levels are found to be 173.38 N/mm2, which is less by time dependent loads, on a structure. Usually it is used
than yield stress of 410 N/mm2. From the results, it can to determine the displacement, stresses, strains and forces
be concluded that the modified TATRA chassis is capable in structures or components when subjected to loads that
to carry the loads beyond the previous payload up to 14 do not induce damping and inertia effects. Assumptions
tonnes. are considered for steady loading and response conditions
Prajwal Kumar M. P. et al.6 discussed the results i.e., the loads and structures response are assumed to vary
pertaining to analysis of tubular space frame chassis slowly with respect to time.
fabricated to resist all likely forces that it might be subjected
to in the racing path. The weight of the chassis is reduced 3.  Modal Analysis
with no compromise on its strength. The chassis’s final
product has been manufactured in a proficient manner The modal analysis is used to find out the vibration
that adhered to the design. Confirmation tests on chassis’s characteristics (natural frequencies and mode shapes) of
final product were conducted for torsional rigidity. a structure or a machine component in the process of its
Hemant B. Patil et al.7 presented the results of stress design. It also serves as a preliminary step for another,
analysis of a ladder type low loader truck chassis structure more detailed, dynamic analysis, viz., harmonic response
comprising C-beams designed for application of 7.5 ton analysis, transient dynamic analysis or spectrum analysis.
using FEM. From obtained numerical results it was The important feature of modal analysis is modal cyclic
reported that altering the location of cross member may symmetry, which allows end-user to model just a sector
be a good choice rather changing the thickness. of it and examine the mode shapes of a cyclic symmetric
Goolla Murali et al.8 presented the results of design structure. Any nonlinearity, such as contact (gap) elements
modification made to improve the load carrying capacity and plasticity, are ignored even if they are defined.

2 Vol 9 (2) | January 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
K. Santa Rao, G. Musalaiah and K. Mohana Krishna Chowdary

4.  Boundary Conditions 5.1  Static Analysis


In static analysis response of the model/vehicle is
The individual assemblies are connected to each other
determined applying steady loads whose value does
by appropriate displacement constraints, which specify
change with time. The responses are measured in terms of
the interconnection with the adjacent assembly. Figure
stresses, strains and displacements.
1 depicts displacement constraints applied in the present
modeling. Table 1 and Table 2 depict the properties and
5.2  Loads and Results
composition of materials used for analysis.
In the analysis, the idle condition of the vehicle subjected
to maximum payload on a flat road is considered. Weight
of the vehicle, Weight of two passengers present in the
cabin and weight of the engine are also considered in the
analysis. In the finite element model nodes attached to axle-
suspension connection are constrained along translation
direction. Figure 2 and Figure 3 depict deflections and
stresses in the vehicle when subjected to static loads. Table
3, Table 4 and Table 5 provide the results and comparison
of displacements, stress distribution, Von Mises stress
distribution obtained by performing static analysis.
 

Figure 1.  Boundary conditions.


6.  Comparison of Displacements
Table 1.  Properties of materials

Material Young’s Density Poisson’s


modulus (kg/m3) Ratio
(N/m2)
Forged Steel 2.0×1011 7839 0.3
Ni-Cr Steel 2.02×1011 8249 0.3
Ni-Mo Steel 2.05×1011 7850 0.3

Table 2.  Composition of materials

Forged Steel Ni-Cr Steel Ni-Mo Steel


C (0.35-0.45)% C (0.08-0.16)% C (0.13-1.18)%
Si (0.5)% Si (1.0)% Si (0.15-0.30)% Figure 2.  Displacement in z-direction.
Mn (0.6-0.9)% Mn (1.0-2.0)% Mn (0.45-0.65)%
Cr (0.7-1.1)% Cr (20.0-22.5)% S (0.04)%
Ni (1.6-2.1)% Ni (19.0-21.0)% Ni (1.65-2.0)%
Mo (0.25-0.45)% Mo (2.5-3.5)% Mo (0.2-0.3)%
Fe Fe Fe

5.  Results and Discussions


Static analysis, response determination and modal analysis
under random excitation is carried out on defined finite
element model. For all the analyses performed the same
finite element model is used. The distinction between the
cases considered lies in the applied loads and boundary
conditions. Figure 3.  Stress in z-direction.

Vol 9 (2) | January 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 3
Finite Element Analysis of a Four Wheeler Automobile Car Chassis

Table 3.  Results and comparison of displacements in static analysis

Material Maximum Displacement in x-direction Displacement in Displacement in


Deflection (m) y-direction z-direction
(m) (m) (m)
Forged Steel 1.374 Max = 0.179448 Max = 0.363E-3 Max = 0.010137
Min = -0.020357 Min = -1.366 Min = -0.010202
Ni-Cr Steel 1.36 Max = 0.177671 Max = 0.360E-3 Max = 0.010036
Min = -0.020155 Min = -1.353 Min = -0.010101
Ni-Mo Steel 1.34 Max = 0.175071 Max = 0.355E-3 Max = 0.009889
Min = -0.01986 Min = -1.333 Min = -0.009953

Table 4.  Results and comparison of stress distribution in static analysis

Material Maximum Deflection Stress in Stress in Stress in


(m) x-direction y-direction z-direction
(N/m2) (N/m2) (N/m2)
Forged Steel 1.374 Max = 0.130E+8 Max = 0.372E+7 Max = 0.349E+7
Min = -0.131E+8 Min = -0.106E+8 Min = -0.226E+8
Ni-Cr Steel 1.36 Max = 0.130E+8 Max = 0.372E+7 Max = 0.349E+7
Min = -0.131E+8 Min = -0.106E+8 Min = -0.226E+8
Ni-Mo Steel 1.34 Max = 0.130E+8 Max = 0.372E+7 Max = 0.349E+7
Min = -0.131E+8 Min = -0.106E+8 Min = -0.226E+8

7. Comparision of Von Mises Stresses


Table 5.  Results and comparison of Von Mises stress distribution in static analysis

Material Maximum Deflection (m) Maximum Stress (N/m2) Minimum Stress (N/m2) Yield Stress (N/m2)
Forged Steel 1.374 Max = 0.130E+8 Max = 0.372E+7 Max = 0.349E+7
Min = -0.131E+8 Min = -0.106E+8 Min = -0.226E+8
Ni-Cr Steel 1.36 Max = 0.130E+8 Max = 0.372E+7 Max = 0.349E+7
Min = -0.131E+8 Min = -0.106E+8 Min = -0.226E+8
Ni-Mo Steel 1.34 Max = 0.130E+8 Max = 0.372E+7 Max = 0.349E+7
Min =- 0.131E+8 Min = -0.106E+8 Min = -0.226E+8

8.  Modal Analysis 9. Comparision of Natural


Modal analysis provides responses when a component Frequencies
or structure is subjected to natural vibration. It involves
finding natural frequencies and modes of vibration. The
results obtained from modal analysis can be taken as an
input to other dynamic analyses viz., spectrum analysis.

8.1  Loads and Results


The only loads taken into consideration in the modal
analysis of the vehicle are displacement constraints
available at nodes. The displacements associated with
first four mode shapes are shown in following: Figure 4,
Table 6 and Table 7 represent results and comparison of
deflections and frequencies obtained when performing
modal analysis respectively. Figure 4.  Frequency in mode-3.

4 Vol 9 (2) | January 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
K. Santa Rao, G. Musalaiah and K. Mohana Krishna Chowdary

Table 6.  Results and comparison of deflections in 11. References


modal analysis
1. Renuke PA. Dynamic analysis of a car chassis. International
Material Maximum Maximum Maximum Journal of Engineering Research and Applications. 2012
Deflection in Deflection in Deflection in Nov-Dec; 2(6):955–9.
x-direction y-direction z-direction 2. Veloso V, Magalhaes HS, Bicalho GI, Palma ES. Failure
(m) (m) (m)
investigation and stress analysis of a longitudinal stringer of
Forged Steel 0.477E-5 0.477E-5 0.597E-5 an automobile chassis. Engineering Failure Analysis. 2009
Ni-Cr Steel 0.465E-5 0.465E-5 0.582E-5 Jul; 16(5):1696–702.
Ni-Mo Steel 0.477E-5 0.477E-5 0.596E-5 3. Mat MH, Ghani ARA. Design and analysis of ‘Eco’ car
chassis. International Symposium on Robotics and
Intelligent Sensors. (IRIS 2012). 2012; 41:1756–60.
Table 7.  Results and comparison of frequencies in 4. Babu TA, Vijay Praveen D, Venkateswarao M. Crash
modal analysis analysis of car chassis frame using finite element method.
IJERT. 2012 Oct; 1(8):1–8.
Material Frequency in Frequency Frequency in 5. Kotari S, Gopinath V. Static and dynamic analysis on Tatra
x-direction in y-direc- z-direction chassis. IJMER. 2012; 2(1):86–94.
(Hz) tion (Hz) (Hz) 6. Prajwal Kumar MP, Muralidharan V, Madhusudhana G.
Forged Steel 0.014841 0.029079 0.034495 Design and analysis of a tubular space frame chassis of a high
Ni-Cr Steel 0.014539 0.028488 0.033795 performance race car. International Journal of Research in
Engineering and Technology. 2014 Feb; 3(2):497–501.
Ni-Mo Steel 0.015014 0.02942 0.034899
7. Patil HB, Kachave SD, Deore ER. Stress analysis of
automotive chassis with various thicknesses. IOSR Journal
of Mechanical and Civil Engineering. 2013 Mar-Apr;
10. Conclusion 6(1):44–9.
In present work, an attempt has been made to use finite 8. Murali G, Subramanyam B, Naveen D. Design improvement
of a truck chassis based on thickness. Altair Technology
element method for static and modal analysis of a four-
Conference; 2013. p. 1–6.
wheeler automobile chassis. Three different materials
9. Farahani H, Barati F, Batmani H. Vibration analysis of
have been considered for the analysis of the component
composite horizontal cylindrical tank with different
and proposed that which material is suitable according layering using the finite element method. Indian Journal of
to the deflections, stress distribution, Von-Mises stress Science and Technology. 2015 Apr; 8(S7):213–9.
distribution and natural frequencies. 10. Zare A, Munisamy KM, Najafzadeh A, Shahizare B, Ahmadi
It has been proposed that Nickel-Molybdenum (Ni- A, Jaafari AA. Finite element analysis of axial fan blade
Mo steel) is suitable for the analysis in comparison with with different chord lengths. Indian Journal of Science and
the other materials in all criterions. Technology. 2013 May; 6(5):4403–9.

Vol 9 (2) | January 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 5

You might also like