Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Application of Opt 00 Jen K
Application of Opt 00 Jen K
DSpace Repository
1982-10
Jenkins, James L.
Monterey, California. Naval Postgraduate School
http://hdl.handle.net/10945/20071
THESIS
APPLICATION OF OPTIMIZATION
TECHNIQUES TO NAVAL SURFACE
COMBATANT SHIP SYNTHESIS
by
James L. Jenkins
October, 1982
James L. Jenkins
» PERFORMING ORGANIZATION NAME ANO AOORESS 10. »»OG»»M EwSmEnT o«q jE:c -
AREA A fO»K UNIT NUMBERS
Naval Postgraduate School
Monterey, California 93940
11. CONTROLLING OFFICE NAME ANO ADDRESS 12 REPORT OATE
Naval Postgraduate School October, 1982
Monterey, California 93940 11 NUMBER OF PAGES
95
M MONITORING AGENCY NAME * AO0RESS/// dlllarani trom Controlling Olllea) IS. SECURITY CLASS, (at tnt, raporrj
I? DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (el tn« abatract antarad In aloe* 30. II dlllarani /ram Rapori)
It SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES
19. KEY WORDS (Continue an reweree tida II nacaaaarr and identity *r mloct numeer
DD Forqj 1473
Jan 73
1
S/.N 0102-014-6601
_______-_-——_—
sceu«ivv clamiucatiow of *»<• p*atr*mm o«»« *».•-•*)
Approved for public release; distribution unlimited
by
James L. Jenkins
Lieutenant United States Navy
,
from the
ABSTRACT
combatants
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. INTRODUCTION 10
A. BACKGROUND 10
B. PROBLEM STATEMENT 12
C. SCOPE 13
D. PRESENTATION OF THESIS 17
A. INTRODUCTION 19
B. DEFINITIONS 19
C. COPES/CONMIN 21
A. HISTORY 27
FUNCTIONS 36
C. CONSTRAINTS 39
V. DESIGN EXAMPLE 45
A. INTRODUCTION 45
B. EXAMPLE DESCRIPTION 45
C. PARAMETER DESCRIPTIONS 48
5
D. CONSTRAINT PHILOSOPHY 51
E. EXAMPLE RESULTS 54
FUNCTIONS 58
B. SENSITIVITY STUDIES 63
LIST OF REFERENCES 71
APPENDIX C NOMENCLATURE 92
8
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
tremendous support
A . BACKGROUND
10
computer-aided design and construction (CASDAC) programs
1. Conceptual Design
2. Preliminary Design
3. Contract Design
11
Feasibility studies can be used for trade-off studies where
B. PROBLEM STATEMENT
12
and too much." This thesis is intended to provide the
C. SCOPE
will let the computer make the decision based on the limi-
mathematical terms.
13
TRADITIONAL
DESIGN SPIRAL
LBP, L/ ,B/ ,C ,C
B H p x
VOLUME 3 STABILITY
T7TTT
SHP IE ARRANGEMENTS
3ZE
WEIGHTS
3T
14
OPTIMIZED DESIGN SPIRAL
LBP, L/ , B/ ,C , C
B H p x
I
a n VOLUME a STABILITY
ARRANGEMENTS
3ZE
WEIGHTS
15
the optimizer changing design variables to meet the require-
16
5. And finally, the freedom to be innovative and
creative in design as a result of no longer
being tied to long, tedious manual calculations.
D. PRESENTATION OF THESIS
presented.
variables
synthesis system.
17
Appendix A is a computer listing of the design example
presented in Chapter V.
meanings
thesis
18
II. OPTIMIZATION TECHNIQUES
A. INTRODUCTION
consulted.
B. DEFINITIONS.
19
Objective function — The single valued function with
is said to be violated.
20
consideration of performance is called a side constraint. A
length or draft
C. COPES /CONMIN
constrained problems.
stated as follows:
X*
ill
where OBJ is the objective function.
< X. < X
u
for i = l,n '
21
the lower and upper bounds, respectively, on the design
variable X. and are the limits over which F(X) and G.(X)
are defined.
S.
22
Consider for example, a hypothetical problem in which we
(LBP), and the length to beam ratio (L/B). There are also
23
TWO VRRIRBLE DESIGN SPACE
L/B RATIO VS. LBP
! i
1 1
—
1
"~i 1 1 1 1
r
10.410.5 10.6 10.7 10.8 10.9 11.0 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5 11.6
LENGTH TO BEAM RATIO (NON-DIMSL)
24
direction or some constraint boundary is encountered. A
which will minimize the objective and yet not violate any
25
indicating the optimal design has been achieved. Point E is
26
III. SHIP SYNTHESIS MODELS
A. HISTORY
ships.
27
carriers. Because of the wide range of ship types in the
28
practices. In addition to its applications during concep-
tual design, the Reed model can also be used during later
studies
by the model.
following data:
29
DATA2 -
SPAYLD UWDIM
GEOM
EPLANT
MACHLQ MBSIZE
MAIN
WEIGHT VRTCG
SEASPD FNCGRP
OUTPUT
HPCALC
VOLUME
SHEER CRVAL
30
INPUT DATA, FNCGRP
SEASPD
NAMES PLACE WTS &
AVG SEA SPEED
CR'S VOL IN FUNC
PAYLOAD GROUPS
PROCEED TO OUTPUT
NEXT SHIP
PRT RESULTS
CALL DATA2
SHIP SPECS
LBP=LBP+10
CALL SPAYLD
SORT WT GRPS
NO
CALL UWDIM
CALC B,H
WEIGHT
CALC FULL LD
HPCALC
& LIGHT SHIP
POWERING EST
DISPLACEMENT
USES CRVAL
EPLANT
CALC KW LOAD LBP=LBP+10
SIZE GEN
31
Following this, the main program calls subroutine SPAYLD
and place them in the proper BSCI weight groups. The value
not be specified.
the design.
BSCI —
"Bureau of Ships Consolidated Index of Drawings,
Materials, and Services, Related to Construction and Con-
version" of February 1965 and given in an appendix to
Reference [14]
2
Variables used in this thesis are described in Appendix
C, Nomenclature.
32
the maximum sustained speed, SHP. If VSUS is input, the
will be by-passed.
have amidships.
33
most naval combatants are now considered volume-limited,
model
terminates
tics .
program.
35
IV. COUPLING COPES /CONMIN AND THE REED MODEL
second term would take into account payload weight and the
design methods and philosophies for the FDL , LHA, and DD-963
36
habitability , vulnerability, survivability, innovation, and
37
selection is further supported by the fact that total ship
function can be made with designs that may have used LBP or
38
each subroutine the variable is used in. It is used by the
and space for inputting any special payload items not in-
C. CONSTRAINTS
loops which were removed. The first loop occurred after all
loop was to check to see if the calculated value for the full
39
within a user specified tolerance. If the difference was not
ment and make the check again. The iteration continued until
draft ratio be greater than two and less than four in order
40
criterion. A variable R is introduced in the subroutine
R = KB + BM - GM - KG - FSCORR
constraints
0.001 < Cv < 0.006 for 0.5 < V//L < 1.3
0.001 < Cv < 0.003 for 0.5 < V//E < 2.0
41
G10 = Cv/0.006 - 1.0 < 0.0
G12 = -1.0
42
Reed/COPES/CONMIN system will process only one design at a
the input data files are made easily and the computational
fractions of 0.01 and 0.03 forward and 0.001 and 0.0075 aft
F0 = (0.03*LBP + D10) - H
43
respectively. These values are comparable to those produced
The Reed model was written giving the program the option
here.
44
V. DESIGN EXAMPLE
A. INTRODUCTION
Reference [3] and the data description and input format for
B. EXAMPLE DESCRIPTION
plished over the lifetime of the ship. From the OR, the
class frigate.
45
at this point. The designer can pick and choose the weapons
I.
TABLE I
SQS-56 Sonar
Mk-92 CIWS/STIR
Harpoon FCS
46
Having made these decisions, which incidentally may have
47
function he considers viable as an objective function and
TABLE II
LBP Officers 1
Accommodations
Cp Flag Accommodations
Cx Troop Accommodations
C. PARAMETER DESCRIPTIONS
48
to warships is that the best design is the one of
least displacement. This design gives the highest
value of the ratio of military load to displacement."
49
and course tracking when comparing designs. The L/B ratio
is in global location 6.
in global location 7.
rectangle whose sides are equal to the draft and the beam at
location 9.
50
presents the side constraints that are imposed as a result
TABLE III
Cp 0.50 0.90
Cx 0.75 0.90
D. CONSTRAINT PHILOSOPHY
51
destroyer synthesis model. Also, he cannot justifiably try
portion of the code. This is not the case with this system
52
Having briefly discussed constraints, it is now appro-
set, 77 and 89, and specifies the upper and lower bounds and
53
TABLE IV
$ BLOCK A
OPTIMIZED VERSION OF THE FFG-7
$ BLOCK B
2,5
$ BLOCK C
3, , ,10, ,,50
$ BLOCK D
0. ,
,-0.02
0.,
$ BLOCK E
0,1,-1.0
$ BLOCK F
$ LBP
300.0,700.0
$ L/B
7.0,12.0
$ B/H
2.0,4.0
$ Cp
0.50,0.90
$ Cx
0.75,0.90
$ BLOCK G
1,5
2,6
3,7
4,8
5,9
$ BLOCK H
1,
$ BLOCK I
77,89
-1.01+15,0.0,0.0,0.0
$ BLOCK V
END
E. EXAMPLE RESULTS
54
with constraints Gl , G2 , and G13 violated. Physically, this
TABLE V
Objective Function
DISPFL 2865.05 3511.68
Design Variables
LBP 300.0 394.38
L/B 9.07 8.76
B/H 3.14 3.32
Cp 0.59 0.50 1
Cx 0.75 0.77
Constraints
Gl 6.22 2 -0.015
G2 1.85 2 -0.068
G3 -3.63 -0.398
G4 -2.15 -0.168
G5 -7.85 -2.062
G6 -1.90 -0.040
G7 -1.52 -0.285
G8 -5 .66 -0.503
G9 -5.57 -0.501
G10 -6.23 -0.665
Gil -4.22 -0.496
G12 -10.0 -1.000
G13 11. 86 2 -0.0006
1
lower bound of design variable
2
violated constraint
3
active constraint
55
Figure 5.1 is a graph of the objective function versus the
The average run time for this example was approximately two
and one half CPU second on an IBM 3033 system. The entire
is provided in Appendix A.
ten percent of the actual and could have been made more
56
OPTIMIZATION HISTORY
DISPLACEMENT VS ITERATIONS
ITERATIONS
57
VI. SYNTHESIS SYSTEM APPLICATION
for comparison.
58
o co 05 in m H 05 CO H O o 05
t> o o m t> ^ t> o CO m 00 H CM rH
1 Q • • • •
m
• • • • t> • • • •
aW CO CO o o 05 CM o m m O o rH
Cm w H
•*
«* rH CO CO H rH
Cm CC!
hm
o 00 CM o CO CM s-
I CO m CO H o 05
>
X -^ CO o m o m rH 05 CO CO <0 rH CM CO
<< • • • • • • • • rH
m
• • • •
s <HI CO o o trrt
03 CM CO m o o rH
Ch o <* H CM CO rH rH
> CO
Q
CQ M rH o c o rH CO CM CO CM H o 05
C XP -»,
^ H •
lO
•
o •
CO o CO
•
m CM CO rH CM CO
fall <u • • • • rH • • • •
•H s< Tf LO o o CO CO CO CO in m o o rH
03 Cm 05 Tjl H CM CO rH rH
Q) 2£ CO
Q
+-> 2
a w t> C^ rH m ^ CO 05 «tf m CO 05 rH
CO XQ LO CM CO c- rH CO rH o -* <# o rH ^
Fn < • • • • • • • • m • • • •
M CD sQ CM co o o rH o CM 05 t> 05 o O CO
> O r* CM H CM "^r 1
H
lO
w •H
J Q
CQ 2 CO CM o o X CO CO CO CM rH c 05
< <4— O CO O LO o <tf o CO m rH co rH CM CO
Eh c X jM • • « • • • • • rH • • • •
o h- CQ n< C- o o rfl 00 CO CO m in O o rH
o S "I
05 'HI H CM CO H rH
CO
J 01 CO o s-
I 'Ht CO CO CO CM rH o 05
Cm CO o m t> m t> CO m rH CO rH CM CO
2 ft • • • • • • • • rH • • • •
i—i CO ^ m c o CO co CO 00 m m o o rH
IOCS
1— 05 «* H CM CO rH rH
G CO
(S
w CO a J
£m
w
2 j o 2
J Cm Cm > O
2 Eh Cm Q ~^. ~~» Eh
< s Cm CQ Oh >H >* ^•^
cs a, < < CQ Cm 3 CO Q <c Cm
<c CQ H a X Cm ^ -^ CQ 1— J
«3J
a, Cm Cm
a J CQ a CJ Q J CQ > Q Cm 3= > CO
59
have slightly different principal dimensions yet remain
with LBP equal to 300 feet , one with LBP equal to 500 feet
one with LBP equal to 700 feet , and a fourth design using
to 300 feet. All cases were run with DISPFL as the objec-
demonstrated.
60
LO CM CO O o CD CM LO rH 05
- CO l> o LO 00 CO o lO O CD CO
E- "Hi • • • • • • • • rH • •
ft 05 ^ CO CO o o CO 05 00 LO LO rM
O CO 05 <H< rH CM CO rH rH
CO
m H 05 CO LO CM O 05 CD LO
- <tf -* m LO o rH CO O CO CD CO
Eh o • • • • • • • • CM • •
ft o ^ CM CO o o CO 05 05 LO lO rH
O c 05 <* H CM CO H r^
CO
o 00 oo 05 to -HH o 00 LO O
E->
- o 1— lO LO o tH o oo CD CO r-t
i—lo • • • • • • • •
CD • •
S o o o ^ c c CO C5 LO L^ CM «#
h- t> o l> CM CM 05 rH
d t>
P
a
Q -
CO rH rH o LO o CO o CM 05
LO CM co LO t> rH r-(. CD CM LO CO
SH gH o • • • • • • • • i-{ • •
M Oh o <tf CO CO o o CO 05 00 lO LO rH
1— o LO 05 "tf H CM CO T-\ rH
> CO
-P
w •H
J r- o CO CD 05 LO <# O o LO rH
33 •H Eh - o H LO lO o rH O oo 05 00 CD
<C £2 )— o • • • • • • • • 05 • •
Eh cd 5H5 o o LO t> o o CO 05 00 00 co X
P t— to o LO H CM <tf rH
csj m
CD
a
CD CJ5 CO "* o t> CO CD CD CM 05
03 - CO o LO LO I-
s
CO t> LO rH CD CO
Eh o • « • • • • • • rH • •
ft o ^ LO CO o o CO 00 oo LO LO l-{
O co 05
CO
"HI rH CM CO rH rH
o oo CO 05 LO <tf c- CD o CD
Eh - o o LO lO o tH o O LO "HH 05
i— o l
• • • • • • • •
CD • •
z o o CO o o o CO 05 ^ 00 CO CO
1— CO o CO H CO CM rH rH
CO
03
W 1
CO
E- 1
3 2
fa J W O
s Eh Ph Q Eh
<c s fc m ft ->>.
03 ft < <c CO 3 CO Q ft
<c CO m 03 ft X --«» ^, CO h-1
J a
ft J 03 Q u u CO J > Q Ph CO
61
philosophy. The ability to be able to make such alterations
i.e. ft 3
/man. Current designs have shown an increasingly
lbs/ft 3
and are therefore a measure of how dense the ship
62
cannot be blindly applied to a problem and the results
other designs.
which the designer may scrutinize and use for future design
B. SENSITIVITY STUDIES
63
helpful in determining the design variables and objective
reduced further by making the LBP less than 394 feet , this
design while the steam and diesel plants are all comparable.
64
SENSITIVITY RNRLYSIS
DISPLACEMENT VS LBP
65
TABLE VIII
66
COPES /CONMIN is capable of performing optimum sensitivity
67
VII. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS .
are critical in each case and has the ability to alter those
68
for changes in design standards and philosophies as well as
to cost."
tive to this area and in some cases the designs are driven
69
A final possibility in the graphics area would be to
maintenance action.
70
LIST OF REFERENCES
Massachusetts, 1971.
—
Designs FDL LHA, DD-963:
, Method and Selected
Features," Transactions SNAME Vol. 79, 1971, pp. 297-
,
365.
755.
Murman Earl M.
, "Application of Numerical Optimization
,
71
11. Zoutendijik, G. Methods of Feasible Directions
, ,
174-202.
—
Preliminary Design An Optimization Problem With
Constraints, Transactions SNAME Vol. 78, 1970, pp.
,
357-380.
73
APPENDIX A
DESIGN EXAMPLE
o
o
111
<jj
a.
- I
O i/> </"></>t/ll/) 13
O <s> 10 </i u. O
X </5 </> </» u. —
O to </» to i/l
</l </> i/J
</!/'</> «/) r*- Z
mm | Q
Ul
K
LOWOI/V/J CO
Ul
O
Ik Z
< U. 13
X Ul
O Ul Ul
III Z to
ui ui < I O
at uj
Ul Ul
uj o o
9 Ul
Ul
Ui
Ul
Ul
Ul
tc H- z
t/| Ul Ul Ul O Z -> X
O IMUMUUIIMlHll
UIUJUIUIUIUIUI >l
</> <
a. o
a > uj
Ul z
O LU —
0.0,0.0.
a. a.
at
a. <X
to Ul
_l
X
ot»-
is
<
x
x
—
_j ui — oooootn^
a. a <<
- ZQ »» UJ « « « O 7"
a. a. O 13 oc o
o
oi
—
>r • •
a. 0.
z
_^ a o -3
a. a. -1 u. m* X-i
a. a, o> 0-0.0.0. -a u.
O •"" K — a: a
UJI-
ex at a.Z z •
coaocuo
a ^ O.U o
— o o
o-o
i_ Ul J cm \r\f\ m • <J <j <J u« <-< rg
3 a
O O u. <»-co • o o cuj u.0.0 •co «x • am or»ti>
a. O O z
Z Hi
Ul uu.
UU. *x <J - im o -uoo-vCf^-^ r~ia.a> • xtJ*
5 U
w O
U O
a z
Z z C
c
Z_<yi
i£c-JS£
Ui—O *<J
» ^O
O •
b£ •
<_>-<
'•C.Jf-O-J •
-m
"DO o iOU -Oi£
cm • <J O U
O JOOUUUO
'JOOUUUO U«/> UX.U <~>— Ul• OIO<->
i_i
— -1" » u
U>
u.
u.
Oo
<-)
u
VJ
u
t_l
W
z
Ul
— UJ
«
l-O
MX
1
X
— UJ
11 1
a
— — _j
cci-earn
a
*»o*'M
-
u
as
"
_j •
«•«*!
-
w
33
«»o
•
.
•
.
O
-J •
or
«»0
-J
—
.
13
<*««m
•
'->
o
o
»
•
«»r-
u
•
•
«»im
>-»
m
•
wtO
«>J
r—
«o
•
cum
»»
«*-«
-o
u vj l-CX
a.1
uuuuuuu au u
74
O
o
o
o UJ
U.O -1
-^ -» z <
o a
+
JJ o
i/>ooooo
Ui •Ml • • • • •
a i *1
o 1
Z "J ooooo
—o aUJ
X SO ao •
QJ
•
© a z
<ir> oo ao <o K
3
_1 i a.
o M^OOCOO _j Z
o O• 1 H -j -5 mo. 1
z — SO <UJ
u o Ml 3 G »* lUx i3
vO r- z zo o Of- -J
» 9 H II It II a i- 3^-
UJ
t-
19
lb 0>>atX»-0
It
M
H-
-1
13
M<
1
UJ
o
oz>ooooo
o—
< u. jir.!/n<iu. ~ao 4 <I o X X oooco
3 <Z2>iac fsl U. o < <
a z o (Mrfza. ~* UJ X o - X UJ
<
ee
o o z zxa>-
Zi-.
X a a.
mix l-O H-
(M UJO 0.0
X •
o
mm
UI -J • •
o o z » O >Z —Z — OO l-O <o at (ONnOO
ooooo
»-
t/»
o
-*
</> •
UJ -UJ
<
a z
ii
i-X
i
».
1
at
1
+* +•
a
a.
VI OHO
OJUJ<
i/i a u
'XI \Sl
2
_i
UJ
>atoooooo
UJUJUJUJUJ
< o
• —
—
i— >»
•«/!- -«
n i
•
1/1
>-z UJV
a
i
o
u.
JJ
ajuj
X.
mm
x*
a
X u.
oO• «»
OO• ^- 330 ao
X
a:3
u
III ••^uiMvma _l JOJ-JZUJ
<-' — aiujh-
x:> Ml zo u • U.O.
U-O oo uo iSS*
i"-ihOO
OOOOO
K >/)CJCJ>«SJI. u <—• o»*» u
a. oro- o*-Z -— at Zl- — •H/)<t Zl- V) 1— *-• •*» ++
k m * in •4 r^oin o,k-i-— '•'jui 1— <«* ^- — z z <1 J- o II HI 1I1HI IIU
3- X M r» -<-i^ LL. t-z<i—i-o— 20 h# l-atX a UJO aj IU41UOOOUO
Kit O UJOQJ^Ioath-O o«ilu— '-OX *-• _uj <— OI-*UJ itooooo
K * * -U^
OO TOO^ZO-<JO 0~ OX — >TTO h- OJ
— UJ X a>-i -300000
3 <_> o z •4 -Jujr:a.a. <: — i/» | •a. < <1 i «* "»—.CJ Cooooui
U o uu>
~uv
Ui
_f— —
••_> o u.2Cviu.<<tl- «i<l.<t(— ^0>-0. INI *-• 1 3.0 •— <; o OJ r- iMiri p- i«i
md Ml •*o w»- UMI JJJ>M Um "* i'J. j- ^» a.i-i « • • * •
r» » J- Q m »• ma t—
• i 0.1— U u-u_^.*— — JtuiC i/l^-O^ X *i-u < Ml «* ooooo
• • • " z < i-COOCZcc 1— Ml >"- a. >o
(d "\ -r U\ <»•— <*e- 1¥»Ui l*J _i< — a. < - -— z at
u- #•*• C-iata.*at _l a. -JO. 2Z - 3 ZUI
u.
— » > ^* M — -'— 1— — I— — ^ U-'X a. ^u'ujujuji^o 3UJ o <"- >-»
z J. u. 'js» «
^- —II p-o a. a. aia! o :3 OO xn
a. «*4ji*r-ajajo*00»-*rursimn»*ru* -*- Z-J2.za.za.aj -j_j •-if\jnisrin«u * _— 2 UI • h- • JU • v)^; •f-ir\i(n*ru%
a NAMWINNM n fOmr«in\n>o»nini -a. i
U43J332UJ <l«l —3 a u> U.U oa oo UJO •
t-a u^zz<u»a o.» * ox o •— QZOil
75
o
o
UJ
o
<
a.
:X..
3
X
OTO
U1Z
X =
OlO 3TO
3oO OO O OO 33 oooom o o
00000000000000000-.0000000
303
it-
uj3ac
-I
§ 2
— <o
-o UU OS
UUUUU3
t-l— z Jt- H-O Q.I—
C"J~aiii>u) KIUJ
<oco •-o 1-t.
«t-o
u«u<a
< *t
ex
h-
3" t- O *ia:i-i:
HI-OSJ <->
ISO
-•«
JUH 2TO V>v)
Ouj<a.V7»-
-J VI
_|0L
SD
^ ^oo>i zz
a.»- ji-ut-i- -J 1/7 1/)
_IQ.V1 IL
xx _x << 33 r MXUJ<u*/iaa. 33«f UJ t-
-
at o i_)OU-t-XO XVI o C£>ICu.ai xv) a. X
O xc 3
X o
o z
X 0*-"1 z — o
•-
— •—Z >
l_)
(J UJ3CM O O OO O O O OO o
go t-o ~ OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOrOOOOOOOOOO so. x->- a
ZUI t- c
—X < Jt- o <
-jZVXjj u
< aeoo OOuj — 3
3 XJZO v> IU>-Ui >• Z
O
<
(3
z ooooo
-**u ! » « I30
OCh
at
xi 30 O
<
X o
X » -j(0-« 1- - O UJ
O
>-
XXUJUJUJUJUJ
joooooa •
o «*
f
UJ Z 0- aa.ooozz_(KOts xco 0.0C030.
>J<S- —
_i
>t
>
V) il-OOOUQ 1 h-^-jtO UJV>aL< t— •— t— _Jt— (—
o
a.
-uooaoo
h<OOODO x
a.
OUJ»-l-l— —xtl-2: Vi UJ</>
1-Q. t-
o
LJ
_i 3 . . • . •
X UJUJ
Wl5r333333jti_j
»»>»-*.<_) <Z
uji-i
U.OZ4 X (-
lOCMtll VI 3
</)Qt
< X ooooo -< o viuiZZZZZ^^^uj Xu. </)Q»llX
> lilUJQO '.U
<
z
v>z«- r
« o
<
03
<o >
jo
•
z Z
>-_» •«
X
04
a
-IO
—o
OOOS^O'IAOOOQ
0000 OOOO B—
0<-"*r>r-OUO«OOtJ OOOOO ooooo xao
ruuiuj
X
X
t-
z
<z a m i— - <o 30.0. 'J CI
< a *o>«r -a3cr — <_,<%! v> (/i >Hi-« OOOOU'mOOO<WOOOf«'<N'H OOOOOQO 1— V)V>
O fc
t—
<
X «J A
u
< vjljO
1UJUJ
mi
_>a r-<-u • U' <* aAfn <j <-l
t- w»
o< .J»
X
a.
«oao
~_ U «3 «* Z 1
Oil >
3 UJ a JO> u. -j a uj
— — CNJOQ
_UJ UJ
& — j.u u <aj t—
z —'— — g <HO£ H> VI*- -OCQ.T'«*C0a3 t-ao. —r -^
5 < X UJ
—
xi_r*j_. _i>- j- X U3
a — • < UJ iumi ii-t- X UJ^t >
«.» • r- tu »l^ UJ «l UJ V'UU'^j.uj JL.J* ^- ^* j- r-
^ oxNm*«i «-
" uiuacr- i. Z x a. */>oo a. Jotujmai-u.ah-Hitui - -j — V'U. Z
> «z ac-i< Z> •— UJ — 3ZZQ.OI Qlfl OU.OCO-Z«T QUJLU 1— —4 o
J a < <o> Z 1- X irtui<iovNa.x x33333otXuta.uiujujuO I«I X OX
u. z at
— V) V) ^</>zzz2Q'Vi^a.ojiiiii.a. XV) UJ ZV1
a.
>-
3 v»
HI
IX
—
«l
JJ l-
_;»*
IX io .£ uj a— r- •» OUT
u uj o*-*<M<^<rtn u - "« U z
O — o t- >—
76
J-
o
o
_ «o *-—«
#**«* ##•
,-. a-
into
*
QO
» u.
z
* »
lAt/iQQOjjun
z-j_jZzaca.o.a.
zzjj-oooiihlo«wju);o —1
* <
>• c£i'>>-(r'</irj"»»«>«'-".r' a) i^-Z *»•:>* 00 mo
OCL<Uja.<uj0.032fnoo<3<t Z-^g.-* > z •» zo
«jt/» a. a. o o. (X O •— s: t- 1— t— X x uj 1 ~ a. a. z
#
a K
a * <
T *g or
U m eg o **• tf\ eg <Dr-m 0030*0^^-00 eg o o * *
Oe-0mgjc0>n>reg^<eo«o»"'-"^0000©0000 oe E o-o -ro
* 3 * z Zin
<*Nmo«fOoOOoO
iftg30 co *-<r'e~tf-a'tr»c/'Ov <D— u.z
gjgjOO"4 eg'4JegcOPjaoegmv~*pgu3
,
o * *
cx> cr cc CDpg^*»»4pgrg «<>»-i«4J.-*p» o 2: r X
eg^* cL^nj— ^- #-• » « *
ero-4" M QC z uu
gft-im * »
a: u l»l e-10
OO.V1 JI33IOQOZZ«jhO <t
z
ce t- »
z
l/l
z
Zlft
ji/10t3"-*egro^ifi43r-H._if- i;^unrti/iOO^ ^ a.
« ^ * u
0<CXQ.O-CLO.Ci.ai— XV^L0_jq£Q(_|».^»— —.<l—
Q.u.jiacatotiacocjt —<-r_izxo</>ocx/> »
O Z a.
3
»
MM
oooooooo<->oooo 00000 00
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
— — — ~- _« _,— *-. _ojiN4rg
• 1
•A
O
00
a> -«: a.a.
or aces
a-CJK-uja.
=>
j.
1-1
lu
7"
«l
1 >ui
a-
u-n»
r— '—'U. U.U4 VJUJWltfJ *-.._'*. u*. ^_ wt "«* Ul >—
lu. ao> x. mo tncuj<j^-viLu £. a. z ^^
uo -r a<i<o.-ieg<z i30mIoZviQ3Zvi
00 cciua. iuaxuussx<t;Zuiuj>3iij; < -1
-
o -OOOCCO-uo»Jcaa;a;wuj>>g;iii^ 1 -1
- x «i CO
t/l r- w
^ .c ulo ^<-l
U u —
u» •-»
O -J
77
in
<J
o
ui
o
<
a.
—<M
oo
lulu LULU
-co CPO
ir>« p-o
oo mO
0>O
—
oo
PJ—
• •
?? oo
1 1
2
o o o—
oo
Z o
o
»«—
oo
o o 5 +
UL) UJ uu aiui S3 LU LULU
o o o p-ui o Oin
o o o
— — at ru op-
o o p-rvi LU
3
vr> a>f)
Of
n
p-
o U>
p»
P-«M
r>--j" a <M
ir\
p- p-*f
a*
-i • •
o•
• • • • • •
o o o OO o OO
oi — o vi t 1
O o — o* — o
Z z* o O o Hi 1 p
oo
III*
OO
.
1
P-X> "— o o o o — !-
a mo io O
*
OO
+ — x
< VI
—1 o o -X o o
+
oo
zee a. +
—
-vo
aeo xO
-.LU — UJ LULU
—{Oqv < i— OO Ul LU LU — Ul
— LUUI
(vj
O
—
O O «0 -J.O LU
Z
z
3
aeo
oo a£p-a> —
Of
I-Z
VI O of "O
—O <
•
—o •«
•»
(M
-o
at ao
OO ae<MO»
4.J.
o
_
o
V)
—
om om
luo
„
ujo
lu
a
*£
» O
—m o
->o
—•«—€>«
aoa
I Ul
ao
i —
LU
> 4«
O
3 r— oi/i
l-CC
><x
—
h-vi
Ulr-
—O
—
-
at i
VI.— < •
—
i
* wm
- —O a'O « a* vio
LU
j:
1
(9
1
ooo
1
3+ O* -4 LU VI***.
LU-P z lj »a oui .*
ui * vi UJ LU-P !/:•*•»
LU LU ^ *Tk -.UJ UJUJLULU < ^>UI <_i U1U< Z ZLU <X r- _UJ LULL. LULU
ZO ZO v) u
—j'o aao sinoco z aim a -to < ao -j x r» 03 0> Xnfiaoau
o O mx«4 —«
ii
— — o o —
— i/io vio Z p-o
o CD
—o
atO
-SMPUOO
JrgLn*-"
m
i—
3
Z
—
at
H-Q
oo <t
a.
O
r"
uO Zui
uo.
-J
<
^J
n ato
f . i ^C^aDr^
>omcu
<*i o o* o am or— <
l^*A«UL «t <m•
r\j •o»»»< * < «<FH uj— m — —-<«-^ ««m
f -, > «j» p* * • • at i-<^ > Lb • t— at • o • ^ • p* • •
-"_i
Ul «Ui LU3Q SO — a. O O ZOOO uj uj luZ lu o Z —o ^V) LU o O ZOOO
o »-o xo a 3 vi z -> i >— at at»» atZ u. -* O uj ^- z —1 1
o luo
xo oo
oo
33 ao z -J a
—
< «- < ««< <0 u. < Xo <-j
— o <
h-o a <
m u vi u. — O at X <t
Qm X<
OO — o lwc at a. o >— 2
—
Ul
at atv>
at,
jj>-_< ajiyi^
at>~
| l—
j»»» vi of"
<_>
p* o
O J — ") o»« z**r-t*\ i
o
i
•
o
•
oo -
• Jt"
-i
a.*"
a.
xi
—
<
Zulu u —
— a q o
L9
UJ
as
UJ
X XO
—
UIZ
i-o
UIO
XUI
KO
3
cl
O LU ZZ —
o vi o— O
(j»-*
• 2T^-r*-f»i
78
ID
o
— <M
oo °°
**
UJUJ UJUJ
xio
-.0
r-O
00
mo
00
-TO
U»0
•->~4 —
• • * •
OO OO
1 1 1 1
o *4«-4 O —.—
O o OO O O
+
OO*
I I
U> UJUJ ui UJUJ
— m-o — H4
m -om c»
m
-or-
m •rr-
in
.or-
cj<j»
in (\IO>
f- a-<r r- 0^
• • • • • •
o 00 O 00
1 1 1 1
o —— -*—
o 00 3 (M 00
+ -
XXI
O UJUJ
Ul XI UJ
0" 00 3»
1
UJ 00
— •r^
m «-ia> O
— O ©<NJ
-o <\iir\ O •0 (M.O
CT> m>o 0" m-o
m (M>0 m NJ)
X — •
O
bi 1 4 I <
ff* UJ
0»
X in X
Ul a. o> a.
V- + -j rx _.
< _ !»> < 0- <
3 m OJ (\J i/> m
O :— M» — O I- — in m o
< Z
— (J • UJ
— w
z — • u>
at wt < 1/1 4 O i/»
13 h» < z ••<
O < Z <* a
h-
v>
(A
h-
z at
H- — (M
a.
a
at
— 3 — a.
O Z < O o OO z
— < O o 00
Z —O
VIu X \ft
a. «• at * 1 X at +*
4 K a UJ UJ —.1X1 UJUJ O -*UJ UJIXJ
1 IX </» »o 1 r— atO -Din <S) nj
4 (M ^- z —0 — IM ~» <ti 1- z — -—r Of- aemnj
> a UJ —0 4 at-r O I— -< OJIM «i o ui «• < at^f 1— Oiniv
i/l
z w a —o 1- a-o 00 t--ro Z o O — v- om + WO 1-vfO
O »• <-< uj »-<j» at — uj03 orom O — «* xi h-<M UJ UJ03 wrou^
w o t/i h- • 03 w • O • > • uj •
>oo
• O
J ujuj Ul»— 03o* ——
-^ >
o >oo
• UJ • ,
xO
at ujuj ujo ujo lid at uj ujo 1
uj UJ —a. uj X • > wm 1
III uj — gc
uj uj X • > win
'
Ill
X.
> << (£1 > «l< in * —
o o (O o
ca ~> :— Lt^J f «. 03 > — «"1- at
X — — — -~~* UJ < • 3
l/?»-4 (*1 — —— X — _ — UJ
I
UJUJUJUJ
+
2 a] xo < OO -in I D 2 a} KO 4 OO -III o ai^- 3r-<Njin
O O ruX o OO at — 4 a. «ICO _J«MOi-" -j O —5" O UO at — T 4 n ^-vf — ^jtno
— 3 i-O 4 h-o Zuj _J o —in «fOoo-r -• 3 h-O 4 l-O 2UJ ^m —«o 4fnmr*-
1- z wo a. 00 ua <t •o cto" >o-rO - 2 uO a. wo Qa •o
m 4<n
ato >m~r~r
4 1~* UJ*-
X
—a Q
V(_j ^ • ^ • • •
4
x
4"-" uj»k »»o
'•—
a**^ "-
> • p- • • •
Ot
uj
—
uj
at
iuz~*
at»->
P-f>
uj
at
IX t
— o uj
u.
.—
o 2 — o .£1/1
.
ai
-
O
•
2
O ZOOO
— I
ui
I—
tu
at
UJ2
at»-
r—
uj
at O
u. •
u.uj
02—
p— at
"-o
•
Z1/1
.
o
•
o 2000
z — 1 1
4 44
1
"• 4 < —
u. X-; < a «< — 4 *ttt4 4 U.X-J
—4 a
— at4
at a a- — «*
Q~ -J »- at ol o at X —
2 Ul uj>-«< uj 1t- w 3 in 1- 2
— uj xi-— uj I— w 1 C:— 'I SI
»« at kti/i at X"* 1^ at^
^1— z <— jj—
*- 1 o II
at at</> at X— «» *"•
4*^ x —
1— I
79
Onj OM
oo
+ * ??
OJUJ UlUi
OO OO
oo
oo oo
Oo
oo oo
-»*— *->
• • • •
OO oo
1 1
1 1
o o oo o o oo
i
UJ—
4> 3 I
at
4>4>
a-ai
UJ UJ J_
9> in om u-l m (MCO
o «r "•t at m <n ."Wl
o» mo» UJ cr CO
.Tl m mcy m —a*
m r~ m* a r- m^r
• • • •
O
•
OO• 1
o oo
1 1
1
O —4— 31 o —*—
o» oo O -• o oo
4> 4> o I
UJ
O + *4>
JJUJ
UJ UJUI I
JJ
o T<B T UJ o <\J«\J
o fO-4 o o-j-
o -rr- m m o -j-m
o O-o o o<o
in IM4 m MO
• •
o oo oo
1 1
i w — 1 — —4—4
oo
oo v»
o
i t o
+
jjuj O o UJ X UJ UJOI
0«(n Z o to
— o. 0> jrr-
mru 3 -J (*» co oo
a UJ
m
co
<
< CO
—
—4—4
r-o
v>a>
<X >- A a <M a m mir
< — <
• • Zae
— UJ O r- • Ul •
OO
•
X "1 oo v» <
z»
o» O ir O
1— < a I I
1— <a. 0< a 1 1
I- VI Z a: a. v» Z XQ. • a.
vj t— «- I-
i— ~i O O a o t- -* »-3 — o —4 u —4 —* —4—4
a Z < VI o a. 3 Z < V) —H o ae o o OO
I Z x » X z< X 1 * *
«« i— a UJ UJ < r- jO
1
UJ
m
UJ —
X—
UJ UJUJ
o
ae vi -> m CD oc V) u p a
* —
•r .
4f r- z — IT) -* 04 aer-m f— Z X M
4 xo
—s«» a— acmi
Omci
i/> a UJ ato> o <M *-m C<MO oO a ujui •^ o IM >--»
KOO
B
o Q o*
1— UJ
O
p*
or\j
UJCO
»-—
orum
rr
a
o ox
—
MJ
<
i—
UJ
oo
H-fO UJ
JJ
"4.
OCU
UJCO otMin
vj o VI o •
UJO
>r
o
• >
o
• u , . i_> a v>_i 1— 03 1_>
UJO
• m • > o• UJ • •
>oo
J. UJ UJ x-« 1 >o<-> .jj UJ X<M 3 1
JJ
so
4.
X
ujx
™4
1—
< —>
-J
UJ >
1
u"»-4 < •
X
•w
m (9
1
— O-tO
1 1 UJ
-^ -j
>—
> < >«I
ibi- z
I-
W
»
a.
UJ
>
1
u?-«
VJP-
tXCM
< •
^f
u
X
— o
m — 0»4«\j
i i
ooo
i
X
Z o«
1— «/> a
— h* — UJO II V>v-I ouo h- a l-V) i— — UJO II J> vio
u VI UJ V> 1 UJ » K0+ » + o ,M UUJ • jj ^ VI 1
» UJ jj * SI 4. 4. 1
«Ui 9
3» «» ^UJ
1
•a — LU UJUJUJUJ « > *_l VI i ZUJ r- — UJ UJUJUJUJ
Z — ai a-u Ci(\t -. '1 X cum 3K1-0 a> X < ao -J II X JJ COM3 xm-4-o
u X o o u— — <t 3. *3 _ _j^)(»-00 O O -«< a X < — CM X m •J. -.or- in
— p I— Km ZUJ — ~<7- <ti\itn.o MM t- < — o ZUJ
-J —4 — - 45T'OUMn
3 1- z _>o winox 1 U5.C- ><riorn CC o -O ox *a
X m <OI
XO> >mOfH
O <
x 1—
<—>
J. •
ujm
X
"-«_>
• >»—j u
<ll«l
;» • h«
rnrum
• • •
<
->
«o
u. • *-
UJ— -.(_)
X • VI— — • -» •
r-i —
KMCSI
r- • • •
jj uiz XI III <j — zv> UJ o zooo III JJ uu o z — 4-V) JJ 3 o Z<JOO
H at*- X X u. a UJ H- z — 1 1 1 oe X XZ u. Mi O UJ — 1 Z — 1 1
"* < < u. I — «x o < < < «»o UL < r-i < X 4
— UJ JJ a z — < — a at z — J — X
Z jji- u a>— 3 r— UJ UJ uuoi-jj- h- u o— v> H
X — VI X—
l/»
— i
x— X—
i -J
—•—
II
o UJ4- UJ JJ -i —
—• iVJ Ub X 1 1— '— J. X 1
1— 1 (-1 VI Hi —
1
-a.-. UJh— — u*»^ *£iNr»m UJ UJ ujo v»— z 4-4 UJ-" — "1 ijf-»
• Z~j r-m
UJ IU X >-X. 3 UJ -- <l r X -UJ X a UJ zz < JJ UJ U -4
jj l-<J t— - VI 0«— '-I - t- l-O X V)
<_>o-- o a (-1 u
80
o
•*
OIM ©CM
oo OO+
lulu Xi LU
oo OO
00
OO
oo OO
00
oo
*—• •*—
• •
•
oo 00
—
1 1 1
1
o cm f ll
00
1
3 o Oo o ¥*
a UuLU
+ I
Ui :
UJ
a—
;
(M fO ~ro
m >i-.<5 m in-f
in muj •o m IM-O
-0 — o« •J- -0 — o>
a (M r- fTl^ •o r- rrfr
• •
o
•
OO a 00•
1 1 1 1
•a o «*— —•—
o
i
-.
o
o oo
- * 3
00*
+•
ui l ui LULU I Ui UIUI
** UJ o fHLft UJ CM CI
•r cm o enn d «\<T
— m o om om
a <a o <s-o D-O
<M IM -n —•o in —~
• • • • • •
O oo OO
1 1 1 1
- o 1 «-4 !
o < oo
**
o ««
O
*
00 1
i/» </l 1
O — UJ X LUUi a O UJ X Ui UiUi
o a. or- z o o a.
—
^- om
§ 1 o<o 3 <M ca Oca
o Ui CM «( o-« o Ui m < r— o-«
3 woco co m OO </»ao en IM CM o>o
O - MM m <s o C«m m cn<n
Zae o o LU • •
OO• •
IX <SI — Ul < m o 1/7 oo• </»
-
•—ui < o o O
ID t- <Q. z« IM o <Q. Z 0»
Z z
1 1
xo.
—•
</> • a. tft eca. •
- — *--3 •* o "• o >- -• »-3 o -<
O 2 <s> u o < v>
Z or f O
— X zat — — zee — 1
h- ao ui — Ui — luui Ui < 1- ao ui
ceo — o> CO
si u » i o era .<«r~ f- u1/1 * • ^4 <J
# ^
at
z ac ~ — IM CO otOro ,-n f» •— SJ ex «» — U3 oo cemm
in O uiui *• < ato o IM 1— a-"*» 1^ XI UJ -* < aeo cr -f"- aocn
o ox — - oo •o om h-*MO r Q2 •«> w Cl~-
— om hMO
O —5 -ao UJ !--• Ui u.a _— .TV u~\
3 —a 4 UJ --« Ui XI CO _;—.ui
u ui O </>-j — a. _>o •> • LU • • • yi_i K a • •a • > • LU . •
at ui ojo luo X«M o o >oo QL UI XI LLIO xr- >CJO
x
1 1
ui
ca
X
XICX
""
I-
<
j
x —
XIH-
—
x
— x
ui
•
- >
>/>—
or-
cein
4
i + w
o*
X
fO
C9
^»0' N •
1 1 1
I
u XI
a > -t >«*
X — -J Ml
^* LUh- X
1-
*«
X
•
XI
>
1
UI — <
oor
cccm
•
~r
X
•M
CO
O
1
— O—l
1 1
3 »-«*
Z O0S.
U
m
Ki/1
•O I—Ui — xiO LOO OOO II -j f— -V)'_! 1— —O XlO 11 > LOO •JO
+ 2 * LU X
mmX
UUI LU tu «/> + pM 0111 » XI UI ai l/l*
4UJ > «_i villiX «;lu
I IS) 1
< ^ «l — vt I «-LU 4
1
^r — LU *jf
81
oo
UJUJ
oo
oo
oo
oo
r"• •
oo
i i
o
o
o
o
—
oo
* z
* * 3
UJ UJUJ
•«• cin
m
—4
c-r ce
~j r~«o UJ
r>- oo>
o r^ <N<J"
• • •
o oo
i t
o —.—
S - o oo*
u o
UJ
+
UJUJ
I
111 u m<o
3 o m**
o coirv i/i </>
o 44 UJ UJ
m •^•O x. z
=1 • v •
o OO
I 1 1
O j
a o oo*
* < + 4-
a UJ z UJ UJUJ UJ UJUJ a u.
co a. •o a*o <o 0»O z CD
•r
— _i o i~«o -o r~co o <
a < (M
m
= —• <VJ
m
ODi-4
CO c O
I/1C0 tM o«o wo CO
>— r- a <n mirt h- z
Zee • LLi • • • • • Zee «x
.1—
— <a
«JJ < ~r o o oo O oo o
Z — o i i 1 1 1— <a. >^- UJ
i/j Z jlo.
— a.
Ox v> z ceo. I—
HO -4 o m* o — x >•* 0-« H- — l-O v> a a
o Z
S
< -1
—* o ce o o oo O oo Z < vt >>1 O 'jj
a. a zoe * o. + + ^* ce Zee UJ _ »-
< i- oo uj UJ — UJ UJUJ 2 — UJ — —U.LU < i- ao -J < <t
ae vt u ce — io cei>- —-««\j a
— ccr» .rg ce i/i i_> o >
at- z — O— aeeom Cx z m — UJ
ce
v»
SO
w uj
O
o
uj
ujuj
OS
—o
-sis
—•
—
t— •
ujo
< ceo
1- OO
«to UJ I— —
ca <j •
ujo x— o
UJ <M
> • uj • •
o >oo
t— -o
or-
ujco
c-ort
h-o>o
uom
H
<
X
i
a
t-4
ON
ujco
> •
O >oo
acODin
O-orn
t-o>o
o<ou>
UJ • •
H-
1/1
z
u
O UJ
o
-J
o
UJ
UJUJ
Out
—a
^>_
ce
«M
-*
--
u
<
2 UJ
X
i/i
UJ
-I
X x X
i 1
z— i^ <
1
o—
m O
SB < —»• ce i j-
— o— z o* «* < >«f i 1/1
X. "~ -J "" UJ </>-< < • u <"J •• ro — O^fM •—• ^ —4 ~-J z s:
_j i— </» u h-</> o »— — uio + </JO 3UO LOO uuu 1— V5 a l-VJ O.UJ z — -) i_i
Z uu
II
<
EC
t—
u 2
J
— 3 — l-O < l-INJ UJ _l -J — -1" <*UMJ^O •« ^ «»u>^o 3 — l_j-» :ij z 3
>- 2 ce "->o CV OvT 6 <xc> >irvco«r ^J m oeo^ >\1\<B*T 2 ce ") 3 _
« «t <<-» — ^m• -im<j -^ -n <tn '^t^fO < zca -* u.
IK »" 3» u. • i— a.
—o
• ^ h* • • • a. • i> • f— • • • p— -> UU •—
ui «<; uj uj «j z o zooo — O o ZOOCJ ujz UJ UJ —.~~ u.UJ Z
•- oei-> ce aez u. — a Z — H z -•III oe»- ce cez h-vl > —
O -^
— <•< < <o u. < 3T J a <
I I I
W
— J a— n i—
t/> ait— UJ lUV-f jj '_i ^
»• u.v>— x fit*— X*~ at— «j UL V1^4 ce ce>-> 2. XJ JJ l/l
o UJZ uj two
I
n— z <i — «t -» <J«* Z»WI UJZ UJ Ull_)
i
ce a. -1 3
u UJ IU £ — uj - u uj zz UJ u P4 U -« ZO z XUJ
as h-o - —a i u i/i o— O l-O l- l-O I- z o
UJ
82
o
o
UJ
o
UJ
hwm»«oo sc
ooooo
*• + SO <
+
o uj uj uj u. uj
ac oo o oo «0 OOOOlfl o o 30J
U'ZOOOOO
&330000 ooooooo ooooo ooooo— ooooo oo Zt-
—1~ l/l
lOOOOOO H<000«>OOOOhNOOOOQOOOOWOON a.
3
<-_ia </)
• • • • • </><a
ooooo a
aCZ
iu3 uo ua »-*- Z -Jh- >-0 CL»-
• •
ooooo • • • — CO — —
ooooooo oooo.
cooot
C
o oo o o o oo o
III I I * - * I - •»•**•*. ooooooo ooooo ooomooooooooo O
3JUJ UJUJ LL.UI UJUJ aiLuu^uu 1— a
m^«-.oo
^[t"*c*jg*ii^— o«—
<i irv co r* o> m o
p~ u^cc ~r>r CJU1
ao _—
IflOOOOin^O'fOOCOOOOOOOlMftjOOO*
— o -jZi/Iuj
u <
ooooo* ^U^-OCC^U^O"* OCT o oouj— i -j 3
oooo- X^>"UlI > 8
ceOujuiuju'uJ
UlZOOOOO • •••••• a.
xxooooo ooooooo oooo OO
ccooooo
jffloooom
I I 1 I I I laooozZji-tJu
>.>-</ji*ovioO*' > ,
ao3 cattoa
3-_l«J>
_i
<
>
ct
t—f-M ujl/JZ.< 1_J _!(—•—
f-_l|-t-
»— —
-^
O
i
• • •
oouuo • • O -O O "O *0 "O *o >o ^ -o >o "0 ^ Cuji-.(-^—«»i-3:
h-O.
UJt/1
»—
o
UJ
o UJUJ 'V^^O U.OZ< i 1—
z
3
CCTZUJUJUJUJUJUJUJU'UIUJUJUJUJ
UJ300C OOOO OOOOOO
^I33333JJIj IX
Ill-UJ
W1CLU.X
'S> 1
3tao OOOOO OOOOOOO
•J 9 CCCOOOOOCOOOOOOO
o •
ooo>>onor-oooo oooo
o a omr-mu-if- ooooooo oooooo oooo
a—
(VJUJUJ
QD
0-
o.
at;
oooo ooooo oooo CO mOOOOOOOON'4 'M'"0 oooooo
3CLQ. o
> ( I I t I I I I I I I — OOCf
iMOU< rory o
— ^oun
vioa -1
lf>«M o « UJUJ u
-I- o ozz >
l-Z
Ul_> cu •^-aoCT'O—cjm^rm^oi^cpc cc
z»- m > o^cjm^rin
• X O C£ P* h* r* CO CO CO CO CD CO aD CO GO 03 3C i- </>»- >-or;Q.T«iaico a.
31- <
— >- -J« -J ja_Li/iu.j>a-iijj </>
a.
«s
Ul
l/>
*.
u> z a.I"«»o*i-^f-aLC i.ox CL(-|-
UJO <
>
a l/IQO a cqoluj>/ic>.i— o-Q.1— •iiui.
o 3zza.oi Qt/1 OU.CCQ.Z4 Oujuj
ts>iu<t on^. v. q. x at 3 3 3 3 3 cc X of a. lb uj uj <_; <_> a- i/ix
Z Z >>cc_joao<-< a.bozzziiat^a.a.o.-'cua.a. Ok.i/)UJ
U4
UJCD
3 o~<<\i<n«j-<rv •J —•^r>j«i>i"iri^jr--co(3x o«-<<M«'i
cu_i
ao
83
vu.
»— c rvj^j-in^rcrmr- <j-raor
W3CM r-corummccco —4f— <\j»
V>0 • •••••«• *••
Z^.co m.j-coo^r^o
—
oo*
<t,
*x
Uji/j —4< n*!»
<M04—j**-—4o<\jcooocDCO<\jmr-in*4'Ctnm
»0O4-iO'*(\iCMu-._>"»r.j-»»-ir -ft- 0—4 r^coO
t—
Z
O
mHOOOOOO
-*-•
J-c^m— f<\l<—(4-4—
-^ —O 9>
4
u-,ao
— r«-<o
O
<
u. «H r^«f ^^j'Com -^t— 034-4
O
Z-J
O IflrtOOOMO -j*——
ooooooo(NJoooo 40
i vii/iaoauj-ja z_j_zzo.OQ.Q-a >-o • ••••»•• ...•
UJ • ZZ-JjCOQIO.-GCal/i-WIO Q-> O OOUOUOO OOOO
I— .»>vii3
uilMU>U.u :»XI" a."-*"/?'"* —
>t_i/>>t_«<o'M ,,»"x«-'u~^a3"».z*v># x
> O—.<UiQ.<UjQ-01ErooO<I'tZ>-Q.-» > 'J
— jmaa.O-n.ct-sHt-Hir"jSX-_ uji— • •»••«•• • « . .
-
a w»
Z
z a._;_!3t_!>>>3:>-:3:_;>3;a:_;v-.os
O
-isr_.03
— i
>j».o©inmf—
—ist-m—^c ocm
Jiiom
cD4—.^nm
X O i/i
O
CCO— < <7>r-fo«\jr>i—«M <\j'oo>
u »• t- (\j.»«\«JO>fr\njo>'0<*i03r-or-Oin-*' 3 > o
-» <M -» <\J
vt »— •J r— Noo'Ooo^oo'r-rajnirtop-flmoooooooo i— —
< X 3 ••••••••••»••••••••• <_>
UJ
r-
O
—
UJ
>-
4< u. —4 01 <n>rcr— <\j(nj—*—-<mcg >oro.j-t—»tr\f\i o u»o
3 •-4 <t)im -« cic^Tsj-.—« < o o «n-T'© _nr>'0 <h*in
—4 i
>
<
Z
•-. oooooooooocooo
> UOC00000000003
>-~— Tff»
<UJh-fO
r-—i-« -.-« crmfM
-« -"
a —- •••••••«••••• a^f-ifaaitn-'—< or-o*— -om-ooo-"COhooo i— 3
< Z —*•"*•*<sj*r—*<>i— i— i—4—«mo— * (4i©m<T4004—>oinr-~rinr-m—40ocomo<7*oooo
•«••••••••••*••••«••• o uj
O.~ O -• 17>—•
«K — > —« ^rmm»o*i»r-f-oootnooOfO—*oomcooinir.ooo— * ^) i— X i—'Q. </>
J> V^ft-4fr\c\ir\lfM —4 O O in <\if\if\l OOOO VI UJC3 h-a. i/> i—
s looj- ~>vo ik — ovj i— z _
I—
a
XI <N^|——.4-i^uiinoiMOO TiHOJOiJirgcio
<*»
ro-o
4-
-j--*
a.
x x
«»
nwi
*.— «i«i
;w u,i/)i/i
—
u ~
i
-j
O.
_(iij
<l-J
_i
I—
(\i<M--'«3.o-~'i»-oo.->-4ojrn-uan.o-4-40
-4-4-4—l-4-4-4_4-4rsl<Mf\J
UJ
_J
Z -J
4-
lOUZKC
0<<(JU>^
i
<zvi-
_3-l/>
- «-x — oooooooouoooooaooooo ^ O O at arul I uaocwiuujo 3cira:4a;
3
O
—O
uz
O.
i-
*—
'
QOoaouoouoouQuuoucjoa
•«••••••••••••••••#• —>
o
—ICB.
o>
_>4a
U.—4
a_
n
a.a.
ISIUJWts*
aat-ib__
^hji^viuj_:
«4W4-U.JL Lk.
Z —4—4—4^4—4<B—4^X4—I—4—400*^0lSi—4—4C\J^3
-«a>00>
X U.
lf>—» UJO VIUJO.
X. I/) Qlt. <•— ~)
«- C» oo >* 4<M«rz 00(DluZifl03z"iO —• o o-4<\jtn«>-m^3 o-<>Mfo
*3 ' OX ooO 'IDujq: uj-xu*JNNx<3Zuiu->3332r
O
j-occac-uu»--uiacu»<z^.._vi o -< a. —4—4—4—4—4—4»-< rsjf>jf\jiM
uv
'-
z</> o
—
—n—-..™— —•** -<-4-4_i
0.
o
M
UJ
84
<
a.
o irnnrjm-o
in in mo> —im •o «o o^ o if»*oo*Cco^J^ vooaoo* o o^ho r*o«-4 <\im ^ccf^J a-omm
m (ytrvtj'o^'
-^ jMnif^mm ooco— j30 a^CO cc -O— u"ic auoo -*r-ro—
o~h <m(\jO -ooo
<
o o
ooooo o^o-cno
oooooo ooooo -oaooscGoo —
[**<" C—
iTO—«0—<i-"0
OCOOOOO OOOO OOOO — OOOO ooo ooco • r-
LTV
t*>«*0—> iTmJ-^-
(M
ooooo oooooo ooooo o ooooo oaoo a-> ocooooo WOOO o oooo oooooo ooo oooo
z>
a
or
o
OinOmO ^jmoO'fO ooooo m p- -o »* o p- P* cm o -JXUL <nj
o <o rn o ** a»
r-tir\ •—
fMCNi^or^aorur* ^m Z_0
c\j <nj ^crmcotnc^o (Nroor- <\» *i-o*nco cor-c* .——4 aroao
oo
r-vj-r-m
a — vf M — C —
rfwinao*r*oi -
fc
^o^C 1
— • —t.cmcN <m,— -* *-*co Cuir-^o
X fM ocj-rocg
ir> it—
X
>0
s rri — COO
—
<
>"-*
<IT\
U.U
I < -*«n_«»r <M -ro -r ~rO"oo-c<r < mfOO PJ^COO*
Orn«M — <*^>o— Cfo p-oc\jo<\ja—03 •o OOO "OrnCMDCP r»-—«*o m-«oo
.— 00*4" <\J —
COO
OOOOO mOOO>-o
OOOOOO OOOOO oooooooooo I/IU. ooooooo oooo o —oooo
OOOOOOO (MOOO o o lf>-0">CO
ihQOOO ,—•0OOO —OO—'
^ooo
-r
OOOOO OOOOOO ooooo oooooooooo -3 3 ooooooo cooo oooo oooooo ooo oooo
ooo«o r0<-"0>r>-or~ ooooo — en OOOOO OOOO ojXvi 0'-«<>Jro<sj—«0 a3ffi<r>o D r-mom a<r^-tno J-OJ/ -^ OCD'O
©cicm^o _•%!_, .OOOCM OOOOO oooooooooo JUZ
—
<UI»-
oo «-4
CM
o «« ao
—
cnj tr\ -ro'fo
^ro—
O ocooao (^•fnrjf-Om
-r
-r
M
f»1(M mo*»^^o<^r^
m«o
-«0-i
^resi
'Oirxvjao
«!• t*1
UI
o
as
4V1UJ-34
—a. a. Z H- Ui
a. aj—
ZI3>J
-UpUJUiLtUj UJ
-EQC
_ —
'^1 >--
i JZZio >Oviaai<i JU
zuotnx aca.1— XI-
J. I I/)UI C ui ^ UJ LLJ < UJ ti_j <3 r^J LLj *; ai
-U IX 3.C.UJ.SUJ
jhuo
Ol/lt-h- u bUOUJ
yiujuj »->_J <r-a. <t^:cx
Ui«l«CU.l_> «f-.*a:._3.«:
o -z
— -£ Jt _IC_
X
«
CZ
U-~0 <I
<tUJl/"#4
JCU. -i a.
IX iocs—
— <-><_>t-it-
u*x<ajuih- jCXuj Z.Z.'->U
r-o.
3 Z
— lima
<UJ "ZUCOQ CWGC<l/)Ui
— < a.
>u.u.a.(-JCCuJUjujuj i
<e a-icOor<-J-« COct>- p^ <:-iu. UOI- -'ZZ o«_ict — VJUIVS
a. !:•< i 30Cjujll:ujuj 1— f-itO X UI<U. < -ia <-iuj UJZZ 4UJ—J-"
t/ljIW jCOCUUUUUUI '/KLL -TQ.CC-0 i/it/ia.o. UVQQ 3"Z=!U)X> Q<3 rtujT
</>
a
^<n^j^co Q»-rvjm-sf*r ooooo o Ot-Hr\jrct^»r('O^-«Ti0 '»-' ,
85
o
o
ir»«\j •»•«-« -o
ML
t-
OOO't'fOOO — 3 cooooo moo
• •••••»• i/^o••••••
* or- ~o o-«o
u-i z*v oooooo ooo
com
Zo
o<
Oeo —<n -o ua -oo^craa j*
•4-eo ho — r» «or-<MU"* o incr-mooooooococonxcor-oorgni-ooo-oorjooor-r- moo
oo
r--«-
oooooooo
nT—OCM
oooooo
oj.
oooooooo —a
••••• -oo
••«
oooooo ooo
3
a
OX —
UJ»- • o^»/> o^in
cor- o co r* cc
aa ao ir»o^fw*t"* «-<
(T>
r--o
CO OO" P" Off'
irs^O r-
O
«
Z-O
o-oo>ooo OOO
mouio o
r-
C*
49r-
zee
— u-lu
r~m o
oo m
r»
ho o 3o
—~* «*
hOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO^
I—
C*
m
*r
ooo
*
r-
cco«»CMf>
co~*rgm**
«ro
•-«
3
U.O
^•^ o*^ -*•" u">m,rr» u
in or- r» r- -rcr»«vio ^in o f>r» m co co
^m —O
rtf- OO ho o
rg««r-r-0 —
ON
f-4<0
NHOOOOOO
rg-*!'
O inio^^)
oooooo COOPlH-OOOO
s
nice
IU.J
•0>1*
r-*r o—
«-•
--O
(M
o OO om
o OOO oooooooo oooooo oooooooooooom
<\i iri
OOO o*~h
tn 03
\r\
r-mommoo^r- Of-
• ••••••• UJXtrt
oooooo ooocor--.ooof~
I
-1^4^111 m ~- nj -n
3—
Ui.2
J3J_iOa,
——J -. •_iccoa_j-jKi on s:i- <xOi/>0-jZ 3tecr-r-«/:x r-otH>— Oh-
UJ— r- :uiuu i— o^)»-q:o Q.O'>»3»•-u
«kc;ju
,
86
*f(>rgON 201^-ff>»C— cow"* mco->j ,
4-a^'M^ oaotf\H^NOOHOoo^o tON > ir, fnOiri<\iOO<virw > ^'^— «*"tfvOsC<\j^f cj lu
XO"-
(*> h- »r\ f- ^ — ^ q- h* ir» co »* ZUU. cr**jcoom»-"»h-ococoCPOU"»^OOr-ir.— s
-i^u.
-»> (M
z z
o a
(J o
UI mr-— o<^Ornc»i.j-^ov Nf O<to
ul o
0«V> &a*v (m^" (\i sf rvjoo^cofsju^ comoD coo* o^rsjc* r>j <\i-j-o>*
com*r^—* 50 — O^**"*? 0*j" — -j-«00 (*>r— — m.^ m^C^rocMfncMf^mu^OcB 0^ (v*J*eo— Zee fvi
o
o
nooo oooaoo
OOOOOOOOOOOrt mo— OO
ooooooo -O
oooooocooooooooooo O—OOOO— OOOOO O OOO — --U-U.'
OOOOOOO OOO OO OOlf ooooaoooooooooooooooo — o
o
x •••••••••••• ••• ........... t-
</>!— • H •
•J
V>
oooooooooooo OOOOOOO cooooooooooooooooo ooooooooooooooooooooo — S—l o
X
uua
*r(\jin^*o o
COOO mac
r-.t-Oir»** 30 (*>r-»w3<Nj—4rMco<Mrurnoirv *o -^mirfl)
«ooo
ooooosoooor- 2U imo—oo ooocooo -co oo oom o— oooooocooo o
-r SU._J
ooooo
oo•••«•••*... cocoooo ooooo o oooooooooooo OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
1
_J
• — k-3 — 1-^
oooooooooooo uzu. ooooooo oooooooooooooooooo OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO V)U2I1
CO
•
eeoe
a.—vj*:
i-wziflfiwhQi-
^.j.^->-a.w^
—o ZQ 'JJt-vlH- a.v-it-_j
vi
_j>— vjlu
x>st
l_ -o o
vii-t-ot-
^,i/.a ju
viv>u
vivio_ioOZ(-vi>-v>Zh-ce
»zaht>"X><ia«»<izajzv)w h-aioo h— «
IU -uoj «;a.cju 'jj
— uj •J^t — CC_it- >owu i— *:a- i-ujcca.(—
uv>>. UJ»— <1LUV)^U-ULLU<1*— *w^-«-J — IX.%
V71/IVJ -.UJ
— 2. aviuj»—>u. uj>-</)0 viu. cto >— ct i— •—a. Utf »02S 1-XQ.I-I VI a— iLU . —
• I(— O
CC«»« a. — X"* CI v> .t a.4Mju<i(ju«^Nr »»t"UJU.2.UJUiV)UICkUXU> ^(Jt— UJLJ J_tt^«*
lOCLtOVJO-UJO. UJt—Z 3cooo.za. <S0LU.<Zja.a:-Juj_5UJZl.>;oviviu.'oouJ^-Z
XCa.zZ3-caiua.a - i_i -JO«t>— UMUCC •-C'_U- 2" — U-v)C--t«— liO— — UJi—u:
I/IU3&ZU.UU.-J£00 uai ^aco Z *-0 UUJ X < I— QC Ct UJ Vlv)UJUJC£ t_J LD X ><a XQ.U.U. eOU-viu.>-o-tco Xcv-ce <» to
3
Z a. e
a 3
m * it o r- co Cf o—iO< — o 0.-«\imo— O -• ro ^ -O f" CO &• O "- mlTi O
trv 1 <^i <•* o^*f\j(*>«*"ir» JDr-coa^Oi^^fm^m-or^cocro^. o
diPjrM«vrv4<\irjr\if\ji\if\j
X a.
vi ts
oooouMfi
mn>nim<mn •4- ^-~r
<\J
socoaooooortMHHHinti
~f >^ j-
-j- -»
>r -»• >r -r-r -j sr ^r -j-
OOOOOOOOOOhh— Hrf- hh-imI at
jj
87
in
z
a
u
mi
O o
— OCOeHVJaj O
Hfloom aoaxoxoHfjooooo o o o
O
'/OOOCD^-0^m(^'^^CD*J
00m
-
rj in -O
30 -« f\IO>0 Z
O
X
O
VI
OOOOOOOOO—
OOOOOOOOOO
0000000000000300CO- •
<m
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
••••••«•«••••••••• ••••••••••••••••••
••••••«••• OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
«•
hOH
i/iuu.
"->
_1
*-
—
o-o>o<v^«o^mo-£ioocvjr--r^-r-
• »•••••••••••••••
cocD30o<o~4~4 00>i'00*r>rr^ir»-'*~
«<1PM«n_pg c\J —
IU
»- I
<
3 — —o-cui •r«om(»<o>rm(nin(nf»(r««-f^'
•* » o *> *3 o» -wojo ift
00
(JWO
m<w o> eoco—'Om 0" «r> vr\ —
O
<
0C
ta
o
*«
OOOOOOOOOO
••• •
iri^ONino^aDO MCJcjoi'io O *M m
r^*o^-*^r-
aooot> ooooo»-ooooooooo o h- o
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO •
00
-<
s
— om
oo<n
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO 00 ua
3uj _J
— 1-3
in
o
—o^corj —
«oooo o
"O
c oo-o
000000000003COOO-
-*"*-«a3
< oOeQoz *-vi»- h- >t-ouc.iflnao.azzzoi-wh v> i/jvi </> i/> - </it-</i»- —o uviu.u.0 *-ho:i-al>a:jl>j
jj_.ll.-3u.u_ x-jr- _u <3a^t-^«atjiUiw^_;xa._r- -_. _J_ X — 2I<-J XO- —•*— — uj uluuj-L _C<----»— uj-MQCCLr— O—._,u>
oiuouc a—w- i/ii_io t— a lu a.a.u.v»->u. t i_ - ccx a™»-- ~*s uu«sa:uioz h-t-<iiu>— —
—
3
tv
Ow awaaiuj< — —<*-•-_'-' ^ _.__. _-_.,-
ii *.«l
Qa.O— __.4a.ci.xa. j"»OUZ-< ju-^--"-tucmtu. --
jwyofc-zuda; 3u-~<icj<i£~t— »~ _£<i>-i-.-o«»uj<--_c -2
«i -u _j
-si/)
<_.>—
I
;
J-
i z x
—-e —
-.
oj<i
ma
_;«-.
<_tua-a_
r- u.*4-_.
aji— _£
-Q-u
u.w.viavlu-' — v»j ^>u- _j^_v
— <___»>— ic^aiCji-u-JiJuj
Xo.<X->»-o__-i«iujc-.--.o
,
Jv3
v- u«oi«:oc<o zsxJZaczvisso^czoiCCo o jis — sv.< u«<o la vn-a.v)«ao£tocax^ju.
Ik
a. 3
fMi^-rm'O^coa— o»->cj—("fin-or-ocro^-: Nm^ifiOn o»-><Mfri-_-in»c^-cocT o»-ifM<-ioo--i
,
i— o o*""^'<'i ,*'<-"<>or-o-'<j*o >-«f\j<n-_-<n.<.
O f>4rv4<MfMCVi<NiCsJtnin 00O0O00000-«-iH^p4HlMil OaOOoQOOOCHH-4H(Mirtfl X aC OOOOOOOOOO*—--**-*— «—•»-*—<
88
</>
a
«*
ox
(JO c0^*f*>»J-O«-^l^O-^Q0P^
».> ••••••••«••
oc< >i-o©<f\r-<M0'0<7oo
H- f\ir- ^j^fnirvirW'O
t^X —••-. w* — <M (MCsJ
UJX -h
111*
<M
_ -I
O moHOoomiOir4
O • ••••••»• »./
X
o
V)
NOOOOCOOOlflO
— —— I — (-^
111 ZUI ...........
« il»- ~>m omtrcvt-iinrg
-» -c <" ifimif»o I c~ ""<« N I mcvimin
m a) o-*-oo i < -•
< <M — .oO-OOl/ieD
1 OOOOOOrjr-fMO>-
<£ ••••••••• •_
000000000x3
^
O OI3
CM (TIKW "J
m —
a -j
< 3
— UJ -* H-*-Q.ZO. a£XX </1 (->03<
«Z «i_i^~«co Uiuu x>- _: -i i *. -^
_ o </vxa z i-szuij ^>uf j
3 IU«rt | l/7a._J«iH-3EO X UXUOJQI-UOLUJI-I- -I
O. »<o.»«<<»jI < 43uiXua:UX2^G _n->-.«\j
5OO^X«je0_l(J3t-O a.<C^"-aX<Q.uj»-vi <i o
a ^- -i
-J3 U
r-CD0'>O<-'<M 3 c ooooooooo
OOOOOOOOO
o
O «<w«.-i(MC>i<\4 u. cc X -i
89
APPENDIX B
GLOBAL CATALOG
8 Cp Prismatic Coefficient
77 Gl DISPFL/DPTRY - 1.0
78 G2 CGFLD/KGTRY - 1.0
79 G3 2.0/BTR - 1.0
80 G4 BTR/4.0 - 1.0
81 G5 -R/10.0
82 G6 0.48/Cp - 1.0
83 G7 Cp/0.70 - 1.0
84 G8 0.5/SLRAT - 1.0
85 G9 0.001/Cv - 1.0
90
APPENDIX B
GLOBAL CATALOG
88 G12 -1.0
2501
91
APPENDIX C
NOMENCLATURE
a* Move Parameter
tion
Cb Block Coefficient
Cp Prismatic Coefficient
Cv Volumetric Coefficient
92
APPENDIX C
NOMENCLATURE
q Iteration Number
s Search Direction
93
INITIAL DISTRIBUTION LIST
No. Copies
8. Michael G. Parsons
Department of Naval Architecture and
Marine Engineering
University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, Michigan 48104
94
INITIAL DISTRIBUTION LIST (Continued)
No. Copies
95
\\JenkiTffi, J"" 5
^ :
1ID:32
m
•ister, Nei
.050221
_ i5 model
."r-.i Rnhert
Thesis 19957».
J45545 Jenkins
c.l Application of
optimization tech-
niques to Naval sur-
face combatant ship
synthesis.
m
Hi
'vwvay3KE