Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mulusew PROJECT
Mulusew PROJECT
Mulusew PROJECT
SUBITED TO …………HIREDIN
SUBMITED BY……….MULUSEW ALAMIREW
ID NUMBER ………….ETS 0959/06
COURSE TYPE……….MASHINE DESIGN PROJECT
It is with a great sense of pleasure that we acknowledge the help and guidance. we would like to
take this opportunity to give our special thanks to our dedicated lecturer, HIREDIN for given
as this project and guiding this project at every stage with clarity, spending much time to discuss
and help with this project, and that priceless gift of getting things done by sharing his valuable
ideas as well as share his knowledge.
I received information from my FRIENDS to work this interesting design project. I am very
much thankful to them for all their support in conducting and writing up my work. Moreover, I
would like to express my heartfelt and sincere for their priceless guidance and support during my
work. Not forgetting my fellow friends who gave a lot of ideas, contributing in my development
of bevel gear bottle jack. Thanks to the almighty GOD; GOD forgive me the life and hope to
finish this project without any major problems.
ABSTRACT
A Bottle jack is a jack which works on the principle of gear and resembles a bottle in its shape.
Bevel bottle jacks depend on force generated by pressure. Bottle jack tend to be stronger and can
lift heavier loads higher. It can be used for lifting vehicles to undergo repair work or dealing with
flat tires. It can also be used in interconnection with more bottle jacks for lifting structures and
for some household purposes.
The purpose of this project is to modify the design of the existing bottle jack in terms of its
functionality and also human factors considerations. In this “ bevel bottle jack design project”,
the scopes of research were on the designing 10KN maximum lifting capacity with 260mm
minimum lifting height and 130mm maximum lifting height of bottle jack by using optimization
concept. The former model was carefully studied in terms of the design features, specifications,
capacity and with the help of new methodology an attempt was made to fabricate a new design
that can lift a load lower than or equal to 10KN, producing same capacity within the economic
range. The work consists of the fabrication of the new model and projects the advantages of the
new method over existing methods. The new design was successfully made and was able to
fulfill all the required objectives. The following work can be a new eye opener for the design
engineers dealing with making the jack work vertically.
The project on this includes the proper way of material selection by considering all the
mechanical and physical properties of the selected material to make a safe design. The force and
stress analysis is based on the design safety purpose. Unbalanced stress and forces have great
influence to the designed material.
The oil required to run the jack is determined for good performance. Then all the hydraulics
bottle jack parts are designed by considering the requirement of consideration. Considering
coating system also have great role to corrosion resistance. Then the design becomes safe when
all requirements are fulfilled by care attention.
INTRODACTION
This project is design a bottle jack with bevel gear. A bottle jack is a device used to
lift heavy loads and consists of a cylindrical body and a neck. The power screw, which
makes contact with the object to be lifted, emerges from the neck of the bottle jack.
People have started feeling the need of having a bottle jack that works vertically 10KN
lifting capacity with 130mm minimum lifting height and 260mm maximum lifting height.
However, in order to make the bottle jacks work like this vertically it requires that the
jack nut is internally threaded and makes the power screw to rotate towards the desired direction
i.e. upward or dawn-ward; to make this, the upper and lower thrust bearings have important role
for carrying load and to keep the position of lifting system. The main parts of this bevel gear type
bottle jack are, power screw, bearings, jack nut, bolts, pinion and spiral bevel gear, pinion shaft
bearings, the input shaft, housing, and vent all these are described with role and designed in
detail way.
In this project in-order to design, parts of bevel gear bottle jack are designed based on
numerically analysis, geometrical analysis, methodology, conceptual analysis and by considering
working principle of this machine.
The project includes rough sketch of two-dimensional assemblage the parts to show force and
power transmission.
BOTTLE JACK
Bottle jacks have a longer threaded power screw, however, it is possible to
get more lift per rotating the input shaft. The device itself is light, compact and portable, but is
capable, of exerting great force.
The input shaft is manually rotated and pinion forced to rotate the spiral bevel gear and then
power screw to move its piston; Torque is built on input shaft and transmitted through gears up-
to power screw using line of action law. Bevel gear bottle jack is based on the torque, which is
multiplied the force to be increased at the power screw for lifting the desired load.
Oil and grease are used for lubricating the internal forced part of the jack to perform smooth
motion in the system.
OBJECTIVE
Re-design improvement the existing bevel gear type bottle jack in terms of its functionality and
human factor consideration. Make a design of bottle jack that is user friendly and easier to
operate as do not required too much force to lift the load. The can lift 10KN maximum load and
minimum and maximum lifting height of 130-260mm respectively.
Therefore, we can design this type of bottle jack by considering the design analysis and its
specifications based on standards.
Power screw: used to hold (lifting the load) by moving up and also used to lift down
and regain the load into the original place.
Jack nut: the main function of this part is, in-order to keep lifting screw to move the
power screw up and down. To make this jack nut is internally threaded so, directional
motion of the power screw is controlled by the jack nut based on the thread and based on
the rotation of the input shaft.
Input shaft: manual force is applied on the shaft then the shaft rotates toward the
desired direction. This happened by torque which is developed on the input shaft to create
angular motion for the effect of other parts.
Pinion gear: used to drive the spiral bevel gear by creating angular motion and by
transmitting power to-wards the gear for further creation of motion for power screw.
Spiral bevel gear: used to control or give direction on the lifting screw to move up and
down based on bevel gear rotation.
Upper thrust bearing: important to keep up ward motion and carry the load.
Lower thrust bearing: in order to keep down ward motion and carry the load.
Input shaft bearing: since force is exerted on the input shaft to resist this load not to
bend and not to created stress on the shaft bearings have great role for carrying the load.
Mounting bolt: used for mount machine with desired place may be on the table.
Fill vent: used as the passage of lubricant fluid into the system.
Housing (casing): the main role of this part is used to protect internal parts from dust,
unwanted contamination and from unwanted external stress from the surrounding.
Power transmission of bevel gear type bottle jack (working principle).
Power transmitted means how the machine is work, to do this:
The machine is mechanically operated or using manual force, the force is applied on the input
shaft, then it becomes rotate to the desired position. In this system the shaft is probably rotate in
to two ways these are; towards clockwise and counter- clockwise direction. Based on this
position there will be specified movement of power screw. Now let us see the working principle
of the machine in each rotation of the shaft.
When the shaft rotates toward clockwise direction, manually using hand wheel attached to the
shaft; the input bearings protect the motion of the shaft by minimizing the friction and power is
transmitted into the pinion gear then it will forced to rotate the spiral gear towards
counterclockwise direction since they are mesh each other and then the lifting screw rotates
counterclockwise direction then the screw move up; finally, the load will lift up. To keep this lift
up motion the upper thrust bearing has great role for carrying the load not to become downward.
When the shaft rotates toward counterclockwise direction, manually using hand wheel attached
to the shaft; the input bearings protect the motion of the shaft by minimizing the friction and
power is transmitted into the pinion gear then it will forced to rotate the spiral gear towards
clockwise direction since they are mesh each other and then the lifting screw rotates clockwise
direction then the screw move down; finally, the load will becomes down. To keep this lift down
motion the lower thrust bearing has great role for carrying the load not to become downward.
GEOMETRICAL ANALYSIS
Geometric of the bottle jack is defined as the machine perform its task, the components of this
bevel gear bottle jack is show movement by changing its position. Geometry means the working
area of the machine.
The main two types of geometric indications are; when the screw move up and down its working
area will be happen.
working.
SCREW JACK –
Bevel gear bottle jack is a portable device consisting of a screw mechanism used to raise or
Lower the load. This type of jacks most commonly used,
Mechanical
Merits of bottle jack –
1] Can be used to lift a heavy load against gravity.
2] Load can be kept in lifted position.
3] Due to hand wheel obtained by handle force required to raise load is very less & can be
applied manually also
Demerits of bottle jack –
1] Chances of dropping of load
2] Tipping or slipping of load.
3] This failure is not “SAFE FAIL”& can cause serious accidents.
Reasons of Accidents –
1] Load is improperly secured on jack.
2] The jack is overloaded.
3] Center of gravity is off center with axis of jack.
4] Jack is not placed on hard & level surface.
5] Using for other purpose instead of using it for which it is designed.
Detail description for parts.
Power screw –
Screw size – Screws is nothing but a member having Helical groove around periphery of solid
bar.
Thread profile – The screw or power screw thread is always a square type because it has more
efficiency than trapezoidal threads and there is no radial thrust on screw i.e. no Bursting
Pressure, so motion is uniform. Square threads usually turned on lathes using single point cutting
tool. It leads us to use free cutting steel.
Square threads are weak in roots. Wear of thread surface lead us to use “Unalloyed free cutting
steel”.
I select “25C12S14 UNALLOED FREE CUTTING STEEL”
It indicates - 025% carbon, 1.2% manganese, 0.14%sulphur
It has tensile strength of 560N/mm2 with 10% elongation. Sulphure gives resistance to wear &
0.25% carbon gives it sufficient strength to compensate weakness in roots. also easy in cutting
due to manganese.
Jack nut –
As we know there always a relative motion between screw and nut, which cause a friction. The
friction causes wear if some material is used for screw & nut it will wears both components. So,
one out of two has to be softer than other so as to ease of replacement. The size & shape of screw
is costlier than nut, so generally we use softer material for nut than screw. Phosphor bronze is
ideal material for nut which is a copper alloy having 0.2% of phosphor which increases tensile
strength. Ultimate tensile strength for this is 19mpa and coefficient of friction is 0.1
Bearing pressure is 10mpa.
Input shaft
Shaft is subjected to bending moments due to over- hanging.
So Material selection “1018Steel Annealed” with yield strength Sy = 220MPa.
Parts of bevel gear bottle jack:-
Power screw
Jack nut
Bevel Gear and pinion
Shaft
Bolt
Bearing
Fill vent
Housing
Assumptions:-
Symbols:-
Assume the bevel gear acts as a nut for power screw and considering the screw is under
compressive stress.
syc 560 Mpa
σc = n
=
5
= 112Mpa
And from our assumption µ = 0.18 → tan ∅=0.18 ⇒ tan−1 ( 0.18 )=10.2˚
56Mpa ¿ 44.12 Mpa therefore; power screw design is safe with factor of safety 5.
Design summary:-
Assume bearing pressure (pb) between steel screw and phosphorus bronze jack nut is 10Mpa.
For jack nut material is bronze.
Material selection phosphorus bronze with shear stress 𝝉s = 19MPa
4W 4∗10000
pb = = ⇒ Z =
π∗(d o ¿ ¿ 2−d c 2)∗Z ¿ π∗(0.014 ¿ ¿ 2−0.0112)∗Z ¿
4∗10000
2 6 = 16.98
π∗(0.014 ¿ ¿ 2−0.011 )∗10∗10 ¿
Take z =17 this is thread number of screw.
Height of jack nut calculated by:-
H= Z*p =17*2 =34mm
Transvers shear stress at the root of thread in nut is given by:-
2∗w 2∗10000
= = 13.4MPa
π∗p∗Z∗d o π∗0.002∗17∗0.014
Therefore; 13.4MP<19MPa jack nut is safe in transvers shear stress at the root.
Transvers shear stress at threads in screw is given by:-
𝝉=W / (π*dc*p/2*Z) = 10000 / (π*0.011*0.001*17) = 17.02MPa
Therefore; 17.02Mpa < 56MPa jack nut is safe in transverse shear stress at screw.
Fig. transverse shear area on the screw body.
σt = W/(π/4×(Do2-do2) = 112×106 = 10000/(π/4×(Do2-0.0142)
4
√
DO = (10000 ×
π × 112×10 6
+0.0142 ) =18mm
Design summary:-
H = 34mm
t = 3mm
Material used phosphorus bronze with allowable shear stress 19MPa
DO’= 24mm
DO = 18mm
As = 254mm2
Symbols:-
L → slant length V.R → velocity ratio
m → module in mm T → number of teeth
N → rotational speed e → error tooth factor in mm
D → diameter a → addendum
d → dedendum
Calculations:-
T = 60P/(2π × N) ⇒ P = (2×𝜋×N×T)/60 = (2×𝜋×50×15)/60 = 78.54 watt
−1 1 3
ϴP1 = tan ( )= tan−1 ( )= 16.7˚
V .R 10
ϴP2 = ϴS −ϴ P2 = 90˚ −¿ 16.7˚ = 73.3˚
TEP = TP× sec(ϴP1) = 18×sec(16.7˚) = 18.8
TEG = TG×sec(ϴP2) = 60×sec(73.3˚) = 208.8
0.684 0.684
Y'P = 0.124−¿ = 0.124−¿ =0.088
TEP 18.8
0.684 0.684
Y'G = 0.124−¿ = 0.124−¿ = 0.121
TEG 208.8
Cheek for designing:-
V.R= (NP/NG) = (10/3) = (30rpm/NG) ⇒ NG = 15rpm
σop × Y'P = 85MPa×0.088 = 7.48 σOG×Y'G = 55MPa×0.121= 6.7
since (σop × Y'P) >( σOG ×Y'P); design must be for the gear.
W T = 2×T/(DG) = 2×15/(m×TG) ………………. DG = m×TG.
WT = 500N/m
π × D G × NG π × m×60 × 15
Pitch line velocity ….. V = = = (47.12m)×10-3 m/s
60 60
6 6
Velocity factor …………. Cv = =
6+V 6+47.12 ×10−3 × m
DG m×TG
Length of pitch cone element ………. L= = = ( 31.32×10-3×m) m
2× sin θp2 2× sin 73.3˚
L (31.32 ×10−3 × m)m
b= = = (10.44×10-3m) m.
3 3
Tangential load on the gear:-
L−b
WT = σOG × Y'P ×Cv × b× 𝜋 × m×
L
6
WT = 500N/m = 55×103[ ]×10.44×m2×𝜋×0.121×0.667
6+47.12 ×10−3 × m
873.53
WT = 500N/m = [ ]×m2 ……… by tray and error method m = 1.5 take m =
6+47.12 ×10−3 × m
2mm
DG = m×TG. = 2×60 = 120mm Dp = m×Tp = 2×18 = 36mm
V = 0.04712×m = 0.1 m/s say V = 1.25m/s based on standard design
WT = 500/m = 500/2 = 250N
Cv = 6/(6 + v) = 0.83
L = 0.03132×m = 63mm
b = 10.44×m = 21mm
From standard design for gear at pitch line velocity @ V=1.25m/s e = 0.0925mm
1
And take K = 0.107 for 14 ˚ composite
2
K ×e 0.107 ×0.0925
Dynamic factor C = [ + ] = [
1 1 1
+
1
] =593.98N/mm
EP EG 3
210 × 10 84 ×10 3
2× T EG 2 ×208.8
Ratio factor Q =
T EG +T EP
= 208.8+18.8
= 1.84
The maximum or limiting load for wear for bevel gears is given by
DP × b ×Q × K 36 ×21 ×1.84 ×1.18
Wear load WW = = = 1713.7N
cos ϴ p 1 cos 16.7 ˚
Since maximum or limiting load is much more than tangential load design for bevel gear is safe.
Addendum a = 1m= 2mm
Dedendum d = 1.2m = 1.2×2= 2.4mm
Clearance = 0.2m = 0.2×2 = 0.4mm
Working depth 2m = 2×2 = 4mm
Thickness of thread = 1.5768m = 1.5768×2 = 3.154mm
b DP 36
Mean radius Rm = ( L− )× = ¿)× = 15mm
2 2× L 2× 63
−1 a −1 2
Addendum angle α =tan ( ) = tan ( )= 1.82˚
L 63
−1 d −1 2.4
Dedendum angle ¿ tan ( ) = tan ( ) = 2.18˚
L 63
Back cone radius of bevel gear is given by;
Torque (N.m) 15
Module (mm) 2
Addendum (mm) 2
Face width 21
ϴS 90˚
K (N/mm2) 0.107
Assumptions:-
dS → diameter of shaft
Te → equivalent torque
Mt → twisting moment
Sy → yield strength of the shaft
𝝉y → shear stress
Calculations:-
Axial force acting on the pinion;
WRH = WT× tan ∅ × sin ϴP 1= 250× tan 14.5× sin 16.7 = 18.56N
Vertical load on the pinion;
WRV = WT × cos θP 1 = 250 × tan 14.5× cos 16.7 = 61.93N
b DP 36
Mean radius Rm = ( L− )× = ¿)× = 15mm
2 2× L 2× 63
Bending moment due to axial and vertical load;
Mb = WRV×Overhang – WRH*Rm
= 61.93×0.02 – 18.56× 0.015 = 0.9602N.m
Bending moment due to tangential load;
MT = WT×Overhang = 250×0.02 = 5N.m
Equivalent bending moment;
Me = √ M b2+ M T 2 = √ 0.96022+ 52 = 5.1N.m
Since the shaft is subjected to twisting moment and bending moment;
Equivalent twisting moment given by;-
𝑇e = √ M e2 +T 2 = √ 5.12+ 152 = 15.84N.m
S 220
𝝉y = y = 2× 2 = 55MPa
2× n
π T 15.84
3
√
𝑇e = 16 ×𝝉y× dS3 ⇒ dS = (16 × e ) =
π ×τ y √
3
(16 ×
16 ×T 16 ×15
Shear stress due to shaft diameter 𝝉 = 3 = =27.84MPa
π ×d s π × 0.0153
Since 𝝉 < 𝝉e shaft design is safe.
Design summary:-
Material used “1018Steel Annealed” with Sy = 220MPa
dS = 15mm
L = 200mm
𝑇e = 15.84MPa
Over hang height by bearing 20mm
do = 10mm
p = 2mm
Thread length for bolt L = 2×do + 6mm = 26mm
Cheek for shearing stress distributed in 6 bolts;
16 × T 16 ×15
𝝉 = π × n× d 3 = π × 6× 0.0083 = 24.87MPa
c
Working shear stress is less than induced shear stress i.e. 𝝉 < 𝝉 = 24.87MPa < 40MPa.
Design for bolt is safe.
Design summary:-
dc = 8mm
do = 10mm
p = 2mm
D = 1.2mm
L = 26mm
Material for bolt mild steel with σ = 𝝉y = 40MPa.
C
Symbols:-
LH → life of bearing in hours.
L → life of bearing in revolutions.
B → bore of bearing.
DO → outer diameter of bearing.
W → basic dynamic equivalent radial load.
N → angular speed for pinion.
R → radius of outer diameter.
Calculations:-
LH = years × days × hours
= 10 ×365×7
= 25,550 hours
Since shaft diameter is 15mm bore of the bearing is 15mm for contact roll bearing.
From table for standard dimension of radial ball bearing with bore 15mm, we can get:-
T 15
W= = = 857.14 N
R 0.0175
1
L
Dynamic load rating C = W×
106 ( ) K
1
7665× 104
C = 857.14× ( 106 ) 3
= 3.641KN ………………. K = 3 for ball bearing.
From standard table, for the corresponding bearing number 201; C = 5.4KN
Design summary:-
Assumptions:-
Bearing type is angular contact ball bearing with inner race rotating.
Specification type for bearing is single row
Load is uniform and steady.
The life of bearing to be 10 years and 7 hours working per day.
Chrome - steel selected as material suitable to carry load.
Symbols:-
Calculations:-
From standard table radial ball bearing bore of 25mm, DO = 52mm, width = 15mm and
T 15
WR = = = 857.14N
R 0.0175
WA = FL = 10KN
W = X × V × WR + Y × WA
For single row angular contact bearing (inner race is rotating) rotational factor V = 1.
Since the selected bearing is angular contact ball bearing single row with bearing number 205
from standard basic static and dynamic capacity of radial ball bearing table, we can get;
WA 10000
= = 11.67
W R 857.14
From the values of X & Y based on the corresponding values at angular ball bearing with the
WA
specification of single row and = 11.67,
WR
WA
>e e = 1.14
WR
X = 0.35 y = 0.57
1
2295× 104
C = 6000× (106 ) 3
……………. take K = 3.
C = 10.75KN
From the standard table C = 11KN …. So, design is safe with bearing number 205.
Design summary:-
Table 4 Values of maximum allowable tooth error in action (e) verses pitch line velocity, for
well cut commercial gears.