Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Business Ethics: Titantic Case Study Notes
Business Ethics: Titantic Case Study Notes
Lifeboats
I. 20 lifeboats
A. 14 standard wooden Harland and Wolff lifeboats with a capacity of 65 people
each
B. four Englehardt "collapsible" (wooden bottom, collapsible canvas sides) lifeboats
(identified as A to D) with a capacity of 47 people each.
1. 2 of them were hard to launch - no davits to lower them and weight made
them difficult to launch by hand
II. 2 emergency cutters with a capacity of 40 people each
III. Titanic had 16 sets of davits, each able to handle four lifeboats - ability to carry up to 64
wooden lifeboats which would have been enough for 4,000 people
A. However, the White Star Line decided that only 16 wooden lifeboats and four
collapsibles would be carried, which could accommodate 1,178 people, only
one-third of Titanic's total capacity.
B. At the time, the Board of Trade's regulations required British vessels over 10,000
tons to only carry 16 lifeboats with a capacity of 990 occupants
IV. At the time, lifeboats were intended to ferry survivors from a sinking ship to a rescuing
ship—not keep afloat the whole population or power them to shore.
A. SS Californian responded to Titanic's distress calls, the lifeboats may have been
adequate to ferry the passengers to safety as planned.
Passengers
I. approximately 1,317 people: 324 in First Class, 284 in Second Class, and 709 in Third
Class.
II. 869 (66%) were male and 447 (34%) female
III. 107 children aboard
A. largest number of whom were in Third Class
IV. considerably under capacity on her maiden voyage, as she could accommodate 2,453
passengers—833 First Class, 614 Second Class, and 1,006 Third Class
A. Usually, a high prestige vessel like Titanic could expect to be fully booked on its
maiden voyage
B. national coal strike in the UK had caused considerable disruption to shipping
schedules in the spring of 1912, causing many crossings to be cancelled
Aftermath
I. news of “mismanagement” by the White Star Line almost immediate
A. first claimed the ship was still floating and being towed into port, then that it had
sunk and the survivors were being taken to Halifax, and finally that they were
being brought to New York.
II. Carpathia itself, there was virtually a news blackout once the list of survivors had been
telegraphed to shore
A. first the first- and second-class passengers and then, almost grudgingly, the
third-class passengers
III. U.S. inquiry Chaired by Senator William Smith: operation to heal a nation and a technical
inquiry, Specific questions it considered included:
A. Did Titanic steam at full speed through an ice zone despite repeated warnings of
icebergs from other ships in the vicinity?
B. Were the design and construction of the vessel adequate for the task?
C. Did the ship have enough lifeboats?
D. Was the third class unfairly discriminated against?
E. Did Bruce Ismay, chairman of the White Star Line, exert any pressure on Captain
Edward Smith to increase the ship’s speed? (If this could be proven, it would open
the company to prosecution for all the lives lost.)
A. Lord Mersey chaired the British inquiry and included in his court a number of
expert witnesses in naval architecture and shipbuilding. Only three passengers
were interviewed—all from first class.
V. Inquiry findings: Everyone, it seems, was just following orders, and no one was
responsible.
A. Ultimately, of course, the buck stops with the captain. But, conveniently, Captain
Smith and his two most senior officers were all dead by then.
C. Captain Smith was exonerated on the grounds that most other ships at that time
also sped through the ice at full speed with no serious consequences.
D. Everyone agreed there should have been more lifeboats on Titanic, and the U.S.
inquiry suggested the British Board of Trade (which had approved the number of
lifeboats) had been sleeping on the job.
E. The British Board of Trade (under whose jurisdiction the British inquiry took
place) was, not surprisingly, more phlegmatic
F. The only person both inquiries heaped scorn on was the captain of SS Californian,
the ship that had stood by about 8 miles off, its crew watching the emergency
flares being fired by Titanic, without doing anything about it until it was too late.
At 23:39 (11:39 p.m.), Fleet first spotted the iceberg and rang the nest's bell three times to warn the
bridge of something ahead. Then, using the nest's telephone he pronounced the infamous "Iceberg!
Right Ahead!" warning to sixth officer James Paul Moody who immediately notified first officer
[15]
William McMaster Murdoch; in charge of the bridge. After the collision, Fleet and Lee remained
[16]
on duty for twenty more minutes.
2 degree turn