Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AISC 1968 v03
AISC 1968 v03
EOITORIAL STAFF
Daniel Farb, Editor
Mary Anne Donohue, Assl. Editor
engineer, and will lead to falJter, easier design and more
nomical high rise steel-fmmed buildings.
ec.
is available. The new book is a pmctical guide for the pmcticing
•-
•
facilities. These include biological and
physical sciences laboratories, a tiered
lecture room and two language labora-
ITtI1flI.,. ..,...:_
I n l " ~Ol"" IIIU104T
.,,..-.-......,,....
1IVI.1'1 P1JUOO" "&CI
--
IIllala,
..... TOn.I'"
L'I • .a..a.u1 naTIO_
1'1''''' _.
•
1.1 ....... ,.wOla UAeI
•••• ac. UCO.I
_ .. 1_- "I.
otat\' .... IHol ......
=1 •
•
.ODD "'1'ICI .......
1'.11.1 aC''''1 ~ .......
. _....
1 .. ICTaICI
.. IT""
con-.o"
1.0• • •
~
• ~'"
•• n~ •• -~
•• IITCI"
I
· _._aUI
tUnlCl ... o,,"c'
• •••••••
• • U: 'I """0"&1'01
•• ItC'9IUll' n ..rr _ _
~.
I ••
I • 111'<:1_
ft",.,. 0'-'1'
•• Itnu..o
1I • -,.
" • • CI
_
aL.Oo1'1
. . . . . . . .ou.fiCA" IU.CI
1'0."
"
f---lo-- -
IiZ:::i • "
•
o ,
"'000
... - L
Tubular .ted <IV" lrltUC8 .pan the 71·/t octagonal central rc.carch-atudy area. The three-dimensional jranu'ng
has an upper compre88iml ring and a lower ten8ion ring at the center.
• tories connected by a soundproof fac· students and staff in the central area. the bottom of the steel was held at 10
ulty work area. Adjacent to the main Each research alcove contains those ft above the lloor. At the perimeter sup·
student entry are a faculty meeting volumes related to a specific discipline. ports, the three dimensional truss is ap·
room, library preparation areas and lav· Consolidation of the student project proximately 9 ft deep. The top and bot·
atories. A public entrance, diagonal to areas, conference rooms and language tom chords converge toward the center
the students' approach, is used for oc· booths promotes an inter'relationship of where the depth is approximately 5 ft·
casions when the community attends disciplines. 6 in. and the bottom of steel is 14 ft-2 in.
special dramatic performances by the above the depressed seating area of the
children or for PTA activities. The can· Structural Solution IIoor. The visual pattern of steel memo
necting link between the Learning Cen· One of the major design challenges, bers creates a constantly changing mod·
ter and the main school building houses according to the architects, was "to ulation of space through the central
the mechanical plant and a modern span the central space with a structural area without being a heavy dominant
kitchen. This kitchen serves over 300 system that would express the basic mass overhead.
meals per sitting to students in the educational philosophy of the school, The entire roof frame was fabricated
Learning Center as well as those in the yet respect the economic limitations from A36 steel tubing. The structure is
existing building. imposed by private fund raising cam· composed of 16 lower chord and 16
A built·in "theatre in the round" for paigns." The architects found an eco- upper chord tubes, each 6 x 4 x 3/16-
theatrical and group discussions com· nomical structural solution that would in. These are connected by 3 x 2 x 3/16-
prises the center of the large space, create the light, intimate, yet dynamic in. web members. Due to the taper of the
where a sunken area of two octagonal space desired by developing a unique truss sections in both plan and section,
steps is provided. The steps are placed radial "V" type truss based on the octag· the system of web members generates
far enough apart so that tables and anal geometry of the plan. Only with a three dimensional compound plane,
chairs may be set up between them for steel tube could the delicate web-like rather than a simple plane. The truss
dining, study, or audience seating. The structure be economically achieved. All was designed as a continuous member,
entire IIoor area is carpeted for this joints were welded, with no rivets, bolts using a compression ring at the center
purpose as well as for acoustic control. or plates to break the visual continuity top chord and a tension ring at the cen·
Research alcoves with student study of movement around the space or to ter bottom chord.
carrels, soundproof listening booths, disturb the impression of structural The octagonal compression ring is the
• microfilm stations, and book stacks are unity across the 72-ft span of the acta· smaller one, composed of 8 x 3'1. x'l.·in.
1
-=
readily available and accessible to the gon. To intensify the intimacy of space, tubing with Y.z·in. plates on each side.
OOAA'" .~ 5
The tension ring is composed of 2 octa- speed up and control fabrication of the
gons, one upon the other, but rotated in compound bevels required at the end
•
plan to pick up a lower chord member of each web member. Four web mem-
at each of the 16 corners thus formed. bers converge at each typical upper and
The tension rings are made up of 4 x 3 lower chord "panel poin!." Each truss
x 'lio-in. tubes. The central "cone" of section was 36 ft long, tapered in width
steel formed by the compression and from 15 ft-D in. to 1 ft-1D in., and sloped
tension rings, with special accent light- from 8-ft-5 in. to 5 ft-6 in. in heigh!. The
ing, provides a dramatic effect over the assembled truss sections were trucked
depressed seating area of the floor. All to the site, under provisions of a special
general lighting for the central space is road permit. The intermediate top chord
concealed in three concentric octagonal and web members were shipped loose
wood "rings" which parallel the walls of for field welding. Tolerance on each
the room and rest upon the bottom piece was held to plus or minus 1/16-in.
chords of the roof trusses, and thread A temporary welded steel tower sup-
their way through the web members. ported the central compression and
The rooms surrounding the central oc- tension rings during erection. Each of
tagonal space were framed with stand- the eight truss sections were lifted over
ard steel joist and deck. The exterior was the lower surrounding roof in an alter-
most simply and economically handled nating pattern. All shop welding and
with concrete block and plywood. field welding of loose members was
done with low-hydrogen rod. The tem-
Fabrication and Erection porary tower was left in place until all
The "V" trusses were shop fabricated superimposed loads were applied.
in eight sections. Each section con- There was a total initial deflection of
sisted of two bottom chord members, approximately 'I2-in. No further deflec-
one upper chord member, and their con- tion has occurred, even under unbal-
necting web members, all jig positioned anced snow loading. All critical welds
for welding. Special "wrap around" card- were X-ray examined before removal of
•
board templates were developed to tower supports.
•
United States Pavilion, EXPO '67, Montreal, Canada
•
imagination and skill of the men who conceived, Steel Fabricators, Bliss Portland, South Portland, Maine;
Atlantic Steel Castings Company
designed, and built this unique and exciting Chester, Pennsylvania
structure. Owner: United Sta tes Information Agency, Washington, D. C.
TH I RD QUARTER 1968 7
Tapered Columns
Express the Structure
•
The Stark Office Building is a 6000
SQ ft, two-story structure in Oakland,
Michigan, located on a 125-ft square
site fronting on the service drive of a
major freeway. The owners, a food
brokerage company, occupy the ground
floor. The second floor, planned as
future growth space for the owners, is
presently leased by the architects. The
owners desired that the building, though
surrounded by larger rental office struc-
tures, be recognizable as a distinguish·
ed image of their company.
The building rests on a 2-ft high
brick·walled base. This podium, to be
covered with marble chips, contains five
8·ft diameter saucers. Four are to be
planted with flowers, the fifth is a foun·
•
tain. The glass enclosed entry is acces·
sible from both the street and the park·
ing lot behind the building. Street and
The .emicircular ,tair at the entl"fl iI parking lot elevations are identical.
de.ill1ted 1(.·ith ,teel box .tringer., require. no
intermediate .upport between /loor •. The fourteen free·standing columns
which support the second floor and roof
are primary to the design concept. They
were designed in steel to economically
achieve the desired shape and lightness
and to express the steel·frame nature of
the building. The tapered column sec·
Each tapered column nction ilnuu1e up 0/ tion was made up of four identical tee
four identical tee .('ction. u.'dded .tem to
.t~m. The tees were cut from 1!WF!7 sections, welded stem to stem. Each tee
section., "illustrated. was cut from a standard 12WF27. By
cutting the web of the WF section on a
slight diagonal, tapering of the tees was
achieved without waste of steel. The
flanges of the columns were eliminated
at top and bottom, forming simple X
sections where they intersect the roof
and base.
Another important design feature is
the semicircular stairway in the entry.
Conceived, like the columns, as a sculp-
tural as well as functional element, it
springs from first to second floor with·
out auxiliary support. The exposed box
•
stringers are made up of V,-in. steel
plates. Covered with an orange-red car-
pet, the stairway is visible from the
street as well as the parking lot.
A radical departure from the "con· The h·p roof is constructed of two non·load·bearing. They do not touch the
ventional" in residential construction, layers of 24·ga. galvanized steel deck· curved ceiling. This permits a truly open
the home of Mr. & Mrs. C. W. Tarkington ing, laid at right angles to each other, plan. The walls only separate and define
is fast becoming a tourist attraction in then plug·welded together. Edge beams different functions of living."
Hayward, California. Travelers on near· are 6WF15.5 steel members. Fiberglass The unique home has one bedroom
by streets and highways, seeing a soar· and asphalt emulsion with a color coat upstairs and a guest room downstairs.
ing roof with a "twist" in it, regularly are sprayed on the exterior as a final Entry to the main floor is via a curved
change course to "find out what it is." coating. The underside of the roof, un· ramp spanning a reflecting pool. The
What they find is a unique hyperbolic· painted, serves as the interior ceiling. 1,400 sq ft of living space includes a
paraboloid house, built of steel, that is
as attractive as it is unusual.
The 2,500 sq ft roof is supported only
According to Oakland designer N.
Kent Linn, "the design and building
materials simplified the engineering
raised steel fireplace, backed by a steel
spiral staircase which connects the two
floors. A 2·car garage·carport provides
_I
at two low points 66.5 ft apart, where it problems and achieved considerable reo an additional 550 sq ft; and a storage
is welded to steel plates anchored to 24- duction of dead loads. The result was area, below the house, utilizes a portion
in. diameter concrete abutments. Light fast and easy construction, plus reduced of the roof as an exterior terrace for the
steel framing for the exterior walls, al· costs." upper floor. The interior features rough·
though not load·bearing, acts to stabi· "Because of the clear span roof." sawn panels of wood, left unpainted, to
lize the roof. Linn points out, "all interior walls are contrast with the steel.
As a member of the jury that met in New York to but did not conceal the fact that they had steel
select AISC Architectural Awards of Excellence bones covered with flesh. The Minges Coliseum was
1968, I was given an opportunity to see how archi- one such building, showing clearly the two-way truss
tects from all the nation use steel in the design of system and framing for a large clear-span sports
their projects. The practitioner, such as I am, is arena.
exposed rarely to so broad a representation of the But the majority of the designers preferred the
buildings by other designers employing steel con-
struction - or any other construction as a matter of
fact. I found the experience personally rewarding
expression provided by a simple framing system of
unadorned steel, meticulously detailed. It was this
expression which seemed to excite the jury most,
. 1
and particularly satisfying, for I believe architects and for good reasons. There seemed to be no limit
are well on the way to developing an exceptionally to its application to large and small projects. A
fine vernacular in steel. variety of forms and details adaptable to many
It took architects thousands of years of innova- building uses articulate sophistication all too rare
tion, experimentation and refinement before the during our era. In this respect, one was reminded
highest order of architectural expression unique to of the common red-brick, white-trim vernacular of
stone technology was achieved. Yet this was a com- late eighteenth century Georgian architecture that
paratively simple technology, easily adaptable to provided aesthetic satisfaction by the designers'
a variety of expressions through honest statements skillful artiCUlation of a vocabulary universally
of structure. understood.
It is surprising that our more complex technol- Some of the architects preferred to use the
ogy, involving the balance of tensile and compress- patina of oxidation as the finish of the exposed
ive forces and' the use of manmade materials in steel members, exploiting a recently developed
new and provocative ways, should find sophisti- metallurgy. Generally, the finish was painted steel
cated architectural expression in such a short time. using a variety of coatings. Both finishes seemed
The entries for the AISC Architectural Awards at- appropriate for the broad spectrum of building
tested to the mature skill and attention to detail types for which the exposed steel system of con-
exercised by designers today. There was evidence struction was chosen.
of consensus. The vocabulary was the same for The quality of the work for AISC Architectural
similar functions, but the statements were varied Awards of Excellence indicated the high level of
and crystal clear. The vernacular was that used for design competence in the general practice of archi-
steel columns, steel beams, and trusses; the state- tecture today. Few of the submissions were the
ments were the creations of conscientious de- designs of award-winning architects, but the greater
signers giving quality, honesty and beauty to the number were those unsung architects, who in their
•
words. day-to-day practice do a commendable job of com-
Most of the buildings submitted for judgment bining aesthetic sensitivity with technical com-
were of the exposed steel variety. Some that re- petence to create satisfying designs of commodity,
ceived awards concealed their steel construction, utility and delight.
•
C. THURSTON LEARNING CENTER OF EAGLEBROOK SCHOOL,
Deerfield, Massachusetts
Architects: The Architects Collaborative, Inc., and
Campbell, Aldric h & Nulty, (Associate Architects)
TOPOROCK STUOIO·RESIOENCE,
Charleston, West Virginia
Architect : Henry Elden & Associates
AWARDS OF
EXCELLENCE
ABRAHAM LINCOLN OASIS, South Holland, Illinois
Architect; David Haid
•
STEEL BRIDGE STUDIO, San Luis Obispo. California
Architects: Paul R. Neel, AlA (Advisor) and Students, School of
Architecture, California State Polytechnic College
•
I
•
SUPERIOR OIL COMPANY GEOPHYSICAL LABORATORY,
Houston, Texas
Architect : Todd·Tackett-Lacy.
Arch itects & Plan nina: Consultants
iI I
~_
~
I
,', - ; -.... ---1..
...... ,~
,"' ,,
'~\ j
\ ;
\- - - :\, J~:::::--,!~
. I.. I -.
...---J ------1=::--,
"'~.--,
,
!
•
Fred De: Falco, Re"onal En,ineer
OMAHA. NER 6I10:2-C/tY NatIonal Bank SldB Henry J. Slrtlna, Selllo, Re,iof'l.1 EnBlflf'f.'r
D..... ,d T Evans, ReB/on,,1 En,inret »muel H Marcus, Re,ion..' En,ineer
Jack A Donnelly, ReBlona' Ef'I,ineer Frederick J, Palmer, R.e"onal En,ineer
ST. LOUIS, MO, 63105-2,lO 5. BemistOll " ...e PITIS8URGH. PA 15219-Ulllon Trusl BldB SYRACUSE, N , Y. 13203-530 Oak 51.
Clyde R Cuder, Re,ion.' En,lneer Ca.btfel M B~ , R~"on.1 En,meer Donald l. Murdock, Re,lOna' En,ineer