Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Peter Robins Paper
Peter Robins Paper
net/publication/264199396
CITATIONS READS
3 934
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Sêr Cymru National Research Network for Low Carbon, Energy and the Environment View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Peter E Robins on 25 July 2014.
Abstract — Complex, high resolution, finite-element three representative Welsh estuaries (Fig. 1), namely the Dyfi
TELEMAC-2D grids have been developed to simulate Estuary [1-3], the Burry Inlet [4], and the Mawddach Estuary
ocean/fluvial interaction in three shallow, intensively managed [5]. A fundamental aim of the study was to develop
Welsh estuaries. In each case, important ecosystems and hydrodynamic solutions based upon accurate, two-
developed areas are exposed to flooding from both tidal and
dimensional model grids of each estuary. The grids
fluvial events. Of particular concern is how the estuaries will be
affected by future sea-level rise due to climate change, and how incorporate anthropogenic features, such as coastal
best to manage the estuaries in the future. breakwaters, railway embankments and sea walls, whilst
Each grid has been generated using BlueKenue© and resolving small-scale bed features in the near shore zone and
comprises several sub-grids to resolve important aspects of the extending off-shore to allow the simulation of tidal
estuary, such as river channels and flood embankments. propagation. Each application has investigated flooding,
Accurate representation of these features is paramount to flood circulation and sediment transport for a selection of mean and
risk modelling. A selection of present-day mean and extreme extreme climatic scenarios.
hydrodynamic/fluvial scenarios has been simulated, as well as The three case studies are described in Section II.
future climate change scenarios. These simulations have
Application of TELEMAC-2D, the flow module, and SISYPHE,
highlighted the need for local management so that coastal
flooding and morphological change are minimised, whilst the sediment transport module, to each estuary is explained in
preserving important ecosystems such as protected salt marshes Section III, including model validation and a summary of the
and peat bogs. Alterations were made to the grids in order to scenarios that have been modelled. Some of the key results are
address possible management options such as coastal presented in Section IV, followed by discussions and
realignment. In this way, key implications for flood risk, conclusions in Section V.
sediment transport and morphological change can be predicted
which will aid management decisions.
I. INTRODUTION
Some of the most challenging environments faced by
ocean modellers are estuaries. These regions are where fresh
river water interacts with saline water to produce strong
baroclinic currents; where shallow water depths generate
highly nonlinear tidal perturbations; and where complex
topography and anthropogenic coastal interventions ultimately
control circulation. Estuaries provide important modelling
case studies because they are often surrounded by protected
ecosystems, and harbour significant human populations which
exploit the area for leisure and tourism.
Around the coast of Wales, UK, there are several
estuaries which urgently require coastal management to
reduce flood risk. These estuaries have been heavily managed
over the past century and coastal realignment has reduced
their natural tidal prisms. De-facto coastal defences are
becoming overtopped more regularly, due to sea-level rise and
increased storm surge and high river flow events. Flooding
episodes drain slowly and hence impact on important
ecosystems and infrastructure. In order to understand the Figure 1. Map showing the three Welsh estuary case studies (boxed areas),
influence of climate change on coastal flooding, and the modelled using TELEMAC-2D (1-The Burry Inlet, 2-the Dyfi Estuary, and 3-
the Mawddach Estuary). The domains overlie model output of bathymetry in
impact of different management options, a three-year project the Irish Sea from a (finite-difference) POM simulation, which was used to
in collaboration with the Countryside Council for Wales provide elevation/velocity boundary harmonics for each of the nested
(CCW) was undertaken where TELEMAC-2D was applied to TELEMAC-2D models.
1
XVIIIth Telemac & Mascaret User Club Chatou, France, October 19–21, 2011
2
XVIIIth Telemac & Mascaret User Club Chatou, France, October 19–21, 2011
3
XVIIIth Telemac & Mascaret User Club Chatou, France, October 19–21, 2011
IV. RESULTS
In each of the three estuarine case studies, increased sea
levels of 1 m and above had the most dramatic influence on
flooding episodes, rather than high river events. Such a
circumstance is caused by an extreme storm surge or due to
predicted sea-level rise in 100 years. Presently, most
embankments and coastal defences are not overtopped during
high spring tide, yet with increased sea levels of 1 m or more,
overtopping occurs and protected marshes and urban areas are
flooded. For example, Fig. 4 shows high spring tide water
levels in the lower Mawddach Estuary, with and without a 2 m
storm surge. The embankments shield the village of
Fairbourne and the protected Arthog Bog from flooding in the
former case, but not with an extreme storm surge. Another
important result, that is generic to all three case studies, is that
by removing some or all of the embankments, tidal
inundations and excess fluvial waters are able to spread out Figure 5 - The Dyfi Estuary management options. Option 1: blue areas show
flooding when existing rail embankments (solid black line) are raised by 2 m.
laterally across the flood plains, which reduces water levels Option 2: green areas show additional flooding when a section of the rail
up-stream in the river channels. Therefore, informed embankment is realigned further south (dashed black line). Option 3: orange
management decisions can reduce flood risk in low-lying areas show further flooding when the same section of the rail embankment is
areas in the upper estuaries. removed all together. The validation points (a - c) are marked (see Fig. 3).
4
XVIIIth Telemac & Mascaret User Club Chatou, France, October 19–21, 2011
inner estuary while tidal flats and deep channels cause ebb- estuary shape - breached training wall in main channel), Grid 2 (wall
removed) and Grid 3 (wall re-built). The brown areas are dry land.
dominance in the outer estuary. With an artificially ‘flattened’
bathymetry (i.e. no tidal flats), the net sediment transport
switches from ebb-dominant to flood-dominant where the Grid 1 (a) Estuary mouth
delta. 3
Fig. 6 shows the effects on sediment transport (compared 2
with the present-day Grid 1) of two management options: (i)
1
removing (Grid 2) and (ii) restoring (Grid 3) a breached
training wall in the main estuary channel. Velocities and 0
170 175 180 185
sediment transport rates were reduced locally, where the wall Time (hours)
had been removed, but increased further up-estuary. The re-
built wall constricts the flow which increased erosion either
Figure 7. Mawddach Estuary - Scenario 1 (mean river flowrates, no surge, no
side of the wall, but reduced sediment transport further up- sea-level rise): sea surface heights for Grid 1(present estuary shape), Grid 2
estuary. (all embankments removed - natural shape) and Grid 3 (upper-estuary
embankments removed - possible management option). Each consecutive
panel, located further up-estuary (see Fig. 1), shows tidal propagation during
spring tide. Sea surface heights are significantly reduced with embankments
removed.
5
XVIIIth Telemac & Mascaret User Club Chatou, France, October 19–21, 2011
V. DISCISSION ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Estuarine environments have always been populated, This was a collaborative study with the Countryside
originally due to trade and industry, but more so today Council for Wales (CCW), spearheaded by Dr. Rod Jones. His
because people are attracted by their outstanding natural guidance and expertise were much appreciated. Dr. Simon
beauty. In order to preserve these environments for future Neill (Bangor University) provided modelled tidal boundary
circumstances involving climate change, coastal management data. LIDAR bathymetry data was provided by the
strategies are essential. Through this study, and other Environment Agency Wales.
modelling projects, interested authorities in Wales are now
realising the potential that modelling has in aiding coastal REFERENCES
management. [1] Robins, P.E. 2009a. Development of a morphodynamic model of the
This study has shown that TELEMAC-2D is a suitable Dyfi Estuary to inform future management decisions. Bangor
modelling framework for estuarine case studies, for the most University, CAMS Report: CAMS 2009-4, pp. 86.
part because of the finite-element grid (orthogonal or [2] Robins, P.E., Davies, A.G. 2010. Morphological controls in sandy
estuaries: the influence of tidal flats and bathymetry on sediment
curvilinear grids will not generate comparable resolution as transport. Ocean Dynamics, 60, 503-517.
efficiently). Simulations of very shallow water depths and [3] Robins, P.E., Davies, A.G., Jones, R. 2011. Application of a coastal
tidal flats (where cells can ‘dry out’) are also essential features model to simulate present and future inundation and aid coastal
which are included in TELEMAC-2D. However, secondary management Journal of Coastal Conservation 15, 1-14.
baroclinic flows, which are often generated in estuaries [4] Robins, P.E. 2009b. Development of a morphodynamic model of the
Burry Inlet to inform future management decisions. Bangor University,
(although shallow depths ensure a vertically mixed water CAMS Report: CAMS 2009-5, pp. 89.
column for the present case studies), will not be simulated in a [5] Robins, P.E. 2011. Development of a morphodynamic model of the
depth-averaged model and, therefore, three-dimensional Mawddach Estuary to inform future management decisions. Bangor
modelling will be required. University, CAMS Report: CAMS 2011-1, pp. 105.
Nevertheless, there are some major shortcomings to this [6] Hervouet, J.M. 2007. Hydrodynamics of Free Surface Flows. 1st Edition,
study, caused primarily by coarse grid resolutions and limited John Wiley and sons, Press 2007, ISBN-13: 978-0-470-03558-0.
model validation. Whilst grid resolutions as fine as 10 m seem [7] Holt, J.T., James, I.D. 2001. An s-coordinate density evolving model of
the northwest European continental shelf: 1-model description and
sufficient for most coastal applications, increasing the density structure. Journal of Geophysical Research 106, 14015-14034.
resolution further would significantly improve the accuracy of [8] Rastori, A.-K., Rodi, W. 1978. Predictions of heat and mass transfer in
the simulations. For example, small-scale features such as open channels. Journal of Hydraulics Division, ASCE, HY3, 397-420.
creeks can have a significant impact on drainage times on the [9] Stanev, E.V., Wolff, J.-O., Brink-Spalink, G. 2006. On the sensitivity of
flood plains. Impermeability of the bed together with sedimentary system in the East Frisian Wadden Sea to sea level rise and
magnitude of wind waves. Ocean Dynamics, 56, 266-283.
unresolved drainage channels lead to unrealistic ‘pooling’ of
[10] Brown, J.M., Davies, A.G. 2009. Methods for medium-term prediction
water behind overtopped embankments. Therefore, the of the net sediment transport by waves and currents in complex coastal
severity of flooding may be over-estimated in some of the regions. Continental Shelf Research, 29, 1502-1514.
simulations. Such errors could be reduced with additional [11] Soulsby, R.L. 1997. Dynamics of Marine Sands: a Manual for Practical
coding to either mimic an impermeable bed or realistic Applications. Telford, London, pp. 249.
drainage, both of which would require validation. [12] Van Rijn, L.C., 1984. Sediment transport, part II, suspended load
Future, similar, estuarine modelling will require accurate transport. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 110, 1431–1456.
high-resolution (< 5 m) bathymetric data, including off-shore [13] Jones, J. E., Davies, A. M. 2005. An intercomparison between finite
difference and finite element (TELEMAC) approaches to modelling
measurements and bathymetry of the river channels. west coast of Britain tides. Ocean Dynamics, 55, 178-198.
Unfortunately, time constraints of the present study did not [14] Brière, C., Abadie, S., Bretel, P. & Lang, P. 2007. Assessment of
allow for extensive validation of the hydrodynamics and TELEMAC system performances, a hydrodynamic case study of Anglet,
sediment transport. Given more time, these issues could be France. Coastal engineering, 54(4), 345-356.
easily addressed which would greatly improve the results [15] Davies A.G., Brown, J.M. 2007. Field measurement and modelling of
presented here. All that being said, the models have given scour pit dynamics in a sandy estuary. Coastal Sediments’07:
proceedings of the 6th International Symposium on Coastal Engineering
considerable insight into local circulation patterns that were and Science of Coastal Sediment Processes, May 2007, New Orleans,
previously not understood. The results presented here have American Society of Civil Engineers, 1609-1622.
provided a foretaste of the vast potential that can be gained
from forecast simulations, from the perspective of coastal
planners.