Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

ORIGINAL INVESTIGATION

Assessment of Chicken-Egg Membrane as a


Dressing for Wound Healing
Fernando Guarderas, MD; Yaowaree Leavell, MD; Trisha Sengupta, BBA;
Mariya Zhukova, BS; and Timothy L. Megraw, PhD

thalmic treatments,6 there are few research data available that


ABSTRACT
have evaluated its effectiveness and safety.
OBJECTIVES: To examine the efficacy of the folk remedy of
The egg membrane is a highly collagenized tissue found to be
chicken-egg membrane dressing on wound healing.
90% protein by weight. The main collagen types are I, IV, and V.
DESIGN: Full-thickness excisional wounds were created on
Other major components include albumin, uronic acid, and sialic
14 male Sprague-Dawley rats in 2 separate trials. Each animal
acid.7 When applied as a home or field dressing, some of the egg
received 2 wounds on the upper back. One wound was untreated,
white is retained,1 which provides adhesive properties, whereas
and the other was dressed with chicken-egg membrane to assess
the membrane retains gas permeability. The egg white contains
its impact on wound healing. Half of the rats received egg
lysozyme, avidin (a biotin binder), ovotransferrin (an iron binder),
membrane treatment on the inferior wound, whereas the other
collagenases, and chondroitin sulfate.8 The membrane hardens
half received egg membrane treatment on the superior wound.
and contracts as it dries, which assists in wound closure. Zadik3
Membrane replacement, wound debridement, and imaging were
described a patient in 2007 with a severe lip laceration that had
done on days 5, 8, and 10 and then imaging continued on days 12,
completely healed using only egg membrane. He noted that
14, 16, 18, and 20 of the experiment. Healing rate was measured
tissue adhesives have not typically been recommended for
based on the wound area over the 20 days of the experiment.
highly mobile areas such as the lip.3 Messens et al9 reviewed
RESULTS: The wounds dressed with chicken-egg membrane had
several food studies to determine the barriers of eggs to bacterial
a significantly (P G .01) faster rate of healing compared with
invasion and concluded that the egg membrane acted as a tem-
the control at the early stages of healing between days 0 and 5.
porary barrier.
This group healed 21% faster during this early phase, compared
The authors used a rat model of wound healing to evaluate
with the control group. Overall, however, wound healing rates
the risks and efficacy of this folk wound treatment protocol.
were indistinguishable from days 5 to 20.
CONCLUSION: Chicken-egg membrane dressing significantly
improves healing of cutaneous wounds in the early stages of METHODS
wound healing. Male Sprague-Dawley rats weighing between 276 and 300 g
KEYWORDS: wound healing, chicken-egg membrane dressing were purchased from Charles River Laboratories, Wilmington,
ADV SKIN WOUND CARE 2016;29:131Y4 Massachusetts. Two separate trials were completed with 6 and
8 rats, respectively. While under inhalation anesthesia with
isoflurane (Abbott Laboratories, Abbott Park, Illinois), the rats
INTRODUCTION were shaved, and 3 treatments of antiseptic iodine/alcohol were
The outer shell membranes of chicken eggs are widely used applied to their backs. Next, 2 full-thickness circular excision
in Ecuador as a home remedy for lacerations and abrasions.1 wounds with a radius of 6 mm were made using a skin punch
Additional anecdotal evidence of their use in wound healing (Acuderm, Fort Lauderdale, Florida) on each rat. The first wound
is reported in France,2 Ukraine,3 and California.4 In Taiwan, a was introduced midline, between the scapulas, and the second
clinical study assessed their effectiveness to treat burns.5 Although was 1.5 cm posterior to the first. Both wounds were then treated
egg membranes were once used in western medicine in oph- with topical gentamicin ointment.

Fernando Guarderas, MD, is an Emergency Medicine Resident, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, North Carolina. Yaowaree Leavell, MD, is an Internal Medicine Resident, Orlando
Regional Medical Center, Internal Medicine Department, Orlando, Florida. Trisha Sengupta, BBA, is a Medical Student, Florida State University College of Medicine, Tallahassee, Florida.
Mariya Zhukova, BS, is a Medical Student, Florida State University College of Medicine, Tallahassee, Florida. Timothy L. Megraw, PhD, is Associate Professor, Florida State University
College of Medicine, Biomedical Sciences, Tallahassee, Florida. The authors disclose they have no financial relationships related to this article. Acknowledgments: The authors have disclosed
that Florida State University College of Medicine provided funding for this study and extend their thanks to the university. The authors also thank Beth Alexander, Dr Kathy Harper, Dr Myra
Hurt, Kim Johnson, Henry Carretta, Dr Michael Blaber, Britney Griffin, Juan Guarderas, and Juan M Espinosa for their generous help with the project. Submitted May 18, 2014; accepted in
revised form August 19, 2014.

WWW.WOUNDCAREJOURNAL.COM 131 ADVANCES IN SKIN & WOUND CARE & MARCH 2016

Copyright © 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.


ORIGINAL INVESTIGATION

also applied if the membrane were to detach in between intervals


Figure 1.
on days 1 to 10. The percentage of healing was calculated using
PREPARATION OF CHICKEN-EGG MEMBRANE
the following formula: area (open wound) / area (initial). The
areas were measured using Image J software to determine a pixel
count of the open wound. This was done to acquire data points for
days 0, 5, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18, and 20 for a total of 9 data points per
wound. The treatment versus nontreatment wounds were
compared using a paired-sample t test (SPSS version 20; IBM,
Armonk, New York) at each data point.
All animal experiments were approved by the Florida State
University Animal Care and Use Committee.

RESULTS
In order to compare the relative healing properties of chicken-
egg membranes on wounds, the authors measured the healing
rates of 2 coincident circular skin punch wounds generated on
the back of rats: 1 control wound, with no dressing, and 1 wound
dressed with egg membrane (Figures 2AYC).
The authors tracked the progress of wound healing by digital
imaging of the wounds on days 0, 5, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 18, and 20
The membrane from the shell of a chicken egg is removed by peeling it from a cracked eggshell.
Arrows point to membrane perched on the tip of a finger and to membrane still attached to the and measured the relative change in wound diameter. The
eggshell. In the experiments where membrane was prepared to dress wounds on rats, sterile
gloves were worn. results indicated that there was a statistically significantly faster
rate of healing of the wounds when they were covered with the
egg membrane treatment compared with the control wounds at
One wound received the egg membrane dressing (Figure 1), the early stages of healing between days 0 and 5 (Figures 2DYE).
and the other received no treatment. Half of the rats received The treatment group healed 21% faster during these early days
egg membrane treatment on the inferior wound, and the other of healing compared with the control group. Overall, however,
half received egg membrane treatment on the superior wound. the wounds healed at indistinguishable rates from days 8 to 21
This was done to control for differences in wound placement. (Figures 2DYE). These results indicate that a wound dressed with
Egg membranes were isolated from pathogen-free eggs chicken-egg membrane heals more rapidly in the early stages of
(Charles River Laboratories). For extraction of membranes, wound healing. The control wounds healed with rates that are
eggs were placed in 70% ethanol for 5 minutes, then dried and similar to other wound-healing studies.10
cracked, and the internal contents disposed. Then the egg mem-
brane was peeled from the shell manually with sterile gloves. DISCUSSION
The egg membranes were dipped in penicillin/streptomycin In this article, the authors show that a traditional folk remedy
solution to prevent infection. Egg white was placed in the middle of dressing a wound with chicken-egg membrane treatment
of the wound and tissue adhesive (Butler Schein Animal Health, (the outer shell membrane) appears to accelerate the early
Dublin, Ohio) on the borders of the membrane. Before waking stages of wound healing. The authors_ data support the idea
from anesthesia, the rats were fitted with restraint jackets (Lomir that this folk remedy provides a benefit to wound treatment,
Biomedical, Inc, Malone, New York) to hamper wound tampering and as a field wound dressing remedy, the application of a
and were kept in these jackets for the duration of the experiment. chicken-egg membrane to a wound might provide benefit over
Five days after wound generation, the dressings were removed, an uncovered wound.
and both wounds were debrided. A 10-megapixel camera (Nikon, The relative rate of healing during the first 5 days was in-
Melville, New York) was used to photograph the wounds from a creased by the addition of the egg membrane. However, the egg
distance of 6 inches above the rats. New egg membranes were membraneYcovered wounds slowed during days 5 to 8 relative to
reapplied to the treated wounds. Membrane replacement, wound the control. The 0 to 5 days represents the lag phase of healing
debridement, and imaging were performed on days 5, 8, and 10 during which disorganized fibroblast migration occurs in order to
and then ceased except for the imaging, which continued on days lay down fibronectin and hyaluronan to act as a scaffold while
12, 14, 16, 18, and 20 of the experiment. A new egg membrane was depositing relatively little collagen.11,12 It is possible that the egg

ADVANCES IN SKIN & WOUND CARE & VOL. 29 NO. 3 132 WWW.WOUNDCAREJOURNAL.COM

Copyright © 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.


ORIGINAL INVESTIGATION

Figure 2.
PROGRESS OF WOUND HEALING BY EGG MEMBRANE TREATMENT

In the examples shown, the anterior wound (left) was untreated, and the posterior wound (right) was dressed with egg membrane. Shown are wounds imaged on (A) day 0, (B) day 5, and (C) day 12.
The white disk in each image is 7 mm in diameter. D, Quantitation of egg membrane effect on wound healing. Shown are the averages of the percentage of healing for the control and egg
membrane-treated wounds for each day for both trials. Error is SEM. E, Table of the significance values for the data for each day of the experiment showing the mean and P values for
each day of the experiment using the Student t test.

membrane provides a scaffold for the fibroblast migration, thus points to closely monitor healing during the early stages of wound
accelerating this lag phase. Other possible mechanisms include healing (days 0Y5). In addition, the application of antibiotics
wound contracture, an added supply of collagen and nutrients should be included in the control wounds.
for healing from the membrane, and/or albumin of egg white As a possible application for this remedy, the egg membranes
assisting in healing. However, because antibiotic application could be incorporated into bandages and used with skin grafts.
was added only to the egg membraneYdressed wounds, it is Moreover, this treatment might be recommended for emergency
possible that this also affected the rate of wound healing. field medicine.
The use of an egg membrane appears to be a safe form of
dressing.1,3,5,6 Caution should be exercised, however, by those POSSIBLE CONFOUNDING VARIABLES
with allergies to eggs. Moreover, as Salmonella often resides The authors_ animal use protocol required placing the egg mem-
outside chicken eggs, there also is a risk of infection. brane in a solution of penicillin plus streptomycin, whereas the
Further investigation of egg membrane efficacy in wound control wound was not exposed to these antibiotics. Because
healing should include histology to probe the mechanism of antibiotics may improve healing by decreasing inflammation,13
increased rate of early healing along with more frequent time this variable may have affected the healing of the dressed

WWW.WOUNDCAREJOURNAL.COM 133 ADVANCES IN SKIN & WOUND CARE & MARCH 2016

Copyright © 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.


ORIGINAL INVESTIGATION

wounds relative to the controls. In addition, the authors had to 4. BackYard Chickens.com blog. http://www.backyardchickens.com/t/744438/uncles-hen-
got-scalped/20. Last accessed January 11, 2016.
remove the dressing and debride both wounds at set intervals
5. Yang JY, Chuang SS, Yang WG, Tsay PK. Egg membrane as a new biological dressing in
in order to measure the extent of wound healing, which may split-thickness skin graft donor sites: a preliminary clinical evaluation. Chang Gung Med J
interfere with the progress of healing,14 but this likely affected 2003:26:153-9.
6. Coover DH. The use of egg membrane in ophthalmic surgery. Ophthal Rec 1899;VIII:223.
both wounds equally.
7. Nakano T, Ikawa NI, Ozimek L. Chemical composition of chicken eggshell and shell
membranes. Poultry Sci 2003;82:510-4.
CONCLUSION 8. Ahn D. Egg Components. Iowa State University. 2010. http://www.public.iastate.edu/~duahn/
teaching/Neobiomaterials%20and%20Bioregulation/Egg%20Components.pdf. Last accessed
In conclusion, the use of a chicken-egg membrane dressing may January 22, 2016.
significantly improve the healing of cutaneous wounds in the 9. Messens W, Grijspeerdt K, Herman L. Eggshell penetration by Salmonella: a review. World
early stages of wound healing.
& Poultry Sci J 2005;61(1):71-86.
10. Greenhalgh DG, Sprugel KH, Murray MJ, Ross R. PDGF and FGF stimulate wound healing
in the genetically diabetic mouse. Am J Pathol 1990;136:1235-46.
REFERENCES 11. Reagan MC, Barbul A. Karolinska Institutet. The Cellular Biology of Wound Healing.
undefined. http://www.neuro.ki.se/neuro/KK2/Jimmy_GoogleCACHE1.html. Last accessed
1. Castro G. Curaciones Caseras. El Universo. 2014. http://www.larevista.ec/orientacion/salud/ January 11, 2016.
curaciones-caseras. Last accessed January 22, 2016. 12. Harley BA, Kim HD, Zaman MH, Yannas IV, Lauffenburger DA, Gibson LJ. Microarchitecture of
2. New York Times archive. Egg membrane for wounds. 1905. http://query.nytimes.com/ three-dimensional scaffolds influences cell migration behavior via junction interactions.
mem/archive-free/pdf?res=9D0DE0DA163EE733A25752C0A9619C946497D6CF. Last Biophys J 2008;95:4013-24.
accessed January 11, 2016. 13. Labro MT. Antibiotics as anti-inflammatory agents. Curr Opin Investig Drugs 2002;3:61-8.
3. Zadik Y. Self-treatment of full-thickness traumatic lip laceration with chicken egg shell 14. Wilcox JR, Carter MJ, Covington S. Frequency of debridements and time to heal: a
membrane. Wilderness Environ Med 2007;18:230-1. retrospective cohort study of 312,744 wounds. JAMA Dermatol 2013;149:1050-8.

CALL FOR PAPERS


Advances in
SKIN&
WOUND CARE
®

Advances in Skin & Wound Care is soliciting manuscripts on


a variety of topics, including original investigations,
clinical concepts, and literature reviews.
Consult the journal’s Web site, www.woundcarejournal.com,
for the Author Guidelines.

ADVANCES IN SKIN & WOUND CARE & VOL. 29 NO. 3 134 WWW.WOUNDCAREJOURNAL.COM

Copyright © 2016 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved.

You might also like