Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Prometheus Books, 59 John Glenn DR, Amherst, New York, $25.95, Pp. 364
Prometheus Books, 59 John Glenn DR, Amherst, New York, $25.95, Pp. 364
, 2000,
Prometheus Books, 59 John Glenn Dr, Amherst, New
York, $25.95, pp. 364
<HR
Reviews of Dr. Arthur Janov's books are difficult to make since they
cover so very much varied and interesting material. It is like being at a
sumptuous banquet and unable to decide which foods to choose. Some
book reviews I have made were about books which had only one
chapter or even less material which was germane to primal therapy.
I was not very interested in reading about brain neurology, physiology
and the role of neurotransmitters. If you are like me and not
particularly interested in those and other neuro-hyphenated subjects,
then skip to the last half of the book. But, be forewarned, if you do,
you will miss some interesting case studies interspersed with those
subjects.
In the Introduction to The Biology of Love Dr. Janov writes that in
1971 neurologists at UCLA's Department of Neurology told him that
it was impossible to relive birth experiences, because such memories
were impossible to store. He writes that this incorrect information
delayed and retarded his work for many years. He said that the
experience proved to him that "we must not be closed-minded to new
approaches." (p. 17)
Janov, the originator of primal therapy, and its chief exponent, has
written an interesting book in which he broadens the commonly used
definition of love to encompass not only the mother's solicitous
relationship with the infant child such as meeting his needs for
tenderness and concern but also includes giving love to the developing
fetus. This means that love is the giving to the fetus what it needs to
develop into a complete person.
If the entire book were to be synopsized in one sentence it would be:
An unloved child has a different kind of physical brain than a loved
child. The damage is not simply psychological. It is neurological and
therefore, physical. Ultimately, it is the lack of love which does us in
before our time, Janov writes. He believes that early trauma causes a
reduction of functioning brain synapses (connections). Does that mean
talking to your baby inutero? No, unlike some authors on regression
therapy, Janov does not go that far. Instead he writes about how
important it is for the pregnant mother not to smoke and to drink little
or no alcohol, and in general being concerned about her own health
when her child is developing.
In the section entitled, How To Love A Brain, Dr. Janov explains that
lack of oxygen during birth or before is also perceived as a lack of
love for the fetus, as is a lack of touch for the post-natal child. We
show love to a child by touching him. Many of his patients, he writes,
suffer from touch deprivation.
Heavily interspersing data from primal theory with neuro-physiology,
neuro-chemistry and neuro-anatomy, the author makes his case that it
is not only birth and the period immediately after birth which causes
neurosis but that even very early intrauterine fetal assaults can harm
the developing child for the rest of his life. He does not write about the
very, very early period of pregnancy, such as, traumas of conception
and implantation.
Dr. Janov has again authored a book which has wonderfully concise
and pithy quotable sentences on just about every page. Some of my
favorites include:
• "The most important stage of child-rearing occurs during the
nine months of pregnancy."
• Drugs take the chemical place of denied love. Oftentimes,
hypersexuality has nothing to do with the sex drive itself. The
"(d)esperation of the sexual need is commensurate with the
early deprivation of love. . ."
• Discussing the drive towards suicide, Janov writes, "It is not
often that the person wants to die. It is rather that the imprint is
that death can end agony. It is that equation from birth that
drives the person both toward and away from death."
• "So many of my patients come in . . . and tell me that they had
very good childhoods. Months later they are writhing on the
padded mat, bewailing their early misery. . . . Nobody suggests
this pain to the patient. It evolves from revisiting one's
childhood. If we rummage around in our personal brain files
there is no telling what we can find."
• "We usually don't die of overweight. . . . We die from the lack
of love that makes us overeat."
• Saying no to drugs, Dr. Janov writes, is saying no "to a
lifetime of emotional deprivation (and) is not easily done." "It's
odd," he writes, "to have a pejorative label attached to us
because we need to kill pain. But if we suffer from an
agonizing imprint from infancy that is just as real and painful
as a broken leg, we may be considered an addict." To consume
illegal drugs is ". . . not a criminal act," he writes, "It is an act
of survival. No one would have to put massive amounts of
painkillers into his system if he did not have pain."
• "For all my heavy smoking patients, birth trauma has been
paramount. The same with the alcoholics."
• "No great fear lies in our system for no reason. If we try to
conquer it, we make it an enemy. It is a friend that tells us
about a life lived, about experiences we have forgotten, and
pain we have buried."
• "Homosexuality gets started so early, it seems genetic."
• ". . . if there were no prebirth and birth trauma, and much love
after birth we would not see . . . panic and anxiety states."
• "It isn't how many times you look at the baby, how many times
you hold him, it is that intangible love you feel while doing it."
• "It is not only a hit in the head that can cause brain damage:
simple neglect can do it too."
• "If there is anything that emotional deprivation involves it is
the lack of touch and caresses very early on."
* * * *