Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5 Assessment of Impacts and Mitigating Measures: 5.1 Generic Significance Criteria
5 Assessment of Impacts and Mitigating Measures: 5.1 Generic Significance Criteria
5 Assessment of Impacts and Mitigating Measures: 5.1 Generic Significance Criteria
The potential noise and vibration impacts during construction are therefore
assessed as Minor Adverse.
Air Quality
The main issues with regard to air quality during construction are:
Dust generated during the earthworks
Dust and particles generated during general construction activities
Exhaust gases from the operation of heavy plant can be a potent source of NOx.
CO, PM and other pollutants.
Impact receptors are:
Construction workers within the site
Nearby lagoon and wetland
The following mitigation measures are proposed to reduce the air quality impacts:
For earthwork operations, construction workers to be enclosed within ventilated
cabs or provided with face masks for potentially dusty earthworks operations
If appropriate, water damping to be used to control dust
Construction plant will be maintained in good running order; all vehicles should
comply with requirements of Road Traffic Act and its subsequent regulations
for emission control.
Solid or shade cloth barriers will be used as appropriate to shield construction
dust along the perimeter of the construction site.
Appropriate setback will be maintained from environmentally sensitive areas;
appropriate shade cloth barriers will be used as appropriate to shied construction
dust.
The potential air quality impacts during construction are therefore assessed
as Minor Adverse.
In order to minimise the risk of reduced water quality during construction the
following measures will be adopted:
Earthworks shall be halted when rain conditions are such that excessive erosion
and silt loaded run-off can be expected.
The construction programme will avoid excessive exposure of bare earth
surfaces which may be prone to erosion.
Care will be taken to avoid excessive mud being transferred by construction
plant to the access road. The vehicles will be driven on firm part of the site to
release excess mud from the wheel before they reach the road. If this becomes
a nuisance, it will be cleared by the Contractor to the satisfaction of the
authorities.
Consideration will be given to undertaking routine maintenance of plant and
vehicles off-site in a properly equipped workshop.
Avoidance of water accumulation and stagnation.
All plant and vehicles shall be maintained in good running order and should
comply with the requirements of Road Traffic Act.
Used oil to be disposed of by approved practices.
Refer to Section 5.3.7 for mitigation measures associated with sewage disposal.
Potential water quality impacts during construction are therefore assessed as
Minor Adverse.
Energy
An electrical supply will be provided for the contractor’s site establishment for a
temporary supply from a suitable location on the existing CEB network (to be
applied for by the contractor if and when required.)
The electrical usage for the contractor’s site establishment will be monitored to
ensure usage is commensurate with construction operations. Efforts will be made
to minimise energy use during construction.
The potential electrical energy usage impacts during construction are
therefore assessed as Minor Adverse.
Water
Potable water will be provided for the welfare of construction workers. A potable
water supply will be provided for the contractor’s site establishment from a
temporary supply from a suitable location on the existing CWA network (to be
applied for by the contractor if and when required).
The potential potable water usage impacts during construction are therefore
assessed as Minor Adverse.
Sewerage
The daily rate of sewage production will evidently depend upon the number of
workers present any day on site, but from past observation, for a site of similar size,
an average of 4 to 7 m³/d can be expected.
Foul effluents will be collected in an appropriate mobile toilet facility that shall be
connected to a conservancy tank.
In order to minimise the impacts of sewage disposal during the construction stage,
the following measures will be adopted:
No. and location of toilet/shower blocks to be adequate for peak no. of
construction workers, facilities to be regularly cleaned.
The Contractor shall ensure that appropriate toilet facilities are available on site
during the whole duration of the works. The toilet block shall be connected to a
conservancy tank and the content of the tank shall be carted away by an
authorised waste carrier to Roche Bois Pumping Station.
Measures to be enforced to ensure that construction workers do not foul areas
surrounding the site.
Potential impacts due to the generation of foul effluents during construction
are therefore assessed as Minor Adverse.
Solid Wastes
Solid waste produced on site will include:
Food wastes from the staff, which will attract stray dogs and cats and rodents
such as rats and sundry vermin
Vegetal remaining after clearing the site
Basalt blocks and surplus earth resulting from earthworks
Asphalt and concrete leftovers
Paper, plastic and metal packages
Pipes, conduits, wires etc.
These solid wastes, will apart from attracting stray animals and other rodents, but
will also constitute a visual impact of untidiness that does not tally with the notion
of improvement of quality of life expected of the Project.
In order to minimise the impacts owing to the generation of solid wastes during
construction stage, the following measures will be adopted:
The Contractor shall put in place a waste management plan aimed at minimising
the production of all wastes.
Where practical, the Contractor shall put measures in place to recycle materials
such as metal off-cuts, some plastics and clean paper/cardboard utilising
existing specialist recycling firms in Mauritius.
A suitable location within the site for placing excess concrete and washing down
equipment will be agreed prior to final removal from site by a licensed waste
operator, or incorporation as backfill material on site.
Non-recyclable materials will be stored in plastic bins, collected and disposed
of through the municipal waste system.
Potentially hazardous wastes shall be stored separately, i.e., hydrocarbon
containers, used batteries.
Waste bins to be provided at toilet blocks, changing areas and other key
locations.
Regular inspections to be made of site and surrounding area to remove litter.
All wastes collected and disposed of regularly by a licensed carrier.
Potential impacts due to the generation of solid wastes during construction are
therefore assessed as Minor Adverse.
Terrestrial Biodiversity
With reference to Section 4.12, the Promoter has considered various options with
respect to the presence of the ESA wetland No.76 on site. The Promoter wishes to
develop the site and fully mitigate its loss by creating a new wetland system around
the northern, eastern and southern perimeters of the site. The Promoter also wishes
to create a native coastal forest due north east of its development and restore the
coastal sand dunes in front of its hotel. A total area of 111,620m² has been allocated
for the implementation of the conservation areas.
A detailed conservation plan together with a detailed wetland management plan will
be prepared prior to the implementation of the project and submitted for approval
to the authorities.
All the proposed works will be implemented with the collaboration of the relevant
authorities.
It is therefore concluded the project impact on the existing wetland results in
a major impacts but the proposed mitigating measures, introduction of a
managed wetland, conservation areas to ensure a similar ecosystem and
performance would result in a moderate adverse impact during the
implementation of the works and a neutral impact in the long term.
Socio-economic
The development will provide employment opportunities during construction.
Subject to the selection of a Main Contractor, it is hoped that some of the labour
will be sourced from the district in order to provide local benefit and increase skills.
Temporary jobs will be created for artisans, masons, electricians, plumber,
carpenters, landscapers, unskilled workers etc.
It is therefore concluded that the employment opportunities during
construction will provide a Moderate Beneficial socio-economic impact.
The seaweed to be demarcated and not be interfered with; ideally installing the
geotextile screen to keep them out the workmen’s reach
Visual check of the work zone every morning and hand-picking of any
significant benthic species for relocation outside the working area.
The potential impact associated with disturbance of the seabed by workers and
materials is therefore assessed as Minor Adverse.
Air Quality
The main issues to consider with regard to air quality during operation are:
Indirect emissions, e.g. through increased traffic, generators etc.
Refrigerant of ozone depleting sources for air conditioning devices
Avoidance of odour nuisance from sewage; refer to Section 5.4.6.
Impact receptors will be:
On-site properties
The following mitigation measures will be recommended to reduce the impacts:
Utilisation of domestic air conditioning devices with zero ozone depleting
substances.
Refer to Section 5.4.5 for mitigation measures associated with sewage disposal.
The potential air quality impacts during operation are therefore assessed as
Minor Adverse.
Hydrology
The main issues to consider with regard to hydrology during operation are:
Managing on-site flood risk
Avoiding increases to off-site flood risk
Impact receivers will be:
On-site properties
Ground water systems
In order to minimise the hydrological impacts during operation, the following
measures will be adopted:
Creation of wetland area 54,030m² to intercept upstream runoff
Storm water network to be inspected and any blockages cleared on frequent
basis.
Road alignments will be designed to ensure that the storm run-off is not
channelled into properties or towards critical infrastructure, even when the
drainage system capacity is exceeded.
Potential impacts to the site hydrology during the operation phase are
therefore assessed as Minor Adverse.
Sewerage
There is no public sewage collection network in the region; therefore all sewage
must be treated and disposed of appropriately on site.
The main issues to consider during operation are:
Avoidance of odour nuisance
Avoidance of contamination of ground water and surface water
Impact receivers will be:
On-site properties
Local/sub-regional surface and ground water users.
In order to minimise potential impacts from disposal of sewage during operation
the following measures will be adopted:
A 450m³ wastewater treatment plant that will be operated in compliance with
the requirements of the Wastewater Management Authority and the standards
of effluents for irrigation as per EPA (2002) as amended in 2008
The wastewater from the kitchen, being normally loaded with oil and grease,
will initially be discharged into a grease trap for the removal of the oil and
grease. The overflow from the grease trap will then be channelled to the
wastewater treatment plant.
The residual grease accumulated in the grease trap will be removed and treated
by a specialist sub-contractor on a regular basis.
The effluent quality after chlorination and filtration will conform to
Environmental Standards for treated effluents for irrigation as per EPA (2002)
as amended in 2008.
Potential impacts associated with sewage disposal during operation phase are
therefore assessed as Negligible Adverse.
Solid Waste
Solid wastes produced during operation will include:
Domestic recyclable materials (e.g. paper, cardboard, plastics, aluminium
cans, etc).
Domestic green waste
Domestic food wastes
Domestic non-recyclable materials
Domestic hazardous materials (e.g. paints, batteries, etc)
Public landscaped area green waste
Impact receptors will be:
An increased load on the municipal waste authority.
Beachcomber Hospitality Investments Ltd shall implement an integrated solid
waste management on site and it will be managed by Don’t Waste Ltd. This shift
in thinking is essential for the implementation of a sustainable resource-efficient
waste management programme which shall integrate recycling, mulching of green
waste and reduction of solid waste sent to La Chaumière Transfer Station and
ultimately to the Mare Chicose Landfill.
Potential impacts due to the generation of solid waste during operation are
therefore assessed as Minor Adverse.
Operation of Jetty
The impacts may be generated by the number of pleasure crafts or powered pirogues
boarding the jetty are:
Hydrocarbon spillage into the sea from the outboard motors powering the
vessels
The generation of turbid sediment plumes as the seabed sediments are sheared
off by the rotating velocity fields induced by propellers and that can be
responsible for the biological destruction of the benthic populations, thereby
deprived of photosynthesis processes.
Mechanical contact between the keels of the vessels, particularly at low tides
and under wave agitation by oars, poles, etc.
The permanent casting over the seabed, of shade from sunlight by the planked
footpath running on top of the jetty.
The main impact receivers will be:
The littoral and beaches adjacent to the jetty, particularly prone to receiving
hydrocarbon spills drifting at the surface to be washed ashore, polluting the
littoral.
The seagrass located with the proximity of the jetty may be destroyed either
biologically by the permanent generation of sediment plumes by propeller, or
mechanically by contact with boats, oars, poles, etc.
The following measures will be enforced to mitigate the adverse impacts described
above:
Outboard motors to be well maintained, in perfect order of operation, with
prohibition of refuelling, servicing, etc on the jetty
The approach to the jetty will be clearly demarcated with buoys towards the
deeper waters to favour travel in deeper waters
Jetty boarding will be strictly limited to the landing platform
Leaving spaces between the planks of the walkway to allow sunlight to reach
the benthos as much as possible; a clearance of 50mm has been allowed for
between each plank.
Potential impacts due to the operation of the jetty is therefore assessed as
Minor Adverse.
Socio-economic
With reference to the social assessment, report in Appendix O, New Mauritius
Hotels Limited is assessing the social needs of the area and shall work in
collaboration with the inhabitants of Grand Rivière Noire VCA to enhance their
quality of life.
It is also anticipated that the development will provide employment opportunities
during operation and this shall benefit the people from the local district.