Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Methodology Lectures - 1st Year B.a.)
Methodology Lectures - 1st Year B.a.)
Undertaking research and writing research papers or reports are integral tasks
for every student to understand some concepts related with methodology and research
introduced for the first time, it is necessary for such students to fully grasp what
concepts, such as methodology, research, an research process, etc., refer to. To reach
throughout the two semesters, beginning with some definitions of the word
‘methodology’ and ending with the different steps of the research process.
I- Definitions of Methodology
Concise Dictionary) It is “the set of methods and principles that are used when
The word research is composed of two syllables, ‘re’ and ‘search.’ ‘re’ is a prefix
meaning again, anew or over again; ‘search’ is a verb meaning to examine closely
-6-
and carefully, to test and try, or to probe. The word ‘research’ refers to the careful,
acceptable scientific methodology to solve problems and create new knowledge that
When you undertake a research work, there are two important decisions to make:
1. What you want to find out about or what research questions (problems) you want to
There are practical steps through which you must pass in your research
journey in order to find answers to your research questions. The path to finding
been stated that “... the mark of a good education is not how much you know, but how
good you are at finding out what you need to know.”(B. A. Chin, How to Write a
topic that you have researched. Generally, you do research on a topic about which
you are not an expert, but you can learn about it by reading the work of experts, i.e.
by doing research. In the end, you can communicate in writing what you have learned
-7-
Writing a research paper can be a daunting task. It requires persistence, attention
to detail, and a willingness to read, revise, and perfect what was written – many times
if necessary.
Very often students wonder whether it is worth writing a research paper. In other
words, they usually ask what they will gain from doing research and writing a paper.
The answer to this question depends on the purpose of writing a research paper, but in
general this will give the students experience in doing research and writing research
papers as there are great chances that the process will be done more than once.
Moreover, the student will learn a great deal about a topic that interests him/ her. This
means that the student might end up an expert in a given subject. Finally, the most
important thing is that the students will gain the experience of taking on a task from
the very beginning to the end, and experience the pride of having accomplished
something.
1. Formulating/ identifying the research problem (i.e. deciding what you want to find
2. Reviewing literature extensively (i.e. looking for similar studies that have been
done) and collecting the data (i.e. gathering sources in the form of questionnaires,
3. Taking notes
-8-
7. Presenting the paper (i.e. informing the others what has been done, what has been
discovered, and what conclusions have been drawn from the findings.)
-9-
STEP 1: FORMULATING/IDENTIFYING THE RESEARCH
PROBLEM
(Finding a Topic)
Choosing a topic for a research paper is the first, and probably, most difficult step
in the research process. This step is sometimes done by the teachers when they
choose a topic for their students, especially when giving them assignments. But many
teachers leave this job up to the students. Although choosing your own topic means
more work and more thinking, it allows you to find a topic you are truly interested in
Choosing one’s own topic is, therefore, a difficult step that can be facilitated by
considering a number of guidelines. First of all, you need to choose a topic that really
interests you. This will motivate you all the way through your research work, because
the more you learn about your topic, the more enthusiastic you become in finding out
new details. Some students may think that the best way to formulate a topic is by
choosing an ‘easy’ one. It is, however, worth noting that by doing so, these students
will spend weeks or even months thinking, reading, and writing about a topic that
Secondly, choose a topic that you can handle. Some topics are hard to handle
because they are too large, or too broad. These are topics that no single person can
cover every aspect of them. For instance, you can never handle a topic as broad as the
French colonization in Algeria. It is better for you to narrow the scope of your topic
to facilitate your job. Even very narrow topics can sometimes change into broad ones
- 10 -
as you start reading and finding out more about them. On the other hand, some topics
can be too limited. Accordingly, you might have trouble writing more than a few
pages about a topic of this kind. In this respect, two questions may come to mind:
When do we know a topic is too broad? And when do we know a topic is too narrow?
framework for examining the research problem and the methods needed to analyze it;
► it can be discussed in great detail in less than the required size of your paper;
► you do not find enough information and what you do find is irrelevant;
► you find information that is so specific that it cannot lead to any significant
conclusions;
► your sources cover so few ideas that you cannot expand them into a significant
paper.
- 11 -
History
of my House
( )
History of my Town
( )
History of my Country
( )
Thirdly, choose a topic about which you can find enough information and
documents. After you chose a topic that seems neither too broad nor too narrow, ask
yourself whether you will find enough information to tackle it. You may choose a
topic that appears fascinating and can even be the basis of a great research paper, but
the only information about it is one or two articles. Another example is that you may
choose a topic that is interesting to very few people; therefore, only a few experts
have written about it. In both cases, such topics cause the students more work and
To make sure you will be able to find enough information about a given topic, it is
1- Look up your topic in an encyclopedia. If you find a good-sized article with a list of
related subjects at the end, this is a sign that you are more likely to find enough
- 12 -
2- Check out the library (in department, school, university, city, etc.) catalogue. Finding
at least three books is an encouraging sign. These books may direct you to other
3- Use search engines on the Internet to do a keyword search. Visit some of the sites
suggested to you and see if they provide reliable information that you can later use in
your research.
If after following these steps you do not find enough information about your
topic, or the sources you find are beyond your level, it is time for you to choose a
new topic!
As mentioned earlier, choosing the right topic for a research paper (one which you
find interesting, which is neither too broad nor too narrow, and about which you will
be able to find enough documents) is an important and difficult step. There are,
however, some ways that are likely to help the student choose the right topic to be
dealt with.
1. An Idea Web
A web is a kind of graphic organizer that helps you organize your ideas visually.
An idea web is based on the principle that one idea leads to another until the student
comes up with the final idea that will constitute the starting point for a research paper.
which you write the first topic that comes to your mind. Write other related topics you
can think of in smaller circles around the first circle. After that, draw lines to link
between the original circle and the smaller ones. The topics in the small circles may
produce more ideas that you can put in even smaller circles. Continue in this way as
- 13 -
much as you can. In the end, there will undoubtedly be an idea that clicks for you (as
shown below):
- 14 -
2. Brainstorming
many ideas as they can to find a solution to a specific problem or a final idea for a
project. Brainstorming a topic for a research paper works exactly in the same way,
except that the student does it alone. This consists in writing down topics that come to
the student’s mind. To be able to do this, you need to free your mind and let the ideas
flow. Even if some ideas may seem totally inappropriate in the beginning, this does
not matter because the purpose is to generate the maximum of ideas. One idea at least
The difference between an idea web and a brainstorm is that all the ideas in an
idea web flow from one related topic to another; however, the ideas in a brainstorm
3. Freewriting
writing down the thoughts that come to your mind without stopping. As one thought
flows freely into another, you will begin to make connections to ideas that interest
you. Eventually, you may come up with ideas that are appealing. Review your
freewriting and underline the most interesting ideas for you. Write more about these
ideas until you find the topic you can develop into a research paper.
but I’ll just write it down anyway. OK, here goes. I could write about,
uh, rabbits! That’s the first thing I thought of. Maybe because I just
read that book about rabbits called Watership Down. The rabbits in the
- 15 -
book could talk. Rabbit communication—I don’t think I’ll find much
communicates in lots of ways. I’d like to know more about what she’s
If a topic is too broad, it should not be discarded altogether just because of this
reason. There are a few strategies that students need in order to narrow a topic down
to a size that they can handle. Some of these strategies are as follows:
1- Asking Questions
One way of narrowing a topic is by asking Wh-questions (who, what, where, why,
which, when and how) to find out more information about it. For instance, a topic
about ‘plants’ is too broad, so you can narrow it by asking the following questions:
Such questions may give birth to topics like “Plant Life in the Desert” or “Plants in
A topic about ‘health’ is too broad and needs to be narrowed. This can be done by
- 16 -
► What specific issues am I interested in – careers in health care, trainings in
health care, specific disorders or diseases, the state of health care in the country,
etc.?
Such questions may lead us to formulate an interesting and more specific topic, such
as:
A pyramid diagram is a graphic organizer that can be used by students who are
- 17 -
Dangerous
Diseases
Organic Mental
Diseases Diseases
A target diagram is another type of graphic organizer which is used when you
want to generate more than two ideas from the preceding idea (as in the pyramid
diagram). This diagram gives you more freedom in terms of the ideas that flow from
one another.
- 18 -
Pictures of the desert trees cited above
- 19 -
IV- Broadening a Topic
Sometimes you may find that there is not enough information on a topic that will
allow you to develop it into a research paper. If this happens, do not immediately give
up your intention to investigate the idea because it could very well be an excellent
topic for a research paper. One way of broadening your topic is to look for parallels
and opportunities for broader associations that apply to the initial research problem.
A good strategy for doing this is to ask yourself basic Wh-questions (who, what,
where, when, how, and why). Reflecting upon these questions during your initial
review of the literature can help you formulate ways to expand your initial research
problem. Once you have identified additional directions in which to proceed with
You can also broaden your topic by including related subjects. In other words,
your initial narrow topic can be broadened by including related aspects identified
during your initial research. You can also do that by expanding your topic
geographically, i.e. select a larger geographic area. You can expand your topic
Finally, you can broaden your topic by examining a larger problem or multiple
concepts or issues.
After you have succeeded in defining the topic of your paper, you can move to the
next step: start your research work. However, it is very important to schedule your
work right from the beginning in order to hand your work on time. This consists in
estimating the time you will need to finish each task. Since the date you will present
your paper does not change, stick to your schedule as much as you can.
- 20 -
Task Planned date to Date
finish finished
Finding a topic
Preliminary research
Collecting data
Extensive reading
Creating an outline
- 21 -
STEP 2: LITERATURE REVIEW & COLLECTION OF DATA
Some early research has already been done by some students to find a topic for
their research papers. The sources used need to be explored again but with more
I- Literature Review
The word ‘literature’ is used here in its broad sense to mean a collection of all the
scholarly writings on a topic. These writings can be in the form of scholarly articles
proceedings. The literature may also include dissertations written by other students.
Generally, the literature forms like a chain of works. There are major works that
have been written on a topic, and then other, later, works build on them. Often, these
later works tend to be extending or responding to the original papers. Therefore, the
that interact with each other. Your job as a researcher in the literature review is to see
where all the loose ends (incomplete parts) are in the various fields that are most
closely related to what you want to do and to figure out what needs to be done next.
- 22 -
II- Exploration of Your Topic
1- Where to Begin
Encyclopedias and the Internet are the best means to get basic information about a
topic.
A. Encyclopedias
General encyclopedias are very good means to begin the exploration of one’s
topic. They generally do not delve deeply into topics, but they give the broad
they do not provide enough information. A general encyclopedia that has separate
books for each one or two letters is better. In addition, there are encyclopedias that
focus on a single topic which might have been chosen by a student. In this case, the
student will find it much easier to get the information they need to start their research
- 23 -
General Encyclopedia
- 24 -
One-Volume Single-Topic Encyclopedias
- 25 -
B. The Internet
Thanks to the extensive range of information resources and services it carries, the
Internet has become the most used means of research throughout the world. Billions
of users around the world surf the Net to explore and use the information provided by
engines (such as Google, Yahoo!, excite, Bing, WebCrawler, etc.) can be used to do a
keyword-search that will lead to a list of websites related to a given topic. The student
can then decide which ones are to be consulted to gather information about their
topic. However, not all websites contain reliable information, so the student should be
careful and selective. For instance, website addresses ending in ‘.edu’ (standing for
‘education’) mean that the sites are connected to a college, university, school, or other
Examples: mit.edu
stanford.edu
harvard.edu
educause.edu
- 26 -
Examples of most commonly used internet search engines:
- 27 -
2- Asking Questions
Once the student has got a broad overview of their topic, he/she knows enough to
start asking questions – an important step in any research work. Having specific
research questions to answer all along the research process helps the student find the
sources that are most helpful. Moreover, the questions help the student focus on what
information they want their paper to contain and how to organize it.
The Wh-questions (what, where, when, why, which, who, and how) are likely to
guide students in developing their list of research questions which will help them find
out the kind of information they need. The research questions can also give the
student an idea of how the paper might take shape (number of sections, chapters,
divisions, etc.)
Collection of data constitutes one of the most important tasks in the research
process which will definitely determine the quality of the research work.
specific sources to use when they begin taking notes for their paper. The best place to
start is the library catalog which includes a list of all the books in the library. Today,
many library catalogs are online and this makes search much quicker and easier. The
student can search the library catalog in three ways: by subject, by title, or by author.
In all cases, the student will get a list of all the books in the library, including the
author, the title, and the call number. This latter is very important because it allows
the student or the librarian to find the book easily on the shelves where books are
placed in numerical order according to the call number (See illustrations below).
- 28 -
Example of an Online Library Catalog
- 29 -
Traditional Index Catalog
Index Card
- 30 -
2- The Periodical Index
basis, i.e. weekly, monthly, annually, etc. It includes academic journals, magazines,
professors, experts, and researchers. It is usually free from any advertising and is
average person and provides information about current issues and events.
Periodicals contain useful information which is often more up-to-date than what
you find in books. The articles in periodicals are sometimes just a few weeks or days
- 31 -
Examples of Foreign Academic/Scholarly Journals
- 32 -
Examples of Algerian Academic/Scholarly Journals
(University of Adrar)
- 33 -
Examples of Magazines/Popular Journals
- 34 -
A periodical index helps you locate articles related to your research topic. It
includes the author’s name (when available), title of the articles, name of the journal,
the volume, the issue, and the pages on which the article appears. Some indexes
Periodical indexes are available for different subject areas. Each index covers a
- 35 -
3- Other Sources
In addition to books and periodicals, other sources can be very useful to your
research and provide you with up-to-the-minute (i.e. latest) information to enrich your
work.
The Internet can be used to find newspaper articles. Today, many newspapers are
available on the Net and have websites that offer an indexed list of all the articles they
www.echoroukonline.com/ara/ (Echorouk)
www.liberte-algerie.com (Liberté)
- 36 -
Examples of Renowned National and Foreign Newspapers
- 37 -
B. Television and Radio
These can also constitute a reliable source of information for your topic. If the
student listens to some programs as part of their research, they have to note down the
name of the program, the station, the date and time of the broadcast.
C. Personal Interviews
Interviewing experts on a given topic may yield precious information that will
enrich a paper and add more interest to a research. However, interviews may be left to
the end of the research, for the student may not know what questions he/she wants to
ask until he/she has completed the work. Interviews can be used to answer questions
- 38 -
STEP 3: TAKING NOTES
Now that the sources have been identified, the researcher can start taking notes on
the information. This is also one of the most important steps in the research process,
While articles and some short books can be read in a reasonable amount of time,
other books may be too long and may cover much more than the student’s topic.
Therefore, they take more time to be read. To save time, the students can use the table
of contents and the index in longer books to find the parts or pages that contain the
information they need for their topic. By doing this, the students can skip the parts
that do not relate to their research work and get the needed information as quickly and
efficiently as possible.
- 39 -
Examples of contents pages
- 40 -
II- Taking Notes on Note Cards
One of the biggest mistakes some students make is to start reading a book and
writing down information on a sheet of paper. By doing this, the student will end up
with a lot of disorganized scribbling that may be totally useless when they outline
their paper and write a first draft. To avoid this, it is recommended to take notes on
index cards.
When you start reading your sources, use index cards (3”x5” or 4”x6”) to write
down information that might be used in the paper. It is, however, important to write
only one idea and all the notes about it on one card. After you have completed a note
card, write the source and the number of the pages from which you took the
information. Finally, in the upper corner of the note card, write one or two words that
describe the specific subject of the card so that you know exactly what information
Knowing what to write on the note cards is very important because strong notes
- 41 -
1- What to write
While undertaking your research, you may come across a lot of interesting pieces
use in your paper. Taking notes on every single detail will lead to a huge amount of
notes that you will not be able to handle. Therefore, always remember that the notes
you take are supposed to help you answer your research questions. On the other hand,
you can save time by taking notes in shorthand which is a quick way of writing that
uses signs to represent words to avoid writing them in full. For instance:
≠ : does not equal, is not the same as, does not result in
+ : and, also, plus
– : minus, without
>< : between
= : equals, is the same as, results in
≈ : is approximately equal to, is similar to
↑ : increase, rise, growth
↓ : decrease, fall, shrinkage
: therefore, thus, consequently
: because
→ : leads to, produces, causes
x : no, not, incorrect
: yes, correct
? : uncertain, possibly, unproven
# : number
: special, important
: change
etc. : etcetera, and so on
i.e. : that is
w/ : with
w/o : without
e.g. : for example
ppl : people
ntl : national
- 42 -
ltd : limited
gvt : government
dpt : department
diff : difference/different, difficulty/difficult
imp : important
lge : language
Q : question
A : answer
stdt(s): student(s)
v : very
vs : against
Examples:
❖ of ↓ of oil price in intl markets gvt decided its ntl dvpt policy
Because of the fall of oil price in international markets the government decided to
Correct answers are sometimes difficult to find without help from other people.
One of the most common problems with research papers is plagiarism. A paper
Internet constitutes plagiarism. The latter means also representing other people’s
work and ideas as your own. In other words, it is copying someone else’s words and
claiming them as your own. Very often, this problem starts at the note-taking step
when the student copies the exact words from a source. Though not always deliberate,
- 43 -
this act is a serious offense in school, and it can result in different penalties, including
expulsion.
One way to avoid plagiarism is to paraphrase. This means writing down ideas in
your own words rather than copying them. Paraphrasing involves putting a passage
from source material into your own words. A paraphrase must also be attributed to
the original source. Paraphrased material is usually shorter than the original passage,
❖ Original passage:
❖ Legitimate paraphrase:
recorded verbatim.
❖ Plagiarized version:
Students often use too many direct quotations when they take notes,
probably only about 10% of the final copy should consist of directly
- 44 -
quoted material. So it is important to limit the amount of source
3- Quoting
Copying the exact words of an author is acceptable when quotation marks are put
around the author’s words and his/her work is mentioned. In this way, a credit is
given to the real writer of the words. Quoting from a source is perfectly permissible
though it should not be done frequently. Quotations are used only to support the
researcher’s idea(s); therefore, they can in no way replace it/ them (ideas). A
quotation should be used only when it provides very interesting information that
readers will find very instructive. However, the best quotations lose their effect if too
many of them are used. If a paper contains so many quotations, one after another, the
readers may wonder where the part written by the researcher himself/herself is! In
Use quotes when a writer says something so well that you could
confusing than the original. Quote when the original words carry with
them some importance that helps make a point, such as when the
Do not, however, fill your research paper with quote after quote. If
you do, your reader is likely to conclude that you really have few or
no ideas of your own on the subject or that you have not studied and
The citizen-investor serves his fellow citizens badly by his inclination to withdraw
from the community. He tends to serve himself badly as well. He does so by focusing
his pursuit of happiness on something that very seldom makes people happy in the
In his essay, “United Shareholders of America,” Jacob Weisberg insists that “The
citizen-investor serves his fellow citizens badly by his inclination to withdraw from
happiness on something that very seldom makes people happy in the way they expect
it to.”
After having used all the sources and taken all the notes, an organization of
the note cards is necessary to turn them into a powerful tool that helps you outline and
The advantage of using index cards to take notes is that you can organize them
in any way you want, and you can lay them out where you can see them all at once.
The first thing to do is to sort all the cards with the same headlines into the same pile
(since they are all about the same basic idea). After that, arrange the piles in an order
that makes sense to you. Experts have suggested six types of order. You can either
- 46 -
1- Chronological (or Time) Order
This covers events in the order in which they happened. This kind of order is
2- Spatial Order
This organizes the information by its place or origin. This order works best for
This discusses how one event or action leads to another. This kind of organization
can work for papers which explain a scientific process or historical events.
4- Problem/Solution
This explains a problem and one or more ways to solve it. This kind of order can
This deals with similarities and differences between people, things, events, or
ideas.
6- Order of Importance
This explains an idea, starting with its most important aspects and ending with the
- 47 -
Examples of note cards organization:
- 48 -