Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Diffusible Hydrogen Measurement in Welding Consumables Using A New Proton-Exchange-Membrane Based Hydrogen Sensor
Diffusible Hydrogen Measurement in Welding Consumables Using A New Proton-Exchange-Membrane Based Hydrogen Sensor
net/publication/239525118
CITATIONS READS
0 760
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Development of weld pattern analyzer for quality analysis of arc welding process View project
Influence of cutting process on the development of residual stress in AISI 304L stainless steel View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Girish Kumar Padhy on 06 June 2014.
Abstract
A new proton exchange membrane based hydrogen sensor (PEMHS) has been used for the
measurement of diffusible hydrogen in welding consumables. Hydrogen evolved from the specimen is
collected in a chamber filled with argon gas and concentration of hydrogen in the gas was measured
using the sensor. The PEMHS is a fuel cell based device and uses nafion as proton exchange membrane.
The sensing electrode is palladium black and the counter electrode is platinum black. The electrolyte is
sandwiched between the barriers and a diffusion barrier at the sensing electrode side limits the supply of
hydrogen to the sensing electrode. The sensing electrode is exposed to hydrogen in argon and the
counter electrode to air. The limiting current produced is linearly dependant on concentration of
hydrogen in argon and hence the sensor is an amperometric device. This sensor is very sensitive and can
accurately measure hydrogen in ppm level in the inert gas mixture. Hence in addition to the total
diffusible hydrogen evolved from the weld after 72 hours of exposure at ambient temperature, the sensor
can also detect hydrogen evolution from the sample as a function of time. The paper presents the
principles of hydrogen measurement using this sensor, its applications for diffusible hydrogen
measurements and the results obtained on diffusible hydrogen measurement of indigenously developed
modified 9Cr-1Mo electrodes.
Key Words:
Diffusible Hydrogen content, Hydrogen Diffusivity, Nafion Based Hydrogen Sensor, Polymer
Electrolyte Membrane, Diffusible Hydrogen Evolution
Introduction
Hydrogen Assisted Cracking (HAC) is a serious problem in ferritic and martensitic steel weld
metal and in the heat affected zone (HAZ) of the weld joints. The diffusible hydrogen content in welding
consumables is used extensively for predicting the susceptibility of weldment to HAC [1]. As the cracks
are not allowed in weld joints, formation of these cracks should be prevented. The main source of
hydrogen in welds is the moisture content present in the flux coating of the electrode [2]. Other sources
include shielding gas, the oil /grease on the surface to be welded and the surrounding atmosphere.
During welding, the high temperature generated in the welding arc causes dissociation of water molecule
into hydrogen and oxygen and dissolution/absorption of the atomic hydrogen in the weld pool from the
arc atmosphere. The solubility of hydrogen in ferritic steel is less than 2 ppm at room temperature. As
the cooling rate is rapid in welds, no equilibrium is attained and the supersaturated hydrogen in the weld
metal diffuses into the HAZ or out of the weld during solidification and subsequent cooling of the weld.
Most of it is trapped at various defects such as grain boundaries, lath boundaries, dislocations etc. in the
weld and in the HAZ. Not all the supersaturated hydrogen is free to diffuse. Diffusion of hydrogen is
possible only if it is released from the traps which in turn depend upon the binding energy of the traps.
Hence only a part of the total hydrogen tends to diffuse at or near room temperature which is referred as
diffusible hydrogen (HD). The diffusible hydrogen interacts with the defects in the weld causing HAC.
Hence, diffusible hydrogen content in the weld metal shall be controlled to decrease cracking in the weld
joints of steels. This in turn requires measurement of diffusible hydrogen in the weld metal by a suitable
technique. As one of the major sources of hydrogen is the consumables, high diffusible hydrogen
content indicates hydrogen introduced from the welding consumable into the weld metal is high. Hence,
diffusible hydrogen content (HD – ml of hydrogen in 100 g of weld metal) is used to classify the welding
consumables on the basis of their hydrogen content. HD content is also useful to predict the minimum
preheat temperature to be employed during welding of steels to avoid cracking [3,4]. The estimation of
HD content from a weld is carried out by allowing hydrogen from the weld to diffuse out for a given time
at a fixed temperature and measuring its volume. The standard methods recommended by ISO, AWS,
DIN, BIS etc. are gas chromatography method and mercury method [5,6,7,8,9]. With both of these
methods measurement of diffusible hydrogen is done at high accuracy. Both the methods have a 1:1
correlation with the results obtained for HD content in ml/100 g of weld [10]. However, these methods
are not without drawbacks. One of the limitations with the mercury method is that the handling of
mercury is hazardous. In this method, only that diffusible hydrogen is measured which is evolved within
72 h of the welding at ambient temperature is measured where as the continuation of diffusible
hydrogen evolution for over 21 days has been reported[11] Also this method uses 72 hours for hydrogen
evolution which is time consuming. The gas chromatography method consumes lesser time (typically
~6 h); but hydrogen evolution is conducted at high temperatures. Another method which was in use but
now being discarded is the glycerin method [12,13]. Determination of HD content by mass spectrometer
has been also reported [14,15].
Recently a sensor for quantitative measurement of hydrogen content in gas mixtures were
developed from a conducting polymer prepared from Polyvinyl Alcohol (PVA) and phosphoric acid as
electrolyte membrane in an Amperometric Hydrogen Sensor operated in the fuel cell mode [16].The
feasibility of PVA based amperometric hydrogen sensor for diffusible hydrogen measurement has been
demonstrated [ 17 , 18 ]. The performance of the sensor agrees well with that of the standard Gas
Chromatography method [17]. The advantages of using the PVA based sensor are, it is simple in
construction, compact, cheaper and can be used in field applications to measure HD in welds. The
chamber can also be designed for HD measurements at elevated temperatures. As the long term stability
of the PVA membrane was poor, a new proton exchange membrane in which Nafion is replaced with the
PVA has been developed and this sensor shows better stability than that based on PVA. The new sensor
operates in fuel cell mode with a mechanical barrier limiting the supply of hydrogen to the sensing side
electrode. The sensor is designed as a two electrode device for hydrogen measurement in a gas mixture
containing hydrogen. Either platinum or palladium was used at the sensing electrode side and platinum
at counter electrode side. [ 19 ]. The present paper discusses the diffusible hydrogen measurements
carried out on standard specimens, which were prepared using modified 9Cr-1Mo steel base plate and
electrode. The sensor directly displays the response corresponding to the current generated due to the
hydrogen using the stored calibration parameters on a display unit and the in situ data acquisition is
done.
Experimental
Materials required for the Measurement
Test specimen preparation
The diffusible hydrogen measurements were done with indigenously developed modified 9Cr-
1Mo steel. The chemical composition of this steel is given in Table 1.The 9Cr-1Mo steel is available as
12 mm thick plate from which test specimens of dimension 30 mm x 15 mm x10 mm are machined out
as prescribed by ISO 3690. Run-on and run-off pieces of dimension 44 mm x 15 mm x 10 mm are also
machined out. The dimensional tolerance of the triplicate pieces are within ± 0.25 mm and all surfaces
are finished at right angles to ensure good contact between adjacent pieces. The schematic diagram of
test piece assembly which is shown in Fig. 1.
Table. 1 Chemical composition in Wt% of modified 9Cr-IMo steel plate and an electrode
Material C Cr Mo Mn Ni S P V Nb Cu N AI
Base metal 0.10 9.50 1.00 0.39 0.14 0.009 0.021 0.250 0.10 ------- 0.065 0.024
Electrode 0.10 9.00 1.00 0.70 0.70 0.012 0.009 0.017 0.06 0.05 0.055 0.010
The specimen chamber [20,21] used to collect diffusible hydrogen is essentially a stainless steel
chamber having an inlet and an outlet connected to needle valves. The chamber can be opened or closed
using a plug and the leak tightness of the plug is ensured with the help of an O-ring. Further by
performing Helium Leak Test of the chamber it is ensured that the leak rate of the chamber is less than
10 -9 std cc/min. Fig.3 shows the schematic of the specimen chamber along with plug. The volume of the
chamber is measured by filling it with distilled water and draining the water completely into a measuring
jar and measuring the volume of water.
1
2
8
Sample
Gas 3 Exit
7
4
Sampling 6
loop 5
Sampling
loop
(a) Mode 1
Hydrogen
Sensor
1
2
8
Sample 3
Gas 7
Exit
4
Sampling 6
5
Loop
Carrier
Gas
(b) Mode 2
Fig.4 Operation of eight-port sampling valve
The hydrogen sensor
The main component of the sensor is a conducting polymer, nafion. The polymer was cast as a
film, coated with palladium black on the sensing side, with platinum on the counter side and electrical
leads were taken. The sensing side of the coated polymer was exposed to the hydrogen argon gas
mixture while the counter side was exposed to air. Thus the sensor consisted of hydrogen exposed inner
palladium film and air exposed outer platinum film with the conducting polymer nafion sandwiched
between them and this acted as a fuel cell. A schematic representation of the sensor with conducting
leads is shown in Fig.5. Hydrogen present in the Ar-H2 mixture gets adsorbed at the sensing electrode
and looses its electron to form H+ which conducts through the polymer to reach the counter electrode
where it reacts with oxygen to form H2O. The signal corresponding to the short circuit current thus
produced due to conduction of hydrogen ion through the polymer was measured which in turn is used to
measure the concentration of hydrogen in the sampling chamber.
0 .0 6
Sensor Signal (a.u.)
1010 ppm
0 .0 5
0 .0 4 757 ppm
0 .0 3
505 ppm
0 .0 2
252 ppm
0 .0 1
0 .0 0
0 500 1000 1500 2000
T im e ( s )
Fig.6 Response of the hydrogen sensor for different concentration of hydrogen in H 2-Ar mixture.
0 .0 5 0
L in e a r R e g re s s io n
Y = A + B * X
0 .0 4 5
P a ra m e te r V a lu e E rro r
------------------------------------------------------------
0 .0 4 0 A -0 .0 0 2 4 0 .0 0 1 4 5
B 4 .7 6 4 E -5 2 .1 1 9 2 5 E -6
------------------------------------------------------------
Peak Height in a.u.
0 .0 3 5
R SD N P
------------------------------------------------------------
0 .0 3 0 0 .9 9 8 0 3 0 .0 0 1 1 8 4 0 .0 0 1 9 7
------------------------------------------------------------
0 .0 2 5
0 .0 2 0
0 .0 1 5
0 .0 1 0
200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100
C o n c . o f H 2 in p p m
Fig.7 Calibration curve for hydrogen sensor obtained using standard Ar-H 2 mixtures
2.0
Polynomial Regression
y = a + b1*x + b2*x^2 + b3*x^3 + b4*x^4 + b5*x^5
1.5
Parameter Value Error
------------------------------------------------------------
a -0.05923 0.0102
b1 0.04178 0.00122
1.0 b2 -3.95733E-4 3.9669E-5
b3 2.3496E-6 5.09042E-7
b4 -7.71073E-9 2.79501E-9
b5 1.03687E-11 5.49691E-12
------------------------------------------------------------
0.5
R-Square(COD) SD N P
------------------------------------------------------------
0.99999 0.00556 7 0.00498
0.0
0 50 100 150 200
Time in Hours
Fig 8. Cumulative hydrogen content from the weld sample as a function of time
two successive measurement (ml/100g of weld metal)
0.035
0.025
0.020
0.015
0.010
0.005
0.000
Fig. 9 Variation of hydrogen evolution from the specimen with time expired after welding.
Conclusion
Major conclusions from this study are the following
a) The proton-exchange-membrane based hydrogen sensor has been successfully
employed for measuring diffusible hydrogen content in the welding consumables and to
study evolution of hydrogen from the weld as a function of time.
b) Hydrogen evolution from the standard specimen for HD measurement is maximum during
initial hours and decreases exponentially with time. However, it is found that hydrogen
evolution continues even after 72h, the maximum duration for hydrogen evolution in most
of the tests.
Acknowledgements
Authors thank S/Shri. M. Arul and D. Manokaran of Materials Joining Section, IGCAR for the
help extended for the preparation of the weld specimen and Shri A.V. Vinod of Radiochemistry
Division, IGCAR for diffusible hydrogen measurement.
Reference
1) Yurioka, N., Suzuki, H. 1990 Hydrogen assisted cracking in C-Mn low alloy steel weldments. International Materials
Reviews 35(4):217-249
2) Doc.IIS/IIW-805-85, 1985.The measurement of weld hydrogen levels. Welding in the world 23 (3/4): 50-62
3) Suzuki, H. and Terasaki, T.: Estimating critical stress and pre heat temperature to avoid cold cracking in implant and
JIS- Y (Tekken Tests), IIW, Doc.IX-1417-86, 1986
4) Ito, Y and Bessyo, K.: Weldability Formulae of High Strength Steels Related to Heat Effected Zone Cracking: IIW
Doc.IX-567-68 (1968)
5) DIN 8572 Part 1 Determination of Diffusible Hydrogen in Weld Metal- Manual Metal Arc Welding Deutsches
Institut fur Normurg e.V., Berlin (1981)
6) AWS A4.3- 86 Standard Method for Determination of Diffusible Hydrogen Content of Martensitic, Bainitic and
Ferritic Steel Weld Metal Produced by Arc Welding, American Welding Society, Miami, Florida (1986)
7) ISO 3690- 1976(E) Welding- Determination of Hydrogen in Deposited Weld Metal Arising from the Use of Covered
Electrodes for Welding Mild and Low Alloy Steels International Organization for Standardization (1976)
8) IS- 11802- 1986, Methods of Determination of Diffusible Hydrogen Content of Deposited Weld Metal from Covered
Electrodes for Welding Mild and Low Alloy Steels, Bureau of Indian standards New Delhi (1986)
9) Japanese Standards Association. Method of Measurement for Hydrogen Evolved from Steel Welds, JIS Z3118-1986.
Tokyo
10) Kotecki, D.J. AND La Fave, R.A. 1985 AWS A5 Committee Studies of Weld Metal Diffusible Hydrogen. Welding
Journal 64(3): 31-37
11) Ravi, R., Honavar, D.S.: Hydrogen in Steel Weldments – A Review, Technical document, D&H SECHERON,
Indore
12) Quintana, M.A.: A Critical Evaluation of Glycerin Test, Welding Journal, 73(5) 141s (1984)
13 ) Siewert, T.A. 1988. Testing of Welding Electrodes for Diffusible Hydrogen and Coating Moisture Hydrogen
Embrittlement Prevention and Control, ASTM STP 962, ed. L. Raymond, ASTM, Philadelphia, Pa, pp 238- 246
14) Noble, D.N., 1985. HAZ Hydrogen Measurement during Weld Cladding. Metal Construction 17(11): 754-757
15) Pressouyre, G. M., Lemoine, L., Dubois, D.J.M., Leblonde, J. Saillard, P.R., and Faure, F.M., 1988. In situ
measurement of hydrogen in weld heat affected zones through Mass Spectrometry and computer Analysis.Ref.6, 219-
237
16 ) An Improved Polymer Electrolyte Based Amperometric Hydrogen Sensor, Ramesh, C., Velayutham, G.,
Murugesan, N., Ganesan, V., Dhathathreyan, K.S., Periaswami, G., Journal of Solid State Electrochemistry, 2003,
Vol.7, Iss.8, pp.511-516.
17) Albert, S.K., Ramesh, C., Murugesan, N., Gill, T.P.S., Periaswami, G. and Kulkarni, S.D.: A New Method to
Measure Diffusible Hydrogen Content in Steel Weldments Using a Polymer Electrolyte Based Hydrogen Sensor,
Welding Research Supplement, July 1997, 251s-255s
18) Albert, S.K. and Gill, T.P.S: Measurement of Diffusible Hydrogen in Weldments- A status Report Indian Welding
journal, 29(2), 1996
19 ) C. Ramesh & N. Murugesan & M. V. Krishnaiah & V. Ganesan & G. Periaswami Improved Nafion-based
amperometric sensor for hydrogen in argon, journal of solid state electrochemistry, Volume 12, No. 9, (2008) pp. 1109-
1116
20) Lundin, C.D., Milton, R., Henning, J.A., and Richy, R.A. 1986 Hydrogen assisted Cracking Sensitivity of Cr-Mo
steels During welding, Advances in Welding Science and Technology. ed. S.A. David , ASM International, Materials
Park, Ohio, pp. 585-596
21 ) Quintana, M.A. and Dannecker, J.R.: Diffusible Hydrogen Testing by Gas Chromatography in Hydrogen
Embrittlement and Control Ed. L. Raymond, ASTM STP 962, American Society For Testing of Materials, Philadelphia,
PP247- 286(1986)
22) Sakammoto, Y. and Takao, K.: Effect of Quenching and Tempering on Diffusion in High Strength Alloy Steels:
ibid, 1A8, PP1-8 (1977)
23) Albert, S.K., Ramasubbu, V., Parvathavarthini, N. and Gill, T.P.S.: Influence on alloying on hydrogen assisted
cracking and diffusible hydrogen content in Cr-Mo steel welds, Sadhana, vol-28, Parts 3& 4, June/August 2003,
pp. 383-393