Access Provided by Universidad de Los Andes at 10/20/12 6:59PM GMT

!"#$%&'()*('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''*)+

506/7$2#$89:';/46/#8$8:'/%<'460'=$842#>'2?'@924$2%*'

,-'./##0%'1230#4'

4'D*'%*!1$2!)'!2'!")G!)'!)$7*!'%!)1*!'02*#)<!)1*!1'$,"*#)<!$%2!:*)!#)"00!'%*!'-!
)1*!D'#)!-,$5/1)!('%(*=)#!"%!)1*$),*!1"#)',:;!&-)*,!$00<!)1*!1"#)',:!'-!)1"%7"%/!$>'5)!
*D')"'%#!$%2!=*,-',D$%(*H)1*!#5>I*()!'-!)1"#!#=*("$0!#*()"'%H"#!(')*,D"%'5#!
?")1!)1"%7"%/!$>'5)!țȐșĮȡıȚȢ6)-,)%727J<!)1*!D'#)!9*K*2!)*,D!"%!&,"#)')0*L#!9*K"%/!
8"$-297:')1*!-'5%2$)"'%!'-!M*#)*,%!2,$D$)"(!)1*',:;!4"%(*!1"#!*$,0"*#)!N*%$"##$%(*!
FRPPHQWDWRUVRYHU¿YHKXQGUHG\HDUVDJRFULWLFLVPKDVSX]]OHGRYHUZKDW$ULVWRWOH
PHDQWZKHQKHFKDUDFWHUL]HGWKHIXQFWLRQRIWUDJHG\DV³WKURXJKSLW\DQGIHDU
*--*()"%/!)1*!=,'=*,!=5,/$)"'%!'-!)1*#*!*D')"'%#OPRU³WKURXJKDFRXUVHRISLW\
DQG IHDU FRPSOHWLQJ WKH SXUL¿FDWLRQ RI WUDJLF DFWV ZKLFK KDYH WKRVH HPRWLRQDO
(1$,$()*,"#)"(#OQ RU ³WR DFFRPSOLVK WKURXJK SLW\ DQG IHDU D FODUL¿FDWLRQ   
('%(*,%"%/!*K=*,"*%(*#!'-!)1*!=")"$>0*!$%2!-*$,-50!7"%2;OR!31"#!$,,$:!'-!(")$)"'%#!
"005#),$)*#!)1*!=,'>0*DG!?1$)!&,"#)')0*!D*$%)!>:!)1"#!(0$5#*!1"%/*#!'%!$!?',2!?1'#*!
"%)*,=,*)$)"'%!,*D$"%#!5%,*#'09*2!=,*("#*0:!>*($5#*!")#!(',,*()!),$%#0$)"'%!,*D$"%#!
XQYHUL¿DEOHWKHZRUGDQGLWVFRJQDWHVDSSHDULQJLQWKHH[WDQW*UHHNFRUSXVLQ
YDULRXVGHQRWDWLRQV7KHZRUG³FDWKDUVLV´XVHGE\PDQ\WUDQVODWRUVLVDFKHDW²
ERUURZHGIURPWKH*UHHNZRUGLQWKHQLQHWHHQWKFHQWXU\SUHFLVHO\WRDYRLGKDYLQJ
WRWUDQVODWHLWLQWR(QJOLVKDVKDSSHQHGLQ)UHQFK>³;)'9)-,)%727<O!(",($!STUVW<!
*HUPDQ>³#2$'<)-,)%727<O!(",($!STXVW<!$%2!$0D'#)!(*,)$"%0:!')1*,!0$%/5$/*#;J
M*!?"00!%*9*,!7%'?!?1$)!&,"#)')0*!D*$%)=!F"#!0$%/5$/*!"#!0'%/!2*$2!$%2<!*9*%!
#*))"%/!=1"0'0'/"($0!"##5*#!$#"2*<!1"#!(',=5#!"#!#*0-Y('%),$2"()',:G!"%!)1*!8"$-297:'
1*!,*-*,#!)'!1"#!)1*',:!'-!6)-,)%727'-,'D!)1*!8";2-297'$%2!)'!1"#!)1*',:!'-!*D')"'%#!
-,'D!)1*!>,$-"%29<!>5)!)1*!2"#(5##"'%#!"%!)1*#*!)?'!>''7#!$,*!",,*('%("0$>0*<!$%2!
)1*!0$,/*,!&,"#)')*0"$%!(',=5#!-5,)1*,!D522"*#!)1*!?$)*,!?")1!2"#(',2$%)!,*D$,7#!
'%!)1*!*D')"'%#L!?',7"%/#!"%!?29,"*)9,$)&'@-,297:!A&'-,$'."/;<!8)%-7'"B'C&2*);7:'
$%2!!"0$*$&-'"B'C&2*);7=!Z%!0"/1)!'-!)1*!=0$"%!"%$2*[5$(:!'-!1"#!,*D$,7#!"%!)1*!
8"$-297:!('DD*%)$)',#!%**2!('%)*K)5$0H*K),$)*K)5$0H#5==',)<!>5)!)1*:!($%!'%0:!
#*0*()"9*0:!(1''#*!")!$%2!D5#)!"/%',*!)1*!('5%)*,*9"2*%(*;!\')!7%'?"%/!&,"#)')0*L#!
"%)*%)"'%#<!"%!')1*,!?',2#<!$!(,")"(!($%!'%0:!*9*,!$22!)'!)1*!1"#)',:!'-!6)-,)%727:'>:!
?1"(1!Z!D*$%!)1*!1"#)',:!'-!1'?!)1*!?',2!1$#!>**%!),$%#0$)*2<!)1*!(0$5#*!"%)*,=,*)*2<!

,-'./##0%'1230#4!"#!$%!&##'("$)*!+,'-*##',!'-!.%/0"#1!$%2!31*$),*!4)52"*#!$)!6',7!8%"9*,#"):;!&#!$!
(,")"(<!1*!1$#!=5>0"#1*2!$,)"(0*#!'%!?,")*,#!#5(1!$#!@"(1*0!@$,(!A'5(1$,2<!A*,)'0)!A,*(1)<!4$,$1!B$%*<!
@'0"C,*<!$%2!3'D!4)'==$,2<!$#!?*00!$#!'%!2,$D$)"(!$%2!=*,-',D$%(*!)1*',:<!"%!9*%5*#!#5(1!$#!!"#$%&'
(%)*)!$%2!+,$)-%$'./%0$1;!&#!$!=,$()")"'%*,<!1*!1$#!2",*()*2!=0$:#!>:!.2?$,2!&0>**<!4$D5*0!A*(7*))<!
$%2!&%)'%!E1*71'9<!$D'%/!')1*,#;!F*!,*(*%)0:!('D=0*)*2!$!>''7<!+,$'!2&#34"#1'.-)5$<!$>'5)!)1*!
,'0*!'-!E$,)*#"$%!)1'5/1)!"%!)1*$),*!1"#)',:;
**)'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''A2B#%/C'2?'.#/9/4$D'E602#>'/%<';#$4$D$89
$%2!)1*!('%(*=)!D$2*!)'!#"/%"-:;!&%2!)15#!?,")"%/!$>'5)!6)-,)%727'>')1!=,'0"-*,$)*#!
$%2!('%)"%5*#!)'!2"##$)"#-:;
$PRUHSUR¿WDEOHYHLQRILQTXLU\LVKLVWRULRJUDSKLFDOLWLQWHUURJDWHVKRZDQG
?1:!)1"#!',!)1$)!"%)*,=,*)$)"'%!($D*!)'!('1*,*!"%!$!1"#)',"($0!D'D*%);!31"#!"%[5",:!
LQYROYHVQRWRQO\KLVWRULFL]LQJWUDQVODWLRQVRI6)-,)%727'EXWDOVRKLVWRULFL]LQJWKH
('%(*=)!'-!*D')"'%!)1$)!5%2*,/",2#!)1*D;!]',!*D')"'%#!2'!1$9*!$!1"#)',:G!(,")"(#!
"%!2"--*,*%)!)"D*#!$%2!=0$(*#!1$9*!D*$%)!2"--*,*%)!)1"%/#!?1*%!)1*:!1$9*!?,"))*%!
'-!)1*!*D')"'%#!"%!/*%*,$0!',!="):!$%2!-*$,!"%!=$,)"(50$,H*9*%!"-!)1*:!1$9*!>**%!
5%$?$,*!)1$)!)1*",!=,*#5=='#")"'%#!$>'5)!)1*#*!)*,D#!?*,*!1"#)',"($00:!('%#)")5)*2;!
$IWHUDOOWKHUHLVQRVWDEOHWKLQJDQ³HPRWLRQ´RUD³IHHOLQJ´RUDQ³DIIHFW´WKDW
*K"#)#!),$%#1"#)',"($00:<!),$%#(50)5,$00:<!',<!"%2**2<!'5)#"2*!'-!',!=,"',!)'!")#!(50)5,$0!
*K=,*##"'%#<!?1*)1*,!)*$,#!',!2,$D$)"(!#(,"=)#;!+*,5#"%/!7*:!)1*',*)"("$%#!'-!)1*!
*D')"'%#!"%!M*#)*,%!)1'5/1)H#5(1!$#!+0$)'<!&,"#)')0*<!^*#($,)*#<!^$9"2!F5D*<!
M"00"$D!_$D*#<!',!4"/D5%2!],*52H'%*!($%!"2*%)"-:!)1*!,*(5,,*%)!2"#$/,**D*%)#!
?1"(1!1$9*!#),5()5,*2!)1*!1"#)',:!'-!*D')"'%!$%2!?1"(1!#*,9*!)'!2"#)"%/5"#1!")#!
D*$%"%/#;!^'!*D')"'%#!',"/"%$)*!"%!)1*!>'2:<!?")1!/''#*!>5D=#!$%2!1')!*$,#<!',!
$,*!)1*:!=,'25()#!'-!D"%2<!/*%*,$)*2!>:!)1*!D*%)$0!$##*##D*%)!)1$)!)1"#!',!)1$)!"#!
IHDUIXORUORYHZRUWK\"$UHWKH\³LUUDWLRQDO´DVLQLQGHSHQGHQWRIUHDVRQRUGRWKH\
$))*%2!('/%")"9*!I52/D*%)#`!&,*!)1*:!"%2"9"25$0!',!#'("$0!*K=*,"*%(*#G!"%1*,*%)0:!
#'0"=#"#)"(!',!*D*,/"%/!'%0:!"%)*,#5>I*()"9*0:`!&,*!)1*:!$()"9*<!',"/"%$)"%/!?")1!)1*!
#*0-<!',!"%),$%#")"9*<!=$##"9*0:!,*(*"9*2!-,'D!'5)#"2*`!&%2!$,*!)1*:!>*#)!('%#"2*,*2!$#!
($5#*#!',!*--*()#G!("'D'9%1'E$9)/7$'D')*'7)#!',<!$#!_$D*#!$%2!D$%:!>*-',*!1"D!?'502!
1$9*!")<!C*'D'7)#'E$9)/7$'D'9%1F!31*!$%#?*,#!)'!)1*#*![5*#)"'%#!1$9*!>**%!$00':*2!
"%!9$,"'5#!?$:#!)'!=,'25(*!5%2*,#)$%2"%/#!'-!*D')"'%<!$%2!)1*#*!5%2*,#)$%2"%/#!
PD\KDYHSUHGRPLQDWHGLQWKLVRUWKDWFXOWXUDOORFDWLRQ7KH\³VXFFHVVLYHO\PDNH
WKHLUDSSHDUDQFHSDVVUHSDVVJOLGHDZD\DQGPLQJOHLQDQLQ¿QLWHYDULHW\RI
SRVWXUHVDQGVLWXDWLRQV´WRTXRWH+XPH¶VGH¿QLWLRQRIPLQGDVDWKHDWUHZKHUHWKLV
=$/*$%)!"#!#)$/*2;X!A5)!1'?*9*,!2'D"%$%)!$!/"9*%!)1*',:!D$:!>*('D*<!")!)''!?"00!
/0"2*!$?$:;!&%2!1'?*9*,!=,'D"#"%/!$!=,*#*%)!*="#)*D'0'/"($0!-,$D*?',7!D$:!>*!
IRUZRUNLQJRXWDQVZHUVQHXURORJLFDOUHVHDUFKVD\KLVWRU\VXJJHVWVWKDWWKHVH
)''<!?"00!*9*%)5$00:!*K")!)1*!#)$/*;!31*![5*#)"'%#!?"00!>*!='#*2!$%*?;!
F'?! '%*! 5%2*,#)$%2#! )1*! %$)5,*! $%2! #),5()5,*! '-! *D')"'%<! Z! 1$9*! #$"2<!
0$,/*0:! 2*)*,D"%*#! 1'?! '%*! 5%2*,#)$%2#H$%2! *9*%! ),$%#0$)*#H6)-,)%727:' $%2!
)1*!('D=0*K"):!'-!*D')"'%!$#!$!('%(*=)!"#!#5//*#)*2!>:!)1*!#(',*#!'-!=5>0"#1*2!
LQWHUSUHWDWLRQV RI$ULVWRWOH¶V FODXVH ZLGHUDQJLQJ LQ WKHLU YDULHW\ 1RWH IRU
H[DPSOHWKDW*HUDOG(OVH¶VLQWHUSUHWDWLRQFLWHGDWQRWHWKUHHDERYHGRGJHVWKH
#=*()$)',#L!*D')"'%#!*%)",*0:<!,*%2*,"%/!6)-,)%727'$!)*,D!'-!$,)!2*%')"%/!$!2*#",$>0*!
2,$D$)5,/"($0!#),5()5,*;!.9*%!\*?!E,")"("#D!1$2!")#!?$:!?")1!&,"#)')0*;aJ!A5)!)1*!
"%)*,=,*)"9*! D*%5! 0*$%#! 1*$9"0:! '%! )1,**! "%/,*2"*%)#<! ?1"(1! (',,*#='%2! )'! )1*!
GH¿QLWLRQVRIWKHZRUGLQWKH/LGGHOO6FRWW-RQHVG%$$6H@&5;27,'I$J29"&G!$!D*2"($0!
6)-,)%727'WKDWGLVFKDUJHVHPRWLRQVRU³SXUJDWLRQ´DUHOLJLRXVOXVWUDWRU\6)-,)%727<!
!"#$%&'()*('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''***
RU³SXUL¿FDWLRQ´DQGD6)-,)%727'RIFRJQLWLYHLOOXPLQDWLRQRU³FODUL¿FDWLRQ´V7KH
WKLUGGH¿QLWLRQVHUYHVDVVXSSRUWIRUP\KLVWRULRJUDSKLFDOWKHVLVZKLOHLWLVQRZ
OLVWHGDVDYHUL¿HGPHDQLQJIRUDQDQFLHQWZRUGLQDGHDGODQJXDJHLQDGLFWLRQDU\
XVHGWRDSSUHKHQGORQJDJRVLJQL¿FDWLRQVLWZDVDGGHGWRWKHI$J29"&!'%0:!"%!")#!
%"%)1!*2")"'%<!=5>0"#1*2!"%!SURb;!31*!'#)*%#">0*!,$)"'%$0*!?'502!1$9*!>**%!%*?!
=1"0'0'/"($0!*9"2*%(*<!>5)!)1*!(50)5,$0!-',(*!2,"9"%/!")!?$#!$!,*#5,/*%)!('/%")"9"#)!
5%2*,#)$%2"%/!'-!)1*!*D')"'%#!'%!?1"(1!6)-,)%727'$()#;TJ!F*,*<!Z!-'(5#!'%!#'D*!
#**D"%/0:! 2"#('%%*()*2! ="*(*#! '-! *$,0:Y)?*%)"*)1Y(*%)5,:! )1*$),*! 1"#)',:H)1*!
ZULWLQJVRI$QWRQLQ$UWDXGWKHUHVHDUFKRIWKH³&DPEULGJHULWXDOLVWV´DQGWKH
D'%)$/*! )1*',:! '-! 4*,/*"! ."#*%#)*"%H$%2! ,*9*$0! )1*",! #),5()5,$0! ('%#'%$%(*;! Z!
H[FDYDWHWKHVKDUHGVWUXFWXUHLQRUGHUWRKLVWRULFL]HWKHSUHVXPSWLRQVDERXWHPRWLRQ
WKDWXQGHUJLUGLW7KHVHSUHVXPSWLRQVEHWUD\WKHLQÀXHQFHRIEHKDYLRULVWSV\FKRORJ\
2*9*0'=*2!>:!_;!A;!M$)#'%!"%!)1*!8%")*2!4)$)*#!$%2!>:!Z9$%!+$90'9!$%2!c0$2"D",!
A*71)*,*9!"%!N5##"$;!A*1$9"',"#D<!Z!#5//*#)<!-$("0")$)*2!$!,*#5,/*%(*!'-!"%)*,*#)!"%!
6)-,)%727'DV³SXUL¿FDWLRQ´EXWLWDOVRPDUNHGGUDPDWLFWKHRU\DQGSUDFWLFHZHOO
>*:'%2!&,"#)')*0"$%!(,")"("#D;!

!d!d!d!

Z%!$!SUQQ!*##$:<!&,)$52!2*,"2*2!-'5,!15%2,*2!:*$,#!'-!M*#)*,%!)1*$),*!1"#)',:!$#!
DQ³)E,"%%)-2"&OUWKDW³OHDYH>V@WKHSXEOLFLQWDFW´DQGIDLOVWR³OHDYHDQLQHIIDFHDEOH
#($,;OSb+HSURSRVHGDQDOWHUQDWLYHWKHDWUHLQZKLFKWKHVSHFWDWRULV³VHL]HGE\WKH
)1*$)*,! $#! >:! $! ?1",0?"%2! '-! 1"/1*,! -',(*#;OSS!31*#*! -',D50$)"'%#! 1"/10"/1)! )1*!
(*%),$0!-*$)5,*#!'-!)1*!)1*$),*!&,)$52!*%9"#"'%*2G!)1*!('*,("9*0:!=1:#"($0!$%2!:*)!
D*)$=1:#"($0!%$)5,*!'-!)1*!#=*()$(0*<!$%2!")#!",,*9*,#">0*!*--*()!'%!)1*!D$)*,"$0!>'2:!
RIWKHVSHFWDWRU&KULVWRSKHU,QQHVKDVGH¿QHGWKHWKHDWUHRIFUXHOW\DVWKHPRGHUQ
*[5"9$0*%)!'-!(0$##"($0!),$/*2:!"%!")#!*D=1$#"#!'%!($)1$,#"#<!0"%7"%/!&,)$52!?")1!')1*,!
SUDFWLWLRQHUVRI³KRO\WKHDWUH´VXFKDV-DFTXHV&RSHDXDQG-HU]\*URWRZVNLZKR
$"D!-',!)1*",!#=*()$)',#L!),$%#-',D$)"'%;SP!&,)$52<!?1'!#$?!1"D#*0-!$#!7/2'5$&$%27<!
ZRXOGQRGRXEWWDNHLVVXHZLWKWKHFRPSDQ\WKDW,QQHVKDVKLPNHHS³0\SOD\V
1$9*! %')1"%/! )'! 2'! ?")1! E'=*$5L#! "D=,'9"#$)"'%#<O! 1*! "%2"/%$%)0:! =,')*#)*2! "%!
SUQP;SQ!A5)!?1"0*!)1*:!$,*!#'D*)"D*#!#*0-Y('%),$2"()',:<!)1*!(0$"D#!)1$)!&,)$52!
PDNHVIRUKLVWKHDWUH²FODLPVWKDWGUDZRQFRPSDULVRQVWRDQFLHQW*UHHNUHOLJLRXV
=,$()"(*#H-',(*-500:!2*-*%2!)1*!),$%#(*%2*%)$0!=')*%)"$0!'-!)1*$),"($0!*D')"'%!"%!
?$:#!)1$)!=5)!1"D!"%!*(0*()"(!('D=$%:;!@$7"%/!,*-*,*%(*!)'!e,=1"(!$%2!.0*5#"%"$%!
D:#)*,:! (50)#<!&,)$52! #),*##*#! )1*! ",,*9'($>"0"):! '-! 1"#! )1*$),"($0! *--*()#<! ?1"(1!
WUDQVIXVH PDWWHU KLV WKHDWUH OLNH DOFKHP\ ¿QGV LWV HVVHQFH²LWV ³¿QO! $%2! ")#!
³%K);2-KOH"%!")#!"D=$()!'%!)1*!#=*()$)',;SR!Z%!)1*!.0*5#"%"$%!,")*#!)'!?1"(1!&,)$52!
DOOXGHVWKHLQLWLDWHXQGHUJRHVDQLUUHYHUVLEOHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQDSXUL¿FDWLRQWKDW
*K=*,"*%)"$00:!*%$()#!)1*!"%-$%)!^*D'=1'f%L#!)*,,"-:"%/!>,5#1!?")1!)1*!/'22*##!
'HPHWHUZKRKDGSXWKLPLQWKH¿UHLQRUGHUWRFRQIHULPPRUWDOLW\SX!31"#!"%")"$)"'%!
**('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''A2B#%/C'2?'.#/9/4$D'E602#>'/%<';#$4$D$89
LVWUDQVIRUPDWLYHUHPDNLQJLWVVXEMHFWMXVWDVWKHWKHDWUHRIFUXHOW\³SURYRNHVWKH
D'#)!D:#)*,"'5#!$0)*,$)"'%#!"%!)1*!g#=",")<!";*;<!$7L%2-W!'-!%')!'%0:!$%!"%2"9"25$0!>5)!
$%!*%)",*!='=50$(*;OSa
$UWDXGDWWHVWVWKDWKHUHVWRUHVWKHDWUHWRWKH³VSLULWRIGHHSDQDUFK\´;M$7L%2-'
#M)&)%9,2$'L%"B"&#$J!*D>'2"*2!>:!)1*!D:#)*,:!,")*#SVH$%2!1"#!*,$!?$#!1*$9"0:!
"%9*#)*2! "%! )1*! (0$"D! )1$)! ),$/*2:! 1$2! *9'09*2! 2",*()0:! -,'D! )1*#*! *(#)$)"(!
(*,*D'%"*#;!31*!(0$"D!?$#!=,'D')*2!>:!)1*!(0$##"("#)#!?1'!($D*!)'!>*!7%'?%!$#!
WKH&DPEULGJHULWXDOLVWV²-DQH+DUULVRQ*LOEHUW0XUUD\)UDQFLV&RUQIRUG²ZKRVH
DWWHPSWV WR OLQN WKH RULJLQV RI WKHDWUH ZLWK VDFUL¿FLDO ULWXDOV LQ DQFLHQW *UHHFH
2'D"%$)*2!*$,0:Y)?*%)"*)1Y(*%)5,:!(0$##"($0!#(1'0$,#1"=;ST!&((',2"%/0:<!)1*!%')"'%!
RI$ULVWRWHOLDQ³SXUL¿FDWLRQ´FDPHDJDLQWRGRPLQDWHGLVFXVVLRQVRI6)-,)%727<!"%!
$!D$,7*2!)5,%!'-!*9*%)#!-,'D!)1*!0$)*Y%"%*)**%)1!(*%)5,:<!?1*%!5%2*,#)$%2"%/#!'-!
³SXUJDWLRQ´KHOGIDYRU$V,KDYHH[SORUHGHOVHZKHUH³SXUJDWLRQ´KDGDVFHQGHG
DVSDUWRIDODUJHUUDWLRQDOL]DWLRQRIWKHP\VWHULHVRIKXPDQH[SHULHQFHLQWKHODWH
QLQHWHHQWKFHQWXU\DQGDORQJVLGHWKHPHGLFDOL]DWLRQRIKXPDQSV\FKRORJ\WKDWKDG
)1*%!)$7*%!-*,D*%);SU,WLVQRDFFLGHQWWKDWWKHHUD¶VNH\SURSRQHQWRI³SXUJDWLRQ´
)1*! (0$##"("#)! _$('>! A*,%$:#<! 1$2! *K=0"($)*2! )1*! D*2"($0! >$#"#! -',!&,"#)')*0"$%!
6)-,)%727'LQWHUPVIXOO\FRQVRQDQWZLWKSV\FKRWKHUDSHXWLF³FDWKDUVLV´DVLWZDV
2*9*0'=*2! >:! 1"#! %"*(*L#! 15#>$%2<! 4"/D5%2! ],*52<! $%2! 1"#! )1*%! =$,)%*,! _'#*-!
A,*5*,;Pb!A5)!I5#)!$#!)1*!E$D>,"2/*!,")5$0"#)#!?'502!('D*!)'!,*D:#)"-:!)1*!*D')"'%$0!
H[SHULHQFHRIWKHDWUHWKDW%HUQD\VKDGGHP\VWL¿HGVRWRRZRXOGWKHDVVRFLDWLRQ
EHWZHHQHPRWLRQVDQGLUUDWLRQDOLW\FRPHWREHUHP\WKRORJL]HGLQGUDPDWLFSUDFWLFH
PRUHJHQHUDOO\:KHQ*HRUJH7KRPVRQZURWHLQWKDWWKHDWUHHPHUJHGRXW
'-!)1*!D:#)*,:!(50)#<!?1'#*!"%")"$)"'%!,")5$0#!"%!)5,%!2*,"9*2!-,'D!)1*!,")*#!'-!)1*!
³SULPLWLYHWRWHPLFFODQ´KHZDVPHUHO\FRQVROLGDWLQJDWKHRU\KRZHYHUVXVSHFW
LWVHYLGHQFHSRSXODUL]HGE\DQWKURSRORJ\RIWKHHDUO\FHQWXU\PS!45(1!"2*$#H#''%!
)'!>*!#:#)*D$)"($00:!$==0"*2!)'!2,$D$!(,")"("#D!>:!],$%("#!]*,/5##'%L#!+,$'D#$)'
"B')'+,$)-$%PPH?*,*!$>#',>*2!"%)'!)1*!)1*$),"($0!(50)5,*<!$%2!)1*:!#)$%2!>*1"%2!
$UWDXG¶VFODLPWKDW³$00!),5*!(50)5,*!,*0"*#!5='%!)1*!>$,>$,"(!$%2!=,"D")"9*!D*$%#!
'-!)')*D"#D!?1'#*!#$9$/*<!";*;<!*%)",*0:!#='%)$%*'5#<!0"-*!Z!?"#1!)'!?',#1"=;OPQ!
+LV WKHRU\ WKXV VKDUHV GHHS DI¿QLWLHV ZLWK WKH ³*2772"&' %$;252$/7$O! '-! E'=*$5!
ZKRKDGDOVRVHOIFRQVFLRXVO\GUDZQIURPWKHP\VWHU\ULWHVDQGRWKHUSLRQHHUV
'-!=,"D")"9"#)!D'2*,%"#D;PR
A')1! D*%<! "%! #),*##"%/! )1*$),"($0! #=*()$)',#1"=L#! ),$%#(*%2*%)$0! ='?*,#! '-!
FRQYHUVLRQLQVWHDGRILWVUHVWRUDWLYHRUQRUPDOL]LQJLPSDFWUHFDSLWXODWHDUHVLOLHQW
1"#)',"($0! 0"%*! '-! )1'5/1)! )1$)! =,*'((5="*2! D$%:!&,"#)')*0"$%! ('DD*%)$)',#<!
LQFOXGLQJ*RWWKROG/HVVLQJDQGVWUHWFKLQJEDFNWRRQHRIWKHHDUOLHVW)UDQFHVFR
N'>',)*00'<!-',!?1'D!6)-,)%727'?$#!$!,*0"/"'5#!D*)$=1',!#"/%$0"%/!)1*!*D')"'%#L!
SXUL¿FDWLRQ+RZHYHU$UWDXG¶VIRUPXODWLRQVJRPXFKIXUWKHUWKDQ5RERUWHOORRU
/HVVLQJLQWKHLUUHYROXWLRQDU\IHUYRUZKLFKLVHQDEOHGE\QHZSDUDGLJPVRIHPRWLRQ
31*#*! =$,$2"/D#<! "%! )5,%<! ?*,*! =,'D50/$)*2! >:! >*1$9"',"#D<! ?1"(1! *K=0"(")0:!
!"#$%&'()*('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''**F

$,)"(50$)*#!$!=,'/,$D!-',!*D')"'%$0!('%2")"'%"%/;!.K$D"%"%/!>*1$9"',"#DL#!D'2*0!
'-!*D')"'%<!?*!($%!('%#"2*,!&,)$52L#!)1*$),*!'-!(,5*0):!"%!('5%)*,='"%)!?")1!)1*!
VHFXODUL]HGEXWQROHVVIHUYHQWSURJUDPSURSRVHGE\KLVFRQWHPSRUDU\DQG3DYORY¶V
('5%),:D$%<!."#*%#)*"%<!?1'!2*D'%#),$)*#!)1$)!*K=*,"*%)"$0!),$%#-',D$)"'%!2'*#!
%')!,*[5",*!)1*!2"9"%*;!
7KHHDUO\WZHQWLHWKFHQWXU\GLVVDWLVIDFWLRQZLWK³SXUJDWLRQ´WKHRULHVGHULYHG
IURP WKHLU QRUPDOL]LQJ LPSXOVH WKHLU FOLQLFDO UHPRYDO RI ZKDW ZDV VHHQ DV DQ
*0*D*%)!'-!D:#)*,:!"%!),$/"(!*K=*,"*%(*;!Z%2**2<!A*,%$:#!1$2!>*/5%!1"#!),*$)"#*!
'%!6)-,)%727ZLWKDZLWKHULQJUHEXWWDORI/HVVLQJZKRVHN)*E/%5'(%)*)-/%51!
),$%#0$)*#!6)-,)%727DV³SXUL¿FDWLRQ´>$2&25/&5J!$%2!?1'!5%2*,#)$%2#!)1*!)*,D!
DV GHQRWLQJ WKH ³WUDQVIRUPDWLRQ´ O$%P)&#;/&5J! '-! )1*! #=*()$)',#L! *D')"'%#;PX!
%HUQD\V¶V ZRUN , KDYH VDLG HPEOHPDWL]HV WKH QLQHWHHQWKFHQWXU\ WUHQG WR
UDWLRQDOL]H P\VWHULHV RI KXPDQ H[SHULHQFH VXPPDUL]LQJ KLV FULWLTXH RI WKH
SXUL¿FDWLRQVFKRRO%HUQD\VGHHPVLWVSURSRQHQWVWHPSHUDPHQWDOO\LQFRPSDWLEOH
?")1!)1*!=1"0'#'=1*,!'-!)1*!8"$-297<!?")1!?1'D!1*!(0$"D#!7"%#1"=G!

>1@RRQHZKRJLYHVWKHPDWWHUWZRPLQXWHV¶UHÀHFWLRQQHHGVDQ\
1*0=!)'!,*$0"#*!1'?!"D='##">0*!")!"#!)1$)!&,"#)')0*<!"%!$!-$#1"'%!
)')$00:!-',*"/%!)'!1"#!&"%*);!1$>")#<!#1'502!1*,*!1$9*!>',,'?*2!$!
=1"0'#'=1"($0!)*,D!-,'D!)1*!0$%/5$/*!'-!='=50$,!,*0"/"'%H'%0:!
)'!D"##!1"#!,*$0!$"D!*%)",*0:;!]',!1*!($%%')!1$9*!1$2!"%!D"%2!)1*!
g,")5$0W!(*,*D'%"*#!)1*D#*09*#H)1*!"%(*%#*!$%2!)1*!$>05)"'%#
;!;!;!;!?"'"&$'2&',27'%25,-'*2&#'('502!#*,"'5#0:!(,*2")!&,"#)')0*!?")1!
#'!='"%)0*##!$%2!'>9"'5#!$!="*(*!'-!9*,>$0!9"&Q/%2&5;Pa!

A*,%$:#! )*00"%/0:! "D=5/%#! )1*! ,$)"'%$0"):! '-! )1'#*! ?1'! *%2',#*! #=*()$)',"$0!
SXUL¿FDWLRQ ³6$2&' 4$7"&&$&$%´ FRXOG EHOLHYH LQ VXFK ³+)79,$&7L2$;$%$2=O! e%!
WKHRWKHUKDQGWKHDQWLUDWLRQDOLVW$UWDXGZKRSHUVRQDOO\KDGDWWHPSWHGWRDVVHUW
UHOLJLRXV IDLWK LQ WKH IDFH RI QRUPDOL]LQJ PHGLFDO WUHDWPHQWVPVJ<! ,*$%(1',#! )1*!
WKHDWULFDO H[SHULHQFH LQ LWV HFVWDWLF HIIHFW RQ LWV VSHFWDWRUV ³VXUFKDUJHG ZLWK
VSLULWXDOLW\´KHZULWHVLQDVXLWDEO\REVFXUHSDVVDJHWKHWKHDWUH³XOWLPDWHO\HYRNHV
"%!)1*!#=",")!$%!$>#'05)*!$%2!$>#),$()!=5,"):<!>*:'%2!?1"(1!)1*,*!($%!>*!%')1"%/;OPT!
&#!&,)$52!*K=0$"%*2!)'!_*$%!+$501$%<!)1*!)1*$),*!'-!(,5*0):!#1'502!('%-,'%)!)1*!
=,"%("=0*!'-!)1*$),*!")#*0-<!?1"(1!"#!D*)$=1:#"($0H1"#!9*,#"'%!'-!)1*!),5"#D!)1$)!
³WKHUHLVQRWUDJHG\ZLWKRXWWUDQVFHQGHQFH´DV.DUO-DVSHUVSXWLWPU
,QHPSKDVL]LQJWKHHFVWDWLFHOHPHQWVRIWKHDWULFDOH[SHULHQFHDQGWKHLUDELOLW\
)'! ),$%#-5#*! )1*! D$)*,"$0! >'2:! '-! )1*! #=*()$)',<! )1*',"#)#! 0"7*!&,)$52! ,*(0$"D!
KLVWRULFDOO\LQÀXHQWLDOFKDUJHVRIDQWLWKHDWULFDOLVWV²KHQFH-RQDV%DULVK¶VDVWXWH
OLQNLQJRI*URWRZVNLDQG$UWDXGWR1LHW]VFKHDQG5RXVVHDXZLWKWKHLUYLVLRQRI
WKHDWUHDVD³SDUWLFLSDWRU\ULWHPHDQWWRDURXVHDQGRYHUZKHOPWKHVSHFWDWRUZLWK
"%)*%#*!#)$)*#!'-!('%#("'5#%*##;OQb!&,)$52!1"D#*0-!*K=0"(")0:!$00"*#!1"#!#)$%(*!?")1!
**G'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''A2B#%/C'2?'.#/9/4$D'E602#>'/%<';#$4$D$89
)1$)!'-!&5/5#)"%*<!>',,'?"%/!1"#!(*%),$0!D*)$=1',!'-!)1*$),*!$#!$!=0$/5*!)1$)!,$2"$)*#!
'5)!-,'D!)1*!,*=,*#*%)$)"'%!$%2!",,*9'($>0:!('%)$D"%$)*#!")#!$52"*%(*;QS!&!?*00Y
,*1*$,#*2!$%)")1*$),"($0"#)!0"%*!1'02#!)1$)!)1*!('%9*,#"'%!?,'5/1)!>:!)1*!=0$/5*Y
0"7*!)1*$),*!"#!)?'-'02;!]",#)<!)1*!$()',#!$,*!D$)*,"$00:!$0)*,*2!$#!$!('%#*[5*%(*!'-!
)1*",!2"##*D>0$%(*;!]',!*K$D=0*<!RQWKHDFFRXQWRI3LHUUH1LFROHZKRDVD
-DQVHQLVWWUDFHVKLVDQWLWKHDWULFDOOLQHDJHGLUHFWO\WR$XJXVWLQH³,)!"#!$!=,'-*##"'%!"%!
?1"(1!D*%!$%2!?'D*%!,*=,*#*%)!)1*!=$##"'%#!'-!1$),*2<!$%/*,<!$D>")"'%<!9*%/*$%(*<!
$%2!*#=*("$00:!0'9*;!31*:!D5#)!*K=,*##!)1*D!$#!%$)5,$00:!$%2!9"9"20:!$#!)1*:!($%<!
$%2!)1*:!('502!%')!2'!#'!"-!)1*:!2"2!%')!"%!#'D*!?$:!*K(")*!)1*#*!=$##"'%#!?")1"%!
)1*D#*09*#h!$%2!"-!)1*#*!=$##"'%#!$,*!)'!>*!*K=,*##*2!)1,'5/1!/*#)5,*#!$%2!?',2#<!
WKH\PXVWEH¿UVWLPSULQWHGRQWKHLUVRXOV´QP!31*!-$D*2!)1*'0'/"$%!_$([5*#!Ai%"/%*!
A'##5*)!D$2*!)1*!#$D*!='"%)!"%!SaUR!?1"0*!$%)"("=$)"%/!&,)$52L#!0$%/5$/*!D',*!
*K=0"(")0:h!-',!1"D<!"%!$()"%/<!?*!)$7*!'%!)1*!³$7L%2-O!'-!)1$)!?1"(1!?*!"D")$)*;QQ!
31"#!³$7L%2-O!VSUHDGVIURPWKHDFWRUVWRWKHDXGLHQFH³31*!#=*()$)',!"#!($,,"*2!
$0'%/!"%!)1"#!#=",");!;!;!;!Z%!)1"#!?$:!)1*!*%)",*!2*9"(*!'-!)1*$)*,!'%0:!D$7*#!D*%!
"D=$##"'%*2;OQR!31*$),*!$()#!$#!)1*!$/*%)<!#")5$)"%/!)1*!('D=0"(")!$()',!$%2!)1*%!
WKHSRZHUOHVVVSHFWDWRUDVREMHFWVWREHDFWHGXSRQLW³PDNHV´LPSDVVLRQHGPHQ
Z%!)1*!D$%%*,!'-!)1*!"%")"$)*!"%)'!D:#)*,:!,")*#<!?1'!"#!/"9*%!'9*,!)'!*(#)$#:!$%2!
)15#!('%9*,)*2!)'!%*?!>*0"*-#<!)1*!'>I*()!'-!)1*$),*!>*('D*#!#5>I5/$)*2!)'!$%2!
WUDQVIRUPHGE\LWVSRZHU$FWHGXSRQKHLVFRQGLWLRQHG³WREHEURXJKWLQWRD
2*#",*2!#)$)*OHA=@=(=J!"%)'!%*?!>*1$9"',#;QX
&RQGLWLRQLQJ²D ³PRGH RI OHDUQLQJ WKDW OHDGV WR EHKDYLRUV´ LQ 6WDQOH\
_$(7#'%L#! #5(("%()! =1,$#*H"#! %')! %*?<! $#! _$(7#'%! "005#),$)*#! ?")1! $! =$##$/*!
-,'D!N'>*,)!A5,)'%L#!SaPS!C&)-"*1'"B'!$;)&9,";1!)1$)!0"7*%#!$!D$%!)'!$!1',#*!
('%2")"'%*2!'5)!'-!#7"))"#1%*##;Qa!31*!5#*!'-!,*=,*#*%)$)"'%$0!$,)!"%!)1*!#*,9"(*!'-!
#5(1!('%2")"'%"%/!"#!%')!%*?<!*")1*,;!N'>',)*00'<!-',!*K$D=0*<!?,")*#!)1$)!)1*$),"($0!
6)-,)%727WHDFKHVPHQWRDFWGLIIHUHQWO\E\DSURFHVVWKDWZHUHFRJQL]HDVHPRWLRQDO
1$>")5$)"'%G

?1*%!D*%!$,*!=,*#*%)!$)!=*,-',D$%(*#<!$%2!)1*:!1*$,!$%2!#**!
=*'=0*! #$:"%/! $%2! 2'"%/! )1"%/#! ?1"(1! 9*,:! (0'#*0:! $==,'$(1!
),5)1!")#*0-:'-,$1'E$9"*$')99/7-"*$#')'!#5--*,"%/<!)'!-*$,"%/<!)'!
="):"%/h!-,27:'2&'-/%&:'9)/7$7'-,$*'='='=')'!#5--*,!0*##!$%2!)'!-*$,!
0*##!;!;!;!;!gMW1*%!)1*!='*)#!"%!)1*!=*,-',D$%(*!'-!)1*",!),$/*2"*#!
=,*#*%)!=*,#'%#!$%2!$()"'%#!D'#)!?',)1:!'-!="):!;!;!;!*$&';$)%&'
?1$)!)1'#*!)1"%/#!$,*!?1"(1!=,'=*,0:!*K(")*!="):!$%2!#',,'?<!$%2!
?1"(1!'%*#!$,'5#*!-*$,;!]"%$00:<!)1*!$52")',#!$%2!#=*()$)',#!'-!
WUDJHGLHVJDLQWKLVEHQH¿WZKLFKLVUHDOO\WKHJUHDWHVWRQH>@QV!

(PSKDVL]LQJ WKDW PHQ ³EHFRPH DFFXVWRPHG´ WKURXJK WKHDWUH ZKLFK ³LQ WXUQ´
³FDXVHV´PHQWRSLW\DQGIHDUOHVV5RERUWHOORPDNHVH[SOLFLWWKHFDXVDOSURFHVV
!"#$%&'()*('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''**H

WKURXJKZKLFK³PHQOHDUQ´²DSURFHVVE\ZKLFKDWKHDWULFDOVWLPXOXVHIIHFWVD
,*#50)!'%!)1*!#=*()$)',<!?1'#*!-*$,-50!$%2!="):"%/!>*1$9"',#!$,*!)1*,*>:!$0)*,*2;!
A5)! N'>',)*00'L#! -',D50$)"'%! "#! )*="2! ('D=$,*2! ?")1! #'D*! )?*%)"*)1Y(*%)5,:!
³SXUL¿FDWLRQ´ FRPPHQWDULHV VXFK DV +XPSKU\ +RXVH¶V ZKLFK VHHV HPRWLRQDO
SRWHQWLDOLW\ EHFRPLQJ ³WUDLQHG´ EHFDXVH RI WKH ³DGHTXDWH VWLPXOL´ RI WKHDWUHQT!
N'>',)*00'L#!$(('5%)!=,*2$)*#!)1*!('%)*K)!)1$)!?'502!=,'9"2*!1"D!?")1!)1*!D'#)!
*K=0"(")! )1*',*)"($0! #5==',);! A:! ('%),$#)<!&,)$52L#! (0$"D#! )1$)! 1"#! )1*$),*! ?"00!
³FDXVHWKLQNLQJ´B)2%$'L$&7$%LQWKH³RUJDQLVP´"%5)&27*$E\³SUHFLVHPHDQV´
*"1$&7'L%K927J!$,*!D$2*!='##">0*<!0"7*!F'5#*L#<!>:!1"#!1"#)',"($0!D'D*%);QU!]',!
?1"0*!>*1$9"',$0!('%2")"'%"%/!1$#!0"7*0:!>**%!=,$()"(*2!)1,'5/1'5)!1"#)',:<!")#!D'#)!
9"/','5#!$%2!*K=*,"D*%)$00:!)*#)*2!-',D50$)"'%#!$,*!'%0:!$!(*%)5,:!'02;Rb!
31*!2"#('5,#*!'-!>*1$9"',"#D!,'#*!'5)!'-!+$90'9L#!(0"%"($0!?',7!'%!('%2")"'%*2!
UHÀH[HVDQGEHFDXVHRIWKHLQÀXHQFHRI-%:DWVRQ,WLVDSURGXFWRIWKHSHULRG
25,"%/!?1"(1!=#:(1'0'/:!?$#!2"#)$%("%/!")#*0-!-,'D!)1*!=1"0'#'=1:!'-!D"%2!$%2!
$))*D=)"%/!)'!*#)$>0"#1!")#*0-!$#!$!#("*%(*<!$%2!#'D*!'-!)1*!$%K"*)"*#!'-!)1$)!*D=","("#)!
$))*D=)!($%!>*!#**%!"%!")#!D*(1$%"#)"(!5%2*,#)$%2"%/!'-!)1*!15D$%!D"%2;!8%0"7*!
)1*!D$%:!25$0"#)"(!D'2*0#!'-!15D$%"):!)1$)!=,*(*2*!")<!?")1!)1*",!9"#"'%#!'-!$!#'50!
$#!$!#*$)!'-!%'%=1:#"'0'/"($0!,*$#'%<!>*1$9"',"#D!#**#!15D$%!=#:(1'0'/:!$#!$!
#5DY)')$0!#*)!'-!=1:#"($0!,*#='%#*#!)1$)<!?")1!*%'5/1!*K=*,"D*%)$0!=$)"*%(*<!('502!
>*!#:#)*D$)"($00:!($)$0'/5*2<!=,*2"()*2<!',!2"--*,*%)0:!('%2")"'%*2;!4"D=0:!#)$)*2<!
>*1$9"',"#D!1'02#!)1$)!?*!$,*!('%#)")5)*2!>:!)1*!D$%%*,!"%!?1"(1!?*!>*1$9*<!$%2!
)15#!'5,!#5>I*()"9"):!($%!>*!$0)*,*2!>:!*K)*,%$0!#)"D50"!)1$)!(1$%/*!'5,!>*1$9"',#;!
Z%!)1"#!?$:<!)1*!>*1$9"',"#)!('%(*=)"'%!'-!)1*!15D$%!>*"%/!,*#*D>0*#!^*#($,)*#L#!
5%2*,#)$%2"%/!'-!)1*!#'500*##!$%"D$0!$#!$!D$(1"%*!?1'#*!*9*,:!$()"9"):!"#!$!=1:#"($0!
,*$()"'%!)'!$%!*K)*,%$0!#)"D505#H$!('D=$,"#'%!)1$)!+$90'9!1"D#*0-!D$7*#!"%!1"#!
0*()5,*#;RS!^*#=")*!1"#!($9*$)#!$>'5)!)''!1$#)"0:!2"#D"##"%/!)1*!E$,)*#"$%!2"#)"%()"'%!
>*)?**%!D$%!$%2!$%"D$0<!+$90'9L#!="'%**,"%/!?',7!'%!('%2")"'%*2!,*#='%#*#!"%!
2'/#![5"(70:!0*2!)'!#"D"0$,!?',7!'%!15D$%!>*1$9"',!>:!=#:(1'0'/"#)#!"%(052"%/!
M$)#'%!$%2!A*71)*,*9;RP
M$)#'%<! -',! *K$D=0*<! *K),$='0$)"%/! -,'D! +$90'9"$%! D'2*0#<! $,)"(50$)*#! $!
EHKDYLRULVW DFFRXQW RI KXPDQ HPRWLRQV GH¿QLQJ WKHP DV KH ZRXOG DQ\ RWKHU
>*1$9"',$0! ,*#='%#*G! $#! ('%#)")5)*2! *%)",*0:! >:! =1:#"'0'/"($0! (1$%/*#! '-! )1*!
³ERGLO\PHFKDQLVP´RQ,Q-DPHVKDG¿JXUHGHPRWLRQDVERWKDIHHOLQJDQGD
SK\VLFDOUHVSRQVHWKDWFRXOGEHFDXVDOO\UHODWHG³>:@HIHHOVRUU\EHFDXVHZHFU\´
KHH[SODLQHG³DQJU\EHFDXVHZHVWULNHDIUDLGEHFDXVHZHWUHPEOHDQGQRWWKDW
?*!(,:<!#),"7*<!',!),*D>0*<!>*($5#*!?*!$,*!#',,:<!$%/,:<!',!-*$,-50<!$#!)1*!($#*!D$:!
>*;ORR!+$90'9<!A*71)*,*9<!$%2!M$)#'%<!'%!)1*!')1*,!1$%2<!,*D'9*!'%*!)*,D!*%)",*0:<!
#),*##"%/!)1$)!)1*!*D')"'%!27!)1*!,*#='%#*;RX$V:DWVRQSXWVLW³>W@KHµFROGVZHDW¶RI
IHDUWKHµEXUVWLQJKHDUW¶WKHµERZHGKHDG¶LQDSDWK\DQGJULHIWKHµH[XEHUDQFHRI
\RXWK¶WKHµSDOSLWDWLQJKHDUW¶RIWKHVZDLQRUPDLGHQDUHPRUHWKDQPHUHOLWHUDU\
*K=,*##"'%#;ORa!]',!M$)#'%<!)1*#*!*K=,*##"'%#!$,*!%')!D*)$=1',"(!',!*9*%!D*)'%:D"(!
**I'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''A2B#%/C'2?'.#/9/4$D'E602#>'/%<';#$4$D$89

VLJQL¿HUVRIHPRWLRQVOLNHIHDUDQGDQJHU5DWKHUDV3DYORYZULWHVIHDUDQGDQJHU
DUHWKH³UHÀH[DFWLYLWLHVRIWKHVXEFRUWLFDOSDUWVRIWKHEUDLQPDGHXSE\D
/,'5="%/!)'/*)1*,!'-!)1*!*0*D*%)$,:!0'('D')',!$()"9")"*#;ORV!
%HKDYLRULVPLPDJLQHVD¿QLWHQXPEHURIHPRWLRQDO³SDWWHUQUHDFWLRQV´HDFK
GH¿QDEOHE\DVHWRISK\VLRORJLFDOUHVSRQVHVWKDWDUHLQKHULWHGIRU:DWVRQIHDU
,$/*<!$%2!0'9*;RT!@',*'9*,<!)1*#*!1$9*!"%>',%!#)"D50";!A5)!)1*#*!,*#='%#*#!>*('D*!
$00':*2!$%2!*)"'0$)*2!"%!,*#='%#*!)'!')1*,!#)"D50"h!)1*:!$,*!D',*!('D=0*K0:!',2*,*2!
DQGDWWDFKHGWRGLIIHUHQWREMHFWVE\PHDQVRIFRQGLWLRQLQJ/LNHDQ\VHWRIEHKDYLRUV
#5(1!$#!#=**(1!',!D'9*D*%)!=$))*,%#<!*D')"'%#!$2$=)!?")1!)1*!"%2"9"25$0<!>*('D"%/!
³VFKRROHGDQGKDELWL]HG´RU!31"#!=,*#(,"=)"9*!9"#"'%!'-!*D')"'%$0!0"-*!"#!$((',2"%/0:!
)*0*'0'/"($0<!$%2!M$)#'%<!#'5%2"%/!0"7*!1"#!4'9"*)!('5%)*,=$,)#<!=,*2"()#!)1$)!'5,!
*D')"'%$0!1$>")#!?"00!'%*!2$:!>*('D*!$#!('%#"#)*%)!$#!'5,!')1*,!>*1$9"',#!$#!?*!
VFLHQWL¿FDOO\ SURJUHVVXb! F*! *9*%! "D$/"%*#! )1*! ,')*! D$%%*,! "%! ?1"(1! 5)"0")$,"$%!
VFLHQFHFRXOGVWDQGDUGL]HRXUEHKDYLRUVVWDUWLQJZLWKD³IXQGDPHQWDOVWLPXOXV
?1"(1!?"00!($00!'5)!)1*!,*#='%#*!"%![5*#)"'%<O!M$)#'%!($%!('%2")"'%!')1*,!#)"D50"!
)'!2'!0"7*?"#*;XS)RUH[DPSOH:DWVRQFRQGLWLRQHG³KRVSLWDOUHDUHG´XP!(1"02,*%!)'!
IHHOIHDU²DVHWRISK\VLRORJLFDOFKDQJHVXQLYHUVDOO\DWWDFKHGWRWKHVWLPXOXV³ORXG
QRLVH´²LQUHVSRQVHWRRWKHUVWLPXOLRIZKLFKWKH\ZHUH³QDWXUDOO\´XQDIUDLGFDWV
2'/#<!,$>>")#<!,$)#;XQ/LNH3DYORY¶VH[SHULPHQWVZLWKGRJVVXFKFOLQLFDOVWXGLHV
5%2*,#(',*!)?'!-*$)5,*#!'-!>*1$9"',"#D!)1$)!$,*!(*%),$0!)'!)1*!('%(*=)!'-!6)-,)%-29'
SXUL¿FDWLRQ DQ XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI HPRWLRQDO UHVSRQVHV DV QRQLQWHOOHFWXDO DQG D
SUHRFFXSDWLRQZLWKEHKDYLRUDOHIIHFWVWKDWGH¿QHDQGSUHVFULSWLYHO\FRQVWUXFWWKH
#5>I*();!
."#*%#)*"%L#! D*(1$%"#)"(! 9"*?! '-! )1*! 15D$%! D"%2! $%2! ('%(*,%! ?")1! )1*!
('%2")"'%#!)1$)!D'2"-:!>*1$9"',H$%2!*9*%!1"#!)*0*'0'/"($0<!$0D'#)!5)'="$%!9"*?!
RI D WUDLQHG DXGLHQFH ZLWK VWDQGDUGL]HG HPRWLRQDO UHVSRQVHV²¿W KDUPRQLFDOO\
?")1!)1*!>*1$9"',"#)!=,'/,$D;!Z%2**2<!1*!/,'5%2*2!1"#!*$,0:!)1*',:!'-!D'%)$/*!
ZKLFKKHIRUPXODWHGLQDQGIRUWKHWKHDWUHEHIRUHKHWXUQHGWR¿OPPDNLQJXRJ!"%!
1"#!5%2*,#)$%2"%/!'-!+$90'9!$%2!*#=*("$00:!A*71)*,*9<!?1'#*!?',7!#'5/1)!/,*$)*,!
=,*("#"'%!"%!)1*!5%2*,#)$%2"%/!'-!)1*!',/$%"#D!$%2<!50)"D$)*0:<!)1*!#'("$0!('00*()"9*;XX!
$V'DYLG%RUGZHOOSXWVLW(LVHQVWHLQ¶VWKHDWUHDQG¿OPERWKZRUN³WRVKDSHWKH
DXGLHQFH¶VUHVSRQVH´LQRUGHUWR³WUDLQWKH6RYLHWFLWL]HQLQWKHDWWLWXGHVRIWKHQHZ
#'("*):;OXa,QDFOHDUUHIHUHQFHWR$ULVWRWOH(LVHQVWHLQKDGQRWHGWKDWKLV¿OP
.-%26$VKRXOG³VWLUWKHVSHFWDWRUWRDVWDWHRISLW\DQGWHUURU´XV!$%2<!D',*!/*%*,$00:<!
KLVSUHVFULSWLRQVIRUDHVWKHWLFDOO\VXFFHVVIXOUHSUHVHQWDWLRQVZLWKDHVWKHWLFVXFFHVV
D*$#5,*2!"%!)*,D#!'-!)1*!#=*()$(0*L#!*--*()!'%!)1*!#=*()$)',J!#1$,*!7*:!-*$)5,*#!
?")1!)1*!8"$-297'DVLWLVXQGHUVWRRGE\SURSRQHQWVRI$ULVWRWHOLDQ³SXUL¿FDWLRQ´
0RUHRYHUKLVH[SODQDWLRQRIPRQWDJHDQGLWVSK\VLRORJLFDOHIIHFWVFODUL¿HVKRZ
)1*!>*1$9"',"#)!=$,$2"/D!'-!*D')"'%!D"/1)!-$("0")$)*!$!6)-,)%727RISXUL¿FDWLRQWKDW
),$%#-',D#!)1*!#=*()$)',!"%!)1*!D$%%*,!=,'='#*2!>:!&,)$52;!
!"#$%&'()*('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''**J

."#*%#)*"%L#! *$,0"*#)! 2"#(5##"'%! '-! D'%)$/*! '((5,#! "%! $! SUPQ! *##$:! $>'5)!
)1*$),"($0! *27$H$&H79R&$ ³7KH 0RQWDJH RI$WWUDFWLRQV´$ IRUPDO WHFKQLTXH
PRQWDJHLVDPHWKRGRI³VWUXFWXULQJWKHVKRZ´LQRUGHUWRIDFLOLWDWH³DJLWDWLRQ´²D
)*,D!)1$)!&,)$52!$0#'!5#*#!)'!2*#(,">*!1"#!/'$0;XT0RQWDJHVHHNV³WKHPRXOGLQJRI
WKHDXGLHQFHLQDGHVLUHGGLUHFWLRQRUPRRG´XU!Z)#!,$?!D$)*,"$0!"#!%')!#(*%*#!"%!)1*!
FRQYHQWLRQDOVHQVHEXWUDWKHUWKHMX[WDSRVLWLRQRILQGLYLGXDOWKHDWULFDO³PRPHQWV´
FDOOHG ³DWWUDFWLRQV´ ³DQ\ DJJUHVVLYH PRPHQW LQ WKHDWUH LH DQ\ HOHPHQW RI LW
WKDW VXEMHFWV WKH DXGLHQFH WR HPRWLRQDO RU SV\FKRORJLFDO LQÀXHQFH YHUL¿HG E\
H[SHULHQFHDQGPDWKHPDWLFDOO\FDOFXODWHGWRSURGXFHVSHFL¿FHPRWLRQDOVKRFNV
"%! )1*! #=*()$)',;Oab 7KDW WKHVH EDVH ³PROHFXODU XQLWV´ RI PRQWDJH²HTXLYDOHQW
WRWKH³FUXDXWpV´RXWRIZKLFK$UWDXGEXLOGVVSHFWDFOH²DUHGH¿QHGLQWHUPVRI
WKHLUSRWHQWLDOIRUHPRWLRQDOLQÀXHQFHVXJJHVWVWKHIRXQGDWLRQDOUROHSOD\HGE\
HPRWLRQLQ(LVHQVWHLQ¶VSURMHFW+HORFDWHVWKHHI¿FDF\RIKLVWKHDWUHLQLWVDELOLW\
%')!'%0:!)'!*%/$/*!")#!#=*()$)',#!*D')"'%$00:!>5)!$0#'!)'!('%2")"'%!)1*",!*D')"'%$0!
,*#='%#*#;!31*!$)),$()"'%<!)1*%<!"#!$%!*K=*,"D*%)$0!#)"D505#!0"7*!+$90'9L#!,"%/"%/!
EHOOVFLHQWL¿FDOO\GHVLJQHGWRDOLJQSUHH[LVWLQJUHÀH[HVLQGLUHFWLRQV³GLFWDWHG
>:!)1*!=,'25()"'%L#!=5,='#*;OaS!
4**7"%/! )'! *%/$/*! #=*()$)',#! *D')"'%$00:! "#! %')! ")#*0-! ,$2"($0h! ."#*%#)*"%L#!
(0$"D#!,*0:!'%!$%!"%)5")"9*!('%(*=)"'%!$>'5)!$,)<!?1"(1!\'j0!E$,,'00!1$#!>05%)0:!
IRUPXODWHGDV³HPRWLRQVRUJDQL]HSHUFHSWLRQV´aP!F'?*9*,<!."#*%#)*"%!"#!,$2"($0!
"%! ,*=0"($)"%/! >*1$9"',"#DL#! 2*Y*D=1$#"#! '-! D"%2;! F*! =,*#5=='#*#! $! #),$)*/"(!
$/*%(:!'%!)1*!=$,)!'-!)1*!*D')"'%$0!#)"D505#!)1$)!($%!$()!2",*()0:!'%!)1*!#=*()$)',L#!
=1:#"'0'/:<!$!#),$)*/"(!$/*%(:<!"%2**2<!)1$)!$!6)-,)%727RISXUL¿FDWLRQZRXOGUHTXLUH
8QGHUWKHVZD\RIEHKDYLRULVWUHÀH[RORJ\LQLWVEROGHVWDUWLFXODWLRQV(LVHQVWHLQ¶V
WKHRU\FRXOGFODLPWKDWPRQWDJHH[HUFLVHVDFOLQLFDOO\UHOLDEOHDQGYHUL¿DEOHHIIHFW
'%!)1*!*D')"'%#!'-!)1*!$52"*%(*;aQ!Z%!.-%26$IRUH[DPSOH²D¿OPZKRVHSXUSRVHWKH
¿OPPDNHUGHVFULEHGDV³DSXUHO\HPRWLRQDOUHYROXWLRQDU\HIIHFWFRQGLWLRQHGE\WKH
=0')OH."#*%#)*"%!"%25(*#!)1*!#=*()$)',#L!$%/*,!)'?$,2!)1*!='0"(*!(1"*-!>:!(5))"%/!
"%! 2'(5D*%)$,:! #1')#! '-! $! >5)(1*,! #0$5/1)*,"%/! $! >500;aR /LNH:DWVRQ¶V LQIDQW¶V
-*$,!'-!0'52!%'"#*#<!)1*!#=*()$)',L#!"%%$)*!#:D=$)1:!-',!)1*!1*0=0*##0:!)1,$#1"%/!
>500!)15#!>*('D*#!$))$(1*2!9"$!$##'("$)"'%!)'!)1*!#),"7*,#<!1"%2*,*2!>:!)1*!='0"(*;!
."#*%#)*"%! ?$#! -$,! -,'D! $0'%*! "%! 1"#! -$")1! "%! #5(1! $! ,*25()"9*! >*1$9"',"#Dh! 1"#!
*%)15#"$#D<!=$,)"(50$,0:!('DD'%!"%!1"#!4'9"*)!('%)*K)!>5)!%')!0"D")*2!)'!")<!?$#!
#1$,*2!>:!$,)"#)#!$(,'##!#*9*,$0!2"#("=0"%*#;aX!
2QHRIWKHNH\³DWWUDFWLRQV´LQPRQWDJHLVWKHDFWRU¶VERG\DQGLQDHVVD\
."#*%#)*"%!*%2',#*#!$!>"'D*(1$%"($0!D*)1'2!'-!$()"%/!)1$)!($00#!-',!)1*!D*(1$%"($0!
25=0"($)"'%!'-!*D')"'%$0!#)$)*#!,$)1*,!)1$%!)1*!%$)5,$0"#)"(!,*=,*#*%)$)"'%#!-$9',*2!
>:!4)$%"#0$9#7:!$%2!1"#!$21*,*%)#;aa!Z%!N5##"$<!)1*!9'/5*!-',!>"'D*(1$%"(#!$%2!
)1*! 2*(0"%*! '-! 4)$%"#0$9#7"$%! %$)5,$0"#D! >*),$:*2! $! -5%2$D*%)$0! #1"-)! "%! )1*!
=$,$2"/D!'-!*D')"'%h!."#*%#)*"%L#!"2*$!)1$)!$%!$()',!('502!25=0"($)*!$%!*D')"'%!
>:!*K=*,)0:!*D>'2:"%/!")#!=1:#"($0!*--*()#!#5//*#)#!)1*!*K)*%)!)'!?1"(1!>*1$9"',"#)!
**K'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''A2B#%/C'2?'.#/9/4$D'E602#>'/%<';#$4$D$89

LGHDVKDGSHQHWUDWHGFXOWXUDOGLVFRXUVHRIWKHV5HPLQGLQJXVIRUFHIXOO\RI
>*1$9"',"#DL#!2*>)!)'!E$,)*#"$%!$%"D$0!=1:#"'0'/:<!."#*%#)*"%L#!=,*#(,"=)"'%#!-',!
$()',!),$"%"%/!*K=0"(")0:!,*($00!(0$##"($0!D*)1'2#!-',!),$"%"%/!$%"D$0#;!&#!N"(1$,2!
7D\ORUQRWHV(LVHQVWHLQVRXJKWWR³VXEMXJDWHWKHDFWRU¶VPLQGDQGERG\WRWKH
2"#("=0"%*! '-! /:D%$#)"(! ('%),'0! $%2! )1*! $()',! 1"D#*0-! D',*! ('D=0*)*0:! )'! )1*!
2"()$)*#!'-!)1*!2",*()',;OaV!."#*%#)*"%!1$2!*9*%!('"%*2!$!?',2!-',!#5(1!$%!$()',G!
&)-/%7,9,26 RU ³PDQQHTXLQ´&,)$52! ?'502! #"D"0$,0:! =,'='#*! -',! 1"#! $()',#! $!
³NLQGRIDIIHFWLYHPXVFXODWXUHZKLFKFRUUHVSRQGVWRWKHSK\VLFDOORFDOL]DWLRQVRI
-**0"%/#;OaT$QGMXVWDV(LVHQVWHLQDQG9VHYRORG0H\HUKROGSUDLVHGWKHVFLHQWL¿F
=,*("#"'%! '-! >"'D*(1$%"($00:! "%25(*2! *D')"'%<!&,)$52! 0$52*2! )1*! A$0"%*#*!
)1*$),*<! ?1'#*! *D')"'%$0! =,*("#"'%<! 1*! (0$"D*2<! "#! ,'')*2! "%! =1:#"($0! /*#)5,*;aU!
+,$"#"%/!)1*!=1:#"($00:!=,*("#*!A$0"%*#*!$()',#<!&,)$52!,*($=")50$)*#!>*1$9"',"#DL#!
-',*/,'5%2"%/!'-!=1:#"($0!,*#='%#*#<!#),*##"%/!)1$)!)1*!$()',#!$,*!5%2*,!)1*!('%),'0!
RIWKHLUSK\VLRORJ\ZKLFKDFWVOLNH>³9"**$'#29-K'L)%OW!$%!'5)#"2*<!#5=*,"',!-',(*VbJ!
$%2!%')!)1*!')1*,!?$:!$,'5%2;!
7KH FRQVRQDQFH ZLWK WUDJHG\¶V HQWLUHO\ VRPDWLF ³SXULILFDWLRQ´ LV FOHDU
@',*'9*,<!&,)$52!('%%*()#!)1"#!#5>I5/$)"'%!*K=0"(")0:!)'!)1*!#=*()$(0*L#!*--*()!'%!")#!
VSHFWDWRUVZKRWKHPVHOYHVDUHVHL]HG²LQWKLVFDVHE\WHUURU$ULVWRWHOLDQL,"E"7G!

.9*,:)1"%/!"#!)15#!,*/50$)*2!$%2!"D=*,#'%$0h!%')!$!D'9*D*%)!
'-!)1*!D5#(0*#<!%')!)1*!,'00"%/!'-!$%!*:*!>5)!#**D!)'!>*0'%/!)'!$!
NLQGRIUHÀHFWLYHPDWKHPDWLFVZKLFKFRQWUROVHYHU\WKLQJDQGE\
PHDQVRIZKLFKHYHU\WKLQJKDSSHQV$NLQGRIWHUURUVHL]HV
XVDWWKHWKRXJKWRIWKHVHPHFKDQL]HGEHLQJVZKRVH>MR\@DQG
g/,"*-W!#**D!%')!)1*",!'?%!>5)!$)!)1*!#*,9"(*!'-!$/*Y'02!,")*#;VS
!
5HFDOOLQJ1LFROHDQG%RVVXHWERWK$UWDXGDQG(LVHQVWHLQHPSKDVL]HWKHSURFHVV
>:!?1"(1!D5#(50$,0:!"%25(*2!$%2!,*=,*#*%)*2!*D')"'%!#=,*$2#!)'!)1*!#=*()$)',<!
VRWKDWWKHVWLPXOXVRIWKHDFWRU¶VHPRWLRQDOPRYHPHQWVLVPHDQWWR³FDOORXW´
:DWVRQ¶VXVHIXOSKUDVHDQHPRWLRQDOLHSK\VLRORJLFDOUHVSRQVHLQWKHDXGLHQFH
([SHULHQFLQJ³PRWRULPLWDWLRQRIWKHDFWLRQ´WKHVSHFWDWRUEHJLQV²MXVWDVWKHDFWRU
2'*#H)'!*K=*,"*%(*!)1*!$==,'=,"$)*!*D')"'%;VP!31*!)1*$),*!'-!(,5*0):!#=,*$2#<!#$:#!
&,)$52<!-,'D!#=*()$(0*!)'!#=*()$)',#!$%2!)15#!5%2'*#!)1*!2"#)"%()"'%!>*)?**%!)1*D;VQ!
4'!)''!2'*#!."#*%#)*"%L#!D'%)$/*G!1*!$##*,)#!)1$)!)1*!,$?!D$)*,"$0#!'-!D'%)$/*!$,*!
³WKHDFWRU¶VERG\´DQG³WKHDXGLHQFH´VR!3'!-',/*!$!('00*()"9"):!"%!1"#!$52"*%(*!$#!
RQHIRUJHVLURQ(LVHQVWHLQXVHVWKH³GLUHFWDQLPDODXGLHQFHDFWLRQWKURXJKDPRWRU
"D")$)"9*!$()!)'?$,2#!$!0"9*!(1$,$()*,!0"7*!'%*#*0-;OVX$UWDXGVXPPDUL]HVVXFKD
=,'(*##!?*00<!#),*##"%/!)1$)!)1*!$()',!%**2#!)'!(50)"9$)*!D5#(50$,0:!"%25(*2!*D')"'%!
#'!)1$)!)1*!#=*()$)',!($%!>*!)1,'?%!"%)'!$!),$%(*h!7%'?"%/!1'?!)'!(50)"9$)*!)1*#*!
HPRWLRQVKHQRWHVLVWKHNH\WR³UHIRUJLQJ´WKLVFDXVDOFKDLQVa
!"#$%&'()*('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''**+
&,)"(50$)"%/! #5(1! =,'(*##*#<! ."#*%#)*"%! $%2!&,)$52! 2'! D',*! )1$%! (0$"D!
)1$)! )1*! $52"*%(*! =$,)"("=$)*#! 7"%*)"($00:! "%! )1*! #=*()$(0*<! $! (0$"D! )1$)! ?'502!
1$,20:! %*(*##")$)*! $! >*1$9"',"#)! 5%2*,#)$%2"%/! '-! *D')"'%;VV! .$(1! /'*#! -$,)1*,<!
HFKRLQJ EHKDYLRULVP E\ PDNLQJ LGHQWL¿FDWLRQ HQWLUHO\ D PDWWHU RI SK\VLRORJ\
$==,'=,"$)*0:!>',%*!D',*!'5)!'-!)1*!%$,,$)"9*L#!-',D!)1$%!")#!('%)*%)G!1*%(*!&,)$52L#!
HPSKDVLV RQ ³PHWDSK\VLFV´ DQG (LVHQVWHLQ¶V QRWH LQ  WKDW KH ZRUNV E\
³SXUHSK\VLRORJLVP´VT!^*#(,">"%/!1"#!"%%'9$)"9*!'9*,)'%$0!D'%)$/*!"%!)1$)!*##$:<!
(LVHQVWHLQLVSDUWLFXODUO\H[SOLFLWFDOOLQJIRU³WRWDOO\SK\VLRORJLFDOVHQVDWLRQV´WKDW
2'!%')!,*0:!$)!$00!'%!)1*!#*D$%)"(!('%)*%)!'-!)1*!"D$/*#!$%2!?1"(1!($%!=,'25(*!
³IHHOLQJ´ LQ WKH DXGLHQFH²ZKDW KH FDOOV WKH ³IRXUWK GLPHQVLRQ´ H[SHULHQFHVU!
45(1!),$%#(*%2*%)$0!*--*()#!>:=$##!>')1!D"%2!$%2!,*=,*#*%)$)"'%h!)1*:!D$%"-*#)!
SK\VLFDOO\,QWKLVVHQVHWKHGHVFULSWLRQRISODJXHZLWKZKLFK$UWDXGRSHQV³7KH
7KHDWHUDQGWKH3ODJXH´³KHKHDUVKLVERG\ÀXLGVPXUPXULQJZLWKLQKLPWRUQ
IDLOLQJLQDGL]]\LQJFROODSVHRIWLVVXHKLVRUJDQVJURZKHDY\DQGJUDGXDOO\WXUQWR
($,>'%OTbJ!=,'9"2*#!$!='*)"($00:!*K$//*,$)*2!>5)!9"9"2!"D$/*!-',!)1*!=1:#"'0'/"($0!
2"#,5=)"'%!$%2!)1*!2*Y*D=1$#"#!'-!D"%2!)1$)!1"#!)1*',:!=,'D')*#;!M$)#'%!1"D#*0-!
FODLPHGWKDWDQHPRWLRQDOVWLPXOXVWKURZVWKH³RUJDQLVP´LQWR³DFKDRWLFVWDWH´TS!
$%2! $! )1*$),*! '-! *D')"'%! ?'502! )15#! >*! 2"#',2*,"%/! $%2! ('*,("9*! -',! )1*! 9*,:!
,*$#'%#!$00*/*2!>:!A*,)'0)!A,*(1);TP!@$2*!D5#(50$,0:!)'!E$,)0$!2"--*,*%)0:<!)1*!
#=*()$)',!B$$;7!2"--*,*%)0:<!$%2<!-'00'?"%/!)1*!0'/"(!'-!>*1$9"',"#D<!)1*!#=*()$)',!
)15#! E$9"*$7' 2"--*,*%);! 31*",! =,'I*()#! )15#! $0"/%! ?")1! )1*! ),$%#-',D$)"'%#! '-! $!
6)-,)%-29'³SXUL¿FDWLRQ´$V+RXVHZULWHVLQKLVFRPPHQWDU\RQ8"$-297³WUDJHG\
,'5#*#!)1*!*D')"'%#!-,'D!=')*%)"$0"):!)'!$()"9"):!>:!?',)1:!$%2!$2*[5$)*!#)"D50";!;!;!;!
:KHQWKH\VXEVLGHWRSRWHQWLDOLW\DJDLQDIWHUWKHSOD\LVRYHULWLVDPRUHµWUDLQHG¶
=')*%)"$0"):!)1$%!>*-',*;!31"#!"#!?1$)!&,"#)')0*!($00#!g6)-,)%727W;OTQ!

d!d!d

,Q(LVHQVWHLQ¶VPRVWYLYLGHFKRLQJRI$UWDXGKHKDGQRWHGWKDWWKHSOD\LV³D
VHPLQDUFRWLFH[SHULHQFH´DQGOLNHQHGVSHFWDWRUVKLSWR³WKHFHOHEUDWHGGDQFHVLQ
$%"D$0!#7"%#!'-!)1*!=,"D")"9*!#$9$/*#;OTR!&,)$52!$%2!."#*%#)*"%L#!$%$0'/"($0!,*('5,#*!
WR³SULPLWLYHWLPHV´PLUURUV$ULVWRWHOLDQFRPPHQWDU\OLNH+DUULVRQ¶VIRUZKRP
ULWXDOZRUVKLS²³QRQHZHUHDFWRUVQRQHVSHFWDWRUV´²JDYHZD\WRDFRUUXSWHG
GUDPDDQG0XUUD\¶VZKLFKOLQNV*UHHNWUDJHG\WRWKHULWHVRI'LRQ\VXVTX!&%2!
VXFKGLVFRXUVHUHÀHFWVWKHGHVLUHWRXQGHUVWDQGDQDXGLHQFHDVDFROOHFWLYHPDVV
?")1!('DD5%$0!%**2#;!A*1$9"',"#D<!?")1!")#!)*0*'0'/"($0!)1,5#)!$%2!2*Y*D=1$#"#!
RIPLQGFRXOGSURYLGHDIRXQGDWLRQIRUVXFKDQXQGHUVWDQGLQJ$QDWRPL]LQJD
>*1$9"',"#)!5%2*,#)$%2"%/!'-!*D')"'%<!?*!($%!,*('%("0*!)1*!('%),$2"()"'%#!5='%!
ZKLFK$UWDXGUHOLHVZKHQKHVWDWHVWKDW³WKHDWHUOLNHWKHSODJXHLVDGHOLULXPDQGLV
FRPPXQLFDWLYH´IRUFRQWDJLRXVFRPPXQLFDWLRQ$UWDXGFODLPVRFFXUVE\³SUHFLVH
PHDQV´*"1$&7'L%K927J!?1'#*!?',7"%/#!($%!%'%*)1*0*##!%')!>*!$,)"(50$)*2!?")1!
*()'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''A2B#%/C'2?'.#/9/4$D'E602#>'/%<';#$4$D$89

³SUHFLVHUHDVRQV´%)27"&7'L%K927$7J;Ta!45(1!('DD5%"($)"'%!"#!#"D"0$,!)'!)1$)!'-!)1*!
(OHXVLQLDQP\VWHULHVZKRVHLQLWLDWH+HOHQH)ROH\QRWHVLV³PDGHWRH[SHULHQFH´
DQGWKXV³FKDQJHKLVRUKHUVWDWHRIPLQG´TV!
A*1$9"',"#D!0'($)*#!)1*!D*(1$%"#D#!-',!#5(1!('DD5%"($)"'%!"%!)1*!=1:#"'0'/:!
'-!")#!#5>I*()#<!?1'!($%!>*!),$"%*2!9"$!('%2")"'%"%/<!D$7"%/!='##">0*!$!9"#"'%!'-!)1*!
$()',L#!$%2!)1*!#=*()$)',L#!=1:#"'0'/"($0!),$%#-',D$)"'%#;!Z%!)1"#!?$:<!>*1$9"',"#)Y
LQÀHFWHG DFFRXQWV RI' 6)-,)%-29' SXUL¿FDWLRQ FDQ RYHUFRPH WKH WHQWDWLYHQHVV RI
/HVVLQJ¶VZKLFKKDGFODLPHGWKDW

g?W1*%! 1*! 1$#! -',! $! 0'%/! #=*00! 2'%*! %')1"%/! >5)! ('=:! ')1*,#<!
g)1*!$()',W!?"00!$)!0$#)!1$9*!$((5D50$)*2!$!%5D>*,!'-!0"))0*!,50*#!
$((',2"%/!)'!?1"(1!1*!>*/"%#!)'!$()!$%2!)1,'5/1!)1*!'>#*,9$%(*!
RIZKLFKLQFRQVHTXHQFHRIWKHODZWKDWWKHPRGL¿FDWLRQVRIWKH
#'50!)1$)!"%25(*!(*,)$"%!(1$%/*#!'-!)1*!>'2:<!"%!,*)5,%!$,*!"%25(*2!
>:!)1*#*!>'2"0:!(1$%/*#J!1*!$,,"9*#!$)!)'7L$92$7'"B'B$$;2&5')1$)!1$#!
QRWLWLVWUXHWKHGXUDWLRQRUWKH¿UHRIWKDWZKLFKDULVHVLQWKH
#'50<!>5)!"#!:*)!='?*,-50!*%'5/1!"%!)1*!D'D*%)#!'-!,*=,*#*%)$)"'%!
)'!>,"%/!$>'5)!#'D*!'-!)1*!"%9'05%)$,:!(1$%/*#!'-!>'2:!?1'#*!
*K"#)*%(*!-',D#!$0D'#)!)1*!'%0:!(*,)$"%!(05*!?*!1$9*!$#!)'!)1*!
=,*#*%(*!'-!"%%*,!-**0"%/;TT!
!
\')!1$D#),5%/!>:!25$0"#)"(!=,*#5D=)"'%#<!."#*%#)*"%!?'502!%*")1*,!1$9*!)'!1*2/*!
KLVFODLPVDERXWHPRWLRQDODXWKHQWLFLW\DV/HVVLQJKDG³HLQHU$UWYRQ(PS¿QGXQJOJ!
QRUPRWLYDWHKLVFODLPVDERXWERGLO\FKDQJHVZLWKLQWKHVRXO7KDWLVZKLOH/HVVLQJ
KDGFODLPHGWKDW³IHHOLQJLVVRPHWKLQJLQWHUQDORIZKLFKZHFDQRQO\MXGJHE\LWV
*K)*,%$0!#"/%#<OTU!."#*%#)*"%!('502!-'(5#!*K(05#"9*0:!'%!)1*!*K)*,%$0!#"/%#!)1$)!-',!
KLP FRQVWLWXWHG UDWKHU WKDQ LQGLFDWHG ³IHHOLQJ´$QG WKXV (LVHQVWHLQ VHHPV WR
,*#'09*!)1*!$#=*()!'-!*D')"'%!)1$)!1$#!),'5>0*2!")#!*%)",*!1"#)',:!$%2!=1"0'#'=1:<!
DQGZKLFKLVHPEHGGHGLQRXUHPRWLRQDOYRFDEXODU\WKHIDFWWKDW³JXLOW%)967!5#O!
LQ(QJOLVK³ODUDJHQRXV9"&7/*$´LQ)UHQFK³GLH$QJVW$%5%$2B-XQV´LQ*HUPDQ'
$UWDXG(LVHQVWHLQDQGWKHRULHVRI$ULVWRWHOLDQ³SXUL¿FDWLRQ´DOOXQGHUVWDQGWKH
#=*()$)',! $#! $! =$##"9*! >'2:! )'! >*! $()*2! 5='%! >:! D*$%#! '-! #=*()$(0*H$%2! )1"#!
5%2*,#)$%2"%/!=,*#*%)#!%'!('%(*=)5$0!=$,$2'K!-',!)1*!*D')"'%$0!=$,$2"/D#!)1$)!
"%-',D!)1*",!)1*',"*#;!
45(1!$!9"*?!(*0*>,$)*#!,$)1*,!)1$%!-,*)#!$>'5)!)1*!"%),$%#")"9"):!'-!>')1!)1*!
*D')"'%#!$%2!)1*!)1*$),"($0!*K=*,"*%(*H)1*!-**0"%/!'-!>*"%/!$()*2!5='%!',!#?*=)!
$?$:<!$#!)?'!(1$,$()*,#!2"#(5##!"%!@$,"$!Z,*%*!]',%*#L#!*%9",'%D*%)$0!S$B/')&#'
N$%'S%2$&#7G

T2&#1G!M1$)!2'*#!)1*!#?**="%/`
! ! T,%27-2&)G!&%!*D')"'%!;!;!;!$!-**0"%/;!
!"#$%&'()*('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''*(*

! ! T2&#1G!31*%!*D')"'%#!1$9*!>,"#)0*#`
! ! T,%27-2&)G!6*#;
T2&#1U'\'?!Z!5%2*,#)$%2;Ub

8%2*,#)$%2"%/!)1*!-**0"%/!'-!='?*,0*##%*##<!)1*!>,"#)0"%/!1*$)!'-!*D')"'%#!)1$)!#**D!
*K)*,"',!)'!)1*!#*0-!$%2!>*:'%2!")#!('%),'0<!#**D#!%*9*,!)'!1$9*!>**%!*$#:H1*%(*!
kD"0*!^5,71*"DL#!)1*',:!)1$)!)1*!"%('D=,*1*%#">"0"):!'-!*D')"'%$0!*K=*,"*%(*#!
0*$2#!$/*%)#!)'!5%2*,#)$%2!")!$#!)1*!=,*#*%(*!'-!$!/'2;US!]',!)1*!E$D>,"2/*!,")5$0"#)#<!
'XUNKHLPZDVDNH\LQÀXHQFHDQG\HWWKH\OLNH$UWDXGXQZLWWLQJO\EHWUD\WKH
9*,:!=1*%'D*%'%!)1$)!^5,71*"D!$22,*##*2!>:!,*$(1"%/!>$(7!"%)'!$!=,*YD"D*)"(!
DVWKH\VDZLWWLPHDQGORRNLQJIRUWKHGLYLQH7KH$ULVWRWHOLDQFRPPHQWDU\WKDW
)1*:!"%#=",*2<!&,)$52L#!)1*$),*!'-!(,5*0):<!$%2!."#*%#)*"%L#!D'%)$/*!'-!$)),$()"'%#!
*$(1!KROGVVLJQL¿FDQFHIRUWKHDWUHKLVWRU\DQGSHUIRUPDQFHWKHRU\RQLWVRZQWHUPV
EXWOD\LQJWKHVHXQOLNHO\EHGIHOORZVQH[WWRRQHDQRWKHUKDVH[HJHWLFDOEHQH¿WV
E'%#'%$%(*#! "%! )1*",! =,*#5=='#")"'%#! $>'5)! *D')"'%! $,*! ,*9*$0*2<! $%2! )1*#*!
SUHVXSSRVLWLRQVFOHDUSURGXFWVRIWKHLUWLPHFDQEHPRUHFDUHIXOO\KLVWRULFL]HG
8%2*,#)$%2"%/!)1*!*D')"'%#!1$#!%*9*,!>**%!*$#:<!?1$)*9*,!]',%*#L#!E"%2:!#$:#;!
A5)!>:!*K($9$)"%/!)1*!5%#)$)*2!$##5D=)"'%#!$>'5)!*D')"'%!)1$)!$%"D$)*!)1"#!',!)1$)!
=*,-',D$%(*!',!2,$D$)"(!)1*',:<!?*!($%!$)!0*$#)!#**!)1*!)1*',:H$%2!*$,0"*,!='"%)#!
"%!)1*$),*!1"#)',:HD',*!(0*$,0:;!^'"%/!#'<!?*!D"/1)!$0#'!"005D"%$)*!'5,!=,*#*%)!
('%)*K)!',!$)!0*$#)!*%('5,$/*!#(,5)"%:!'-!'5,!'?%!('%(*=)5$0!5%2*,="%%"%/#;!&-)*,!
$00<!?1*)1*,!?*!$,*!(,")"(#<!$()',#<!2",*()',#<!',!=0$:?,"/1)#<!'5,!5%2*,#)$%2"%/!'-!
)1*!*D')"'%#!,*D$"%#!(*%),$0!)'!'5,!)1*$),"($0!*%2*$9',#<!*9*%!"-!'5,!'?%!$%#?*,#!
D$:!>*!#5#=*()!$%2!)"D*>'5%2;!

L2408

S;!!]',!1"#!,*#*$,(1!$##"#)$%(*<!Z!/,$)*-500:!$(7%'?0*2/*!&0*K!]*,,'%*;
P;!!4;!F;!A5)(1*,<!),$%#;<!+,$'8"$-297'"B'C%27-"-;$:WKHG/RQGRQ0DFPLOODQ
*HUDOG(OVHWUDQV8"$-297'$QQ$UERU8RI0LFKLJDQ3
R;!!@$,)1$!\5##>$5DL#!=$,$=1,$#*!'-!&,"#)')0*!$==*$,#!"%!1*,!S%)52;2-1'"B'G""#&$77&DPEULGJH
E$D>,"2/*!8+<!SUTaJ!QUS;
X;!!^$9"2!F5D*<!C'+%$)-27$'"B'N/*)&'?)-/%$HG/$6HOE\%LJJHQGHG2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQ
SUVTJ!PXQ;!
(OVH¶V1HZ&ULWLFDOLQÀHFWLRQVDUHVHHQPRVWFOHDUO\LQ8"$-297'PQb;!
+HQU\*HRUJH/LGGHOOHWDOHGVC'G%$$6H@&5;27,'I$J29"&:'WKHG2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQ
%\FRQWUDVW³SXUJDWLRQ´DQG³SXUL¿FDWLRQ´DUHOLVWHGDOUHDG\DWWKHOH[LFRQ¶VEHJLQQLQJV+HQU\
*HRUJH/LGGHOODQG5REHUW6FRWWHGVC'G%$$6H@&5;27,'I$J29"&VWHG2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQ
6HH5'DUUHQ*REHUW³&RJQLWLYH&DWKDUVLVLQ+,$'T)/9)72)&'T,);6'T2%9;$<O!!"#$%&'(%)*)'
LQZKLFK,WUDFHWKHGHYHORSPHQWRIQHZFRJQLWLYLVWSDUDGLJPVRIHPRWLRQLQWKHPLGWR
0$)*Y)?*%)"*)1!(*%)5,:!$%2!*K$D"%*!)1*",!"D=$()!'%!,*$2"%/#!'-!&,"#)')0*<!#5(1!$#!)1$)!'-!\5##>$5D;
U;! 7KH HGLWRUV RI WKH *DOOLPDUG V/0%$7' 9"*L;R-$7! (',,*()!&,)$52L#! ):=*?,"))*%! D$%5#(,"=)L#!
³)E,"%%)-2"&´ WR ³)E$%%)-2"&O! '%! )1*! >$#"#! )1$)! 1*! 2"()$)*2! )'! $! ('=:"#);!&%)'%"%!&,)$52<! V/0%$7'
9"*L;R-$7YROV3DULV*DOOLPDUGZcG!QVS!%;X;!A5)!/"9*%!&,)$52L#!*%)15#"$#D!*0#*?1*,*!
"%!1"#!?,")"%/#!-',!$00!D$%%*,!'-!)E$%%)-2"&7<!$%2!*#=*("$00:!/"9*%!)1"#!*##$:L#!"%)*,*#)!"%!('D>$)"%/!
WKH³9"&B"%*27*$´,9RIWKH:HVWHUQWKHDWUHWKHQHRORJLVP)E,"%%)-2"&!D$:!>*!$==,'=,"$)*;!
*(('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''A2B#%/C'2?'.#/9/4$D'E602#>'/%<';#$4$D$89
Sb;!!&%)'%"%!&,)$52<!+,$'+,$)-$%')&#'2-7'("/E;$:'WUDQV0DU\&DUROLQH5LFKDUGV1HZ<RUN
*URYH$OOWUDQVODWLRQVIURP)UHQFKDQG*HUPDQEXWQRW5XVVLDQKDYHEHHQVFUXWLQL]HG
$/$"%#)!)1*!',"/"%$0<!$%2!$%:!5%(,*2")*2!),$%#0$)"'%#!$,*!D:!'?%;!
SS;!!TQ;!
SP;!!E1,"#)'=1*,!Z%%*#<!N";1'+,$)-%$U'>2-/);')&#'-,$'C0)&-'G)%#$'&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH83
SUTSJ!PXQ;!
SQ;!!&,)$52<!+,$)-$%'SbU;!
SR;!!&,)$52<!V/0%$7!ZcG!XT;
SX;!!31*!"%")"$)*!)15#!1'=*#!)'!/$"%<!$#!^*D'=1'f%!2'*#<!$!>*))*,!0"-*!"%!)1*!$-)*,?',02;!M1"0*!)1*!
*K$()!('%)*%)!'-!)1*!D:#)*,"*#!,*D$"%#!5%7%'?%<!)1*",!',"/"%!D:)1!"#!,*(',2*2!"%!)1*!F'D*,"(!N1*&'
-"'($*$-$%GHFODULQJWKDWVKHZLOO³OD\GRZQWKHULWHVVRWKDWKHUHDIWHUSHUIRUPLQJGXHULWHV\RX
PD\SURSLWLDWHP\VSLULW´'HPHWHU³UHYHDOHGWKHFRQGXFWRIKHUULWHVDQGWDXJKWKHU0\VWHULHVWRDOO
RIWKHPKRO\ULWHVWKDWDUHQRWWREHWUDQVJUHVVHGQRUSULHGLQWRQRUGLYXOJHG´+HOHQH)ROH\HG
$%2!),$%#;!+,$'N"*$%29'N1*&'-"'($*$-$%'3ULQFHWRQ3ULQFHWRQ83OO2QWKH
D:#)*,"*#<!#**!]'0*:L#!('DD*%)$,:<!*#=*("$00:!$)!Qb<!aUYVb<!$%2!Ta;
Sa;! !&,)$52<! +,$)-$%' Pa;! N"(1$,2#L#! ),$%#0$)"'%! '-! $7L%2- DV ³PLQG´ LV KHUH XQVDWLVIDFWRU\ IRU
³PLQG´¿WVLOOZLWK³/&'L$/L;$´DQG³$7L%2-O!>*$,#!%'!"%)*00*()5$0!('%%')$)"'%#;!M1"0*!)1*,*!"#!%'!=,*("#*!
(QJOLVKHTXLYDOHQW³VSLULW´LVWUXHUWR$UWDXG¶VVHQVHZKRVHRULJLQDODSSHDUVDW$UWDXGV/0%$7!ZcG!QP;
SV;!!ZcG!XS;
ST;!!]',!$%!'9*,9"*?!'-!)1*!,")5$0"#)!)1*#"#<!#**!)1*!"%),'25()"'%!)'!N'>*,)!&;!4*/$0<!*2;<!+,$'!1-,'
)&#'>2-/);'+,$"%1'2[IRUG%ODFNZHOO,QDGH¿QLQJDUWLFOHRQ+DUULVRQ-XOLH6WRQH3HWHUV
1$#!%')*2!)1$)<!2*#=")*!)1*!)*%2*%(:!)'!/,'5=!)1*!#(1'0$,#!)'/*)1*,<!F$,,"#'%!?$#!>')1!'02*,!$%2!)1*!
¿UVWWRDUWLFXODWHDQLQFKRDWHYHUVLRQRIWKHWKHVLVDVHDUO\DVVHH3HWHUV³-DQH+DUULVRQDQGWKH
4$9$/*!^"'%:#5#G!&,(1$*'0'/"($0!c':$/*#<!N")5$0!e,"/"%#<!&%)1,'='0'/:<!$%2!)1*!@'2*,%!31*$),*<O!
!"#$%&'(%)*)'
SU;! ! 4**! 4)$%0*:!M;! _$(7#'%<! T)%$' "B' -,$' 8719,$U'C' N27-"%1' "B' 8719,";"529);' N$);2&5 1HZ
F$9*%G!6$0*!8+<!SUUUJ!V;!
Pb;!!A*,%$:#L#!WP$2'CE,)&#;/&5$&'XE$%'#2$')%27-"-$;279,$'+,$"%2$'#$7'(%)*)'g+P"'@77)17'"&'-,$'
C%27-"-$;2)&'+,$"%1'"B'(%)*)@%HUOLQ:+HUW]SURYLGHGWKHODWHQLQHWHHQWKFHQWXU\ZLWKLWV
2'D"%$%)!5%2*,#)$%2"%/!'-!&,"#)')0*<!*9*%!$(1"*9"%/!='=50$,!#5((*##;!Z!*K=0',*!)1*!#'D*)"D*#!5%($%%:!
SDUDOOHOVEHWZHHQWKLVWH[W¶VPHGLFDOL]HGXQGHUVWDQGLQJRI$ULVWRWOHDQGWKHLOOQHVVRI$QQD2)UHXGDQG
%UHXHU¶V¿UVW³K\VWHULF´LQ5'DUUHQ*REHUW³'UDPDWLF&DWKDUVLV)UHXGLDQ+\VWHULDDQGWKHµ3ULYDWH
31*$),*L!'-!&%%$;!e<O!@*"-2"&7U'C'T/;-/%);'.-/#2$7'>$)#$%:'*2;!_*%%"-*,!F$,2"%/!$%2!.;!^*"2,*!+,">,$D!
1HZ<RUN5RXWOHGJH%\UHPDUNDEOHFRLQFLGHQFH$QQD2%HUWKD3DSSHQKHLPIHOOLOOLQWKH
#$D*!:*$,!)1$)!A*,%$:#L#!),*$)"#*!?$#!=5>0"#1*2G!STTb;!
-HQQLIHUDQG-RQDWKDQ%DUQHVKDYHWUDQVODWHGSDJHVRI%HUQD\V¶VSDJHERRNDV³$ULVWRWOH
'%!)1*!.--*()!'-!3,$/*2:<O!C%-29;$7'"&'C%27-"-;$YROV/RQGRQ'XFNZRUWK,9
PS;!!*HRUJH7KRPVRQC$79,1;/7')&#'C-,$&7/RQGRQ/DZUHQFHDQG:LVKDUW6HH
WRR*LOEHUW0XUUD\¶VVLPLODUDUJXPHQWLQKLVSUHIDFHWR,QJUDP%\ZDWHU¶VWUDQVODWLRQRIWKH8"$-297G!
C%27-"-;$'"&'-,$'C%-'"B'8"$-%1'2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQ!
)HUJXVVRQLQYRNHV³WKH&DPEULGJH6FKRRORI&ODVVLFDO$QWKURSRORJLVWV´VSHFL¿FDOO\QRWLQJ
WKDW ³&RUQIRUG +DUULVRQ 0XUUD\ DQG RWKHUV RI WKLV VFKRRO KDYH JLYHQ XV D QHZ XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI
*UHHN7UDJHG\E\GHPRQVWUDWLQJLWVURRWVLQP\WKDQGULWXDO´)UDQFLV)HUJXVVRQ+,$'D#$)'"B')'+,$)-$%'
3ULQFHWRQ3ULQFHWRQ83
PQ;!!&,)$52<!+,$)-$%'Sb;!
PR;!!_$([5*#!E'=*$5<!?"-$7'7/%';$'*K-2$%'#$'9"*K#2$&3DULV0LFKHO%ULHQW4**!$0#'!
_'1%!N520"%:'Y)9Z/$7'T"L$)/&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH83PT;
PX;!!³)RUZKRHYHUKDVHQGHDYRXUHGWRDUULYHDWDMXVWDQGFRPSOHWHFRQFHSWLRQRI$ULVWRWOH¶V
GRFWULQHRIWKHSXUL¿FDWLRQRIWKHSDVVLRQVZLOO¿QGWKDWWKLVSXUL¿FDWLRQUHVWVLQQRWKLQJHOVHWKDQ
LQWKHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQRISDVVLRQVLQWRYLUWXRXVKDELWV´*(/HVVLQJN)*E/%5'(%)*)-/%51:'),$%#;!
9LFWRU/DQJH1HZ<RUN'RYHU7KHRULJLQDODSSHDUVDW*(/HVVLQJ[$%6$:'*2;!B0$5#!
%RKQHQYROV)UDQNIXUWDP0DLQ'HXWVFKHU.ODVVLNHU9,
Pa;!! %HUQD\V³$ULVWRWOH´  P\ HPSKDVLV7KH RULJLQDO DSSHDUV DW -DFRE %HUQD\V WP$2'
CE,)&#;/&5$&'XE$%'#2$')%27-"-$;279,$'+,$"%2$'#$7'(%)*)'%HUOLQ:LOKHOP+HU]J!SQ;!
PV;!!'XULQJKLVQLQH\HDUVRIFRQ¿QHPHQWWRDV\OXPV$UWDXGUHFRQYHUWHGWRDQGUHUHQRXQFHG
E1,"#)"$%"):!$%2!2$>>0*2!"%!F"%25"#D!$%2!9$,"'5#!'((50)!=,$()"(*#h!N'%$02!F$:D$%<!C%-)/#')&#'CB-$%!
2[IRUG2[IRUG83$UWDXG¶VDWWLWXGHWRZDUGVERWKP\VWLFLVPDQGUDWLRQDOSV\FKRORJ\
"#!($=)5,*2!?*00!"%!)1*!-'00'?"%/!=$##$/*!-,'D!1"#!,*$2"%/!%')*#<!$)!V/0%$7<!cZZZG!SRRG
!"#$%&'()*('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''*(F
!+05#!0L1'DD*!#*!=,i'((5=*!2*!05"<!=05#!#*#!=,i'((5=$)"'%#!i(1$==*%)!*%!,i$0")i!
l!0L1'DD*<
!i/'(*%),"#D*!"%2"9"25$0"#)*!*)!=#:(1'0'/"[5*
!'=='#i!l!0L15D$%"#D*<
!0L1'DD*![5$%2!'%!0*!#*,,*!2*!=,C#<!(*0$!$>'5)")!)'5I'5,#!l!),'59*,!(*![5"!%L*#)!
=$#!0L1'DD*!;!;!;!;
/DSV\FKRORJLHQ¶HVWSDVODVFLHQFHGHO¶KRPPHDXFRQWUDLUH
g! 31*! D',*! =,*'((5="*2! D$%! "#! ?")1! 1"D#*0-<! )1*! D',*! ",,*0*9$%)! 1"#!
=,*'((5=$)"'%#!$,*!)'!15D$%!,*$0"):<!
!"%2"9"25$0"#)"(!$%2!=#:(1'0'/"($0!*/'(*%),"#D
!'=='#*2!)'!15D$%"#D<
VTXHH]HDPDQDQG\RXZLOODOZD\V¿QGVRPHWKLQJQRWKXPDQ
!+#:(1'0'/:!"#!%')!)1*!#("*%(*!'-!D$%<!'%!)1*!('%),$,:;W

PT;!!&,)$52<!+,$)-$%'XP;!
PU;!³>/H@SULQFLSHPrPHGXWKpkWUHTXLHVWPpWDSK\VLTXH´&,)$52<!V/0%$7'ZcG!SQT;!B$,0!_$#=*,#<!
+%)5$#1'27'?"-'@&"/5,WUDQV+DUDOG$75HLFKHHWDOA'#)'%G!A*$('%<!SUXPJ!RS;
Qb;!!_'%$#!A$,"#1<!+,$'C&-2-,$)-%29);'8%$Q/#29$'%HUNHOH\8RI&DOLIRUQLD3
QS;!!³,Q+,$'T2-1'"B'G"#!4);!&5/5#)"%*!('D=0$"%#!'-!)1"#!#"D"0$,"):!>*)?**%!)1*!$()"'%!'-!)1*!
=0$/5*!)1$)!7"00#!?")1'5)!2*#),':"%/!)1*!',/$%#!$%2!)1*!)1*$)*,!?1"(1<!?")1'5)!7"00"%/<!=,'9'7*#!)1*!
D'#)!D:#)*,"'5#!$0)*,$)"'%#!"%!)1*!g#=",")!";*;<!$7L%2-W!'-!%')!'%0:!$%!"%2"9"25$0!>5)!$%!*%)",*!='=50$(*Oh!
&,)$52<!+,$)-$%!Pa;!31*!',"/"%$0!$==*$,#!$)!&,)$52<!V/0%$7'ZcG!QP;
QP;!³&¶HVWXQPpWLHURGHVKRPPHV GHVIHPPHVUHSUpVHQWHQWGHVSDVVLRQVGHKDLQHGHFROHUH
G¶DPELWLRQGHYHQJHDQFH SULQFLSDOHPHQWG¶DPRXU,OIDXWTX¶LOVOHVH[SULPHQWOHSOXVQDWXUHOOHPHQW
OHSOXVYLYHPHQWTX¶LOOHXUHVWSRVVLEOH LOVQHOHVDXURLHQWIDLUHV¶LOVQHOHVH[FLWHQWHQTXHOTXH
VRUWHHQHX[PrPHV VLOHXUDPHQHVHOHVLPSULPHSRXUOHVH[SULPHUH[WHULHXUHPHQWSDUOHVJHVWHV
SDUOHVSDUROHV´3LHUUH1LFROH³7UDLWpGHODFRPpGLH´@77)27'#$'*"%);$:'YROV3DULV*XLOODXPH
'HVSUH],,,
QQ;!³(QLPLWDQWTXHOTXHFKRVHRQHQSUHQDLWO¶HVSULW´-DFTXHV%pQLJQH%RVVXHW!)J2*$7'$-'
UpÀH[LRQVVXUODFRPpGLHHG$*D]LHU3DULV%HOLQ
QR;!³/HVSHFWDWHXUHQWUDLWDXVVLGDQVOHPrPHHVSULW$LQVLWRXWO¶DSSDUHLOGXWKpkWUHQHWHQG
[5Ll!-$",*!2*#!1'DD*#!=$##"'%%i#;O!XQ;
QX;!!31$)!"#<!$#!&,)$52!#5//*#)#<!)1*!)1*$),*!($5#*#!#5>#*[5*%)!$()"'%<!I5#)!$#!)1*!=0$/5*!2'*#G!
³WKHREHGLHQWDQGYLUWXRXVVRQNLOOVKLVIDWKHUWKHFKDVWHPDQSHUIRUPVVRGRP\RQKLVQHLJKERUV7KH
OHFKHUEHFRPHVSXUH7KHPLVHUWKURZVKLVJROGLQKDQGIXOVRXWWKHZLQGRZ7KHZDUULRUKHURVHWV¿UH
)'!)1*!("):!1*!'%(*!,"#7*2!1"#!0"-*!)'!#$9*;O!+,$)-$%'PR;!!
Qa;!!_$(7#'%'QbU<!QSS;
QV;!!4WGLQ%HUQDUG:HLQEHUJ³5RERUWHOORRQWKH8"$-297<O!T%2-297')&#'T%2-2927*U'C&92$&-')&#'
!"#$%&:'HG56&UDQHHWDOE1"($/'G!8!'-!E1"($/'!+<!SUXPJ!QPPh!D:!*D=1$#"#;
QT;!!F5D=1,:!F'5#*<!C%27-"-;$M7'+'*)"(#G!C'T"/%7$'2&'@25,-'I$9-/%$7'/RQGRQ5XSHUW+DUW'DYLG
SUXaJ!SSb<!SbU;
QU;!!&,)$52<!V/0%$7'ZcG!TQ<!UV<!UU;!
Rb;!!e%!)1*!,"#*!'-!>*1$9"',"#D!"%!)1*!)?*%)"*)1!(*%)5,:!$%2!")#!('%#'%$%(*!?")1!'02*,!=,$()"(*#!
"%!>')1!"%#)")5)"'%$0!=*2$/'/:!$%2!$%"D$0!),$"%"%/<!#**!_$(7#'%!QbTYPP;!_$(7#'%!$0*,)#!1"#!,*$2*,!)'!
DPD]LQJSDVVDJHVIURP6RORPRQ'LDPRQG¶VDQWKRORJ\+,$'>""-7'"B'8719,";"51<!"%(052"%/!'%*!>:!$!
#"K)**%)1Y(*%)5,:!?,")*,!)1$)!2*#(,">*#!1'?!$!($D*0!($%!>*!)$5/1)!)'!2$%(*!>:!$##'("$)"%/!2,5D>*$)#!
ZLWKWKHDSSOLFDWLRQRI¿UHWRLWVIHHW
RS;!!+$90'9!%')*#!)1$)!#)52"*#!'-!$%"D$0!>*1$9"',!1$2!³-,5")-500:!$==0"*2!;!;!;!;!^*#($,)*#L!('%(*=)"'%!
RI WKH UHÀH[´ EXW DOZD\V ³VWRSSHG VKRUW RI WKH FHUHEUDO FRUWH[´²D OLPLWDWLRQ KH DQG OLNHPLQGHG
=#:(1'0'/"#)#!'9*,($D*h!Z;!+;!+$90'9<!&RQGLWLRQHG5HÀH[HVWUDQVDQGHG*9$QUHS1HZ<RUN
\',)'%<!SUabJ!R;!4),*##"%/!)1*!('%)"%5"):!>*)?**%!,*#*$,(1!'%!$%"D$0!=1:#"'0'/:!$%2!15D$%!>*1$9"',<!
IRUH[DPSOH3DYORYKDGFROODSVHGWKHGLVWLQFWLRQEHWZHHQ³QHUYRXV´LHSK\VLFDODQG³SV\FKLF´
LHPHQWDOGLVRUGHUVE\VXJJHVWLQJDFXUHIRUK\VWHULDWKDWGHULYHGIURPKLVEHKDYLRUDOPRGL¿FDWLRQ
'-!$%!*K(")$>0*!2'/h!QUa;!
RP;!!3DYORY¶VDVVHUWLRQWKDW³DWWKHSUHVHQWVWDJHRIRXUZRUNQRGHWDLOHGDSSOLFDWLRQRILWVUHVXOWV
WRPDQLV\HWSHUPLVVLEOH´ZHQWXQKHHGHGDVODWHUSV\FKRORJLVWV]HDORXVO\SXUVXHGKLVFODLPWKDW³>L@W
"#!'>9"'5#!)1$)!)1*!2"--*,*%)!7"%2#!'-!1$>")#!>$#*2!'%!),$"%"%/<!*25($)"'%!$%2!2"#("=0"%*!'-!$%:!#',)!$,*!
QRWKLQJEXWDORQJFKDLQRIFRQGLWLRQHGUHÀH[HV´%HNKWHUHYIRUH[DPSOHZULWHVWKDWUHÀH[RORJ\
³FRQVLVWVLQLQYHVWLJDWLQJIURPWKHVWULFWO\REMHFWLYHVWDQGSRLQWQRWRQO\WKHPRUHHOHPHQWDU\EXWDOVR
$00!)1*!1"/1*,<!-5%()"'%#!'-!)1*!15D$%!>*"%/<!?1"(1!"%!*9*,:2$:!0$%/5$/*!$,*!($00*2!)1*!D$%"-*#)$)"'%#!'-!
*(G'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''A2B#%/C'2?'.#/9/4$D'E602#>'/%<';#$4$D$89
IHHOLQJNQRZLQJDQGZLOOLQJRUVSHDNLQJJHQHUDOO\WKHSKHQRPHQDRISV\FKLFDFWLYLW\²WKHµVSLULWXDO
#=1*,*;LO!c0$2"D",!A*71)*,*9<!*HQHUDO3ULQFLSOHVRI+XPDQ5HÀH[RORJ\),$%#;!.DD$!$%2!M"00"$D!
0XUSK\1HZ<RUN,QWHUQDWLRQDO'QQ;!
RQ;!!)RU:DWVRQ³C&'$*"-2"&'27')&',$%$#2-)%1'\L)--$%&H%$)9-2"&M'2&0";02&5'L%"B"/&#'9,)&5$7'"B'-,$'
E"#2;1'*$9,)&27*')7')'P,";$:'E/-'L)%-29/;)%;1'"B'-,$'0279$%);')&#'5;)&#/;)%'717-$*7=!A:!=$))*,%Y,*$()"'%!
?*!D*$%!)1$)!)1*!#*=$,$)*!2*)$"0#!'-!,*#='%#*!$==*$,!?")1!#'D*!('%#)$%(:<!?")1!#'D*!,*/50$,"):!$%2!"%!
$==,'K"D$)*0:!)1*!#$D*!#*[5*%)"$0!',2*,!*$(1!)"D*!)1*!*K(")"%/!#)"D505#!"#!=,*#*%)*2Oh!_;!A;!M$)#'%<!
8719,";"51'B%"*'-,$'.-)&#L"2&-'"B')'4$,)02"%27-3KLODGHOSKLD/LSSLQFRWWKLVLWDOLFV
RR;!!M"00"$D!_$D*#<!+,$'8%2&92L;$7'"B'8719,";"51YROV&DPEULGJH+DUYDUG83,,
RX;!!%HNKWHUHYH[SUHVVHVWKLVSRLQWH[SOLFLWO\³7KH-DPHV/DQJHWKHRU\DVZHNQRZUHJDUGV
#'D$)"(!=,'(*##*#!$#!=,"D$,:!"%!*D')"'%!;!;!;!;!F'?*9*,<!)1"#![5*#)"'%!D$:!>*!$#7*2!'%0:!>:!)1'#*!1'02"%/!
WKHGXDOLVWLFYLHZSRLQW%XWIRUXV>LHUHÀH[RORJLVWV@WKLVTXHVWLRQGRHVQRWDULVH´G$&$%);'RbX;
Ra;!!_;!A;!M$)#'%<!4$,)02"%27*'1HZ<RUN1RUWRQ
RV;!!+$90'9'R;
RT;!!M$)#'%<!8719,";"51!SUUh!M$)#'%<!4$,)02"%27*!SPR;
RU;!!SQb;
Xb;!!³:HQRORQJHUUHDFWWRGLVWDQWDQGDOPRVWLQYLVLEOHPRXQWDLQVDVLIWKH\ZHUHWKHKRPHVRI
JQRPHVDQGIDLULHV6FLHQFHJHRJUDSK\DQGWUDYHOKDYHVWDQGDUGL]HGRXUUHVSRQVHV2XUUHDFWLRQVWR
IRRGVDUHEHFRPLQJVWDQGDUGL]HGWKURXJKWKHZRUNRIWKHIRRGFKHPLVW:HQRORQJHUWKLQNRIDQ\
SDUWLFXODUIRUPRIIRRGDVEHLQJµFOHDQ¶RUµXQFOHDQ¶:HWKLQNRILWQRZDVIXO¿OOLQJRUQRWIXO¿OOLQJ
GH¿QLWHERGLO\UHTXLUHPHQWV´:DWVRQ4$,)02"%27*!SSR;!
XS;!!SPX;
XP;!!SSU;
XQ;!!SPaYPUh!M$)#'%<!8719,";"51!PbQYba;
XR;!!!,KHUHGLVFXVV(LVHQVWHLQ¶VPRQWDJHIURPKLVVWDJHZRUNWKURXJKKLV¿OPA;#')&#'?$P
DQGIURP³7KH0RQWDJHRI$WWUDFWLRQV´WR³7KH)RXUWK'LPHQVLRQLQ&LQHPD´E\ZKLFK
WLPHKLVWKHRULHVKDGEHFRPHDWWHQXDWHGDQGKLVIDLWKLQUHÀH[RORJLFDOFRQGLWLRQLQJKDGGLPLQLVKHG
XX;!!."#*%#)*"%!1$2!,*$2!$%2!,*=*$)*20:!(")*#!A*71)*,*9L#!?',7h!#**<!-',!*K$D=0*<!4*,/*"!."#*%#)*"%<!
.$;$9-$#'["%67']HGDQGWUDQV5LFKDUG7D\ORU%ORRPLQJWRQ,QGLDQD837D\ORU
(0$"D#!)1$)!)1*!2",*()',!1$2!#)52"*2!>')1!'-!A*71)*,*9L#!G$&$%);'8%2&92L;$7!$%2!&ROOHFWLYH5HÀH[RORJ\!
Q0RUHRYHU(LVHQVWHLQ¶VWHDFKLQJSURJUDPIRUGLUHFWRUVLQFOXGHGDVHFWLRQRQ³H[SUHVVLYH
D$%"-*#)$)"'%Oh!1"#!$##"/%*2!,*$2"%/#!"%(052*2!A*71)*,*9!$%2!+$90'9h!."#*%#)*"%<!.$;$9-$#'["%67'^:'*2;!
5LFKDUG7D\ORUWUDQV:LOOLDP3RZHOO/RQGRQ%),%HNKWHUHY¶VZRUNRQLQGLYLGXDOEHKDYLRU
SDYHGWKHZD\IRUKLVWKHRU\RI³FROOHFWLYHUHÀH[RORJ\´7U\LQJWRRYHUFRPHWKHOLPLWDWLRQVRIZKDW
KHFDOOHG³IRONSV\FKRORJ\´FROOHFWLYHUHÀH[RORJ\ZDVWKH³SXUHO\REMHFWLYHVFLHQFHLQWKHVWULFWHVW
VHQVHRIWKHZRUG7KHUROHRIKLJKHURUGHUHOHPHQWVRUKLJKHUUHÀH[HVLQVRFLDOSKHQRPHQDVXFKDVIRU
LQVWDQFHZDUFROOHFWLYHZRUNH[FKDQJHWKHHFRQRP\WKH¿QDQFLDOVSKHUHHWF´A*71)*,*9<!T";;$9-20$'
5HÀH[RORJ\3DUW,HG/OR\G+6WULFNODQGWUDQV(XJHQLD/RFNZRRG&RPPDFN1<1RYD
Xa;!!^$9"2!A',2?*00<!+,$'T2&$*)'"B'@27$&7-$2&'&DPEULGJH+DUYDUG83
XV;!!m)2;!"%!A',2?*00!aS;
XT;!!."#*%#)*"%<!.$;$9-$#'["%67']'QR;!&,)$52<!V/0%$7'ZcG!SbP;
XU;!!."#*%#)*"%<!.$;$9-$#'["%67']'QR;
ab;!!QR;
aS;!'RS;
aP;!!\'j0!E$,,'00<!³$UW1DUUDWLYHDQG(PRWLRQ´@*"-2"&')&#'-,$'C%-7<!*2;!@*))*!FI',)!$%2!45*!
/DYHU1HZ<RUN2[IRUG83
aQ;!!."#*%#)*"%<!.$;$9-$#'["%67']'Rb;
aR;!!Ra;
aX;!!."#*%#)*"%L#!+$90'9"$%!$*#)1*)"(#!-',!1"#!_%2-$OYLHZHUVXEMHFWUHFDOOIRUH[DPSOHWKRVHRI
0H\HUKROGLQWKHWKHDWUHWKRVHRI$OH[DQGHU5RGFKHQNRLQSKRWRJUDSK\DQGWKRVHRI1LNRODL/DGRYVN\
LQDUFKLWHFWXUHHDFKSUHVXPHVDQLPPRELOL]HGSXEOLFWREHFRQGLWLRQHG
aa;!!."#*%#)*"%!1$2!)$7*%!$()"%/!?',7#1'=#!-,'D!@*:*,1'02!"%!SUPS!$%2!SUPP<!$0)1'5/1!1*!?'502!
ODWHUUHMHFW0H\HUKROG¶VWKHRULHVIRUWKRVHRI5XGROI%|GHZKRVHDLPZDVWR³EULQJWKHRUJDQLVPLQWR
$!=#:(1'Y=1:#"($0!('%2")"'%!?1"(1!?"00!D$7*!='##">0*!$!-,**!2*9*0'=D*%)!$%2!$!('D=0*)*!('%),'0!'-!")#!
D')',!='?*,#;O!N52'0-!Af2*<!@JL%$772"&HG1*&)7-297WUDQV6RQ\D)RUWKDODQG(OL]DEHWK:DWHUPDQ
\*?!6',7G!A$,%*#<!SUQSJ!0H\HUKROG¶VWKHRU\LQWXUQRULJLQDWHGLQWKH³HXUK\WKPLF´J\PQDVWLFV
RI(PLO-DTXHV'DOFUR]HZKRVHLPSDFWRQ&RSHDXZDVVLPLODUO\IRXQGDWLRQDO3DXO/RXLV0LJQRQ
Y)9Z/$7'T"L$)/+$,"#G!_500"$,2<!SUUQJ!SST;
aV;!!."#*%#)*"%<!.$;$9-$#'["%67'^!Qaa!%;Sb;
aT;!!&,)$52<!+,$)-$%'SQQ;!
!"#$%&'()*('''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''*(H
³F*,*!"#!$!?1'0*!('00*()"'%!'-!,")5$0!/*#)5,*#!)'!?1"(1!?*!2'!%')!1$9*!)1*!7*:!$%2!?1"(1!#**D!
)'!'>*:!*K),*D*0:!=,*("#*!D5#"($0!"%2"($)"'%#<!?")1!#'D*)1"%/!D',*!)1$)!2'*#!%')!/*%*,$00:!>*0'%/!
)'!D5#"(!$%2!#**D#!"%)*%2*2!)'!*%(",(0*!)1'5/1)<!)'!1'5%2!")!2'?%!$%2!0*$2!")!"%)'!$%!"%*K),"($>0*!
$%2!(*,)$"%!#:#)*D;!Z%!-$()!*9*,:)1"%/!"%!)1"#!)1*$),*!"#!($0(50$)*2!?")1!$%!*%(1$%)"%/!D$)1*D$)"($0!
D*)"(50'5#%*##;O!&,)$52<!+,$)-$%'XV;!,WLVLPSRUWDQWWREHPLQGIXORI$UWDXG¶V2ULHQWDOL]LQJQRWRULRXVO\
1"#!-$"05,*!)'!5%2*,#)$%2!)1*!A$0"%*#*!2"$0'/5*!0*2!1"D!)'!$##*,)!)1*",!)1*$),*L#!%'%9*,>$0!-'5%2$)"'%;
Vb;!!&,)$52<!V/0%$7'ZcG!Vb;!
VS;!!&,)$52<!+,$)-$%'XT;!&,)$52L#!5%(*,)$"%):!$#!)'!?1*)1*,!)1*!#)$/*!>'2"*#<!0"7*!)1*!#=*()$)',#L!
>'2"*#<!#1'502!>*!('%#"2*,*2!"%2"9"25$00:!',!$#!$!('00*()"9*H$%!5%(*,)$"%):!)1$)!1$5%)#!$00!2"#(5##"'%#!
RIWKHDWULFDOHPRWLRQ²LVPDGHFOHDUE\VFUXWLQL]LQJKLVWH[WXDOYDULDQWV]',!*K$D=0*<!"%!)1"#!*##$:!
WKH\LQFOXGH³XQMHXGHPXVFOH´³XQMHXGHPXVFOHV´³OHXUMRLH´³OHXUVMRLHV´DQG³OHXUGRXOHXU´
³OHXUVGRXOHXUV´7KHHGLWRUVRIWKH*DOOLPDUGV/0%$7'9"*L;R-$7!=,"9"0*/*!&,)$52L#!*$,0:!D$%5#(,"=)#!
LQUHWDLQLQJWKHVLQJXODUIRU³PXVFOH´EXWWKH\SUHIHU³MRLHV´DQG³GRXOHXUV´LQWKHSOXUDODVSHUWKH
SUQT!=,"%)!9*,#"'%H$%!"%('%#"#)*%(:!)1$)!Z!1$9*!$D*%2*2!"%!>')1!)1*!',"/"%$0!$%2!")#!.%/0"#1!),$%#0$)"'%;!
31*!',"/"%$0!],*%(1!$==*$,#!$)!&,)$52<!V/0%$7'ZcG!Vb;
VP;!!."#*%#)*"%<!.$;$9-$#'["%67']'Rb;
VQ;!!&,)$52<!V/0%$7'ZcG!SbQ;
VR;!!."#*%#)*"%<!.$;$9-$#'["%67']'XS<!QU;
   ³>5@HIRUJLQJ VRPHRQH HOVH¶V SV\FKH LV QR OHVV GLI¿FXOW DQG FRQVLGHUDEOH D WDVN WKDQ
-',/"%/!",'%Oh!RU;
Va;!!&,)$52<!+,$)-$%'LQKLVDSWO\WLWOHG³$Q$IIHFWLYH$WKOHWLFLVP´
VV;!!31*!"2*$!)1$)!$!#=*()$)',!*%/$/*#!?")1!)1*!#=*()$(0*!=1:#"'0'/"($00:H$#<!-',!*K$D=0*<!?1*%!
D¿OPJRHU¿QGVKHUVHOILQFKLQJIRUZDUGZKLOHZDWFKLQJD¿OPKHURLQDVXVSHQVHIXOVWDQGRII²UHFXUV
)1,'5/1'5)!)1*!1"#)',:!'-!#=*()$(0*;!3?'!>,'$20:!('%),$#)"%/!*K$D=0*#G!N'>*,)!F$%%"%/!'5)0"%*#!1'?!
PHGLHYDOF\FOHSOD\VPRELOL]HDQDXGLHQFH¶VNLQHVWKHWLFLPLWDWLRQRIVWDJHGDFWLRQ²VHH³$7KHDWHURI
^'D*#)"($)"'%!$%2!.%),$=D*%)G!31*!E:(0*!+0$:#<O!CLL%")9,$7'-"'+$)9,2&5'!$#2$0);'@&5;27,'(%)*)<!
HG5LFKDUG(PPHUVRQ1HZ<RUN0/$²DQG1RsO&DUUROOH[DPLQHVWKHSKHQRPHQRQ
LQKRUURU¿OPVHH+,$'8,2;"7"L,1'"B'N"%%"%:'"%:'8)%)#"J$7'"B'-,$'N$)%-'1HZ<RUN5RXWOHGJH
7KHH[SHULHQFHV+DQQLQJDQG&DUUROOH[SORUHDUHVLPLODUEXWQRWLGHQWLFDOWRWKHPXFKWKHRUL]HG
%')"'%!'-!7"%*#)1*)"(!*D=$)1:;!
VT;!!."#*%#)*"%<!.$;$9-$#'["%67']'SUP;
VU;!!STa<!STQ<!STX;!&#!#1')!0*%/)1#!$,*!9$,"*2!$%2!I5K)$='#*2!"%!D*),"(!D'%)$/*<!'9*,)'%*#!$,*!
5#*2!?")1"%!$!/"9*%!#1')!)'!(,*$)*!$!1'#)!'-!#*('%2$,:!,*#'%$%(*#!>')1!"%!1$,D'%:!$%2!2"#(',2!?")1!
LWVGRPLQDQWWRQH7KLVFRPSOH[RIGRPLQDQWDQGVHFRQGDU\UHVRQDQFHVSURGXFHV³IHHOLQJ´6XFKD
WKHRU\VWDQGVEHKLQG(LVHQVWHLQ¶VGHVLUHZKHQKLVIDLWKLQEHKDYLRULVPZDVFUHVWLQJWR¿OPDQHQWLUHO\
=0')0*##!$2$=)$)"'%!'-!@$,KL#!<)L2-);='A',2?*00!SPR;
Tb;!!&,)$52<!+,$)-$%'SX;!
TS;!!M$)#'%<!8719,";"51'SUa
TP;!!A,*(1)L#!,*0$)"'%#1"=!)'!>*1$9"',"#)!=$,$2"/D#!'-!*D')"'%!*9'09*2!('%#"2*,$>0:G!"%!1"#!*$,0:!
ZRUNKHZDVFOHDUO\GHHSO\LQÀXHQFHGEXWKHFDPHWRUHMHFWWKHPIRUFHIXOO\DQGWRDEVRUE²HYHQ
DUWLFXODWH²DFRJQLWLYLVWPRGHORIHPRWLRQLQVWHDG6HH*REHUW³&RJQLWLYH&DWKDUVLV´
TQ;!!F'5#*!SbUYSSb;
TR;!!."#*%#)*"%<!.$;$9-$#'["%67']'RT<!RU;
TX;!!_$%*!F$,,"#'%<!!1-,";"51')&#'!"&/*$&-7'"B'C&92$&-'C-,$&7'/RQGRQ0DFPLOODQ
PUbh!@5,,$:!SX;
Ta;!!&,)$52<!+,$)-$%'PV<!V/0%$7'ZcG!TU<!QQ;!
TV;!!]'0*:!aU;
/HVVLQJN)*E/%5P\HPSKDVLV7KHRULJLQDOLVDW/HVVLQJ[$%6$'SUT;
/HVVLQJN)*E/%5'SP;!
Ub;!!@$,"$!Z,*%*!]',%*#<!S$B/')&#'N$%'S%2$&#7'1HZ<RUN3$-
US;!!kD"0*!^5,71*"D<!+,$'@;$*$&-)%1'S"%*7'"B'-,$'>$;252"/7'I2B$<!),$%#;!_'#*=1!M$,2!4?$"%!
/RQGRQ*HRUJH$OOHQ