Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Camera Traps in The Canopy: Surveying Wildlife at Tree Hollow Entrances
Camera Traps in The Canopy: Surveying Wildlife at Tree Hollow Entrances
Abstract. This is the first comprehensive camera trap study to examine hollow usage by wildlife in the canopy of trees.
Eighty cameras directed at tree hollows were deployed across eight sites in nine species of eucalypt in north-east New
South Wales. In total, 38 species (including 21 birds, 9 mammals and 8 reptiles) were recorded at hollow entrances over a
three-month period. There was a significant difference between wildlife hollow usage associated with site disturbance and
tree growth stage (ANOSIM, P . 0.05); however, there was no significant difference associated with tree hollow diameter
(ANOSIM, P . 0.05). The level of anthropogenic disturbance at each site, including vegetation modification of the
understorey, was a significant predictor of species presence. Despite the limitations of using camera traps in the canopy of
trees this study demonstrates the potential to garner useful insights into the ecology and behaviour of arboreal wildlife.
Received 24 September 2015, accepted 9 February 2016, published online 15 March 2016
questions. These include, but are not limited to, interspecific and different vegetation communities (Office of Environment and
intraspecific competition, predation, resource selection, niche Heritage 2012a). These communities have been grouped into
partitioning, activity periods, population density estimates and broader vegetation classes and vegetation formations in accor-
assemblages of species using hollows. dance with Keith (2006). Nearly 50% of the vegetation in the
To better understand the behavioural responses of arboreal LGA is wet sclerophyll forest, almost 20% is dry sclerophyll
vertebrates, further research is required regarding the interac- forest, 12% is rainforest and nearly 6% is coastal vegetation
tions between competitors and predators and the role this plays communities. Other communities include plantations, exotics
in cavity choice. While the height of hollows above ground level and regenerating pioneers that cover almost 10% of the vegetated
has been suggested as a mechanism to avoid predators (Cockle area in the LGA.
et al. 2011; Goldingay 2011), no study has specifically exam-
ined this hypothesis. Ambrose (1982) observed that, despite an Site selection
abundance of hollows, regular disputes over certain hollows
Mapping of High Value Arboreal Habitats (hereafter HVAH)
were noted and that the preferences for hollows needs to be
(Fisher et al. 2014) on the coastal plain of the Coffs Harbour
better understood. Thomson et al. (2008) suggest that targeted
LGA was used as a surrogate to identify broad locations of
surveys of hollow occupancy by species dependent on hollows
habitat containing hollow-bearing eucalypt trees. ‘Eucalypts’
will assist in an understanding of competition for hollows.
for the purpose of this study included the tree genera Eucalyptus,
Understanding behavioural interactions of cavity-using species
Angophora, Corymbia, Lophostemon and Syncarpia. The
will better inform management, particularly where there is a
coastal plain was selected for this study because of the already
scarcity of hollows and populations are threatened (Goldingay
depleted areas of HVAH and the increasing development
2009).
pressures being placed on this resource.
Camera traps provide the opportunity to better understand
Eight geographic sites were selected on the coastal flood-
the usage of tree hollows by vertebrate fauna and their behaviour
plain on the basis of the number of camera traps available for the
at hollow entrances. Therefore, the aim of this study was to
study (n ¼ 80), which allowed for 10 cameras at each site. The
compare faunal usage with site characteristics and tree attribute
study included eight different vegetation types selected from a
information including hollows, DBH (diameter at breast height),
possible 15 eucalypt-based coastal vegetation communities
age and species. We approached this by deploying a large
known from the LGA (Office of Environment and Heritage
number of camera traps in tree canopies at selected locations.
2012b). However, due to a paucity of HVAH on the coastal
floodplain, four sites had to be selected from Coast and Escarp-
Methods ment Blackbutt Dry Forest (see Table 1). Blackbutt (Eucalyptus
Study area pilularis) is recognised as the dominant tree species for this
vegetation type (Office of Environment and Heritage 2012b).
The study area encompasses the rural, semirural and forested
The eight sites were allocated a descriptive name based on the
landscapes of the Coffs Harbour Local Government Area (LGA)
closest road name or geographical feature (Fig. 1).
on the eastern seaboard of New South Wales, Australia (Fig. 1).
All selected sites with hollow-bearing trees were arbitrarily
The LGA has an area of 117 300 ha, of which 88 964 ha is
allocated a disturbance category of 1 to 5. High-quality sites
vegetated (Office of Environment and Heritage 2012a).
(Category 1), were considered remote from human habitation
The Coffs Harbour Meteorological office (30.318S,
and had a complex midstorey and understorey of native plants.
153.128E) records a mean annual rainfall of 1707 mm (mm), a
Poor sites (Category 5) were regularly mown, had high human
mean maximum temperature of 238C and mean minimum
visitation and little to no understorey (see Table 1).
temperature of 148C (Bureau of Meteorology 2014). Overall,
Sites were also grouped to determine the number of each tree
the climate is considered subtropical.
species used in the study. Faunal species richness was compared
The Coffs Harbour LGA is one of the few places along
with the number of trees for each species used in the study.
eastern Australia where the Great Dividing Range and con-
Faunal species richness was based on one record of each species
nected Great Escarpment link to the coastal plain. The area’s
per location per period.
unique topography and geography provide for a diversity of
ecosystems that have representatives of tropical, subtropical and
temperate flora and fauna. Camera trap specifications and deployment
This study was undertaken on the coastal plains of the Coffs For ease of use and cost, camera trap selection included three
Harbour LGA. The coastal plains are a low-relief landscape with Scoutguard digital cameras (SG550, SG560, SG565F-8M).
little variation in altitude. The plains gradually rise from sea Cameras were set to normal sensitivity and were programmed to
level to around 50 m elevation. Slopes are predominantly flat to record two successive still images (1 s apart) upon each ‘trigger
undulating (0–58), though there are some small hills with steeper event’. The delay period was set at an interval of 10 s following
slopes. The coastal plain is characterised by alluvial sediments each trigger event. Image quality was set to the highest resolu-
derived from floodplain deposits and older weathered metasedi- tion of 8 Mb per image. For the purposes of this study, an
ments of the Coramba formation (Milford 1999). The Coffs ‘independent picture’ was considered valid after 60 min.
Harbour LGA coastline stretches 80 km and features a series of Camera selection was based on a trade-off between unsettling
prominent rocky headlands and beaches. wildlife with an incandescent white flash but improving the
The Coffs Harbour LGA is characterised by a variety of soil chance of species identification with the aid of sharp high-
moisture gradients, geologies and topography that support 79 resolution colour images (Glen et al. 2013; Meek et al. 2014b).
50 Pacific Conservation Biology N. Cotsell and K. Vernes
8 - Barcoongere way
COFFS HARBOUR
LOCAL GOVERNMENT AREA
7 - Corindi cemetery
3 - Swans road
N
2 - Lawson crescent
SCALE@A4 1 : 135000 GRID NTH
1 - Showground
0 0.5 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Kilometres
Table 1. Vegetation type and disturbance category for eight selected sites in the Coffs Harbour LGA
Site no. Location Dominant species Vegetation type (OEH 2012b) Disturbance
category (1–5)
1. Show Ground Blackbutt (Eucalyptus pilularis) Coast and Escarpment Blackbutt Dry Forest 5
(CH_DOF01)
2. Lawson Crescent Bastard tallowwood (Eucalyptus Sandstone Bloodwood – Needlebark Stringybark Heathy 4
planchoniana) (CH_DOF02)
3. Swans Road Brushbox Escarpment and Lowland Bangalow – Carabeen – Black 1
(Lophostemon confertus) Booyong Palm Gully Rainforest (CH_RF11)
4. Moonee Reserve Forest red gum Lowlands Swamp Box – Paperbark – Red Gum Dry 4
(Eucalyptus tereticornis) Forest (CH_DOF06)
5. Old Bucca Road Pink bloodwood Foothills Turpentine – Grey Gum – Ironbark Moist 2
(Eucalyptus intermedia) Shrubby Forest (CH_WSF17)
6. Orara East State Forest Blackbutt (Eucalyptus pilularis) Coast and Escarpment Blackbutt Dry Forest 2
(CH_DOF01)
7. Corindi Cemetery Blackbutt (Eucalyptus pilularis) Coast and Escarpment Blackbutt Dry Forest 3
(CH_DOF01)
8. Barcoongere Way Red mahogany (Eucalyptus Coast and Escarpment Blackbutt Dry Forest 1
resinifera subsp. hemilampra) (CH_DOF01)
40
30
Degrees (°C)
20
10
0
1 6 11 16 21 26 31 36 41 46 51 56 61 66 71 76
Days
100
80
Percent (%)
60
40
20
0
1 6 11 16 21 26 31 36 41 46 51 56 61 66 71 76
Days
9 a.m. relative humidity (%)
3 p.m. relative humidity (%)
Linear (3 p.m. relative humidity (%))
70
60
Rainfall (mm)
50
40
30
20
10
0
1 6 11 16 21 26 31 36 41 46 51 56 61 66 71 76 81
Days
Fig. 2. Meteorological data collected over the course of the camera trap study (September–December 2013). (a) Daily minimum and maximum temperatures,
(b) relative humidity, and (c) daily rainfall.
to be sourced from 12 cameras linked to either problems with the retrieval of cameras, which meant that cameras could not be
camera or secure digital card (SD card). Data from five cameras checked at intervals to determine their functionality.
were also discarded because no wildlife images were recorded,
generally as a result of the SD cards lasting less than a day Daily weather records over the duration of the camera
following constant background stimuli of leaves and branches, trap study
which resulted in false triggers. Given the exposed windy envi- Weather data were sourced for the months of September (part),
ronment into which the camera traps were deployed, it is not October, November and December (part) 2013. Daily minimum
surprising that several cameras and SD cards failed. Also notable and maximum temperatures remained relatively stable over the
was the large range in the number of days that each of the 63 SD course of the camera trap survey (Fig. 2a). Relative humidity
cards lasted as a result of false trigger events. Limited access to (Fig. 2b) showed a gradual increase over the course of the field
the elevated work platform only allowed for deployment and study; however, there was a significant increase in humidity
Surveying wildlife at tree hollow entrances Pacific Conservation Biology 53
30
Independent pictures
25
20
15
10
0
eet
possum
r
ed lorikeet
Dollarbird
Squirrel glider
htail possum
okuburra
ider
inus
ake
ng
thrush
Noisy minor
g parrot
Galah
gtail possum
ake
duck
er
nded snake
l
ed skink
isher
neyeater
phascogale
k
flying fox
let-nightjar
Grey faintail
rbird
ink
lizard
Little corella
ter dragon
oo
yeater
d glider
Rufous fantai
Lace monito
Grey goshaw
ed treecreep
Pied currawo
black cockat
Bar-sided sk
Rainbow lorik
Brown tree sn
Green tree sn
Feathertail gl
Brown antech
Regent bowe
Sacred kingf
Pacific black
Pink-tongued
Grey shrike-
Lewin’s hone
Yellow-bellie
Australian kin
Dark bar-sid
Brush-tailed
Blue-faced ho
Laughing ko
Grey-headed
Australian wa
Scaly-breast
Australian ow
Stephen’s ba
Brush-tailed
Mountain brus
Common rin
White-throat
Yellow-tailed
Species
Fig. 3. Fauna species ranked by number of independent pictures across all sites in Coffs Harbour LGA
(September–December 2013).
Table 2. Vertebrate fauna species accumulation over 80 days during a camera trap study in the Coffs Harbour LGA
(September–December 2013)
was virtually no activity between 20:00 and 21:00 hours. The Arboreal mammals
most active bird was the grey shrike-thrush (Colluricincla Activity periods for arboreal mammals were more variable
harmonica), which was active from 06:00–07:00 until 21:00– between species across a 24-h period when compared with
22:00 hours (see Fig. 6a). both birds and reptiles (see Fig. 6c). There was very little
arboreal mammal activity until 21:00–22:00 hours, which
Reptiles continued through until 06:00–0700 hours for most species.
The three most common species of reptile had a core activity Both the brown antechinus (Antechinus stuartii) and feather-
peak between 08:00–09:00 and 14:00–15:00 hours, with a spike tail glider (Acrobatus pygmaeus) had minor periods of diurnal
at 10:00–11:00 hours for all three species. Activity periods for activity but avoided the hottest part of the day between 12:00
reptiles were most likely correlated with the hottest parts of the and 14:00 hours. The squirrel glider (Petaurus norfolcensis)
day. There were no records of reptiles before 07:00 hours; did not commence any nocturnal activity until 20:00–21:00
however, both the lace monitor (Varanus varius) and Stephens’ hours, with maximum activity recorded between 02:00 and
banded snake (Hoplocephalus stephensii) were recorded as 03:00 hours. Common brush-tailed possums (Trichosurus
active between 19:00 and 20:00 hours. Core activity periods vulpecula) were active during the day and night with peak
for V. varius was between 08:00–09:00 and 11:00–12:00 hours, periods between 05:00 and 07:00 and between 21:00 and 22:00
with very little activity outside these times (see Fig. 6b). hours.
Surveying wildlife at tree hollow entrances Pacific Conservation Biology 55
Eucalyptus tereticornis 1
Syncarpia glomulifera 2
Eucalyptus resinifera subsp. hemilampra 5
Eucalypt species
Angophora costata 6
Lophostemon confertus 7
Eucalyptus planchoniana 7
Eucalyptus microcorys 7
Corymbia intermedia 19
Eucalyptus pilularis 20
0 5 10 15 20 25
Frequency
Total number of individuals Fauna species richness
Fig. 5. Faunal species richness at tree hollow entrances compared with eucalypt species across 63
camera trap sites in the Coffs Harbour LGA.
Commonly detected species overall. They were largely absent from sites that were highly
An analysis of the percentage of each species at each site is disturbed or contained high levels of human occupation, including
provided below for the following commonly recorded species. frequent domestic dog activity. As a total percentage of each
Other species could have been included in the results but the species, monitors were plentiful in bushland areas at Old Bucca
differences at each site were not significant. Road (38.57%) and Orara East State Forest (25.5%). They were
moderately common at Corindi Cemetery (8.1%), Swans Road
Common brush-tailed possum (Trichosurus vulpecula) (8.0%) and Barcoongere Way (5.8%). However, monitors were
absent or recorded at very low frequencies at sites with distur-
This was the highest ranked species by number of independent
bance categories of 4 or 5 (see Table 1), including Moonee
pictures (n ¼ 176) and the most abundantly recorded species at
Reserve (0.6%), Showground (0%) and Lawson Crescent (0%).
Corindi Cemetary (69.3%), Orara East State Forest (50.9%) and
Despite no feeding events being captured at hollow
Old Bucca Road (44.3%). The species was also relatively
entrances, the camera trap results show that lace monitors were
common at Lawson Crescent (34.7%), the Showground
actively engaged in searching hollows. Sequences of camera
(21.4%) and Moonee Reserve (14.1%). The brush-tailed possum
trap footage revealed monitors’ dexterity in being able to access
was entirely absent from Barcoongere Way and Swans Road,
hollows on the end of branches, climb inside and then exit head
which were the lowest-disturbance-category sites (see Table 1).
first. While no predation events were captured at the entrance of
hollows, it is likely that such events occurred within the hollow.
Rainbow lorikeet (Trichoglossus haematodus)
Possible targets are likely to have been bird eggs, chicks, or adult
These large aggressive lorikeets dominated by number and birds or mammals of varying age classes.
species percentage at the Showground (46.5% of total number), Observations of the size and markings of monitors confirmed
Moonee Reserve (46.0%) and Lawson Crescent (42.9%) sites. that the same hollow was being visited by the same individual on
By contrast, these birds were totally absent from Barcoongere multiple occasions or was frequented by up to four separate
Way, Corindi Cemetary, Orara East State Forest and Swans individuals over the duration of the field study. In some cases,
Road and in very low numbers at Old Bucca Road (1.4%). monitors were captured visiting the same hollow every day for
The abundance of rainbow lorikeets in areas of high habitat up to five consecutive days and also basked in the same tree at
modification in urban and periurban environments was highly the same location over extended periods. Two separate indivi-
significant. Perhaps the most interesting result was the total duals were recorded residing in the same tree hollow over
absence of the species from the least disturbed sites. Their absence several nights.
correlated strongly with the presence of lace monitors. Following Lace monitor activity in trees was solely diurnal, reaching a
removal of camera traps it was noted that several lorikeets had peak between 9:00 and 11:00 hours. This behaviour was often
either eggs or chicks within the subject hollow and both the female repeated by the same individual over several days. Lace monitors
and male were being regularly recorded by the camera trap. It was were captured at the highest-set cameras (25 m). Activities
also observed that the predatory laughing kookaburra and pied beyond this height were not recorded.
currawong and brush-tailed possum were occasional visitors to
the hollows that contained eggs and young of rainbow lorikeets. Dollarbird (Eurystomus orientalis)
The migratory dollarbird was the fifth highest ranked species
Lace monitor (Varanus varius) by number of independent pictures (n ¼ 40). One camera
Lace monitors were common in all bushland areas and were recorded a particularly long photographic sequence of a nesting
the third most frequently observed species across all sites pair of birds, and two chicks were present at the time of camera
56 Pacific Conservation Biology N. Cotsell and K. Vernes
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
00:00-01:00
01:00-02:00
02:00-03:00
03:00-04:00
04:00-05:00
05:00-06:00
06:00-07:00
07:00-08:00
08:00-09:00
09:00-10:00
10:00-11:00
11:00-12:00
12:00-13:00
13:00-14:00
14:00-15:00
15:00-16:00
16:00-17:00
17:00-18:00
18:00-19:00
19:00-20:00
20:00-21:00
21:00-22:00
22:00-23:00
23:00-24:00
CC5b
SG2b
SG6
M5a BW5b
OE4a
LC3b
M1a
M3
M5b
M6
OBR4b
OBR2a
OBR2b
OBR1b
BW4b
OBR6
SG1b
CC4a
LC3a
LC4b
SG4
M1b
LC6a
OBR1a
SG2a
SG5a
M7
OBR3b
LC1a
OE4b
LC5
OE5
SG5b
OBR4a
CC3a
SR2b
BW6
OE6
OE2b
CC2b
M4a
CC2a
M4b
OBR3a
OE1b
OE7a
OE1a
CC1a
BW4a
BW3a
OE2a
BW2a
SR1a
SR3
SG1a
LC2
BW2b
CC3b
BW5a
SR2a
SR1b
Hours
0.7
Fig. 7. Bray–Curtis similarity showing the clustering of sites (cameras)
0.6 and outliers.
0.5
Frequency
0.4
retrieval. As for the rainbow lorikeet, the hollow was visited by
0.3
laughing kookaburras, pied currawongs and common brush-
0.2
tailed possums at intervals sometimes weeks apart. These
0.1
predators were possibly attracted by the noise of the chicks or
0 the hollows were within their home range and part of a regular
00:00-01:00
01:00-02:00
02:00-03:00
03:00-04:00
04:00-05:00
05:00-06:00
06:00-07:00
07:00-08:00
08:00-09:00
09:00-10:00
10:00-11:00
11:00-12:00
12:00-13:00
13:00-14:00
14:00-15:00
15:00-16:00
16:00-17:00
17:00-18:00
18:00-19:00
19:00-20:00
20:00-21:00
21:00-22:00
22:00-23:00
23:00-24:00
inspection route. Other than their head, these predators were too
large to pass through the hollow entrance to reach the eggs or
chicks.
Hours
Squirrel glider (Petaurus norfolcensis)
Brown tree Lace monitor Stephen’s banded The squirrel glider was the sixth most common species
snake snake ranked by frequency of independent pictures (n ¼ 22) and was
recorded at four sites with a disturbance category of #3 (see
Table 1). The species was particularly abundant at Barcoongere
0.6 Way (30.8%) as a percentage of all species.
0.5
Patterns in usage of hollows by fauna
0.4
Results for the Bray–Curtis similarity resemblance in Fig. 7
0.3 show that species at individual hollows were similar except at
0.2
two outliers: BW5b (red mahogany, hollow diameter 16 cm, site
Barcoongere Way) and SR5a (brushbox, hollow diameter
0.1 12 cm, site Swans Road). These two hollows were classed as
0 outliers because they attracted a single species only, which was
00:00-01:00
01:00-02:00
02:00-03:00
03:00-04:00
04:00-05:00
05:00-06:00
06:00-07:00
07:00-08:00
08:00-09:00
09:00-10:00
10:00-11:00
11:00-12:00
12:00-13:00
13:00-14:00
14:00-15:00
15:00-16:00
16:00-17:00
17:00-18:00
18:00-19:00
19:00-20:00
20:00-21:00
21:00-22:00
22:00-23:00
23:00-24:00
not recorded by any other camera trap. They included the brown
tree snake (Boiga irregularis) at BW5b and a regent bowerbird
(Sericulus chrysocephalus) at SR5a.
A second MDS test generated a Bray–Curtis similarity resem-
Hours blance using disturbance, growth form and hollow diameter as
factors. There was little separation in the first two factors but there
Common brushtail possum Mountain brushtail possum was a relatively strong separation between species based on the
Squirrel glider Brown antechinus
Feathertail glider
level of disturbance.
The 2D stress test separated out Category 1 sites, based on
Fig. 6. (a) Activity patterns across all geographic areas for the six most
their site quality; that is, they were classified as having good
common diurnal birds over 80 days (b) Activity periods across all sites for ecological condition in that they showed low levels of overall
the three most common arboreal reptiles after 80 days (c) Activity periods disturbance and had an understorey and mid-stratum that was
across all sites for the five most common arboreal mammals after 80 days. intact and were represented by a diversity of plant species. Both
Surveying wildlife at tree hollow entrances Pacific Conservation Biology 57
Fig. 8. MDS plot showing ecological separation based on five levels of disturbance for 63 camera
traps located on the coastal floodplain of the Coffs Harbour LGA.
Barcoongere Way and Swans Road sites fell into this category generally .10 cm in diameter, while the smaller native bees
(see Fig. 8). appeared to prefer small fissures or cracks in the branches of
A one-way analysis of similarities (ANOSIM) was undertaken eucalypts.
on the same factors of disturbance, growth form and hollow
diameter to test whether there was a significant difference Discussion
between two or more sites. The results were statistically signifi- The detection of wildlife at tree hollow entrances is a relatively
cant for disturbance (ANOSIM Global R ¼ 0.27, P ¼ 0.001), new technique. This study has demonstrated that, with the
growth form (Global R ¼ 0.11, P ¼ 0.003), but not hollow dia- appropriate camera trap accessories and some prior planning,
meter (Global R ¼ 0.004, P ¼ 0.40). While the P-values suggest a it is possible to survey tree hollow entrances for vertebrate
significant result for disturbance and growth form, the low R arboreal wildlife.
values indicate that there was not a high level of separation Some refinement of camera deployment methods may be
between the factors. required to minimise the 15% failure rate of camera traps
experienced in this study. Working from an Elevated Work
Incidental observations
Platform in an environment that was often windy and rainy
Arboreal termite nest exacerbated by a confined work space and limited time created
A camera trap located at the Barcoongere Way site was less than optimal deployment conditions. Like Gregory et al.
mounted 12 m above ground on a pink bloodwood (Corymbia (2014), we found that cameras were often triggered by non-
intermedia) directed at a ‘mud hollow’ instead of a natural tree target motion (e.g. leaves and branches), which rapidly filled
hollow. All other tree hollow options in the vicinity had been memory cards well before camera retrieval after 80 days.
exhausted. Despite the SD Card lasting only 34 days, the camera Mistakes made at set-up also had to be carried through until
recorded some of the most cryptic arboreal mammals including retrieval as quality checks of the data were not possible due to
the feathertail glider, brown antechinus, squirrel glider and the costs associated with operating the Elevated Work Platform.
brush-tailed phascogale. The phascogale record was the only More expensive camera traps that use remote or continuous
one obtained over the duration of the study. For each of these download of data via Bluetooth or wireless would provide a
species, the sequence of photographs show each species taking better alternative and allow checks to monitor camera functionality
an active interest in the termite mound, often climbing over the and data quality.
mound. The mud hollow was also visited by three individual
lace monitors, two of which entered the cavity and appeared to Eucalypt species versus wildlife hollow preferences
actively excavate the mound to source termites. The overall percentage of each eucalypt species used in the
camera trap study is broadly reflective of the overall composi-
European and native bees tion of hollow-bearing trees remaining on the coastal floodplain
Although bees were not the target of this study, up to 10% of of the Coffs Harbour LGA. Both blackbutt and pink bloodwood
hollows inspected were found to contain the European honey constitute a significant proportion of remaining hollow-bearing
bee (Apis mellifera) – the presence of bees excluded these trees on the coastal floodplain (authors’ obs.). The number of
hollows from the study. Bee hives were often near to small fauna species active at hollow entrances of these two eucalypts
native bees, with the introduced bees occupying large cavities, may simply be reflective of the frequency at which these two
58 Pacific Conservation Biology N. Cotsell and K. Vernes
tree species occur. For this study, hollow selection was inde- The squirrel glider, a TSC Act Schedule 2 species, was far
pendent of tree species selection. It was not the aim of this study more common, occurring at four sites (disturbance ranking of 3
to determine whether arboreal wildlife had a preference for or less), suggesting that this species prefers sites that have
hollows of a specific eucalypt tree species although this would minimal human disturbance.
make an informative future study. A camera at Barcoongere Way also recorded the presence of
Some of the individual camera trap set-ups recorded parti- Stephens’ banded snake, a species listed as vulnerable under the
cularly long sequences of breeding events, multiple species TSC Act. The species’ presence was notable for its occurrence in
visits or unusual behaviours. Comparison across sites and dry sclerophyll forest as it is traditionally thought to inhabit
preferential use by wildlife of the nine eucalypt species is also mesic forests (Fitzgerald et al. 2002). The snake was recorded
discussed, as are some of the interactions between individual spending long periods basking in the sun in a vertical-facing
wildlife species and site quality. hollow during the hottest part of the day.
The level of predation pressure that lace monitors are
Lace monitor (Varanus varius) imposing on threatened arboreal fauna such as yellow-bellied
gliders, squirrel gliders, brush-tailed phascogales and Stephen’s
The frequency of visits to hollows and the abundance of lace
banded snake should be further investigated.
monitors suggest that large arboreal monitor lizards may have a
significant impact on hollow-dependent arboreal fauna, parti-
Behavioural responses
cularly those species that depend on hollows for at least a part of
their lifecycle. The absence of monitors in urban and periurban Probably the most surprising and opportunistic result of this
environments is likely to account for the high abundance of study was the level of wildlife activity at an active termitarium.
rainbow lorikeets at these sites. Whether this is a result of habitat During camera deployment at Barcoongere Way, the absence of
modification, interactions with humans, domestic dogs, or a any suitable tree hollow resulted in a camera trap being sited on
combination of all three, is a subject for further research. the entrance of an arboreal ‘mud hollow’, or termitarium, 12 m
There is growing evidence that monitor lizards may be from the ground. Given the size of the entrance, the hollow was
released from predation pressure as a result of targeted manage- probably excavated by a bird, most likely the laughing kooka-
ment programs focussed on mammalian predators including burra, which is known to nest in arboreal termitaria (Hindwood
wild dogs, foxes and cats (Olsson et al. 2005; Sutherland et al. 1959). The SD Card of this camera lasted just 34 days but
2011; Allen et al. 2013; Anson et al. 2013; Jessop et al. 2013). recorded four mammals, including two threatened species. Most
Given the results of this study, it is reasonable to speculate that visiting fauna were observed to be actively engaged with the
wild dog, and potentially fox, control may be indirectly impact- termite nest, possibly for the food resources it held. Additionally,
ing on native arboreal wildlife by releasing lace monitors from three individual lace monitors spent long periods investigating the
predation pressure in bushland ecosystems. This in turn may be termitarium, climbing inside and excavating the entrance to
negatively impacting on native bird and arboreal mammal source termites. Monitor lizards are also known to lay their eggs
populations. in termite nests and seal the entrance (Carter 1991).
Conversely, the absence of lace monitors from sites with higher
levels of anthropogenic disturbance resulted in significantly high Conclusions
densities of rainbow and scaly-breasted lorikeets. Long sequences
There are limitations to undertaking camera trap studies in the
of camera trap data suggest that both rainbow lorikeets and
high canopy of trees; however, the wealth of data that can be
dollarbirds select small (generally ,10 cm diameter) hollows to
obtained can add substantially to our understanding of arboreal
exclude predators. Alternatively, only birds that select hollow
wildlife. There are obvious limitations including cost and access
entrances ,10 cm diameter are successful in fledging their young.
to appropriate sites and the problems associated with ‘false
Tree hollows containing eggs and young were visited by a range of
triggers’ as a result of branch and leaf movement. However, with
avian and mammalian predators that were ultimately too large to
appropriate hollow selection and astute camera placement this
take advantage of the food resources contained within.
study has shown that it is possible to record long series of
behavioural information that, until recently, was otherwise
Threatened species unavailable.
The yellow-bellied glider is listed as vulnerable under both the A closer examination of isolated old trees and high-value
Environmental Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act arboreal habitat on the coastal floodplain and their importance to
1999 and New South Wales Threatened Species Conservation Act wildlife seems to be of critical importance if we are to maintain
1995 (TSC Act). The brush-tailed phascogale is listed as vulnerable and enhance terrestrial landscapes that have high-quality habitat
under the TSC Act. The rarity of these two species was a notable for arboreal species.
feature of this camera trap study, with both species being recorded Similarly, the functional role of large trees in the landscape
only once by separate cameras. On the basis of records in the Atlas matrix is very poorly understood. Given the recent emphasis and
of Living Australia, both of these species are considered to be investment in protecting threatened species nationally, the spatial
relatively rare within the study area, although better detection rates relationship and the importance of old trees needs to be more
may have been achieved using more traditional methods such closely examined. A strong policy and legislative response is
as spotlighting and ‘stag watching’. Potentially, the use of cameras required, but this will not transpire unless there is a better
trained on targeted baits in high-quality habitat may have achieved understanding of the dynamics of tree hollows and their impor-
higher detection rates for both species. tance to wildlife across the broader landscape.
Surveying wildlife at tree hollow entrances Pacific Conservation Biology 59
There are ongoing human demands being placed on the Clarke, K. R., and Gorley, R. N. (2006). ‘PRIMER V6: User Manual/
eucalypt forests of the Australian landscape. What is abundantly Tutorial.’ (PRIMER-E: Plymouth.)
clear is that future targeted research and long-term monitoring Clarke, K., and Green, R. (1988). Statistical design and analysis for a
programs of old, isolated trees and HVAH are essential if we are ‘‘biological effects’’ study. Marine Ecology Progress Series 46,
to understand and interpret the legacies of past forest manage- 213–226. doi:10.3354/MEPS046213
Cockle, K., Martin, K., and Wiebe, K. (2011). Selection of nest trees by
ment practices. This information will give us a better under-
cavity-nesting birds in the neotropical Atlantic Forest. Biotropica 43,
standing of how current land uses are impacting on Australia’s 228–236. doi:10.1111/J.1744-7429.2010.00661.X
native arboreal fauna. Davis, A., Major, R. E., and Taylor, C. E. (2013). Housing shortages in urban
regions: aggressive interactions at tree hollows in forest remnants. PLoS
Suggested future research initiatives using camera traps One 8(3), e59332. doi:10.1371/JOURNAL.PONE.0059332
Whether lace monitors are exerting significant predation De Bondi, N., White, J. G., Stevens, M., and Cooke, R. (2010). A comparison
of the effectiveness of camera trapping and live trapping for sampling
pressure on threatened arboreal wildlife and if their presence/
terrestrial small-mammal communities. Wildlife Research 37, 456–465.
absence is influencing the ecological guild doi:10.1071/WR10046
The role and function of arboreal termitaria to vertebrate Fisher, M., Cotsell, N., Scotts, D., & Cameron, M. (2014). High value
arboreal wildlife habitats in the Coffs Harbour local government area. Coffs Harbour City
Arboreal species preferences for hollows in different Council in conjunction with the Office of Environment and Heritage,
eucalypts Coffs Harbour, New South Wales.
The importance of isolated old trees and HVAH on the coastal Fitzgerald, M., Shine, R., and Lemckert, F. (2002). Spatial ecology of
floodplain to arboreal vertebrate wildlife with consideration arboreal snakes (Hoplocephalus stephensii, Elapidae) in an eastern
of the spatial context of these trees in the landscape matrix. Australian forest. Austral Ecology 27, 537–545. doi:10.1046/J.1442-
9993.2002.01214.X
Glen, A. S., Cockburn, S., Nichols, M., Ekanayake, J., and Warburton, B.
Supplementary material (2013). Optimising camera traps for monitoring small mammals. PLoS
A selection of arboreal wildlife images captured at tree hollow One 8(6), e67940. doi:10.1371/JOURNAL.PONE.0067940
entrances by camera traps is available on the Journal’s website. Goldingay, R. L. (2009). Characteristics of tree hollows used by Australian
birds and bats. Wildlife Research 36, 394–409. doi:10.1071/WR08172
Acknowledgements Goldingay, R. L. (2011). Characteristics of tree hollows used by Australian
arboreal and scansorial mammals. Australian Journal of Zoology 59,
We thank the Coffs Harbour offices of National Parks and Wildlife and 277–294. doi:10.1071/ZO11081
Forests NSW for allowing us to undertake research on publicly owned land.
Gregory, T., Carrasco Rueda, F., Deichmann, J., Kolowski, J., and Alonso, A.
Appreciation is also extended to Coffs Harbour City Council for allowing (2014). Arboreal camera trapping: taking a proven method to new heights.
access to its elevated work platform, and to Council’s arborists, Mark Baker Methods in Ecology and Evolution 5, 443–451. doi:10.1111/2041-210X.
and Brett Prendagast, who provided valuable assistance in organising and 12177
operating the heavy machinery. The GIS section of Council also provided
Harley, D. K. P., Holland, G. J., Hradsky, B. A. K., and Antrobus, J. S.
support with the preparation of spatial layers and maps. Helpful reviewer (2014). The use of camera traps to detect cryptic arboreal mammals:
comments were provided by Ross Goldingay and an anonymous reviewer. lessons from targeted surveys for the cryptic Leadbeater’s Possum
We thank Skye Ravenscroft and Donella Andersen for editorial comment. (Gymnobelideus leadbeateri). In ‘Camera Trapping’. (Eds P. Meek,
Dave Scotts assisted with identification of some of the more cryptic species.
P. Fleming, G. Ballard, P. Banks, A. Claridge, J. Sanderson, and
D. Swann.) pp. 233–242. (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne.)
References Hindwood, K. A. (1959). The nesting of birds in the nests of social insects.
Allen, B., Allen, L., Engeman, R., and Leung, L. K.-P. (2013). Intraguild Emu 59, 1–36. doi:10.1071/MU959001
relationships between sympatric predators exposed to lethal control: Hirakawa, H. (2005). Luring bats to the camera – a new technique for bat
predator manipulation experiments. Frontiers in Zoology 10, 39. surveys. Mammal Study 30, 69–71. doi:10.3106/1348-6160(2005)30
doi:10.1186/1742-9994-10-39 [69:LBTTCA]2.0.CO;2
Ambrose, G. J. (1982). An ecological and behavioural study of vertebrates Jessop, T. S., Kearney, M., Moore, J., Lockwood, T., and Johnston, M.
using hollows in eucalypt branches. Ph.D. Thesis, La Trobe University, (2013). Evaluating and predicting risk to a large reptile (Varanus varius)
Melbourne. from feral cat baiting protocols. Biological Invasions 15, 1653–1663.
Anson, J. R., Dickman, C. R., Boonstra, R., and Jessop, T. S. (2013). Stress doi:10.1007/S10530-012-0398-3
triangle: do introduced predators exert indirect costs on native predators Keith, D. (2006). From ocean shores to desert dunes: the vegetation of New
and prey? PLoS One 8(4). doi:10.1371/JOURNAL.PONE.0060916 South Wales and the ACT. Department of Environment and Conservation
Bureau of Meteorology (2014) Monthly climate statistics for the Coffs NSW, Hurtsville.
Harbour area. Available at: http://www.bom.gov.au [accessed 15 March Lindenmayer, D. B., Cunningham, R. B., and McCarthy, M. A. (1999). The
2014]. conservation of arboreal marsupials in the montane ash forests of
Carter, D. B. (1991). Reproductive cycle of female Varanus varius in south- the central highlands of Victoria, south-eastern Australia. VIII. Land-
eastern Australia. Mertensiella 2, 256. scape analysis of the occurrence of arboreal marsupials. Biological
Cerbo, A., and Biancardi, C. (2012). Monitoring small and arboreal Conservation 89, 83–92. doi:10.1016/S0006-3207(98)00116-5
mammals by camera traps: effectiveness and applications. Acta Therio- Meek, P., Fleming, P., Ballard, G., Banks, P., Claridge, A., Sanderson, J., and
logica 1–5. doi:10.1007/S13364-012-0122-9 Swann, D. (2014a). ‘Camera Trapping – wildlife management and
Claridge, A. W., Paull, D. J., and Barry, S. C. (2010). Detection of medium- research.’ (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne.)
sized ground-dwelling mammals using infrared digital cameras: an Meek, P. D., Ballard, G.-A., Fleming, P. J. S., Schaefer, M., Williams, W.,
alternative way forward? Australian Mammalogy 32, 165–171. and Falzon, G. (2014b). Camera traps can be heard and seen by animals.
doi:10.1071/AM09039 PLoS One 9(10), e110832. doi:10.1371/JOURNAL.PONE.0110832
60 Pacific Conservation Biology N. Cotsell and K. Vernes
Milford, H. (1999). Soil Landscapes of the Coffs Harbour 1:100,000 Sheet Smith, A., Lindenmayer, D., Begg, R., Macfarlane, M., Seebeck, J., and
Report. Sydney. Suckling, G. (1989). Evaluation of the stag-watching technique for
Office of Environment and Heritage (2012a). Development of a fine-scale census of possums and gliders in tall open forest. Wildlife Research
vegetation map for the Coffs Harbour Local Government Area: Volume 16, 575–580. doi:10.1071/WR9890575
1. Project report. Office of Environment and Heritage, Sydney. Sutherland, D. R., Glen, A. S., and de Tores, P. J. (2011). Could controlling
Office of Environment and Heritage (2012b). Development of a fine-scale mammalian carnivores lead to mesopredator release of carnivorous
vegetation map for the Coffs Harbour Local Government Area: reptiles? Proceedings of Biological Science 278, 641–648. doi:10.1098/
Volume 2. Vegetation community profiles. Office of Environment RSPB.2010.2103
and Heritage, Sydney. Taylor, B. D., and Goldingay, R. L. (2012). Restoring connectivity in
Oliveira-Santos, L. G. R., Tortato, M. A., and Graipel, M. E. (2008). Activity landscapes fragmented by major roads: a case study using wooden poles
pattern of Atlantic Forest small arboreal mammals as revealed by camera as ‘‘Stepping Stones’’ for gliding mammals. Restoration Ecology 20,
traps. Journal of Tropical Ecology 24, 563–567. doi:10.1017/ 671–678. doi:10.1111/J.1526-100X.2011.00847.X
S0266467408005324 Thompson, G. G., and Withers, P. C. (2003). Effect of species richness and
Olsson, M., Wapstra, E., Swan, G., Snaith, E. R. N., Clarke, R. O. N., and relative abundance on the shape of the species accumulation curve.
Madsen, T. (2005). Effects of long-term fox baiting on species compo- Austral Ecology 28, 355–360. doi:10.1046/J.1442-9993.2003.01294.X
sition and abundance in an Australian lizard community. Austral Thomson, J., Horrocks, G., Cunningham, S., and Mac Nally, R. (2008).
Ecology 30, 899–905. doi:10.1111/J.1442-9993.2005.01534.X Modelling tree hollow availability over time in the Barmah landscape
Otani, T. (2001). Measuring fig foraging frequency of the Yakushima zone. Goulburn–Broken Catchment Management Authority, Monash
macaque by using automatic cameras. Ecological Research 16, 49–54. University.
doi:10.1046/J.1440-1703.2001.00370.X Tobler, M. W., Carrillo-Percastegui, S. E., Leite Pitman, R., Mares, R., and
Sanderson, J., and Harris, G. (2013). Automatic data organisation, storage, Powell, G. (2008). An evaluation of camera traps for inventorying large-
and analysis of camera trap pictures. Journal of Indonesian Natural and medium-sized terrestrial rainforest mammals. Animal Conservation
History 1, 6–14. 11, 169–178. doi:10.1111/J.1469-1795.2008.00169.X
www.publish.csiro.au/journals/pcb