900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Issuer: Contractor Comment Sheet ID.: F08643S-S0206-04 Issued on: 08.12.2020

Contactor: hanlei@china-hei.com Stage: Detail Design Completion Date: 14.12.2020

Reviewer KE Document Control TEG Document Control NESPAK Document Control RE2 Document Control
Contact: ...............@ke.com.pk piotr.sputo@tractebel.engie.com haseeb.saqib@nespak.com.pk ke.design@renewableresources.com.pk

Drawing/Document ID: F08643S-S0206-04

Drawing/Document Title: DETAILS OF SUPPORT (2)

The Categories of Approval: 1 = Approved, no comments / reviewed

Cat: 2
Besides the information discussed in the following, it is assumed that
2 = Approved with comments / reviewed as noted
subjects and the document itself are at least in accordance with the
Contract specification. Approval or comment will not relieve the 3 = Not approved, rejected / returned for correction
Contractor from fulfilling his contractual obligations. 4 = For information only

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
1. 0 KE NILL Section 4-4 to be revised as top of slab to be avoided and Noted. Partly covered the
embedded plate along with pipe support to be rest along trench.
the length of trench as discussed during DDRM

2. 0 KE NILL Please confirm the Beam shall be provided end to end Change the layout.
along the support

3. 0 KE NILL Please confirm the detail of sleeves shown in layout. Its Noted. It may be canceled in
reference and drawing number next version.

4. 0 KE NILL Please refer notes on layout drawing for soil replacement Noted.
and gravel around foundation

5. 0 NES NILL Please refer to our comments on document no. F08643S- Noted.
S0206-CA

Page 1 of 3
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
6. 0 NES NILL Reference no. of all the related approved drawings of All of the piping should refer to
Piping Installation sections shall be incorporated in the F08643S-S0205 for details. It is
drawing. not suitable to incorporate the
pipe to avoid confusion of civil
construction.

7. 0 NES NILL The depth of foundation, underneath select-fill, bearing

capacity and compaction requirement shall be as per
Noted.
Geo-technical recommendation.

8. 0 NES NILL Foundation shall be placed below NSL. Most of the foundation level is
3.200m.

9. 0 NES NILL Most of the foundations are placed on the existing ground It is impossible to embedded
level and have no embedment depth. All the foundations the foundation to the ground.
shall be embedded in the ground up to about 1 m. Trench and pipe for #5 and #6
are everywhere.
Moreover, finished ground level around the foundations
(embedment depth) shall be clearly shown in all the
foundation sections provided in the drawing.

10. 0 NES NILL Replacement has only been considered for FD-3 and FD- All of the foundation is at level
4. Foundations shall not be directly placed on the 3.200m ,and liquefiable soil
liquefiable soil layer and replacement shall be provided layer won’t influent the
under each foundation.

11. 0 NES NILL On-site sandy soils can be used if they meet the Noted.
specifications. Therefore, HEI should submit detailed
specifications of backfill/engineered fill material (PI,
percentage fines, large size particles, etc. should be
within the acceptable limits) for our review and approval.

12. 0 NES NIL HEI are utilizing the existing structures (trench & tunnel) Noted. Existing structure
to construct new supports for Cooling water pipe. strength detection is finished at
However, please note that the responsibility to confirm site. The strength is C20.
the safety and capacity of existing structure to safely
Page 2 of 3
900 MW BQPS-III Combined Cycle & Associated Projects, Pakistan

Com. Doc. Revi- Predec Owner’s / Owner’s Engineer’s Comments Contractor’s Response / Action Conclusion
ID: Rev. ewer essor [Abbreviations: KE=K-Electric Ltd. (Owner); TEG = Tractebel Engineering (To be submitted together with the
GmbH (Owner’s Engineer); NES = NESPAK (Owner’s Engineer); RE2 = revised/completed documents)
Renewable Resources Ltd. (Owner’s Engineer)]
support the additional loads lies totally with HEI.
We understand that HEI has completely evaluated the
capacity and condition of existing structures. In case of
any failure/damage to existing structure, HEI shall be
solely responsible.

13. 1 NES 5 Please refer to our comments on document no. F08643S-

S0206-CA

14. 1 NES 6 to 7 Noted

One behalf ofthe Owner On behalf of the Owner’s Engineer On behalf of the Contractor
Name:

Signature
:

Date:

Page 3 of 3