FAKULTAS PASCASARJANA

UNIVERSITAS INDRAPRASTA PGRI

Pertemuan Ke
A REVIEW ARTICLE
06
• Defining a review article
Fakultas • Exploring sample text of review article
PASCASARJANA • Preparing for review article

Program studi
BAHASA INGGRIS
 FAKULTAS PASCASARJANA
UNIVERSITAS INDRAPRASTA PGRI

A REVIEW ARTICLE
Pertemuan Ke
• A critical, constructive analysis of the
06 literature in a specific field through
summary, classification, analysis,
Fakultas comparison.
PASCASARJANA
• A scientific text relying on previously
published literature or data.
Program studi
BAHASA INGGRIS • A stand-alone publication.
(Philip Mayer, 2009)
 FAKULTAS PASCASARJANA
UNIVERSITAS INDRAPRASTA PGRI

The function of a review article?

Pertemuan Ke

06
– to organize literature
– to evaluate literature
– to identify patterns and trends in the
Fakultas
PASCASARJANA
literature
– to synthesize literature
– to identify research gaps and
Program studi
BAHASA INGGRIS recommend new research areas
(Philip Mayer, 2009)
 FAKULTAS PASCASARJANA
UNIVERSITAS INDRAPRASTA PGRI
The Types of Review Articles
– Narrative review
Pertemuan Ke Selected studies are compared and
06 summarized on the basis of the author’s
experience, existing theories and models.
Results are based on a qualitative rather
than a quantitative level. It is written in
Fakultas an easily readable format.
PASCASARJANA
– Systematic review
a very detailed, and comprehensive
literature surveying is performed on the
Program studi selected topic. Meta-Analyses are used
BAHASA INGGRIS
to pool the results of individual studies.
(Philip Mayer, 2009; Gulpinar & Guclu, 2013)
 FAKULTAS PASCASARJANA
UNIVERSITAS INDRAPRASTA PGRI

The Structure of Systematic Review

Pertemuan Ke

06
Fakultas
PASCASARJANA

Program studi
BAHASA INGGRIS (Turk J. Urol, 2013)
 FAKULTAS PASCASARJANA
UNIVERSITAS INDRAPRASTA PGRI

See the Sample Texts of

Pertemuan Ke
A REVIEW ARTICLE
06 Guided by the following questions:
1. What describes in Introduction?
2. On Result Section (main body of article), how many and
Fakultas what Heading and Sub-heading you found?
PASCASARJANA 3. If any, what describes in Method Section?
4. How does the author conclude his article? By stating the
purpose of the review, by restating the result, or by giving
suggestions?
Program studi 5. Do you find RESEARCH QUESTION on the article? If yes,
BAHASA INGGRIS
what is it? If not, can you formulate it?
 FAKULTAS PASCASARJANA
UNIVERSITAS INDRAPRASTA PGRI
PREPARING
A REVIEW ARTICLE
Pertemuan Ke 1. Narrow the topic (not too specific/large, reachable topic)

06 2. Define a few research questions, for example:

a) to what extent does the expansion of ICT/technology render merits and

benefits to EFL teaching in Indonesian secondary schools?
b) How does Indonesian EFL teaching during emergency remote
Fakultas system/Covid-19 pandemic in the areas of challenges and opportunities?
PASCASARJANA
3. Search for literature sources
4. Read, evaluate, classify and make notes.
5. Redefine the topic/focus and research questions.
Program studi
BAHASA INGGRIS 6. Make an outline to your article
 FAKULTAS PASCASARJANA
UNIVERSITAS INDRAPRASTA PGRI

OUTLINE of A REVIEW ARTICLE

Proposed Topic/Focus:
The development of EFL Teaching in Indonesian Secondary Schools for two decades concerning
Pertemuan Ke

06
to English Pedagogy and the expansion of technology

Proposed Title:
The Face of EFL Teaching in Indonesian in 21st Century Learning: A Review of Pedagogy and
Technology

Proposed Research Question(s):

How does EFL teaching in Indonesian secondary schools in the area of pedagogy from 2000 to
Fakultas 2020?
How does EFL teaching in Indonesian secondary schools in the area of technology from 2000 to
PASCASARJANA 2020?

Proposed Outline:
1. Pedagogy Area
a. Teaching approach/method/technique/strategy
b. Teacher issue: competence,
Program studi c. Student issue: motivation, attitude
2. Technology Area
BAHASA INGGRIS a. Digital platform/website/software/devices to enhance English teaching and learning
b. Social media
c. Gamification
 FAKULTAS PASCASARJANA
UNIVERSITAS INDRAPRASTA PGRI

Pertemuan Ke

06 Make your
OUTLINE of A REVIEW ARTICLE
Fakultas
PASCASARJANA

Program studi
BAHASA INGGRIS
 FAKULTAS PASCASARJANA
UNIVERSITAS INDRAPRASTA PGRI

Pertemuan Ke

06
Fakultas
Thank You
PASCASARJANA

Program studi
BAHASA INGGRIS