Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Webpage Not Available - 1616229020330
Webpage Not Available - 1616229020330
1640
Catholicism …
While teaching that in the bread
consecrated in the Eucharist there is
absolutely no change open to the senses
or to scientific investigation, the Catholic
Church supports the real presence, i.e. that
the reality of the bread is changed into that
of the body of Christ. The Church
teachings refer to this change as one of
the "substance" or "transubstantiation".[7] It
rejects the Lollard doctrine of
"consubstantiation", which suggests that
the substance or reality of the bread
remains after the consecration, instead of
being converted or changed into that of
the body of Christ. At the same time, the
Church holds that all that can be examined
either directly or by scientific
investigation – what in Aristotelean
philosophy are called the "accidents" (as
opposed to the reality) – remains quite
unchanged.
Eastern Orthodoxy …
Lutheranism …
Reformed Christianity …
The Reformed Churches, which include the
Continental Reformed, Reformed Anglican,
Presbyterian, Congregationalist and
Reformed Baptist traditions, teach the
pneumatic presence of Christ in the Lord's
Supper—that Christ is really spiritually
present in the sacrament of Holy
Communion.[5] The Congregationalist
theologian Alfred Ernest Garvie explicated
the Congregationalist belief regarding the
pneumatic presence in The Holy Catholic
Church from the Congregational Point of
View:[13]
He is really present at the Lord's
Supper without any such
limitation to the element unless
we are prepared to maintain
that the material is more real
than the spiritual. It is the
whole Christ who presents
Himself to faith, so that the
believer has communion with
Him.[13]
Methodism …
Methodists teach the real presence of
Christ in the Eucharist, but maintain that
the way He is made present to be a Holy
Mystery.[14] The Discipline of the Free
Methodist Church thus teaches:[15]
The Church
Catholicism …
1 Corinthians, from the Douai Bible, 1749
Eastern Orthodoxy …
Protestantism …
See also
Christian Church
Eucharist
Sacramental bread
Blood of Christ
Bride of Christ
Mystici corporis Christi
References
1. McElwee, Joshua J. (13 June 2017).
"Launching World Day of the Poor, Francis
says 'no Christian may disregard' serving
them" . National Catholic Reporter.
2. Mystici corporis Christi, a papal encyclical
issued by Pope Pius XII, sections 60–62
3. Losch, Richard R. (1 May 2002). A Guide to
World Religions and Christian Traditions.
Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing. p. 90.
ISBN 9780802805218. "In the Roman
Catholic Church the official explanation of
how Christ is present is called
transubstantiation. This is simply an
explanation of how, not a statement that, he
is present. Anglicans and Orthodox do not
attempt to define how, but simply accept
the mystery of his presence."
4. Neal, Gregory S. (19 December 2014).
Sacramental Theology and the Christian
Life. WestBow Press. p. 111.
ISBN 9781490860077.
5. McKim, Donald K. (1998). Major Themes in
the Reformed Tradition. Wipf and Stock
Publishers. ISBN 978-1-57910-104-6. "The
Westminster Confession emphatically
declares that Christ is truly present in the
elements and is truly received by those
partaking, "yet not carnally and corporally,
but spiritually" (chap. 31, par. 7). The
insistence is that while Christ's presence is
not physical in nature it is no less a real and
vital presence, as if it were a physical
presence. ... Those of us in the Reformed
tradition are under strong obligation to
honour the notion of the real presence of
Christ in the Lord's Supper."
. Veliko, Lydia; Gros, Jeffrey (2005). Growing
Consensus II: Church Dialogues in the
United States, 1992–2004. Bishop's
Committee for Ecumenical and
Interreligious Affairs, United States
Conference of Catholic Bishops. p. 90.
ISBN 978-1574555578.
7. Council of Trent, The Thirteenth Session
Archived February 11, 2008, at the
Wayback Machine
. "The bread and wine are changed, or
transubstantiated, into the very Body of
Christ, and into the very Blood of Christ"
(question 339 ).
9. "In the celebration (of the Eucharist) we
believe the Lord Jesus Christ to be present,
not typically, nor figuratively, nor by
superabundant grace, as in the other
Mysteries, nor by a bare presence, as some
of the Fathers have said concerning
Baptism, or by impanation, so that the
Divinity of the Word is united to the set
forth bread of the Eucharist hypostatically,
as the followers of Luther most ignorantly
and wretchedly suppose, but truly and
really, so that after the consecration of the
bread and of the wine, the bread is
transmuted, transubstantiated, converted
and transformed into the true Body Itself of
the Lord, Which was born in Bethlehem of
the ever-Virgin, was baptised in the Jordan,
suffered, was buried, rose again, was
received up, sitteth at the right hand of the
God and Father, and is to come again in the
clouds of Heaven; and the wine is
converted and transubstantiated into the
true Blood Itself of the Lord, Which as He
hung upon the Cross, was poured out for
the life of the world." (Decree XVII
Archived 2011-09-27 at the Wayback
Machine)
10. The Encyclopedia of Protestantism by Hans
Joachim Hillerbrand 2003 ISBN 0-415-
92472-3 page 676
11. Knouse, Nola Reed (2008). The Music of
the Moravian Church in America. University
Rochester Press. p. 34. ISBN 978-
1580462600. "Holy Communion, of course,
is a central act of worship for all Christians,
and it should come as no surprise that it
was also highly esteemed in the Moravian
Church. Zinzendorf referred to it as the
"most intimate of all connection with the
person of the Saviour." The real presence of
Christ was thankfully received, though,
typically, the Moravians refrained from
delving too much into the precise way the
Savior was sacramentally present"
12. Atwood, Craig D. (1 November 2010).
Community of the Cross: Moravian Piety in
Colonial Bethlehem. Penn State Press.
p. 165. ISBN 9780271047508. "In the
eighteenth century, the Moravians
consistently promoted the Lutheran
doctrine of the real presence, which they
described as a "sacramental presence.""
13. Garvie, Alfred Ernest (1920). The Holy
Catholic Church from the Congregational
Point of View, namely, the One Church in
the Many Churches. London: Faith Press.
14. Neal, Gregory S. (19 December 2014).
Grace Upon Grace. WestBow Press. p. 107.
ISBN 9781490860060.
15. Oden, Thomas C. (2008). Doctrinal
Standards in the Wesleyan Tradition:
Revised Edition. Abingdon Press. p. 184.
ISBN 9780687651115.
1 . Catechism of the Catholic Church, 795
Archived December 25, 2007, at the
Wayback Machine
17. John 15:4–5
1 . Catechism of the Catholic Church, 789
Archived December 25, 2007, at the
Wayback Machine
19. Vatican II Decree on the Church
20. Lumen Gentium, Chapter 2, Footnote 19.
21. "Unitatis redintegratio" . www.vatican.va.
Retrieved 2019-09-24.
22. Anonymous Christians
Further reading
Kim, Yung Suk. Christ's Body in Corinth:
The Politics of a Metaphor (2008)
ISBN 0-8006-6285-7
Kim, Yung Suk A Theological Introduction
to Paul's Letters (2011) ISBN 978-1-
60899-793-0
External links
Herbermann, Charles, ed. (1913).
"Mystical Body of the Church" . Catholic
Encyclopedia. New York: Robert
Appleton Company.
Retrieved from
"https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?
title=Body_of_Christ&oldid=1009337530"