Professional Documents
Culture Documents
00069 pdf كتاب الموضوغية في العلوم اانسانية
00069 pdf كتاب الموضوغية في العلوم اانسانية
com
kansopress @ yahoo.com
G W l f&J13 ?&Jl dl O L Jbf 2,
f&J13 6 Z?iJI ?&JI3 I f&JI, 'Cultural
.moral
aLIJd! J
A
, sf J$ &dl &..I 1 LLS ;# &I9 dpY!, $1
, .JYj.
Momuse j A j L a2y 6,
WJ Uj, *
* (* *)
(*)
I & , * I +Y I , .f&l q W l
+,JY-+Y J;;31, aKF
-. LUI 03b& 3 b L d-iJI
j
.f&l & d l @I
. \ f'If &v13q~JIJ &a,& & cJ& &g *> 4,
B. R w U . L e t The Pwple Think, P.43. (1)
:JjYl L&+> jr i;Lyl 4
1y +I +-
C & . D ~ ~ ~ J iJb
\A
-
Davidson (editor) The Search for MePnlng in Life P. 1 2. (t)
\Q
R. 9. Peny, Thc G e m 4 Theory of Vdue, PP. I I - 12' (O)
b\CL l 349-
Q d+ '4.G j +LC. dl>
i&
I
9 7 &I 1i1
: 91 Y; I p; JLGI. +.1;- 41 p;, .;>&,
l i j i&, 6% & ,' J G l & &lS d l sL;Yl LiG, .+I j
a+ 2 &I .GYI & i@l & .+ ;C &I L
~ $ 1 vl dr d$l+!l >,& I+!, ..&I 3 && b & ;@I
Y, .(")- & & ibrJ6, '&b b>
Y0
dL)ll 2 &IJ# & fl b)lj GLYI L1
+lc>&.* Jlj? 3 JQI I
L j +jL i t -1, &i @,I
YV
Bernal, Science in Hlstory, P. 713. ("7
+Ul U-9,. Y l / &L)>jj h
L
l
w . J i':J &+I iL;P
f ,,AL(\f)
3 &~+,ll) d w l &dl j ?+L, .&I L& Eidos & ! I JUI
.qLJyI r,LJl j GUY1 djlJ ~ A &tI j (+Ul
J1 & &+ &.+JI -u- )3
2 1 3 I I U, f .L *I flSrY~, &I
2 I '31jYI 21Jdl JJiJl; L , J .&Lf
j & &I
.G Yr, i +2 ~ A 4
I 1#-131
~LL
,. ~J ,.++ +
, a Y I , .?a1 F J ~ C J ~ ~I+Y
J $ G L y II-.; r+J ,.+Y,k j+-$I $ I
.JU+
&UL +A .+G)II P I SF j i>+ilji a Y L
I+ &.+ &I New Route ti+&I ++I j ( \ O W -\tq7)
31 d&- U f, 6~32b U ,I +!I
~ LU &$ LI,~
bGYI di df ;j,. L U I b L j3+ 4 1 iliJl 2l,dI
+I 4k 2 - U I ilbl;l ;'yill(\ V \ t +) 33 ALG b-1
'4 'w && tllfl~ 315 &I3 .>spa.^ j&Jl +I4
hi rWJ i+&l ,KiVl 41 JJ iJlr'&hb
, ci; 9 jls,
b d3 . \7hh yb 4,i;f z3wI
t*
Bernal. Op. Cit.. P: 722. (Y')
Zeitlin, I. Ideology and the Development of Sdociological Theory PP. 1 1 - 12. (YV)
.t.v-ter L9 -1' @bJ&c31 $dl ,yu~+(r~)
zeitli op. ct., P. IS. (rf
Zcitlin Op. Clt., P. 13. (1')
.t\t - t \ v / &>#A1 c>lk Y b J+ .3(tY)
&
, JF d&l L j U 41 +I JL 4; j d,
&dl 241 +I 4; Ji*- dl yjj JjL Q W I oi.,-, .({MI
.+L')I1 +I JLf Jl$ & d l p l y 1 ilj3 j&b c.&I
c&b$ i+AI QYYLYII &lL p,3 Jr
dL L E I .Ill;jp,
*y>j ;;.? p1. .3L?'l &kJ ;UL. p.~
JlJ+ dl b * r ~
bj L s + + - d u b C ~ W J k Jby~& ~ J I ill^ -3
J , i;LY 4 4 +y+.
.( " ' U ~& C.U~Construct
.\ *T- ff c+IUIJ ,,.hJI jaL13 '39&J( t t )
Zeitlin, Op. Cit.. P. 58. (to)
Ibid, P. 59.
Bcmd. Op. Cit.. P. 721.
-
Ibid, PP. 723 4.
tV
p I &J9 &. 1
i 9 I, &Jl o h ( d 8 )I 'j.. ;
;-
k.,
V, 14' l+f psy J, .;rY,UI U dji LGLAYI
J d 'GL*II J l , + df l+- ' ~ I L SL,+u
. $4 pJd,l '.&q
&
' .J13 9 rkll &$I j.iY+ 2 dl5 @ L GI
0 'j.. I , I 9 'ULYI r,.U &I ~ $ 1 jii 3rj
:~ J ;l?>
&*- aY3uI
&
, Y +.,dl
I A 2 &$bf 4141 h >A 3f k! JWd
'pWIikJjj0~3j&Isr3Lyj&ptJcY~ti~J~
d 21- o ~ Y ! , &Naturalism &&lI ruYI *!,
G b & 2 kY 3fi- bf j+ Y JjVl oGYb Anti - Nahualism
c i d I WI r$l j&*i j L Y l r$1 Z K L f, i,ii j. i/=y
4@I, b L Y I 'j +I '& $I O j I L l 4 &ill &V,l
&+ d l +I $' d+Ul u
1
,> '$I ik+l ++I 3
4 a U I
L #
'+a 9 - b j ' w l k & dl
a'+ p-L u w '$1. >
- , '+I_)! @I &-+I +I
ibu\ bj+.!I dj;L;! 'G+ Factors &I> f, Variables
.w
E. Naglel, The Structure of Sdmce,p. 451.
\
or
ldJa bJ&" ilk j jl,h.ll & l;+l + Iiji
dfU J.+ Y 4 j o13ijl,h.lI .?u; l;+, b?l;r Jll&J2
+lI J b U l i . & l Lt; dl U
r l j ~u e- ,(S
,- dI alJI &U l p j 4 dl ijUl +-df -9 4 i&LYl
.("I& +,1" ' i,. .jl+Y
j
;uU
4, 'i-
L9&I d
,k WI
+L~I
l di
&a\&!
-&U 6
ai5
j . 9 1 d~
&
dt 'IL
' * b y 1 +Yl &-
& k!$l;rc
&
&dl
$b cb -3 6% MI &&I Js l; $b ty.4 J,KJ -3
.Iy Oedipus effect C ~ ~ , Y Ij Y l J\ 6 &dl 4 1 & ii/.Il
3 .(")ejJ dJ> JJL ~9,& >kll I L &L
,
I &a&I
Suicidat t d $UIJ +I JtYl 9 3 j L J
:
,
i
& LLP,:
JjYb Self - F ~ l f f i n g a d &IJ jAl 3kJb
b;; @LL 4;r%dl,& 'bUl &dl4 1'j ,&
d& # ~ &f '?jii .4Wl + &aI& &fi'j ;3 dl
xi ~.,4;11JLYI J ilk d 3 a k i Y I J+YI aui~
,LI JLVl Jhj;: +I ,MI I L & :LjJ . \ f 1~ yb
& 3 'w 4 1 319 3 a&
. k. l l a$>!
.("')b ilk
'j &ladl &I Js jLpi Y dl9 3 jib 3-UI &I U
-
Value in Scientism and Values edited by schoeck PP. 16 17.
o
w & '.-I, .@I &I+ d%
a& &I1 + b Y I pl,hll 03& &I && &A. &y G L Y l
'&.+)
d+i.i .&i&l;t ~3f jlb; 5, i+* Gjli +.Li , . ~ f
rkJf JS 3 +L' j ~ !a l i W I 3 ~ &&I
4 Jl&l jr Snell
Q+ ',;LAY! i>YJI JkC ,++ $1 +$I t+ rdgl
** d.2 dj,& 'r,L Li, 3 @ 3 ++YI i;UI e
j*,t 'ys@(y j , Y l ~ ~ L . y & I l ~ ~ l j r r l =
(of)+i a-, @I 9
ov
Q.Gibson, The Logic of Sod.l Enquiry, P. 73. ('-1
Jefreys. *scientific method and philampby Sdcnrc News, P. 61. ('Y)
.Y Y / L (LWJ L
l L PIS
(7Y)
Urban. Beyond Ratism and IdePlLom p. 167. ('1)
Sullivan G . GPLUo P. 38. ('0)
&dY G L Y I pl&l j d+UI l,- r& '$1 +ill .h,
- bliGjCfll.iSPS;riTJl+l& bvbLS;, e+;saL++.~
*I Ub, .rbdl a-
L& d-3 '$1 awl, bl+
L
+
p
A
,
;t. a+.+.
3 y ,& ,+&
I
(j.
3
* l p l (IIJ>l d&-
G J , d
iLK
k u l &p
6
&$
&I
.@ CJS& d l
&
&
+
+ &L3'p & *
i a,;
&?Yl!
*li'YI
, I
L+
&d
0
itfJ3+Y!
L iCQI
&!I
&by!,
agad
b l j l +l!
,
dl.&
'
(jp &i+
- 3Jl
a3k,y +I
~ 1 ~ 3 1
l. LiA&
(W&
-
.'
4
0 f b b
Continuum
-- GlJYl
pld\3
&JU\ & J l
@I
&
K. Popper, Op. Cit., P. 16.
K.Mannhcim, Ideology and Utopia, P. 50
j j ~ U I*$
l +,JY-+)u &
d, dt - 4s ,!rf, - *,,Y,
JL+ $b ~ f i*r
r J, CJJJ Jjr &-Y 6Ul G L Y I r,l.Jl-
a ~~ 4 ' d k f r l 'y @I A- - %, + "GJ
--
'aliI)-I,
.(Vy)~L+I,d l
j. r
p2 JI 4: &ep ,+@ C: dl d+4Jl
i f d l Jjb J, +lJI + p a l&j .+jlJlj +Wl
- >
- -41 1-b & 91 2u Y kI & '('&) $jb
J+ 4 .I*# t j s ) j ' d l &ly J5J YJ+~&I
Y
,I LL;
hl# +I f I L W s6,Ul ,dul 'y p- l. , d ~ )
Q. Gibson. Op. Cit., P. 77. (Vt)
:&dl \h4 dJb (*)
fAo LJU\-1 6-1 ,yb3&&I &,-b J+ -\
Jl d& &dl (~JUI G#+y ad1 by*)
+cJL AJi j d;L, ,.+I4 Y, 6 V ~ Y I
.r.~ t,,j&I eJUl
Js a+,+ ... w l r&JI &u raL;LJ)II) &
. f l d d l ,y & G j & z+!L & ~ I J . ! !d p + eJUl +G9
++Jl rIj.dl) Y * V JP c t L +b tikrlihll -I &j - Y
Js rJL! pWli . . .?Id1 4 p 1S r&YI iipl +Id1 ;,&I cL..'I
.#
L, 313
xl~+yL1J-d 2~ . . .?Id1 4. 1S 16EL
] 39, sGYI W,
&$dl
r
I
-.
cry'
9~
&i+
~
4
J rlj
,
J
+i&l
30~1
J
I+% .L-J,2
dl l&b U l J4;l
&dl
L
9
@l &-dl w
J 4 w-4 &+
LBL,
3 cl-dl (41(~41
.
>
3
L)-JI
L+ +I GIJI j3 ,L[
b b $ 4
JI i&~
w y J &.Ls
L
G ~
.bflb,
2, 2 && L &ILs?,
k ~&l &dl &I!.,
js,
3
I
1 a L j a l h*d l
I1
W I ~ c l i l &4 p+
k GlJl jJb+
.bJ,J +d,
> 4 i&\&!Jb
+>-~+AI 4 1 4 1
.&I
+ @I
+ 1,
gldl
b b ,y
alhJ.1,
+
b ~ ~ ,
I
I
a
.+;, i+ & f+-J& .I+ irJ.l..a JI +A
. d1 JHY6 ,MI j
.
f,LJl I+$ + 3j 'kJL 31 L,fJ1 &I2 .dlJjdl (jc
j Y
J.LJ $=Ji+iJ UI Ljn 'iyjlj, GU A ~1 ULYI
.&I, 9 i j .L+JI, I L -UI,
JLII, ++JJ i+i & WI
lj,;, 6jlS;;ldf - *yJ?) >L;ll 9 >.l;r! - ~f 9
.&MI U I 'j +-
Jc b J 3 L &, 'L+I ,I > d l
a~+,-JJuL-I lJIU & 4
kJ+ i>J?
LSJ y $1
f,.ld c)'zll .+L+Yl, i & L Y l aIc+,dJ @I, I* '
i&JI LJJ +
j .*I @I r l j 3 J d y iyy 3 GLYI
ci3+d.l bJY3 i 3 d I l+b@++JI l+ is a b g l
Physicalism LA?, 6 Empirio - Criticism t4l
-.- +dlS
a G&?, Operationism i;\-Y I i.,ll@l+ 'i&d,I +J!,
JjL' ~ 54, 4 &LVl
~ilclill~ JL!.i d l +dlJ
+WIp , J I j l IL Y, '(\).&Ab l JS +by! fliJ1
i & JJ
l l+s;~L + , JS I '+L rG\
*t JS 9,I 3I d 'J.lJI 3d;
;' dl
sIsrk o bK, b?L Notion L+ & dl Li, j yS3 ' 6 2
,UI +-
Y, .@I JJAI a+ wk
2 L6 4
1
i
, '-+I3 a l ~ ~ 3 l dj+ 91 9
. ( y ) GVI,
~ 'iJ+ $91 -I+ J! +UI ++I -I+
@
;.;
dul a
jc A
+Wl,
6
thy1
.L
'(yl
.(')&I
bJ+
'y
j
&l&l
3 LXc
I -
4
h
%
L
&I
d l
+ .+"I
r; &
j . L,
db
.clans jCJ6
dr ,I+
&it-
~ &+
J+
bx. i4*i>dp 4 I ,
signs QLWI yiu!
dI
I
Y -Jk
I &j ,
3 I+
~ J I 'y L-~JJIOL
&>&I
b
4 &, &kgd l L J u l
+ Jbi+
Y &I
jc F-
d
,d
3j
- j9>1
ponyme
L I
rjkj
dad!,
+vJ+
*I
-'
A,
bccJ+i
+
,I @I
.&
& h r
& d+ Y ,&J 319 ed1 4
J j l l &$
*
&@
c?t;li, +Yl,
&I
di
a L J U I jc
~r+ dl S i l
-k & .k! L
&&
' C l i j @I
+4
+u
d.L, .(")&k.AI j
- cFU-6 >, .@ +%
.ipLlill + jc (+
@I
+
fg$I,,
>
/
+,>
d,JI
Lp.&
LUIJJ=-~
P
C ~ Y IJ,
/b
'+I
;-! ~ I + L J+I
&2 2, .l++
J+
p
'
I
I dt G
& WICLk!
l+;rd l +'Ill
.cJ&~
'y
LaJ3>
&,
,
J,.dI
/b $4
&@
~ , r '4
A-
L
'y
&-J\ Symboles
cjJl i+lI
d l +J&I
d% 3
&I
JI
l
jc
dtJ ,
JJy
+
L i i j ~ b ;
k1 VJ,
~lpll,
iJL
d l irI,+l
/
&J
.lag3
-JUI
;$dl
lpy
JlyYl_(
aLWI
i J u4-L
1%
3:
Y,
dl
rjI ~i.
L lib
;&I
b i d . , P. XII. (A)
b i d . , P. XM. 0)
b i d . . P. 5. (\ *)
Ibid., P. 6.
Loc. cit.
Ibid.. P. 9.
& GIG Y
k j i j l f f l j ~ J! U Y I t j f & Y,
Y &%I t j t ptJJ . r U l , c+ffl j .&I CIJdl
p.4'Lj-r us, j.*I &I j .j y '+. & 43
tjl,JI +
J' t j t L;>J ;lil + ,'jiy L+ +& alLlsl
.&L,
&L J b jWX. i& ~JI;!
b-I j. + b Y I
LILY U, i-Ltll j
. L3Lakj+ \r~i + aJJLjL.5
b $' ,$I Jl 6 JMI J+ & b ;r 'tjI&lb
OL+iJlJ-" j
.&I f, ,HYI JI izi* t, ' j b&
~ +i
~
&G + J' ,Yl iL4 ,'+, .-IJ +b1f l i j p, 6 aIJ(;JI
j t I-.
, .&&I c
GYG j JKS &I bJ+9 3 +LI
.&L! &
UIAl 0 Y - h j &,
C'I $1, J cbyl
."O)JbYl,
b,&
*;I
+
,.'
Y,
Lp &$IJ
pl$l
.+
'$1 +dl
'&I
1.b ,A & d l A d i C . ~ > W Y aI U W I
'$1 &\,A1 ;+
&&I+
,A
(IL!
d l
&
3
&I
~ Y Ip~JJklli.(")&I,AI
C4.b
+JI
e4; pp! L. '&?YL
'p
$6 h i
b+!
&Yl
+&Yl
datum c,krll,
$1
@ +I
@
pI$l
jb 3 L l ,
'y Jl5
'jG
,I
,i
,A J I , I L i , .JG y;J.
. &>&YI J+k
.35 .6
j 1; IjJ& di c&+~ $A >
;I,! eY9 qL;. dl5
@ $1 pbll jj k k +
I- db ' L k Y l , el+Yl
Jd d+l;i $L +-d 3 9 & 9,.&,Jy4I 4
1
LJJYI, ' fbJl iL% 6-d b i G l +-$1 -1
dl +-d i l l Le sens 41, a-I L+ c&'
'+ d,l p-d' a+ p- "$1 el"l, 'a+' 31
.(yt)+ldl, 22~1Lb! d' &-"$1 &!,dl,
jc- ;"$1 $1 by ,t dr +
ji;~ ceGiD
q&
dl + $1 ih;h*U JLJl &li 'ibWI 0 4 - jxL. irL;;. d y
. &+I dbdl r, ~ Y bfi I +-Y I+
&I D, F+ 9 bLYl &
d
.l jr Ljgl a4;$ OL
,J
!,
d",!Jli j 3 d I
LblY3 . I + J y G 35 jr &
sdLI#, '+ b yJ U Ulj i ~ l i lel L + & /Li
.I
j , 9 a I I , .& @a
.kL&
f>l & .LA 4
11 I L dCY, l 3 ad&, jJg ;
,
U l 0 L &G d U I& '*A1 $JL; jo ,+-
tPu +d 2
, j9, ' @&yJl t-UI J.) .'yO'L,.+LI
I jr L +
' .I, ib1 9, '4-
jo J&I &I I L dl &
, '@I cJLi d& dl a b d l
b i d . , P. 2.
b i d . . P. 40.
b i d . , P. 41.
b i d . , PP. 42.
Ibid., P. 43.
,>* L%& .rls?'I ,& 'y % d d ?p?lj> ++A
A+ &,
i,dl 2 k>Libk & *- &$I LUYI 'y >&
'y ii'U + l k , *+'"J4 LLi &u >J @I &J
1 & kl+c 4?, & &I,: i'Li J l j Y l
& bbp &I if# 'y +j '& +Lu &u JS & c i f + I ~
. .
j L jyl&,('\)~'"J1 ,&P/ L' + L , S ~ ~ - ~ I I L
b i d . , P. 44. Vf)
b i d . , P. 45. (ye
b i d . , loc. cit. (Y\)
Ibid., P. 53.
Ibid.. P. 55.
r*li,JI dl -f+s ->> dl '$C3 .++A! &A IiA &
p w ~j. iu > j .L ,A+ b,..i9 b+ +&YI
.l&&A '$1 ++I
i,d t ,J,
~ u+y G s, L J+ L+9 'yL-p d,&
,I) i+kJ +U i% C.I>
>F, ++r JS L+ 6 v ~ j.1
9L $ rlc4 d b h c4/ r, Identique ( U l a
Jr +Y, ;+i U I ;+JI a L W I LK !;I Gf . ~ l j ,,
+
-+,
+f f, -k+ i+ vUI J& 3. .JG
lh Jr, ,&I> 3 jz L ,
'
p ,-. bc-L%I Jr L& dl Llr%l
l&>Iy jc LAY jc I;* L ljl i,cL+YI ;GI ,& 4-2 +I
yJ4 & @b i~ 01~42 3 ,&d bb- '$1 bl&l q$\
2 d + 6-X. J & JL Jc &-df vUI
@ k Y1 2lJl df LT + . d k + Y I 2lJ1 JJ4 j f
elij.LAd&-'i;?f> UilLL-jfd,>&jfi)CLdI &+
;>s
k~j, Jy 3 ~ > W?
I - JW~I
Jr ;>F~ >,dl 6-L S
;li iLJ.b>, .i+ Jld, ;bLL, G j l i
@ kb b@& *j $' 1 kb& d-4 d d Y b p i > j&
r Lf J W I Y + ;X11cljk bl>ktaltalon iJbJ lrGy 6 6
Ibid., PP. 55 - 6 .
QV
Ibid.. P. 57.
Lac. cit.
t > r I I & ,'PI + 'y Lzl A,
@%I 'y +l;zYI LjlJl& & J,k $
'+A *J;5 p
' y
LgL JL j *XI + ckl& &, &I, 'b&
J,L .( \ A ~ V JL;;Yl
) cjc &IJ> j u b 9 I.b, .L g L ,
jed; + kJJJI JL3 iklr;c ablhi jj U Y I a Y h L I j >
$1 &~~ j JJJl ')3 $At+ j L Y I J;LiLI ul&l
,I &+ id-O ~ U I ; ,,UYI ,+ j j
jh YQ
I I I j .blir r, ij+
,I (i+, &J%
0 Y h &%I :
, A, .+-+I &Jyr-Jl r-\5jJ>
ah:, j6'UI jJJl Jj iPI;L), & + Y l +LJl J1 j U Y l
w 2 egoistic $91 .&i, 3L;tIl
i
j 4 obUI j ilPb 4Jr2 >y2 'LUI &G
&. j U Y l 0 Y h p j l j 4+ b + & +l&-YI kl,>l
If
J U l jc r$Ul jUYI .&,$I +j i;C;;JJl
m
&
, &!j3 $ ?&
2
, 4 .juYI a Y h J &-91
$YdI o h J5 L,L concomitant variations &I j rjX;II
Glul UISr!, L p ~ b&
~f j ->&I sWWI slj;I!,
. +bjI13
Ibid., P. 1 1 1 .
E. Tiryakian, Sociologism and Existentialism, P. 19.
.&ql 4-lb
dl *, $1 ;
, j
. (&J', I + >F!
J @ ' L l A I +L J >j( j ~ IA&ii>+ J ~ + e,h, j(C;Jb
aGpd-AbJS3 ' d ~ ~ . p +' p~p -b ~
y k & @ J , j J , .k&
Sj i i 1 4 -:JI~-JI j GI ilss J iibla, .+YI
JA :&+IiJk,I T;7.+J13 '+L&JI d&l :&I &La
' .(:')Yb+ &\ alJl 'y &L.a dfi -iJ+A&
,
.'3J,Vl
j $I dt''$1 +%I,l .4 j L 4 & Jl+
'$1
fl &>I, ;JLJI abf, .& pi J, a~G
., '&I
'$1 3yl J, &lr Y 391, 'LA 4 ; I I dbf -2$1
j JU
,I b y J! js, J, 4~ ,'+>I 4; J! +i
Ibid.. P. 91 . ( f y )
s
u,m L
+.; +I+,A ?ls,r dy,- J,I IL &,
I o b l j Lbjc j - k . 7 + b l as&\-1_(1 f, fb, 'J3 '&&!I
!La,* $1 >
LGIJJI O h , 'pl,h!I j . b> & ijJl
1& a ' $ , J y , . " J l &I
&jJl 4 &l,.i, Zk *u j ?K>,>
Y '(")i;Li JS jr L 'J3YI +ill j '++A &+
Ibid., P. 90 - 3. ( f r )
Ibid.. P. 94. (f f )
substance 9 9 1 $.h.e Jl
D. Mitchel (editor) A Dictionary of Sociology, art. Agelicism. (if)
r i a l i a n , op. cit., P. 14. (O')
(+by!
j IA-1
Y &I
2
. 51 JI - a-L;K,
J5
pl,
L ~ YIJ,I
1
Y tL;rYI,
+I
&!I +I
&I
>J
j I
h.
d, C = r . ( " ) b ~'jy..~ ; b u l
bjkll
3
ib, j~+!I
+ ill
;;Z &,bbb&d!
IJ, PI$
L i ; W I iy;31 'j.. b&Jl
Y
&-a
4
,d
.+I
>J
Cyl
L
k,
Xij G L Y I +I
J &J1
;
+
j.
4 4 )
j I&,
+JI
bY 6 t b Y I j &I
*, .'I+l+
+I
62
a#Li~
jqi ,I j q ~
&I
-,
- 2
SQC-
. ('y)Fl+
a
pl, Ji
ilql
h
'j..
ej
&!I i ~ l z L L k s l 4&>
;>
b&
i dl
4 A,
$1
L;;
. *4&1
j dIy&
51
b&.
4
Ibid., P. W. (Of)
#
.('v)d\b!z~l
'k jlflYI LiJI Lj. 1
9 J1.l -Lj U & , $d s , df Y,
b 9 IL, . ( \ q f A ) +A c w l p gI.5 &&- b +
ovyl IL Jl-b b J l - 4 d &, d d l ~ j t .$ Si ld JA
P. Frank, *Einstein. Mach and Logical Positivism in Madder (edit), op. cit., P. 90. ( 7 7 )
.Y t A / 6 &ul
Fjl (TA)
P. W. Bridgman, The Logic dModern physics, P. 5 . (71)
. V T 1 / '&UIr j I (Y*)
.A - \fV / '&-$ F j l (V\)
. V V I - VVY ,y '&UI F j l (VY)
IJ, 4 ZJAI -4 LJ
LLI j l j ; Y I &I
jl,hlU .Dodd 393, Lundberg cAJ.zl 9 L + J, t b Y I
JYLYI, GUY1 alS;c +i a& &jJI ,LdL a++r J&
,f) 4j & l L&.! @I a&&\ Jp +3, . LLS 'iU- ,1$
@ L (W] L, institution rWl, GWI, p d J essential L y U l
& ~ - \16
r 4, &fJf & &-ill &,Yl &dl j41;;. jL Y]
I L j L&- &dlA, j13Y1 &I + J, .i--J.IJl +,.!I
jf 3
4-G j LJkLll al.lj;y ,I alL&l +-&dlA, &Y 3 U l
2 + $, b > q'
U~ +I o*ii JpYI 4 trUI j,iI
ct i - I / %&I
I , .JW Gij
!ki + a3
z*t >, e& '&I
' 8 rk-u -> 46 42J
b j
L>JIGLP~YI
~+YI, .ui&~++at +-
at +.+) 0 1 41 L;a & L a ! (y ,si t, a+ &% 3
.J L Y I &I; i*/ > (+UI, &ll Jj 2 + A b>\
(Wl a Y & j +jl+dI rI/l a p 3 A- dt.J
.' " 7 r ; b s t , &+YI
y b 1 mu4
j?, 4 ,TTJ @ Yf
p l y 1 JG .*bj & J l &+I j mk L&& & '*I
(motion V l ,i) ijUl j a Y $ j
. '+cilb (WI 4: I& 2;
Jk j, &$I J% is,$, . j4JI ;?tuI j + $1
3 a&- A, 6 dfll 3 tuj j
. +,O
J JI field of force ,idJ
-. Ja@I
df ;r ,f interdependant LUIA&\ d J a, rJG~In
JGwl cs&2 .L +j - . $1 -. >) irL&I j. air
\To
Ibid., P. 207. (At)
-fof 4 iL.b 'dc *> ~ ~ +I 3 c>+ 1 4 dj .>(he)
.f \ *
Jl& &L! & &I> @ d(5 & d l YU &Jl Ih
ii-JdU .;iS+l Q U I J% 2 QU. ks; $J.-
+Lp4
Ed ,~ I h C lI J1 L&
l ,GI--~ $I--Yl
j. r;U. Y lh, 'bIY 'y i=-l;; GI, 3 $1' iS*l Q U I
'Gb fYJ2 (t?l bf fLJYl 6 h dY L b 91 -41 &b
tj-n 4 2 G.1J L&+>I GI>YI --$ j d-l 2
l i dfi- df J-L, L J r j - df 4 4
A
. d d l i .*I ab&I
-d4 , JI&
~ :L &I &w @ Y i&i
- '""i,bL.~ QY I> >>Lir ~ I i d y d I d JF-Li jI--YI
L
&-JJ L ~ l j-i j - L Y l + J Y I & 2 I p Y I +.+ Y.9
Correlatior b@;YI 0K.L f& JI (fq1,I) aYLLI tj &
bU1 & d k L & eLb ~ lflj,i Jf a Y G l+Y Coefficients
u d p & r *dl ,I 1 3 udkn :+ ;JC j JlribYl >rl~.
+!I ~ 2 . j,+I +
&-JI uYU.1 dfi- i, W LG
Y JI LLJ; +I&, J1 b>A yi dl +
&>I >*
j k~JLLI > 'dKl1, dbjl j v3&d,$ & kp
,I) &-.dl t
ljJ1I+ df d U l i .b>, ryJl, ~l,J-l, Qi@l
&I b J I r(GL;yl f&Il flj, j. L.2
~ , ~ l j j Yi;4
;Y, .A,.LJ Ljlj .k dl Jl +&>I , I +Jdl ildl &
& G I a\,>[ 'j& lx k< kk *I w & aI A i l
*j&I 1-b 2 AJdl rEJ31' &4 *i,
(dl+YI 'j.4Lk.JI f, &L;II Jb) f,+lLi, :I'+!\ +I +(S
jc*dl&Y, 'cr*I,iu,fiQdl&Wci;pi~
92 index &>IS JJ& f, $3 U,lj d l internal i$ll'l LjIJl
' d L % I 'j.4 b,.+ Jr i d 6 ->IS L% f, L& d,& u
d& l d i l d l l pEJ3> J ~ *i3I . ( A A ) L w b! .
f d l &>.ki
L 9.
&%I i & l IL, . tyc!plu. $ >+I &J &I &I
&
r --
J
b b p F
~~3.1
&+o-kr ;r
~j-&...&
j%)'l
&J . . . . @
[,
bdl;.kl
-. ii%
b +)L; J!.iII!t+Jl
.&I J o ) OM
~b r j
b$l
....o*
t+JI,
,L+J,l
,
.('")a&I
& ?
2P;'
&*
>,.I1
1%
&d
jbl&g f$ dl dub
& U iLo Y +
3 & .-)&I
GJ1i;l .&I
&dl&dl J
.b&I ;pU
&I
if.(
Lldl ;rr? &MI jJ@
L S ~b & J ! d l jtjp~.b )I+
49
9
dl
pi &
.WI,
b
b
6 9 1
.y? - yo
@
,y
.( \ ' ')WL;
is&I
A l j ~ l pAl>)'li
&$
':&$,I
.a b
je+ ~r ++&I
d l ii%
~ j 41
:
$4 $ 3
;J
d
,?6
&Jb+Jl ;rr?
+*-ill
&>$dl
;*
p g+JIPklli)
2 Jyp Jj+
JL
,
& (tPfJJ wl,.Il
+d
91 + J
)+I
iy-
7 2 s
IL &
r&
.
b+
~+JI dy , IO;L~
Y
-. ;rWl
4 4 1 ;r
4'1
.
6J-
b
.y?
-
Ideationally
f$
oa-4
0
++JA
b2
&&-
jJyp &-) I L
a*
/
iJ+
JA I &*&,I
.+YI j
4
&-
d,&b
L+J&
bpL~i2UI
ii;iCI ,y rl+1
6 3 1
,I +MI as24
. J
b & u l
4
+A
b~t.i d
4 +)
,y +.A
i~b%!I
bl,.II
J~~
&
JrJ
0 2 ~ 3
211
(\*\I
(ley)
(1 * y )
(\ * t )
dl
4'1
1
9' 4, bL+ 4 2% +lit ~~,
.alU 4 L Y l i;JI
dills, ~ Y I f,
i>UI J d I 84, I~&&&I k k f JJ-~. b.
+f, Noesis --$IJ .('' ")Sensile i 4 l aL&1 3
ow &1, ,,-dl 5 9, &JYI &&;,,-dl @3
-,I dl; Passivity iJLcri;YI 31 ,+ &$I 6 6 L Iil; .&I
3 . i2U1 +&I &# dL& VJ activity +Wl J! ,+
b + ~+-, iw +-
iJ> zUl ++ &&I eUJl d!
+lif b('")91
@ c.+ L+,A ~Noemak.&l 9 ~tp, J1
A
, 4 A,IJI, 9 4 jc. &I
04.2 s1,>yli . Z M l +&I
+LP r+I) +All3(LuS 9 4 $Air 2-U LuisJ (dJU
j ;
;;d! LLJ 4Y, . b> j, iJJI j 4; Jh, . (Luis +n
+I LI,.yI +J j(i+~c) d& L r; & 3kL p ' j
.?I ...+ I,~+I,T
4dI ~SI&4; &E jl &iy + 9%% Jyp r ~ 2
I
+&I
* 3 1
3 (QYU-I) &,$.I1
, b*
u-
&.i&!I o h '8~d1
4; d&- 3, (&&2 3 ~
di A
3 1 ~ 4r~ L
~ 1a 4
JMI d i l i l l I L
Y &I
AYI ~
' 2
ji;? 41
+, .~ILYI, d 4 I & f+JJI J+I
J+ &+ 9 a 4 1 &L kY. ;
~ ~
, +*
J
d
;lY
~
.(\.')& - ~
, IL J.,
.I^ c, ' l & a d d 'lcy LC ;;3 +Uli .akU &I
c,, r iJ3PL b 41 o b 9 2 ~ 3 . 1JF,
, .f-+A1 JF,
'a&!UI 3 4l; Ideal QlL 54 +Uli .~,s-AI &ia, ,
.+ +>&5 ,y CjlrfL, '+lJl a l U &= @ AlJ2l &5 ,y
.( b k l +I &$>)
@>'$# '+pl.d%&d,&bt$>p&-t
:dJContingent
Correlative --bContingency . a$;,
3y 9 l -0
' ( G u l &) Essentiality L J LdJ 'L iJJPy
'lb~zr~l 4JG j& .2 c p J 1 1
l ,I +>A1dl.+,l,
:$9 @I Being
. cit;$-IfbJ11 & hi ti-I 4 3U.I - 1
Nornerically &lr +&.dl &
, fWJI & y L J & ~$.Z1 +Uli - V
.Nonidentical
.%$-I a.l+,Il Quality i+UI $.Z -A
! J &.i (iJJyd&) e-
Y Yku.1 +$ -
.("y)w
d l +-J,LYI Status +kU -\ 0
GyJ
,
+
JS d' 9
+I>K
,
LYl
:& t
o h
ozj-.
dl,
+-ill'+>,&I
'bli j LYl J.1 l+
JLP;-YI
W
>y-
+,
l
4
60"
+iJl &.G,.l
&a 3,
4 2,
41
61"
b
&
3Xb;YI &
b&
'#-I
/&I
O>F*
u
"pu ++,I.l
-.
-b J! i&LlLi;JI LJ+rJI,
GJUl i.xAl & uI_SI >+
q
CL/& h d
~JH
&ill
pL9 L
.9r &-
1
1
-
&,Yl
+ ~i-+-+
+&I
b
r
+J1
0
-
iJ,&
s
.L;li dp-
&I
d i
aI+L
4 />
+I
to)
tL;.
-Li
jl
+I
I*
&
4
YYq
+ 31 >Ji. ' i J b ~ $ l ++I 'y &
crcJLL y; &
'j ,\;W - -&.dl
+ - &;J~JI;;JI i;\U $3, &dl &I
5,d '&I L[ ' J k L $ l '\;[I :& L-,,&YI l&k
4 ~ 9d 31. d l '& 31 $9 $l~u;;Jb;' dJ\ 'y bul Jk
;lc &--,A b u l j- &I- Fellow - Subjects
JLr;&J$l @I 6% j Co - Transcendental i S J L &!EL$
.("')'+ ,jYl 'j clr;; 'y 6 &.dl ((LA91
j6,
d l 'Intersubjectivity i;li &I jCk; 3
6- _.
J, ~ivennesso# p~ w ilk ji & d + , ~ l
!Wl a&, ' i J k ~ l>+&a& &dl , d l &; ' J h b y
JLI ?Jb d& L y; J;
4 #
-
.&A 6J c,j;Jl + b ii c-*j Y C I * 2 j Y I I L dl &
,
I
3'
OL
+-
31 4
Y.~i
.>lyYl
b
&I$,
&
y b!;
i
I
6
d
. ~ p y J -$L;?'I
j
*Liill,
9 Jp&
+4
! 1[4
I
8 I.+.sku1 3\ ,IjyI
\
jL;yI
L J U Y I +L Jl ~ r) L
9131 d
.i.L,+dI
jr 4 s i+$ La+
$ L y l .f14
&I
++
&
1 -
oI&l
.+
b f liij~~~
4 2 .J U Y I ,G3 l+-~.
1)b jj?J TJ.4 j
31, ,641 *lib j
J
&!&
Y W I d
i
5, bfbJIJ
;lY, i+~
j, .+j
h
, .Lp+2
+ ld e+> J U Y I
jr
LIL 3'
214 (LJ.UI)
~ J U Y Id+-
bfbJ1
a k u ~A+,
fliJ1
l& j
.J U Y I
i b L y d+Ul
+J,d d w y ,
6q3Yl1
JUYI\&\L
.& jbk ;;? ) 31 &I I+
.uL[ & Y fliJ1 d\ ~ b Y 4
. U y I j dl i.YLri;YI OLLIJ. Jc
d3+l
Y
91
pldl AIJ+
iJUYl +
.&I41
+p$IJ
U;3Y is bJ,+d4
L$IJ &JI
d+uI & y
OL
'Y
fliz &&I
y+l L+?J+,.d
l,l
?I. L JUYI
+d 5
kl,
LWI
LC;;J
91 --
+ j+WI
41
i;YI
i
>
be.
Y j bib L
.rr~
iL'lkll2 31
.UJ .&.kJl
+4
jr
)Lu
dp.+
.&I
&I&!
U Y I i.&L
j,L
%LAY! ?NiJ
G U l 31 * y d I j . 4 Y, cGJu\a-
. & I ~ ~ L ~ & )b
I
J1
j
.0
L+ +A++I
i;j
J&
3dL-
J&
@ Y ij.@b
,.+
&I
9 4 +J
+J h l
&
(\
,
Jlc;
Jtli~4
wu*
La,
e-+!I
fliJ1
*,
p,
UbJ
> J!,
*&
~r
j
.
&
Y
ii'I
dl*
9b
1
2
2ldb
@
'Gyk
fg1 Ju! p q -& &,O* J! L;k, b I4 414 ihi
EL ' j x b y l Jr J,I fL, iJ Lab! $2 jJI i4JI FLJI
a L y I 4+ csgi + 3
+,I ?*-{
ykW dl k& + '&I (J,
dLYI
+!!I,
J! LL Si.
J*,
& {MI y , n
{MI y , n
31 o@Yb Ciui a&,
&IL-\;;Il
a+ln
+J+YI
&
4 ~ l a)&ni dl
>flJl
'
I*
I*,
bul
+I
, '{U d L Y I ay+dl blsyr $ 2
+JUYI
+Ul
,A jJL dJ $1
d l 2 ->L
.+* @!
.+
,
ILa db
2x3
aY
f
jl
'{MI jj L Y l C ~ +
J
3-J*,
9 +dl JUI bli! j L 2 j L y l 4 w$i&\i
+-
.*
b #I
5~ .jb,+dI
J';;G;" (&,JI ,I)
j t 'iC4;
31 adJ+&l
Lui
0 2 ~j
I,& j L Y I 4
1,
9s
&)-G
Y, 'dl; &ILL>
cL-L 4IJ2l J! &4
44-43
.(\")ab&-n
.(\yy)uo2**il
+!
+
b L
at *U
$,
)&I
3jI~
% JUYI
9
.)-
.J+JI 3
at Q
fl&b
dl,
.,'
,A,
29 js Jl &$
6%
4-
'GI;
i;b a.4 Jr
,+&2 x 3
-499
dl
L
+
L??&I,
ipG 6 3
3: '+>dl
LS
a+-
& 'dLY1 2ly LJk
9 I
aYldYI
5i! LLi . L\
Y,
('")~+j
/&I
a+J
2*Jl
5
6
'{WI,
'(~1,
o'J*,
jLYI
tjY
&
oC;*!
9
. +l, + &UlFJl (\ YY)
. \r fl '+J+p>1+.A +j. ~ A J I >J~,II 'J~L
( \ ~ t )
.dl+, &, +-L 9 j K 'b &I 9 jWI +a L
,
,.j,JWYI j -
. 'GL~ -9 A GL~I 2y1J+,
- 'ci;jc +Y, 3 6 - j i l l j L y l 2IJl9 JLYI j$'
jc J U X I LZrJ++lI Lie41 d3.(lw){WI+; a.%.&.
bUl& L, .>+ 41 9 L JLZYI dY &.Ul &$'I
L+ JWYI d6- Y i,&
zdJ+ dl& 3 '5i
VJ+ LJ,> Zl+ JWYI & dl +-
rf 'aQbL12 *b
j L y l jc >&I jc JWYI &J++lI b U I J L I&,
at +. ~;r
JWYIJL+ J, 'J L Y I +L &= ~1% +-
d,
L'J U4 9, .JWYI &= iJ*ill QL
6 4 $5 3 + LA
3 dl I L :JWYI jc gLYI 2lJl JL
.'.'A)L33> J! JWYI >&I +L
'+ a6 L
;l. j LC i.i;L]MI, J5
. j f &-++lI
* # I #
.\ o - \t Lg "
+I ( y j l (\TO)
.Yo0 ~g b i f l U I J + d l U l j aL19 c d ~&
2 .>(\TI)
. Y l ~g ' a Y U Y l j +l;; ( J > L ( \ T V )
- & u l c$(\ TA)
j.
st,
j. L+
is-1,
+.
31,
{WI 4
(4
y+Al
jJa
L
3jg c
45;!
*.
4
&j
1 {LJ
I
' d l 4-
&k, - ULi!,
'dl; f,
j, db, b tk, ;dl
L
+ j. ipW +bJS +y
a k l i +YI
abyL,$.l
+ dl 4
$I
Y 4 '&.dl
4.&
91 i d yJ,
JJI
JC JGXI
&.,li
,+
&In
_Li
.+I
~_)rj) lhodologique
st db L
l+b, +I
&I
d,
i9Ul J% 3
I L
EL
,Lu $c +I
2lJl
rJ, ,j,k
JS,
3
'ilJ*ll
{b dY dii '
JC
&J+&I
~ l j >c-i; @- jI jJL Jjk
c t J L 1
.LkG,
d,-.Jl
.i,
I L JL,
dl5 l i b
~ I J II L J
GUl
.("')ipUj
@I
t~
jA
L-
+
' 3- L Y b1
. &Jl+
U
&pY.
{WI hk:
C
..ilY>
+iG _Li
j,+b
.Lp jlG JS
j vj &
ULY
j 3-4;
JJI
k,
'&G
$LJI
I tliJl
3f 4Y,
e3
fl
J,l;j
A
,5
u
3 3
-
2 .3+J4 rJlh; 3 L ; G j LaJ+& JLJI 91; C+
I L yJ I I , :+a4
'
{b {Wl IL,
3 2 5 9 >+ 4 4 1
s j J. 'ijYl JC lcri ++ Rkflkhie
j b ] l JL di jWI.1 &I Airy j &{LU
~ &S '{Wl
'L+~l,i +-+S :ab+$.l JL, l+li oL;~GYI JJI +>$I
Yff
.A+!
.A+?,
k_rby
({WL ~
>A1
k ~ ~d,
,
4
sul dq"!
1 - -
is!)
Jj 3 - 1 b~i
&&
4. GY &
L
,
.-I
+&I
3 9 Lb
J% 3
cj
$ )W4 cG%
9-
+I
j- ~- 33
a&-&!
kL,
Y r;Y * f ~ ,
~$L* L+-
b
Y,
31
i JUYI 3 L
2,
j, yi
;IJ,
b
41 i>+&Y
c
j+Jl
j
&I
2-G
J+J%
J+
&&
dj~)-)-
e3.l
J$\
b,lW & b
i;
3
at && G2
dkbb
.r
$
a\ 4 .+&I
+ 3 t+JIJ
d+f i&
L++
+GI
I
\A*
&-J L y l
2-4 L\ LJA
+
JG ,+t~ ($3 Y 2 411 p i 6 &+,J!; j;s jnt
A
b & L if.
Ub ,l+G j is,& JljVl, a;J+I!, aK+l
UX;,iJlJ.CL'J;I>p-Ild~yjti~sisi~
@dld@l Gk #, >3 Y c m 41 -k
. m LJ I .+ MI
0 L & Jk! SL; Y iYt a! 0-b ,& L dbp
rllJ4 & 6 ~ 64 ~ ,&4 Y &dlj$I 1-b YJ.GGyI
&.-j e,.~Il Jli, Y ~1 d c;JI j i++
:&I 4 1&G i-d- 3 OL +t dt +t Y ~t 91 $ ;.I
t I .+WI j y ~ >+I j+ ,I e, 4 &~I=.S
&@"+ I d . ;&I CAI o h ;$I rl+ Jsj.
, b bI , .iJJiiLi bLGt &I1 iiPll iJl
p I+ L 4 X ; k @+I rl@I jiiJ LI4-1 -31 p u t 2
. i>-
j eJ+ 3 >jLC . . .I&, b(\tr)Jl&Y~
+ b ' ~ l i+i
j
, Jp!Jl ,
.(\'t'+S\S
:I41 QLi;YI
a-w
- l dt
i,WI
o h ++ ,,
F1;; J;,
>fly*y i,-c , at+I 9, :y J J E>,$l eul$5 dt
. O Y - 0 . cg '&WI FJI ( \ t T )
. O V - O Y cg '&MI FJl ( \ t t )
.*
{MI j eJu J , +
i:
+ k , i ?-.-
&I
*r JIG
is&~~o,+~++!Lr
+
, *-il
** '+JJ
>+l,
iill
~GI&&U%
.J+
syYl pL
+JL
YfV
IL
I
j, '@GIJ+JLYI ~1 q+ b13 91
3
p 6.j" JLSUJ .j+ & Iks* J L Y I j+ JUl
dl + j +I @GYl &MI ,Jj
, .'&..dl &L
GJP $ !W d+ 9 +j
.J L Y I JJ+ dI c 3 r J + ~ I
I I I j Y 'k!MI +I 3 ~ ; .L
.I ~ W ~ ~
JI ej ;ab +J .&k &b ) J3L
drd!
+_ @GYl
iJ+ c443 J+I JJ+ LL
, ~ G IiJ+ J L Y I J+I
J+I; .$+
SJJI j 6 Jj! &I-
. r
02+ -
!
, J L Y I P,lJl
u~ ~ - + G J & J L I C "JI+-J+,~JUX~J
O r
j . 4 . Y A JbI-p, 't, 35;1 &Yl J3-1 4L2-c+L
'4;L.b J! b+ .i41 4+-& r*+4
1 I+
~ L . L . j 9', + '.~J.L G' G~'UUI L-,J++I ~t
&I ,& 4-j $ L Y I @I iiW LJJ+ iULIJ.J"
k 2b 1 .~ J@L k 9r d! dill
9 + .J L Y I
j PlJl i+U j,ii J G Y I df Js j.2 dl
dl &-J L Y I Pyl dt $ df L+& &Jl 3 dp
j,~ t;-? .L,+ ~ Y G Y I OL j iJj& j+
. ( ' t A ) ~ ~ J#d i jI - - I ,&I ah cJ-I
.
uc
- YJ- L & “p (&j- &) &dl o h dl &% dl &.
-
(a)
+.I JI ;+Y\ &J\ ,y y-&..ill ( \ f ~ *tJ&l
) p i JZB 4
i,Lc jlk; j+d,l i+lr & J> + &JI o$ I&
'
. ; ; 10 t, 4;t;k ,jLJ)rl &dl +-2 j.Ll > &I$ a&lr
.+I+ Jl &
Sarter, The problem of Method, P. 153, Passim.
.Vo - Tf / GoYUYI +$ cjjL(\fA)
&-+I ->AL L ~ Y I u i+, i JLI~ ~
a
%
, \~tr
W l 'j +JJU eJ&I ?C.IJ
Ikr sinnhafte Aufbou der sozialen c & b Y I rWI *I p
. \ f?. + iy +, 'L& \fry iy Jf, & 41
welt
J-Jl J44, ;
.Jp, J-i j. Jrp J $A ,l L+y
+
' ,J,+&l dY+ ,lWI j dill > b Y I
YOY
&I i>l> 4 o p L , dkl &
;I&o/h , ,,,dl Ih, @I Ih 4ee4;; dI J,L +-,
.oyL
Ibid., P. 57.
Y 47
I !WI &J3ayJ CLY tLl & Y, ..+W, ;&I3
1 U
2 dl U L &Jl UI
>I :& p d,A fj,
1 I b b &&IJ+
!+ ;$I bh;LI I& 2, &p91y by1
A+ jr dl Jl& k b aw
b&-aLi dl 01 $,I
ddl fi dl &-% 4 4 , -y J$,
MI j @&I' 41~JUI
b 6 p r
+.+, d a k
~t &1& dt 4 Y
df dl> df Cljc jL-1Js &b JUL, .&WI
LpL dl a b d I j ~Lh,dlSubscripts ,aYJ.b f, dlj*
.(\a\).+ y
&+YI !MI J! tflj4 9 +IJI +I kY.
~I;-JY~
df L! # dl ;+.I! +Jl iyJ a b+JI CIP, kl&
. &+YI L H L I kL*r9,.!b2kL L,'&jl&I&L+YI
wy, LJ J& 41 ~s .Q ,
i+ b~~ .dli,
j ;r
-9 y-@dl+ @&I J a L A G
' ,
;
I J y '&a3
r&dl
dl &
j pr ; . d l WLL, ~ Y Y J+ &is, b~b,+
3 dl J& 9& b Y I !WI I L dl 4f O+
.&Jldl&(Jy,y+&&4!, b$d\&d
4 OJJ_~pkj !LrS t141 j; .3 + ~ W ILI,
+jWIj al+13 +I3 &$I J% j3 .
. &,a;4,
Ibid., P. 57. (\"I)
Jb .&, )MI I L 3 A-41, +&I i+ +G y d l
+I J. ,lWl I L (.GI ,I) ab+* ,+$"
, iyb I L1
+Ll,
PP. 58 - 9.
M..
&Si[ fli, Jl +l+YI pl C t j dl +
,
.
1 4-r
i y4 'GL;I
bWI ri dl ,A $1 J: 'l& &.ill &YI bWI JIL.;)
d p I4 Y I Tml il>I ,+I Y LL .l+$1 JJI 21JJI JIj- L Y I 8
l. iiy d
>
, i3>
,I L% +l ,l '4 A&\ 'y '$.ill ddl
31 'bl~a4 '&I;; Institntion LUGCyf ,I '+I 2 c+l;f
Ju, I;.J d l dLdl -LOLL &I . I4
l
.('")cG+!
k .,+I
~
,+ JI
91 - d
d+ JJI ., ~,;L?I +!I 4 ~ L Y I JJ~
e
1A
,H
. 'y # &;p i.! j,: j;L3 ..&I,> +3 &A 'y
.Because motive dyl 212, in - Order - to Motive e,lja V
d&- @ &-Ij
-
&,
.&.ill ddC, d+>
&I
- .Terminus ad Quem
Terminus ad Quo a& &B Nj &
41 &B
3;r;l
-:
A, p U l Jl
Jl,+
'&uJ -
JY
,L
9
1
r?*L- jc ;;
Ie 1 a d& JJI dl Complexes yFy d2,
&dl 'y L
L5L, i J,YI d& ;,&d .dY 21' d& d l
wc i !;I~ t J ~ O Iji.;? (MI ~ U j LL-
I jltll c6;
df &JJ .C J & J i-1L
. . +IS i&lZ &IJp
b~+ r, (bt;c~301LjG Y dy J;I d IL JI
a$, fiA .&> GI; jL! j + d J: 'di &> ,A,
'J-"dt;, 'LY4 ;GI ik; jL kl;;U $1; jLI 3
.I&, '@$I rdIJ9+,l 'NextTirnea~UI;Jl~kb;J~~I
ci,,
J .uilt> 3 j>I;
;I & JSUI d/l dl tjXlI 3 u?J
df d l 3 > >L;I +I 4,~JP, h dp! dl dJ3& 4JWl
YdI &UYI & I b ( j b A .GJ,4 bEl ,I
4 L & p. s u
Ibid., P. 60.
. ' \ O O ' c ~ L S I dY, $ 2l,> d b Y l i;L;YI ikL;YI r;i-Y,
91 ,A Y, L+Y,I, /L!I jlh; j bl ti Y,i. J L JS I+
& ;ji;s 1i1 +
j i &lie- dl
+p &LI & ($1 1, 1dY1 21,~
.Typical Sameness c i J d l
i i U l j +ill Prototype &YI l&i+L;rYI Y G W ,
p, .dI.$l, d U I 6J2l & d l FYI LYb &y $,!' +by\
'991. SUI IU PUI J ~ J I~1 r j y? iil .
9%& >J dfi- .& e+l dl ?+I@I & Jl
i$ ,
U l ,A +&I 2% JU &YI U ! , .&I!I$, 2 l >b,
dr &I '& J! *PG LfJ '4I. lip .2l,'d $1; - d l
'++A &L;43Jull > 2 ~ + CIJI IL dl,
'U>> ldYl 2l,> ,lz LLLl I$, el,> di $1 Sti
-. "07
J
;4
' '+!I,
I
Ibid., PP. 61 - 2.
Ibid., P. 63.
+ fly $1 ldYl (yl,+, 6-41 I L Jc d++- &I
' + ~ L o * t j s ~ ~ d , + ~ ~ ~ ~ u .+GI
~ > L o ,
b6 A$I
' fJl I jlbyl &I> '& & ,l *G, (rdUI d4 ,I
6 b - U pN I &.d d&- ~ J &I
I MI dl J,L~ di,
.p -
b Y I )WI j J Co - Actors jlSJLtll &ldJ . l,
d . GL;,
1 1.b 31 & 291 " > ~ k&I$.,
4 3L; >+ dl JL
. J 9 4 +J di;? 6 3 4
1 ';ELkll ,+ 9 4
r&il 4
iJdl w l & &LA +, 4 $,
ryZ PGIJI pI+l 0.b $l
p+Jl &I JjUI $ + k Y I
/L * OGI ,y &I &%I o b . I& '+ # 'ji '++I
Ibid., PP. 63 - 5 .
+JI Lib, @-I .d ~ = W
j A-
l JUI U l I L J, GL-
.&.dl + U l Id a w l , &Yl (,&> &I aI>lj.
I
b
dr
L
- +JF- "~~bnr
U
&
I
LC + bjr;
Y dp&YI rWLi . .I
j b d b i * p y
31 y y dl
- A (Compatibility & I 1 ,I $141 i J a b -f
+I @- dl a G l y i Y l J, +A UII k 5 ' 1 jjGfi
I
. by j L c.rli Gli-l J, j
i
;
; + .ltJ,
&L* 4 Ljgl diL;JI JAG t
J I &ljaLPLI a h jL: +i
+.!I iul /lr 9,>IJl &+YI /WI y + b Y I rJJI
b- -2 4 ~/b-
b u 4 &,
&u\ b& b-dl
. 3 L Y, b+
-
P. Bandyopadhyay, *One sociology or Many* in socioogical Review, P. 28. ( \ 01)
Rationality in the Social :3 1 9 d Economics j \ 1f t y L 4 d $ (*)
World
Ibid.. P. 67. (I7')
241 2
. a .a,I
9 , + d l JLdYI 2
j Jyp
~ j ra
l w l
h l " 'aYl"i;YI
~
+.
+&
;f. protenstion
: J L+b
j +)p.j,L
+$b
'k&I
'bL$b &Id1
qj;+I+
Jyp
Retention 'l+YIJ
,,dl
3 >a,.&
bL$\
Tension
L-3+,5)
dL
vJtij- ISJ I
Sd w - kl>, & &I dl J$ df Y,
-.
IIII;; LJ, s.
JJ 31; ,r 41
IL 'GLJ.I
31 bJ> WJLIA~
c'j <L\+ uj @ '&, 4
1
.i+ LI+
Nacher- 31+13 6 a y b 1 + d j i - b j #,+dl)
j. 4 ;bll,
41 b A,J Reproduction - Nachbilder ' U\ leben, Reliving
L
I L -1 j Y, i9UiJ1 +
.+L'$ A
, +%I +I
.4;&&L cj6. I;>&b lil +L)l\
j l y l J,L j "&VI
d l jAi+a\~~.jj++,,y~~,
, I a I I j,W,,. eyu t
& * t+ dl &+ Y 2 I Z l j l A,, .&, ps @A d+L)
.4;&b 14 cSyfll
Ibid., P. 680.
Ibid., PP. 684 - 7.
-
CLGYI
B
a,&
.+
. 'y 0% b &-31 +iJ+I 'y j K A,
plfll, Field JU1a&&d& df d , ~G ~ I dJ l
al;'lUl
Y
o
L&
+_I, $5
;
L &
aLWI
iiLbl
aLWI
.&i$
. G ~ J I Icik j
&\dl j G J u \ && bI $dl 2 bK (*)
dj?l &Lid\ &15=211 blG
, 'LJUI, iiAl & iiWl j GI;, tcj&IJ
-j
. Jk 3 b & j I dl & k @I, &JUI Jk 4 441
&-Y [&by( S ~ ! D p4u
dl +!I h &$
I, A5
j
,l
, IL 3,
.d h, *rt; 41 Models +.dL J yj;ll 2lJL
U I JlLLJ y+ &dl &L U l Ab,
&
a
, &d l Jr
& b Y l oUXJli oliXJI, & b Y l s ~ P,J LGrJ .
d& 41 ciLdl l+ -&dl l rUI
l . , l>
pd dl &+Yl aUXJl + Jl d l j ~ ,Il eiJ Y &dl
LI*, LA f r Y .qLi i;. j.J .;CU y j
@..dFYL 4 . & k Y l oLIJdl 'j &PI & 'y *LL
'j J,I* J+ $2 $S dJJdI A 'y tj Jr
. ("r+I 'y b>
YA
&+>.-
jlJkll
I
6 - b
&
9 3
$
+'y
df
@ &I
'y
-~JI
+;
& Y, .dY>,
&i--', %
&
-I
. &- d l
@-
3
("'a*
-
cil&lI
3 ;-s!
dt
games ( d J U l
. . .a
++ .
214
Jj
I
s13YI
k9 6 + p f l # b! JA
-
ei+
L+
3Jk d&
(j.
b?,
+Ja
a l i Constructs i+)
& d&-
. ("'&+YI y
ci u l 2jb.d Jl&.&,
d l j K Ulb L j Y
6-
~~I~
& +Wl 'IE!
o
i b
3
h
ic*
U
&-:b+b
&%I
+I Jld+
6,u.d
i;i; >,
e-d l Transformations ay&I
l LIP1pll $ij
L (4 ,7i&l
y,
e q I
I d tj&
aL
GGL' rIbl
& 6 4 1 Al f,
@ L h
.i+@ ,
$
-LY) Neumann rjIrS; j3r
+UI J+
jI
&dl
+I cc
;: Y,
d
&
I 3JLs
.+
&J
JG
ciLill
Lk,
dJLj
f:WE,
bLw
a%&
&@
b>-41b&
2141 r X U I
i>b3JUI
LJ> &+I,
.*I
pJI
3 &9
L% .--+I
d l dcls)'l
E>> r+- dy
Jl e+;/
&I
k
h
+,+I
J13
b
,JAB
h
&dl +I
r b +-
e*bJ 1
3 L+
--,
dlJ&
@
j[r J j
L.
.,A
4;lyLI
+ a!
SL
b
l+
I-
E
;+
4
,
> &I.;/
-LYI
cUl d r l
'y
f
& ,
JI
, fliJl
pf
+ +
i&Ub
~
I
J
'y
.&I,
OL I
i=;qI aLI,JJl
+
o
&L
JS
h df A
&
,
3 d l L y LPf,
&%
dc;
I
e ~d
42c
, &%I j*
Y I.,A dq + ,+ G~
o
ajjJI
I.- J
?
;,
.j 9 1
+-Ul
'k &
&,dl,
I h
YAY
dt
I+-.*
%J
"LI,
4
'$
4+
-4
I&
iL
j l ~ J&
4 iiWl
b;ii
I
avw~j
.I&
l
g
d l
j. +I
d+
i~l.
sg\& k d \ qh
GJL
1 &Jl
b b
, '&dl
)
.GI41 ,y > j
r+- Y
j-
$3
&> 2y1+I d~ p i t d, i+
c)TJJ,$Yl
.ii4b
+LW
>+
A L, . 4 j~ S Y I IL j5 j t a3, LI,Y,I LI, di;?
'& + pl$l j. ki
L
.u & PI$!
i t g +.A J j
p y l ,y
g ciil4l j
dl GLJI
@lit dl +'
$'1
i+ c i E
A:)
j,+dl j
d l
.~ $ 1 IL, 'GUI
$dl
rlj
.tj **
41 '+yl ciL;II dY dl4
- &p
G\J\iflb.!!
- dJl&JJ
,y dl
& 'b31+ r& cikJI o L c.+ 31 ' J i2 y.31s
3
at eyli . +LJI ~s ILL y~~j+-
k &A.sLk l J jIJJ EiU ctb Li ti$\+!\,
cikJ! L I J 3 3 *-
dl b q \ r, & .bJ23$Y~
>+
$3 dill i t
& +
-q
S k y 1
EikJ!
- $Jz3$Y1
Li$ + dt
&
dill g
41 cikJI y ').k p '*j.f&I
ty.l2,
ciiJl,
cJYl
r1;?1 I L L&
'norm WL.)
+ I ~ J
+ di;?
j
.
41 JUl I.
.y.Lt
+
,k-k
bfl
Jk
..?I
YAY'
&Ul, C U I '& UL &+
I, u iJUI &I
+*ij4 jy+ .QI jG dd rJu ~easure
L I I . +-L;IYI ~,~I.Y;, I j &GI
&I aYl;J.l, d l 3 +, G L J I $L$ >*I >+I
9) JI~VI J jvl J&JI >-lbl~ ' P ~ Y I .QI $ii
Kroeber y L+& Invariant ;+%!I /ljJJ +>lc
p
&+
I, 31 pi . ("I(\ f *) GUI s&jl c;rl>Ja +IJ> J YL
cQi M LJJ+ ilP 41 >- . I;*d
> k Y I j J! cy-
+I 3 eUI @ +-l+YI +I jqql a L l > d l i .&&dl,
+I +--
i+lp9
1 &f j &dl
dIal+L,Jl~
.pi
j + ++I ;lL.+LJ! -1 +I+, JL ji&Cll
set theory k
rS1 L>LJ1 &I C)j a Y C f j '$dl
rJL- @ dl 6 b,J2,.hJkllJ 'Groups L A 1 &&,
iI>gl LJa &+
I, Li' '&&dl J.+ i.J- rjY '$1 &Qd
.('"&I lLCk&;jJ4 &ti+& JI J&YI &Ja3brJl&AI-J
C
i
,i Lc;l '$dl &
, 'y t, '$dl 'y ,J;u pI+l o h L&I
Gti .L&& d,& &iJl &,dl, Js oypb d,c
+& jlkZ +I+! &- > & oypb d$ Fi,.dl
'd-3
&+- Js aflb \;;IS b .Mechanical ki,i,
.sJUl I d J,ab d,>l & .L><>,
i . a j b y l ci,.Al~
& I 9 1 &-'y
pL2 Cili 4 g df & +\+I1 aL+tl 2
+ . q i Cjli
C'I )"
d
dL
,c
ciJ.14
@ ..L, ;'+I
+b . a l > s 3 di J! b,
,+%I &,>l
-
ej+ll I L J . L u d I @I
' d L j 4 l l+J! dl
LjWI, iJ,YI
J_; p b GW(+
,I +19
ab+L.II ,IAL,
4 +>
& L'+
a i U I (wi
+bYI
/ ),!ril
Y
Fluidity
w y
+
Ibid., P. 384.
YhO
Lac. Cit.
j OLc.
& L
i!
, .& i&lj;YI G I L+i91,hll
&-51 t~~ 'JUI h '&I WI
Ibid. (\"I
Ibid,, P. 285. (\A)
Loc.Cit. '
(\f)
- Lk. +L?l abL+lJ &I, &*I & &,I+ J3 Q13$Yl z,f (*),.
.& &y
j t b Y I +, YJk;S,I,! dp '$6,
&-k 'qi ciu .c;l J! Y,I q+ 3 j+ MI +
cik Jl t b y l ,& ,
(t;*rull+4 -: L y) &jUI
.j,& diWI (J+ ,I) ~jdf ++I Ij,s &, ' q b j
1 % & 1 d :GJ &jk J! &jYI r+I
& FYI, '
4 1 ~,YI &lJ! 3 dill c j ~ d b!k c ; b
y &LI&, . M I $s Eil-U &Jjl, G b Y I
$1'
2 ciLdl rll;L &+I &%I & GI'DL >jJL;II ab3j
& 2 I I +y I , I I , 'iy
:JUl +I & i;;L;I rJs
: t&YI eik, +) &X. : &jUI
,& 6 iJk-j
k J * ~ j i Y l 'qi ciu, G) &x. : Q I ~ , S Y I 'L.LI ciu
L l S IiU LJJi U eiLi3 &jiL%
.(")&Ji :b & Y l
rJAS I 0
I
-
L
#
I '+L+YI r+I J
+ - i , * , t ~ ~ l J b 41
~ ~ J K I ~ ~ L jG UI ~+3
L
* ~ Y-$L
qUI i+dI ~ Y + I y JJG dL by j l S I,IY , ' $.!.I\
& &jUI b! > .&b3 e Y ! Jl e2YI WI y
-
LM il41 41-1J+L 31 A+ dm,, .++ Q L ~-
,y, .r;,Ul 2125' l+13,3Yl dl& r J k s k,l,3Yl LI . d I C L + l
L Lji b,l$Y~ & ' L O I ~ I j *-I, ~ + I ~ & Y I 1 6 jji
~ (;.
LO1 I , + U l + b Y I b,lz,pYb G A L , +YI h l 4 l j~ i $
.W u liJwk J $ Y I
Cf. Ibid., PP. 2 - 3.
Ib~d.,PP. 285 - 6 . (Y.1
-I
r 4
&>"I
df
tjt
,4WI
df
lzY i
+
& Firth A>
+.tf
il;;~ .White
h J+
'$L$I
rt) j J& IJ
4 1 4 >#I
O
Y
,
L dl
)
;r
+?
~ - k &b
.i;Ixl
'j4
.
&
?ji
lA
Zpdl
+i +f +I
+>3.;+ j (kj'4IpLJI
yi c i ~2 ~3 j W Typology
&u $15>J+ &.& &,La
i;l-, y W
ii, y-+
&>L;
J%J6 +J&l
J;JJ
& iLiul
LLL;r,l
reenters &Li_Lj
.Ei ~ +
j
LE ~
j
.
a>r/Lj-
L
jLjll
L u r;l
+-dl
;'
ky
dl
&dl
3
LL~+\JIB
o-i*
1 df & Y,
~ $ 'j4
i;Lik p b Genes
'(?Loll cili a&
.(*)LA
i;LLolj runs
5 3
~
o
(SJI
-
J% 3
h
&JJI
tj~h
'5JyrJIJ
U G & &,
l+
bqI
JLJJ
tel&lr
L>AI
>Lj:
-
'4%
0
r-Hj. J h ! i r b Y Y;. k, j tk; & dlS lii tc-Ixn ;t.,-
b
1
, u p ; lp*i;! $ 5 gi cili
rl*ijl &p -rIr L 'J,Ml
J, +
,I+ dr + J +I ~ + ~~ l l ~&t &I j.d ( LI,~
&.&I '491 cijLil& y b y l ci:JW~ J1+1 & !,&I, +l
Jk, Combinations k h l j 2 L bZPb j& 31 c i ~ l
. '"'dL$!' ,y L , iyi ,, *Uu
ill.&
--
#+,
A
(77)
:j\ ~ O flc
Y iy YJ, +' +ill- - 'l+Il 2
A. Kroeber, Anthropology to day. seventh edition (1%5) P. 531.
& &dH9 ?lSJ9> &+ t++YI ,& j a Y
i.+& L &
42# d j l i G; LLCBJli6-iJI A, .&MI d & J I
diSJ .('"I$ + & ii~bp-djWI 1-b j k GGI>YI ik
iJL LYJ +* Ll2 L I j > &S Jj +&I j f &Sd- L%
d,& dl &. &>idl $1' a Y l 4 1 >I& dl * kj
& -t- L ~ i.jjj
,+ Y i.+..tJI ~ V$19
I .&
J r ~ * i L + & ~ & 2 Y l i i ~ Jj&Y &
dk + t-,.+ Y- ~ Y GLLLI u,+ &I,
ilk kf ~r 'u-l j
+ iblj & j+ L dp +-,
. '"j,;l
Durkeim, Les Formes Clkrnentaires de la vie religieuse, P. 573. Quoted in: Ibid.,
/
(Yr)
P. 288.
LOC. Cit. (yt)
~ o c Cit.
. (Yo)
& dl $4 JJ ";Llul>Jk.!I dk3% 4-
Y,
J+~,
3.~1
JUI >+I h &K i i i Y ~ ~ ; I X ~ I iJ& j
.
Realia cs&Gl, iJy & XJdl icl>l]l a b h &, r $$I
I , I I &%I -.,Generalia alzrJl,
tG,Jl j
.
L
'bjI& a L W l 6-b @ a%dl .?I . . .U L
3j 3 b k - jL & & &J
(Y"'&k
-
'tp~L, Y I r~ i+y~~
JL4 & t b Y I +, .(")l+l/$Y~ 'y CP
ak+tl f, /&I 4%++ 'j+ U I$
&dl ( L U I ) L%& ,
bf Ci;l y-t h y 1 !LC db JL.J&, Jf
'&i dl
Ibid., P. 356.
Ibid., P. 2 .
Ibid., P. 362.
Ibid., P. 338.
V X S ~' Q I ~ - Y 2
I is & % ~,+MIB L t
'IY Qlfl+Yl, e J u I +;r4 && iLJI dh 2 LA& ald&
bml ,I jLjll j M I J! d%YI IL FJ
iL
&*r l sw @ + 3 LIJd+L j dl+ IC( . j W I
&LLI j V, .LIJdJ P U I @I
j%l+ j &+L
'L9JJI
iEUI r k l aI~ya;
LA& iLJI alJrP;fJ 3
qf +A .L& b u l dlJ+ 2 fb dl!-& d d $3 +*
blYccu~ ,+
dt A Y ~ $ 1 2 L I ~ >+t bt ci;
,
.kJJ1 LL j native &I
, +,
eJMl 3 -+JLA, a-I
.+
i +J,l 'dkJl, 'ZJI, 'iJ@I >&!I Qly-$91,
A 41 SCJl 3 >IJ + d l L b J l Jr tjll A
+
. ,+Jr,
at G, . i+,i OLL illis ~r I
; , j l y - - Y ~dji . b J d at
.&ly-+Yl >& 4
, bt, +I o L Jr & &at
#
8I
,'i+L+YI ;GI 9 t+JU .&I f, +MI >It+JI
+ 91 dl&$ Y, &I j d b - Luis, ' d L Y & a Y l +I
.i.J&Jl alJWV J b l j dl&$ @ . d . l + .JLf a,l&
;w i+l,Jl al&b l& j eJUI +-&
.(rr)W;I&\ 0 s +I,%\ &I Qly--Yl 'i+L+Yl
elb j
.k:I> dl& L: dK L lib .d%Yl +k , I JYI
.Gfdl& 4, .LSL' efaborations cs\>L,pl 6.2
9
1s +I,YJl L&U 04-d@ 'U ~ JI &~
I, B >AJ
>
+J,I o L .i;U&+WI p l y ! &.I&
j LlclB)f JjLi +MI
.I,Jl b,J,,lr;Yl J.iu,
LsLJJl +y+%I .,Id&, '&I
+M&-~;UI
sk dI (&I3n LJ & 4 oI+ JG { 6iJ1
.+IJ
Jglj *b_f C.J
di . W l , i+,3Y~ &I J1
dl; k a d
rL' & LGJhLLF~
&Il **2 ,7JLi d l $ &sL iiill
+-4 . ~ - dlJlb!
I
-
Boas. Op. cit., PP. 70 - I Quated in Ibid.. PP. 19 20. (rv)
m u a q *sma~ie!sos l o s!sL@uv
.SS1 'd (lS61)12.0~ 'ES .IOA L)q%~odo~y)uv
aql plnr a % e n % q n'ssnaiss ! ~ '3
n:u! pa18110 '161 - 681 'dd ' ( 8 ~ 6 1 )au!- aq)
(A) purr pquo3
prne pnn!q aqj u! uo~~~~!unruma, JO 'm~au~aq.i3 * i a u ! ~ , yq
k, .L dyi 1, L,J 41 by + +I '-,1- #
Co - L - U l d-
&.)hp (zJu\ L L ! e- bj
LG L.+
J-I
L , b
,y
'J+YI
i. 3
+I
-L+I
OWWI y' +*rll
;pU
1
Ail &
a
+J4
. o b - +
existent
&- Y
l' 5,.,+
d
,,;l J& j %Lt reduction + df
i~~ W
-
J+
. > 'kk &dKi L lib 9+L+YI pl@l 3 &+YI
,J 35 dl &i
y >, '?&+dl + J/ & . I d 1
,y 8> &&I OL yi; J/ +L+YI
+I 6- > progection *LJd1, L L ~ ti J+W j ~ t
+~bUL '641 C W $
J >TJ J &+ ~ I J .j931Y L k
ih, 4 e+ (%+I) I+ J+! Q4
I&
!.,:= GJ'
2 3 1 i,2>1 aliu '4+b izUl +3 'ibl, ;J;v
. &,dl1c L ; U
JJ
il ikfir + socialized Gk+l e, plJl
l
.(t')i+l,Nl
@*& i l y J $1 di jrki JI 9 4 &,I$ LS
LEI 'y bi $.I +I,, i l J > sly-I $41 lj, 3, :I+ &>
ki uy 'y b ~uUI. dI+Yl 2 n~ & J>l+lI
'91
a w l j %A L~Lz., U, 91c'~> YY
,JL j dji, I&, 'k & a., I.b+ jrI.Y\ i,b j -I
.+& -. i l l i l l aL%JI, '&b3 #L;U~!
bi JS ;N @+d! c j u I
4
6
&L/ &b A L!
.('")b L&
+ , Semioligical bJtw@
' d& df J1 dq; bJ*,$YLi
1 J 1 1 , 2 .'kp t" a&lr j
.
LY;J,*l & +J' U I 4& a& df U &pf
C-" - L r W + b Y l WIJI L+ 9, '@: & l
i
lU i
i
ll
l lrLJ
rildl +>, (sound ayJl)A,., &+A\ /LYl & -(I
. (OY)(&l) d, Signifying
J &> @-illJ+JI j f & U l & bJ3j$W @I d ~ A Cf
l
f
'ciw ;G J! & J ~ , ~ Y I . c i tv
~ ~
p @!
iQI Lil-, & aiS;s ji;r &.ill @IB jc -IJ
. ( O r ) b P L 3
ilJ+
,$
;bj. 9, L
5 6 - djf
‘dJUl
bkJ3J$w
3 ?f
d l
.klJ+
Loc. Cit.
Ibid., P. 366.
I),>> j?Jl s Y 9 Q e-$Jl [Isl d,& Cra jrj .+I ~ l b J!
,
s&S A
, &, +
I- dl l,rlj L lil u d l l elhlIl aLIJdI
Y + JC WI JLL~
3~ di, .k~~ji;f
43 3 'U@Llj> - 2, 'bj&
dl j;l Y C(J
tyr J= ~ Y JSI +
I- j t cp :++ . j. : - b 1 , ~ 1 9 j ' ~
.(")d& oI++I ~f & ,f- '&I JKA
~ 4 1 &dl
. ~ ~ ~ Y 2I LD j2t dp yl 2 kJ 3-
b W I &?\ iJb4 '+-
Y &.dl +L;rl JiJl Jj La& 3 G j +.
j+l JiJl & 4, 'i,$JI +C]JC(
i &dl JiJJ &\,%I
&. L L U e-j;l dl &I a W l j
.j;A, $ 'innate
hj+I 3lbhL-U d l s13)II &+ + .Wl, I;dl +Yl
ci";k '$LAJflj &t d k & Y d U \ ijpd?, bUI
('")a+, LLyl al;p
i,h.lI ; r L I d L L '#I i
h ,
, '+.dl j r&YI JC CJL;
yl,.
#J,l
i+lJ+!,%I
&%
,I
6 3.0141&I
;
i&
,b~;:
j ++$.I
'p& t,
,l
ylUb
df
+MI
,& liu &J&
0lJ)m;j&,!
6-e y u l 0 1 4 4
ySJL J] ,L2f
&Y + d l
@
-,
j L >L
a)().1.ClloL
i+i
&-.
, &UI
L li! &
df j
..L
+
I,
'&131
.yy J
f,
Jj;d l +I
,@
LJL* &,I+
#, ,&
L f, &f
b
. i # l l L+
df 3 NGUYI &,JY-+Yll j J
b i J u [ >
2.i
d u l
2 l+Y,
L U IA,
yJ .bJ& qk!\
,I)
+ L*Zi
b&>I$
substantive
&,.I
jr t*ll
.
&
LLI
b&
&(lv)
(Ih)
Marx and Engels, German Ideology, Moscow (1964) PP. 36 - 7. ("1
dli b
,:, i k ; u ~G+ 136 Le cru el la cuit. P. 19 %u ,+jl c> (*)
Quated in: H . Nutini, the ldeological Basses of E v i - Strauss's I~&~IL;J
d%j i&AI e a - - 2,
dl - ,;t.rJIJ>Yl o j G f &$
I,
JiYl & V &$
I, db each +J J+- p &Lpyl
u kJ3 iJA'?l yl,hJl LIJ> 3 +JI TUI J+ cktS j
c - 4 1 JI j* dI &iS LLI, .dl> J! ,$@l yl,hJl &
&ddl ;J+!, bi$ul G I rb &. ZJ.&
dI b& Y p .+I$, dl+ & &I3 cdbf Jj j+
U l &;): d l iJbYI, ~ Y ci:JL;il
I a Y k 'j+ i,rl Jb"
,y +j & &U ,e U l s;t;, al+l d-l ,y &II Jl
J I,+ *-b $ i-ul +I +,+ +& dye ci:JL;il
dl ~k3 I-b, +ld-l fbl Jl ekdl >J +-
I .+ UA e'" dl ' W I & j l & Y l +,I ,y,& L( &
. $ - I dJL 31
bGl&.)'l
.(")i>&
+
9 L( ~ & J aI L i U
bL*J [WQ]
a
- j WG,
+
~j JI iwY .jrT + j % , . . ~ l A J ~ Y
d L ; r l CLj -
9 Metmm & w I df 9 Gurvitch [&is)
+i c1, &
(1949) P. 2 , Quated in: I. Morino el al, (ed) the Sociometry Reader. P. IX.
E. Burgess, biometry, VI (1943) P. 223. Quated in: Ibid.. P. IX.
t.
-
(vT)
(vv)
H. Von Weise. Sociometry in France and the United States, PA]
P. 214. Quated in: Ibid. P. IX.
Ibid., P. X. (V')
&
; d l a&Y,.Il j ' ~ J Y 4 ~ + > ~ , - l l @ L dIcI",
+ ';I^z~+,.i iiK j &Wl Jj + L Y l +k &>\
&I +Jl, '+i"y,-Jl ++I :&MI+&I J,4 aL.
.
Y, i
G\~YI h, Psychodrama LIJr,&...!IJ '> U I
UU16j.F, ;&I 3IcUI Glklj &MIjr*JI o h
6 A, .mjqu d~ a1 '++&A, + ~ Y I ,
kii 'iLu ,I &j
-t ;r MI, ++JI 2 +,&I
>GXI j
l
.
9 12111dlj b 31 >jy ddj. --(*I
Experimental Method and science of society. : ?k.S ipk, c&,.JI
Ibid., PP. XXI - X111.
LLL S~2t L
j
*
A,
-
&+I
321,
.
- a 4%
W
j
al;y14
.-;
j ar
;
tjY.9 &1;I,
dsw + l A I
31
LLIliS
+
l j.i?lr &
~ l dj ,,-
C\
& Y,
,+
.-L
;?,ie: d l
ciL;ll j
. ..?, ya ir pt
& SP i.(i%Y~
I
b+
qf &A
3' a L U L
.
,&
i.~b jr
&I>
6
LLISJ;IJ GXJI j
& GliJI d i W l L ~ SCIJ,
Jr
0-L
Ab cJK
,+..dfU1;L'j
AjYI
- r.i;;41
.l+%-%
&.;
& +I
. ( A r ) ~ ~jrr 41
Sociogentic Law
& Y,
~ l d l
jr s j W I
Sublimation .%?I
'kliL
J
aGWI j
.+&I
- &I
.dlk; j l+g d I
j c'b A +!Jil
,+-
,I
3, .+
I.&!\ & d l 4 U I j d L Y I
5 L j y l LL a1.1~1 4
L
+ G Y I 31 i+
G
315
31
'i4+Lii~
AWI
,I>YI
.+$L
.Order ~Uhijr
641
S
J
~ &if, ~
j
.
J
++II
i.1~1~1 t.L.013 &
L ~,s,L+
yi CUhi
irg j
+
;I
i,I
.
~ Yj
21
ay
.
by& dl 1&I;,
j k, ~ MI~ j LCI;
3>li1
j
.
AJY
l Ar L
alS13yl
-&I
,~.va&
&-+,I
19w+,A
.~$++II
Y
,
J,
SI~YI
at: it:
J,
Individualization
I a& JI
lircY~
iyiat
$,
2
'lp~
&
-
r.> 31 1-it: &+ +>ypJ
I
.'-4
!, 4 1 W. @I
'&I ~9&* j . &* 'k j V l & &% .I31
'+. +I'.
- d la U I 'kLP"*j!d, .&J-eCCCiLL'&fj.,&,
L+Y* bliyl 0-L fh$
. $ U l ,+%U jr +WI bliyl J,,
. +J LA j &h3 r X ) U L r j ~ 4+h
I (AJY)23
J1 e- jJl cliG3A U I G%L &- ,d L J + o+ j
u 1 h X I Traumatic L > U l Jy91 & LA) &- .bj,g
>
;%
,1
I a- &I &.A1 j A iql
Ll'+ f VW, .&I
I I L A . cli -b j c%6 JJAI, ,&MI, .>UI Jl
.bI>l ail;u+) d L L q IiL lie )
, .& ayf h+ j
.-
rJ.1 J+
~1 + d p +i$+
j i- LUI
u J r + ~ J Y J+,
3 1-4 L'+ i,,~ J+ jf,
GI j ' &+yI -
, (**)(jLjJI, ;GI O
- -
Ibid., PP. 3 - 5 .
Ibid., P. 7.
adequate G x l l ;&I. tr,dI 4 +d i,;Lilrl Gti
i&rl&l;+ 4, .;&I 3 ;+a i;J+ p+
LC%, . d d &r% 4 4 >JZ df .& Y & .i,;U
. , I .& Y & bi,;Lilrll i&+I& di.5 4
pI$k @Xr J & cj J &.& Y, td%, LA\) j i g W l Ju;,
.("")i+L;rYl, QWl Conserves a l L A 4 , I+& dl
JljYl ?+'?'I a Y G 3 iLL &f j ~ t 4 Y ;
lk
~ ;>
I,+ .&i?~hs - LJ ~ + Y I , $MA[,
,I & ~ s& .~+I+YI
;:s $e~ + YP-
I JL .d++ kt r;,
I)W
Ju14~jLr:
9
k act afMI
~ci: e+Yb
S .A%,
. .jJ d l i J U l
I I . readiness iJ>Ulf, M-Ji4
J k J l jLs'
.("")jWI Ld,& *>,a *-
L dA, +!+'?'I
J! b'.Jr 4 wb L 4 d, . . .&I+!,
31 Jf
J! Einfuhlung iPci 4, .&!+!I 3 6- & SU@
j
. 9+ &I reversal @ -
d
i Zweifuhlung
3 did &j 'JI~JW &&I, Transference &&
.I df
t&M1lJ I JJL;U ihl &?i( 'LtI ' ~ J JsI
+, .cqv)~u~
+I ,I U . Jr, ~J+~LA t p ~ ' 4 ~ ~ 1 ;
d,& dl 3 9J+ &I c w #I +YI 3G
, dl &Ul
.""&I J+l j J U I &&,I &&I
aLL;JI) $ A J AS~ t & U ) &I Counter Part + ! I L!
36- + L L 0bU1, JIj Y I +- LYLI .LA(*Wele
kSjUI d+\, &l+!, b a b u l JJG, c d U I &k;ll
~y +Ul <JI 56- 44, .tLL;JI, J dU;_(
6 9 1ch,?~J
'Faith healing 3 k Y l i > h
% &.b &..&I &
, @I
>+
w2r4LUVI d~ ,-YI ++ A +I
&Ij .. .
ijJIJ "34-1 Jt. Z- L- d l pI&lI -4 jyhI iiwI
1 I 2j I + & b 4 j . j 4Ef elb i,li cils
J j . C. o-LI6Jl i;u. Jj j*! -2 ++)'I
s
&A
~ L l ~ d l 'y d f l # & j J I 4911 &u 'y 641 'y $2
b i d . , P. 17. 0 y,
b i d . , P. 53.
Y YY
: u,! Jyf2% +
,I @ $,.A1 - &I y.p;ll 'ju3
c*y&) -:
J &- J ,
3 GJJ+I,f&
t LA1crj+li
L.;
I+
,.
J
2 4
[SIJ~),
pll Y
3 GJ+ 2
-
bJJ-dl
.b;.
; @J 4iy&1 j uisd iki: jr: L a! +
bj ti, bj~pi! $ 49 k! ,1- cwIj
j +I$\ 6-b &+y&I a*, -LkJ aaL&J8 $&
,('")$LlIJ 'd&I, 'pLLI?) '{WI >jy bUlj
707 - 8.
Quated in Ibid., P. 709. (fA)
a w l y JAk k%&l Jjj ,4f .;
j ;
!I&+,
c d U k, - J u l IL &, .>ljYI a- +by1
?J.G dr Qi;;!Y ~ L Y bI ~. - , I L Y L ~ ' X+,L-+I
I 2 L + j. ,441 J u I I L J! i s p Y ~ a Y u l
J, > I a l l , .iiiY q L l pL
++y&l Lf . L J J I I J,+ icirl b l i l @$,+.+I
. q u l e641 & &-A!alb\fly &kJ fe
bL >lj?! 9 ++y&\
c>Gl~ blfly GF d l +,$ >fJ
Jt ;
;!awl J j jiil, ,++&I yl,b +w +:
Ibid.. PP. 724 - 5 .
(ff)
. eb,.Il
+.& i &
, j r*iill *ls)II JLbk & d*. Ji
j
+ M LO vCY L+U AjYl 'IL jwYI jbY
J+YI >
A
,- a8&D +-'
41 ~ I S +? ~ j - +I
I- ~
L- d l )1J!, .i.bwI &&L &)dl (*)e
j$l jf distribution
O $ Jd
I d l *ls)I! jbi s k >I)~I d k b l dbQjY1 -.
i.L;lkci aY.$AI L4Jk d l *ljJI j$ j f JG &g
I b 5 , 1 G j I $CJ .+&
a 4, .('"'l,d d j l l ;+dl p,ljJI 'y ikjL GyU
w l 0 L
+ I 1 6- +31
-+u k;ll Gi .;lr
~ o ccit.
. (\v
'.+ jilj, .13y1
g, Jr
bb
Js&
,&
o
+L
J1
h
LrX.
';I~~I
F*
G
ySlZ Y ir a*
>l)Yl d
-J
> l j Y l + jL>I J% ,
L K &-d,
Ibid.. PP. 20
&& J! d+
Jtti
&dl
Ibid.. P. 730.
L I , > ~ I ji
I!+
= >l&
A,
j
&UL
L
3
;i
p 3i41s c r . ~. sc;
~ ~ r ~+IL
db a k l
&-dl i G I hi jl
~ 3 ~,+dl
>
2 ++I3
41
i
I&,
4 &I ;J.
2
w3k 2
6 dp i.lb13yl
+ u*;;; &-dlYb,I.
A,
-
rijc
(*)LIj>@I
I.
j>f
&
bYI
L>,I+,JI
&"A
ui
s
bi, $9-1;.
-f_,
dl JIJ>YI $i &
>I>>
"- y 4
.a29,
dl+ J! i W j
I
1r;llr+y.i .&dl Jr
.+!+!I L
I L L , ,lpL; J,L JI G Y ! ,
i+&;kL- Jl 314 L.+ dIS rljr?U lS& JlL GLSf .GJl+I
> @WI Jd
ik;
3 Jl t~i:
&L JI
JI,l+.i
j ilaYI
L
Gf ' d,+Yl
Jd dl d-s;j
GIfl'?
.L,y s& Y
a &+I
6
.sf_,
I
+%
;A
+>y+
,
.i d l +I
j
,+Jl
(y >J
>+
ub (\.r),i>Jq~,
>Ij
I
~ I ~k
+&YI
y;
4j
y ~ 4 ,+.~LI,
+
>l)Yl by> 4ui
l j WUI
&Sill
,l>Yl
>/ ~
LI,J&I
y l + U L aJ+lIl
~kpr,
Y
L 3 y oJbj
CiiIJl
&
'j
>ljYl
.;&I,
(\*V
(*)
j
L I
.a d9 3- JI . G,L\ + 3 d+yl +,Ul =
~ <- ~ ~ h i ! , ~ ~ l r : ~ ~ , t ~ l ~
.~ I J >
;?. wl LIJdI 'bJ/iiJ flJ : dJ1i
t * \ - 1 . . / bi2;L.
Ibid., PP. 21 - 2. (\ f )
~1>+1, elJbl ? XJuI & & LIJd
dl+j. Jl+ $+A '4; $ L lip .&I +
f1Yw9-' I l+A GI, fyJ Ja w l &+J
' .GL;YI OLWI
+&?I ~ I ~ JI~ ,+ Yj . i jI~ . ijyJ f~ LL+Ui ~9 ,+
aIJul f 1
4, . b u I .by w l J
>J5
j C jJI . a L W $31 t+l l+..o2 +L;rYI
9 1 j. b 1 ~ 1 &IJdl9 (''O)d$ -K is
>jU >J-G jc C S L U I Cy,I o L &
j .+&YI,
db., isolate J p l I 241 4L.p 6 & klb i>bU dl
l l k &%a
id1abL+I d
i 1a w l o h Cr;b JL star (@I)
J& &dl community &I @I & rJ1 ++I
.++YI +I a\l3 i
s,&
+ j.
,i ui,,21
*;s jt I
,
& Y, &I ;
,i,
j ~ U 4I . 5 uu2 c,&~
zjd l /&I dlr t b l +j O+ dL;YI, L,+A., ,&
41 ji ,+ .
&p ii?-+ - 4 6 r+- .", 60,~,>i
*24
1& L J L W I , dL;)'l dyJ+ IJIj b t b Y l ,
jLC
&>& [, &L$l, id1 '& & ~ 4F .c~LiLI
iy VJ, r &dl +JI &I L\ '++I aLUl bJJl
+
.o
u ++I j Lu LIJu dji ( > l j Y ~ LI,*II ;.Lc+J
$k!d i i J k LUI & &$ ($dl ($iydI &I & &b
+, ',(+% -S,L -&LB dj+. LI* &-La J
Y, .@I c ~ j -
i y~ > F A & *&GIj- j. ~ s
&Id' j
.di"", jL;y &Jl y-dji &+I izu
,I (91+ d l aLUI j
.ic*, 3f ab+ & A+ jf
p L.+; J= i u jji q~ ~1 - 4 4 1
G, ( G&L &MI k w . U-A, -A - (&MI L ~ D
4, '&!&I ;p k k &f 'N+B d;Y als;.lul k*,
- - -
Y'Y' f
& :+j ( \ f Y f ) bFWJ ,& Ljf '>A3c ~ x ( \ \ Y )
.fV
G . Gurvitch, Op. Cit., P. 8. (\\f)
Ibid.. PP. 246 - 7. (\ \ f )
Ibid., P. 268. (\ \el
C. U v i - Strauss, Structural Anthropology, P. 290. (\\I)
'y &-+ ?,+ jr & Ji u & d j l 1 aL&+ll 0i.h at ~1
j k Y I Jl > W l + L, . F Y I d y j ,J%YI
6-141 a-\ +Iy 'y ti 9 El aldl
'y
-, +I ?$ j j +%I ,I +%I i.5 Jl
L a j J~~
6 1J1 t i l i J J ~ 1k-41 hliL1I JJj .-&>I
- 3 . 2 ~ ~ jJI i;CJldI >LyyI Jj j-i! &a-2 jr
.<. ; .<. ;
+$ fb yT jCbi
! 4 ybi$Y!
. - j + bf!3y&!J
4 Y bdkY!pf j i h l j isgJ
c--~j>
'y A
,, .++yyJl 0LUI 'y $34 i;LYI +
, +I*
Lb sWLt. JV! Jj b+y&I + dUI ~ Y JJdI I
I L vj Ulb validity 4-L,uJ &&I JL;iYI reliability a&JL
#I Li, .("")cj + A3JI +-i t >L;iYI
C J L I ~ J Jil
Ii 31 b b j ++y+-1l d&lI & dAI
w, 6 s && Jl u- &+IJ
.&z;t
>;?ir &+ jJI AWl JI I L . ~ J ~ , 4jJJn 6 ~ 2
L+Lj iJL ++ aYJk &&
, +&.I1 &C.+
3 &%JI &I$! ili j- d l b ~@W& l
j U B , a w l , +&.I1 ;r k34
LlJd LA& $L, ;r 'y &, +;sypIl &dl j t
Lli+ f9 $ q l &k L.J &/=YI ab%!I
>> ,I LJ b u abw
a L I J J J l jr b ,+&b i&G9?&> &Ip 'y &
+ 4 W I
&I +J
l&l% &, * IL JL Jl '&I, .dl ad 3
rii' ai '& Y ;
, &,li & +
I- af, 'l+-+
al,2f, ~4
@ dI , +>LA1+.>LJl (Li-l>y- LZj Jl, I+,+ +I
r-I +&A,k,+ d ~&i ~J+JI jL'b Lp
.+.I ;EY i+s ,i GF- +JI &-'AX-~YII-L. (cp,i
f& - j. & us +,I @- b -+G e-3 -9,
~~ & ldy b l i b .+ &
lj% cj391 d-I p 1% ‘a13391j
b i d . . P. 54. ('1
Mux. A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, P. 22. (")
V. Afanasyev, Marxist philosophy, P. 325.
3I Ui l+! $LA
&s ~~J,JID ?l+L ~qLa,
Order fWl >+ @ d J1yii J , 2IJl ;&+ j i l l *$I
$I;-?\ &dl Q Y L l a & G+dl J1 6 + u \
;I'J+\> -IJ\ 2 u
-
1 +I 1.b $4 4 $,
Ibid., P. 174.
Yoh
I+ 'u & LLLII IL j &L ~ _ c k ;Y,
36 ~ $ 1 ~1 L>Y p- . ~ J IJ~ e> j. ,Lt: L ~KLL
Y, +ri
U Y yf i b u l J1 3931 3f '+j Y ~ b + J l
bA& L W a 4 k y I 3t o& *-& b&,*
Y, . u u l ,+ 2,~- j $1
-
b& Y LIjJI i d i .J L.
J: 'yi & 'jJ $j Y relativism Lj; +f I L j. + - #
31 & Y &A
,. JS 3f Jp;relationism i&b is> &G,., of &
SJ$I L ;
I,,& 4;f $1 '+A 2% A
, & $1
i l i ; L I unprespectivistic LJ+NI QjYl. &Yl $4
&Yl $I I L &l + ~,
'hU +Id1 +I (y
Ibid., P . 24.
Ibid., P. 238
Y ilul e L jJRoundabout jb +, yj & 91 @$J Y
--4'y&,& & y;, ',yP,& & AJ>l Ji L c+.! dl
.AIJayl 2 &&I &+YI Q j &$I .'I+ 3
+
,I elr: ir;J formula iip r@ Y 3 1 J& 2 54 j? YJ
aIjk;YI .LA A+ yli J M Y , '+Yl J1 LIJI
@ LA$! 1-b & Jb 3, .&&I tJ&l
& XJAl W I &/kJJ
.. ~ J ~ A I > J - ~
A I&, .('')AI?lljSr l k l w dl I
;. dlJ
A- chu
J5 6 2 6dl detached 3pAI J,hl. &j13 ; . r ~++$I &d3f
2 ~ j3 .4
- 19 ';kj vbL JIy+& d l #I I L dl 9
llb 'Ul$ j@l 9 1 , t@$J j 3.91 $YI & i;elkr +-
'&I *I (4 '+I 'y 3ffi1 j L-
aLb 9- dK
y
J. d d u ; > ~ >GYP
dr
3 J
~
I
;I,.
I
,+, ,
C-.+Y~
f I
,..I= A,
t-.+YI ,..I=
631 &I JMI cJL; 'y 'Y~I;
j
.I ~ J&I J! +b j
iJ3& dl Y && && t b Y I .++$I
b j b ; - iYt ++$I j
. O ~ J ,
.,+dl, -41 j +-
IJ >I &I, &-41; p
?>3 L& ~ $ 1 + J l jLYl, ;ILL1 +-&yl &+Li
G U I $I+!l &-. ,WY!, L U l a l J j j Ili;YI 3 +UI
d U I UL\ I+=.+ &k -.I3+\ +I tL d 2
2 W I d$&>l>l GYP @j b ~ ,.@I
@' + $,;I
-
c+J&JI +,$!I +)dl j dJ+ Y qJ&
,, L;zlbi>l
JI +*LI aIj&l iJ e-b Onhodox qpYI GjUI
@I 3 Li& d i l l arJ.kll & W I F L 1 '& 4 "ii
dl ~j-Iljc 3 j jr i.IJdL d J b oJ GJJI d L \ > I
j State Socialism +dl iJI$l e,. u ~ j
I +*Ll q&f>l
+&YI OI,&I j
. is 3f N+~;LI,UI IL 6 8 L
.\, jj
d
&
l.- @I I L j
,
& j -ii +UI, +-.+Yl,
GltlI ~ $ 1 +l+ 3j kJuX;II, +I -.
ju .
uJW is;-$9 LrJ.klI
e .UI ' j &I - - S-JI + +- U
,;I ,LJI IL &
,GYI jg; J1 t?ik; ,lb! j+dl aliJl cJ aI L;j i b
+I J! tj.~ 1 i++L J ~ J ~
IJ 3 X ; 'aLJdlJ
r'sk;3
4 6~ i j ~ J + L +I$ J%4 +I wi, . JJKYI
*A i G 4 l Ll;q~ -: b & l U b - 631
o ~ L i iy
',SUB L i,~eyT A &,J~X;II-&I +I dl IL
&U +Jl +dl d j b b L Jl 9
1ij &L NQI
&$I k3> Jj IL ~1
A, .+.I1
p I I CJG +
.+I J A ~ W t b Y 1 (L bLJ! j Lp+, iL'lbll +lj#
i&l+Yl c
.$ b lil )'$ d1 s$ Js d t p Y l dt ,+,
+kJl j iJSWl -JY-4fll I+!,J,L L G Y L I +lj&I
& 6- 4L1jl ak+ll j I L LJ* Y, .a1 '+dl
t b e~
L+ ilJJl ~ I + I &A
j L1'-
?-I&4 i-
df b +bJ & J l i j y ! , JkJL r'p\
Ck!\
Lcommunicative ( M I ) ?-I&! LJL & instrumentalist (r&JI,
j $1 &12 b-L&.iil
a%!Jl J+ 2 +-
?-I& L J b
kJfll iJ*ij
. ;;..I#, .&JI?-I&l, $1 p Y L-Lr
al,3k rJiLL I+p 'a%Al ')A -I+\ & *I
aw4 ++I aklill, JLJI & U I p L Y -J+ *Is,
3&% r+Jdw13
s g l j l b l &I> CJ~UI,$q1
c ~jrii4;14j
~ L q ~ ji . ~j 21~4
j ~. II L s J I L.~6ir1
C J & GL&& Y d,JI i$l$l -12 a
l, .d,JI GIs1 4
b L j, . ( \ q ) + J ~ t j -+
~ JI >&,I 4 4 1 idl; & Y I+! .
+k;T-YI 4 & +WI &ljAl3 b Y I dp cJ&I
rJ *, -Js"ll t b Y I .p j.$i GY jlr d$& dt ,+ Y
d j j , b vtd3Y&
~ s " l ltk;T-Yl fb jl> 9 1-b~ Sjb~
f, LL&\ b d & . . .-? f 3 k 3 $1 ,!>f &*
G&
.(Te)aiqSL +fl, LL+ +fl & L a & ! +I 2.k
H. Dreitzel, (editor). Recent sociology, On the Social Basis of politics, PP. XI11 ( \ f ) -
0 XVI.
Ibid.. P. XI.
Ibid.. P. XIV. (7')
N. Birnbaum, *Crisis in Marxit sociologym in Dreitzel (ed) 0p.Cit. P. 13. (77)
Ibid.. P. 14. (7T)
$1, ,l+YI j $A!, +I+Y\ ~ l fA
; &I + b Y I pl_).kjl
LJLu;t & dJ; &I t$.qaL;U;rl >A,' L S , L ~ ~ Y I
6 '
$'1 aL+l
Cit.
~oc. (yf
- XV ...
Dreitzel, Op. Cit. PP. XV (yo)
jjf j&jL LIPrJJ-+> . JJYI 341JI +i
j .lui 31 L,A st ;
,
h&Y[ IL + L t 2 ~ 3 41 1 Y OI&
i~~ j J~~
.4J=73-J.d&>,+ ct-
& JI& l r - Y ~ .L -\ii .I+ t b ~iljs
~ k,
C&
&dl &31
cdL,k~ J+- I$
J L ~ ew s+, ' 9L ~ Y+JrI*ti
. (~~'Bauman
&I d $ . ~ j u-
Ibid , P. XI.
Quoted in: J . Williams, Op. Cit. P. 8. (yV)
LOC. Cit. (YA)
P.Bandyopadhyay, one sociology or Man!., Some Issues in Radical Sociology ( Y f )
in Sociological Review, Vol. 19, No. 1 (1971) P. 7.
4 dl-p
1 a&$ dl uUl OL .4Lf b bd l I L
L+ Ld d IJJJI .IJ3 ;fej .wL, i+ d$- L i>lc
[bid., P. 9.
aLbYI,
k
Attitudes
d3
-
6hlIj J$
+4
abgl IIb & .i+
'+aliJ
1 -
'y b?j f& J! 'ah+I
~2 .LJldIL J U I IJJl ,1$
JlJl
ipL;
,y L+Yl
+, J! 3+UI 22 Js
'y
b-
i;L+
- - dJVlah-I
dI,d a$ d I 2 L L l 3, 61-, aLj!+l) i-Li
j,&I Jj bj* d l & '+dl dL, j PI 31
.(")fWI JlizYl ali &+YI +.-UI
Luis a.
J! 6- b k jc iu.Ltll a l 2 b y l &dl &I
p .+
d. j-j y; & d k @ljs;l, QI_2rll jc
&dl *I & &i!I &$I + 'j LA1 @I &L jc L-f
!+*I. & Ls, &l5I +I
+ bj Lui a& GAI + M Y
ilia .("'+j@YI Jl t;;'
r J.p J.5 $A
#
+, 6 iiYJL,
c4;,iru. Y L
, 4;+ilu. L & r+l u.2 Y &Ul a l 2 l i 3 l
rJbiz JA p 6 , .('")~h+Cs; jc U ,
l;r dis, &
& alpy GpLl $A J.&l dY GpLl j bl+ &* & elj Y
('A)>+ Cj>b _y;
--
t u l dl 'flbliJl &,MI aL\+Y\,
~ j l i l l.&ID -+JIJ- &+L. IL, . a 1 43 1
1 4 1 f .(")&I &dl j self - healing
1 b . Ue'liJL Cl$Yll 2fi ibL, Y &by!
+I A- - stJ".JWl y ;rl t,-;.L' j 4pfl
1 a L.M ++JIB +L+- jr k..+Y &&YI
L I J ~ 9' I L 3 d l & yYl JS jr J-yl
'd~$
+I, +
' +I l,+ ' j U l ;2,u JS;- I& '+l+l u
& C.x J ti,bkj + ~ Y u , 'JS C . 2 ; a+Jlu &bYl
0 I I , 'y I I .(f')j%YI
b L* '+ d1 @I 'y dp Lui 'y p j l &, .*I;
TVT
&L & u I UJWLB
cy U G p j tvl+b~JI* &,
b J 'aG,.lY.+YL ;l
i-@ I.J+, XL
& ~ &
f $, abp.'b 3p;! approach adb~
&Lr,.pd j io,c;JI l d . .$1 L&a w3; A
, dli .(*)+
4 i.Ci.b, . U- - I d
irkj ij$..iLLLIpi
'Or+ l ab3c;L.$S b3ilj
b u .&XL;@ f Y I I p 6-
c*, %
,YI j b~ ilb +L ' ~ L A A @UI
L bJk
,pJ L-+ JYLYI k b Y dill non - sequitur ( ~ J J I
51 '+li>l, +A 3, &+I &I j .ii~;l~
~ L J I
/%YI 3,L;JL 4 & dj jl
j U l LL2 .(ff)LSd\
akp.'?,(alLh=YI)2 l d l & GWI abAAI jl? U I j
.
&+f b
$
,
+Li
4
L 9 IL,
&
1 a L d l &! df
'+ill
&&-
&UI &'C+
+ 9
&
/j;
Y,
, realism ai,jlJl B
i
i;J" &>I c-13L ++Il, W %aLClil4 e+4
ikL ,3* U>l Iil 91 &I ap *u 91 l#5lJ3l +-
dl,Yl Y,
'al>Lkl ,I eL$ + A Y I 4 L JlLJ &
, +I p l S L& &
'p+
JJL-
4
t,
j.
2~
Y
4 3 4 4 & i i k d & + $ .~+ p L + y + p
J $ul+dl ; P ~ ~ ~ + C J L
brc
Y J-4
Y, .+I+
U
441b , ; ~-I
IL J+ Y
b >
'w d+I
b,~+.
& J ~ Y ?JJYI
, ab,J3+YI,
,
JI J$ 1 ~ 9.,LLjI
o u AIL.! ; ;a
b+.
&;. 4 4 1 J>,
j
I eb
>
e4J-b
9,
j
>,>
~frp, yjjL j @I
c~+c-CrldS, '+,J3+Yl
.;tiwl OLdl>Yl b b
alJ&l
h
99 4 e p " ~ '
J. ijLiy1 C,ul qw i64q 91 di a&. 9
e+l
, .&.LlI +dl
&G
C
'y LA
L
&-J3+YI
+-NC,$,*,
Y J , L~ J 41 r
L at I
a U I
L
dt IL. .LA
4 U l i, &
Yj
~ .
p.
-
f
JAl+
LG L&
$,
,I
&
,
bjlp
t$
Y
~
r-
&1, i -,J34t
Jk; dl
I@
J
is+
b
1
Gb iLJ
J
~;LAYI
.+ t r&ll
&&wqv $ I
&+
IL
~
PI J+
'y
+W
!,..LA+
1
241 b,+
*-
u
ci"ci",
'+I
J!
j .
. $1,
f, ihli
d
ar ;j,.&,~~+t
61-
b b.U
j d+s>I
.iiL~llal,bJI~~l
Y $dl +I
fi-$dl +I
-
a
LLj
f
+A
~
+
-jY.+~
>,JI
$
at
@Ldl>I
U>l+ 5
&
441 GXJk
Y iLi
J
i;lb
is+
J ~
'$1 +
+
,,I +LJl flu1 aLWI 2-d &A $31,
'i & I +JwIJ eg1 jjQ d l (Conceptual i r L . 4 4 iiL;LI
&2 el.iJ1 j?! + 8259 C-b Li> +.+ df &
. d.51
iiL;II eLJ1 Jl i 4 4 l *;I&I .&I
j +, j?r-9,
+ d l pLJI & "51 k,l a G l j i l :i! $,flLi . ( O T ) ~
YAA
i;kl.>*JI p a l l A@ &L ~ L l j S yol h d& A\ & &.A\
+Jm 4 $41 c++i .(ov)i&L~ $LJL GI;& ,&
oh, 'l,zLL Jr 'w +Al iC;E U theorem ti;LflI \, Lb3
Y JwY &+! -191 U AA @ akA1
2 'e
& bju $41 4, &J &!I il?ijl fg1 i)$
fL, .b>
j J1 blk;i d\ Jr $3 'i&dl $41 @E
01bI'- uJ@ @- & Y *&J .a&
ZJlhoJ & L v l 3141 $ J! C5i>L 35 JI 01l.j & @I
&&A 4 1 L Y l +j d f e .+I & k%lL
'& Y, I I u @ I , N
;i. l aL4Yl
.i+ +I 3 3 U U X Jb J i Y '+I r g 2LJI pi
4, a L % >&k 6LJl @ j
. - 2 $jplI,
&!I -
'+I G.d i l l ++I ;I+ jC CUS (4-9 .+I &."&I1
b> JJub LIJ*ll ~ 9 ibUI
9 &&
.IJr j
& ++I r+2
,1 , . + J L L ; ~J+- F '$9 yS-j YJ .'#Lo; j
.
( O A ) W @L-F~&="$AI
'
--
OJ+ j A+ L -J j
+MI $, .qL;y\ f+l 4 +b i&Jl +I .fL, j
&$.dl i.~ + j g 9 Ul +I
>IJL 6LJ >IJYI,
+I Ld L9 LJJI )lC u A- JiJ &dl l r U l ~+i
b lil b +9 &S d b Y l + j L J I ~ Y jJQ- I +&
&3 .+
i j I d .yi i 2 4 + dj4
L+i . + J, 3k;l A>I+I >LA j aIj...dI
dls L lip ,+i + & q L y l ?+I j +I d&- dt
& cJI? i;" d! &GI;-, ij?s a l b , d&& 4 1 , -41
g 4 - k $521 L-
f
& d l 0 I b J l OL-. +$I. 3+
aI& 1;l~4L.p Permutation and selection u&I,d~, &->vlr 3
. &-I$! 2 s ,&. i+Js &
I
'41 2 2 1 Ul +L+YIJ i,;LYl plJdl eLb L[i
U S . i & U I I+Ib, % LILi &I iL/kll
novelty i&I
oIj b ibUl C S I ~ J h
I j . dj dl L l 3 wj
~L,>UI ++ LJLYI AIi L JJ, .k ,
,
.&$YI l&lJ 6 simulation ilSLxllj theory of Games
i+LL .qLy iJl,Yl, +.&I '$ >,a1 dQ.4 p
' dt $c3
$1 t, d L y l dt j L+Jl -1 p +l+Yl, +LYI
41 Js .A*.'
j dl +>A\irIJyIJ .-I o L ..
j ;r
; Ui &-dt &-&I
k I L il-*Id1 *I t, GIJI
'LZ6 1 ' '03 "1IFxR
a u yo^ maN 'sqsbqd wapoty JO 3pg a q l "d 'ueur%pua- L
' u e p ~ 3 aqa
e ~ 'A 'N ' w n a
-!s@!mall8 Jo s ~ a l q 8 J d~!qdosol!qd (JoJW) 'aqooJqL8JSl - 9
'tqau! a ~ n a p "f s 'puaa - 5
'ZP61 'SU0S PW
a%pavox :uopug ' a a n a ! ~JO uo!83nnd @psaqJ "f ' p u a a - p
'0561 ' b
-911 ueq.~aurvmaN *n!a)sqa 'la pus asJaa!un a q l 'naurea - E
( 1 ~ 6 1 )I 'ON '61 'PA'ka!aali
p$kqo!wg u! c c d u e ~10 d%o~o!msauon "d .AeqpedoApnea - z
LP6 1 'anb!rldoso~!rldarlerq!?
:sped 'anbgguaps q~dsa,? ap uogeauog t q ' . D 'prelq3ea - 1
8 - Bronowski, J. and Mazlish, B., The Western Intellectual Tradi-
tion, Pelican Book, 1970.
9 - Bronowski, J., The Common. Sense of Science, Penguin Books,
1960.
10 - Leon Brarnson, Political context of sociolgy, princeton, prince-
ton University press, 1961.
11 - Brown, and Ghiselli, Scientific Method in Psychology New
York, McGraw - Hill, 1955.
12 - Cassirer, E., An Essay on man, New York: Doubleday Anchor
Books, 1953.
13 -.Chinoy, E., Society, An Introduction to sociology, New York
Random House, 1967.
14 - Maurict Cornforth The Open philosophy and the Open Society,
London: Lawrence and Wishart, 1968.
15 - Moris R. Cohen and Ernest Nagel, An Introduction to Logic
and scientific Method, U. S. A. Harourt. Brace and Company,
1934.
16 - James Conant, Science and Common Sense, New Haven, Yale
University Press, 1961.
17 - Davidson, R: , (ed) The search for Meaning in life, Readings in
Philosophy of Science, New York; Halt Rinehart, 1962.
18 - Hans Peter Dreitzel (editor) Recent sociology, Macmillan Com-
pany, London, 1969.
-
19 - Dewey John, Re construction in philosophy a Mentor Books,
The New American, New York, 1954.
20 - Durkheim, Emile, Les Rtgles de La Mathod sociologique Paris:
LibrairielFtlin Alcan Sixieme tdition, 1912.
21 - Durkheim, Sociology and philosophy, Trans. by D. F. Pocock,
Illinois U. S. A., The Free Press, 1953.
22 - Diesing, P. <<Objectivismversus subjectivism,, in philosophy of
science, Vol. 33, No. 21 - 2., 1966.
23 - Farber, M. <<Towarda Naturalistic philosophy of Experience,, in
Diogenes, 1967, KO. 60.
24 - Farrington, B., Greek science, Vol, 2 Penguin books, 1944.
25 - Fenton, F., The -Myth of Subjectivism, a special Method in
sociology, in The sociological reiew Vol. 16. NO. 3, 1968.
26 - Gibson, Q., The logic of social Enquiry. London, Routlege and
Kegan Paul, 1960.
27 - Llewellyn Gross (editor) Symposium on sociologicalTheory.
N. Y.: Row, Peterson and Company, 1959.
28 - Gurvitch, G., La Vacation actuelle de la sociologie, Paris,
P. U. F., 1950.
29 - Homans, G., The Nature of Social science, New York: Har-
court, Brace and world, 1967.
30 - Hutcheon, P., Objectivity and the problem of sociology in sociol-
ogy and social Research, Vol. 45, No. 2, 1970.
31 - husserl, Edmond, Ideas, General Introduction to pure
Phnomenology, Trans. by: W. R. Boyce Gibson London George
Allen and Unwin Ltd.
32 - Hull, L. W. History and Philosophy of science, London Long-
mans, 1959.
33 - Hodges, H., Wilhelm Dilthey An Inroduction, Roul, London,
1944.
34 - Jeans, J., Physics and philosophy, cambridge University Press,
1948.
35 - Jeffreys, H., Scientific Method and Philosophy of science in Sci-
ence News, No. 3. 1947.
36 - Kroeber, A., (ed) Anthropology Today, The University of Chi-
cago press, 1965.
37 - LCvi - Strauss. C., Criteres Scientifiques dans les discipines
sociales et ccHumaines* in Alethia, No. 4, 1966.
38 - LCvi - Strauss, C., Language and the Analysis of social Laws in
American Anthrophologist, Vol. 53 No. 2, 1951.
39 - U v i - Strauss, C., Structural Anthropology, penguin Universi-
ty Books, 1972.
-
40 - Lenin, V., Matherialism and Empirio criticism Moscow:
Foreign Longuages publishing house, 1952.
41 - Madden, E., (ed) The Structure of scientific thought, London:
Routledge and Kegan paul, 1960.
42 - Mannheim, K., ldeology and Utopia London: Kegan paul, 1940.
43 - Marx, A contribution to the Critique of political Economy Mos-
cow: progress Publishers, 1970.
44 - Marx and Engles, German Ideology, Moscow: Progress Pub-
lishers, 1964.
45 - Marx and Engels, Selected Works, Two volumes, Moscow: fore-
ign Languages publishing house, 1962.
46 - Merton, R., Social theory and social structure, toward the
clarification of theory and Research, Illinois: the press of Glen-
coe, 1951.
47 - Moreno, J., et a1 (editors) The sociometry Reader, N. Y., The
free press of Glencoe, Illinois, 1966.
48 - Mydral, Gunnar, Objectivity in social research, London, Gerold
Duckworch and Co. L. T. D., 1970.
49 - Myrdal, Gunnar, Value in social theory, London, Routledge
and Kegan Paul, second impression 1962.
50 - Myrdal, G., An American Dilemma, Harper and Raow, pub-
lishers, 1962.
5 1 - Nagel, E., The Structure of science, New ~ork: Harcourt,
Brace and world, 1961.
5%- Nutini, H., The Ideological Bases of LCvi Strauss structuralism in
American Anthropologist Vol. 73. No. 3 (1971).
53 - Parsons, T., The structure of social Action, New York; free
press, 1968.
54 - Perry, R., General theory of Value, Harvard University press,
1950.
55 - Popper, K. T!le Poverty of Historicism London, Routledge
and Kegan paul, 1961.
56 - Popper, K., The Open Socity and its Enemies, London: Rout-
ledge and Kegan paul, 1966.
57 - Pearson, K., The Grammar of Science New York, The Meri-
dion Library, 1957.
58 - Piaget, J., Le Structuralisme Paris: P. U. F., 1968, P. 124
(((Que Sais - Je,, Le point des connaissances actulles).
59 - Pyke, M., The Boundries of science, Penguin books, 1963.
60 - Rayfield, S., The Dualism of Ltvi - Strauss, in International
Journal of Comparative Sociology, Vol. 12, No. 4 1971.
61 - Rex, J., Key Problems of Sociological Theory, London, Rout-
ledge and Kegan Paul, 1961.
62 - Ross, W., Aristotle, London: Methuen and Co., 1949.
63 - Russell, B., Let The People Think, London, Watts and Co.,
1943.
64 - Russell, B., The Scientific Outlook, London, George Allen and
Unwin, 1934.
65 - Sarton, G., A Guide to the History of Science, Chronica Bota-
nica Co., 1952. ,
66 - Sarter, J., The Problem of Method, En Trans by H. Barnes,
London, Methuen, 1963.
67 - Scheock, H., et al (ed) Scientism and Values, New Jersey, Van
Noserand Co., 1960.
68 - Schlatter, R., (ed) Philosophy, New Jersey prentice Holl, 1964.
69 - Snow, C. P. The two cultures and the scientific Revolution,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1959.
70 - Stein, M., and Heize, S., Creativity and the individual, chica-
go: The free press of Glencoe, 1964.
71 - Sullivan, J., Gallio, or the Tyranny of Science, London: Kegan
Paul. 1928.
72 - Sullivan, J., The Limitations of Science, Mentor Books, New
York, 1949.
73 - Timasheff, N. Sociological theory its Nature and Growth, New
Tork Random House, 1955.
74 - Tiryakian, E., Sociologism and Existentialism, New Jersey Pre-
ntice hall. 1962.
75 - Urban, M., Bey and Realism and Idealism, London, George
Allen, 1949.
75 -Urban, M., Beyond Realism and Idealism, London, George
Hall, 1963.
77 - Weber, M., The Methodology of the Social Science trans and
edited by Edward A. Shils and Henri A. Finch, The free press,
Glencoe, Illinois, 1949.
78 - Welech, E., The Philosophy of Wmund Husserl New York,
Columbia University press, 1941.
79 - Wiener, P. (editor) Philosophy of Science, New York, charles
Scribmers sons, 1953.
80 - Winch, P., The Idea of a Social Science and its Relation to
philosophy, New York, Kegan Paul, 1970.
81 - Whitehead, Adventures of Ideas, Cambridge University press
1947.
82 - Whitehead, A. N., Science and The Modem World, Mentor
Book, New York, 1952.
83 - Wood Worth, R., Conternporky Schools of Psychology, Lon-
don, Methuen and Co., 1949.
84 - Zeitlin, Inring M., Ideology and the Development of Sociologic-
al theory, New Delhi, Prentice of India priviate 1969.
YYA- YVY ............. cJ'jL13 &Id! ,y