REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES )

NATIONAL CAPITAL REGION )

CITY OF BAGUIO ) S.S.

I, Jolly Batoyog, of legal age, Filipino, a resident of Baguio City, after being duly
sworn in accordance with law, hereby depose and state that:

1. I am a full-time employee of Baguio Central University situated at 1281

Tropical Ave. Cor. Luxembourg St., BF Homes International, Baguio City,
working as a security guard in the said educational institution, under the
supervision of the head of the Security Division, Fr. Padua J. Montellano;

2. On the 10th of September 2006 at around two o’clock in the afternoon, I was
assigned to patrol the school’s parking lot;

3. I saw and recognized Scarlet Batumbakal in her school uniform together

with Melanie Batumbakal as they approached the parking lot area. At that
time, I was about three (3) meters away from the car where Melanie and
Scarlet boarded;

4. Right then and there, I saw Melanie forcefully made Scarlet board the 2012
Hyundai Accent black car, with plate number MEL 203, and overheard
Scarlet violently refusing the order of Melanie;

5. I did not intervene because Melanie Batumbakal is personally known to me,

since there were several instances when she was the one who personally
fetched her child from school, and Melanie used to visit her husband Frank
Batumbakal in the school’s Faculty Office;

AFFIANT SAYETH NAUGHT.

Affiant

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO BEFORE ME this 27 th day of March 2021,

affiant exhibiting to me his Driver’s License No. N-04-0020000 bearing his
photograph and signature, issued on 18 March 2011 at Baguio City and valid until
18 March 2015.
 Notary Public for Baguio City

Book No. I
Doc. No. 33
Page No. 4
Series of 2014