Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tadesse Yacob of Cairo and Addis Ababa
Tadesse Yacob of Cairo and Addis Ababa
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
Tsehai Publishers is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
International Journal of Ethiopian Studies
Tadesse Yacob, a Public Service High Commissioner with the rank of Minister in
Emperor Haile Selassies era, was an international figure with conflicting identities. He
was both a member of the marginal Beta Israel (once known as <fFalasha "2) community,
an Ethiopian patriot, and a cosmopolitan. He died in Addis Abeba in January 2005. This
article will recount Tadesse Yacob's life, with particular reference to his Beta Israel origins
and his early Jewish education, and suggest that the schooling he received in Cairo set the
stage for three prominent and at times conflicting identities?internationalist, nationalist
and parochialist. The article is framed within a wider research setting carried on
internationally1 on Dr. Faitlovitch's pupils, of whom Tadesse Yacob was the youngest.
mission in Asmara,8 and together with Gete Ermias from Gondar,9 set off to
Europe to imbibe the boys with a full Jewish and secular education, first in
Jerusalem and later in Italy and France. In 1908, he returned to Ethiopia for
a second expedition and again returned to Europe with boys from the Beta
Israel.10 From the time of his first mission to Ethiopia in 1904-5 until 1935,
when he was finally prevented from visiting Ethiopia because of the fascist
Italian occupation, Dr. Faitlovitch brought out of Ethiopia 25 young Falasha
males, whom he "planted" in different Jewish communities in Palestine and
Europe (in London, Paris, Florence, Vienna, Frankfurt and Zaghreb).11 The
dream was that these boys would return to Ethiopia and teach their brethren
the tenets of Judaism.12
the first p?ipil selected by the Jewish advocate, Dr. Jacques Faitlovitch. Until
the age of 12, Tadesse Yacob studied in the local Christian village school in his
native village in Semano in the Sekelt district in Dembia.
In 1923, Dr. Faitlovitch founded the "Falasha" school in Addis Abeba and
appointed his first pupil, Tamrat Emmanuel, as principal of the school.25 He
had played with the idea of setting up a school for the Beta Israel elsewhere,
for example in Palestine,26 but in the end, he found Addis Abeba a viable
option, despite its location far away from the Beta Israel villages. Faitlovitch
believed that education was the answer both to the increasing influence of
Christian missionaries on the Beta Israel, and to the group's isolation from
world Judaism.
In 1925, Tamrat Emmanuel brought his nephew Tadesse Yacob to join the
Addis Abeba school. He was the youngest of all the students?and one of the
brightest. In 1929, he returned to his parent's village, at their request, where
he studied at the Christian Mission School opened by the German Protestant
missionary Flad at Djenda in the mid-nineteenth century.27 It is interesting that
his parents wanted Tadesse to acquire the best education, and he moved from
the Jewish counter-mission that Dr. Faitlovitch set up to oppose the missionary
movement in Christianity among the Beta Israel, to the Mission. This oscillation
pervaded Tadesse Yacob's personal life, at times defining himself as a Jew, and
at other times as a Christian. By 1930, Tadesse persuaded his parents to return
to Addis Abeba and he was re-installed again at the Falasha school. Once there,
he was selected to study in Egypt. Tadesse was unique among Dr. Faitlovitch's
pupils in that he did not receive his education in Europe or Palestine.
It should be pointed out that although Tadesse Yacob was the only one
of Dr. Fatilovitch's pupils to stay for a substantial period in Egypt, he was not
the first Beta Israel to study there. In fact, he was following in the footsteps
of Daniel, the Beta Israel boy who arrived in Europe in 1868 with Prof.
Halevy. However, probably due to racism, Daniel was not accepted in the
Alliance Israelite Universelle school in Paris, and was sent back to Alexandria in
Egypt, where he died soon after. The Alliance claimed that he was purchased
in a slave market in Africa and was not a Jew, while senior members of the
Ethiopian Jewish community in Israel today have told me that they heard from
their ancestors that Daniel "looked" like a barya (slave)2* and may have come
from the Sudanese border.29 Furthermore, Hizkiahu Finkas, another of Dr.
Faitlovitch's pupils mentioned above, had also studied in Alexandria, Egypt,
but he fell desperately ill, his studies were poor, and he was a burden to the
Jewish community.30
Religious-ethnic Identity
the Falasha school in Wuzzaba was burned down in the 1950s, according to
an Israeli Consulate report (5.2.1958), Tadesse claimed that the attack was a
demonstration by the local Christian population displaying their dissatisfaction
with the fact that the school had become a propaganda centre encouraging
aliya (immigration) to Israel.36 In interviews with me, he expressed the opinion
many times that aliya was detrimental to the condition of the "Falashas" and
would not improve their lot.37
The establishment of the State of Israel in 1948 was a turning-point for
Jewish diaspora. The Beta Israel, as Ethiopian citizens, were not permitted
by the government of Emperor Haile Sellasie to emigrate to Israel. As an
Ethiopian nationalist, Tadesse Yacob was an advocate for the modernization
of the Beta Israel and he helped organize ten village classes for 200 Beta
Israel students in Ethiopia. His uncle, Tamrat Emmanuel, described him as a
member of the group "qui s'int?resse a donner aux Falashas une organization
moderne."38 In the 1950s, he served as treasurer in Dr. Faitlovitch's Pro-Falash?
Committee, which established a school in Asmara. He very often interceded
with the Emperor on behalf of the Ethiopian Jews in the Gondar region and
was instrumental in the 1950s in dispatching two groups of youth (including
his own son) to study in the Kfar Batya dormitory school in Israel.39
His religio-ethnic ties moved him to help his brethren, but did not succeed
in linking him emotionally to the wider Jewish people. He did not really support
Operation Moses (1984-5) and the exit of the Beta Israel from Ethiopia to
Israel.40 When Operation Solomon took place in 1991 and the Beta Israel were
airlifted to Israel from Addis Abeba,41 he had the opportunity of migrating to
Israel, but he preferred to remain in Ethiopia.
National Identity
There is no question that Tadesse Yacob was a nationalist, in the sense
of the word that is less fashionable today. His career was meteoric, and in
many ways can be considered parallel to the progress of Ethiopia as a modern
country. His employment opportunities not only helped him personally, but
also moved Ethiopia from an essentially feudalistic society to a more modern
one.
Tadesse was recruited straight from Egypt to work in the Secretariat of the
Secret Service of the English army in Khartoum.42 In 1940, he was appointe
chief of the Propaganda Unit of the Godjam Front on behalf of Haile Selassi
the Emperor, who was hoping to re-enter Ethiopia. In 1941, Tadesse becam
Director of the Ministry of Finances in Ethiopia, a position in which he work
till March 1944. In 1952, he was appointed the Director-General of the Mine
in the Ministry of Finance; in 1954, he became Vice President of the Cons
of Administration of Telecommunications; in 1956, he acted as Assistan
Minister of the Ethiopian Electric Light and Powers Authority; in 1958, he
was appointed Vice Minister of the Ministry of Finances. In 1960, Tades
became the Vice-Minister of the Ministry of Agriculture. In December 1961,
he was appointed Minister of State in the Prime Minister's Cabinet, a post
he held till 1966, when he was appointed High Public Service Commissioner
with the rank of Minster of the Public Service Pension Commission, and of
the Central Personnel Agency and Public Service Commission. From 196
till 1974, when he was imprisoned as part of Haile Selassie's entourage,
also acted as President of the Advisory Council of the Commercial Bank of
Ethiopia.
He was a survivor, like Ethiopia itself. In December 1960, he survived the
attempted coup d'etat against the Emperor, and was rewarded by receiving
the title "Excellency" in his post of Vice-Minister of Agriculture.43 He also
survived the regime of Mengistu Haile Mariam, although he was imprisoned
for 81/2 years during that period, emerging a patriot in a "new" Ethiopia.
His identity was linked with the national identity of Ethiopia and he was a
fierce advocate for his country, believing in the future and modernization of
Ethiopia. He received the Ethiopian Star of Victory in 1941, the Grand Officer
of the order of Menelik II and the Grand Cordon of the order of the Ethiopian
Star.
International Identity
and Arabic, Tadesse Yacob simultaneously felt an identity with the concept of
internationalism. He was frequently the host of important overseas celebrities,
including a long line of academics, ranging from Prof. Edward Ullendorff
to Prof. Wolf Leslau, and acted as the cosmopolitan in all his dealings with
foreign guests. He was often requested to act as mediator in international
negotiations, and sometimes to intervene with the Emperor, either with respect
to his more parochial "Falasha" identity, or with respect to his Ethiopian
national identity.
Conclusion
This paper has examined the role and identities of Tadesse Yacob as part
of the growing literature on Dr. Faitlovitch's pupils, who studied in Europe,
Palestine and Egypt during the pre-Second World War era. To the best of
my knowledge, the paper is the first academic article on Tadesse Yacob, who
ironically reached the highest position in Ethiopia of all Dr. Faitlovitch's
students, and from many points of view, was the most successful.
Notes
1 There have been various spellings in English of Tadesse Yacob 's name:
Taddasa Yaqob, Taddessa Jacob and more. This article has selected the way
Tadesse Yacob himself chose to write and sign his own name in English; he even
wrote me his own curriculum vitae with this spelling (personal correspondence
Tadesse Yacob-Shalva Weil, May 1989).
2 For different designations of the group "Falasha," "Beta Israel,"
"Ethiopian Jew" and more, see: Shalva Weil, 1995. "Collective Designations
and Collective Identity among Ethiopian Jews," in Shalva Weil (Ed), Israel
Social Science Research, 10, 2, 25-40.
3In particular, in Italy and Israel, but also in France and elsewhere.
4 Emanuela, Trevisan Semi. 1999. "Universalisme juif et pros?lytisme:
l'action de Jacques Faitlovitch, 'p?re' des Beta Israel (Falachas)," in Revue de
Vhistoire des religions 216,193-211.
6 Steven Kaplan. 1991. The Beta Israel (Falasha) in Ethiopia (New York and
London: New York University Press), 141.
7 Joseph Tobi. 2005. "Joseph Halevy and the Study of Yemenite Jewry,"
Pe'amim 100, 23-72.
8 Emanuela Trevisan Semi. 2000. L1 epistolario di Taamrat Emmanuel: Un
intellettuale ebreo d'Ethiopia nellaprima meta del XXsecolo. (Torino: L'Harmattan
Italia), 14-53.
9 Carlo Guandalina. 2005. "Gete Yirmiahu and Beta Israel's Regeneration:
a Difficult Path," in Tudor, Parfitt and Emanuela, Trevisan Semi Jews of
Ethiopia: the Birth of an Elite (London and New York: Routledge), 112-121.
10 Jacques Faitlovitch. 1910. Quer durch Abessinien: Meine zweite Reise zu den
Falaschas. (Berlin: Poppelauer).
llRichard, Pankhurst. 1962. 'The foundations of education, printing,
newspapers, book production, libraries and literacy in Ethiopia," Ethiopian
Observer, 6, 3, 241-290. Pankhurst mentions 22 Beta Israel pupils who studied
abroad, but there were 25.
Emanuela, Trevisan Semi Jews of Ethiopia: the Birth of an Elite (London and
New York: Routledge), 74-100.
15 Shalva, Weil. 1987. "In memoriam: Yona Bogale." Pe'amim 33:140-143.
(Hebrew).
16 Emanuela, Trevisan Semi. 1999. "From Wolleqa to Florence: the Tragic
Story of Faitlovitch's Pupil Hizkiahu Finkas," in Tudor, Parfitt and Emanuela,
Trevisan Semi (eds.) The Beta Israel in Ethiopia and Israel: Studies on the Ethiopian
Jews. London: Curzon, 15-39.
17 Shalva, Weil. 1999. "The Life and Death of Solomon Isaac," in Tudor
Parfitt and Emanuela, Trevisan Semi (eds.) The Beta Israel in Ethiopia and Israel:
Studies on the Ethiopian Jews. (London: Curzon), 40-49.
18 Benjamin, Mekuria. 1999. "The Long Journey of the Young Beta Israel
from Lasta," in Tudor, Parfitt and Emanuela, Trevisan Semi (eds.) The Beta
Israel in Ethiopia and Israel: Studies on the Ethiopian Jews. (London: Curzon), 296
300.
19 Shalva Weil. 2003. "Abraham Adgeh," Encyclopaedia Aethiopica
(Weisbaden), 48; Shalva Weil. 2005. "Abraham Adgeh: the Perfect English
Gentleman," in Tudor Parfitt and Emanuela Trevisan Semi Jews of Ethiopia:
the Birth of an Elite (London and New York: Routledge), 101-111.
21 My thanks to the Addis Ababa University and the Institute for Ethiopian
Studies for facilitating that conference.
29 Emanuela Trevisan Semi. 2005. "Ethiopian Jews in Europe" op. cit. 76,
97, fn. 10.
30 Emanuela, Trevisan Semi. 1999. "From Wolleqa to Florence" op. cit.
31 Personal correspondence: Tadesse Yacob-Shalva Weil, Addis Ababa, 13
July 1990.
41 Asher, Nairn. 2003. Saving the Lost Tribe: The Rescue and Redemption of the
Ethiopian Jews. (New York: Ballantine).
42 The following section is based on a series of interviews with Tadesse
Yacob in 1988.
43 Messing, Simon. 1982. The Story of the Falashas "Black Jews" of Ethiopia
(Connecticut: Balshon), 68.